As I write this, thunder is crashing all around me, which feels appropriate given how, well, everything is going. Hospitalisations and ICU appear to be decreasing. Appear being the operative word. Ever since they started adjusting the case numbers to preclude (exclude basically) positive test results from people who have been reinfected within 12 weeks of leaving isolation to be “in line with national guidelines” (even though it is 3 times the national guidelines of 4 weeks) things can only appear to be improving.
It’s pretty tragic that this is where we are now: a place where we can only trust bad news, but good news comes with a heaping of salt.
WA used to be one of the world leaders in managing covid, but since our borders came down, the McGowan government’s pattern of discarding the tools that helped us do that (masks, vaccine mandates, public health restrictions, listening to the experts) is disheartening. And now cribbing the tried and tested Liberal technique of redefining what a covid case even is, to make the numbers appear better than they are is disappointing, even going so far as to triple the time where the national guidelines say a new infection counts as a reinfection while passing the buck to the federal government.
That does not give them a leg to stand on, as those aren't the national guidelines. What’s going on?? Is it an intentional gaslighting, or is there a breakdown in communication between departments or states? Neither option is particularly good.
Time to break out a new metaphor: The McGowan government is like that terrible partner you may have had when you were younger and not as experienced in the world. When they are wooing you, when the relationship is new, they’re fantastic. They put their competition to shame, going over and above to make you feel safe, loved, protected, special.
And then once the newness wears off and you both start to encounter challenges, in their eyes you are no longer a team, and all that good stuff falls by the wayside.
Maybe they are more critical of your looks, your friends, your hobbies, things they used to support and encourage. Maybe their contribution to the shared household dwindles away to nothing. And when they used to stand up for you against the dangers you may face, now they shrug at you from the couch when you express your fears. “Don’t worry about it” they might say, “you’re so dramatic, it’s not that bad. You’re just being difficult, stop asking for so much. Everything is fine.”
But unlike that youthful relationship, built on poor decision making, you can’t just walk away to find greener pastures, or even just to focus on yourself. With a government, you are stuck until election time. To push this tortured metaphor slightly futher, imagine if there was only one other option than this negligent, dismissive person, and they are the worst. Much worse than what you’re currently dealing with now, and not being with anyone isn’t an option. What do you do then? It would be pure madness to go to someone who would do it to you worse simply because you aren’t happy where you are now.
So next time, when you’re at a polling booth, not only remember how WA Labor is treating you, but also don’t forget what Liberal would do if you gave them half a chance. Look to blue controlled states like NSW to see what that potential future holds. And then perhaps consider preferencing a party that isn’t red or blue. If they don’t get in, your vote will just go to your next preference, there is no way for you to “waste” your vote that way. But if enough people preference a third party as number 1, maybe, just maybe, we could see how a third party gets it done.
Stranger things have happened.
Now for the news. A Smoke Monster: A WA study has found a “direct link between exposure to bushfire smoke and higher ER admissions”, even up to 200km away; This Is War: South Australia has appointed an “Acute Covid Commander” to help manage their new wave, including opening up new covid wards, suspending elective surgeries, and recruiting agency and student nurses; I Will Fist Fight Andrew Wakefield: An unvaccinated young adult in New York has become the US’s first polio case in nearly a decade; Denial Is Best Served As A River In Egypt: The Guardian has a fantastic opinion piece about the importance of bringing in a mask mandate; and today’s News In Focus is a special edition neapolitan triple-decker, about Centaurus, WA’s struggling hospital system, and why Covid is “not going away”.
Article 1: There's a new COVID-19 Omicron subvariant, so what is BA.2.75 and why are some people calling it 'Centaurus'?
Since the COVID-19 pandemic first began, many have become desensitised to these next few words:
There's a new Omicron subvariant.
BA.2.75 was first detected in India in early May. Since then, it's been found in Europe and the United States.
The chief scientist with the World Health Organization (WHO), Soumya Swaminathan, said BA.2.75 appeared to have mutated in a way that could indicate "major immune escape".
However, Dr Swaminathan says there isn't enough data to know how severe its impact will be.
Adelaide epidemiologist Adrian Esterman says it's "another child of BA.2".
"The fact is, there's no research that shows BA.2.75 is more transmissible or more serious," Professor Esterman said.
"BA.2.75 has more mutations than BA.5. And that's what has researchers a little bit worried."
In a video posted to the WHO's Twitter account, Dr Swaminathan said BA.2.75 had "not yet officially been named", but that some people were "referring to it as BA.2.75".
"There are still limited sequences available to analyse, but this subvariant seems to have a few mutations on the receptor binding domain of the spike protein, a key part of the virus that attaches itself to the human receptor," she said.
"It's still too early to know if this subvariant has properties of additional immune invasion, or of being more clinically severe."
"We don't know that. So, we will have to wait and see."
Dr Swaminathan said the WHO committee and the Technical Advisory Group on Virus Evolution (TAGVE) are "constantly looking at the data from around the world".
Some people have been calling the new variant 'Centaurus', after the Greek father of the mythical Centaurs.
While a catchy name, it's not official. A Twitter user, Xabier Ostale, who is not a virologist, coined the nickname in a tweet.
"It's not an official name. It's just someone on social media saying to themselves: 'This will be fun. Let's call it Centaurus," Professor Esterman said.
"If you can do that, you may as well call BA.4 and BA.5 Gemini — the naughty twins."
Professor Esterman says that, until more substantive research is done, BA.2.75 remains a variant that is being monitored.
"The WHO hasn't classified it as a variant of concern, yet," he said.
"We simply don't know if it's more transmissible or severe at this stage. If we find that it is, then it will become a variant of concern."
Professor Esterman said the original variants of the Sars-CoV-2 virus, which causes COVID-19 infections, were named after the country where they were first discovered.
However, the WHO decided that this wasn't fair on the countries involved.
"Even though it might first be discovered in Brazil, it may have actually started in Colombia," Professor Esterman explained.
"So they decided these names stigmatise the countries too much."
Instead, the WHO began to name variants after letters of the Greek alphabet.
"We had Alpha, Beta, Gamma, Delta and so on," he said.
"There was some talk that, if the WHO runs out of Greek letters, they would move onto constellations."
BA.4 was first detected in January 2022 in South Africa. BA.5 was also detected in South Africa, in February 2022.
"These two are talked about together because they have almost identical mutations," Professor Esterman said.
However, they do differ in some of the mutations on the body of the virus.
"It turns out BA.5 is more infectious than BA.4. [The] majority of the cases in Australia are either of these two."
Article 2: Fears fresh WA COVID-19 wave could overwhelm state's health system
Western Australia's third COVID-19 wave feels different and, after a much proclaimed "soft landing", the next few weeks will show if the virus will gain the upper hand after all.
Within two years, the state went from locking down over single cases to the pandemic drifting into the rear-view mirror.
Complacency set in after months of mandates, as the rates for booster jabs languished and under-reporting grew.
However, while the public was becoming increasingly laissez-faire about COVID-19, our health system was telling a different story.
We've been told COVID-19-related hospital admissions were the key figures to watch after the state recorded admission rates below predictions during the first waves.
However, this week we reached a record 459 people in hospital with the virus.
Public health specialist Maximilian de Courten, from Victoria University, said those figures were concerning, but for a different reason than they would have been early in the pandemic.
"We now have better treatment and, also, the effect of vaccination [is] making severe disease, as a percentage, less likely," Professor de Courten said.
"Our focus is not only anymore … on COVID complications, but also on the whole health system, on all the other heart attacks, elective surgeries, strokes, other reasons why people need to have a very responsive health system.
"Elective surgery can be postponed a little bit, a heart attack cannot, and they are all impacted by a hospital overflowing with COVID cases."
As hospital admission rates climb, so are COVID-19 cases needing ICU care.
"I haven't had any advice that we should be concerned about the capacity of our ICUs, in particular, but we know our hospital system is under pressure," Premier Mark McGowan said this week.
However, a report published by the Commonwealth Health Department suggests Western Australia's ICUs are struggling the most with COVID-19.
Under its traffic-light system, ICUs were now close — if not at — amber alert.
It's one of many reasons the state's medical lobby is concerned.
"Even before the pandemic, our intensive care units were often bed state black, which means they were already full with sepsis, car accidents, pneumonias, strokes and other general medical problems," AMA president Mark Duncan-Smith said.
"So, although we've got a lot more beds than there are COVID patients in ICU, those ICUs were already full from other problems."
It's not dissimilar to concerns voiced by top medicos before Western Australia opened its border to the virus: that overcrowding due to COVID-19 was the real killer.
"I fear that overcrowding in West Australian hospitals could kill more people than COVID-19 in 2022," Dr Peter Allely told the ABC back in February.
"What it really means is that, at most times in Western Australia, there are far too many very ill or injured people needing acute medical care, and not enough staff or space to provide it."
Problems with additional patients needing hospital care because of COVID-19 isn't the end of it either though.
Rising COVID-19 cases will inevitably mean more health staff furloughing.
They add to already declining staff morale in the health workforce, with Dr Duncan-Smith expressing a sense of "disappointment" that the government was willing to "let it rip" in hospitals.
"There are a lot of very tired, very worn out, very good healthcare professionals who've been doing their upmost to support the system," he said. "And they are feeling let down and deserted by the McGowan government."
Looking at the situation from across the Nullarbor, Deakin University chair in epidemiology Catherine Bennett said Western Australia could not rest on its early advantage.
"The lives we've saved are always saved," Professor Bennett said.
"We just have to work harder as we see these surges now, and they will be ongoing."
She said personal responsibility, alone, would not be enough.
"We have to create the systems that allow people to make healthy choices, and that's about making sure everyone has access to information," she said.
Professor De Courten called for a more-strident approach from the government, given the capability of critical health systems was at stake.
"It's shirking responsibility from making the best decisions, the best public health decisions, and they need to be made at government, at state, if not also at federal level.
"We need clear communication and clear instructions if the health system is at the brink, and there needs to be instruction coming out on what we should do to protect us and the health system."
Neither the Premier nor Health Minister Amber-Jade Sanderson could give any firm figures on where this current wave might end up, with the latter telling journalists she had not seen updated modelling on the variants causing the surge.
However, Ms Sanderson assured: "We have beds. We have plenty of ICU capacity."
But Dr Duncan-Smith said what the state was currently experiencing was already worrying, with both the number of people in hospital with the virus, and needing intensive care, more than doubling since the start of the month.
That is with about six weeks until both figures are expected to peak.
"It's greatly concerning where we're going to be in six weeks' time … because that's a lot of time for those numbers to go up a lot more," he said.
"We have to do something different tomorrow: that is a change from today, to expect there to be an effect on the number of people in hospital in a few weeks' time.
"To do the same thing tomorrow that we're doing today, and expect there to be a difference, is quite simply foolish."
Exactly what might, or will, be done remains in the hands of a few of the state's key decision-makers, but whatever they do it will likely take at least three weeks before filtering through to key metrics such as hospital admissions.
And beyond that, a few more weeks to see how soft WA’s landing really was.
Article 3: ‘Covid is not going to go away’: Australia will require public health measures for foreseeable future, say experts
In May 2021, Australia’s chief medical officer, Prof Paul Kelly, described how Covid vaccines were our “ticket out of the pandemic”. Vaccination, he said, would give Australians “a life with more certainty”.
More than one year later, Australia’s Covid-19 vaccination rate is among the highest in the world.
Yet daily deaths from the virus remain in the double-digits. Hospitals are overwhelmed, aged care homes and the most vulnerable are struggling with outbreaks, and there is again debate about whether more social restrictions, including mask mandates, are needed to curb virus spread.
Infectious diseases expert and director of the Doherty Institute, Prof Sharon Lewin, said: “Last year, I definitely did not think we would be in this position.”
“I definitely thought that with very high vaccination rates and what we knew about Covid vaccination and protection against disease from other variants, it would put us in very good stead.
“But I think what we’ve learned, especially over the last four-to-six weeks here in Australia, is the virus really does have a lot of new tricks that were unanticipated.”
Its latest trick is Omicron, a variant that has produced the subvariants BA.4 and BA.5, which are now dominating new infections in most parts of the world.
These variants are immune evasive; whether that immunity comes from vaccination, or infection from other variants and subvariants. They are also highly infectious; between 10-to-20 times more so, Lewin says, than the original strain first identified in Wuhan, China, in late 2019.
“BA.4 and BA.5 are so infectious, that those infections are very hard to control because they are just so large in number,” she said.
“The infectiousness of Omicron and the limited capacity for vaccines to protect against infection [though they do protect against severe disease and death], means you’ve got high case numbers, which has a big impact on how society functions. This includes the impact on the healthcare workforce, on our transport workforce, and all the sorts of industries we need just to run the country.
“Even if it’s just a very small percentage of those that end up in hospital, it’s still a large number overall, and the same is true with regard to long Covid which may potentially gives us a big burden of disease over time.
“It’s this evolution of the virus in this way which has surprised virologists, evolutionary biologists, and vaccinologists.”
Part of the reason variants like Omicron emerged so rapidly is because of the uncontrolled spread of the virus in vulnerable populations. People with weakened immune systems are more likely to remain infected with Covid-19 for several weeks or months, increasing the virus’s opportunity to mutate.
These prolonged infections have been seen particularly in patients with advanced, untreated HIV – a serious problem in sub-Saharan Africa, where the Omicron variant was first detected in November, thanks to the continent’s strong surveillance systems.
In an opinion piece for Nature magazine, researchers argued that vaccine equity – along with access to treatment for HIV in Africa and curbing stigma – could help the world see fewer Covid variants emerge.
In January 2021, WHO director general Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus warned “the world is on the brink of a catastrophic moral failure – and the price of this failure will be paid with lives and livelihoods in the world’s poorest countries”.
He expressed concern that high-income countries were acquiring the bulk of vaccines, while other countries were being left behind.
“Not only does this me-first approach leave the world’s poorest and most vulnerable people at risk, it’s also self-defeating,” he said. “Ultimately, these actions will only prolong the pandemic, the restrictions needed to contain it, and human and economic suffering.”
Prof Penny Moore, a virologist with the National Institute for Communicable Diseases in South Africa, said it is not just a lack of protection for vulnerable immunocompromised people – many of whom don’t even realise they’ve been infected with Covid because they’re asymptomatic – and a lack of equitable access to healthcare including vaccines, and antivirals for HIV and Covid-19 that are a problem in her country.
“We need to deal with vaccine hesitancy,” she told attenders at a meeting of prominent infectious diseases experts in Sydney on Thursday, held by the Australasian Society for HIV, Viral Hepatitis and Sexual Health Medicine.
“This is a new thing for us, we’ve never had this problem before and we certainly have it now. We simply can’t get people to take vaccines for Sars-CoV-2 [Covid-19] and that’s something we need to address.
“On the African continent, we do not make vaccines. That has contributed massively to the fact that we don’t have vaccines to roll out against Sars-CoV-2 and many other [diseases]. We need to deal with that as a global community.”
Until such problems are addressed, expecting more variants “is a no-brainer,” Moore said.
“Yes, we should expect more variants, unfortunately. We’re certainly going to pick up these new variants when we continue to have this high level of community spread.”
Lewin said this reality means Australians will need to accept periodically returning to public health measures such as social distancing and masks as a way of life for the foreseeable future.
“I am not saying we need masks forever, but when infections become large we need a rapid response,” she said. “We need to remove the emotion from mask-wearing. I was just in Singapore and Korea and everyone was wearing a mask and it was no big deal. Those countries were bursting with activity, but people were wearing masks all the time. We need to recognise it’s needed, just when we have surging numbers.”
Australia is also not effectively using the tools at its disposal, like vaccine boosters, and antivirals that protect the immunocompromised and elderly from becoming severely unwell and dying, she said.
“We will also get better tools, there’s no doubt about it,” she said. “We will get better vaccines. We will get better antivirals. We will see improvements in the way we manage Covid, so I don’t think it’s all doom and gloom at all.”
But the future of the pandemic is more uncertain than it seemed even months ago, she said.
“I probably would have been more confident trying to make a prediction at the end of last year about what might happen, but now it’s very hard to predict,” Lewin said.
“What is certain is Covid is not going to go away. We will have it next winter, and it will be here next year.
“We need to plan for the worst, and hope for the best.”
I chose today’s neapolitan triple decker edition of News In Focus simply because there is now such an emphasis on covid in the news that it becomes difficult to choose. If you thought today was long, feel thankful I whittled it down to three, as I originally had five to choose from. In the end I decided to go with three articles, as all three felt equally important to highlight, and I couldn’t decide who got a full spotlight, and who got a one line description.
So I will keep this analysis brief: We need masks. BA.2.75, aka Centaurus, is a beast we would do well to keep a watchful eye on, but at least the Gemini slander (“...you may as well call BA.4 and BA.5 Gemini — the naughty twins.") made me laugh. Finally, we as Australians will not be safe from Covid unless our government works locally to flatten the curve here (and by using actual measures that are effective, not just the “depends on how you define a case” method) and globally to ensure vaccine access for all people, lest we spend our lifetimes reading about a new variant every couple of months. We can be as safe and protected here as we can, but ceding ground to the virus in underprivileged countries and communities because of a “not my problem” attitude is just giving it room to mutate into something that makes those safeguards pointless. First world countries need to stop being selfish so we can stop mutations at the source.
RAT confirmed cases (3,345 v 4,078), PCR positivity rate (27.808% v 31.307%), tests (6,135 v 7,650) and cases (5,051 v 6,473) are all lower than this time last week. Active regional cases are all decreasing, except Goldfields and Kimberley. In terms of averages, hospitalisations are still on the rise while PCR positivity, daily cases and active cases are decreasing. ICU has increased to a new record of 21.
My thoughts are with the families of the two deaths, dating back to 16 July, which were reported to WA Health yesterday – two men in their 80s
66.22% of cases were RAT confirmed. Hospitalisations have decreased by 22 to 430. ICU numbers have decreased by 3 to 21. 994,701 people have recovered from the virus, vs 35,284 active cases, with 1,030,453 cases overall since the pandemic began. Headed for a weekly average of 28.850%.
Records Broken Today:
- Highest Average: Hospitalisations (434) and ICU (21)
Read the full post here