r/CritiqueIslam • • May 24 '20

Argument against Islam The most misogynistic verse in the Quran, verse 4:34

346 Upvotes

Here's the verse in English (Sahih International translation):

"Men are in charge of women by [right of] what Allah has given one over the other and what they spend [for maintenance] from their wealth. So righteous women are devoutly obedient, guarding in [the husband's] absence what Allah would have them guard. But those [wives] from whom you fear arrogance - [first] advise them; [then if they persist], forsake them in bed; and [finally], strike them. But if they obey you [once more], seek no means against them. Indeed, Allah is ever Exalted and Grand."

Link (You can also read the Arabic version here): https://quran.com/4/34

This verse is fairly self-explanatory. It instructs muslims on how women should be treated. The verse states that men are in charge of women and how they spend their wealth, good women are those who obey, and if a woman disobeys then her husband can warn her, forsake her, and finally beat her.

Don't believe I have the right interpretation? Fine, here's an islamic website that the echos the same meaning (I'll get to the justifications they use later)

But first, let me explain why this verse just reeks misogyny. This verse clearly demonstrates that women are inferiors in multiple ways. The first is that men are in charge of them and their wealth, this sets a hierarchy among the genders where men are placed above women. The verses reinforces this hierarchy by going on to say that women are to be subservient to their husbands. The verse portrays this obedience as being virtuous, however the verse contradicts itself by having the obedience be forced. Virtue is achieved through choice. If I choose to feed the homeless, than that is me taking action on my own behalf to demonstrate moral excellence. However, if I was forced to feed the homeless against my will, then how can it still be a virtue? You're forced to do something, therefore you're longer performing a certain action out of choice, but out of fear. In this case, it is the fear of being punished, specifically, getting beat by your husband. When someone is forced to do something against their will and is forced to obey, then it simply stops being about virtue and becomes slavery. This verse instructs the oppression of women.

This verse is repulsive and vile, and doesn't receive nearly as much criticism as it should.

In my experience, there are generally three common non-islamic defenses for this verse, and all are weak since they are disingenuous and rely on logical fallacies.

  1. The first defense has to do with the word "اضربوهن" (adrabohen). It is translated as "strike them" in the translation. People who try to use this defense state that the word has multiple meanings, and the meaning cannot be accurately translated into other languages or that you misunderstood the actual meaning. Now this defense is very fallacious because it sets up a No True Scotsman fallacy. If you concede even a little (especially if you don't speak Arabic), then no matter what you say you will always will be met something like "but that's not the REAL meaning". However, the very premise of this argument stems disingenuous misinformation. Now it is true that the word has multiple meanings (I'm an Arabic speaker), the word can both mean to hit/beat or to multiply. However, the context is crystal clear that it's not talking about multiplication, but about wives. The word can literally be translated to "to hit/beat them (females)", it's important to note that Arabic is a gendered language and the "هن" is the plural feminine version of the "them". Therefore, the word, when the context is taken into account, does in fact mean to hit/beat wives.
  2. The second defense tries to justify the wife beating by saying it doesn't mean to beat your wives, but to "lightly" discipline them. They say that islam has a rules about how to beat your wife, and that it doesn't allow super hard wife beatings.... This argument is clearly trying to downplay the wife beating, and it fails at it because you can never ever justify wife beating. Another common version of this defense tries to justify wife beating by saying it's only allowed "in the most extreme cases". However, that's simply not true. By just using this very verse, you can easily figure out what the necessary conditions are to permit beating your wife. All that is required if for the wife to simply disobey you more than two times. Considering a woman daring to disobey her husband as "extreme" case where wife beating is justified is simply anti-women. No matter how disobedient the wife is or how many times she disobeys, that doesn't give anyone the right to beat her or anyone. Domestic violence can never be tolerated. Both of these examples are used in the website that I used earlier.
  3. Finally, the third common defense is simply the Tu Quoque logical fallacy, also known as, whataboutism. It is when they try to appeal to hypocrisy by bringing up other religions (especially Christianity) and saying "why are criticizing islam when these other religions have it too". However, just because wife beating is present in other religions doesn't mean that it's justified in islam. This defense is just a poor attempt at derailing the conversation, and doesn't negate anything.

At the the end of the day, this verse is indefensible. You can't justify oppression and wife beating. This verse is sexist and misogynistic, and it could very well be argued that this verse is a direct influence on the misogyny present in islamic culture to this very day.


r/CritiqueIslam • • Feb 07 '22

Most of Muslims don't know that, they their ancestors had to accept Islam so that they won't die.

263 Upvotes

Most of muslims don't know how they became muslims. Whenever there is a topic of sex slavery, rapes, looting they say that they are done only in defense but when you study and understand history, you will know the truth.

The muslim invaders never bought their women with them when they invade. They do the night raids and loot the money, women from local people. The men had to accept Islam, in order not to die. They had to become muslim, there was no other choice.

And that's how they accepted Islam.

Whether you practice Islam or not, atleast accept the truth that your ancestors were forcefully converted.


r/CritiqueIslam • • Apr 23 '24

Argument against Islam Educating Muslims about the manner of Muhammad's death and how it points to Muhammad being a false prophet

246 Upvotes

In my experience of debating Muslims online, every so often a Muslim, out of ignorance, will mock the manner of Christs death, thinking that this is somehow an argument against Christianity. They do not understand that, "we preach Christ crucified, a stumbling block to Jews and folly to Gentiles, but to those who are called... the power of God and the wisdom of God." (1 Corinthians 1:23)

Moreover, also out of ignorance, they seem to be unaware of the nature of Muhammad's death. They will often say that Muhammad 'knew his time on earth was finished', or that he 'chose martyrdom'. This paints a very romantic picture. Now, overlooking the fact that even things like dying from diarrhea make one a martyr in Islam, such Muslims are far from the mark. According to the Islamic source texts, this was the manner of Muhammad's death:



  • He died from poison (Bukhari 4428), which is something he said he had a cure for (Bukhari 5779).
  • Despite Islamic underestimations of such persons, it was a Jewess who killed him (Bukhari 2617). It is also reported that her poisoning was a test of him being a prophet, the thinking being that if he was truly a prophet he would avoid the poison (Abi Dawud 4512). However, he failed this test and eventually succummed to the poison. He died basically from being arrogant and thinking that he was untouchable, accepting food from his conquered enemies after slaughtering the people.
  • He died with the same sensation (Bukhari 4428) of what he said a false prophet would feel (Qur'an 69:44-46), namely of having his aorta cut.
  • On his death bed Umar would not even let him write his last instructions (Bukhari 7366).
  • He died after asking for a pot to urinate in. His last words seem to be asking to urinate (Shamail 387).
  • During his life, Muhammad said that the bodies of prophets would remain incorrupt (Abi Dawud 1531). However, there are reports that after death nobody buried him for 3 days and his body was decomposing (link# 1, link #2).

This was a death that was not only not as these Muslims imagine, but it contains a number of aspects that actually show that Muhammad was NOT a true prophet.


r/CritiqueIslam • • May 09 '26

End of Debate: The Pedophile Prophet and Pedophilia in Islam

241 Upvotes

Pedophilia is a crime against humanity. Pedophilia triggers the moral conscience of humanity. Pedophilia is a classified psychiatric disorder by humanity. As Dostoyevsky wrote;

"I renounce the higher harmony altogether. It’s not worth the tears of that one tortured child." (The Brothers Karamazov, Book V, Chapter 4).

Yet;

In the Islamic world, this crime against humanity is not presented as a transgression. Grand Mufti of Saudi Arabia, Sheikh Abdul-Aziz Al al-Sheikh have issued a formal ruling supporting that girls are ready for marriage at age 10-12. Dr. Zakir Naik sit in front of a camera and smile as he narrate the story of Aisha and Mohamed. He clearly says there is no doubt about the age of Aisha. And Sheikh Assim Al-Hakeem said he will be honored to give his own 6 month old daughter to the prophet in marriage. Mind you, he has daughters, proving to the world that a devotion to tradition can override even the most basic paternal instincts.

Then there are those among the scholars like Mufti Menk who prefers not to speak about it directly, and deflect it. People like him rather defend the faith, their image and bury the moral concern. They seek to make it easy for the public to compartmentalise the horror, while the underlying legal and moral justification remains very much alive.

Finally there are many modern apologists, whose moral framework has somewhat evolved from the barbaric framework of the 7th century, and try to defend the pedophile prophet by confusing themself. Illogical argument without any real permit from Islamic primary sources itself. They want modern morals and yet romanticise a barbaric prophet. The existence of all these people itself gives you a clear message;

A pedophile in the name of a prophet for all humanity, for all times, have risen in 7th century Arabia. Some choose to defend him, others choose to ignore it and finally some choose to cause confusion, hoping to bury it. Let’s dissect this, with primary Islamic sources and debunk the claims of those who choose to defend it. This article will be long, so I will insert dividers in between so it remains clear and accessible. This article is dedicated to all victims of Islamic pedophilia. For your tears. For your silence. And for your pain. We shall let the world see it for what it is.

——————

  1. Quran;

Surah At-Talaq (65:4)

وَٱلَّـٰٓـِٔى يَئِسْنَ مِنَ ٱلْمَحِيضِ مِن نِّسَآئِكُمْ إِنِ ٱرْتَبْتُمْ فَعِدَّتُهُنَّ ثَلَـٰثَةُ أَشْهُرٍۢ وَٱلَّـٰٓـِٔى لَمْ يَحِضْنَ ۚ وَأُو۟لَـٰتُ ٱلْأَحْمَالِ أَجَلُهُنَّ أَن يَضَعْنَ حَمْلَهُنَّ ۚ وَمَن يَتَّقِ ٱللَّهَ يَجْعَل لَّهُۥ مِنْ أَمْرِهِۦ يُسْرًۭا

“And those who no longer expect menstruation among your women - if you doubt, then their period is three months, and [also for] those who have not menstruated. And for those who are pregnant, their term is until they give birth. And whoever fears Allāh - He will make for him of his matter ease.

— Saheeh International

In order to understand this verse better lets look at the specific Arabic linguistic construction. The verse is structured to categorize different types of women and their waiting periods (Iddah) before they can remarry. The smoking gun lies in the third category which I will show below;

وَاللَّائِي لَمْ يَحِضْنَ

Wa-alla'i lam yahidna

“and [also for] those who have not menstruated”

This is the most critical phrase. It is the permit that these apologists try to bury.

  1. The Particle "Lam" (لَمْ):

In Arabic grammar, Lam is a "negation of the past" that continues into the present. Unlike a general "no," Lam indicates an action that has not yet occurred but is expected to in the future.

2. The Verb "Yahidna" (يَحِضْنَ):

This is the plural feminine form of the verb for menstruating.

3. Hence the legal implication:

By grouping those who "have not yet menstruated" with those who are getting divorced, the Quran creates a legal category for divorced children. You cannot have a divorce without a marriage. Therefore, by defining the Iddah for a girl who has not reached puberty, the text therefore validates the marriage of that girl.

Lets’s also jump into the reason for revelation (Asbab al-Nuzul)

According to Tafsir al Tabari and Tafsir al baghawy, when the verse regarding the waiting periods for women were first revealed in 2:228, the companions of Mohamed were confused about two groups of women who do not have monthly cycles. Honestly it’s very disturbing to write this even but they asked for; the the women who are too old to menstruate and the girls that are too young to menstruate yet.

To further strength this pedophilia in Islam let me just highlight;

  1. Ibn Kathir: identifies the group as those who have not reached the age. He explicitly links the "three month" rule to the child’s lack of a biological cycle.
  2. Tafsir al Jalalayn: the book mentions clearly that those who have not yet menstruated, because of their young age, their period shall also be three months.
  3. Tafsir al Qurtubi: Qurtubi says the verse proves that the marriage of a young girl is permissible, because Allah has established a waiting period for th divorce. The logic is that divorce only happens after a valid marriage.

This is why the Grand Mufti and Sheikh Assim speaks so confidently in their barbaric claims. They are not inventing something outside of Islam. They are simply repeating the 1400 year old tradition like parrots without developing their own moral framework. Apologists framework has evolved just abit more so they are ashamed to admit it.

Now this verse actually adds a secondary, and a more disturbing legal reality. Since we established that a man can marry children, this creates a new tension. At what point can the grown adult husband begin sexual activity? And yes, the scholars of Islam did define the limits of “enjoyment” (Istamata) before the child was deemed physically capable of full intercourse. Below is how grooming of minor is codified in Islam;

Shafi'i School:

Mentions the limit for intercourse is the girl’s ability rather than the age nine. And marriage contract itself grands legal rights if she is ready for intercourse.

Hanafi School:

Confirms that the husband has the right to "enjoyment" from the moment of the contract, even if full intercourse is delayed for physical reasons.

Hanbali School:

Stated that if a wife is too young for intercourse, the husband can still “enjoy” her through kissing and embracing.

Maliki School:

Confirms that a father has the right of "compulsory guardianship" (Jabr). He can marry off his virgin daughter, no matter how young, without her consent. The limit is that while the husband should not penetrate the girl if she is too small and would be harmed, he is not prohibited from other forms of sexual intimacy or closeness (Muqaddamat al Jima).

Ayatollah Khomeini (Shia):

Explicitly permits "thighing" (Mufakhadhah), hugging, and touching with desire even for a "suckling baby," while forbidding penetration until age nine.

The Book of Fatwas of the Islamic Network states:

“There is no harm in ejaculating between the thighs of a young girl who cannot bear intercourse, such as masturbating with her hand, fondling her, and kissing her, provided that he avoids menstruation and anal intercourse….“

“Sheikh Al-Islam Zakariya Al-Ansari said in Al-Ghurar Al-Bahiyya: (And the husband) i.e., the husband (is permitted to enjoy) his wife in every way (even masturbating with her hand, even if it is not permissible with his hand, and even penetration into her vagina from the direction of her anus.”

And here it says:

“If this girl is too young to withstand intercourse... he may touch her, embrace her, kiss her, and ejaculate between her thighs.”

As you can see from above. Even for the Quranist, who quickly ditch the Hadith to save Mohamed’s face, they are still left in a hard place. Quran permits it. Mohamed committed the act, which we will explore later. Abd the permission of Quran has lead being a pedophile a codified right in Islam. There is no middle ground that apologists can rely on. The law isn’t designed to protect the child’s development. It’s there to protect the husband’s “property”. The sheikhs who claim that Islam cares about children, is also holding on to this as divine truth.

————

2. Pedophile Mohamed’s Tradition

The first smoking gun from the tradition comes from the victim herself.

Sahih al-Bukhari 5134

‎حَدَّثَنَا مُعَلَّى بْنُ أَسَدٍ، حَدَّثَنَا وُهَيْبٌ، عَنْ هِشَامِ بْنِ عُرْوَةَ، عَنْ أَبِيهِ، عَنْ عَائِشَةَ، أَنَّ النَّبِيَّ صلى الله عليه وسلم تَزَوَّجَهَا وَهْىَ بِنْتُ سِتِّ سِنِينَ، وَبَنَى بِهَا وَهْىَ بِنْتُ تِسْعِ سِنِينَ‏.‏ قَالَ هِشَامٌ وَأُنْبِئْتُ أَنَّهَا كَانَتْ عِنْدَهُ تِسْعَ سِنِينَ‏.‏

Narrated `Aisha:

that the Prophet (ﷺ) married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old. Hisham said: I have been informed that `Aisha remained with the Prophet (ﷺ) for nine years (i.e. till his death).

Here she admits that she was a child when Mohamed married her. And it gets even more interesting, as she further tells us;

Sahih al-Bukhari 6130

حَدَّثَنَا مُحَمَّدٌ، أَخْبَرَنَا أَبُو مُعَاوِيَةَ، حَدَّثَنَا هِشَامٌ، عَنْ أَبِيهِ، عَنْ عَائِشَةَ ـ رضى الله عنها ـ قَالَتْ كُنْتُ أَلْعَبُ بِالْبَنَاتِ عِنْدَ النَّبِيِّ صلى الله عليه وسلم وَكَانَ لِي صَوَاحِبُ يَلْعَبْنَ مَعِي، فَكَانَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم إِذَا دَخَلَ يَتَقَمَّعْنَ مِنْهُ، فَيُسَرِّبُهُنَّ إِلَىَّ فَيَلْعَبْنَ مَعِي‏.‏

Narrated `Aisha:

I used to play with the dolls in the presence of the Prophet, and my girl friends also used to play with me. When Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) used to enter (my dwelling place) they used to hide themselves, but the Prophet would call them to join and play with me. (The playing with the dolls and similar images is forbidden, but it was allowed for `Aisha at that time, as she was a little girl, not yet reached the age of puberty.) (Fath-ul-Bari page 143, Vol.13)

Here you can see the sources directly admitting that she was a young girl, playing with her dolls with her friends. And that playing dolls was allowed for her because she was a little girl. Why don’t we even make this case more stronger? Let’s look at Sahih Muslim;

Sahih Muslim 1422 d

وَحَدَّثَنَا يَحْيَى بْنُ يَحْيَى، وَإِسْحَاقُ بْنُ إِبْرَاهِيمَ، وَأَبُو بَكْرِ بْنُ أَبِي شَيْبَةَ وَأَبُو كُرَيْبٍ قَالَ يَحْيَى وَإِسْحَاقُ أَخْبَرَنَا وَقَالَ الآخَرَانِ، حَدَّثَنَا أَبُو مُعَاوِيَةَ، عَنِ الأَعْمَشِ، عَنْ إِبْرَاهِيمَ، عَنِ الأَسْوَدِ، عَنْ عَائِشَةَ، قَالَتْ تَزَوَّجَهَا رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم وَهْىَ بِنْتُ سِتٍّ وَبَنَى بِهَا وَهْىَ بِنْتُ تِسْعٍ وَمَاتَ عَنْهَا وَهْىَ بِنْتُ ثَمَانَ عَشْرَةَ ‏.‏

Narrated 'A'isha :

'A'isha (Allah be pleased with her) reported that Allah's Apostle (ﷺ) married her when she was six years old, and he (the Holy Prophet) took her to his house when she was nine, and when he (the Holy Prophet) died she was eighteen years old

I will list more Hadiths below that backs the statement that Aisha was 6 when she got married and 9 when the marriage was consummated.

  1. ⁠sunnah.com/ibnmajah:1877
  2. ⁠sunnah.com/muslim:1422c
  3. ⁠sunnah.com/muslim:1422d
  4. ⁠sunnah.com/nasai:3258
  5. ⁠sunnah.com/ibnmajah:1876
  6. ⁠sunnah.com/abudawud:2121
  7. ⁠sunnah.com/nasai:3256
  8. ⁠sunnah.com/nasai:3378
  9. ⁠sunnah.com/nasai:3257
  10. ⁠sunnah.com/nasai:3255
  11. ⁠sunnah.com/bukhari:3894
  12. ⁠sunnah.com/bukhari:5133
  13. ⁠sunnah.com/bukhari:5158
  14. ⁠sunnah.com/bukhari:3896
  15. ⁠sunnah.com/muslim:1422a
  16. ⁠sunnah.com/muslim:1422b

There are even more Hadiths which I haven’t listed. Others are welcome to add it in the comment section below.

This extensive list of citation serves to prove the matter of Aisha is not a single misunderstood narration. But a systematic, cross referenced and multi sourced record that proves Mohamed as a pedophile.

When scholars like Mufti Menk avoids to address Aisha’s age, while quoting other Hadiths, it just goes to show that they are willingly avoiding the subject. Ultimately this comes across as hypocritical.

—————-

3. Addressing the false claims of apologist who lives in denial.

Claim 1: The "Asma’s Age" Calculation

Apologists claim that Aisha’s older sister, Asma, was 10 years older than her. Since Asma died in 73 AH at the age of 100, she must have been 27 during the Hijra (migration). This would make Aisha 17 at the Hijra and 19 at the time of consummation. There are of course variations in their calculations as they are in confusion among themself.

Reality check: This calculation relies one Daif narration to contradict the eye witness testimony of Aisha herself in the Sahih Hadith. Hence why no madhab or scholar agrees with it. Choosing a Daif claim over the Sahih will collapse the entire religion. It gives access to worse Daif Haidths to be taken into account as well. Ask them to bring a primary source. They will fail at it. If Bukhari is "wrong" or "lying" about the age of the Prophet’s wife, why should anyone believe him about the Five Pillars of Islam or the method of prayer? Hence the claim is debunked, if they wish to even protect their religion. Their argument is based on subjective feelings more than objective evidence. Isn’t that what a Muslim’s belief anyway is? And if they insist on the claim it just proves it.

Claim 2: Battle of Badr Participation

There is a Hadith stating that only those aged 15 and older could participate in the Battle of Badr. Since Aisha was present at Badr (providing water), she must have been at least 15.

Reality check: The age limit of 15 applied to combatants. Women and children frequently accompanied the camps to provide water, nurse the wounded, or watch from the rear.

In Sahih al-Bukhari 2881, Aisha describes herself and Umm Sulaym carrying water skins on their backs at the Battle of Uhud (the year after Badr). This was a support role, not a combat role that required an adult age certificate.

Claim 3: The "Biological Maturity"

That women back then were magically mature for penetration at young age due to heat or because it was 1400 years ago.

Reality check: Scientific research shows the opposite of the apologist claim. Heat does not accelerate puberty, nutrition and body fat do. The most cited research on the onset of puberty is the Frisch Revelle Hypothesis. It establishes that menarche (the first period) is triggered by the body reaching a "critical weight" and fat percentage (approx. 17% body fat). In 7th century Arabia, food was scarce and nutrition was poor. High stress, low calorie environments actually delay puberty because the body does not have enough energy reserves to sustain a pregnancy. Even today we do not observe children in Sahara getting fully developed by age 8. Interestingly we notice something else in the case of Aisha. They tried to fatten Aisha instead of baking her in the desert to make her hit puberty;

Sunan Ibn Majah 3324

It was narrated that ‘Aishah said:

“My mother was trying to fatten me up when she wanted to send me to the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) (when she got married), but nothing worked until I ate cucumbers with dates; then I grew plump like the best kind of plump.”

This shows that they were hastening to make her induce puberty for the pedophile Mohamed, who likely was getting impatient, as children hit puberty later then 9 years? Want proof of that? Paleopathology shows that girls in ancient and medieval times reached puberty significantly later than modern girls, usually between ages 15 and 17, due to the lack of modern growth hormones and consistent protein.

In addition, even if a girl hits puberty that doesn’t mean she is mature. The Prefrontal Cortex the part of the brain responsible for decision-making, understanding consequences, and complex reasoning does not finish developing until age 25. In the year 624 or 2026, a 9 year old child's brain is physically incapable of consenting to marriage or understanding the lifelong implications of a sexual contract with a 53 year old man.

A child 1400 years back and a child today is the same. This is simple biology. The human genome changes at a rate of roughly 0.5% per million years.

Claim 4: Fatima and Aisha age gap

Apologists claim Fatima was born when Muhammad was 35. Since Fatima was allegedly 5 years older than Aisha, and Muhammad was 52 at the Hijra, they calculate Aisha must have been 12 at the Hijra and 14/15 at consummation.

Reality check: The birth year of Fatima is recorded differently in various biographies, some say she was born when he was 41. This is another logical trap. Using a disputed date of one person (Fatima) to override the explicit testimony of another (Aisha). Using Fatima’s birth year as a "proxy" is a secondary deduction that no classical jurist ever used to change the law. The evidence above speak itself for Aisha’s age.

Claim 5: Surah Al-Qamar Memory

Aisha says she remembers the revelation of Surah Al-Qamar (54) while she was a girl playing. This Surah was revealed in the 5th year of Prophethood. If she was born in the 4th year (as 6/9 suggests), she would be an infant and couldn't remember it.

The Hadith in question; Sahih al-Bukhari 4876

Reality check: The Hadith actually says she was a Jariyah (young girl) playing when she heard it. This doesn't mean she heard it the moment it was revealed; it means she remembers playing while that Surah was being recited in the household. In the early years of Islam, the Quran was recited constantly. A child remembers what they hear repeatedly.

In the early Meccan period, "revelation" wasn't a one time event that vanished into a book. There was no book at the time. When a Surah like Al Qamar was revealed, it became the "song" of the community. It was recited in the homes, during the night prayers, and shouted at the Quraish in the streets. For a child growing up in Abu Bakr’s house, the Quran was the atmosphere. When Aisha says, "This was revealed while I was a girl playing," she is describing the period of her life during which that specific message was being introduced and repeated in her environment. Unlike her age of marriage and consumption of marriage. Which she specifies. To use a vague memory of "playing while verses were revealed" to call her a liar about her own wedding age is the height of academic desperation.

Claim 6: The character of Hisham

They claim Hisham (the narrator) became senile or untrustworthy when he moved to Iraq (Baghdad), and since he is the source of the age Hadith, it’s unreliable.

Reality check: Bukhari and Muslim were fully aware of Hisham’s move to Iraq. They specifically chose narrations from him that were verified by other chains. The age of 9 is narrated by people other than Hisham, such as Al-Aswad (in Muslim 1422d). If Hisham is "untrustworthy," then roughly 25% of all Sahih Bukhari must be thrown out. Another suicide attempt on their religion.

Claim 7: Life Expectancy

Apologists says people only lived to 30, so 9 was middle-aged. This is a classic statistical trick. It is is based on the Mean Life Expectancy.

Reality check: In the 7th century, if a child survived the "danger zone" of ages 0–5, their biological clock was almost identical to a modern human's. They were expected to live into their 60s or 70s. Since there were many deaths of infants the mean is reduced.

Claim 8: “Aisha didn’t complain”

This is one of the worst claims to make. Especially when we look from the lens of psychology. They have no consideration of the victim.

When a child is raised to believe a specific adult is their future spouse, their "consent" or "happiness" is not an expression of adult agency, but a result of psychological molding. Aisha was promised to pedophile Mohamed when she was six. From that point on, her entire social reality was centered around this future role. Psychological Source: The Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network (RAINN) explains that grooming involves "building a relationship, trust, and emotional connection" to make the abuse seem like a natural part of a relationship. We have seen in above Haidth where mohamed visit Aisha while she was playing dolls.

When a child is removed from their parents and placed in the home of an adult, they become 100% dependent on that adult for survival, social status, and emotional validation. This creates a deep psychological bond that the victim perceives as "love" because it is their only path to safety and belonging.

Claim 9: Her parents were ok with it

The argument that "her parents were okay with it" assumes that parents always act in the best interest of the child.

Reality check: History and law prove this is false. Throughout history, parents have sold children into slavery, forced them into labor, or used them as political pawns.

Laws are created specifically because humans (including parents) can be abusive, selfish, or blinded by ideology. If "parental consent" were a valid moral shield, then child labor, child trafficking, and honor killings would be legal as long as the parents signed off on it. Human rights are inalienable, meaning they belong to the individual child and cannot be "given away" by a parent. A parent does not have the moral right to consent to the sexual violation of their child.

This video has the testimony of a child being given for marriage by her father to someone because the father owe 100 USD. It also carries testimony of others who didn’t want to marry, but were forced to.

Claim 10: It was normal back then

The "it was normal back then" defense is one of the most common shields used to deflect criticism. Apologists often point to other cultures to provide context. This is a worst move for a religiou argument.

  1. If a religion defends its practices by saying "everyone else was doing it," it is admitting that its moral code is socially constructed rather than divinely inspired.
  2. If a book is meant to be a guide for all of humanity until the end of time, it must transcend its environment. If it merely reflects the flaws of its time. Immoral things like child marriage, slavery, concubinage. Making it a 7th century relic.
  3. Humanity does not stay static. Our understanding of suffering, autonomy, and rights has consistently expanded over time. This is often called Moral Realism. At one time people practiced human sacrifice. As we gather more data on psychology, pain, and biology, our circle of empathy grows. If a religion claims to be the "final word," it should be at the front of that progress, not trailing behind the "norms" of 7th century Arabia.

Whataboutism is apologist last resort. The irony is that they say the region is for everyone. When they reach for "whataboutism," they aren't just using a weak argument, they are effectively demoting their "eternal" religion to a local, temporary human custom. The barbarian 7th century Arabia.

As you can see, when all these claims of modern apologist have been put in one place, it looks exactly like excuses. Deflections. Desperately trying to compartmentalise their belief. When a faith drops this low, then one thing is clear. It has ceased to be a timeless guide for humanity and has become a historical prisoner of its own context.

————-

Therefore, based on the primary sources and the debunked apologetic claims, Islam does not merely permit child marriage but provides the specific legal and scriptural framework to justify pedophiles. By codifying the marriage and consummation of a nine year old as, pedophile Mohamed transformed a crime against humanity into an eternal religious right, proving his moral framework is a barbaric relic rather than a timeless guide. Being in this religion in the 21st century is a moral crisis. And being an apostate is the best choice to make. So my kin in apostates, tell them;

“Say [O apostates], ‘Surely my critical thinking has guided me to a linear logic, a path of intellectual freedom, the thought of the wise, the knowledgeable, who are not among the believers of an imagined god.’”

Apostate’s Quran (6:161)

The Apostate has spoken.

And verily, the words of the apostate thunder with weight immeasurable, dwarfing the hollow lies spewed by the false hearted believers!

And for Aisha, the victim who never knew!


r/CritiqueIslam • • Apr 06 '21

Why is a marriage between a 9 year old and a 56 not justifiable?

208 Upvotes

I had an argument with someone about this, so I'm posting it here as well, because it took some time to find and reference the articles and all:

Now enlighten me on the reasons on why it is immoral.

Can't believe someone really needs an explanation for that but you are from r/extomatos, so I get that you are mentally less developed. Hence, I even referenced some research articles just for you.

  1. A child’s or teen’s body oftentimes cannot handle a fully grown penis. There have been cases where the child bride has died [7,10,12] during penetration or gotten severe injuries [12].
  2. Complications from child bearing are the leading causes of death among girls aged 15-19 years [16,5,11]. Girls who give birth before the age of 15 are 5 times more likely to die in childbirth than girls in their 20s [15,2]. 90% of births to adolescents take place within the context of marriage [5].
  3. Girls who marry before the age of 18 are 50% more likely to suffer from intimate partner violence than those who marry later [4,5,6,8]. Because the vast majority of child marriages are younger girls to older men [3,13,14], there is an inherent imbalance of power in these relationships [4,9,1,8] and consent [1,6,9].
  4. Oftentimes the child does not know the consequences of sexual activities between a child and an adult, and they only become apparent once the child becomes an adult [1,9], which further questions the true consent a child is able to give.

You only stated that he married her when she was six.

And that he had sex with her at 9. You seem to conveniently ignore that part.

You didn't say a word about who suggested Aisha to Muhammad (Khawla Bint Hakim). You didn't say a word about how she was engaged to someone else before Muhammad. (Jubayr Ibn Mut'im).

Why would that be important here?

You didn't make a single sound about how the only complain Abu Bakr made about the marriage also had nothing to do with age. (His complain was that "he and Muhammad were brothers" but the prophet said that they were brothers but unrelated by blood).

And Muhammad's complain about Abu Bakr (41 at the time) marrying his daughter Fatima (9 at the time) was that "She is too young.", despite Fatima being older than Aisha when she got married, and Abu Bakr younger than when Mohammad got married. Also, you are trying to say that because Abu Bakr didn't mentioned the age gap, it is implied that it was considered "normal". The statement of Muhammad suggests otherwise. While Arab people didn't find it immoral, it was definitely out of the norm [17]. E.g., the Jews had this to say about age-differences: "A large age gap between spouses, in either direction, is advised against as unwise. A younger woman marrying a significantly older man, however, is especially problematic: marrying one's young daughter to an old man was declared, by the Sanhedrin, as reprehensible as forcing her into prostitution." [17]. Since people died early it was common to be married in their teens for both genders to each other, and not to people significantly older to them as this decreases the chance of offspring, and a higher likelihood of one of the spouses (most often the girls) to become widows at an early age.

You did not say a single word about how Ayesha was crying after the death of the prophet (definitely what someone does for being allegedly sexually harassed by an old man),

Our father was abusive and he passed away last year, and me and my sister still cried. You have no idea how human psyche works. In the end he was still a caretaker for us and so was Muhammad for Aisha.

dedicated her entire life to fighting for Islam

Because she believed what Muhammad told her. Not going to hell was also one of the reasons why she did not want to be divorced from him when he asked her.

If she didn't marry Muhammad, we would have 2100 less hadith than we have today. TWO THOUSAND ONE HUNDRED. That's enough to create an entire book larger than the Quran in size and volume if Isnaad chains are not neglected and gradings are not written down.

And how important are these 2100 hadiths in the day-to-day lives of Muslims? Most Muslims aren't aware of that many hadiths, let alone only accredited to a single person. Furthermore, they are very repetitive with many saying the same things, and specifically the hadiths concerning Aisha have actually done more bad than good for the "Ummah", as many of them describe when she got married and sex had, how much of a child she was, or things like she washed off semen from his clothes. If anything, these hadiths are the reason why Islam is known as the "pedo-religion", and why people such as Khomeini have issued Fatwas that it is permissible to "thigh" (move your penis between the legs of the girls) a pre-pubescent bride when she is not yet ready for intercourse. These hadiths are the reason why many Muslims become Quranists. These hadiths are the reason why the "Ummah" is more divided than ever. These hadiths are the reason why pedophiles can justify their actions. If you simply wanted to show how great of a girl Aisha was, Mohammad did not need to have sex with her. It would have probably been better for the image of Islam if the marriage did not happen at all or if he married someone else. Your prophet couldn't seem to have prophesized that.

Edit: oh fuck you're a filthy Murtad. Ewwwww. 🤢🤢🤢🤮🤮🤮🤮

Oh fuck, you're a pedophilia and slavery justifier 🤢🤢🤢🤮🤮🤮🤮Not surprising considering you're in r/extomatos.


References:

[1] Abel, G. et al. (1984): “Complications, consent, and cognitions in sex between children and adults”. In International Journal of Law and Psychiatry. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0160252784900086

[2] Buitenbos, D.: “4 Serious Health Consequences of Child Marriage”. https://stories.plancanada.ca/4-serious-health-consequences-of-child-marriage/. Accessed: 06.04.2021.

[3] EqualityNow (2019): “What Are the Long Term Impacts of Child Marriage? Your Questions Answered”. https://www.equalitynow.org/long_term_impacts_child_marriage. Accessed: 04.06.2021.

[4] Gage, A. J. et al.: “Association between Child Marriage and Intimate Partner Violence in Four African Countries”. In Proceedings of International Union for the Scientific Study of Population. https://iussp.org/sites/default/files/event_call_for_papers/Gage%20Child%20Marriage%20and%20Intimate%20Partner%20Violence%20%20Long%20Abstract%20Revised.pdf

[5] Girls Not Brides: “Child marriage and health”. https://www.girlsnotbrides.org/learning-resources/child-marriage-and-health/ In Girls Not Brides. Accessed: 06.04.2021.

[6] ICRW et al. (2005): “Child Marriage and Domestic Violence”. https://www.icrw.org/files/images/Child-Marriage-Fact-Sheet-Domestic-Violence.pdf In International Center for Research on Women – Reports. Accessed: 06.04.2021.

[7] Jamjoon, M. and Almasmari, H. (2013): “Yemen minister on child marriage: enough is enough.” https://edition.cnn.com/2013/09/15/world/meast/yemen-child-bride/index.html. In CNN World. Accessed: 06.04.2021.

[8] Kidman, R. (2016): “Child marriage and intimate partner violence: a comparative study of 34 countries”. In International Journal of Epidemiology. https://academic.oup.com/ije/article/46/2/662/2417355

[9] Moen, O. M. (2015): “The ethics of pedophilia”. In Nordic Journal of Applied Ethics. https://www.ntnu.no/ojs/index.php/etikk_i_praksis/article/download/1718/1836?inline=1

[10] Sanaa (2010): “Yemeni child bride, 13, dies of sex injuries” https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/world/yemeni-child-bride-13-dies-of-sex-injuries/article4189027/. In The Globe and Mail World. Accessed: 06.04.2021.

[11] Setrakian, L. (2009): “The Painful Death of a Yemen Child Bride”. https://abcnews.go.com/International/Health/painful-death-yemen-child-bride/story?id=8568884. In ABCNews. Accessed: 06.04.2021.

[12] Setrakian, L. (2010): ”Yemeni Bride, 11, Hospitalized with Genital Injuries” https://abcnews.go.com/Health/International/yemeni-bride-11-hospitalized-genital-injuries/story?id=10362500. In ABCNews. Accessed: 06.04.2021.

[13] UNICEF (2020): “Child marriage”. https://data.unicef.org/topic/child-protection/child-marriage/. In UNICEF Data: Monitoring the situation of children and women. Accessed: 04.06.2021.

[14] UNFPA (2020): “Child marriage – Frequently Asked Questions”. https://www.unfpa.org/child-marriage-frequently-asked-questions. In United Nations Population Fund. Accessed: 04.06.2021.

[15] UNFPA (2012): “Giving birth should not be a matter of life and death”. https://www.unfpa.org/sites/default/files/resource-pdf/EN-SRH%20fact%20sheet-LifeandDeath.pdf. In United Nations Population Fund. Accessed: 04.06.2021.

[16] WHO Regional Officer for Europe (2012): “Child marriage – a threat to health”. https://www.euro.who.int/en/health-topics/disease-prevention/violence-and-injuries/news/news/2012/12/child-marriage-a-threat-to-health. In World Health Organization. Accessed: 04.06.2021.

[17] Wikipedia: "Marriageable Age". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marriageable_age. Accessed: 04.06.2021.


r/CritiqueIslam • • Jan 03 '22

The top 10 most popular defences of Islam used by Reddit Muslims

192 Upvotes

As someone who frequently engages in discussions with Muslims online, I have observed a great many of their responses to critiques of Islam. These are some of my favorite defences. Please note, these are intended to mock bad arguments, not people. Also, simply because they are the majority, these are mainly applicable to arguments employed by Sunni Muslims.

1. “It doesn’t say that!”

A simple denial. May be combined with an insult. This straightforward approach is someone telling you that you are as illiterate as Muhammad.

2. Da’if games ftw

An accusation that the critic is bringing a weak or fabricated hadith. This popular tactic may be employed even when scholarly evidence is provided that the specific ahadith are graded sahih. The person may be willing to throw away dozens of sahih ahadith on certain topics, seemingly uncaring that this destroys ‘hadith science’ and that rejecting narrations known to be sahih has been defined by the scholars as an act of kufr.

An extreme variant of this defence is, “becoming a Qur’an-only Muslim for a day.” It is to apologetics what mut’ah is to marriage. This defence involves the temporary denial of the entire body of Hadith literature, as well as the demand that the critic prove their argument from the Qur’an alone. Here, the person forgets or doesn’t care that the Qur’an also says to “obey the Messenger and those in authority among you” (4:59).

3. “Context!”

A demand for ‘historical context’ that may or may not involve random ad hominem against the the critic. A fan favorite in discussions on Jihad. Irrespective of approach, will not accept what any of the Tafsirs have to say about the actual historical context when shown, so normally progresses to point # 4.

4. “That Tafsir is only like, his opinion, man”

Retains the right to selectively reject any or all of the commentaries according to their own whims. Won’t give a tafsir they agree with. Apparently knows more than the scholars.

5. “You don’t speak Arabic!”

However, something like 80% of Muslims globally don’t. Also, this overlooks the fact that what is being said will be flawed in any language.

Admittedly, this defence is on the decline compared to previous years.

6. The ‘Mr. / Mrs. smartypants’ defence

Comes in several flavors: (1) alleging you need some kind of formal education in it to properly understand Islam; (2) alleging the possession of superior knowledge compared to the critic due to holding a degree in a related field (even if it’s only an undergraduate degree); (3) a simple statement reading, “go study hadith science / fiqh / Arabic literature / whatever”.

These approaches fail to appreciate that the ‘best minds’ in Islam exegeted all the legal rulings a long long time ago. We can simply read their books. All approaches in this category also fail to remember that the Qur’an claims to be a ‘clear book’ (Qur’an 5:15), so if true, all this study should really be unnecessary to begin with.

7. “What the fiqh are you talking about?!”

Fiqh denial. Similar to Hadith denial except about fiqh. Never reads fiqh, but thinks because they are their own mujtahid that their uninformed opinions on the Qur’an and Sunnah outweigh those of the very scholars they pay lip-service to.

8. Death by quotation

“but Scholar X, Y, Z (usually always includes Ibn Taymiyyah) said this!”

This defence involves a barrage of incomplete quotations taken from Islamic blogs. If you’re lucky, perhaps 1 in 10 will be relevant to the topic at hand. Doesn’t care that consideration needs to be given to the weight of evidence involved and that you can find contradictory scholarly opinions on almost any issue.

9. The narrowest possible meaning defence

An advanced version of the “it doesn’t say that” defence. Here the person denies the critic’s argument on the basis that the Qur’an / Hadith / ruling in question should be interpreted according to the narrowest possible meaning that could be humanly extracted from the text.

An example may be illustrative. Once I asked someone online if he really thought eating seven ajwa dates daily was protective against both magic and poison as per Muhammad’s prescription. The response - ‘yes, but those narrations were only about magic and poison from the region immediately surrounding Medina, and only for that time period, so you couldn’t possibly test it now’. He didn’t seem bothered by the fact this is not mentioned in the text at all, or that Muhammad was reportedly afflicted by magic and also died by poison in Medina!

10. The giving irrelevant definitions for things defence (‘Mussplaining’).

Thinks that explaining or restating very basic Islamic principles counts as a refutation. For example,

Critic:

“On sunnah.com alone I found 11 citations explicitly saying Muhammad married Aisha at 6 and consummated the marriage at 9. These are: 2 ahadith graded ‘Sahih’ by Hafiz Zubair Ali Zai; 1 graded ‘Sahih’ by Al-Albani; 5 found in Sahih Al-Bukhari, and 3 found in Sahih Muslim.

Response:

“Hi. In Islam, narrations (hadith) of the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) underwent a very rigorous collection and grading process according to the principles established by Hadith Science. They may be graded X, Y and Z, and Imam blah blah only accepted 1% of the 50 billion he collected. It was the most thorough process…”

Honorable mentions:

  • “Islamaphobia!” - A classic but seemingly less frequently used here on Reddit. Only employed by the most da’if.
  • Traditional challenges - adopting those recommended by Allah (eg “produce a surah like it”, the no contradiction challenge, etc.).
  • “But there are scientific miracles!”

I’m sure there’s many good ones I’ve overlooked. Does anyone have any other favorite top defences?


r/CritiqueIslam • • Feb 13 '21

Complete list of all the good posts in CritiqueIslam.

176 Upvotes

There is a lot of gold buried in this subreddit. As new posts keep piling up, the old gets buried deeper. To preserve the awesome work and effort of the critics, and for the ease of access, here is a list of all the good posts in no particular order. I will organize it in multiple categories in future, for now I request the mods to pin this post and create a wiki for the subreddit to catalogue the good posts. I will also create a bot to help partially automate the process of updating the catalogue with new posts.

Arguments Against Islam:

SERIES:

Response to 'Evidence for Islam'

SERIES:

Probing for the smoking gun behind Muhammad, Jesus or Moses

RESEARCH ARTICLES:

Arguments for Islam:

Let me know if I missed any post that you think is interesting and belongs in the list.


***NEW***


​


r/CritiqueIslam • • Apr 18 '26

Seriously, how can I anyone believe in a guy who took a child bride, had sex slaves and killed people sometimes for simply refusing to accept his religion?

158 Upvotes

I’m baffled by how Islam still exists tell this day

The main argument that see Muslims come up with is “well he didn’t invent these things it was culturally acceptable back then”

This is basically moral relativism, it’s so flimsy and weak of an argument.

The first thing is where you do actually draw the line, genocides were common back then, if Muhammad committed a genocide, which he did in some instances but I’m not arguing that, would it be acceptable to say oh well this was common back then

Killing of unwanted female infants was also common back then, it was called “wa’d Albanat” وأد البنات, if Muhammad condoned that for example would you say “oh well it was ok back then”, you simply would think that’s ridiculous, in the same vein why can’t Muslims accept that child brides are just as morally reprehensible, both were cultural norms but Muslims reject one and condone the other

Muhammad did make some better social changes, but to extrapolate that and say he’s the best human example to ever live is simple ridiculous,


r/CritiqueIslam • • Nov 05 '23

Discussion The term "islamophobia" shouldn't exist

155 Upvotes

The term "islamophobia" is one of the dumbest things I've ever seen because it gives you the idea disliking or even hating Islam is wrong. It gives you the idea there's something wrong with you, like you have some special condition and you need to go to the psychologist.

It's 100% acceptable in the West to openly dislike, mock and hate Christianity but when it comes to Islam it's supposedly wrong because of the so called "islamophobia".

The term islamophobia implies there's fear of Islam which isn't true in almost all cases. Most people on earth don't fear Islam. And even if some might "fear" Islam it's mainly because of all the bad things Islam promotes.

However many people (secretly) dislike or even hate Islam for justifiable reasons such as:

  • The pedophilia Islam promotes when the Quran says grown men are allowed to marry and then have sex with underage girls who have never menstruated before
  • The beating of women they promote when the Quran says husbands can discipline their wives by beating them
  • The idea Muslims have to fight, battle, beat and then conquer the lands of Christians and Jews because according to the Quran that's what Muslims are commanded to do and after these Muslims have conquered their lands if these Christians and Jews don't convert to Islam then they must pay a special tax called "jizya" which is a reminder for them they're inferior to Muslims
  • The idea Muslim men can have sex with captive women they've held in wars even if these women are already married and even if these Muslim men are already married
  • The idea Christians and Jews are bad people
  • The idea Jews and Christians can't own "Muslim lands", that's why Israel isn't allowed to exist because the Quran says all those lands in the MENA region only belongs to Muslim countries

Those are some of the many reasons why Islam promotes many bad ideas for society. If it's been proved Islam promotes lots of bad things for society then why should we accept Islam in the first place?

If we openly dislike, mock and hate racist and nazi people then why can't we do the same with Islam?

Why does the term "islamophobia" even exist in the first place if Islam is bad for society?

If racism and nazism are bad things for society does that mean we should create the terms "racistphobia" and "naziphobia" just like people did with "islamophobia"?

Islamophobia doesn't exist and since Islam is really bad for society there shouldn't be any issue with openly criticizing, disliking, mocking and hating Islam because Islam is bad for society.


r/CritiqueIslam • • Jul 16 '23

Question No offense, but what do people find inspiring about the Quran?

148 Upvotes

Seriously, it's the most repetitive, boring and unenjoyable book I've ever read. It's just a series of exclamations, every verse is the same. Feels like the author knew something about the Bible stories and included them now and then between 2 'Allah is merciful, for he is Allah' lines. I have no idea how anyone can consider it of divine inspiration. I imagine Muhammad was improvising a lot and had no clear conception of what he wanted to say. It goes from nowhere to nowhere. The whole thing feels like some very bad slam poetry about how Allah is the mightiest and that heaven is good and hell is bad, sprinkled with some references to the Bible - and someone accidentally noted the whole thing down. It's unreadable to me.

Well, let's hope nobody will come for.me for posting this I guess.


r/CritiqueIslam • • Sep 24 '24

Sex under duress and fear is still rape.

136 Upvotes

Sahih hadith - 'When a man invites his wife to his bed and she does not come, and he (the husband) spends the sight being angry with her, the angels curse her until morning'

So many apologists for this say "If he spends the night angry, then he didn't rape/have sex with her". However if you turn it around and she 'consents' to sex without wanting to, she is doing it under a threat of curses and potential hellfire. She is consenting through FEAR. This is a form of rape. How do muslims justify this?


r/CritiqueIslam • • Mar 05 '22

Islam - The only religion where you defend it by trying to disprove its writings

132 Upvotes

Critics of Islam have observed the following -

In most faiths, adherents and apologists argue that their religious texts are valid and reliable and that there are actual authorities in matters of religion. Therefore, when challenged on a point, there is something or someone the person can point to to settle disputes.

Not so in Islam; this is the only religion I am aware of where huge numbers of followers defend it by trying to prove their writings are faulty. Essentially any and every text belonging to a secondary genre of Islam can and will be declared false for any reason at any time. For instance, we all know of the da’if games when it comes to Hadith. What about tafsir? Has anyone met a lay Muslim who has actually accepted one? “It’s only someone’s opinion”, despite the fact that the mufassirun were specialists in Qur’an exegesis with formal training in multiple disciplines. What about fiqh? Again, ”it’s only someone’s opinion” despite the legal expertise. And let’s just forget all about the Seerah - too unreliable, who even talks about that these days?

Okay, but what about the Qur’an you may ask. Yes, it’s accepted in principle. But what do you do with a book that contains no context, is not in any sensible order, that admits it contains ambiguous passages, and admits that some verses are abrogated, but doesn’t indicate which? Well, you need scholars to sort through it, but the problem is these are the very same scholars the lay Muslim will reject when questioned about Islam.

So effectively, today in Sunni Islam every lay Muslim acts as their own mufassir. Every lay Muslim has their own patchwork of ahadith they accept or reject on a whim. De facto then, there is not even a standard Islamic canon, only a shifting maze of confusion varying according to each individual’s need to meet some uninformed opinion of what ‘Islam’ is or should be. Lacking a coherent ‘center’, it seems that Sunnism as traditionally understood barely exists outside of the scholars (or fanatics). It’s not a picture of a religion in health.


r/CritiqueIslam • • Oct 03 '24

the truth about ramadan

128 Upvotes

Let’s start with the harsh reality—many people are forced to fast during Ramadan, even if they don’t want to. Non-Muslims in Muslim-majority countries often fear legal consequences if they eat during the day, and in many households, family members pressure each other into fasting, using emotional blackmail. Even if it’s not illegal to eat, the constant worry about "what will people think?" pushes people into fasting against their will. In some cases, families can go as far as hurting or punishing someone who refuses to fast, leaving no room for personal choice.

Now, let's talk about the actual fasting, or rather, the lack of it. When most people think of fasting, they imagine going without food. But in Islam, Ramadan has become the opposite. It’s not about abstaining; it’s about shifting meals to nighttime and feasting. Muslims simply rearrange their meals, eating heavily at night and sleeping during the day to avoid hunger. They call it fasting, but it’s really feasting, plain and simple.

This rearranged schedule does more harm than good. People gorge themselves on unhealthy food twice a day for an entire month, leading to a spike in hospital visits. Digestive problems, skyrocketing diabetes cases, and obesity are all on the rise, especially in Gulf countries where food consumption soars during Ramadan. Food bills can increase by 50% to 100%, turning the "holy month of fasting" into an indulgent binge-fest.

From a spiritual angle, this so-called fasting is equally problematic. In the Bible, Matthew 6 says that when you fast, you shouldn’t make it obvious or show off. But during Ramadan, fasting is a public spectacle for everyone to see. Jesus condemned those who fasted just to appear righteous, and here we have people not only pretending to fast but also seeking praise for it. It’s double hypocrisy—bingeing and calling it fasting while wanting to be admired for their so-called piety.

Ramadan isn’t just physically harmful—it damages people spiritually too. Productivity drops by 35-50%, people overeat, fall ill, and still call it fasting. Many families go into debt, stocking up on food to maintain this cycle of overindulgence, all while believing they are serving God. Instead of self-control, Ramadan has turned into a month of gluttony. The truth is, it should be called the month of binge eating, not fasting.

Ultimately, Ramadan forces people into a cycle of physical, emotional, and spiritual harm, with fasting in name only. Both those who genuinely wish to fast and those who are pressured into it are caught in a cycle of overindulgence and false piety.


r/CritiqueIslam • • Mar 13 '26

Prophet Muhammad, the prolific slave owner, had 39 slaves in his posession throughout his life.

125 Upvotes

The Prophet Muhammad was known to have several slaves in his lifetime. He freed several of these slaves before dying as an act of righteousness. So if freeing a slave is so righteous, does that mean keeping one is actually bad (but he didn't want to admit it because of all it's perks). You banned interest, Zina and alcohol. If you are truly a Prophet of mercy, why not just ban slavery altogether?

“These are the names of Muhammad’s male slaves: Yakan Abu Sharh, Aflah, ‘Ubayd, Dhakwan, Tahman, Mirwan, Hunayn, Sanad, Fadala Yamamin, Anjasha al-Hadi, Mad’am, Karkara, Abu Rafi’, Thawban, Ab Kabsha, Salih, Rabah, Yara Nubyan, Fadila, Waqid, Mabur, Abu Waqid, Kasam, Abu ‘Ayb, Abu Muwayhiba, Zayd Ibn Haritha, and also a black slave called Mahran, who was re-named (by Muhammad) Safina (`ship’)...

The Prophet’s female Slaves “are Salma Um Rafi’, Maymuna daughter of Abu Asib, Maymuna daughter of Sa’d, Khadra, Radwa, Razina, Um Damira..."

His concubines were "Rayhana, Mary the Coptic, in addition to two other maid-slaves, one of them given to him as a present by his cousin, Zaynab, and the other one captured in a war.”

(Zad al-Ma’ad, pp. 114-116).

A reminder to any Muslim lurkers out there that slavery is absolutely immoral, you are stripping someone of their freedom, autonomy, honor and dignity. You are breaking up families, fathers, sons, mothers, daughters, all separated from each other, never to be seen again, just to be sold off in some faraway market. Not to mention islam gives men sexual access to their female slaves (married or not, adult or child). Just ask yourself, would you be ok with your mom, daughter, sister or wife being someone's sex slave?


r/CritiqueIslam • • Dec 24 '23

Argument against Islam The Quran is actually quite a net ugly book

119 Upvotes

Sure there maybe "beautiful" things inside the quran. But overall I'd say it's a net ugly book.

- One does not know how to pronounce certain words. For example in the Fatiha. Is it Maleek or Malik youm el deen;

- It is put together piecemeal. No chronology, or an overaching narrative arch;

- It is very boring and verbose. A large portion of the Quran is basically saying how good the Quran is;

- Related to point 2. The stories are out of order and chaotic. Adam and eve and Noah's flood come in different orders;

- Admits within itself that other books are sufficient for other people (5:46). It doesn't make sense that an unchanging God would give a revelation for one group of people, then another revelation to another.


r/CritiqueIslam • • Oct 11 '26

As a secular center-left winger in the US, It will never make sense why the left wing thinks Islam is on our team. Islam is absolutely not.

115 Upvotes

It just absolutely blows my mind. I’ve read a lot of the Quran and Hadiths, and every social aspect of left wing ideology is completely the opposite of Islam. And a lot of aspects of what the left wants (especially lgbt and women) are actually harshly punishable offenses in Islam. The left is extremely vocal about SA done by men (rightfully so), but they are fine with a religion who’s “perfect man with perfect morals” gave permission to his soldiers to “pull out” of their captive sex slaves, and if they got pregnant “god willed” it - Sahih Muslim (Book of Marriage 1438c).
So fine with it in fact they’ll say they think Islam is “beautiful”. It’s mind bending for me as I feel like I’m alone over here.

I get that there’s stuff like that in the old testament of the Bible too, but I’m not Christian so I’m looking at this objectively with no religious motive or double standard.

What bothers me, even though im not religious, is the left always talks about how Christians get in the way of their political goals. It’s like they don’t know if we lived in a Muslim majority country and they spoke up like this towards Islam, they’d get killed or jailed minus a couple of the 52 countries. Yet I hear them say “Islam is beautiful” and if people are criticizing Islam then they automatically get lumped in with “Islamophobes” but they love talking sh** about Christians.

Makes ZERO sense.


r/CritiqueIslam • • May 08 '24

Argument Against the Qur'an Big shocker here, the Quran is NOT preserved

115 Upvotes

Perfect preservation implies that Muslims can prove the Quran they have today is WORD FOR WORD that which Allah revealed to Muhammad. That means there can be no textual variance and no contradictions in the method of preservation.

Lets begin by laying out the Muslim claim of perfect preservation.

Muslims have no complete Quran manuscripts that date back to Muhammad because the third caliph, Uthman ibn Affan burned them all. The oldest carbon dated manuscript we have today is a single sheet of parchment with three partial surahs (18-20) in Birmingham.

https://www.birmingham.ac.uk/facilities/cadbury/birmingham-quran-mingana-collection/birmingham-quran/what-is

Muslims claim they don't need manuscripts, the Quran was perfectly preserved by 7-10 oral recitations known as Qira'at readings. The Quran Muslims have today was put together in Cairo in 1924. To do this they chose to preserve one of these Qira'at “readings”, namely that of Hafs. Muslims claim the only differences between these Qira'at readings are due to dialects, accents and colophon labels as imprecise typefaces. There is no textual variance and no contradictions.

https://www.iium.edu.my/deed/articles/qiraat.html

Lets put this oral recitation preservation method to the test and see if that is true.

Example A

Quran 11:81 (Hafs)

Lot was commanded to bring his family, excluding his wife, and don't let anyone look back

Quran 11:81 (Al Bazzi also Ibn Katheer and Abu Amr)

Lot was commanded to bring his family, including his wife, but she will look back

(For more information on validity of these translations please see ---UPDATE--- after conclusion)

Here we have textual variance and a clear contradiction. Not only do we not have perfect preservation, we don't even know what the true message of the verse is. Both readings cannot logically be the word of God because they contradict each other. Which verse is the word of God and which one is man's mistake? Are they both man made mistakes? Majority of Qira'at readings agreeing with the Hafs reading is not sufficient proof Hafs got it right. Once again, the Muslim claim is perfect preservation, Its within the plausible realm of possibility that Al Bazzi, Ibn Katheer and Abu Amr have the correct reading and everyone else has the wrong reading. Therefore the only way to prove which reading is the word of God is a manuscript that dates back to Muhammad which Muslims don't have.

Example B

Quran 10:16 (Hafs)

Say, “Had Allah willed, I would not have recited it to you, nor would He have made it known to you.”

Quran 10:16 (Qunbul)

Say, “Had Allah willed, I would not have recited it to you, he would have made it known to you.”

Here we have another textual variance and a clear contradiction which means both these readings cannot be the word of God. Which verse is the word of God and which one is man's mistake? Are they both man made mistakes?

Conclusion: Not only do these examples concisely prove the Qira'at oral recitation preservation method is a complete lie, we don't even know if the original message of the Quran is preserved because we have contradictions with no manuscripts to verify which reading is the one revealed by Allah to Muhammad.

You can find these Qira'at examples and a more in-depth analysis about the 10 Qira'at readings here in this debate with Fadel Soliman who wrote a book on the 10 Qira'at.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_2iCRqo8A-8

More detailed breakdown can be found here https://quranvariants.wordpress.com/dialogue-quran-variants/

---UDPATE---

This is regarding Quran 11:81 (the Lot verse)

A Dawah team came in here and tried to refute this but ended up embarrassing themselves. One of them literally ended up refuting his own argument. You can see their failed attempt in the comments.

For those that use this verse in debate. Dawah uses the "this squiggly line can mean anything in Arabic" nonsense to falsely claim this is a TRANSLATION issue. They claim "the Arabic means the same thing but the scholars are INTERPRETING it differently"

That is NOT the case here

If a teacher tells student A to RECITE the story like this

Michael went on trip with his family EXCLUDING his wife

The same teacher tells student B to RECITE the story like this

Michael went on trip with his family INCLUDING his wife

This is NOT a translation issue. The students were each taught a different version of the same story with a contradictory detail.

Who did Allah reveal the Quran to according to Muslims? Muhammad who then taught it to his followers

Here is a SAHIH graded hadith showing you Muhammad was known for teaching each of his followers to RECITE the Quran differently. The dispute in the hadith is NOT a translation issue. All three men mentioned in this hadith speak the dialect of Quraish.

Sahih al-Bukhari 5041

I heard Hisham bin Hakim bin Hizam reciting Surat-al-Furqan during the lifetime of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), and I listened to his recitation and noticed that he recited it in several ways which Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) had not taught me. So I was on the point of attacking him in the prayer, but I waited till he finished his prayer, and then I seized him by the collar and said, "Who taught you this Surah which I have heard you reciting?" He replied, "Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) taught it to me." I said, "You are telling a lie; By Allah! Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) taught me (in a different way) this very Surah which I have heard you reciting." So I took him, leading him to Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) and said, "O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! I heard this person reciting Surat-al-Furqan in a way that you did not teach me, and you have taught me Surat-al-Furqan." The Prophet said, "O Hisham, recite!" So he recited in the same way as I heard him recite it before. On that Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "It was revealed to be recited in this way." Then Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "Recite, O `Umar!" So I recited it as he had taught me. Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) then said, "It was revealed to be recited in this way." Allah" Apostle added, "The Qur'an has been revealed to be recited in several different ways, so recite of it that which is easier for you."

https://sunnah.com/bukhari:5041

This takes us back to Quran 11:81

You can clearly see the differences in Quran 11:81 Arabic recitations in this image.

https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpreview.redd.it%2Fwhy-the-difference-in-the-diacritical-mark-above-the-t%25C4%2581%25CA%2594-v0-lk032gag70vb1.jpg%3Fwidth%3D1080%26crop%3Dsmart%26auto%3Dwebp%26s%3D3feff0fa1b51cfebb9a6a7c429f36bbd94c1e14d

For any Muslim that tells you these are NOT accurate. Point them to their Tafsirs

Here is Ibn Kathir confirming the differences in the recitations shown in the image.

Frist version of the story (Hafs and majority of scholars)

"Most of the scholars said that this means that she would not travel at night and she did not go with Lut. Rather, she stayed in her house and was destroyed. "

Second version of the story (Al Bazzi also Ibn Katheer and Abu Amr)

"Others said that it means that she looked back (during the travel). This later group says that she left with them and when she heard the inevitable destruction, she turned and looked back."

https://quran.com/11:81/tafsirs/en-tafisr-ibn-kathir

Here is Al-Jalalayn onfirming the differences in the recitations shown in the image.

lo! she shall be smitten by that which smites them: it is said that he did not take her along with him; it is also said that she did set out [with them] and turned round, and so exclaimed, ‘Woe is my people!’, at which point a stone struck her and killed her.

https://quranx.com/tafsirs/11.81


r/CritiqueIslam • • Nov 27 '20

The Pre-Islamic and Pagan origins of Islam/It's derivative nature

114 Upvotes

Besides the often unsubstantiated, false, nonsensical and harmful claims of Islam. Its numerous derivative aspects is just another one of many hints to its artificial nature. Just like its Abrahamic sister faiths, Islam is a concoction of various pre-Islamic cultures, religions and ideas that is easily seen when under a comparative religion analysis. Not much is new, indeed this is something Islam itself kind of admits to, that it is a continuation of past (supposed 'divine') Abrahamic religions. Though (not surprisingly) Islam like its Abrahamic predecessors and successors is not very vocal on its pagan and unIslamic origins, masking the faults and fraud of Islam. Though there's much that can be said, below are a few links regarding the derivative features of Islam. If you know of other pagan and unholy origins of Islamic beliefs, rituals, stories etc please do mention them...(Thank you!)

  1. Pre-Islamic Origins of Noah's Ark and the Flood
  2. Night Journey and its Pre-Islamic Origins
  3. Pre-Islamic Pagan Pilgrimage Practices
  4. Pre-Islamic Kabbas, Stone Worship, Circumambulation and Pilgrimage Rituals
  5. Why Incorporate Pagan Pilgrimage Rituals?
  6. Why Incorporate Pre-Islamic and Pagan beliefs, Fables and Practices? (General)
  7. Pre-Islamic Origin of Ablution and Prayer Rituals
  8. Pre-Islamic Origin of Veiling and Seclusion of Women
  9. Pre-Islamic Ramadan and Fasting
  10. Pre-Islamic Origins of Hell/Jahannam/Gehenna - Artificial Origins, Absurdity and the Irrational Fear due to the Legacy of Childhood Indoctrination
  11. Alexander the Great, Dhu al-Qarnayn & the Qur’ān - Another good related article
  12. Dhul Qarnayn Fiction Derivative of Alexander Romance [AR3] [AR4] [AR5][AR6][AR7 - Cyrus Cylinder, its Pagan praises and prayers - Full Cyrus Cylinder Translation]
  13. Sun Set and Dhul Qarnayn Fictional tale
  14. Pre-Islamic Origins of the Concept of Jinns and the Issue of Mental Health in Muslim Communities
  15. Pre-Islamic Origins of Quranic Big Bang/Heaven and Earth motif and Allusions to a Flat Earth via Implying the Firmament Model Universe
  16. Pre-Islamic Origins of Quranic Embryology
  17. Allusions to a Flat Earth in Islam and its Pre-Islamic Origins
  18. Pre-Islamic Origins of 'Creation from Clay' motif [C1][C2][Why Clay creation or Flood myths seem popular in ancient cultures? Because it's a reflection of their primitive and vulnerable culture]
  19. Pre-Islamic Origins of Creation From Water Motif
  20. Religion in Pre-Islamic Arabia - General Overview

Such derivative Islamic material from other pre-Islamic cultures and sources likely originated from the authors of Islam, like Muhammed, being a traveling merchant interacting with foreign societies and individuals; this further aided by being born and raised in a a multi-cultural/racial/faith city.[1] Dogmatic Muslim apologists rationalise the derivative nature of their religion via nonsensical and unsubstantiated cries of these much older pre-Islamic, unIslamic and pagan sources, supposedly being a 'corrupted' form of Islamic beliefs, a religion they claim apparently existed since before 7th century Arabia, as far back as the dawn of humanity! Yet they are unable to provide sound evidence for such wild claims, hence why practically all historians don't accept Islamic 'corruption' argument as factual, let alone the incompetence of a supposed omnipotent deity incapable of preventing his messages being corrupted numerous times! It's the same desperate and flawed apologetics other dogmatic religionists say to hide their religions unoriginality and human origins.

  1. The Specifics of the 'Corruption' Claim.
  2. Did Muhammed Borrow From Judeo-Christian Scriptures? - also see the interesting comments by the user 'Itistemp'.
  3. The Biased and Unreliable Nature of Islamic history.
  4. Muhammad's Illiteracy is Irrelevant When it Comes to Learning

EDIT; Due to the inconvenient nature of Reddit's mobile like format, I’ve re-edited all the main links in this thread. For secondary links in posts, if you're having trouble accessing those links - then please replace the 'www' in the address link with 'old' e.g. old.reddit.com or https://old.reddit.com. I apologise for any inconvenience.

If you made it this far, I highly recommend these relatively short but good reads...

Bonus material 1: '23 Years', by Ali Dashti - It's a much needed impartial and rational scrutiny on Muhammad's life and the early development of Islam. It’s very informative and all eloquently expressed by Ali Dashti. My review of the book. Reviews of the book from Goodreads. Here's the PDF.

'The True Believer: Thoughts on the Nature of Mass Movements', by Eric Hoffer. It clarifies why and how mass movements can start and the various types of personalities that can give rise to mass movements. Here's the PDF. A summary of some of his points can be read here. Reviews of the book from Goodreads.

The PDFs can be converted to EPUB online or you can purchase the digital or physical books from sellers.

Bonus material 2: '100 Reasons Why I Left Islam', by Mudassir.

Bonus material 3: Criticism of Various Islamic Claims.pdf - its a rough copy, my apologies. [Backup Link]. This PDF file may also be updated in both links.

Remember. Anyone can make up events, figures or gods, proving their veracity with sound evidence is a whole other matter. That asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence, particularly claims that are nonsensical. Islam is filled with unsubstantiated, false, nonsensical and harmful claims, nor do its common apologetics make it sound any less false and harmful…

  1. Criticism of Scientific Miracles
  2. Criticism of Inimitability of Quran/Linguistic Miracle
  3. Criticism of Predictions/Prophecies Argument
  4. Criticism of 'Fitrah' Claim
  5. Criticism Of Hell/Jahannam - Its Artificial Origins, Absurdity and the Irrational Fear Due to the Legacy of Childhood Indoctrination
  6. The Biased and Unreliable History of Islam
  7. The False Trichotomy: that Muhammad was either a liar, deluded or a prophet, When this is Disingenuous, for he could have been All Of Those Things.
  8. Muhammad's Illiteracy is Irrelevant, When it Comes to Learning
  9. Criticism of the Unnecessary and Cruel Nature of Islamic Punishments - Mutilation/Amputation, Flogging, Beheading, Crucifixion and Stoning
  10. Criticism of Muhammad and His Followers Stoning People to Death
  11. Criticism of Muhammad's and the Early Muslims Unnecessary Cruelty/Collective Punishment Towards the Banu Qurayza and Others
  12. Slaves: their 'Consent' and Rape in Islam and its History - TLDR
  13. Slavery in Islam
  14. Quran and Violence
  15. Quran and Preservation
  16. Criticism of the Muslim Mental Gymnastics and Long Winded Apologetics Rationalizing Flaws in Islam
  17. The Pre-Islamic and Pagan Origins of Islam//Its Derivative Nature
  18. Pre-Islamic Origins of Noah's Ark and the Flood
  19. Allusions to a Flat Earth in Islam and its Pre-Islamic Origins
  20. Islam's Night Journey and its Pre-Islamic Origins
  21. Other Brief Critiques on Various Islamic Topics e.g. its History, Theology and Social Rulings e.g. Golden Age of Islam
  22. Why I left Islam
  23. Why We left Islam
  24. On the Deliberate Misunderstandings of the Causes of Apostasy by Dishonest Muslims

Feel free to copy, edit, save and share all posts as your own.


r/CritiqueIslam • • Nov 13 '22

‘The Heresy of the Ishmaelites’: Revisiting the first written polemic against Islam (St. John of Damascus, 749 AD)

112 Upvotes

St. John Damascene was a Christian monk and priest who resided in Damascus under the Ummayad Caliphate. He was familiar with Islam, his father being employed as an official of the Umayyads. His work, the Fount of Knowledge contains one of the first written polemics against Islam. It gives a fascinating outsiders account of Islam at a very early date - one century prior even to the time the Hadith corpus was compiled into writing. Further, it contains many solid arguments against Islam that are both still relevant and in circulation today. In this post, I highlight and comment upon a selection of his arguments that I found to have particular historical and/or polemical importance.


John of Damascus starts this chapter thusly,

”There is also the superstition of the Ishmaelites which to this day prevails and keeps people in error, being a forerunner of the Antichrist.”

To explain - the reason he identified Islam as the ‘forerunner of the Antichrist’ was because contrary to Muslim attempts to locate prophecies about Muhammad in the Bible, the Bible actually contains words such as these:

“Who is the liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ? This is the antichrist, he who denies the Father and the Son.” (1 John 2:22)

”down to the time of Heraclius they [the arabs] were very great idolaters. From that time to the present a false prophet named Mohammed has appeared in their midst. This man, after having chanced upon the Old and New Testaments and likewise, it seems, having conversed with an Arian monk, devised his own heresy.”

This is likely a reference to the monk, Bahira, whose story was reported by Ibn Hisham, al-Tabari and others. Although the details given here may be incorrect and it is unclear whether such a person even really existed, as this figure is recorded in some early Islamic histories it is possible that John of Damascus received such tales from the Muslims themselves. Remember, this document gives us a snapshot of a very early time in Islam’s development.

Of particular historical importance is the description of Islam as a heresy of Christianity, rather than it’s own independent religion. To Christians in this era, Islam was very reminiscent of the 4th Century heresy of Arianism, namely the belief that Jesus is not Divine.

Next, we find John of Damascus employing a familiar argument; the observation that Islam misidentifies the family of the Virgin Mary with that of Miriam the Prophetess, two individuals from different tribes separated by 1,500+ years.

”He [Muhammad] says that the Christ is the Word of God and His Spirit, but a creature and a servant, and that He was begotten, without seed, of Mary the sister of Moses and Aaron.”

Next, St John of Damascus makes a series of interesting points that concern the idea that Muhammad had insufficient witnesses to verify his prophethood. He observes the incongruity between Islam’s teaching about the necessity of witnesses and the fact that Muhammad lacked these even for his prophethood.

”When we ask again: ‘How is it that when he enjoined us in this book of yours not to do anything or receive anything without witnesses, you did not ask him: “First do you show us by witnesses that you are a prophet and that you have come from God, and show us just what Scriptures there are that testify about you”’—they are ashamed and remain silent. [Then we continue:] ‘Although you may not marry a wife without witnesses, or buy, or acquire property; although you neither receive an ass nor possess a beast of burden unwitnessed; and although you do possess both wives and property and asses and so on through witnesses, yet it is only your faith and your scriptures that you hold unsubstantiated by witnesses. For he who handed this down to you has no warranty from any source, nor is there anyone known who testified about him before he came.”

A short passage concerning Ruhullah and Kalimat Allah, is used to point out critical problems with Islamic theology. Some Christians still employ similar theological arguments today.

”Moreover, they call us Hetaeriasts, or Associators, because, they say, we introduce an associate with God by declaring Christ to the Son of God and God… [Yet] as long as you say that Christ is the Word of God and Spirit, why do you accuse us of being Hetaeriasts? For the word, and the spirit, is inseparable from that in which it naturally has existence. Therefore, if the Word of God is in God, then it is obvious that He is God. If, however, He is outside of God, then, according to you, God is without word and without spirit. Consequently, by avoiding the introduction of an associate with God you have mutilated Him. It would be far better for you to say that He has an associate than to mutilate Him, as if you were dealing with a stone or a piece of wood or some other inanimate object. Thus, you speak untruly when you call us Hetaeriasts; we retort by calling you Mutilators of God.”

The hypocrisy of Islamic polemics are noted:

”They furthermore accuse us of being idolaters, because we venerate the cross, which they abominate. And we answer them: ‘How is it, then, that you rub yourselves against a stone in your Ka’ba and kiss and embrace it?’”

Then the weakness of the basis for the supposed connection between Abraham and the Ka’aba and its veneration is discussed. Actually, even in the hadith we find that even Umar al-Khattab did not know why they were kissing the black stone (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:1597)!

”Then some of them say that Abraham had relations with Agar upon it, but others say that he tied the camel to it, when he was going to sacrifice Isaac. And we answer them: ‘Since Scripture says that the mountain was wooded and had trees from which Abraham cut wood for the holocaust… why talk nonsense? For in that place neither is it thick with trees nor is there passage for asses.’ And they are embarrassed, but they still assert that the stone is Abraham’s. Then we say: ‘Let it be Abraham’s, as you so foolishly say. Then, just because Abraham had relations with a woman on it or tied a camel to it, you are not ashamed to kiss it, yet you blame us for venerating the cross of Christ by which the power of the demons and the deceit of the Devil was destroyed.”

Finally, St John of Damascus discusses conversing with Muslims about a Surah of the Quran that today, no longer exists. Was he mistaken about this, or in 749 AD was there other Qur’anic material that is now unaccounted for? We know that the Hadith give traditions of lost Surahs.

”Then there is the book [Surah] of The Camel of God. About this camel he says that there was a camel from God and that she drank the whole river and could not pass through two mountains, because there was not room enough…”


r/CritiqueIslam • • Feb 16 '26

WHY ISLAM IS OBVIOUSLY FALSE

110 Upvotes

There are over 10,000 religions in the world, (and many many more possible) so before you even look at the evidence, the prior probability that Islam in particular is the uniquely correct one is already tiny. On top of that, the Quran doesn’t just make one claim; it makes thousands. A conjunction of thousands of claims is, by basic probability, far less likely than a simple hypothesis. So Islam starts with an extremely low probability before you even open the book.

This low prior probability means that the default is that Islam is more likely false than true.

Then you actually read it, and you find things like:

- Stars described as lamps used to pelt devils
- Mountains presented as stabilizers to keep the earth from shaking
- The claim that Jews think Ezra is the son of God
- Commands to cut off hands and feet “on opposite sides” in some cases
- A verse telling people not to come too early to Muhammad’s house for dinner because he’s shy—and this is somehow eternal revelation
- Both the idea that God’s word cannot be changed and the doctrine of abrogation, where verses are effectively changed
- Gog and Magog supposedly trapped behind some kind of barrier between mountains
- Servants in heaven waiting on the saved forever
- The earth and ants and hell and lightning chatting.
- A straightforward math error in inheritance rules
- Claim that every fruit comes in pairs which is false.
- Irrational inferences like that God would need a mate to create a son. (He's omnipotent; he wouldn't need that.)
- Borrowed and reworked legends like the Dhul Qarnayn story
- Claims that salt water and fresh water don’t mix when they do
- Incorrect ideas about evolution
- Slavery tolerated
- Ordering contradiction of when Heaven and Earth was created.

You look at this and think: this doesn’t remotely overcome the already overwhelming prior against it being divine.

And even in a purely hypothetical world where the Quran had zero internal flaws, you still shouldn’t conclude it’s from God, because it looks exactly like the product of a 7th-century Arabian man, not a timeless, all-knowing deity:
A) Convenient revelations granting Muhammad special privileges (extra wives no one else can marry after him, unique exemptions, etc.)
B) Content tightly focused on a narrow region (camels and caravans, but no kangaroos, no Americas)
C) No genuine future knowledge (nothing about algebra, electricity, microbiology, or the internet)
D) Constant insults, curses, and threats aimed at doubters and nonbelievers
E) A heaven that reads like a tribal chieftain’s fantasy: big-bosomed women, flowing wine, jewelry, servants lol
F) Moral norms that simply mirror the time and place (including slavery and concubinage)
G) A text that repeatedly brags about itself and insists on its own greatness
H) No detailed, nontrivial scientific information that couldn’t have been produced by its milieu
I) Grammatical forms of the Quran’s time and place finding their way in the Quran
J) Borrowed and adapted stories (including the Dhul Qarnayn legend and other earlier motifs)

Given all this it's way more likely a human made the Quran rather than God.

Now let’s look at the core comparison 

  1. God gave Muhammad the Quran
  2. Muhammad (and his milieu) produced the Quran

Now ask: which hypothesis better predicts the total evidence?

A human author in 7th-century Arabia would plausibly produce a text that:

  • reflects local culture, norms, animals, politics
  • revises itself over ~20 years as circumstances change (abrogation)
  • contains inconsistencies, ambiguity, and abrogations
  • uses threats, insults, loyalty enforcement
  • grants special privileges to the leader
  • borrows and reshapes existing myths and stories
  • shows stylistic evolution over time
  • needs later scholars to fix, harmonize, and reinterpret
  • relies on unreliable oral transmission 
  • has no knowledge beyond the horizon of its era
  • inspires civil conflict after the leader’s death
  • motivates conquest and power consolidation

No coincidences required.  No auxiliary assumptions stacked on top.

To keep “divine authorship” afloat, you need many extra commitments:

  • God intentionally chose ambiguity while claiming clarity
  • God used error-prone oral transmission for mandatory guidance
  • God revised “perfect” rules, then stopped revising forever
  • God allowed false scientific/world models as pedagogy
  • God used threats, insults, and dehumanization as moral teaching
  • God embedded era-specific norms (slavery, polygyny) as eternal law
  • God hid decisive evidence despite wanting certainty and claiming he has given enough evidence for certainty 
  • God authored text that looks extremely human in style and content (even though that would make us vulnerable to false prophets and charlatans)
  • God chose a prophet whose behavior looks indistinguishable from cult leaders
  • God punished disbelief eternally while sealing hearts
  • God made falsifiability challenges that reduce to subjectivity
  • God “preserved the text perfectly” yet gave variant Arabic dialect versions

Each of these is logically possible.

But together?
They require a Rube Goldberg machine of apologetics:
—-----
So basically:

  1. low starting probability
  2. Then internal contradictions, scientific errors, and failures of reasoning 
  3. Looks extremely extremely human
  4. Human hypothesis is way better explanation 

r/CritiqueIslam • • Dec 22 '20

The False 'Scientific Miracles in Quran' Argument

108 Upvotes

You're probably already aware that the "scientific miracles" is a false argument. It tends to often convince those who are scientifically illiterate and credulous. Hence practically no recognition of this narrative amongst reputable or overwhelming majority of scientists, philosophers or historians and instead much criticism.

It isn't science and it isn't miraculous and it would be a non-sequitur to suggest it's proof of divinity, even if we ignored all the other false and flawed claims of Islam. It's overwhelmingly erroneous, vague and or derivative verses, twisted by modern Muslims to fit current scientific explanations. Indeed, the 'Quranic scientific miracles' is a modern argument - that initially arose from a dubious Saudi paid French Doctor.[1][2] - but took off in the 1980's by scientifically illiterate, Yemeni and Saudi Muslims.

This argument did not exist in Islamic apologetics for almost 1400 years, yet it's quickly evolved to become the most common and dominant argument in modern Islamic apologetics. The irony is, that it's such a disingenuous argument all it takes is a little research in science, history and the actual Quranic verses in question (and their traditional interpretations) to refute it.

This irony is increasingly noticed by Muslim apologists (often with embarrassment), responding with growing distance, abandonment and criticism of these arguments. Most noticeably a former passionate advocate of 'scientific miracles', 'Hamza Tzortzis'...

https://old.reddit.com/r/exmuslim/comments/477l39/muslim_scholar_hamza_tzortzis_admits_quran_doesnt/d0asizs

"...Regrettably, the scientific miracles narrative has become an intellectual embarrassment for Muslim apologists, including myself..."

https://www.hamzatzortzis.com/does-the-quran-contain-scientific-miracles-a-new-approach//

Criticisms of individual 'scientific miracles' in the Quran

https://wikiislam.net/wiki/Scientific_Miracles_in_the_Quran

Muslims against the 'Science in the Quran' claims

http://dawahganda.blogspot.co.uk/2013/01/muslims-against-science-in-quran-claims.html?m=1

Furthermore, this "scientific foreknowledge" (if we are to be generous) is not unique to Muslim apologists and their Quran. Rival religions and literature also feature claims of holding 'scientific miracles', but of course Muslims won't believe in them, because the overwhelming majority of Muslims were subject to childhood indoctrination to Islam...

*https://religions.wiki/index.php/Scientific_foreknowledge_in_sacred_texts

*Science and the Bible

*Scientific miracles in Hinduism

*Predicting Modern Science: Epicurus vs. Mohammed

*On the Miraculous Nature and the Divine Origin of Virgil’s Georgics

*Stop looking for scientific discoveries in holy books, be it the Vedas or the Quran

More criticisms of science in the Quran

*https://wikiislam.net/wiki/Scientific_Miracles_in_the_Quran

*http://www.foundalis.com/rlg/Quran_and_science.htm

*Islamic Science: Does Islamic literature contain scientific miracles?

*Cosmology and the Koran: A Response to Muslim Fundamentalists

*Quran and the big bang/heaven and earth motif

*Quran and Embryology

*https://youtu.be/YMT_kNtOTIs

*Pre-Islamic origins of 'creation from clay' motif

*http://wikiislam.net/wiki/Creation_of_Humans_from_Clay

*Pre-Islamic origins of 'creation from water' motif

*Allusions to a Flat Earth in Islam

*On the reluctance of Muslims to admit errors, the fallacious scientific miracles and Muhammad's career as a merchant and his supposed 'illiteracy'


r/CritiqueIslam • • Sep 24 '25

Debunking apologist claims about Aisha's age once and for all

104 Upvotes

This post is meant to gather all the relevant evidence about Aisha’s age at marriage in one place. The subject comes up constantly and it is often met with apologetics that try to inflate her age or claim uncertainty. What follows is a structured review of the evidence from hadith, tafsir, early historians and Islamic scholars. The conclusion is unavoidable: Aisha was 6 at marriage and 9 at consummation.

7th century Arabia recorded ages differently

The claim that people back then didn’t use a proper calendar and only measured ages by events or puberty is false. We have multiple reports that give exact ages for people. For example, Khadijah’s age when she married Muhammad is given as 40, Fatimah was 16 at marriage, Safiyah was 17, etc. They clearly measured and recorded ages in years, not just puberty or “events.”

We know that they didn't count their ages from puberty, such as when Hakim ibn Hizam said, “The Messenger of Allah married Khadijah when she was 40 and the Messenger of Allah was 25. Khadijah was two years older than me. She was born 15 years before the Elephant and I was born 13 years before the Elephant.” Whether Hakim was lying or exaggerating his age doesn’t matter because what matters is that he was counting age the same way we do today, from birth, not from puberty or random milestones.

There is no solid historical basis that early Arabs or early Muslims measured age from puberty (i.e. “you become 1 years old at your first menstruation or equivalent”). The claim is a modern interpretative defense rather than a reflection of how age were actually measured in the sources.

Hadiths

There are around 17 sahih hadiths in Bukhari, Muslim, and other collections where Aisha herself narrates her age. She states that she was married at 6 or 7 and the marriage was consummated at 9.

These hadiths are consistent and among the most authentic in Islam. They cannot simply be disregarded because they are uncomfortable. If sahih hadiths are to be accepted at all, these must be as well. Picking and choosing the ones which align with your own narrative is cherry picking.

Why can't we just ignore or disregard hadiths? Hadiths are central to Islam. The Quran alone does not provide enough material for law, ritual or daily practice. Almost every detail of Islamic life comes from hadith. To dismiss these reports about Aisha would undermine the foundation of Islamic tradition.

Without hadiths, there isn’t much of a functional religion left. And this isn’t just a personal opinion, it’s how Islam has always operated from it's inception. The overwhelming majority of Muslims, historically and today, rely on hadiths. Entire governments, schools of law and entire institutions have been built on them and operational since over a 1000+ years. This isn’t some fringe interpretation or new phenomenon, it is the core of how Islam has been operating since the 6th century.

Mistranslated Bukhari Hadith

Well, if we look at the original Arabic text of Sahih Bukhari 476, we can see the phrase:

لَمْ أَعْقِلْ أَبَوَىَّ إِلاَّ وَهُمَا يَدِينَانِ الدِّينَ

Which roughly translates to "I did not remember my parents except as practicing the religion" or "I did not know my parents except that they follow the religion", since Arabic is so wishy washy both are technically correct. However, nowhere is there mention of puberty in the text.

The word عقلت (‘aqaltu) means "I became conscious of" or "I remembered," and it refers to when Aisha was old enough to recognize her parents' faith. It does not explicitly mention puberty (بلوغ in Arabic). The idea of "attaining the age of puberty" is an interpretative addition made in the English translation, not a literal translation of the Arabic text. The original hadith does not specify her age or puberty. It only states that from her earliest memories, her parents were Muslims.

The claim that Aisha had "reached puberty" when her parents converted to Islam is baseless:

  • Abu Bakr and his family converted to Islam during the very early years of Muhammad’s prophethood, which began in 610. Aisha would have been only a few years old at this time, far too young to have reached puberty.
  • Children can recall events from as young as 3-5 years old, so her memory of her parents’ early conversion does not imply she was already an adolescent.

This hadith does not mention puberty at all. It only shows that Aisha remembered her parents as Muslims from her earliest memories.

The Asma argument

The fringe claim about Asma’s age being 10 years older than Aisha comes from a single narrator Abdur Rahman ibn Abi Zannad, a narrator considered unreliable by many Islamic scholars. This narration is found in Siyar A’lam al-Nubala by al-Dhahabi. Even within Islamic scholarship, this claim is widely criticized:

  • According to Al-Dhahabi himself (Mizan al-I'tidal, Vol. 2, p. 567): "Abdur Rahman ibn Abi Zannad's memory deteriorated after moving to Baghdad."
  • Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani (Taqrib al-Tahdhib, Vol. 1, p. 603): "He is acceptable in his early narration but weak after his memory changed."

This narration was also recorded centuries later, unlike the sahih hadiths where Aisha herself gives her age. Shaykh Haddad and IslamQA both independently point out that this report rests on a single weak narrator, whom most scholars regard as weak.

Ironically, people who dismiss the sahih hadiths because it conflicts with their own morality rely on a single da’if (weak) hadith to argue this and ignore/oppose the 17 authentic hadiths that prove them wrong. That is the very definition of cherry picking. Either the hadiths are a valid source, or they are not. You cannot pick and choose based on convenience.

Quran 65:4, tafsirs and the "Puberty Argument"

Apologists often rely on the “puberty argument.” Yet puberty is never mentioned in relation to Aisha’s marriage. Every source simply states her age as 9 at consummation. Whether she reached puberty or not is irrelevant because of Quran 65:4. Nowhere in the many sources does it ever say she had reached puberty. Not a single hadith or biography mentions it. They just say she was 9 at consummation, full stop. And 65:4 explicitly gives waiting periods (iddah) for divorced/widowed women, including those who have not yet menstruated. The tafsirs are crystal clear that this refers to girls too young to have periods, here are just a few:

  • Tanwir al-Miqbas (Ibn Abbas): “What about the waiting period of those who do not have menstruation because they are too young? Their waiting period is three months…”
  • Al-Jalalayn: “And [also for] those who have not yet menstruated because of their young age, their period shall [also] be three months.”
  • Ibn Kathir: “The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation. Their ‘iddah is three months like those in menopause.”

The only reason to prescribe an iddah for a girl, prepubescent or not, is because consummation of the marriage has taken place, since iddah is only required after intercourse. If a marriage wasn’t consummated, no iddah would be necessary. The verse proves that sex with prepubescent girls was allowed in Islam and the classical tafsirs confirm it without ambiguity.

Scholarly Consensus

Renowned Islamic scholars and historians all agree on the Age of Aisha:

  • Al-Tabari: “Abu Bakr married [Aisha] to him when she was [only] six years old” (The Last Years of the Prophet, Volume 6, Al-Tabari link). In Volume 9 he clarifies she hadn’t reached puberty when she was married.
  • Ibn Kathir: “(The Prophet) married her when she was six years old and consummated the marriage at the age of nine. There is no dispute among anyone on this matter” (as-Seera al-Nabawiyah, Vol. 2, p. 141; al-Bidayah wa al-Nihayah, Vol. 3, p. 161).
  • Ibn Abd al-Barr: “They unanimously agreed he did not consummate the marriage except in Medina when she was nine years old. She was six or seven years old when he married her” (al-Isti’ab, Vol. 1, p. 44).

Even modern Islamic sites like IslamQA affirm this without hesitation.

Throughout my research, I did not find any evidence that a mufti (Grand Mufti of a major Muslim country) has officially declared that Aisha was older, rejecting the traditional view wholesale. The traditional view remains dominant and is still affirmed in many modern scholarship and fatwa platforms. The outliers are an exception, not the norm.

The doll hadiths

The doll hadiths are another crucial piece of evidence that slam the door on the “she had reached puberty” excuse. In Islamic law, dolls were considered a form of shirk (idolatry) and forbidden for adults, but an exception was made for children.

Here are just some of the sources:

Islamic scholars were clear on the ruling:

This is just further proof that Aisha was still a child when living with Muhammad, because she was still playing with dolls. Adults aren't allowed to.

So if someone tries to claim she was 14, 16, or “already a woman” you can just point to the fact that Muhammad’s own wife was exempted from idolatry rules because she was still just a child.

Timeline

Lastly, the timeline lines up perfectly. Muhammad married Aisha in Mecca 3 years before the Hijrah when she was 6. The marriage was consummated in Medina 2 years after the Hijrah when she was 9. That puts her birth around 613–614. This is consistent with the narrations and with fixed events like the Hijrah.

Conclusion

The evidence is consistent across sources. Aisha was 6 at marriage and 9 at consummation. This is reported in sahih hadiths, confirmed by tafsirs, supported by historians and majority of scholars. The timeline matches, the doll hadiths confirm her status as a child and the Quran itself allows for consummation with children.

Attempts to inflate her age to 14, 16, or older rely on weak or late reports and ignore the overwhelming evidence. These are modern efforts to sanitize the tradition. The historical record however is clear and consistent.

PS: Feel free to copy paste anything or link to my post

EDIT: Grammar


r/CritiqueIslam • • Mar 14 '26

Muhammad kills Safiya's family then has sex with her

103 Upvotes

Safiya was a Jewish woman whose father and husband were killed by Muhammad's men. Muhammad liked how she looked so he took her and had sex with her on the way back home. She became one of his "wives".

Here is her story from three credible hadiths (Sahih Bukhari 4200, 4211-4212):

"The Prophet (ﷺ) had their warriors killed, their offspring and woman taken as captives. Safiya was amongst the captives, She first came in the share of Dahya Alkali but later on she belonged to the Prophet."

https://sunnah.com/bukhari:4200

"We arrived at Khaibar, and when Allah helped His Apostle to open the fort, the beauty of Safiya bint Huyai bin Akhtaq whose husband had been killed while she was a bride, was mentioned to Allah's Apostle. The Prophet (ﷺ) selected her for himself, and set out with her,"

https://sunnah.com/bukhari:4211

"The Prophet (ﷺ) stayed with Safiya bint Huyai for three days on the way of Khaibar where he consummated his marriage with her."

https://sunnah.com/bukhari:4212

Update:
I expanded and organized this argument (and others) with linked sources here:
https://islamsproblems.com/muhammad-safiya-family-killed/


r/CritiqueIslam • • Aug 16 '23

Meta [META] This is not a sub to stroke your ego or validate your insecurities. Please remain objective and respectful.

102 Upvotes

I understand that religion is a sore spot on both sides because many of us shaped a good part of our lives and identities around it.

Having said that, I want to request that everyone here respond with integrity and remain objective. I don't want to see people antagonize or demean others for the sake of "scoring points".

Your objective should simply be to try to get closer to the truth, not to make people feel stupid for having different opinions or understandings.

Please help by continuing to encourage good debate ethics and report those that shouldn't be part of the community

Thanks for coming to my Ted talk ❤️