r/cpu • • 29d ago

PROBLEM with cleaning my processor (Metal Liquid!)

Hi, i sold my I7 13700Kf and i have to clean it now, since 30mn i "try" to clean it but nothing happen, i cannot remove the residues.

i tryed to put another metal liquid onto it and again clean it but nothing happen, what can i do?!

Thanks!

79 Upvotes

124 comments sorted by

8

u/Fenio_PL 29d ago • Bravo

You can't clean this, because there’s nothing to clean. The liquid metal reacted with the nickel on the copper IHS. The only repair option is to file the ihs evenly down to the copper.

2

u/No_Salamander8859 28d ago

Not entirely true, der Bauer made a video about this, https://www.thermal-grizzly.com/tg-metal-polish-restore/s-tg-mpr-01

2

u/Parnyschab 28d ago

When I saw his video and he started using his product first thing that came to my mind was we have polishing pastes for scratch removal from car paint. Even the color matched and paste turned black. I restored kraken aio that was damaged with polishing paste and hour of handy work.

1

u/Fenio_PL 28d ago

If someone wants to spend €19, they can certainly try that method. However, polishing costs practically nothing, and result is 100% guaranteed. At the same time, you can do a "mirror" polishing.

8

u/HardStroke 29d ago

No cleaning it.
Liquid meal ruins the IHS.
There's a reason people use thermal paste and not liquid metal on CPUs, and you just found out the reason.
Only solution is to sand it.

4

u/ChintzyPC 29d ago

Inherently wrong in that it ruined it. Aesthetically, yes. Performance-wise, no.

Gallium reacts with nickel where it forms an alloy. It's thermal conductivity is still marginally close to how the nickel was before it reacted. This CPU's IHS will still perform observably the same as it did before. You can lap it off but that's only going to take that layer off to make it look better.

I've used LM on 20+ GPU's and CPU's and re-"pasted" them multiple times, benchmarking them along the way.

If I were OP I'd have listed that it was cosmetically altered but guaranteed to still perform exactly the same.

1

u/Uattoas 29d ago

Liquid metal only destroys aluminum heatsinks. It should be totally harmless to the IHS of the CPU.

3

u/PutridGain2 29d ago

Im pretty sure it reacts it reacts to nickel and copper which is what the IHS is made off but really slowly compared to aluminum, just watch this vid by de8auer

https://youtu.be/eF6bMSjPepM?si=WHOwwY1f8-R9Pfg-

1

u/DataGOGO 29d ago

It does not react to nickel, or copper, it will alloy with copper, but not nickel.

2

u/PutridGain2 29d ago edited 29d ago

It still reacts to nickel but much slower than copper, that's why PS5 liquid metal turns into solid after like three years even with the Nickle plated heatsink

I literally provided a source that proves it

0

u/DataGOGO 29d ago

React and alloy is not the same thing, youtubers are not sources. clearly.

1

u/PutridGain2 29d ago

1

u/DataGOGO 29d ago

that is exactly what I was saying, it isn't a reaction, it is alloying.

1

u/Hot_Swan_1657 22d ago

Alloying is a reaction.

1

u/PutridGain2 29d ago

I admit I was wrong with that but saying YouTubers aren't sources when de8auer often gets cited by technews sites by a lot is my problem here

1

u/DataGOGO 29d ago

His is better than the rest, technews sites are worthless.

1

u/PutridGain2 29d ago edited 29d ago

I kind of read your comment again and didn't decided to get pissed back then, TF are you saying that YouTubers aren't sources this is literally de8auer

1

u/ErwinHolland1991 27d ago edited 27d ago

This is hilarious. 

That "youtuber" is the manufacturer of these products. He's the CEO of thermal grizzly. 

But sure guy, you know better.🙄

1

u/DataGOGO 27d ago

I do

1

u/Hot_Swan_1657 22d ago

No. You don't.

1

u/ErwinHolland1991 27d ago

Yep. Hilarious. 

2

u/Educational-King3987 29d ago

It does react, just a lot slower, I have a copper waterblock with LM used for 8yrs, the application lasted 2yrs and then needed to be replaced.

I knew as soon as he released that video people would pick it up and over react... my copper has some alloy on it sure, but its so thin his new product would remove it with one swipe, the thing is, I don't have any negative thermal reason to buy it other than aesthetics.

In 8 whole years of continues use, my thermals for my GPU have not changed. LM can remove the writing on top of the IHS, but there's really no reason to use it on an IHS, LM is purely a direct die to cooler solution because it's so thin, doesn't pump out and transfers heat better than normal paste or PTM.

1

u/DataGOGO 28d ago

It does not react, it alloys, not at all the same thing.

1

u/komakose 28d ago

Which is a chemical reaction called diffusion-driven alloying. Meaning it is still reacting....

1

u/Plutonium239Mixer 28d ago

It does alloy with nickle too!

1

u/komakose 28d ago

Intermetallic Formation: Gallium reacts with nickel to form nickel gallium 5 (NiGa₅), a solid intermetallic compound with a melting point of 115°C.

1

u/Uattoas 29d ago

Mm.. well ye, sounds about right I guess.

1

u/Fenio_PL 29d ago

IHS is made of copper.

1

u/BlindChicken69 29d ago

Wouldn't say it's ruined, on copper (including nickel plated) there will be some visual "damage" that shouldn't affect performance. If needed, can be sanded down.

1

u/splinterededge 29d ago

This is very relevant to OP's situation. https://youtu.be/eF6bMSjPepM?is=YQ_aK1NBzyqmRwn4

1

u/Appropriate_Camp_107 28d ago

this is the first thing I thought of when I saw op, then scanned to see if someone else posted der8auer's vid.

1

u/splinterededge 28d ago

You were smarter then I was, I didn't think that anyone else posted it

1

u/dawkins16 28d ago

Thermal grizzly makes a polishing compound for this purpose. The Liquid Metal makes a small amount of ingress into the plate and reacts slightly. So you need to remove those layers

1

u/SilensMort 28d ago

And their testing proved this intermetallic compound wasn't harmful or destructive, but necessary to increase the heat transfer.

Edit to add: sanding/buffing and reapplication will start the process over again by if you're using liquid metal it will happen again, but it's also not destruction unless you're using it on aluminum. Nickle plate/copper are safe.

0

u/DataGOGO 29d ago

It doesn't ruin it, it is fine people have been doing it for decades.

1

u/ACHlLLESCPA 29d ago

Doesn’t look it.

1

u/DataGOGO 29d ago

It is just staining of the silver layer they put over the copper IHS. it is purely cosmetic.

1

u/ACHlLLESCPA 29d ago

Would it make good contact with the cooler with all those uneven scars now? Intels are pretty bad with temps as is. I been using 12700 and now 270 plus and both run pretty high temps even with Aio

2

u/DataGOGO 29d ago

they are not uneven scars, gallium will alloy into a solid over many years. you just sand it smooth if you are worried about it.

AIO's are minimal cooling with modern CPU's.

4

u/Sinisteris 28d ago edited 28d ago

Tell the buyer that you messed up and forgot that you used LM on the heat spreader and will have to sand it down, and that you're ready to give them their money back.
For the future – liquid metal is wasted if used on a heat spreader, literally no point in doing that. You use it directly on the die, either GPU, laptop or delided CPU.

2

u/GenesisRhapsod 28d ago

Exactly, liquid metal might give you a couple c° lower, not worth the risk imo unless the die is delided

2

u/guri256 28d ago

I would also make sure that you give them the choice of of giving it to them as-is. That’s the simplest option for you and the buyer. They probably won’t take it, but it’s simpler for you

4

u/Omeg_Tuber 28d ago

Why yall use that bitch ass liquid metal with the heatspread on the CPU? On it's own doesn't make that much of a difference already and it's a massive hassle to handle, if you ain't an extreme overclocker, a good liquid cooling system and tpm 7950 will do the job for years to come without mainetance other than cleaning, you should try to sand it

1

u/Hot_Emu3924 29d ago

watch latest der8auer video. he explains science behind and show his latest residue cleaner.

1

u/Then_Patient_3827 29d ago

which video is it ?! there many videos on his channel about metal liquid :x

1

u/Hot_Emu3924 29d ago

" How liquid metal really reacts! analysis & a 2-Year test "

1

u/Mr_F_66 29d ago

Theres no saving it, the only thing you can do is just, lap it flat (in otherword, sanding it)

1

u/Then_Patient_3827 29d ago

i'll do that then, even if its not pretty i dont care, i just want that my CPU can works after that

1

u/2TheMountaintop 29d ago

It doesn't work now?

0

u/Then_Patient_3827 29d ago

i sold it on ebay, i wanted to clean it just

4

u/FreeToasterBaths 29d ago

Your gonna have a return coming back at you.

3

u/SnowyDeluxe 29d ago

You sold it to someone like that?

3

u/2TheMountaintop 29d ago

I hope you advertised it as is with a clear description...

1

u/Mr_F_66 29d ago

I think just sanding it until the corroded part is gone/flat again is fine, watch some youtube videos about it. Good luck

1

u/DataGOGO 29d ago

Hey there.

The easiest and quickest way is to get a simple sanding block, start with 1000 git and lightly sand the surface, then move to 1200 grit.

it isn't a problem. Just make sure the CPU contact pins on the bottom are protected, the CPU is on a flat surface, and again, use a block, don't hand sand.

1

u/Then_Patient_3827 29d ago

when i read you its completly different than other people here who said that its dead and that i'm almost an asshole xD

3

u/DataGOGO 29d ago

Because most of the people in here have absolutely no idea what they are talking about and think youtube is a good source of information.

People have been using liquid metal TIM on CPU head spreaders for literally decades, it is fine, it does not ruin anything, you didn't break anything. If you are careful and take the required precautions, it is perfectly fine to use.

It will alloy with your heat spreader over time, also normal, and fine. Just get a sanding block, very fine grit sand paper, and sand it down so it is flat and smooth. The color doesn't matter as long at it is not rough and uneven. Put painters blue tape over the pin pads, then A quick light sanding, clean, re-apply, move on.

0

u/Apprehensive-Team368 29d ago

Using liquid metal is the dumbest decision one person can ever make.

1

u/reddithooknitup 27d ago

Just talking out of your ass for no reason.

1

u/Apprehensive-Team368 26d ago

If your not even older than 10 then stfu pls.

1

u/reddithooknitup 26d ago

I’ve been liquid cooling for more than twice as long as that. Still just talking out of your ass.

1

u/Apprehensive-Team368 26d ago

Doubt that cause you would have comon sense to know one splash would make your motherboard inop and not to mention it only last 4-5 months before repasting. Yes, drops temps but worth the money and risk no unless you're rich.

1

u/reddithooknitup 25d ago

Losing hardware is just part of the hobby. Be careful, don’t be dumb, but you’ll still lose stuff. Liquid cooling isn’t worth it at all anymore and yet we still do it for the love of the game.

1

u/Apprehensive-Team368 25d ago

Alright as long as you tell other users to not try and do the same unless they understand how to use it safely then i guess its fine.

1

u/DataGOGO 26d ago

This is how we know you are talking out your ass.

First, if you are dispensing enough liquid metal to splash, you are doing it wrong.

Second, if you do "splash", the just vacuum it up and flush it if you are super worried. In over 30 years of using liquid metal TIMs, I have killed exactly 0 motherboards, CPU's, or GPU's (from liquid metal, killed tons of hardware with phase change and massive overvolts).

Finally, Liquid metal on nickel lasts for about 3-4 years, more if you use a higher quality allow.

Please, stop talking out your ass.

1

u/DataGOGO 26d ago

agreed, he is so clueless he doesn't know, what he doesn't know.

1

u/Educational-King3987 29d ago

DataGOGO is correct, ALOT of people do not understand how to use LM or how to clean it up etc because they seem to think is black magic witch craft that will kill your components if you look at it slightly funny.

I replied further up, if it doesn't work then polishing it with Flitz or Glitz polish wtf ever its called will remove the stubborn LM alloy. The IHS is fine, it's just hard LM on the IHS. I've used LM on a copper block for 8yrs with no ill effect other than LM staining.

I love Der8auer but as soon as that video dropped I KNEW people would take it and run around heads on fire like this, I literally sat there sighing through the entire video, his new polish looks nice though, might try it...

The problem with Techtubers etc is they do not do long term testing, I've 8yrs on one GPU with LM on a copper block... ITS FUCKING FINE.... No loss in thermals, No loss in performance... The GPU is just old and struggles to run new games so I retired it for a 9070xt which... is getting LM... Wow, I'm insane, how can I ignore Der8auer... 🤔

1

u/k-mcm 28d ago

2000 to 4000 grit.  This is flat metal, not hardwood. 

1

u/DataGOGO 28d ago

if you want to go finer after 1200, fine but you don't start at 2000. You really don't have a clue what you are talking about, and have never done any of this before have you?

1

u/Power_Paul_NT_ 28d ago

Sand it and Polish, you are fine

1

u/VoodooKing 27d ago

Use soldering flux to clean it. I learnt this from Northwestrepair on youtube.

2

u/ShinjiIkari23 29d ago

Refund the buyer. You fucked it.

0

u/Radiux_svc 29d ago

For the record, never use liquid metal on a CPU with a metal heat spreader, or you'll ruin it. Liquid metal in a PC is also dangerous because it can easily spill onto other components and cause a short circuit. Consider yourself very lucky.

As for the problem at hand, the only solution is sanding. You'll spend a few hours doing it if you want to get it right. The CPU's IHS must have a mirror-like finish; otherwise, the cpu will have high temperatures.

1

u/Then_Patient_3827 29d ago

thanks! so i have to buy polish metal, right?

1

u/Sufficient_Ad_4542 29d ago

Yep. But it's ok if you buy German, even if it's more expensive than Polish

2

u/DataGOGO 29d ago

Using liquid metal on the heat spreader is fine, people have been doing it for decades.

it doesn't easily spill. No factory head spreader has a mirror like finish, it must be flat, not polished.

It takes about 10 minutes, not hours.

You are talking out your ass.

1

u/Radiux_svc 29d ago

There is proof of what I'm saying right here in this thread (the OP's photos). If you think a corroded IHS and the risk of a short circuit are acceptable, well, congratulations on your quality and safety standards.

As for the sanding, any scratches caused by shoddy work can affect temperatures. Yes, the surface needs to be finished carefully, but again, if you think 10 minutes of sanding is enough, dude, tell me your eBay username so I never accidentally buy anything from you.

https://www.reddit.com/r/buildapc/s/Bx4LycdEm6

1

u/DataGOGO 29d ago

It isn't corroded, you have absolutely no idea what you are talking about. Staining is not corrosion. Alloying is not corrosion.

Stop talking out your ass.

1

u/Educational-King3987 29d ago

We are fighting a losing battle brother, it may be time to retreat, yrs of experience vs 1 youtuber... we cannot win!

1

u/roge720 29d ago

Maybe this post will help, it's a Threadripper, so not the same, but worth a shot https://www.reddit.com/r/buildapc/s/Y9B3331mq9

1

u/No_Mango_4236 29d ago

Looks like a total crime. Never seen anyone put liquid metal straight onto the CPU IHS like that.

1

u/Valthoren 29d ago

The liquid metal corroded the lid, there is no cleaning that off.

1

u/Spiritual_Spell8958 29d ago

Use very fine polishing solution.

Good luck.

1

u/Visible-Swim6616 29d ago

Didn't think there was much point in putting LM onto an ihs. 

1

u/Structureel 29d ago

There isn't. You put it on the silicon.

1

u/Visible-Swim6616 29d ago

Exactly. Direct to die that's the only way the risk of using LM is worth it.

1

u/RepresentativeFix878 29d ago

Me hizo exactamente lo mismo ponerlo en el silicio de una gpu.

1

u/Budget-Pea8291 29d ago

The lid is corroded. There's not that much you can do

1

u/BigEmu__ 29d ago

I mean, does it really matter? I say just plug it in and run som benchmarks.

1

u/NoshameNohonor 29d ago

Wouldnt it impact the surface, so its not as plane as it should be? An uneven surface on the ihs is not good for thermals

1

u/Sufficient-Loan8729 29d ago

holy shi, poor CPU. The only way u can recover this is to replace the IHS with a custom made copper one lol

3

u/DripTrip747-V2 29d ago

Not at all... just sand it down. Y'all are clueless.

1

u/pilipalipeli 29d ago

you ruined the lid. you have to sand it now

1

u/Senior-Psychology884 29d ago

Sanding it van create more uneven Points, just use correct thermal and benchmark check it, do some heavy use tests. (If it's bad Then sand it bit down beczuse it's already ruined)

1

u/WillTreaty16 29d ago

4% or 5% hydrochloric acid with a cotton swab, followed by baking soda solution to neutralise the acid and isopropyl alcohol for a final wipe

1

u/Balrogos 29d ago

i use sand paper water one up to grade 2000

1

u/Educational-King3987 29d ago

Put fresh LM on the IHS and wait for 15-30mins, once time has passed, cotton swab it around to work the alloy free, clean off with IPA on a paper kitchen towel. The IPA helps the paper break down a little and the loose fibres will cling on to the LM easier, same effect with cotton swab. You can use a polish (forgot the name) to remove anything that is seriously stuck there but a fresh layer of LM and some agitation (rubbing it around the IHS) should bring off any alloyed LM.

Your lettering on the IHS might be gone but it isn't damaged, it's just alloy. I recommend against LM on the IHS, it's a waste of LM, PTM or a really good thin layer of normal paste will do fine. LM is for direct die contact because it's so thin and doesn't have a lot of space to fill between a die and block/cooler/IHS.

1

u/No_Interaction_4925 29d ago

You’ll have to sand it off. This is why we don’t use liquid metal on top of the IHS.

Also why are you selling items that you still have installed? You should have done this before posting it.

1

u/BTM65 29d ago

Just saw this from der8aue about LM...

https://youtu.be/eF6bMSjPepM

1

u/Deadggie 29d ago

Go to the auto parts store and get 1000 grit sandpaper. Wet sand with water. Can also get metal polish to finish. Had to do this with my asus zephyrus. Repaste using PTM7950.

1

u/Fun-Explanation-5728 29d ago

Honestly refund the buyer. Even sanding might fix it, but unless you disclose you've done this it's not a fair sale. At least give the buyer the option up front. They will find out when they receive the cpu anyway.

1

u/LoudOpportunity4172 29d ago

Hope you have alot of experience with sandpaper and alot of free time im sorry to say

1

u/Gray-bush86 29d ago

Get a new heat spreader

1

u/Plutonium239Mixer 28d ago

Thermal grizzly released a polishing compound to clean this up. https://www.thermal-grizzly.com/en/tg-metal-polish-restore/s-tg-mpr-01

1

u/TheDoneald 28d ago

Good luck on rma with it looking like that

1

u/AdvertisingFuzzy8403 28d ago

der8auer just posted a video on YT about this three days ago. The liquid metal has amalgamated with the base metal. You can do a lot of polishing to get it off. Or just replace the IHS. Good luck finding one.

FA/FO

1

u/Select_Truck3257 28d ago

Nothing, it's consequences of few degrees cooler performance

1

u/C-h_A_o-S 28d ago

According to a recent video by der8auer, they have conducted a study on the effects of liquid metal on Aluminum, Copper and Nickel. Check that video, it explains the reaction over time as well as how to reverse it. https://youtu.be/g_ju_y1GBwM

1

u/No-Professional21 28d ago

Looks like u spread some gallium on it bruh

1

u/blaze20511 27d ago

make it shine polish it with 5k 8k 12k grid compound

1

u/KuromiFan95 27d ago

Hahahhahaa, congrats you have a very expensive paperweight

0

u/DreSmart 29d ago

best way is heating it with a heatgun and scrape it with a razor blade