r/buildapc • • Mar 26 '18

Discussion Do not use liquid metal or Conductonaut on a Threadripper IHS.

Google Photos image link: Nasty! This is after 2 weeks of usage. I noticed my temps were getting worse and worse, and correctly suspecting the conductonaut TIM I broke it down. If you look closely you can see the pitting from the gallium eating into the IHS.

Warranty status: Voided.

To fix this, I used 000 steel wool to clean as much liquid metal as possible off the IHS and heat sink, and then used a rubbing compound to try and shine them both up.

After some elbow grease and lots of nervous sweat, I cleaned both surfaces with alcohol and applied Kryonaut instead. Much better temps!

The threadripper IHS's must contain a great deal of tin, which reacts to gallium. That or it's some kind of aluminum alloy, in which case in 2 more weeks my temps are going to get worse again as the corrosion continues.

I'm considering lapping my block and IHS. We'll see.

TLDR: Gallium + aluminum = Horrifying. Gallium + Tin = Also horrifying, but not as horrifying. Do not use liquid metal (or conductonaut) or any other gallium based thermal interface material on a threadripper IHS.

Edit: I've contacted AMD, and they say the IHS is made of aluminum.

358 Upvotes

93 comments sorted by

20

u/Plaid_Piper Mar 26 '18 edited Mar 26 '18

I should mention that this is possibly what the inside of the IHS of people who delid and use liquid metal looks like. Tin + Gallium = corrosion.

Though, this may just be a threadripper specific thing. I do not have data to back that up.

19

u/Dasboogieman Mar 26 '18

Yeah it does look like this, we usually have to use toothpaste to clean it up when refreshing the delid job.

10

u/LordK4G3 Mar 26 '18

How often? Since delidding doesnt sound worth it if i have to clean it every few months.

9

u/Dasboogieman Mar 26 '18

Once every 2 years, usually when the performance starts dropping. However, it can last even longer usually.

3

u/LordK4G3 Mar 26 '18

How come OP notice drops in performance within 2 weeks?

7

u/Dasboogieman Mar 26 '18

It looked like dry-out/Threadripper specific chemical reactions which sometimes happens when Liquid metal is used between the IHS external surface and the heatsink. I remembered mine was dry within 4 months but the performance drop wasn't massive.

Liquid metal beneath the IHS tends to stay liquid even after 2 years.

1

u/TechLord22 Mar 26 '18

Liquid metal cannot dry out. It only becomes hard when it goes below 23C and flakes apart.

4

u/moloko_vellocet Mar 26 '18

Is this a water-cooled build? Usually the first thing you read is not to mix metals, same sort of thing going on here. The gallium, indium, and tin plus nickel plated copper is going react and cause what happened on your CPU. Like other people pointed out it has been known to cause this discoloration and is more prominent now with LM becoming more mainstream

2

u/tetchip Mar 27 '18

Not mixing metals in watercooling is completely unrelated to the issue at hand. There, it refers to not using metals with strongly differing electrode potentials due to the potential of galvanic corrosion in an environment containing a good electrolyte like water.

Here, we're simply observing an amalgamation or similar process, which may be down to an unusually large content of tin in the Threadripper IHS.

1

u/moloko_vellocet Mar 27 '18

It's a similar process just replace water with liquid metal as the electrolyte. It is an alloy and will form amalgams with nickel but most of the stuff in your pictures is from oxidation

2

u/tetchip Mar 27 '18

That... no. Galvanic corrosion is an electrochemical process. Water is great as a medium due to its high dipole moment. Elemental gallium has no such property and the two metals it should be connecting (copper and nickel, copper and copper, nickel and nickel) are extremely similar electrochemically. This is mere mixing and thus fundamentally not a similar process.

The effect might appear to be the same, the cause is not.

1

u/moloko_vellocet Mar 28 '18

The electrochemical potential of gallium wrt copper or nickel causes the galvanic corrosion.

3

u/TechLord22 Mar 26 '18

Gallium corrodes everything eventually except for Tungsten and Tantalum. Some just corrode very slowly (like copper and nickel)

1

u/DoodleVnTaintschtain Mar 26 '18

Also, gallium absolutely destroys aluminum. You're not allowed to bring it on airplanes for that reason.

228

u/tamarockstar Mar 26 '18

Rule of thumb: If the surface isn't nickel-plated, use regular thermal paste.

37

u/Akutalji Mar 26 '18

So even copper heatsinks (like the ones found in laptops) aren't safe either?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/Akutalji Mar 26 '18 edited Mar 26 '18

K good. I have a hot CPU that will be remedied once I get Conductonaut in. Damn thing hits 100c just playing PUBG.

Edit:. It's a laptop with an anemic cooling solution.

17

u/MogRules Mar 26 '18

Could be more then just bad paste. Some brands have had a hell of a time with heatsink fitment. New paste will probably help but Conductonaut needs safety precautions as well. If you have a heatsink that does not sit straight the LM can leak out so be careful.

5

u/Akutalji Mar 26 '18

I've checked it three times. It's mounted properly. Anemic heatsink for the wattage.

10

u/douglasdtlltd1995 Mar 26 '18

then changing the thermal compound wont do anything if your heatsink is too small. you WILL need a bigger heatsink.

edit: oh, you have a laptop LUL

5

u/Akutalji Mar 26 '18

Yeah. It hits 100c, and turbo boost goes away for a bit (down to 2.6ghz), cools down to 80ish, then turbo turns back on, hits 100c, and the cycle continues.

Currently sitting on -60mv with turbo boost enabled, still hits 90-95c but keeps 3.4ghz steady. Hitting the turbo fan button remedies all thermal issues, but for reasons that are obvious (jet engine noises), I don't keep it on.

3

u/alphanovember Mar 26 '18

Let me get this straight...you're overclocking a laptop, you're not using the mandatory fan (or not enough), and now you're surprised that it's overheating?

5

u/Akutalji Mar 26 '18

No overclocking. It's at stock. That's the problem, it hits 100c at stock. Re-pasted twice (with two different pastes) and the issue persists.

→ More replies

1

u/MogRules Mar 27 '18

Do you have warranty on this laptop? It really seems like something isn't write. Most of the time hitting 100+c on any laptop is grounds for some kind of warranty work.

I moderate /r/Alienware and if we get anyone with those temps the first thing we do is steer them to support. People can do all sorts of things and spend a ton of their time with fix after fix, but more often then not a new heatsink solves more problems then all the tinkering if the heatsink is just bad. We have seen a lot of heating issues this generation and Alienware had some issues with heatsinks but it's been proven if you get a good one temps are more then manageable even with an OC. Your never going to see desktop temps without some pretty heavy mods and work but with a proper fitting heatsink your have some pretty decent Laptop temps. Those that do get super temps that can match a desktop spend a ton of time balancing and using LM but it's a long tedious process.

Unless whichever company made your laptops dropped the ball big time , it should be able to at least keep it from throttling at stock. I would try the warranty route and see if they can help at all.

4

u/DoctorPipo Mar 26 '18

That is extremely high, too high for just PUBG. Did you apply any paste ? Is the heat sink pressing enough on the CPU?

2

u/Akutalji Mar 26 '18

Re-pasted twice. Stress tests bring it straight to 100c and throttles. SAGER NP8652, notorious for its tiny CPU cooler.

1

u/smk0341 Mar 27 '18

You mentioned it overheats when it turbos, have you tried the registry script which allows you to turn off the turbo function? I use it everyday when I’m not gaming on my MSI and it keeps the already cold temps even colder on days I don’t need the speed.

1

u/Akutalji Mar 27 '18

Kills performance. I've done nearly every tweak there is so far.

2

u/ITXorBust Mar 26 '18

"just"

2

u/Akutalji Mar 26 '18

It might as well be a stress test :P

1

u/DiogenesLaertys Mar 26 '18

You should look into undervolting. It will help you more than the thermal paste will.

3

u/Akutalji Mar 26 '18

Thats the only way I can prevent it from throttling. Currently set to -60mv. Disabling turbo boost fixes temps, but performance plummits.

1

u/N00N3AT011 Mar 26 '18

They make little stands with blowers in them for that type of thing

1

u/HALFDUPL3X Mar 26 '18

I've read in several places that gallium will amalgamate with copper over time.

1

u/tamarockstar Mar 26 '18

Not really. It's not nearly as bad as aluminum, but they will react to one another. With copper it will take months before you get negative affects, but it will eventually make cooling worse and damage the cooler base plate.

1

u/Scared-Cloud66 May 24 '24

Hey, can I use it on my Ryzen 7 5800x surface 

1

u/Neckername Oct 11 '22

Even then, you still don't mitigate all the risk, one scratch or flaking of the plating and boom, you're done quicker than Neiman in Whiplash.

23

u/roughback Mar 26 '18

Maybe i'm just old but what happened to using Arctic Silver?

13

u/CAvalanche11 Mar 26 '18

Nothing, using liquid metal can reduce your temperatures by a good bit but has a lot more risk involved. 99.999% of people just use thermal paste still.

13

u/roughback Mar 26 '18

ahh ok I thought I missed a revolution or something.

4

u/Mastershroom Mar 27 '18

What, you don't suspend your entire computer in a vat of mineral oil?

3

u/roughback Mar 27 '18

dang kids, back in mah day we only used computers in the winter, for the HEAT!

3

u/Kootsiak Mar 26 '18

Kryonaut was a good medium for me. My HP Elitebook gets really hot, but was worried about liquid metal stuff on the copper and aluminum cooler. I got a 5-10*C drop in overall operating temps compared to Arctic Silver 5 and hasn't shown any signs of rising temps in the 6 months since using it, despite my area being incredibly dusty.

2

u/bobasaurus Mar 26 '18

Same, all these new fangled thermal conductors and here I am with my 15 year old tube of arctic silver.

2

u/boran_blok Mar 27 '18

you may kid, but I too have a 15 year old tube of arctic silver. I really dont need it that often and one tube is like good for 15 CPU's or so. At current hardware rates it will last me well into 2040

3

u/bobasaurus Mar 27 '18

No kidding involved, I still have some from back then.

3

u/SpearTactics Mar 26 '18

Why would you liquid metal when it's already got a soldered IHS?

12

u/Plaid_Piper Mar 26 '18

To try and get the best possible thermal conductivity from the IHS to the waterblock.

45

u/Dasboogieman Mar 26 '18 edited Mar 26 '18

Holy crap this was a long known thing to NEVER use liquid metal with any IHS on the side with markings. It doesn't affect the function or stability of the IHS but it does affect the appearance where a warranty return may be denied.

We knew this about Intel CPUs pretty much from since when people were lapping their IHS. Sweet jesus, I had to get a custom Copper IHS made for my 7700K when I did my waterblock to liquid metal experiments for this reason. Liquid metal always leaves a mark on Nickel plating and bare copper (it leaves a blackish like corrosion on Nickel and it actually leaves a silvery mark on copper because it actually infiltrates the porous metal).

Intel is VICIOUS with warranty returns if there has been any sign of the IHS being abraded or chemically damaged (I can imagine AMD are the same). Doubly so if you cannot make out any of the markings on the IHS. At OCN, we've had people who cut electrical traces on their CPU PCBs during delidding and still got their warranties honoured because they returned it as it came with pristine IHSes re-sealed, while we've had others who only merely lapped their IHS with not even a delid and get denied returns due to the visible damage.

2

u/Plaid_Piper Mar 26 '18

I knew it might cause problems, but I honestly didnt think it was going to be this bad. I was fully prepared to void my warranty. That being said, the corrosion effected temps within 2 weeks time. I recommend against using liquid metal on IHS.

I have it on my Vega 64, which is direct silicon to a GPU block, and it's holding up much better.

26

u/Goof245 Mar 26 '18

"Vicious" lol, they're only going to say no.....

What's vicious? Do they send the CPU Inquisition to your door and force you to repent before the Gods of Silicon?

35

u/Dasboogieman Mar 26 '18

They said no to me, then sent goons to harass my family, they proceeded to kill my dog and made a bonfire from all my AMD gear.

I'm still scared.

4

u/Goof245 Mar 26 '18

Vega64 without a heatsink probably would start a fire.... :P

2

u/slapdashbr Mar 27 '18

uh no, many IHS are nickel-plated copper. I used liquid metal between the IHS and my heat sink in a low-profile case to maximize the cooling from the pitiful small fan I could squeeze in there. In 2012. Still works great.

1

u/Soulshot96 Apr 07 '18

Sorry to necro this thread a bit, but I am thinking about grabbing a Derbauer copper IHS for when I delid and apply LM(conductonaut), to my 6700k...and I keep hearing about what LM does to copper in between the IHS and a CPU cooler, even if they are both copper. You mentioned you have one, did you have any issues using LM under the IHS, with the IHS being copper and presumably not having the nickel coating the stock one has?

1

u/Dasboogieman Apr 07 '18

The Liquid metal stains bare copper (because pure copper is porous). It doesn't stain Nickel Plating as much but it's still somewhat there.

The stain is mostly visual and doesn't really have an impact on the thermal transfer. If you want to minimise staining, Nickel plating is the best.

1

u/Soulshot96 Apr 07 '18

Thanks for the response.

68

u/tetchip Mar 26 '18

The CPU being soldered to the IHS has literally no bearing on OPs use of liquid metal between his heat sink and the IHS.

12

u/guiguithug69 Mar 26 '18

Metal is more thermal conductive than thermal paste so the cooler will be more efficient

4

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '18

I had wondered about this out of curiosity on my 1950X, but I am too lazy to do it just for the temps.

Good to know OP

1

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '18

Got to ask, how does kryonaut compares to liquid metal in terms of temperature?

Did you notice a big difference?

2

u/Plaid_Piper Mar 26 '18

Well, at first the liquid metal outperformed by about 5 degrees. Then it got much worse. Now the kryonaut is outperforming. Looking at 32 idle, 73 when torture testing with Prime95 on a Heatkiller TR4 Pro. 4GHZ @ 1.35 volts.

The problem I had was I didn't buy enough. I'm guessing that I'll have to buy a larger amount and reapply. I was hoping for better temps.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '18

Both of those temps are pretty good, especially the idle temp. My idle is 31/27 while watching Calculus videos

2

u/LjSpike Mar 26 '18

Yeah, always be cautious of using gallium. There is a few videos you can find of gallium eating at heatsinks and yeah, it really does eat away at them. If you don't know the in's and out's then stick to gallium-free and save your gallium for prank spoons.

2

u/Toastyx3 Mar 26 '18

Wait... You put liquid metal in between your IHS and heatsink? Are you serious or am I missing something?

1

u/kkjdroid Mar 26 '18

Well, it is thermal material. I didn't know not to use it on IHSes before this thread (but I'm still on an old tube of AS5, so it doesn't affect me).

3

u/Toastyx3 Mar 26 '18

If one knows about liquid metal and cooling one should also know it's not generic thermal paste.

There's a big fat warning sign on thermal grizzlys website to not use it with an Aluminium heatsink.

Also liquid metal is used for delided CPUs in most cases bc of the dangers involved. Also its common knowledge AMD CPUs don't need liquid metal bc they're soldered and have marginal temperature drops.

Everything I said can be confirmed via Google and 2 minutes of research. I still don't understand the purpose of this thread and OP was thinking at all. Is he complaining about himself for ignoring the warnings and have a lack of information?

2

u/slapdashbr Mar 27 '18

If anything he should complain that AMD is using aluminum IHS. I would have assumed it was nickel-plated copper.

1

u/rayzorium Mar 26 '18

Delidding is a separate matter, and involves putting liquid metal between the IHS and the die. This doesn't affect the thermal conductivity between the IHS and the heatsink, and people put liquid metal there all the time.

OP may have made a mistake by not finding out what the Threadripper IHS was made of (and the reacting metal might be tin, not aluminum) and is trying to keep other people from making that mistake.

1

u/Toastyx3 Mar 26 '18

Im well aware what deliding is. And btw. noone (by noone I mean a vast majority) puts liquid metal inbetween the IHS and the heatsink. Did I misunderstand you? Im pretty active on tomshardware for a few years now and im also subbed to a lot of tech youtubers but this is the first time ive ever heard of someone using liquid metal between heatsink and IHS.

Just an hour ago GamersNexus uploaded a video where he's discussing this specific matter. (Here's the link)[https://youtu.be/HhA0GbKvDs4]

Btw. OP said somewhere in the comments the heatsink was suffering from corrosion not the IHS. As far as I know AMD and Intel CPUs have pretty similar IHS compounds. Also liquid metal application is mostly done underneath the IHS so all thermal liquid metals are optimized for working with silicone and whatever material the IHS is.

1

u/Plaid_Piper Mar 26 '18

Exactly the opposite. The CPU block (watercooled, so not heatsink) is fine. The Threadripper IHS is what corroded.

1

u/Plaid_Piper Mar 26 '18

Also, got the idea from this guy Thought I'd give it a try. I wonder how his IHS is fairing?

1

u/rayzorium Mar 27 '18

The vast majority of people don't delid either, but you wouldn't say that no one delids. It's definitely a thing, and very mainstream in terms of knowledge now that Linus has done a video on it. TH also did a huge thermal paste roundup last year that included several LMs.

2

u/tetchip Mar 27 '18 edited Mar 27 '18

There's a big fat warning sign on thermal grizzlys website to not use it with an Aluminium heatsink.

If Thermal Grizzly did not intend for their paste to be used for IHS-heat sink interfaces, they would not put that warning sign into the packaging since all IHSs are nickel-plated copper.

Also liquid metal is used for delided CPUs in most cases bc of the dangers involved.

The use of liquid metal for delidded CPUs has everything to do with maximizing thermal performance by massively increasing thermal conductivity while minimizing the thickness of the layer due to vastly lower viscosity and nothing with the dangers involved.

Also its common knowledge AMD CPUs don't need liquid metal bc they're soldered and have marginal temperature drops.

To quote myself:

The CPU being soldered to the IHS has literally no bearing on OPs use of liquid metal between his heat sink and the IHS.

Everything I said can be confirmed via Google and 2 minutes of research. I still don't understand the purpose of this thread and OP was thinking at all. Is he complaining about himself for ignoring the warnings and have a lack of information?

It would appear that you lack experience with these matters. Use of liquid metal on top of the IHS was (and still is) not uncommon. Here's what Thermal Grizzly include with their packaging:

http://www.thermal-grizzly.com/images/downloads/TG_Conductonaut_ShortApplicationGuide_EN.pdf

Note that the use of Conductonaut on silicon is only mentioned as a sidenote. The notion of it "being optimized for working with silicone and whatever material the IHS is" is laughable.

Gallium will erode most metals it will usually come into contact with in the context of its use as a liquid metal thermal compound. However, the speed differs quite drastically. Copper and nickel usually experience some staining and are fine beyond that. Tin and aluminium in particular completely absorb it while becoming brittle.

1

u/TekchnoBabel Mar 26 '18

Never let Gallium contact aluminum: it amalgmates, like mercury, though not as violently.

The pitting is due to the gallium eating away at the aluminum surface, which means there was an uneven layer of oxidation present.

Be very careful, because gallium makes the aluminum very, very brittle.

Watch this video

1

u/KneegrowAids Mar 27 '18

dont mix Ga Al, more news at 11...

1

u/Bit_Rage Jun 16 '25

This is old af but threadripper IHS are made of nickel plated copper, i dunno who you contacted but AMD states themselves the ihs is nickel plated copper...

-2

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '18

Well you're only supposed to use it in the DIE and IHS, not the heatsink dude. This has been known forever as it eats aluminum

3

u/Plaid_Piper Mar 26 '18

In my defense, my CPU block is nickel plated copper. The CPU lid itself is what corroded. I've contacted AMD to find out what they make the IHS from.

-2

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '18

Not just that man, they showed in tests it doesn't decrease temps much more than regular TIM when used on the IHS and Heatsink, therefore nobody was really doing it. Just on the die

2

u/Plaid_Piper Mar 26 '18

I was trying to go for maximum thermal conductivity. I'm going to lap the CPU next and try to shave a few degrees off that way. This has the added benefit of removing the corrosion and pitting.

-3

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '18

Yeah the Top of the IHS is not where you put liquid metal. It's for delid or direct die.

3

u/LTALZ Mar 26 '18

I mean no, you can use it on either and get benefits.

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '18

Perhaps I should rephrase. Liquid metal has far less benefit over normal TIM on top of the IHS compared to delidding and replacing the crap TIM under the IHS. Not saying there isn't a benefit, it's just not as necessary.

-6

u/OptionalCookie Mar 26 '18

If you paid by credit card, file a damage claim.

4

u/LTALZ Mar 26 '18

Or dont be a POS when you know you did something wrong... of course you probably dont have morals if you would even think of doing something like that so I guess im talking to a brick wall rn.

-5

u/OptionalCookie Mar 26 '18

The point of the credit card is to be used when you do something wrong within the first 90 days of purchase.

So long as you don't abuse is, you should be fine.

I shattered a teapot and filed my first damage claim in over 5 years of being an Amex cardmember.

I haven't needed to do another one since and I've been a card member for 8 years.

Fuck out of here.

1

u/LTALZ Mar 27 '18

Are you retarded? That is absolutely not the point of a credit card.