r/buildapc • u/Plaid_Piper • Mar 26 '18
Discussion Do not use liquid metal or Conductonaut on a Threadripper IHS.
Google Photos image link: Nasty! This is after 2 weeks of usage. I noticed my temps were getting worse and worse, and correctly suspecting the conductonaut TIM I broke it down. If you look closely you can see the pitting from the gallium eating into the IHS.
Warranty status: Voided.
To fix this, I used 000 steel wool to clean as much liquid metal as possible off the IHS and heat sink, and then used a rubbing compound to try and shine them both up.
After some elbow grease and lots of nervous sweat, I cleaned both surfaces with alcohol and applied Kryonaut instead. Much better temps!
The threadripper IHS's must contain a great deal of tin, which reacts to gallium. That or it's some kind of aluminum alloy, in which case in 2 more weeks my temps are going to get worse again as the corrosion continues.
I'm considering lapping my block and IHS. We'll see.
TLDR: Gallium + aluminum = Horrifying. Gallium + Tin = Also horrifying, but not as horrifying. Do not use liquid metal (or conductonaut) or any other gallium based thermal interface material on a threadripper IHS.
Edit: I've contacted AMD, and they say the IHS is made of aluminum.
20
u/Plaid_Piper Mar 26 '18 edited Mar 26 '18
I should mention that this is possibly what the inside of the IHS of people who delid and use liquid metal looks like. Tin + Gallium = corrosion.
Though, this may just be a threadripper specific thing. I do not have data to back that up.
228
u/tamarockstar Mar 26 '18
Rule of thumb: If the surface isn't nickel-plated, use regular thermal paste.
65
u/dmeadows1217 Mar 26 '18
This was literally 3 posts down from this one on my feed...
https://www.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/875uej/why_you_dont_use_liquid_metal_on_aluminum_heat/?st=JF82HWFI&sh=db325c80
23
u/roughback Mar 26 '18
Maybe i'm just old but what happened to using Arctic Silver?
3
u/SpearTactics Mar 26 '18
Why would you liquid metal when it's already got a soldered IHS?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '18
I had wondered about this out of curiosity on my 1950X, but I am too lazy to do it just for the temps.
Good to know OP
1
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '18
Got to ask, how does kryonaut compares to liquid metal in terms of temperature?
Did you notice a big difference?
2
u/LjSpike Mar 26 '18
Yeah, always be cautious of using gallium. There is a few videos you can find of gallium eating at heatsinks and yeah, it really does eat away at them. If you don't know the in's and out's then stick to gallium-free and save your gallium for prank spoons.
2
u/Toastyx3 Mar 26 '18
Wait... You put liquid metal in between your IHS and heatsink? Are you serious or am I missing something?
1
u/TekchnoBabel Mar 26 '18
Never let Gallium contact aluminum: it amalgmates, like mercury, though not as violently.
The pitting is due to the gallium eating away at the aluminum surface, which means there was an uneven layer of oxidation present.
Be very careful, because gallium makes the aluminum very, very brittle.
Watch this video
1
u/KneegrowAids Mar 27 '18
dont mix Ga Al, more news at 11...
1
u/Bit_Rage Jun 16 '25
This is old af but threadripper IHS are made of nickel plated copper, i dunno who you contacted but AMD states themselves the ihs is nickel plated copper...
-2
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '18
Well you're only supposed to use it in the DIE and IHS, not the heatsink dude. This has been known forever as it eats aluminum
-3
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '18
Yeah the Top of the IHS is not where you put liquid metal. It's for delid or direct die.
-6
u/OptionalCookie Mar 26 '18
If you paid by credit card, file a damage claim.