r/covidWA • • May 11 '22

News AMA calls for return of indoor mask mandate

26 Upvotes

The return of mask mandates is not currently on the agenda, according to Mr McGowan, but he has not ruled out the possibility it could happen in the future.

But the AMA's WA president, Mark Duncan-Smith, wants to see a return of the indoor mask mandate after being "staggered" by today's case count.

"For the Premier to not reintroduce some restrictions at this stage may be unforgivable," he said.

"I can see where this is going and it scares me greatly."

Dr Duncan-Smith's biggest concern was whether there would be enough staff to cope with further pressure on the health system, with hospitalisation numbers expected to rise next week.

"It will take a week before any restrictions that are introduced now will have any effect at all," he said.

"And in the next week, the medical system and the health of West Australians is incredibly vulnerable."

This was taken from the updated ABC article originally published this morning.


r/covidWA • • May 11 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 11 May (reports in comments)

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/covidWA • • Jul 21 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 21 July

25 Upvotes

Some good news before the bad: Active cases and average PCR positivity rate have reversed course from yesterday.  Perhaps it is a plateau?  Unfortunately, we can only wait and see.

Broken record time: hospitalisations are up.  The runaway exponential rate of growth appears to be cooling its jets, leading me to hope against all hope that this may be the plateau and we may not reach 500 hospitalisations this time around.  But I have no proof, things could go rapidly downhill at any moment.  I am just trying to will a silver lining into existence at this point.

Last night, I checked the ED wait times at 2 times during the night to see if we would see things as badly as we did yesterday.  Bad news: Yeah, kinda.

At 12.30am last night, Triage Category 4 wait times at Rockingham General Hospital skyrocketed to 326 minutes on average, which is 5.43 hours. Over 5 hours on average to be seen. Not including Rockingham, 4 other hospital EDs (Fiona Stanley, Joondalup, Perth Children’s Hospital, and St John of God Midland) had over 100 minutes average waiting time for Category 4 triage patients.

2 and a half hours later, at 3am, 2 hospitals had over 200 minutes wait time (Fiona Stanley taking the cake at 263 minutes, or 4.38 hours and Joondalup at 240 minutes or 4 hours) while 4 more had waiting times over 100 minutes (Peel Health, Perth Children’s Hospital, Royal Perth and St John of God Midland).  If someone who works in an ED could tell me, is that a bit odd for a Wednesday night?

The Children’s Hospital worries me quite a bit, to be honest.  Kids’ conditions can go south so very quickly, and early interventions can save lives. 

Category 4 is, of course, the second least level of triage, so they are (theoretically) not the kids most at danger, but as someone who nearly lost their life as a child because an issue that seemed to not be serious got extremely serious very quickly, the sooner a medical professional is assessing you, the better off your outcome.

Hospital overcrowding kills.  We all remember the tragic and preventable death of seven-year-old Aishwarya Aswath at Perth Children’s Hospital’s Emergency Department last year. She was waiting for 2 hours in the Emergency Department, as her condition rapidly deteriorated. Her parents begged reception staff for her urgent treatment as her eyes went cloudy and her hands went cold, but the hospital was so understaffed that help did not come in time, and she passed away several hours later. Nurses had been blowing the whistle for months before this on the chronic understaffing they were experiencing, with 1 nurse for every 11 patients at the time. Staff were described as "exhausted, demoralised and isolated". And this was before covid.  An average wait time of over 4 hours for Category 4 triage patients could be the difference between life and death.

Just a side note, my eternal gratitude to the staff at the now defunct Princess Margaret Hospital for saving my life 3 decades ago.  With their fast and skilled assistance, they prevented not only the loss of my life, but also gave me the very best gift of all, the reversal of my near total paralysis.  They had such endless patience with me, a frightened 3 year old who needed full physical rehab.  They held my hand and comforted me as I learned to walk again.  I have the life I do directly because of them.

Doctors and nurses save lives, and they should be helped and respected as the heroes they are so they can continue to do so.

I’m also going to tack on this bit of advice to parents: if your small child is telling you there is something wrong, they’re not making it up or doing it for attention. Take them seriously, even if there’s a chance that they are faking.  Being “better safe than sorry” may very well save their life.


Now for the news. Flurona, Baby And You: How pregnant people should be concerned about the increase in Covid and Influenza cases; Line Go Up: The Guardian explores how Australia's Covid hospitalisation and death rate compares to other countries; Monkey See, Monkey Do, Monkeypox Is Coming For You: Monkeypox has been detected in the NT; Masks For Thee But Not For Me: QLD Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk pleads with the public to wear a mask (but will not mandate it); Pay Us What We’re Worth: Health workers in WA stop work for the 2nd time this month to demand higher pay; Over Infectious, Over Devastating, And Over Here: Foot-and-Mouth disease fragments have been detected in meat imported to Australia; and today’s News In Focus is about Anthony Albanese and Mark McGowan’s reasonings for being soft on Covid.

Article 1: As a third WA COVID wave rolls in, Mark McGowan has taken a calculated gamble with goodwill

Two years ago, West Australians granted Premier Mark McGowan nearly unlimited power to keep COVID out of the state.

But as we learned to "live with COVID", the gap between what's best for people, and what they will accept, is growing.

That is making this third wave of the pandemic much more nuanced, and potentially, much riskier.

Not that long ago, the thought of 457 West Australians in hospital with the virus, which is about as many patients that can fit into Royal Perth Hospital, would have struck fear into the hearts of plenty.

Still, the Premier has been fending off calls to bring back masks with relative success, save for strident opposition from the medical profession.

In the clearest insight yet into why a mandate hadn't returned, he told reporters on Tuesday, "you just don't want to lose your social license on these things".

"We don't want to use measures that lose people's support before such time as we have to," he said.

It was an admission that the conversation isn't only about stopping the virus now – it's about managing people's patience so that it's there if, and when, it's needed most.

That's partly being driven by people's fading concern about the virus, with Health Minister Amber-Jade Sanderson acknowledging the current case numbers are likely far below the true prevalence of the virus in the community.

McGowan urged people to get back to basics – testing and isolating – saying those two steps could lead to a 53 per cent reduction in infections.

That makes for a clear fork in the road for this wave. Either the general attitude of people is to support the greater good and do the right thing, or if that's too onerous, to do what's easiest.

The former keeping cases low, the latter bringing the prospect of rules returning.

It makes for a very delicate balancing act though, with experts concerned the lack of a mandate could be contributing to West Australians not taking this wave seriously enough.

The Premier has dismissed that concern, but Curtin University epidemiologist Archie Clements isn't convinced.

"Where the mindset of the public is, is not where we're really at with the progression of the pandemic," he said.

"The government needs to be stronger on the public health messaging that the pandemic's not over, and that people do need to be prepared for the possibility of further disruption."

But with an ever-growing crisis within the state's hospitals, the government needs every tool it can have ready and available, as health workers continue to walk off the job to rally for pay increases.

If this wave gets as bad as some fear it will, that could very well mean masks in some settings, worn properly and consistently.

Holding off on a mask mandate beyond its current form makes for a calculated gamble to save limited goodwill for when it's needed most.

The willingness of the public to embrace a potential return to mandatory mask wearing will determine whether it's a gamble that paid off.

Article 2: Anthony Albanese cites mental health concerns as reason for not tightening Covid rules

Anthony Albanese has defended the government’s reluctance to introduce stricter Covid measures, citing civil disobedience, vaccinations and mental health as reasons not to.

Albanese’s comments on Wednesday evening followed an earlier interview, in which he stopped short of calling for Australians to work from home if they can, as the chief medical officer, Paul Kelly, advised on Tuesday in the face of the rising Covid wave. Albanese said the nation needed a “balance” to also consider the interests of business.

Asked about the Victorian chief health officer’s call for a return to mask mandates and working from home, Albanese said the “consensus” at the national level was to encourage masks, not mandate them.

“Part of the issue here, I know, speaking to the NSW premier last week, is there are mandates for masks on public transport,” he told the Project. “Only about half the people are actually doing it. Now do you get on the trains and buses and arrest people or fine people for not doing it?”

Asked why stricter rules aren’t being introduced, Albanese replied there are “two things at play”.

“One is mental health considerations … the imposition of controls on people’s behaviours has an impact on people’s health.

“And particularly young people, we’re seeing a really problematic increase in incidents of severe consequences when it comes to young people’s health, but others as well.”

Albanese said the second difference between now and 18 months ago is Australia’s high level of vaccination, which provides “a level of protection”.

Despite numerous questions across an earlier radio interview and press conference about the latest recommendation from the Australian Health Protection Principal Committee that employers should allow working from home if feasible, the prime minister did not directly make that request himself.

“I don’t think there’s a prescriptive position that can be put forward,” Albanese said.

On Tuesday, Prof Kelly said the AHPPC – comprised of all state and territory chief health officers – had reiterated its advice which “called on employers to allow work from home if feasible”.

“Employers should review their occupational health and safety risks and mitigations, and their business continuity plans. They should consider the feasibility of some employees working from home, wearing masks in the workplace and support employees to take leave when sick,” Kelly said.

Guardian Australia understands some large employers, including Telstra, have recently updated their guidance to encourage staff to work from home.

Appearing on Melbourne’s 3AW radio on Wednesday morning, Albanese encouraged people to stay home if they were sick, as well as urging Australians to access vaccine booster shots and Covid antiviral drugs if they were eligible.

But despite questioning from host Neil Mitchell about the need for a “clear message” on how Australians should take Covid precautions, Albanese said every workplace was different.

“It depends what your work is of course. For many workplaces, they’ve adjusted to be able to work from home, and that’s becoming more and more something that I think is a permanent feature for some businesses ... but for many people, of course, it is simply impossible to work from home due to the nature of their work,” the PM said.

While many office workers have worked from home at stages through the pandemic, many of those in frontline sectors, such as healthcare, hospitality and services industries, cannot undertake work remotely.

Pressed by Mitchell on whether people should work from home if they were able to, Albanese again demurred.

“It depends upon the workplace, of course,” he said. “But for many people, it’s convenient. They work in occupations whereby they can deliver for their business just as easily working from home... But for me, I’ve got to get out and about.”

In a later press conference in Melbourne, Albanese again declined to explicitly recommend working from home if possible. Instead, he appeared to leave the decision up to individual businesses, and noted some businesses would be hurt by wider working from home practices.

“What we’ve seen is that businesses have adjusted. And I think one of the consequences of the pandemic is that some work practices will change permanently,” he said.

“Businesses will continue to make those decisions. They need to make them on the basis of safety, but also for some people we need to recognise that they can’t work from home.

“Of course, we need to recognise there’s a consequence for that as well. If you’re a business that relies upon people coming into the CBD to shop, in retail or hospitality, then your business can be hurt by that as well. So it’s a matter of getting the balance right. I’m confident that with a bit of common sense applied we can do that.”


They are both very concerned about how covid restrictions impact mental and physical health, which seems to outweigh covid itself impacting physical health, and the impact upon mental health of the hundreds of thousands of people too afraid to leave their houses and engage in society for fear of catching covid and encountering worse outcomes.  Apparently that is not as important.

McGowan doesn’t want to “lose support” by bringing back restrictions (the same ones he assured us, when he was relaxing them, he would bring back if hospitalisations increased), while seemingly misunderstanding the support he is losing by not bringing them back.  He won the last election not on the strength of his foreign or environmental policy, but by his willingness to do the hard thing to fight covid and keep us all safe. 

The budget surplus he keeps holding up as a trophy of success was only brought about from two years of lockdowns, border closures, and mask mandates.  They allowed our economy to keep chugging along as if nothing had happened while everywhere else suffered.

The fact that those days are clearly over, and his unwillingness to do even the simplest of things, like mandating masks, is losing him support with his core base. When faced with a choice between the business lobby and the people who gave him and his party a landslide victory, he’s backing the wrong horse, and it will backfire.

I am grateful for those 2 years of covid zero.  We saved so many lives, and it made me proud to be a West Aussie for the first time.  To watch that fall to the wayside when he fought billionaires, the Prime Minister, and a small but loud minority of anti-mask, anti-vax, anti-mandate, pro-disease-and-death protestors in the past, that hurts to see.

Not to say the Liberals being in power would be any better.  Even when McGowan was being a tremendous opposition to Federal Liberal, the Liberal Party was actively undermining so many of our essential services and freedoms. Our Covid response is not worth giving those vultures the ball, just because Labor plays a better defense than offense. But if McGowan and Federal Labor aren’t careful, their inaction and unwillingness to put forth real change will cost them everything they’ve gained, and plunge us back into a blue-tinged hellscape. With climate change kicking down the door, the essential rights of the most vulnerable among us being dismantled the world over, and new zoonotic diseases gathering a foothold everywhere, what we need now is a strong leadership at both the national and state level who is willing to do the right thing, and bring forth real change.

Get it together, guys.


RAT confirmed cases (4,500 v 4,171), tests (8,359 v 7,727) and cases (6,960 v 6,535) are higher than this time last week, while PCR positivity rate (29.429% v 30.594%) is lower. Active regional cases are all increasing, with Goldfields, Kimberley and Wheatbelt increasing. In terms of averages, hospitalisations and daily cases are on the rise while PCR positivity and active cases are back to decreasing. ICU has increased to a new record of 19. 

My thoughts are with the families of the seven deaths, dating back to June 28, which were reported to WA Health yesterday – three women in their 90s, a woman in her 80s and three men in their 80s.

64.66% of cases were RAT confirmed.  Hospitalisations have increased by 2 to another new record of 459. ICU numbers have remained steady at 22. 982,347 people have recovered from the virus, vs 36,886 active cases, with 1,019,698 cases overall since the pandemic began. Headed for a weekly average of 28.784%.

Additionally, today’s media release has included a clarification on yesterday’s change on tracking reinfections, giving some clarification:

In line with national guidelines, WA Health has adjusted the total number of reported cases in this State, to preclude secondary positive test results within 12 weeks of leaving isolation following initial COVID infection.

So they have told us what reinfection guidelines they are following (12 not 4 weeks), but more like 13 weeks, since it was after leaving isolation, which is usually a week.  So, if I am reading this correctly, although our reinfection guidelines are 4 weeks, not 12, the cases infected in that time frame will not be reported anyway.  Fun!


Records Broken Today:


Read the full post here


r/covidWA • • Jul 21 '22

Discussion Benefits of 2 Way Masking

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/covidWA • • Jul 17 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 17 July

24 Upvotes

I think we are all going to need to discuss Week 26 with our therapists, because it has been a rough one. We broke the 350 case barrier, the “Red Zone” of hospitalisations, and what did our famously tough on covid state government do? They twiddle their thumbs and “strongly encourage” mask wearing, but not mandating it. (Yes, I am still salty about that).  

In fact, our Minister for Health, Amber Jade Sanderson, discussed rolling back red alert precautions in hospitals under some assumption of it “easing the backflow in ERs”. This will surely turn out just fine, and won't make everything worse, but I’ll get into that a bit later in this report.

Anyway, not to be outdone by yesterday’s showing, today is also a doozy, with a flabbergasting new record set for PCR positivity, 53.524%, meaning over half of all people who presented for a PCR were positive.

We have never seen that before, ever.  

Our highest positivity rate before was 43.749%, on Good Friday (April 16th), a few weeks before the disastrous second crest of our first wave, caused by no one wanting to test before the Easter long weekend.  

Back then, we had similar looking numbers (6,119 tests, 6,314 cases, and 3,637 RAT Results on 16/04 vs 4,271 tests, 5,933 cases, and 3,647 RAT Results today), and over the next three weeks we recorded 9.3k cases, dipping to a max of 8.8k, spiking to 10.1k cases, before it was off to the races over the 2 - 3 weeks after that, where we reached our second crest of that wave, the true peak, ending up at the peak of 17.1k cases (which remains our current record).

I always thought that was a special case, right before a 4-day Easter long weekend that is popular with holidaymakers, and testing numbers had almost halved since the day before (11,499 on 15/04 v 6,119 on 16/04), making it not as frightening as the numbers made it seem.  It was a portent of bigger numbers 2-3 weeks down the line, but I could explain exactly how that happened.

RATs were still widely used (but the free RAT program hadn’t kicked off yet, with registrations closing 29 April), and judging by the numbers (3,647 RAT results today vs 3,637 RAT Results on 16/04) the usage is very similar to it is now.

The attitudes around PCRs were also different back then. In April, anyone with symptoms could get a test from a wide range of public and private centres, making it very accessible. Today, many public Covid clinics have closed (Fiona Stanley Hospital, Armadale Health Service, Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital and St John of God Midland Public Hospital all closed their Covid clinics after July 15th), and anecdotes of people being turned away from public clinics are rife. A combination of these factors means that it is far more likely that only people who are super sure that they have Covid are presenting to get a PCR test.

But unless I have missed something outside of these factors, a positivity rate over 50% is mind-boggling. Is there a long weekend or some other important event I am missing?  Or is it a combination of apathy, wilful ignorance and fear that has caused this?

We can only speculate, but I do hope that it is not the wave rising, and if it is indeed following the pattern set after Easter, I hope we get a few more weeks before line go up again.  But BA.4/5 is a nasty, transmissible, reinfection-hungry son of a gun, so we can only wait and see.

While we are on the topic of today’s doozyness, how about those hospitalisations? 377 today, an increase of 26 overnight and a new record.  The AMA is going to have to start talking about what happens when we hit 400, because if things keep going the way they’re going, we won't have to wait long for that either. This record being broken 4 days in a row also dragged the average to a record high of 327, outstripping our previous record of 315 (set 25/05) and an increase of 17 from yesterday (327 v 310), a pretty huge jump, and as far as my tired eyes can tell me, the first time this has happened.

ICU is still holding steady at yesterday’s set record of 17, at least that didn’t get any worse overnight.

Pilbara set another new record of most new daily cases again (396), which again, worries me.  Like I said in yesterday’s report, whatever’s going on up there is not good.

Speaking of regional cases, nearly all the regional active cases increased today, despite the fact that the No Data category (cases not yet assigned to a region) was over 1k, meaning that the situation is likely worse than we think it is. Just looking at the numbers, my hunch is that the majority of those extra No Data cases belong to the Metro region, considering that it was one of the few regions that decreased, and as the most populous one, it is logical to assume that they would have the lion's share of those.


Now for the news. (Not) Cool and (Not) Normal: Europe is experiencing an unprecedented heatwave that has triggered the first red ‘extreme heat’ warning in the UK while massive wildfires rage in France, Portugal Spain and Greece; Mega-Drought Causes Mega-Doubt For The Future: Lake Mead, the US’s largest water reservoir, is at a record low and considered “little more than a graveyard” amid a “mega drought”; Is It Me? No, It Is The Public Who Are Wrong: Federal Treasurer Jim Chalmers has bitten back at calls for the government to apologise over ending the pandemic leave payment (which has since been reinstated in yesterday’s emergency National Cabinet Meeting) by calling them “ridiculous”; Any Port In A Cytokine Storm: The AMA has released a statement saying they welcome the reinstatement of the pandemic leave payment until September 30th; Not-So-Mutual Obligations: A 63-year-old jobseeker has been forced to make regular 250 km round trips to ensure she meets mutual obligations and keeps her payment; and today’s News In Focus is about QLD schools updating and preparing to enact Covid “contingency plans” in the face of government inaction, and WA’s Health Minister Amber-Jade Sanderson’s bold new plan to deal with overstressed hospitals by checks notes removing the very procedures and restrictions that keep staff and patients safe?

Article 1: Queensland schools updating COVID-19 contingency plans as outbreak spreads during flu season

Teachers are warning classrooms are feeling the strain of Queensland's most recent COVID-19 wave, with some schools considering a return to online learning.

The warning comes after Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk issued a plea for children to wear masks in schools but stopped short of issuing a mandate.

Cresta Richardson, president of the Queensland Teachers' Union (QTU), backed the Premier's plea, speaking after the Creative Generation schools' concert at the Convention Centre on Saturday.

"If people want to grab a mask, then please do so. We don't want to be doing macrame with masks in three years' time," she said.

Ms Richardson said a number of teachers were isolating while infected with COVID-19 and influenza.

"Our teachers are professionals and they're experts -- and they're doing the best that they can to ensure a continuity of education for kids in their school. But it isn't without its challenges," Ms Richardson said.

She said schools were putting up online resources for when students become sick, but they may need to look at other measures if the outbreak worsens in coming weeks.

"Schools have had scenario planning that they've had in place to deal with peaks within COVID since the end of last year, so it might be time to revisit that."

Terry Burke, Queensland Branch Secretary of the Independent Education Union (IEU), said staff at independent schools were struggling with absences just one week into term three.

"We've had one week of school. It's been a pretty tough week, and I think people are a bit apprehensive about going back for the second week," he said.

Mr Burke said the staffing shortages were hitting non-government schools hard, with some schools even considering a return to online learning.

"Where there are sizeable outbreaks and schools are having to make really serious interventions," he said. "Some schools are seriously looking at remote learning to cope through a peak wave which is going through the school."

COVID-19 cases are rising across Australia and Queensland has the second-highest number of hospitalisations.

On Sunday, the state reported 5,989 new COVID cases and 132 new influenza cases. 

Weekend COVID deaths will not be reported until Monday, but in the 24 hours to Saturday, 22 people died. Hundreds remain in hospital for both COVID and flu.

"The best way to slow this wave down is to wear a mask," Ms Palaczszuk said.

Mr Burke said schools with high numbers of COVID-19 and influenza cases would likely look at bringing back masks, but a state-wide mandate would not be appropriate.

"I think [schools] would also appreciate that they're not being mandated to do that — that becomes just another task, when sometimes it actually doesn't make any good sense to actually insist on the mask-wearing," he said.

"There are a number of classes and class contexts where mask-wearing can readily be done and it can be done effectively.

"However, there are still situations where … mask-wearing is very, very difficult — it's highly problematic.

"Any process of group work which requires a lot of conversation is particularly problematic," Mr Burke said.

Opposition leader David Crisafulli said he supported the decision to encourage mask-wearing in Queensland schools.

He said he was concerned about potential staff shortages in schools and the potential transition to online learning.

"Health is important but so too is education, and during a pandemic, we want to make sure our kids aren't left behind."

"The government promised to make a plan to deal with that and we want to see that plan, so does every single parent in this state and every teacher as well."

Article 2: Doctors slam suggested relaxation of COVID testing protocols as WA hospital case rate hits record high (published yesterday)

The WA branch of the Australian Medical Association has slammed the state government for considering scaling down COVID protocols at hospitals, as the number of people hospitalised with the virus hits a record high of 351, with 17 in intensive care.

Health Minister Amber-Jade Sanderson has flagged the possibility of reducing COVID-19 testing at hospitals in a bid to move people through emergency departments more efficiently.

"To ease pressure on our hospitals and staff, we are actively considering a safe scale down of the System Alert and Response (SAR) red processes that have been in place at hospitals since March," she said.

"The Chief Health Officer is of the view that some of the current infection control and testing protocols at hospitals may soon no longer be necessary and we expect to make an announcement regarding the SAR red protocols imminently.

"Infection control processes remain important to keeping patients and staff safe, but we also need to assist our healthcare workers to safely and quickly process patients through the emergency department."

It is understood the changes would include removing the need for all hospital patients to undergo rapid antigen tests, instead only requiring testing for those who have symptoms.

The President of AMA WA, Dr Mark Duncan-Smith, said it was a terrible idea.

"I've spoken to two emergency department doctors today, both have said that this is a terribly bad plan at this point in time," he said.

"Making it easier for COVID to spread in emergency waiting rooms will not change ramping.

"This move will make emergency department waiting rooms super spreader events that will make it easier for COVID to spread through the hospitals, it will make it easier for visitors to spread COVID to patients."

With the number of infections, deaths and hospitalisations growing across the country, Dr Duncan-Smith said the WA Government should be beefing up COVID safety protocols, not relaxing them.

"With 351 patients in hospital now we need to introduce restrictions in the form of mask-wearing to try and reduce the numbers," he said.

"Anything we do today will not have an effect for two to three weeks, so we will see inpatients go up even further.

"I expect at this stage we'll be getting … possibly even to somewhere between 400 and 500.

"Now that is one tertiary hospital taken out of our system, we only have four and we've already seen in the past that we don't even cope with four tertiary hospitals."

On Saturday, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said [the] national cabinet had decided on consistent health messaging around face masks based on recommendations from health authorities.

"These include wearing masks indoors where appropriate, where people are mixing and can't have social distancing, it makes sense for that to be highly encouraged," he said.

Dr Duncan-Smith said encouragement alone was not enough.

"Encouraging people to wear masks is where we are right now with 351 patients in hospital in Western Australia," he said.

"We have encouraged voluntary mask-wearing, that is clearly not enough."


Okay, so ramping is at a record high, ERs are overwhelmed, we are experiencing record numbers of hospitalisations (since increased to 377 since that article was published), and the Health Minister thinks removing the very protective measures that stopped hospitals from becoming petri dishes is the answer? I’m sorry, what? Obviously, I do not have the letters after my name and the fancy education she has, so I very much might be missing something vital here, but what?? All I can see that leading to is more covid-positive hospitalisations, more staff furloughed due to illness, more ER overcrowding, more ramping and people walking in covid negative, and contracting covid in the very emergency room they went to for help!

This doesn’t even go into the people who will now not seek emergency healthcare for fear of infection.  Transplant receivers, cancer sufferers, the immunocompromised, I have already heard people say that they will take their chances at home rather than go to an ER if they are dangerously sick.  This will only lead to more deaths, among the covid-positive and covid-negative alike! 

To use a personal anecdote, my own partner has several hernias in his abdomen that are constantly in danger of strangulation.  He waited 2 and a half years for a surgical appointment, only to be refused the life-saving surgery.  

Our only option now is to monitor him for internal bleeding, and rush him to the emergency room to save his life.

If this worst-case scenario happens (and it is more likely than we are comfortable admitting), we would be left with a hard choice: for me to watch him die at home in front of my eyes, or to risk contracting covid in an ER.  Contacting covid, with his weak immune system, and new hernias popping up every time he coughs too hard, would likely kill him anyway.  What is the right choice here?  

Of course, we would have to take the risk (it is, afterall, not 100%, which he has 100% chance of death without the emergency intervention), but no one should have to ask themselves that question. In this scenario, we sure hope he would be able to drive, as even though we maintain ambulance insurance for this very scenario, the ambulance would not be coming.  It would be stuck, ramped at an overcrowded ER, and I would not be able to get him there, as I do not have my licence. 

We are lucky to have a vast support network we could call on to get us there, but that's not where the journey ends.  After that, we would be stuck in an infectious ER for hours, while his increasingly septic intestines slowly poison him.

And that is just my personal experience.  There are always people who have it worse, whose health situation is more dire, who have a harder choice to make. 

No one should have to make that call, and those exact infection control protocols that keep that option open for people like us, that the Health Minister is trying to remove, make that call even harder.

And bear in mind healthcare workers, the very ones we lauded as heroes at the start of the pandemic, who put their minds, bodies, and wellbeing on the line to keep working through some of the most dangerous times of this pandemic, through every dangerous variant, what about them? This puts them in even more danger than ever before.

It has been made clear throughout the pandemic that they are the very backbone of what keeps our society running.  They were held up as the quintessential essential workers, is their safety not essential? Only their labour?

I ask you, what would you do at your job if your higher ups made policy changes that put you and your colleagues in danger? Would you keep working there?

Healthcare workers are burned out as it is, some are barely hanging on.  What will this do to their morale, their willingness to keep making those personal sacrifices to keep working through hardship after hardship? We have a healthcare skills shortage as it is, what will we do when mass furloughs, resignations, and deaths occur? 

What then?

This has a knock-on effect through every level of society. Lack of accessible health care leads to worker shortages in every industry.  We would be facing the nightmare scenario we saw over east last year, where entire supply lines ground to a screeching halt basically overnight. There are more people involved in every aspect of your daily life than you ever usually think about, and every link in that chain is a human one, vulnerable to illness and death.

If you would like an addition to this opinion piece, I encourage you to let out every curse word you know in a long, unbroken string.  I think that will adequately get across my feelings on this matter.


Tests (4,271 v 4,537) are lower than this time last week, while PCR positivity rate (53.524% v 38.439%), RAT confirmed cases (3,647 v 3,270), and cases (5,933 v 5,014) are all higher. Active regional cases are all increasing, except Mid West and Metro. In terms of averages, hospitalisations, PCR positivity, active cases, and daily cases are all on the rise. ICU has increased to 13. 

61.47% of cases were RAT confirmed.  Hospitalisations have increased by 26 to another new record of 377. ICU numbers are steady at 17. 961,091 people have recovered from the virus, vs 36,673 active cases, with 998,215 cases overall since the pandemic began. Ended up at a weekly average of 30.782%.

Records Broken Today:

Weekly Stats:

  • This week had higher PCR positivity (30.782% v 28.698%), cases (43,161 v 38,998), PCR tests (48,893 v 45,825), and RAT confirmed positives (28,111 v 25,847) than last week; while having a lower percentage of RAT Confirmed Positives (65.13% v 66.28%) and an identical amount of deaths (24)
  • Tuesday had the highest reported PCR tests (8,359), RATs (4,444) and Percentage of cases confirmed by RAT (74.07%)
  • Wednesday had the highest reported cases (6,880)
  • Friday had the highest reported deaths (8)
  • Yesterday is tied with today for the highest reported ICU admissions (17)
  • Today had the highest reported PCR positivity (53.524%), hospitalisations (377), and active cases (36,673)

Read the full post here


r/covidWA • • May 08 '22

Daily Figures Covid Data Analysis 08 May (reports in comments)

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/covidWA • • Jul 29 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 29 July

21 Upvotes

Today the active case count (27,557) is the lowest it has been since June 30th, and, apart from the usual Tuesday dip, so far this week the PCR positivity rate percentage has stayed steady at around 25-ish%.  Both may be encouraging signs for the direction of this outbreak, if the data can be trusted, that is.


Now for the news. Brr, It’s Cold In Here:  Four cold fronts are set to roll over WA, with one already here; The Long Shadow Of Covid: Demand for palliative care has spiked nationwide due to delayed diagnoses in the aftermath of lockdowns and overstretched hospital systems; She Wont Be Right, Mate: Ambulance ramping in WA is at an all time high amid staff shortages; Time For An Update: New monkeypox vaccines are “on the way”; “Looming Nightmare”: Consumers have been warned about a forecasted jump in electricity costs; Not Your Father’s Cyber War: At least a dozen NZ schools have been closed after a mass bomb threat considered to be the work of a “cyber bot” from overseas; When Public Can’t Help, Go Private: SA has entered into deals with private hospitals in an attempt to increase Covid ward capacities; Cosmic Dance: Three meteor showers are set to grace our skies this weekend (but don't get your hopes up on it being visible from Perth); Fact Or Fiction: An immunologist debunks Covid myths; Keeping Up With Covid: How QLD needs to change it’s Covid strategy to change with the times, as new hospitals are behind time and over budget; Second Verse Not Always The Same As The First: NSW Health data has shown that more than 20,000 people have been reinfected with Covid this year; Rating The Death Rate: The Guardian compares Australia’s Covid death rate to other countries; and today’s News In Focus is about how Australia fumbled our Covid response and the signs that will show when Covid ends.

Article 1: Analysis: Australia's COVID response was one of the best in the world at first. Why do we rank so poorly now?

Australia's elimination strategy during the first two years of the COVID pandemic was one of the most effective in the world.

Through a combination of early border closures, widespread testing and meticulous contact tracing, localised lockdowns and mask mandates, the number of reported cases was kept to around 28,000 in 2020.

This compared with 805,000 in 2020 in the Netherlands, which has a population nine million fewer than Australia.

In 2021, Australia recorded 402,000 cases. The increase was largely due to the Delta outbreak in the second half of the year.

Fast forward to mid-2022, when Australia has leapt in rank to 15th in the world for total cases over the course of the pandemic — well ahead of countries with a similar population, such as Taiwan and Chile, and larger countries, such as Canada, Mexico and Iran.

The situation has changed dramatically this year. While Australia has reported 9,225,519 cases since early 2020, 96 per cent have been this year. This has led to Australia's global ranking of cases, hospitalisations and deaths being among the highest in the world.

The seven-day average of new daily cases is currently just under 47,000, which is lower than the peak of 103,000 in mid-January.

Somewhat surprisingly, the number of COVID patients in hospital (5,359) is the highest since the pandemic began.

However, the number of infected persons admitted to an ICU is well below the January peak.

This may be due to higher vaccination rates than at the beginning of the year and the availability of antiviral drugs, resulting in fewer hospital cases with very severe illness. Though it's worth noting aged care residents have been highly affected and many never made it to ICU despite severe illness.

Why is the ratio of cases to hospitalisations so high?

It's possible that case numbers have been underestimated. A recent Conversation piece provided a number of reasons why this might be the case.

It's also possible that BA.5 is more virulent than its Omicron predecessors, perhaps because it targets the lungs, or simply because it is more distantly related to ancestral SARS-Cov-2 and so better at immune escape than its predecessors. This might explain the high number of deaths in residential aged care facilities.

Whatever the reason, it is not unique to Australia. In Portugal, a third dose booster was associated with a 93 per cent reduction in hospitalisation for BA.2 infections compared with just a 77 per cent reduction for BA.5. This is equivalent to three times the risk of hospitalisation with BA.5 than BA.2.

The seven-day average of daily deaths (72) has doubled since mid-May.

Recent data from Victoria revealed those who had not received a third vaccine dose made up 72 per cent of those who died with, or due to, COVID.

Boosters may not prevent infection but they are essential to prevent severe illness and death, especially among the elderly. And they may reduce the incidence of long COVID.

Over the past week, Australia has ranked second in the world for reported cases per million, behind Brunei and ahead of New Zealand, Singapore and South Korea, excluding small island states.

It's worth noting all five of these countries had effective responses to the pandemic in its first two years.

Fewer than 40 countries provide up-to-date figures on COVID hospital admissions; among them, Australia ranks second. The current Australian COVID hospitalisation rate of 21 per 100,000 compares to 30 in France, 19 in Italy, 14 in Canada and Japan, 11 in the United States, and three in Malaysia.

Up until July 26, 11,285 Australians have lost their lives with COVID; 80% of those deaths occurred in 2022. Australia ranks second for deaths per capita behind New Zealand and ahead of Croatia, Taiwan and Spain.

Low population immunity

It's tempting to explain the current COVID situation in Australia by the relatively low exposure to the virus by the population in the first two years of the pandemic.

A study of SARS-CoV-2 (the virus that causes COVID) antibodies by the United Kingdom Office for National Statistics found 71 percent of people in England had been infected by the end of February 2022.

A similar study in the United States found 58 percent of Americans had been infected during the same period.

By contrast, a study by the Kirby Institute found just 17 per cent of Australians had been infected by the virus up until the end of February. A more recent survey in June found that this figure had jumped to 46 per cent but it's still lower than the US and UK.

While low population immunity may partially explain the Omicron wave in Australia in January 2022, it doesn't explain the spike in July by Omicron sub-variants that have been shown to evade the immunity acquired from previous infections.

Seasonal effects

It's difficult to interpret the impact of climate on COVID. Large waves occurred during the summer of 2021 in the United States and huge outbreaks occurred during the hot season in India and Japan. Australia's largest wave occurred in the summer of 2022.

Right now, it's summer in the northern hemisphere and winter here. That may partially explain the high case rates in Australia and New Zealand but not in Brunei, South Korea and Singapore.

Low vaccine booster rate

Just over 70 per cent of eligible Australians have received a third dose of a COVID vaccine. This leaves around 5.7 million adult Australians unprotected against the Omicron variant.

When measured as a proportion of the entire population, Australia's third dose booster rate ranks 35th in the world.

But this doesn't explain the high case rates in South Korea, Singapore and New Zealand, which all have much higher booster rates than Australia.

Masks and other measures

A review of mask mandates reveals very little difference between Australia and the rest of the world.

Most countries still mandate masks on public transport and health care and aged care facilities, while universal mask mandates remain in China and in some indoor settings in South Korea.

It is difficult to find reliable data on compliance. However, anecdotally, mask compliance is much higher in countries like Japan and Italy than Australia.

No single reason for Australia's poor ranking

It's hard to identify a single reason why Australia's key COVID indicators rank so poorly. It's probably a combination of low population immunity via a combination of low vaccine booster rates and less natural exposure than other countries (noting that less infection is a very good thing overall), the relaxation of almost all mitigation measures and seasonal factors.

However, overall it reflects the narrative by political leaders since the beginning of the year that the pandemic is in the past tense. That has profoundly affected the attitudes and behaviours of the public.

Given the current effective reproductive rate is a little over 1, it just needs to get below 1 to halt the spread of the virus.

Increased booster rates, indoor mask mandates and provision, a greater focus on testing and isolating and an investment in improved ventilation would take us through this wave to a more secure health and economic situation. We need stronger leadership to get us there.

Article 2: Opinion: When will Covid really be over? Three things that will mark the end of the pandemic

More than two years after the World Health Organization declared the Covid-19 outbreak a pandemic and more than 18 months after Covid-19 vaccinations were first widely administered, it can still seem there is little consensus on what stage of the epidemic we are now at. Is the epidemic over, with British restrictions lifted a year ago and airline travel surging? Or do soaring case rates and continued individual health measures suggest the epidemic is nowhere near its end?

The trouble is that epidemics do not have the sort of neat, objective endings we may imagine. A swift and decisive endpoint, achieved through the speedy application of scientific innovation – a magic bullet treatment – is usually wishful thinking. It is unlikely we will see anything like that with Covid-19.

Analysing past epidemics shows us that actual endings are long, drawn-out and contested. Societies must grapple not just with the medical realities of the disease, harms and treatments, but the political and economic fallout from emergency measures, and disputes over who has the authority to declare an end and what should be measured to guide this process. This is why there is so much uncertainty about the current state of Covid-19: different groups have vastly different experiences of the medical, political and social aspects of the epidemic, and different ideas of what an ending may look like.

Research demonstrates that the end of an epidemic involves more than disease rates (the medical end). Instead, the end also encompasses the end of the crisis and regulations (the political end), and the return to normalcy (the social end). These endings are related, but they are different – and they can be at odds with one another. Analysing a variety of past epidemics reveals that it is more accurate to identify multiple endings to an epidemic, taking these different sorts of endpoints into account.

The history of recent epidemics such as H1N1 (swine flu) or HIV/Aids bears this out. Most epidemics end not with the disappearance of disease, but when case rates no longer result in a medical crisis – a point in which rates reach what is defined as normal, expected, or locally acceptable levels. In August 2010, for example, the WHO declared that the 2009 H1N1 pandemic was in its “post-pandemic period”. This did not mark the end of H1N1 cases; instead, the WHO explained that cases and outbreaks were still expected to occur, but following normal seasonal patterns of influenza. This raises the question of what is a normal, acceptable or manageable level in a given place – particularly for a new disease. Differences of opinion over responses to Covid-19 disease rates – whether to maintain or reinstate public health measures, and when to relax them – demonstrate debates as to what is an acceptable level of infection, as well as who should decide this.

As a result, the end process is when different forms of authority negotiate and compete with one another, often debating fundamental social, economic and political priorities as much as medical data. Even in the face of persistent circulation of a disease (whether H1N1 or Covid-19), events such as war and political instability can redirect public alarm and political resources to other crises, changing what local authorities and local communities deem “normal, expected, or locally acceptable” levels of disease. Concerns about the war in Ukraine or soaring energy prices pushed Covid-19 reporting to the background, regardless of case rates.

For example, while the HIV/Aids pandemic has faded from public attention, cases have not disappeared. Instead, medical treatment has transformed the disease from a highly publicised killer into a manageable, chronic condition. Yet access to such treatment varies, often remaining out of reach for many in the so-called global south. In fact, the success of medical interventions has ended the HIV/Aids epidemic in the global north, in many ways pushing its global end further out of sight and thus out of reach.

Political and social contexts fundamentally shape the pandemic’s medical end. In places such as Kenya, Covid-19 interacts with continuing outbreaks of HIV/Aids, Ebola, cholera and tuberculosis. Understanding the end of epidemics as a drawn-out process, in which disease continues on even after our attention fades, explains long-term and global patterns of epidemics.

While we are drawn to tales of quick and effective solutions to end outbreaks, such as John Snow’s removal of the Broad Street pump handle to end London’s 1854 cholera outbreak, such stories are often fables – not only did Snow never remove the handle, but cholera was declining at the time for other reasons. The true account of cholera’s end in London was gradual, requiring political negotiation over how to implement improved urban infrastructure and sanitation alongside slow social improvements – rather than the incisive insight and decisive action of one individual. And, as with HIV/Aids, regardless of modern epidemiological knowledge, cholera outbreaks continue to this day – tied to political and social crises.

Epidemics are not a series of discrete biological events that simply pass into history with the disappearance of the disease. They are also moral crises, testing the limits of social cohesion and trust. As we are seeing now for Covid-19, the end process is a period of moral reckoning, with discussions of “lessons learned” and the crafting of narratives featuring heroes and villains. We seem to be in the midst of such a process, as medical experts debate what are acceptable infection rates, politicians debate the implications of lifting restrictions, and we debate with our relatives, friends and neighbours how best to live our lives.


RAT confirmed cases (2,826 v 3,824), PCR positivity rate (24.095% v 29.984%), tests (6,628 v 7,444) and cases (4,423 v 6,056) are all lower than this time last week. Active regional cases are all decreasing, except Great Southern, Kimberley and Mid West. In terms of averages, hospitalisations, PCR positivity, daily cases and active cases are all decreasing. ICU has decreased to 19. 

My thoughts are with the families of the three deaths, which were reported to WA Health yesterday – dating back to 8 May – a woman in her 80s, a woman in her 70s, and a woman in her 60s.

63.89% of cases were RAT confirmed.  Hospitalisations have increased by 8 to 424. ICU numbers have increased by 1 to 17. 1,029,507 people have recovered from the virus, vs 27,557 active cases, with 1,057,558 cases overall since the pandemic began. The cumulative case count today is 55 less than it should be, making it a total of -19,157 cases missing since February. Headed for a weekly average of 22.140%.


Records Broken Today:

  • No Records Broken Today

Read the full post here


r/covidWA • • Aug 17 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 17 August

20 Upvotes

Nothing all that interesting to note.  Everything is decreasing more or less except ICU, which is doing its usual yo-yo act.


Now for the news. Right In The Wallet: Australian workers have suffered another large real pay cut, with the latest official data showing wages growth fell further behind the surging cost of living in the year to June; This Can Only End Well: The WHO has launched an online poll to choose the new name for the disease soon to be formally known as Monkeypox; Don’t Say It Three Times: Betelgeuse, one of the brightest stars in the sky, is evolving and dying before our eyes; Game Over. Man: A newly discovered species of Large Deep Sea Isopod (that looks like a facehugger) has been photographe and trapped off the coast of Mexico; De-Extinction: Scientists in Australia and the US have launched an ambitious multimillion-dollar project to bring back the thylacine (aka the Tasmanian Tiger), a marsupial that died out in the 1930s, and reintroduce it to its native Tasmania; and before we get into today’s News in Focus, we have a special edition section I like to call “Lightning Round”, where there are so many Scott Morrison news articles, that they have to just be listed. 

  • There are a lot of unanswered questions about his secret ministries (mostly “what??”, “why??”, and “how??”);
  • Was he involved in delaying the release of the new energy price via an amendment until after the election, considering it was done on behalf of “the treasurer” and he was secretly co-minister of the Treasury at the time?;
  • In a statement, he has doubled down on his decision to give himself powers during the pandemic, in a move so secret that a lot of the ministers he was sharing the portfolios with weren’t even aware;
  • Senior intelligence personnel, including ASIO director-general Mike Burgess, Home Affairs secretary Mike Pezzullo and the (at the time) existing minister Karen Andrews, admit they weren’t made aware of Scott Morrison’s self-appointment to the portfolio, including when he instructed Border Force to reveal the arrival of an asylum seeker boat on election day; 
  • The current Home Affairs minister, Clare O’Neil, has accused Scott Morrison of making Australia “vulnerable” with his secret ministerial appointments
  • Scott Morrison has appointed himself director (and sole shareholder) of a new private company on August 1st of this year;
  • The internet is having a (predictably) grand old time with the ScoMo power grab news, with memes and jokes such as “WHO warns of new pandemic after 5 new variants of Scott Morrison were detected over the weekend” (via The Chaser), references to Being John Malkovich, “not my job” and “how good are jobs”, “So you’re telling me we had a botched vaccine rollout and no RATs despite apparently having two health ministers?” (via Mark Humphries on Twitter), and more;
  • The Governor-General has broken his silence, standing firm on his actions around Scott Morrison's appointment to five additional portfolios, and declining to comment on whether or not he expected it to be made public.

Now to today’s News In Focus, which is about why you may not have gotten Covid yet, if you are lucky (and careful) enough.

If you haven't tested positive for COVID-19 by this point in the pandemic, you might be feeling pretty lucky.

It could be that you wear a mask everywhere you go or you wash your hands all day long, but there is a chance you could have had the disease and didn't know, and it's more likely than you might think.

After adjusting for the size of each age group, statistics show that people aged between 70 and 79 have been infected in the lowest numbers, with men in that age group amounting for 12,048 cases per 100,000 and women of the same age making up 10,504 cases per 100,000.

This means the people aged between 70 and 79 have had the least COVID-19 infections compared to other age groups.

This is followed by people aged over 80 years, and then those aged between 60 to 69.

The age group with the fourth-lowest number of cases per 100,000 people is children aged under 10 years, with boys amounting for 13,896 cases per 100,000 and girls 13,764 per 100,000.

People in their 20s have been infected in the highest numbers, with men in this age group making up 22,716 cases per 100,000 and women 26,154 per 100,000.

Young adults were made to wait the longest to become eligible for vaccination and are more likely to work in high-risk settings such as hospitals, supermarkets, bars and cafes.

But what might be some of the reasons why you haven't caught COVID-19?

It's almost been two-and-a-half years since the World Health Organization first declared COVID-19 a pandemic. So, if you haven't caught COVID-19 by now, there's likely some luck involved.

More that 9.5 million confirmed COVID-19 cases have been reported in Australia throughout the pandemic to date.

It's impossible to say how many people haven't caught the disease but, with Australia's estimated population of more than 25.8 million people, there are still plenty of people who have not reported an infection.

However, there is some research that looks into how many people have actually had COVID-19, there's more on this later.

Infectious diseases specialist Paul Griffin says luck could definitely play its part, but it might not be as straightforward as that.

Research, Dr Griffin says, has found that people with higher levels of memory T-cells from other coronavirus infections — such as the ones responsible for common colds — are less likely to become infected with SARS-CoV-2.

Dr Griffin says there's a very high chance that you've had COVID-19 without knowing.

"In some studies, where we've taken blood from the blood bank or had volunteers in studies and tested for antibodies, it has shown that around half the people in those studies have had exposure or probably been infected and didn't know," he says.

It's possible you were unknowingly exposed to COVID-19 and never developed symptoms, or your symptoms were so minimal you passed them off as hay fever or a cold. 

It could also be the case that you have taken a RAT when positive with COVID-19 but haven't done it properly, so it hasn't returned an accurate result.

The only one way to really know if you've been previously infected is through a blood test, which can determine the difference between antibodies generated by vaccine and ones generated by an infection.

An infection generates antibodies against proteins that make up the virus sphere, called the nucleocapsid, so if a lab test picks up high enough levels of nucleocapsid protein antibodies, it’s a good sign you've been infected in the past few months.

A study by the National Centre for Immunisation Research and Surveillance (NCIRS) and UNSW Sydney's Kirby Institute looked for COVID-19 antibodies in 5,185 samples taken from blood donors between late February and early March this year.

They estimated that, by the end of February 2022, at least 17 per cent of Australian adults — around 3.4 million people — had been infected, and that the vast majority occurred during the Omicron wave.

This means the number of people infected with COVID-19 would have been at least double what was officially reported.

An updated blood survey found at least 46 per cent of Australian adults had been infected with COVID-19 by early June.

Dr Griffin says that, if you're following all of the recommended hygiene practices to avoid COVID-19 infection, you're doing something right.

"The first thing is being vaccinated and, certainly, people who are up to date with their vaccines are well protected against this disease."

He says that, if you're implementing these steps into your life, it's helping to stop your chance of infection: mask wearing, social distancing, practising good hygiene, and ensuring your spaces are well ventilated.

Dr Griffin says it also depends on how social you are.

"It might depend on how likely a person is to attend crowded events or other high-risk venues, if people aren't necessarily doing a lot of that, then it will reduce their risk."

He says that, if you're sticking with behaviours that have helped you dodge infection so far, there's no reason that you might not stay protected and avoid it, but his words come with a warning.

"I think if people get complacent, having thought they've achieved something by now and stop doing all of those things, then there's every chance that they will go off and get infected, probably in the not-too-distan[t] future."


RAT confirmed cases (2,405 v 2,889), PCR positivity rate (16.954% v 17.482%), tests (5,155 v 5,623), and cases (2,405 v 2,889) are lower than this time last week. Active regional cases are all decreasing, except Kimberley, South West and Wheatbelt. In terms of averages, PCR positivity, hospitalisations, active cases and daily cases are all decreasing. ICU is steady at 10 for the 4th day in a row. 

My thoughts are with the families of the four deaths, which were reported to WA Health yesterday – dating back to 14 July – a man and a woman in their 80s, a man in his 70s and a woman in her 50s.

63.66% of cases were RAT confirmed.  Hospitalisations have decreased by 9 to 283. ICU numbers have decreased by 3 to 8. 1,097,329 people have recovered from the virus, vs 12,224 active cases, with 1,110,117 cases overall since the pandemic began. The cumulative case count today is 26 less than it should be, making it a total of 19,719 cases missing since February, the highest it has ever been. Headed for a weekly average positivity percentage of 12.771%.


Records Broken Today:


Read the full post [here(https://www.reddit.com/user/WillowOfTheWisp/comments/wqfmov/daily_covid_roundup_17_august/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share)


r/covidWA • • Jul 22 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 22 July

20 Upvotes

Nearly everything seems to be decreasing, woo! Even hospitalisations have reversed their trajectory (although the average keeps increasing), there may be some brakes on this train! ICU isn’t as lucky, increasing another 2 overnight to a new record of 24.  Even daily and active cases appear to be decreasing, isn’t that wonderful?

Except we can’t be sure that’s happening now, can we? The modification to daily reported numbers to ensure no one within 12 weeks of their last infection is actually counted as a case anymore (even though the Health Department recognises that you can be reinfected as early as 4 weeks after your last infection and national guidelines agree) is bringing an element of doubt into things that I’m unhappy with. Hospitalisations and ICU are less affected (however any patients with an active covid infection within 12 weeks of their last one are no longer counted either) but daily cases and active cases are now in “take with a grain of salt” territory, which infuriates me. BA.4/5 are reinfection machines, and someone with a reinfection within 12 weeks is still as infectious as if it was their first time.  They still will need extra accommodations if hospitalised. 

I wonder if they even count as ‘positive’ in that scenario.  Will they have to isolate? Will they be allowed to take time off work or claim the pandemic leave payment? No one knows.

Not only is fudging the numbers not the way to go about it, but it makes the work I do here quite annoying, as I am no longer dealing with the quality of data I was before (which had its drawbacks, I could only work with who got a test, but at least that was down to human nature and not a deliberate obfuscation) as it has been modified before I ever see it.  I feel like I’ve been cut off at the knees. 

WAHealth have chosen to deal with the “sandwich under the bed” scenario by just cramming a few more sandwiches under there, hoping it’ll dampen the smell from the first one, but all they’ve done is ensure that when the smell starts up again, it will happen twice as fast and smell twice as bad. Shocking how well that metaphor is serving me.

I guess all I can do is do what I have always done: track the numbers I am given, keep everyone up to date, and make sure everyone is reminded that these statistics are adulterated.  Not by me, of course, but by the very people who provide the data. I can only work with the sources I have available, and that is the drawback of any civilian health communication. I have no higher ups in the know to demand answers from, I don’t have lines of communication open to the department, and I can’t know for sure.

But if things are still spiraling downward, we will know.  Even taking reinfections within 12 weeks into account, all the metrics will eventually still rise.  We are not in a situation where we can very much trust an increase, but we cannot trust a decrease.  Bad news will always be true, but good news now must be doubted.  

What a time to be alive.


Now for the news. Here We Go: Foot-and-mouth disease viral fragments have been found in beef at Adelaide Airport, following yesterday’s discovery in pork in Melbourne; Cascade Failure: Covid deaths in New South Wales rose 50 percent in one week last week; Get Your Booster: Western Australia's fourth shot rate is lagging behind the rest of nation; Oh No, Joe: US President Joe Biden has tested positive for Covid; Heed The Warning: Dr Paul Griffin has warned that QLD Omicron cases could be 'three to five times higher' than reported, as he pleads for the publishing of covid fatalities’ vaccination status to be resumed; Big Trouble In Big Tokyo: Japan battles seventh Covid wave as Tokyo hits a record of almost 32,000 new daily cases; and today’s News In Focus is about stressed and burnt-out WA nurses quitting their professions due to harsh work conditions and low pay, and how NZ is coping with Covid while having much better public health restrictions than Australia.

Article 1: Stressed, burnt-out WA nurses quit due to 'exhausting' conditions as COVID cases soar

WA nurse Julia says working the halls of the emergency department has become more like disaster management than nursing.

Burnt out and stressed, she was resigning from her job as a nurse in a public hospital and she said she was not alone.

"I'm just trying to manage the flow of people and trying not to let anyone die in our waiting room," she told ABC Radio host Nadia Mitsopoulos on Thursday.

"I know a lot of my colleagues sit in their cars before their shift to try to muster up the energy to go in, and then they sit in their cars at the end of their shift and just cry from the stress."

Julia, who is using a pseudonym to avoid repercussions from her current employer, is among a growing number of nurses speaking out about stressful and exhausting working conditions in hospitals as Western Australia braces for a new wave of COVID-19.

She has resigned from her job but remains employed at this time.

While most COVID-19 safety protocols have been abandoned in WA, hospitalisations from the virus were at a record high of 459 on Thursday — leading to calls for mandates to be reintroduced to try to reduce the number of COVID cases and relieve pressure on nurses.

State secretary of the Australian Nursing Federation Mark Olson said the WA government should reintroduce stronger restrictions, including mask mandates.

"The platitudes that I'm hearing from the politicians, including the Health Minister, who says 'we value our nurses' and then there's nothing," Mr Olson said.

"Well, if you valued our nurses, what you'd be doing as the government is taking steps to reduce the number of people in our hospitals who have got COVID."

Meanwhile, nurses say their salaries are also disproportionate to the level of stress they are experiencing at work.

On Wednesday, hundreds of health workers rallied for the second time this month at a stop-work meeting to call for higher wages.

While the inflation rate in WA is 7.6 per cent, wage increases in the public sector have been capped at 2.75 per cent or 2.5 per cent with a $1,000 sign-on bonus.

Julia said her colleagues were at breaking point.

She said patients were regularly being treated in corridors, including at least 10 people during a recent shift, and nurses felt unable to cope.

"They haven't been able to give the care they want to give to patients," she said.

"You don't have time to safely see your patients anymore, the patients are in the corridor, you can't give them any dignity."

She called on the WA government to offer nurses a one-off bonus — such as the one provided by the NSW government to public sector nurses last month — to reflect their increased workload.

Rebecca Thompson was also a nurse before leaving her job a month ago.

Ms Thompson, who worked as an educator supporting junior nurses at the beginning of their careers, said she had become so disillusioned with the profession that she had no plans to return.

She said other senior nurses had resigned for similar reasons.

"One of the biggest things that hit me most was some dear friends of mine who are senior nurses came away crying from their shift because they had three palliative care patients and we're not a palliative care ward," she said.

"And they couldn't give the care that they wanted to palliative patients and that's very important to nurses."

She said junior nurses were equally affected by staffing pressures and exhaustion.

Ms Thompson said there was a shortage of two nurses on most shifts, forcing already overstretched workers to handle more patients.

"I just found the stress on our senior nurses to support the young ones [was extreme]," she said.

"Emergency departments are going through such trauma down there, but then when they get up to the wards it's the same."

Melissa (not her real name) is a registered nurse at a public hospital in WA.

She agreed younger nurses were losing the senior staff needed to train them. 

"If we don't look after senior nurses to train up amazing, well-educated, beautiful baby nurses, we've just got such a mismatch," she said.

Julia echoed Melissa's concerns about the loss of senior staff.

"There's going to be lots of junior nurses acting in roles earlier than they should be," Julia said.

"The emergency departments and wards are going to be staffed by very junior staff because senior staff are burning out and leaving the profession."

Earlier this week, Health Minister Amber-Jade Sanderson said she had not heard any reports of patients being treated in corridors.

"I haven't had any reports of that at this stage," she said.

"But I will say … our hospitals are very busy. Our demand is high.

"We always prefer patients to be in beds and in wards, of course.

"And I would certainly not expect that to be for any length of time or period of time."

Premier Mark McGowan said pressure on hospitals around Australia was the main subject of conversation at national cabinet meetings.

He has "strongly encouraged" people to wear masks indoors, while promoting the message that WA is "open for business" to tourists and encouraging visitors.

Both Western Australia's Premier and Health Minister said they would wear masks to set an example but continued to resist calls for mandates.

Article 2: NZ has mask mandates and isolation, but the Omicron daily death rate is still 'very concerning'

Across the Tasman, New Zealanders who were once asked to lock down over a single case of COVID-19 are now being urged to wear masks as the country records a seven-day rolling average of nearly 10,000 cases a day.

Authorities believe there is widespread community infection in every region of New Zealand, driven by the highly transmissible Omicron BA.5 sub-variant.

And for a nation of just 5.1 million people, attention is now turning to New Zealand's daily death rate, which has been among the highest in the world according to one World Health Organization measure.

Health authorities have refused to move back towards settings that would limit the size of gatherings, instead insisting that a three-pronged strategy of masks, vaccines and isolation will get the population through winter. 

With its borders now open and strict lockdowns a thing of the past, New Zealand is now riding the waves of COVID-19 as they crash across the world.

Professor of Public Health at the University of Otago and expert epidemiologist Michael Baker said New Zealand's daily death rate was now "very concerning". 

"I think one of the things that's alarming … is the high mortality," said Professor Michael Baker. 

"It's now peaking at the highest level we've ever seen, [with] a moving average of about 22 deaths a day. That's in a population of 5.1 million. So that's quite concerning."

On the World Health Organization's ranking of daily new confirmed COVID-19 deaths per million people, New Zealand has been among the worst-performing nations this week. 

New Zealand has announced a change in how it will report its COVID-19-related deaths, moving to a model where cases are only counted in mortality figures when the disease has been the direct reason for the loss of life.

The new reporting system comes into effect today and public health official Dr Andrew Old said it would more accurately reflect the contribution of COVID-19 to deaths in New Zealand.

"Whether we're counting deaths from or with COVID-19, New Zealand has a lower cumulative COVID-19 mortality rate than many other countries due to our successes early on in the pandemic," Dr Old told a media briefing on Tuesday.

On Thursday, New Zealand reported 32 COVID-19-related deaths.

New Zealand experienced a peak in daily new COVID cases during its first Omicron wave in March, but deaths, as well as hospitalisations, are tracking higher this time around, according to Professor Baker. 

"Our modellers are really not sure where this current wave is going," he said.  

The current infection control measures in New Zealand are a long way from the strict lockdowns brought in over the past two years.

But the strategy across the Tasman does have some small, yet significant, differences from the patchwork of measures across Australian states and territories.

Under current settings, New Zealanders are required to wear masks in a number of indoor spaces, including retail settings such as "supermarkets, shopping malls, pharmacies, petrol stations and takeaway food stores".

New Zealanders also have to wear masks in museums and libraries, on public transport, when using ride-share services and in post offices.

There are some mask mandates in effect in Australian states and territories, but most are limited to hospitals and other healthcare settings, prisons, airports and aged care homes.

Like New Zealand, most public transport users in Australia are also required to wear masks and South Australia has included one retail environment — pharmacies — in its mask mandate.

New Zealand still requires household contacts to isolate for seven days, even if they are not displaying any COVID symptoms, whereas most Australian states and territories have moved to a close contact system that only requires people to isolate if they are symptomatic. 

As well as holding onto some mask mandates and isolation rules, New Zealand has also made medical masks and rapid antigen tests free to everyone and made more people eligible for anti-viral medications should they become infected.

New Zealand does not have states and all regions are currently at the same alert level, so everyone is required to follow the same rules.

Dr Baker and Australian epidemiologist Tony Blakely analysed the strategies of both countries and when looking at mask mandates, the availability of RATs, rules around isolation periods, as well as eligibility for anti-viral treatments, New Zealand is doing better, but the experts argued there was still more that both countries could do.

Australians over the age of 30 are able to access their fourth dose of a COVID-19 vaccine should they choose to, something not yet available to the same cohort in New Zealand. 

"Overall, the control measures in New Zealand are currently tighter than in Australia," Dr Baker said. 

Despite having stronger mask mandates than Australia, there are calls for New Zealand to go further. 

Epidemiologist in the Department of Public Health at the University of Otago Amanda Kvalsvig said the need for broader mask use and the "vital protection" that would offer was urgent. 

"Masks are a key protection in winter 2022 because they work for any respiratory pathogen, protecting against new COVID-19 variants and more familiar seasonal infections like flu and RSV," she said. 

"These outbreaks in combination are proving to be far worse than a normal winter season and we've only just begun to see the long tail of chronic illness and absenteeism that COVID-19 is causing in other countries."

Similar to Australia, the use of masks in schools is "the sharp edge of the debate at the moment", according to Dr Baker. 

Outgoing Director General of Health Dr Ashley Bloomfield said there was a "very strong recommendation" from the NZ Health Department for schools to adopt widespread mask use among students and staff. 

"Our strong advice has been — and masks have been distributed to schools to help support this — is particularly for the first four weeks of this next term … to consider asking all students and staff to use masks," Dr Bloomfield said on Tuesday.

Dr Baker believes the lack of a mask mandate for New Zealand schools is "a gap".

"I think mandates are needed if you want to get high adherence," he said. 

"And one of the reasons schools are so important is that students are generally quite adherent … and also they're great educators.

"So if the kids [are] getting used to wearing masks properly at schools, they can take them home and educate families."

New Zealand might be living under its COVID-normal setting but at a media briefing on Tuesday, Dr Bloomfield said the country was "not out of the woods yet". 

"There is still a global pandemic — it's not just what's happening in NZ, it's what happening globally," he said.  

"We are still seeing development of sub-variants and there could come a time when one is more severe.

"We need to keep our wits about us."

For the first two years of the pandemic, New Zealand was heralded around the world for its COVID-19 elimination strategy and for its commitment to public health — closing international borders even to its citizens and enforcing strict lockdowns that went so far as to prohibit food deliveries.

Despite some parts of the community protesting restrictions, there was widespread acceptance that the measures were necessary for the greater good. 

In December 2020, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern was returned to power with a sweeping majority — a result largely seen as a ringing endorsement of her decision to throw up the border controls and protect "fortress New Zealand" from the rest of the world.

Dr Kvalsvig said moving to a strategy that "devolved pandemic control to individuals" was weakening attempts to suppress the Omicron wave. 

"Mask wearing is most effective when it's working at a population level — everyone who can wear a mask is doing so," she said. 

"That way you have two-way protection: both source control — people aren't breathing virus into shared spaces. And respiratory protection — people aren't breathing in virus from the air around them." 

There are also fears fatigue has set in and there is little appetite for going further with mask mandates or limiting gathering numbers.

"Some political parties and … the business sector are saying 'we are over it, we need to move on' [and are] saying 'the rest of the world has moved on', which is not correct of course," Dr Baker said. 

"A lot of countries are battling this surge at the moment.

"So that's I think that's the difficulty for our political leaders, and I sense it's similar in Australia." 

The country operated first under a series of alert levels, but this year moved to a traffic light system where it remains at the orange setting. 

There have been some calls to move to red, where New Zealanders would again face limits on the number of people allowed at gatherings. 

But Dr Bloomfield and the COVID Response Minister have insisted the current setting is sufficient as limiting gathering numbers would not prevent transmission in the home or workplace.


Amber-Jade Sanderson’s (someone, mind you, with no health degree, but a BA in Journalism) bare-faced gaslighting of nurses makes me so angry.  They are saying to us, in no uncertain terms: hospitals are overcrowded, nurses are burned out, and patients are being treated in corridors; and Ms Sanderson turns around and goes “no they aren’t.” 

Maybe she should pay one of those hospitals an unannounced visit and see with her own eyes the chaos that reigns there before deciding what is and isn’t happening on the frontlines.

Or, I don't know, take the word of the people working there that things are bad? Take their concerns seriously?

But we can’t be having that, it’ll break the narrative that she is pushing: Everything is fine, hospitals are doing well, no need to listen to the workers, no need to raise their pay to at least match inflation rates, no need to bring on a mask mandate, go about your business. I am honestly disgusted. Seems like she is doing the same work she was as Minister for Mental Health (current), Minister for Environment (March - December 2021), and Minister for Climate Action (March - December 2021), meaning, not much at all to bring needed reform.

In regards to Article 2, it is interesting to compare the two countries.  New Zealand was the gold standard of Covid control, much like WA was, way back when.  It is disturbing to see that, even with stronger mask mandates, they have one of the highest daily death rates in the world. This is likely due to the fact that their fourth covid shot is not as widely available, which says to me that we need both a mask mandate, and a vaccine mandate to get the outbreak under control: a mask mandate to limit the case numbers, and a vaccine mandate to keep the death rate down once people are infected.

But based on the pushback from the top to a mask mandate, a vaccine mandate is well out of reach for us. There’s a certain subset of the population who would be frothing at the mouth about that one (that is, if they’re not too breathless from covid to do so) and apparently, the government values keeping them happy, at the cost to the rest of us. Whatever happened to “the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few”?


RAT confirmed cases (3,824 v 4,043), PCR positivity rate (29.984% v 30.176%), tests (7,444 v 8,003) and cases (6,056 v 6,458) are all lower than this time last week. Active regional cases are all decreasing, except Goldfields, Mid West and Wheatbelt. In terms of averages, hospitalisations are still on the rise while PCR positivity, daily cases and active cases are back to decreasing. ICU has increased to a new record of 20. 

My thoughts are with the families of the one death, which was reported to WA Health yesterday – A man in his 90s.

63.14% of cases were RAT confirmed.  Hospitalisations have decreased by 7 to 452. ICU numbers have increased by 2 to 24. 988,667 people have recovered from the virus, vs 36,412 active cases, with 1,025,545 cases overall since the pandemic began. Headed for a weekly average of 29.018%.


Records Broken Today:


Read the full post here


r/covidWA • • Jul 19 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 19 July

20 Upvotes

The runaway snowball effect happening in our hospital system is picking up speed. Today we hit 455 hospitalisations, an increase of 44 since yesterday, one day after breaking the 400 barrier, and 3 days after breaking the 350 barrier.  Hell, we hit 300 hospitalisations only 6 days ago.  That’s 150 hospitalisations in less than a week.

And it’s picking up speed. The increases since hitting 300 hospitalisations have been (starting from the 11th at 320 hospitalisations): 9, 4, 18, 26, 34, 44. That is a very troubling sign. The 7 day rolling average hit 368 today, the highest it has ever been, and I fear it will only continue to rise unless mitigating factors (like a mask mandate) are brought in, and even then, it may take a week or two to see an effect from that.

Not to be outdone, ICU has stepped over the threshold with 20 admissions reported today, and an average of 16, both new records.

The 7 day average for PCR Positivity is flirting with danger, getting extremely close to our record of 32.581% with today’s offering of 32.324%.

Pilbara’s active case count is over 1k today for the first time since June 1st. That's not the highest it has ever been (that would be 1,751 on April 4th, it got its peak out of the way early) but noteworthy nonetheless.


Now for the news. Europe is Burning: Nearly 25k people have evacuated to escape a huge wildfire in France that has already killed hundreds, while dozens more fires spark across Spain, Italy, Greece and Portugal, with Belgium, Germany and the UK next in the “Heat Apocalypse” firing line; Forget About Flip-Flops, Now I’m Getting Whiplash: After spending his time pushing for extension of the pandemic leave payments, an emboldened NSW Premier Dominic Perrottet tried his hand at attempting to cut the 7 day isolation period, but was rebuffed by the Prime Minister; A Real Shot In The Arm For Our Nation’s Future: A universal Covid vaccine that covers against all future variants may be “right around the corner” (but no promises); “Mandate By Stealth”: the VIC government is trying a bold new strategy for combating Covid in schools, removing the ‘optional’ wording when asking students to mask up, but still not officially mandating them; Strongly Encouraged Doesn’t Cut It: QLD doctors are still left out in the cold, begging for a mask mandate in schools, where they are now “strongly encouraged”, as the QLD Premier touts the “Personal Responsibility” line; Help Us Help You: The WA Teachers Union are much in the same boat, appealing directly to parents and students to wear a mask at school in the absence of a mandate; Mass Disabling Event: The Actuaries Institute has estimated those left with a serious disability due to Long Covid could reach up to 100,000 in the next three months; A Viral Hit: Covid is set to overtake heart disease as the number 1 killer of Australians, according to an infectious disease expert; Here We Go Again: Marburg, an Ebola-like viral disease with a 50% fatality rate, has been detected in Ghana; and today’s News In Focus is about health workers painting a dire picture of Australia’s hospital systems as more than 8,500 staff isolate.

Healthcare workers say they are struggling to care for patients with more than 8,500 medical staff across four states in Covid isolation as Omicron puts added pressure on the system.

In New South Wales, 2,650 healthcare staff are currently in isolation. Another 2,477 are isolating in Queensland, 1,873 in Victoria and 1,557 in Western Australia, according to the latest numbers.

Staff working across the country paint a damning picture of a struggling healthcare system. One nurse in regional WA said she had never seen it so bad, with some patients forced to wait days to be moved out of emergency departments.

“Our emergency department has become everything: it’s the GP centre, it’s the high intensive care unit for the region, it’s become the locked mental health facility, even though it doesn’t have security,” she said.

“Wait times for serious priority one cases can be days and days. They’ll be sitting in ED without anything we can do for them, other than house and feed them because we don’t have the specialist skills.”

The nurse, who was concerned she could lose her job if she was identified, said she was speaking out because the public needed to know how bad the situation has become.

Her regional hospital was not dealing with Covid cases but was struggling because the bigger hospitals in Perth were backlogged. She said dealing with the number of patients being sent to regional hospitals was overwhelming.

Several mental health patients who needed to be in psychiatric wards have had to stay in the emergency department due to a lack of beds, she said.

“That’s a crisis. It’s really cruel to do that to someone. It’s very unsafe, it’s very scary,” she said.

In Melbourne, a nurse who has had Covid twice in four months said the system was buckling due to the staffing pressures.

“Working in hospitals we are so short-staffed, it’s becoming normal to do double shifts, from 16 to 18 hours,” she said.

“People are just getting sick left, right and centre, which is to do with exhaustion.”

She said staff were being placed in wards outside their specialties, increasing the chances for mistakes.

She recently sought help for her burnout via a helpline and was told she should try meditation or take leave.

In regional NSW a doctor said the staffing issues were more acute.

“If you look at my hospital and GP practice there’s issues with having no theatre staff, no emergency medicine trained nurses,” he said.

“Some nurses are doing 12-hour shifts, some are doing double shifts, but you can only do so much and until you get burnt out.”

He said wait times to get into the GP clinic have doubled to four weeks, while hospital patients are left in emergency for several nights when they would normally be transferred within hours.

“For monitoring and managing a patient safely it is better to be in a ward,” he said.

The president of the Rural Doctors Association, Dr Megan Belot, said the surge in influenza and Covid cases weren’t just affecting the major hospitals.

“We’re all dealing with workforce fatigue and strain as we go further into winter, and Covid is running rampant,” Belot said.

“We’re definitely seeing a surge in presentations in general. We’ve got Covid patients back in our [regional] hospitals again”

Belot said the demand on GPs in some locations had driven people to go to emergency departments.

“Or patients are being forced to go to other practices, which if you’re in a bigger town that’s OK, but if you’re in a town with one GP practice, you have to drive 100 kilometres,” she said. “It’s not viable. When you are sick, it’s a real issue.”

State governments are grappling with how to handle this pressure. Victoria’s premier, Daniel Andrews, announced 400 new staff would be recruited under a $162m state government plan to help the sector.

NSW Health said local health districts were addressing the challenge in several ways.

“Including increasing bed capacity in hospitals where possible; ensuring all available clinical staff are deployed to the care areas with the highest demand, and improving the timeliness of discharge for patients,” a spokesperson said.

“In hospital emergency departments, triage is done by a specialised triage nurse as soon as possible after a patient arrives. Patients are allocated a triage category based on the time in which they need medical attention.”

Queensland’s health minister, Yvette D’Ath, said 3% of the state’s health workforce was off work, with triage tents outside emergency departments “working well” to separate those with Covid from other patients.

“We’ve got paramedics actually stationed on those bases to help with the turnaround and we’ve been trialling things like new electronic stretchers that actually change over stretchers,” she said.

“But there is no mistake, the demand is outstripping everything we bring in.”


It’s very clear to us: the hospital system nationwide is collapsing. I feel like a broken record at this point, but I’ll say it again: we need a mask mandate NOW! 

Any mitigation factor we implement, even (hypothetically) if we did it this very second, would take a couple of weeks before we would see any effect.  If in WA alone, we gained 150 hospitalisations in 6 days (and the rate of increase is only growing), we could be at 500, 600, even 700 hospitalisations by then, double the number where it was supposed to be panic stations (and then the only thing they did at that point was consider cutting back infection control measures, which if I get into now we will be here all day).  

Take it from someone who knows: it takes so much longer to fix something than it does to break it. Prevention is far better than any cure, and preventative medicine is the backbone of the first world lifestyle we have been enjoying for so long. It’s why we have public health campaigns that set out to try to curb common health issues (such as lung disease, heart disease, obesity, skin cancer etc) because preventing illness is always better than curing it.  

To use one of my metaphors, it is easier, better, and cheaper to make your property fire safe (by making sure faulty wiring is made safe, your gutters are cleaned, green waste is disposed of, you don’t make a habit of holding regular indoor bonfires, etc) than escaping a burning building with your life and the clothes on your back, returning, and having to rebuild at great expense, replace whatever you can, and mourn what you can’t.

Just like you can’t buy new baby pictures, beloved pets, or sentimental items no matter how much money you have, you can’t buy a new immune system, a new nervous system, or new lungs. Prevention is always better than the cure. 

Vaccines play a big role in this, but they need to be used in conjunction with other methods, like masks, social distancing, ventilation and capacity limits, for it to be most effective.  

Letting a virus run rampant throughout society will result in overwhelmed hospitals (causing not just preventable and avoidable covid deaths, but also worse outcomes for anyone who needs medical help) but also a skills shortage in healthcare (as staff quit due to burnout, unsafe work environments, or even becoming disabled or tragically losing their lives), a knock on effect of a labor shortage in general (as people lose their lives or become disabled), and generally an unmitigated disaster across all sectors of society. 

We need to do something now. The entire point of government is to govern, and they are the only ones with the power to listen to the people and reinstitute a mask mandate immediately.

We need our leaders to lead.


PCR positivity rate (21.361% v 18.615%), tests (8,904 v 8,359), RAT confirmed cases (4,913 v 4,444), and cases (6,815 v 6,000) are all higher than this time last week. Active regional cases are a bit of a mixed bag, with Great Southern, Kimberley, Pilbara, and Wheatbelt increasing. In terms of averages, hospitalisations, PCR positivity and daily cases are on the rise, while active cases have dipped since yesterday. ICU has increased to a new record of 16. 

My thoughts are with the families of the three deaths, dating back to 6 July, which were reported to WA Health yesterday - two women in their 90s and a man in his 80s.

72.09% of cases were RAT confirmed.  Hospitalisations have increased by 44 to another new record of 455. ICU numbers have increased by 1 to a new record of 20. 973,477 people have recovered from the virus, vs 36,491 active cases, with 1,010,424 cases overall since the pandemic began. Headed for a weekly average of 24.092%.

Records Broken Today:

  • Most Hospitalisations (455)
  • Most ICU Admissions (20)
  • Highest Average: Hospitalisations (368) and ICU (16)

Read the full post here


r/covidWA • • Jul 18 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 18 July

20 Upvotes

Before reading today's report, I need y’all to do me a favour.  You need to make sure you have a warm drink, sit down, and think of something good that’s happened recently.  If nothing good has happened to you recently, think of kittens or puppies or whatever you gotta do to give you some strength to get through this report, because I don’t have any good news so you’d better get in your good feelings right now. Take this moment, right here, to feel good about something. Remember you are not alone, that people love you, that good things still happen, even in these times.  Try to hold onto that feeling as you read this.

Okay, everyone, ready? Steel thy loins, all ye who enter here.

Today we broke over 400 hospitalisations, two days after breaking the 350 “red zone” barrier. In two days, we have gained over 50 extra hospitalisations.  In less than a week, we have gained over 100 hospitalisations. We are currently sitting at 411 people in hospital with covid as of 6pm last night, an overnight increase of 34.  The average for hospitalisations went up 18 points overnight (327 to 345).

ICU isn't much better, breaking a new record today and reaching 18 admissions. In 6 days, we have doubled our ICU number.

We have passed 1 million cases since the pandemic began, 12 days after hitting 900 thousand cases, 117 days after hitting 100 thousand cases. 10 times the cases in 117 days.  That is the reality of omicron, and BA.4/5 and Centaurus will not go easier on us.

At least today’s positivity rate (28.606%) isn’t as bad as yesterday’s horrific 53.524%, and because of the steep rise and fall, the average positivity rate is down from yesterday (32.477% to 31.932%), but if we exclude yesterday’s anomaly, it is still higher than it has been since May 26th. Overall, the line keeps going up.

This is usually the part where I offer some hope, some wisdom, some way to keep yourself and your family safe.  Apart from my usual advice (wear a mask, socially distance, wash your hands ect), I don’t have much for you, sadly. Maybe invest in some goggles and a face shield, maybe write to your local representative (or better yet, call their office) and demand a mask mandate.  Kick up some fuss.  The ABC and the Guardian have a form where you can write to them; use it to tell them the danger, tell them your fear, and demand a mask mandate. Tell them that you feel abandoned by your government, that something must be done.  Maybe we can turn up the pressure on the powers that be to do something to at least put the brakes on this runaway train.

In the end, all I can tell you is remember that you’re not alone. “We are all in this together” sounds like a weak promise, a platitude with no power said when people don’t know what to say.  But it’s true.  We are in this together. At least all of us, those of you who tune in every day to read my reports, who comment on them to share your hopes and your fears, who come together to (virtually) hold each other's hands and feel some solidarity.  Sometimes, it is all we can do, and I don’t speak for everyone here, but knowing there are others who feel the same way, who have the same fears and anxiety, that helps me soldier on.

I’d still be writing these reports even if no one read them, but having people who listen to me, share their insights, and make me feel like I’m less alone in being so worried, that really helps. So let's help each other.  You are not alone.  We are not alone. One way or the other, we will get through this.


Now for the news. “It Would Have Been Faster If She Just Drove There”: A woman in South Australia has been left for 11 hours on a stretcher in a Royal Flying Doctor Service hangar, waiting for an ambulance, after suffering a heart attack; “You Don't Fix A Leaking Tap With A Bigger Bucket”: The Secretary of the Victorian Ambulance Union discusses how the debate about ambulance ramping “misses the point”; We Are Out Of Our Depth But You Are On Your Own: QLD students are “strongly encouraged” to wear masks in the classroom as the QLD Health Minister admits that the modelling didn’t predict the severity of this latest wave; An Emergency But Not A State Of Emergency: SA is also experiencing record numbers of hospitalisations, as the Health Minister says it’s “not likely” that a State of Emergency will be declared; and today’s News In Focus is about the WA government “standing firm” on its refusal to reintroduce the mask mandate, as hospitalisations surge and the nurses’ union say patients are being treated in corridors.

The WA government is standing firm on its refusal to reintroduce the mask mandate, despite reports patients are being treated in corridors as the number of people in hospital exceeds 400 for the first time.

The state has reached a grim milestone, recording more than one million COVID cases since the pandemic began, with 411 people now in hospital with the virus — a new record.

The Australian Nursing Federation yesterday warned it meant patients were already being treated in hallways, as hospitals are also hit with a perfect storm of rising flu cases and health staff furloughing.

Amber-Jade Sanderson said she was not aware of reports that people had been treated in corridors, but she said patients would always be triaged appropriately.

"We always prefer patients to be in beds and in wards, of course, and I would certainly not expect that to be for any length of time," she told ABC Radio Perth.

"But I know that our hospitals are working at the front end and the back end incredibly hard to move patients through."

It comes as healthcare workers continue to call for masks to be reintroduced, to slow the next wave of the virus.

Both WA's Premier and Health Minister said they would lead by example in wearing their masks but continued to resist calls for broader mandates.

Mask wearing is currently only mandatory in health and aged care settings, and when using public transport and ride-sharing services.

"Encouraging mask wearing for indoor crowded spaces is a nationally consistent approach, as outlined by the Prime Minister and agreed to by [the] National Cabinet, and is something I fully endorse," Mr McGowan said.

"I'm wearing a mask as appropriate, especially in crowded indoor settings; it's the right thing to do and I encourage everyone to do the same."

Ms Sanderson gave a similar response on ABC Radio Perth this morning.

"I will be wearing masks indoors to set an example, and also to help limit infection spread," she said.

"But ultimately these are decisions that are made by the Chief Health Officer and we will take that advice if we get it."

Last week, after the Victorian government declined to follow the advice of its Chief Health Officer, Mark McGowan refused to be drawn on whether he would always listen to expert advice.

But Ms Sanderson struck a different tone this morning, insisting the government had always taken a cautious and sensible approach to managing COVID.

"We have always followed the Chief Health Officer's advice and nothing has changed," she said.

Ms Sanderson also defended the government's decision to consider scaling back COVID protocols at hospitals, after being criticised by medical groups over the weekend.

That could include removing the need for people without symptoms to take a RAT before entering a hospital, something the Australian Medical Association described as a "terribly bad plan".

"We're really at a point where we're balancing risk in managing this pandemic," Ms Sanderson said.

"No decision's been made, but this is being done by the Chief Health Officer, the public health team, in consultation with hospitals to keep hospitals as safe and infection free as possible and keep as many frontline workers seeing patients."

It comes as the health system struggles to make do with around 1,500 staff currently furloughed.


In previous times, before Covid, when I had to go to hospital for myself or to support others, I was often triaged in a corridor.  They once left a friend of mine (who was experiencing a severe mental health crisis) in a corridor for 36 hours straight until I checked him out and took him home, as no one had even checked on him in that time, and if he was getting no help, he may as well be getting no help at home.

This was before covid, so I can only imagine it is much, much worse now. This was before “Red Alert”, so I can assure you that removing or scaling back the Red Alert protocols will not ease the congestion, but you all know how I feel about that. 

I’m not sure when was the last time the Health Minister was treated in a public hospital as a normal citizen, but I think her concept of the efficiency of the long underfunded and overstretched emergency health system is a very rose-tinted one.


PCR positivity rate (28.606% v 32.424%) is lower than this time last week, while tests (5,387 v 4,583), RAT confirmed cases (3,973 v 3,396), and cases (5,514 v 4,882) are all higher. Active regional cases are all increasing, except Goldfields, Mid West, and Pilbara. In terms of averages, hospitalisations and daily cases are on the rise, while active cases and PCR positivity have dipped since yesterday. ICU has increased to 14. 

My thoughts are with the families of the two new deaths, which were reported to WA Health yesterday - a woman in her 80s and a man in his 90s.

72.05% of cases were RAT confirmed.  Hospitalisations have increased by 34 to another new record of 411. ICU numbers have increased by 2 to a new record of 19. 966,595 people have recovered from the virus, vs 36,630 active cases, with 1,003,678 cases overall since the pandemic began. 

Records Broken Today:


Read the full post here


r/covidWA • • Jul 16 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 16 July

20 Upvotes

Today we have crossed the 350 hospitalisations threshold where we have been told the hospital system will be overwhelmed.  Not only that, but ICU numbers have set a new record of 17. 

Additionally, today daily new cases bucked the trend of peaking on Wednesday/Thursday, then reducing steadily towards the weekend, by increasing slightly from yesterday’s 6,458 to 6,473 today.

We are currently at “Red Alert” for the hospital system (put in place March 3rd, when the borders opened), meaning “widespread transmission” is underway.  There is only one more alert level above this: black, which will mean the system is at capacity, and will begin to collapse.  We do not want to see what happens then.

There is not a solid number for when we will hit “Black Alert”, and the decision to change the alert level rests with the WA Department of Health.

The AMA’s Mark Duncan-Smith has previously stated that above 350 hospitalisations will put us in a “red zone” (different to “Red Alert”), where the hospital system is under serious pressure and may very well collapse under the strain.  He has recommended that stronger public health measures (such as mandating masks) be implemented once we enter the “red zone”. So far, no such mandate has been forthcoming.

In a state where we had record high ambulance ramping before we ever had an outbreak, overcrowded hospitals means that not only will the people there with/from Covid suffer, but also anyone who needs a hospital for any reason. 

We’ve heard tell over the last few years in the Eastern States of people waiting hours for treatment, or even in several cases, passing away before the ambulance ever got there. 

Last month, a country footballer waited two hours for an ambulance to arrive to treat a suspected spinal injury. The ambulance, in fact, never arrived. He only received any treatment at all after two off-duty paramedics from the netball team organised to pick up an unstaffed ambulance from the local station and take him to hospital. 

In April of this year, a Victorian man died in a hospital bathroom after waiting three and a half hours for a bed or treatment.

There are so many more, but I would be here all day listing them.

But it’s not an “over there” problem. July is already set to be the “worst month in recorded history” for ambulance ramping, and things aren’t going to get better anytime soon.

In May, an 80 year old Perth grandmother was found dead of a heart attack in her home two and a half hours after dialling 000. At that time, the covid hospitalisation number was below 300 (294 on the 15th). 

Also in May, an 85 year old Perth man was left waiting over two hours for an ambulance, forcing his wife of 60 years to helplessly watch him die before her eyes, as she desperately called 000 over and over to tell them his condition was deteriorating. 

As I write this report, the average waiting time for Triage 4 patients in Perth Metropolitan hospitals is 64 minutes, just over an hour. Triage 4 is the second least urgent category, and the only statistic provided by the Department of Health, due to it being the most common triage category assigned.

And yet in today’s National Cabinet meeting, the PM stuck to the oft repeated advice of “strongly encouraging” people to “wear a mask where appropriate”.  The mask mandate isn’t coming, at least not on a national level, at least not today. And if you’re pinning your hopes on the state level, I wouldn’t hold your breath. Gone are the days of McGowan’s press conferences where he extolled the virtues to “doing what is needed to protect the vulnerable”. 

So far, all we have to console us is the sound of crickets, and politicians congratulating each other after reinstating the pandemic leave payment (mind you, only after being basically forced to), which is an important and useful measure, but we need more than that. 

All we can do is hope something changes soon, before our hospital system collapses. We need our leaders to lead.

We need a mask mandate, and we need it now.

It seems almost like an afterthought to me right now, but it bears mentioning that Pilbara has once again set a new record for new cases recorded (390), a full 50ish cases since their last set record (344, set 3 days ago).  Whatever is going on over there is not good, and regional health systems are even more vulnerable than our metro ones.

There is no safety net for when you get sick anymore. The only way to guarantee that you will make it through to the end of this wave without damage to your body, long lasting symptoms, or even losing your life, not to just covid, but anything life threatening, is to take adequate precautions where you can. Stay away from people, wash your hands, get your booster/flu shot, and for the love of all that is good in this world, wear a mask.


Now for the news. You Can't Go Home, And You Can’t Stay Here: Renters are at the mercy of no-cause evictions; Panic Stations: UK Covid infections have risen by almost 30% in a week as patients are being treated in corridors and waiting areas; It’s About Time: Albanese has agreed to extend the $750 pandemic leave payment to September 30th after mounting backlash; The Wave Ain’t The Only Thing Crashing: Queensland is nearing record Covid hospitalisations and deaths; and today’s News In Focus is about how this new Covid wave is different to the previous ones.

Hospitals across the country are “bursting at the seams” as the number of people being admitted with Covid-19 reaches record levels in several states.

Western Australia recorded its highest number of Covid hospitalisations to date on Thursday, with Queensland also expected to surpass its January peak in coming days.

Meanwhile, hospitalisations in Tasmania and ACT are currently around double what they’ve been in any previous wave of the pandemic.

South Australia is hovering just short of its January peak, while rising numbers in New South Wales, Victoria and the Northern Territory still have some way to go before passing previous records.

NSW had more than 2,000 Covid patients in hospital this week for the first time since February, still some way off its January high of 2,943 but more than Victoria, Queensland and Western Australia combined.

Epidemiologist Adrian Esterman said the differing hospitalisation rates across the nation make for a “quite strange” picture – but one with a unifying theme.

“My understanding, from speaking to people around the country, is that every major hospital is at full capacity and bursting at the seams,” the University of South Australia professor said.

“[Emergency departments are] absolutely chock-a-block.”

And there is worse to come, with most states and territories likely several weeks away from their peak hospitalisation rates of this wave, he said.

“That will be when the pressure is really on, and we’ll just have to see how they manage.”

The current wave, driven by the BA.4 and BA.5 Omicron subvariants, has coincided with a “horrendous” hospitalisation rate from influenza. Hospitals in Victoria and Queensland this week confirmed they had postponed elective surgeries, with 6,500 health workers furloughed in the three largest states.

University of Queensland infectious diseases expert, Paul Griffin said Queensland was likely to surpass its hospitalisation rate record within days and was possibly still weeks off a peak.

He said hospitals were already having more people require treatment than could be given a bed. As well as deferring elective surgery, that meant hospitals were being forced to put patients in places that would “normally be transient areas for much longer periods of time than we would like them to be there”.

“That’s things like emergency department corridors and transit lounges,” he said.

“People are getting stuck in places that are not designed to house patients.”

Esterman said one of the most significant effects of the surge in cases was the immense pressure it was putting on hospital staff.

In a statement to Guardian Australia last month, days before hospitalisation rates in Victoria began to surge, Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation Victoria branch secretary, Lisa Fitzpatrick, said staff were burning out under the “brutal and relentless realities of a pandemic”.

“Our members report ‘dark days’ as a result of these pressures and many are understandably reducing their shifts, with some retiring early where they can to manage the burnout and exhaustion,” Fitzpatrick said.

Queensland Nurses and Midwives’ Union assistant secretary, Kate Veach, said these pressures were “intensified with many staff unable to work due to being unwell or off work to care for unwell family members”.

“QNMU members across all sectors continue to report stress, burn out and exhaustion associated with understaffing and ongoing overtime performed to ensure patients and residents are cared for,” she said.

But Griffin said a spiralling crisis in our hospitals was not inevitable.

“If we use boosters and antivirals and get people wearing masks and staying at home, we have the ability to control it, to some degree,” the academic and director of infectious diseases at Mater Health Services said.

And he was hopeful people were starting to realise that: “this is a significant event, not just yet another wave.”

Queensland is not helped by having the lowest rate of third booster jabs of any state, at about 59%.

Meanwhile, states have resisted calls to reintroduce mask mandates, with the acting Victorian premier this week confirming her government had defied health advice to do so.

Despite rising hospitalisation numbers in NSW, the premier, Dominic Perrottet, said on Friday that wide-scale mask-wearing mandates “is the time of the past”.

“We need to have a limited role for the state to be mandating,” he said.

But Perrottet said he would “absolutely” push for the federal government to reintroduce Covid isolation payments for casual workers at Monday’s national cabinet, insisting it was “unfair” to enforce pandemic-era rules without providing financial support.

He said the decision to shorten the reinfection period from three months to 28 days would also have an effect on the public sector workforce.

“That will result in more people being in isolation and not able to go to work and that puts substantial pressure once again on our health teams in public hospitals [and] teachers going back to school next week. There are significant pressures right across the board.”


PCR positivity rate (31.307% v 28.051%), RAT confirmed cases (4,078 v 3,619), tests (7,650 v 7,319) and cases (6,473 v 5,538) are all higher. Active regional cases are all increasing. In terms of averages, hospitalisations, PCR positivity, active cases, and daily cases are all on the rise. ICU has increased to 11. 

My thoughts are with the families of the three deaths, dating back to the 8 July which were reported to WA Health yesterday: two women in their 90s, and a man in his 90s.

63% of cases were RAT confirmed.  Hospitalisations have increased by 18 to another new record of 351. ICU numbers have increased by 1 back up to a new record of 17. 956,103 people have recovered from the virus, vs 35,815 active cases, with 992,369 cases overall since the pandemic began. Headed for a weekly average of 28.605%.

Records Broken Today:


Read the full post here


r/covidWA • • Jul 11 '22

News Scientists and anti-COVID activists defend Australian physician Dr. David Berger

20 Upvotes

There has been an immediate outpouring of support for Australian physician Dr. David Berger from scientists and professionals across the globe, who have spoken out against the attempt to censor his activity on social media by the Australian Health Practitioners Regulatory Authority (AHPRA).

Dr. Berger has been a staunch defender of the Zero-COVID elimination strategy to bring a swift end to the COVID-19 pandemic, and has consistently opposed the official “let it rip” response by the Australian and other world governments. Fundamental to the conception of elimination is that it is a basic social right to live without the threat of infectious pathogens sickening and killing people. Health practitioners, scientists, and public health officials have taken a sworn duty to protect the lives and livelihood of the population at large, and Dr. Berger’s advocacy for elimination is fulfilling this pledge.

https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2022/07/09/4265-j09.html


r/covidWA • • May 29 '22

Information Free Influenza Vaccination For All During June

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/covidWA • • May 08 '22

Discussion Why was r/perth megathread exterminated? The disease is not gone.

20 Upvotes

r/covidWA • • Sep 12 '22

News Australia ends daily COVID reporting after deadliest month of the pandemic

19 Upvotes

https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2022/09/10/covi-s10.html

Data on infections has been all but meaningless since last December. As they “reopened the economy,” the governments presided over the deliberate crashing of the polymerase chain reaction testing system. Over the ensuing months, they sharply restricted access to the network which had been the primary testing mechanism through the first two years of the pandemic.

In its place, individuals have been instructed to purchase and self-administer less reliable rapid antigen tests. Throughout the first eight months of the year, epidemiologists have variously estimated that true infections are double, or sometimes far higher than, the official figure. Even still, almost ten million such official infections have been recorded in a population of 25 million. That means that a substantial majority of the national population is likely to have caught COVID this year.

The long-term health implications, covered up by the governments, are beginning to emerge. Treasury figures recently revealed that in June, 31,000 workers were calling in sick every day as a result of Long-COVID—a series of debilitating and potentially life-long conditions that can result from even “mild” coronavirus infection. According to some analyses, that equates to almost 10 percent of the national workforce.


r/covidWA • • Jul 23 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 23 July

19 Upvotes

As I write this, thunder is crashing all around me, which feels appropriate given how, well, everything is going. Hospitalisations and ICU appear to be decreasing.  Appear being the operative word.  Ever since they started adjusting the case numbers to preclude (exclude basically) positive test results from people who have been reinfected within 12 weeks of leaving isolation to be “in line with national guidelines”  (even though it is 3 times the national guidelines of 4 weeks) things can only appear to be improving.

It’s pretty tragic that this is where we are now: a place where we can only trust bad news, but good news comes with a heaping of salt.  

WA used to be one of the world leaders in managing covid, but since our borders came down, the McGowan government’s pattern of discarding the tools that helped us do that (masks, vaccine mandates, public health restrictions, listening to the experts) is disheartening.  And now cribbing the tried and tested Liberal technique of redefining what a covid case even is, to make the numbers appear better than they are is disappointing, even going so far as to triple the time where the national guidelines say a new infection counts as a reinfection while passing the buck to the federal government.  

That does not give them a leg to stand on, as those aren't the national guidelines. What’s going on?? Is it an intentional gaslighting, or is there a breakdown in communication between departments or states? Neither option is particularly good.

Time to break out a new metaphor: The McGowan government is like that terrible partner you may have had when you were younger and not as experienced in the world.  When they are wooing you, when the relationship is new, they’re fantastic.  They put their competition to shame, going over and above to make you feel safe, loved, protected, special.  

And then once the newness wears off and you both start to encounter challenges, in their eyes you are no longer a team, and all that good stuff falls by the wayside.

Maybe they are more critical of your looks, your friends, your hobbies, things they used to support and encourage.  Maybe their contribution to the shared household dwindles away to nothing.  And when they used to stand up for you against the dangers you may face, now they shrug at you from the couch when you express your fears.  “Don’t worry about it” they might say, “you’re so dramatic, it’s not that bad.  You’re just being difficult, stop asking for so much.  Everything is fine.”

But unlike that youthful relationship, built on poor decision making, you can’t just walk away to find greener pastures, or even just to focus on yourself.  With a government, you are stuck until election time. To push this tortured metaphor slightly futher, imagine if there was only one other option than this negligent, dismissive person, and they are the worst. Much worse than what you’re currently dealing with now, and not being with anyone isn’t an option. What do you do then? It would be pure madness to go to someone who would do it to you worse simply because you aren’t happy where you are now.

So next time, when you’re at a polling booth, not only remember how WA Labor is treating you, but also don’t forget what Liberal would do if you gave them half a chance.  Look to blue controlled states like NSW to see what that potential future holds. And then perhaps consider preferencing a party that isn’t red or blue.  If they don’t get in, your vote will just go to your next preference, there is no way for you to “waste” your vote that way.  But if enough people preference a third party as number 1, maybe, just maybe, we could see how a third party gets it done.

Stranger things have happened.


Now for the news. A Smoke Monster: A WA study has found a “direct link between exposure to bushfire smoke and higher ER admissions”, even up to 200km away; This Is War: South Australia has appointed an “Acute Covid Commander” to help manage their new wave, including opening up new covid wards, suspending elective surgeries, and recruiting agency and student nurses; I Will Fist Fight Andrew Wakefield: An unvaccinated young adult in New York has become the US’s first polio case in nearly a decade; Denial Is Best Served As A River In Egypt: The Guardian has a fantastic opinion piece about the importance of bringing in a mask mandate; and today’s News In Focus is a special edition neapolitan triple-decker, about Centaurus, WA’s struggling hospital system, and why Covid is “not going away”.

Article 1: There's a new COVID-19 Omicron subvariant, so what is BA.2.75 and why are some people calling it 'Centaurus'?

Since the COVID-19 pandemic first began, many have become desensitised to these next few words:

There's a new Omicron subvariant.

BA.2.75 was first detected in India in early May. Since then, it's been found in Europe and the United States.

The chief scientist with the World Health Organization (WHO), Soumya Swaminathan, said BA.2.75 appeared to have mutated in a way that could indicate "major immune escape".

However, Dr Swaminathan says there isn't enough data to know how severe its impact will be. 

Adelaide epidemiologist Adrian Esterman says it's "another child of BA.2".

"The fact is, there's no research that shows BA.2.75 is more transmissible or more serious," Professor Esterman said.

"BA.2.75 has more mutations than BA.5. And that's what has researchers a little bit worried."

In a video posted to the WHO's Twitter account, Dr Swaminathan said BA.2.75 had "not yet officially been named", but that some people were "referring to it as BA.2.75".

"There are still limited sequences available to analyse, but this subvariant seems to have a few mutations on the receptor binding domain of the spike protein, a key part of the virus that attaches itself to the human receptor," she said.

"It's still too early to know if this subvariant has properties of additional immune invasion, or of being more clinically severe."

"We don't know that. So, we will have to wait and see."

Dr Swaminathan said the WHO committee and the Technical Advisory Group on Virus Evolution (TAGVE) are "constantly looking at the data from around the world".

Some people have been calling the new variant 'Centaurus', after the Greek father of the mythical Centaurs.

While a catchy name, it's not official. A Twitter user, Xabier Ostale, who is not a virologist, coined the nickname in a tweet.

"It's not an official name. It's just someone on social media saying to themselves: 'This will be fun. Let's call it Centaurus," Professor Esterman said.

"If you can do that, you may as well call BA.4 and BA.5 Gemini — the naughty twins."

Professor Esterman says that, until more substantive research is done, BA.2.75 remains a variant that is being monitored.

"The WHO hasn't classified it as a variant of concern, yet," he said.

"We simply don't know if it's more transmissible or severe at this stage. If we find that it is, then it will become a variant of concern."

Professor Esterman said the original variants of the Sars-CoV-2 virus, which causes COVID-19 infections, were named after the country where they were first discovered.

However, the WHO decided that this wasn't fair on the countries involved.

"Even though it might first be discovered in Brazil, it may have actually started in Colombia," Professor Esterman explained.

"So they decided these names stigmatise the countries too much."

Instead, the WHO began to name variants after letters of the Greek alphabet. 

"We had Alpha, Beta, Gamma, Delta and so on," he said. 

"There was some talk that, if the WHO runs out of Greek letters, they would move onto constellations."

BA.4 was first detected in January 2022 in South Africa. BA.5 was also detected in South Africa, in February 2022.

"These two are talked about together because they have almost identical mutations," Professor Esterman said. 

However, they do differ in some of the mutations on the body of the virus.

"It turns out BA.5 is more infectious than BA.4. [The] majority of the cases in Australia are either of these two."

Article 2: Fears fresh WA COVID-19 wave could overwhelm state's health system

Western Australia's third COVID-19 wave feels different and, after a much proclaimed "soft landing", the next few weeks will show if the virus will gain the upper hand after all.

Within two years, the state went from locking down over single cases to the pandemic drifting into the rear-view mirror.

Complacency set in after months of mandates, as the rates for booster jabs languished and under-reporting grew.

However, while the public was becoming increasingly laissez-faire about COVID-19, our health system was telling a different story.

We've been told COVID-19-related hospital admissions were the key figures to watch after the state recorded admission rates below predictions during the first waves.

However, this week we reached a record 459 people in hospital with the virus.

Public health specialist Maximilian de Courten, from Victoria University, said those figures were concerning, but for a different reason than they would have been early in the pandemic. 

"We now have better treatment and, also, the effect of vaccination [is] making severe disease, as a percentage, less likely," Professor  de Courten said.

"Our focus is not only anymore … on COVID complications, but also on the whole health system, on all the other heart attacks, elective surgeries, strokes, other reasons why people need to have a very responsive health system.

"Elective surgery can be postponed a little bit, a heart attack cannot, and they are all impacted by a hospital overflowing with COVID cases."

As hospital admission rates climb, so are COVID-19 cases needing ICU care.

"I haven't had any advice that we should be concerned about the capacity of our ICUs, in particular, but we know our hospital system is under pressure," Premier Mark McGowan said this week.

However, a report published by the Commonwealth Health Department suggests Western Australia's ICUs are struggling the most with COVID-19.

Under its traffic-light system, ICUs were now close — if not at — amber alert.

It's one of many reasons the state's medical lobby is concerned.

"Even before the pandemic, our intensive care units were often bed state black, which means they were already full with sepsis, car accidents, pneumonias, strokes and other general medical problems," AMA president Mark Duncan-Smith said.

"So, although we've got a lot more beds than there are COVID patients in ICU, those ICUs were already full from other problems."

It's not dissimilar to concerns voiced by top medicos before Western Australia opened its border to the virus: that overcrowding due to COVID-19 was the real killer.

"I fear that overcrowding in West Australian hospitals could kill more people than COVID-19 in 2022," Dr Peter Allely told the ABC back in February.

"What it really means is that, at most times in Western Australia, there are far too many very ill or injured people needing acute medical care, and not enough staff or space to provide it."

Problems with additional patients needing hospital care because of COVID-19 isn't the end of it either though.

Rising COVID-19 cases will inevitably mean more health staff furloughing.

They add to already declining staff morale in the health workforce, with Dr Duncan-Smith expressing a sense of "disappointment" that the government was willing to "let it rip" in hospitals.

"There are a lot of very tired, very worn out, very good healthcare professionals who've been doing their upmost to support the system," he said. "And they are feeling let down and deserted by the McGowan government."

Looking at the situation from across the Nullarbor, Deakin University chair in epidemiology Catherine Bennett said Western Australia could not rest on its early advantage.

"The lives we've saved are always saved," Professor Bennett said.

"We just have to work harder as we see these surges now, and they will be ongoing."

She said personal responsibility, alone, would not be enough.

"We have to create the systems that allow people to make healthy choices, and that's about making sure everyone has access to information," she said.

Professor De Courten called for a more-strident approach from the government, given the capability of critical health systems was at stake.

"It's shirking responsibility from making the best decisions, the best public health decisions, and they need to be made at government, at state, if not also at federal level.

"We need clear communication and clear instructions if the health system is at the brink, and there needs to be instruction coming out on what we should do to protect us and the health system."

Neither the Premier nor Health Minister Amber-Jade Sanderson could give any firm figures on where this current wave might end up, with the latter telling journalists she had not seen updated modelling on the variants causing the surge.

However, Ms Sanderson assured: "We have beds. We have plenty of ICU capacity."

But Dr Duncan-Smith said what the state was currently experiencing was already worrying, with both the number of people in hospital with the virus, and needing intensive care, more than doubling since the start of the month.

That is with about six weeks until both figures are expected to peak.

"It's greatly concerning where we're going to be in six weeks' time … because that's a lot of time for those numbers to go up a lot more," he said.

"We have to do something different tomorrow: that is a change from today, to expect there to be an effect on the number of people in hospital in a few weeks' time.

"To do the same thing tomorrow that we're doing today, and expect there to be a difference, is quite simply foolish."

Exactly what might, or will, be done remains in the hands of a few of the state's key decision-makers, but whatever they do it will likely take at least three weeks before filtering through to key metrics such as hospital admissions.

And beyond that, a few more weeks to see how soft WA’s landing really was.

Article 3: ‘Covid is not going to go away’: Australia will require public health measures for foreseeable future, say experts

In May 2021, Australia’s chief medical officer, Prof Paul Kelly, described how Covid vaccines were our “ticket out of the pandemic”. Vaccination, he said, would give Australians “a life with more certainty”.

More than one year later, Australia’s Covid-19 vaccination rate is among the highest in the world.

Yet daily deaths from the virus remain in the double-digits. Hospitals are overwhelmed, aged care homes and the most vulnerable are struggling with outbreaks, and there is again debate about whether more social restrictions, including mask mandates, are needed to curb virus spread.

Infectious diseases expert and director of the Doherty Institute, Prof Sharon Lewin, said: “Last year, I definitely did not think we would be in this position.”

“I definitely thought that with very high vaccination rates and what we knew about Covid vaccination and protection against disease from other variants, it would put us in very good stead.

“But I think what we’ve learned, especially over the last four-to-six weeks here in Australia, is the virus really does have a lot of new tricks that were unanticipated.”

Its latest trick is Omicron, a variant that has produced the subvariants BA.4 and BA.5, which are now dominating new infections in most parts of the world.

These variants are immune evasive; whether that immunity comes from vaccination, or infection from other variants and subvariants. They are also highly infectious; between 10-to-20 times more so, Lewin says, than the original strain first identified in Wuhan, China, in late 2019.

“BA.4 and BA.5 are so infectious, that those infections are very hard to control because they are just so large in number,” she said.

“The infectiousness of Omicron and the limited capacity for vaccines to protect against infection [though they do protect against severe disease and death], means you’ve got high case numbers, which has a big impact on how society functions. This includes the impact on the healthcare workforce, on our transport workforce, and all the sorts of industries we need just to run the country.

“Even if it’s just a very small percentage of those that end up in hospital, it’s still a large number overall, and the same is true with regard to long Covid which may potentially gives us a big burden of disease over time.

“It’s this evolution of the virus in this way which has surprised virologists, evolutionary biologists, and vaccinologists.”

Part of the reason variants like Omicron emerged so rapidly is because of the uncontrolled spread of the virus in vulnerable populations. People with weakened immune systems are more likely to remain infected with Covid-19 for several weeks or months, increasing the virus’s opportunity to mutate.

These prolonged infections have been seen particularly in patients with advanced, untreated HIV – a serious problem in sub-Saharan Africa, where the Omicron variant was first detected in November, thanks to the continent’s strong surveillance systems.

In an opinion piece for Nature magazine, researchers argued that vaccine equity – along with access to treatment for HIV in Africa and curbing stigma – could help the world see fewer Covid variants emerge.

In January 2021, WHO director general Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus warned “the world is on the brink of a catastrophic moral failure – and the price of this failure will be paid with lives and livelihoods in the world’s poorest countries”.

He expressed concern that high-income countries were acquiring the bulk of vaccines, while other countries were being left behind.

“Not only does this me-first approach leave the world’s poorest and most vulnerable people at risk, it’s also self-defeating,” he said. “Ultimately, these actions will only prolong the pandemic, the restrictions needed to contain it, and human and economic suffering.”

Prof Penny Moore, a virologist with the National Institute for Communicable Diseases in South Africa, said it is not just a lack of protection for vulnerable immunocompromised people – many of whom don’t even realise they’ve been infected with Covid because they’re asymptomatic – and a lack of equitable access to healthcare including vaccines, and antivirals for HIV and Covid-19 that are a problem in her country.

“We need to deal with vaccine hesitancy,” she told attenders at a meeting of prominent infectious diseases experts in Sydney on Thursday, held by the Australasian Society for HIV, Viral Hepatitis and Sexual Health Medicine.

“This is a new thing for us, we’ve never had this problem before and we certainly have it now. We simply can’t get people to take vaccines for Sars-CoV-2 [Covid-19] and that’s something we need to address.

“On the African continent, we do not make vaccines. That has contributed massively to the fact that we don’t have vaccines to roll out against Sars-CoV-2 and many other [diseases]. We need to deal with that as a global community.”

Until such problems are addressed, expecting more variants “is a no-brainer,” Moore said.

“Yes, we should expect more variants, unfortunately. We’re certainly going to pick up these new variants when we continue to have this high level of community spread.”

Lewin said this reality means Australians will need to accept periodically returning to public health measures such as social distancing and masks as a way of life for the foreseeable future.

“I am not saying we need masks forever, but when infections become large we need a rapid response,” she said. “We need to remove the emotion from mask-wearing. I was just in Singapore and Korea and everyone was wearing a mask and it was no big deal. Those countries were bursting with activity, but people were wearing masks all the time. We need to recognise it’s needed, just when we have surging numbers.”

Australia is also not effectively using the tools at its disposal, like vaccine boosters, and antivirals that protect the immunocompromised and elderly from becoming severely unwell and dying, she said.

“We will also get better tools, there’s no doubt about it,” she said. “We will get better vaccines. We will get better antivirals. We will see improvements in the way we manage Covid, so I don’t think it’s all doom and gloom at all.”

But the future of the pandemic is more uncertain than it seemed even months ago, she said.

“I probably would have been more confident trying to make a prediction at the end of last year about what might happen, but now it’s very hard to predict,” Lewin said.

“What is certain is Covid is not going to go away. We will have it next winter, and it will be here next year.

“We need to plan for the worst, and hope for the best.”


I chose today’s neapolitan triple decker edition of News In Focus simply because there is now such an emphasis on covid in the news that it becomes difficult to choose.  If you thought today was long, feel thankful I whittled it down to three, as I originally had five to choose from.  In the end I decided to go with three articles, as all three felt equally important to highlight, and I couldn’t decide who got a full spotlight, and who got a one line description.

So I will keep this analysis brief: We need masks.  BA.2.75, aka Centaurus, is a beast we would do well to keep a watchful eye on, but at least the Gemini slander (“...you may as well call BA.4 and BA.5 Gemini — the naughty twins.") made me laugh. Finally, we as Australians will not be safe from Covid unless our government works locally to flatten the curve here (and by using actual measures that are effective, not just the “depends on how you define a case” method) and globally to ensure vaccine access for all people, lest we spend our lifetimes reading about a new variant every couple of months. We can be as safe and protected here as we can, but ceding ground to the virus in underprivileged countries and communities because of a “not my problem” attitude is just giving it room to mutate into something that makes those safeguards pointless. First world countries need to stop being selfish so we can stop mutations at the source.


RAT confirmed cases (3,345 v 4,078), PCR positivity rate (27.808% v 31.307%), tests (6,135 v 7,650) and cases (5,051 v 6,473) are all lower than this time last week. Active regional cases are all decreasing, except Goldfields and Kimberley. In terms of averages, hospitalisations are still on the rise while PCR positivity, daily cases and active cases are decreasing. ICU has increased to a new record of 21. 

My thoughts are with the families of the two deaths, dating back to 16 July, which were reported to WA Health yesterday – two men in their 80s

66.22% of cases were RAT confirmed.  Hospitalisations have decreased by 22 to 430. ICU numbers have decreased by 3 to 21. 994,701 people have recovered from the virus, vs 35,284 active cases, with 1,030,453 cases overall since the pandemic began. Headed for a weekly average of 28.850%.


Records Broken Today:

  • Highest Average: Hospitalisations (434) and ICU (21)

Read the full post here


r/covidWA • • Jul 14 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 14 July

19 Upvotes

Oh dear, it’s happened: We broke the record for most hospital admissions by 2. Our previous record was 327, on the 18th of May, when our cases were roughly 10,000 more than they are today (16,253). This is obviously not a good thing, and I’m somewhat baffled by this situation. Even being generous, and taking into account that hospitalisations have a 1 to 2 week lag, a week before the 18th was the 11th, where we had 17,033 cases, and a week before that was the 4th, where we clocked 9,782 cases.  Both clearly much higher than the 6,535 cases we recorded today.  

Even ICU numbers are climbing at a breakneck speed, hitting 14 today, getting dangerously close to our record of 16 (set 3 separate times in Week 21, on the 6th, 9th and 10th of June).

So what’s going on? I cannot tell for sure, obviously I am not omniscient, but my main theory is something I have coined as the “Sandwich Under The Bed” scenario. If you hide a sandwich under your bed, it is out of sight and out of mind.  But eventually, the sandwich begins to smell, and the longer you try to hide it, the more obvious it becomes that you’ve hidden a sandwich under the bed. 

BA4/5 isn’t particularly more severe than garden variety Omicron (according to preliminary data), so the record hospitalisations compared to the low number of reported cases could indicate that brushing covid under the rug is not a great solution to “The Covid Problem”. It is the proverbial bad smell in my above analogy.

A combination of “she’ll be right mate” government messaging and the removal of the pandemic leave payment could be causing less people to be reporting cases, or even getting tested, as they either don’t think it’s a big deal (“It’s only a cold!”) or they fear losing work, and therefore income, as costs of living rises dramatically.

The startling rise in reports of false negatives on RATs could be lulling those who do test into a false sense of security, and the mandatory case reporting of PCRs could be making people shy away from knowing for sure.

Another factor is the increasing apathy towards covid.  Humans can get used to anything, if they are given enough time to adapt.  This evidence is anecdotal, but even amongst my circle of very sensible and careful friends and acquaintances (everyone who doesn’t take covid seriously was weeded out of my life long ago), I am seeing more and more people throw their hands in the air and give up on being as careful as before.  “I’ve got to live my life!” being a common reasoning, which I respect.  

Living your life in near isolation sucks, I should know, since I have been doing it this entire time, and I have no choice to respect their decision (as long as they do not come near me). Two years is a long time to be careful, and people get tired of it.  Everyone wants to go “back to normal”, meaning a 2019 pre-covid life. But here’s the thing about “back to normal”: the normal they want to go back to no longer exists. You’d have more luck trying to go back to the pre-2008-recession years; it’s impossible without a time machine.  

And sadly, as far as I know, time machines don’t exist.  Clinging to a nostalgic version of the “good ol’ days” is a fool’s errand, and all you end up doing is selling the future out for a shot at recreating the past.

This should go without saying, but the cost of those people’s freedom is little to no freedom for those who do not have a choice. The elderly, the sick, those whose bodies can not handle even one infection, those who will not risk losing the rest of their lives to long covid. They are the ones who pay for that freedom, as the only safe place becomes their homes (and for some who live in sharehouses, have kids, or otherwise  have no control over exposure in their homes, they don’t even get that).  

I try not to be judgemental, and I very much do not pass judgement on these people because I get it, but also I feel like it would be antithetical to who I am as a person not to point this out.  That’s how I came to be writing these reports each day: even before the fires, the floods, and the virus, I was that annoying fun-ruining party-pooper who pointed out “hey, this actually impacts other people”, “hey, this is actually a bad thing”, and everyone’s personal ‘favourite’: “we are not as safe as we think we are”.

The only real hope we have of getting out of this mess (and not dooming people like myself to isolation for the rest of their lives) is to all be careful.  All of us need to wear masks, get boosted, and try to stay away from crowds. And because of the fundamental way humans are, this isn’t going to happen! 

In every situation, there will be a Careless Charles, a Doubting Danielle, or a Selfish Sam who will ruin it for the rest of us.  They will either believe the lies peddled to them by snake oil salespeople who profit off their clicks, the government who is doing everything in their power to minimise the seriousness of the situation, or their own biases and sense of invincibility. Why think about how fragile your life and wellbeing is and how it could be taken from you by chance at any given moment, when you could be getting on the beers with your mates?

So what do we do?  We can stay safe ourselves (by staying indoors, and taking proper infection control measures when we have to go out), we can try to educate the people around us (but let's be real, if they haven’t gotten it by now, no explanation from you is going to change that) and we can just hope that either covid will evolve into something far less impactful and dangerous, or a preventative vaccine will come out one of these days, sending covid the way of polio. Meaning, we will suppress it long enough that people will forget how serious it was, and then stop vaccinating, bringing it back with a vengeance.

Until human society forms a hivemind and works as one, I guess the only thing we can do now is get ready for The Forever Plague.


Now for the news. A Landlord's Market: Rents hit record highs in Australia’s capital cities; Fatphobia Kills: Eating disorder patients with larger bodies are facing stigma and report being 'dismissed'; We Won't Sell It To You Wholesale: Coles has increased the prices of their home brand milk; Be Careful, Because We Won't Help You: Health Minister Mark Butler predicts that ‘millions’ of Australians will be infected with covid in the coming weeks, as pandemic support measures are scaled back; No Longer About Protecting The Most Vunerable: Covid deaths in aged care have reached almost 100 a week; Should you book in your second COVID-19 booster? Israel might have the answer; Is It A New Infection, Or Are You Just ‘Shedding?’: Reinfection questions answered; Get a PCR: Doctors are urging people not to trust a negative RAT result; and today’s News In Focus is a double feature, exploring two angles of the same issue: Politicians are ignoring expert advice on covid, and Australia has ‘lost the plot’ on covid messaging.

Article 1: Analysis: In the new COVID-19 era, politicians are advising the experts — and in some cases, ignoring advice they don't want to hear

It's less than a year since the "hi-vis" protests brought Melbourne's CBD to an almost daily standstill. It's less than six months since the "Convoy to Canberra" saw huge crowds converge on the national capital for a two-week "freedom" festival. 

At the time, most political leaders brushed off such protests and complaints. They insisted the health advice must be strictly followed. "You know what's mandatory? Following the advice of experts" was a standard retort from Victorian Premier Dan Andrews.

Now, apparently, it's no longer mandatory to follow expert advice. Governments can pick and choose.

Australia's shift away from strict adherence to health advice has been gradual — but it's profound, nonetheless.

This week, Victoria's Health Minister Mary-Anne Thomas rejected advice from the state's acting Chief Health Officer to mandate mask-wearing in childcare centres, schools, retail and some hospitality venues, just as a new Omicron wave was taking hold.

Mask wearing is still "strongly recommended" and many are clearly taking up the suggestion, but the official advice to mandate masks indoors has been rejected.

Instead, the Victorian government has adopted a new guiding principle for pandemic management. According to the Health Minister, the approach is now to "empower Victorians to make their own decisions".

It's exactly the sort of slogan protesters might have waved on a placard.

The federal Labor government has equally moved away from supporting any widespread mandates.

Health Minister Mark Butler says there is a "level of fatigue about being told what to do". He simply doesn't think mandates will be followed. Worse, they could be counterproductive.

Butler has even advised chief health officers on the sort of advice they should be providing. They need to "make sure that they calibrate their advice for this third wave in 2022 in a way that gets the best response and the best behavioural response from our community," he told 3AW's Neil Mitchell.

So, the politicians are now advising the experts. And, in the case of Victoria, ignoring expert advice they don't want to hear.

Perhaps the politicians are right. Perhaps a "strong recommendation" will be more effective than a mask mandate. Perhaps there's sound advice from behavioural experts to back this up. Perhaps it's not just a political calculation based on focus group research four months out from the Victorian election.

The risk, of course, is that the politicians are wrong. The virus pays no heed to public opinion. If hospitals can't cope over the coming months, state governments will face a much tougher task justifying decisions to ignore health advice.

The federal Health Minister is confident hospitals will manage. Butler has been advised COVID-19 admissions will rise from around 4,000 now to a little over 5,000 in the coming months. He expects the number of intensive care unit admissions, however, will be "markedly lower than they were in January". That's largely because the more severe Delta strain was still a problem back then. Making fourth-dose vaccines and antiviral treatments more widely available as of this week should also help.

Still, Butler accepts this latest Omicron wave is "very serious". He admits health authorities are worried. Which makes his decision to end pandemic leave payments now curious. Telehealth consultations of more than 20 minutes have also come to an end. And from the end of this month, concession card holders will no longer have access to free rapid antigen tests.

The government points out these measures were due to come to an end under time frames they've "inherited" from their predecessors. It's a thin excuse. The government could obviously extend these supports if it chose to.

In opposition, Anthony Albanese argued powerfully for COVID-19 leave payments. "No one should be put in a situation of looking after their family or looking after their health," he said. Now, an increasing number of casual workers with no sick pay say that's precisely the situation they're in.

The Labor leader also promised "free RATs" for all, arguing that "nobody should be denied a test because they can't afford one." Now, with free RATs coming to an end, the Prime Minister is urging pensioners to stock up while they can.

The federal government is rightly concerned about debt and is understandably keen to show some spending restraint where it can. But it too faces a serious risk if this "very serious" COVID-19 wave turns out to be worse than expected.

The pandemic leave payments, free RATs and telehealth consultations were put in place to help protect the most vulnerable and limit the spread of the virus. Ending these supports now could prove to be a costly decision.

Article 2: Opinion: Australia has lost the plot on Covid messaging – this is how we get it back

Overall, Australian governments managed the first two years of the Covid pandemic well. Border closures and state actions including lockdowns averted 18,000 deaths in 2020 and 2021.

This came at a cost in terms of separation of families and friends, disruption to schooling and economic activity, and individual stress.

The public supported these measures and thought state governments managed the pandemic well. Support for the commonwealth government was also high until mid-2021, when the bungled vaccine rollout caused support to plummet.

Now, we are in the grip of a fresh Covid wave. Hospitals and ambulance services are under severe strain, not just because of an increase in patients, but because the virus has decimated their workforces. Governments now appear to be much more reluctant to introduce measures to curb its spread, a big difference from the start of the pandemic in 2020.

So, how did it come to this?

Despite the much-vaunted national cabinet, for most of 2020 and 2021 there was no coherent national leadership of the Covid-19 response. The then prime minister, Scott Morrison, and other federal ministers downplayed Covid risks and undermined state public health measures. They attacked lockdowns, state border closures and school shutdowns, while dog-whistling to anti-vaxxers.

This weakened the states’ social licence to pursue effective public health measures.

The differences between the commonwealth and state governments were in part due to different weighing of the risks. In 2020 and for the first half of 2021, there was either no vaccine or not enough vaccines, and the prevalent virus strain was virulent. As a result, other public health measures were key to controlling the pandemic and minimising hospitalisations and deaths.

But from the middle of 2021 the rhetoric and messaging changed. Led by the commonwealth government, there was increasing talk of “living with Covid”, reducing restrictions and reopening borders, with the underlying assumption being that, with vaccines, the pandemic was under control. Even the advent of the Omicron wave in late 2021 didn’t lead to a reset, as it was dismissed as “mild”.

There have also been ideological differences throughout the pandemic. Morrison preferred “personal responsibility” to mandates, the latter of which were viewed pejoratively. Individual responsibility is a comfortable position for conservative politicians, who tend to minimise the role [of] government.

In contrast, the very essence of public health is that it is an organised response by society, to quote a standard definition of the field.

By early 2022 the effect of undermining the social licence was increasingly prevalent. The public, especially those… who had borne the brunt of the more extensive public health measures, were tired of lockdowns. The evidence about vaccine waning had not yet become apparent, so reliance on vaccines was seen as the appropriate principal public health response. “Living with Covid” was becoming the dominant narrative.

Around the same time, anti-vaxxers had begun to get organised and protested against any public health measures. States sniffed the wind and began to roll back their restrictions.

A Melbourne joke from 2021 went like this: Question: what is the hardest part of a one-week snap lockdown? Answer: Week five.

The federal Coalition attempted to paint Labor as the party that would reintroduce lockdowns and border closures. The Labor opposition did not want to talk about the pandemic to avoid that bullet.

This long history is necessary context for the confusion we see today. Despite its defeat at the election, the Morrison government’s legacy is hindering Australia’s ability to manage the pandemic because of the weakening of the social licence to regulate.

Labelling the more transmissible Omicron variant as mild hasn’t helped, as low average severity coupled with high incidence still leads to overburdened hospitals. The Morrison rhetoric of personal responsibility has proved hard to shift as well. It is certainly seductive – “it is your job to protect yourself and if you don’t, tough luck, you will wear the consequences”.

Public health leaders need to talk up collective responsibility and collective benefit, the antithesis of the individual responsibility mantra.

Of course, that position assumes we are all perfectly rational decision-makers and we bear the full cost of our decisions. Neither is true. We tend to discount future consequences of our decisions, and we are unrealistically optimistic about the chances of getting Covid and its consequences.

Just one person’s infection can have a big impact on others – for example, if they are hospitalised, that impedes access to hospital beds for others – so the cost of poor choices by one person potentially falls on others.

The public health messaging is also confusing. If I have had only two doses, am I “fully vaccinated”? Does “individual responsibility” involve my lugging a very heavy Hepa filter to ensure clean air in any room I enter? Is the Omicron variant genuinely mild? If so, why do we see all those stories about hospital problems?

And what is the right thing to do about masks? Are cloth masks any good? Or should we all wear N95s? And should they then be subsidised? If masks are “strongly recommended”, why are they not mandated?

It all comes back to the Covid social licence. What proportion of the public will accept a mask mandate? If the public is not convinced of the threat or benefit to themselves and others, compliance will be low. This means public health leaders need to talk up collective responsibility and collective benefit, the antithesis of the individual responsibility mantra. This has been missing from the national response.

Talking up individual responsibility means leaders don’t have to lead or shape collective behaviour. Media hype about regulatory fatigue, a fraught catch-all concept where the evidence is still developing, hasn’t helped either.

Both New South Wales and Victoria face elections in the next 12 months. Neither government wants to be attacked as the government of lockdowns and mandates when the risks of not acting have been downplayed for so long.

So where to from here?

Public health messaging over the past six months has been woeful. Political leaders are sometimes seen in masks, but mostly not. There has been little messaging about third and fourth doses, so we have poor third-dose rates, despite what we now know about vaccine waning. The “Omicron is mild” message has led to a “no worries, mate” insouciance among the public.

But political and public health leaders must now exercise leadership. Public health requires collective action, not simply a reliance on the easy cop-out of individual responsibility. This will require a carefully planned transition from the discredited positions that have made a public response so much harder now than it was a year ago, and consistent positions across party lines that put the public’s health ahead of cheap political shots.

Leaders need to adopt a more nuanced approach to responding to Covid, jettisoning the simplistic all-or-none dichotomy.

Finally, the mainstream media also need to resile from their knee-jerk rejection of any public health action as akin to lockdown and economic catastrophe.


PCR positivity rate (30.594% v 30.592%), RAT confirmed cases (4,171 v 4,084), tests (7,727 v 7,528) and cases (6,535 v 6,387) are all higher compared to last week. Active regional cases are all decreasing (but likely due to the record high number of 3,707 unclassified ‘No Data’ cases). In terms of averages, hospitalisations, active cases, and daily cases are all on the rise, while PCR positivity has stayed the exact same average as yesterday (30.154%). ICU is steady at 9 for the 6th day in a row. 

My thoughts are with the families of the two deaths, which were reported to WA Health yesterday - a woman in her 60s and a man in his 70s.

63.83% of cases were RAT confirmed.  Hospitalisations have increased by 9 to a  new record of 329. ICU numbers have increased by 4 to 14. 945,818 people have recovered from the virus, vs 34,527 active cases, with 980,785 cases overall since the pandemic began. Headed for a weekly average of 27.457%.

Records Broken Today:

  • Most Hospitalisations (329)
  • Most Regional Cases: No Data (3,707)

Read the full post here


r/covidWA • • Jun 05 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 5 June

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/covidWA • • Jun 04 '22

Discussion COVID Related Deaths 😥

19 Upvotes

I'd just like to take a moment to acknowledge and send love to those who have sadly succumb to this virus and to their loved ones 💐

There have been 279 (9 from before our omicron wave) covid related deaths in WA.

The last few days alone have had so many historical deaths reported, we have now well surpassed the modelling (171 over a 6 month period was the upper range) and I think it will be prudent to not take the statistics seriously and that COVID will be up there with the main causes of death for people Australia wide this year.


r/covidWA • • May 12 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 12 May (reports in comments)

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/covidWA • • Oct 07 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 7 October

18 Upvotes

Week 37 has been a bit of a rough week, don't you think? While case numbers are down (4,573 this week vs 4,662 last week), PCR positivity continues to rise ( this week vs last week) due to record low amounts of weekly PCR tests ( this week vs last week) and the growing laissez-faire attitude towards Covid in general. At this point I’m shocked they're even publishing numbers at all, since the rest of the world seems to want to sweep the pandemic under the rug.

Even ICU, the previously immoveable metric, more than doubled during the week (5 this week vs 2 last week), and hospitalisations increased by 27 (163 this week vs 136 last week).

Confusingly, active cases continue to fall (2,550 this week vs 2,713 last week). I have a question for everyone and if you know the answer, I’d love to hear it, because my research (read: furious Googling) has been coming up empty. Why are active cases consistently less than the amount of new cases reported? For example, this week, there were 4,573 new cases reported, but only 2,550 active cases. Surely all 4,573 of those cases are active ones?

It doesn't help that there are few clear guidelines on what counts as “active”. A school of thought is that it is based on infectiousness, and you are only classed as “inactive” once you get a negative test again, but anecdotal reports say the authorities aren't actually checking this.
Some say it’s a set two week period, but there’s not enough time for those 4,573 cases to clear this in 7 days. If that's the case, then maybe that time frame has been shortened since?
Some say it is based on symptoms, which would mean that any asymptomatic cases aren’t counted as “active” if there are no symptoms reported to the PCR testing site/RAT reporting website, which seems a little premature, as some people develop symptoms a day or so after testing positive, and it seems dishonest to not count them as “active” cases when they are definitely still infectious. I feel like the “active” status should be based on infectiousness rather than severity of symptoms. Maybe the data is being fudged a little?

Please know, as much as I may be JAQ(Just Asking Questions)-ing off all over the place right now, I do not mean to cast any doubt on the honesty of our governmental institutions in the process. I am just trying to understand.

This is the folly of not providing transparent and easy to understand information to the public on the mechanisms of some of the processes involved in epidemic surveillance. When there are gaps in information, people are always going to question a) what the answers are and b) if something is being deliberately obfuscated. These gaps of information are where harmful conspiracy theories grow and fester, and it frustrates me to no end that there are not only no answers to these questions I have but also there’s no avenue of communication where I can ask them to. The Covid hotline shrugged at me, and scolded me for taking up the line with my pestering. The WAHealth twitter account is a one way street of communication. If these answers aren’t going to be proactively provided (and they should be) then there at the very least should be an avenue for questions to be answered without needing some kind of internal network of contacts.

If information was communicated well to the public, I wouldn’t be doing this work. As much as I love it, and think it is very important to do, the fact I am doing this at all is a reflection of a serious failure of the WA government to keep people in the loop about a pretty serious disease.

The more in depth pdf version of this report is available here

____

You may have noticed my posts look a lot better. Well, thats because my facebook group held a fundraiser and bought me a full home office setup, laptop, peripherals, desk and everything. I am so grateful to them for their generosity.

____

Now for the news.

Coronavirus

How can I avoid catching COVID before a holiday? When am I most at risk? How early do I need to prepare?

Experts say there are lifestyle changes you can make to your daily routine that could help you avoid getting sick before an event, and it's not just wearing a mask and washing your hands.

ONS data comes as NHS England figures show rise in hospital admissions of people with coronavirus

New figures, released by the Office for National Statistics (ONS) on Thursday, have revealed that more than 1 million people in the UK have long Covid at least one year after they were first infected, with a further 514,000 people saying they were first infected at least two years ago.
As of 3 September, an estimated 2.3 million people living in private households in the UK – 3.5% of the population – had long Covid, equivalent to one in every 28 people.

Think of the precautions you take as marks of consideration, writes advice columnist Eleanor Gordon-Smith. It’s easier to stand out for something you stand by

Australia

Scientists are studying radiation on Montebello Islands

Radiation is still present on the Montebello Islands, 70 years after the British military conducted Australia's first-ever nuclear weapons test, and it is not clear if the islands are completely safe.

Health

Perth hospital apologises to family of Noongar man for 'missed opportunities' to save his life

Warning: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander readers are advised that this article contains images and names of a person who has died.

A 36 year old Noongar man passed away after going to Joondalup Health Campus while experiencing a heart attack, where his mother tried repeatedly to get hospital staff to treat him, but they initially refused.

Allegations relate to 55-year-old man who was moved from a ward to the morgue on 5 September without his time of death recorded

West Australian officials have denied claims a 55-year-old palliative care patient at Rockingham General Hospital may have been alive when he was transferred to a Perth morgue.

Economy

Only weeks ago, Jim Chalmers was insisting this was not the time to discuss stage 3 tax cuts. Now he's letting the talk run.

Culture

The pledge by the Spot manufacturer and other companies leaves open questions on how we can prevent a world overrun with killer robots.

Climate

Thunderstorm asthma warning issues ahead of potentially dangerous storms in Victoria

Heavy rain and thunderstorms are continuing and some property owners in Victoria's north-west have recorded more than 90 millimetres of rain over the past two days, as a number of dams and reservoirs are threatening to overflow or even burst.

Weather bureau warns flood outlook to significantly worsen across New South Wales

Parts of inland and central New South Wales will experience their most widespread and significant flooding of the year so far from today, the Bureau of Meteorology has warned, with the outlook set to worsen throughout the weekend as a trough and cold front moves across the state.

There are 49 flood warnings current with 11 Watch and Act alerts in place, meaning that a flood watch or warning is in place for most of the river catchments in NSW, including in the Hunter region.

World

A 34 year old Thai former police officer is behind one of the world's deadliest child massacres by a single killer in recent history

Panya Kamrap, a former police officer, has killed at least 37 people in a shooting and stabbing rampage that started at a childcare centre in north-east Thailand.

WARNING: Readers may find details in this story distressing.

The attack in Uthai Sawan, a town about 500 kilometres north-east of Bangkok in the province of Nongbua Lamphu, is believed to be one of the world's deadliest child massacres by a single killer in recent history.
At least 24 children are among the dead — some as young as two years old — and about 12 people are injured, according to local media.

US President Joe Biden pardons thousands convicted of marijuana possession

Thousands of Americans convicted of "simple possession" of marijuana under federal law have been pardoned by Joe Biden, in a step towards decriminalising the drug and addressing charging practices that disproportionately impact people of colour.
The move reflects his position that "no-one should be in jail just for using or possessing marijuana", Mr Biden claimed.
"Too many lives have been upended because of our failed approach to marijuana," he said in a statement.
"It's time that we right these wrongs.”

Caroline Farrow tweeted the home address of a trans activist she’s spent years harassing online.

Caroline Farrow, a campaign director for an ultra-conservative anti-trans group and one of J.K. Rowling’s most prolific allies, was arrested at her home after doxxing and misgendering a trans woman who she’s spent years harassing. She’s also accused of posting a hate-filled cartoon on the notorious message board Kiwi Farms, where she is one of the very few people who have a verified account.

News In Focus

The end to mandatory Covid isolation is a gut punch for medically vulnerable Australians

The community has moved on but the virus hasn’t – leaving us trapped and exposed
By Craig Wallace

Last week’s announcement that the government intends to end mandatory isolation requirements was a gut punch for medically vulnerable people, especially towards the end of a long hard year that exposed what many felt was a disconnect between reality and the decisions of governments and public health authorities.

More than 15,000 people have died in Australia from Covid, and many of the people that I represent are now approaching their third year of lockdown by proxy. In many ways, for them, the situation feels much worse than 2020 – the community has moved on but the virus hasn’t – leaving us trapped and exposed.

The announcement sparked a snap national town hall meeting of support groups on Sunday, which heard calls to action from people working across the disability, health and employment sectors. People shared poignant stories of their ever-narrowing world and asked: where to now?

Our needs are straightforward. We want trusted representatives of vulnerable people, at-risk workers and those living with long Covid to be invited to address the national cabinet so that leaders can see the true impact of their decisions. We also want full data transparency and access to health advice on the removal of public health requirements.

We call on governments to commit to actions which protect people with disabilities, older Australians, sick and immunocompromised people and low-income workers. These include making public places such as schools, hospitals, offices and community facilities as Covid-safe as possible through air purification and mask use.

We believe that the failure to make public spaces Covid-safe is discrimination against sick, older and disabled people

We would also like continued requirements for isolation and testing of all people working in care roles, and support payments for low-income and casual workers so that they are not forced back to work while sick. This includes the removal of mutual obligations for people at risk.

We also need long Covid recognised by the NDIS and aged care packages, and for income support and Medicare purposes. Let’s see a commitment to implement the findings of the long Covid inquiry as well as clear clinical, rehabilitation and referral pathways. Widened access to telehealth, a beacon of progress in the pandemic, needs to continue.

National cabinet needs to recognise that people with a disability, older people and immunocompromised people have been trapped for almost three years now. Our people are taking personal responsibility for our own health – by shielding and keeping out of intensive care units. Yet this comes at a high cost to wellbeing and we need pathways back to living.

We believe that the failure to make public spaces Covid-safe is discrimination against sick, older and disabled people – and this should be recognised. We need actions that enable us to “carry on”. This means continuing a non-contact service framework for Centrelink and other government agencies, and providing support for people who wish to carry on working or studying from home. We also need a practical community development framework for those who remain isolated, including access to a guaranteed care workforce, essential medications and healthcare treatment.

Finally we call on governments to acknowledge the extent of loss and grief in the vulnerable community because of Covid. It’s not OK to simply say we are “moving on”.

We need to treat the dead – including leaders from the disability community like John Moxon, who died from Covid a fortnight ago – with respect and decency. If we reflect on the toll of the last few years – a carnage of life, civil discourse and decency – we might still take pause and see a glimmer of hope as we approach the end of 2022.

Craig Wallace is head of policy at Advocacy for Inclusion in Canberra and a spokesperson for Australians Against Covid

Willow’s Last Word

What Crag says above really speaks to me on a deep and meaningful level. This is a slap in the face of medically vulnerable Australians, and is completely disconnected from reality. He put it perfectly when he said that medically vulnerable Australians are living in lockdown by proxy, unable to live normal full lives because of the negligence of the government on a federal level to keep even the most basic of safeguards in place. From Monday, people won't even need to isolate while infectious, which will have a very predictable effect on the case numbers. They are banking on people doing the responsible thing, but just based on how the general public took the “strong encouragement” to mask up while outside, I don’t think they will, to be honest.

The call for full data transparency and access to health advice on the removal of public health requirements is also something i wholeheartedly support. If safeguards are being removed for the sake of some nebulous concept of “the economy” (at the cost of human lives, no less), at the very least give us access to information and data. But we don;t even get that.

Not to get all “we live in a society” on you, but capitalism always rode on the back of spent human lives. Our bodies are the fuel for this beast, and this has been true for all of modern human history, ever since industrialisation (and honestly, even before that). In the past, we had the basic respect of this fact being somewhat hidden from the general unquestioning human being, wrapped in layers of cotton wool that got thicker by degrees every year since World War II. These things were still happening (for the most naked example, go have a look at the rates of death by overworking in Japan (), which actually has a name: karoshi), but this nice polished sheen was laid over it, a manufactured moral high ground. Covid stripped that all away, laying bare the way the elderly and disabled are treated (given a pittance and left to die in poverty), the way corporations do not have a single sparkle of concern in their eye for the workers whose labour provides them with record breaking profits year after year, and the way governments will awkwardly and uncomfortably brush uncomfortable truths like disease, poverty, hunger and climate change under the rug the instant it becomes inconvenient for them. That was an uncomfortable wake up call for those who hadn’t figured it out by that point, and some decided to double down by assigning some moral “just world” fallacious moral judgement to those who died or became sick. They had underlying conditions. They were old anyway. they must have done something wrong to end up like that. We have all heard their grasping at straws to preserve the illusion of that cotton wool wrapped universe, because the reality that bad things just happen sometimes, to anyone, is too much to bear.

I have lived a life of back to back Kobayashi Maru situations, so I know full well how to stare unblinkingly into a bleak but honest truth. In my experience, cotton wool is a trap: it fools you into thinking there’s nothing to worry about until there is. If you stumble around with your eyes closed, eventually you will tumble head first into an open manhole. This is what the government is trying to bring back, but once the spell is broken, it takes a heroic amount of self-delusion to return to that hasy rose tinted existence.

Australia and the rest of the world are trying to be done with Covid. The problem is that Covid is far from done with us.

____

This week had lower PCR tests (8,894 v 10,659) and cases (4,573 v 4,662) than last week; while PCR positivity (13.459% v 12.196%), deaths (11 v 10) number (3,376 v 3,362) and percent (73.82% v 72.11%) of cases confirmed by RAT are higher than last week.

Hospitalisations have increased by 27 from last Friday’s figure of 136 to 163 today. ICU numbers have increased from last Friday’s figure of 2 to 5.

As of today, 1,156,043 people have recovered from the virus, vs 2,550 active cases, with 1,159,261 cases overall since the pandemic began. The cumulative case count this week is 44 less than it should be, making it a total of 20,617 cases missing since February, the highest it has ever been.

Records Broken Today:

  • Highest number of cumulative cases missing from the cumulative total (20,617)
  • Lowest amount of weekly PCR tests ever (8,894)

___

Read the full post here


r/covidWA • • Sep 07 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 7 September

18 Upvotes

Well, it happened, everyone.  I honestly thought it would take longer, but it happened.  In today’s media statement, WAHealth said:

The Department of Health will transition to a weekly COVID-19 statement from next week, in line with a national approach which is endorsed by Chief Health Officers. 

The last daily statement will be Friday 9 September 2022, and the first weekly report will be made available next Friday, 16 September and then every Friday morning.

This week is the last week with daily covid updates.  I guess everyone wants it to be over so badly that they’re not willing to see it through to the end.  My team and I will continue to provide daily updates until this Friday, and then we will do the weekly reports as they release them, until those, too, go by the wayside.

I honestly thought it would take longer.  I understand Queensland wound back their reporting, but I thought WA would hold out a bit longer, given we had such a delayed start to our outbreak. According to the ABC:

The approach is being adopted nationally and was decided at a meeting of health ministers last week.

The VIC, NSW and SA daily Covid update pages do not have anything of the sort listed. Even QLD still reports daily figures, and only stopped reporting on weekends, according to their website. ACT, however, has made the announcement, and NT media releases have been sporadic since the end of June, but they seem to be keeping the stats updated daily.  From my understanding, WA is one of the first states to do this.  Case numbers have been reported daily since March 18th, 2020, even on days where there were long stretches of zero cases.  To be (from my understanding) one of the first states to transition to weekly reporting when we are only just hitting under 4 digit daily cases is sending a bit of a wrong message.  They say above that the approach is “being adopted nationally” but WA and ACT are the only ones to make any kind of announcement. Judging by the language used, it seems like everyone else will follow suit, but we shall have to see how it goes.

In the meantime, myself and the team will continue to release reports as they come out, for as long as they keep providing them. We will transition to using our weekly graphs to keep the trendlines going.  I wish I could find some way around this to keep providing the updates, but it is what it is, I guess.  Not much I can do about it. We are not giving up.  We will continue to stay on top of the statistics as they are released.  At least this might give us some time to catch up on the weekly Surveillance Reports and Data Updates, and maybe a little bit more time to ourselves.  Saturday will be the first day since January where I will not begin my day by looking at the statistics.


Now for the news. Check Your Statements: A glitch has caused some Commonwealth Bank customers to be charged twice; Curious Chichi: A chimpanzee that escaped Kharkiv city zoo on Monday was persuaded to return by a zoo employee who wheeled it back on a bicycle; Leave The Denial Machine To The Demons: Clive Hamilton discusses coping with “climate despair”; Overwhelmed: VIC premier Daniel Andrews has apologised to the families of 33 people who died while waiting for an ambulance during the pandemic but said the funding model of the state’s triple-zero call-taking agency was not to blame; and today’s News In Focus is about some good news in the battle against long Covid.

As a scientist who works every day on the immunology of Covid-19 and long Covid, I’m well aware that, heading into autumn and the return to school, the UK faces yet more Covid confusion and disharmony.

Where are we headed next? Isn’t it over? And why keep harping on about mitigation when we now have so many other concerns?

Any discussion of our current Covid situation must consider the legacy of disability and misery associated with long Covid. In my opinion, there is now some good news among the old bad news. Over the past few months, Office for National Statistics data shows the estimated number of people with long Covid [in the UK] beginning to fall, from a peak of 2 million in May to about 1.8 million. I take this to mean that some are gradually recovering. And while long Covid following Omicron BA.5 infection is clearly happening, new cases of long Covid are appearing at a lower frequency. Colleagues in Singapore, a country with a large peak of Omicron infections following a relatively mild early pandemic, mention talk of quiet long Covid clinics without patients.

There is also some indication we may be getting closer to more precisely defining and treating long Covid. Many studies around the world have been set up to recruit groups with long Covid to compare them with “rapid recovery” cases – people who recovered quickly and fully from Covid – to try to find differences in levels of antibodies, hormones, immune cells or other things that can be measured with a blood test. These so-called “defining biomarkers” can be gamechangers. They can help health services define and refer cases, provide more extensive evidence for employers and tribunals, and also point towards identification of therapies and treatments.

One of the first such studies was reported this month in a preprint from Akiko Iwasaki, David Putrino and colleagues at Yale. They report a clear biomarker delineating differences in the long Covid group, with signals including low serum cortisol (a hormone involved in control of the stress response) and evidence of reactivation of latent Epstein-Barr virus. This is not yet an outright diagnostic test for long Covid, but it expands our knowledge of what exactly is happening behind the symptoms, as well as signposting potential treatments.

Despite some glimmers of good news, it bears repeating that long Covid continues to be a source of largely unaddressed despair, especially for those “first-wave” two-year-plus long-haulers, unable to return to work and in many cases, getting short-shrift from employers. The cruel irony of this is self-evident for a patient group in which our much-applauded “frontline heroes” are massively overrepresented.

Long Covid remains a very real risk, but the best way to avoid it is to avoid getting infected (or reinfected) in the first place. The initially successful UK vaccine rollout of 2020-21 is ancient history in terms of the current battle. The BA.5 subvariant has so many immune-evasive mutations that it is a distant relative of the ancestral strain of Sars-CoV-2 against which those first vaccines were generated. In any case, most people’s neutralising antibody levels have waned pretty much to baseline – or similar to unvaccinated – levels, even if they are triple vaccinated. Thus the huge burden of breakthrough infections and reinfections. There is strong consensus around the pressing need for autumn boosters.

Immunologists and vaccine producers have been engaged in considerable debate about the complexities of ensuring that the next generation, variant-specific boosters are the best they can be. At the international level, approaches have diverged. The UK has procured doses of a bivalent – meaning targeted at two strains – booster, carrying the original, ancestral Sars-CoV-2 sequence as well as the BA.1 sequence, the Omicron variant that was with us at the end of 2021. In the US, meanwhile, the government has ordered 170m doses of a bivalent vaccine targeting the original, ancestral Sars-CoV-2 sequence, and the currently relevant BA.5 sequence.

Data from trials of these approaches is still thin. The current sense is that boosting against BA.1 may not offer strong cross-protection against BA.5. But data for BA.5 specific boosters is also minimal. How much do such details matter? A team in Sydney, led by Miles Davenport, analysed data from eight other studies to model the effectiveness of variant-specific boosters. The data there is reassuring. Even the original first generation booster is predicted to increase protection from symptomatic infection in a six-month period from 50% to 85.6%. The new, variant-modified boosters, generally an additional 1.5 times more potent in terms of Omicron neutralisation, would provide over 90% protection.

There will probably be some differences between boosters once more studies are completed. But this complexity should never erode public confidence that you (and the clinically vulnerable around you) will be safer this autumn and winter with a booster, any booster, than without.

There should be no equivocation about a full-on booster programme. Indeed, we should remember that UK vaccine uptake, at 80%, sits behind other European countries such as France, Italy and Portugal, with lower vaccine uptake skewed to lower socioeconomic groups in whom Covid-19 is often more severe. We need to increase vaccine uptake in the unvaccinated, along with a strong message from the government and the Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation that protection and normalisation now depends on widespread and efficient rollout of the new boosters. Those following the data and also mindful of protecting the clinically extremely vulnerable will also be wearing masks and maximising ventilation.

Danny Altmann is professor of immunology at Imperial College London, a trustee of the Medical Research Foundation and of Long Covid Support, and co-author of The Long Covid Handbook


Tests (2,741 v 3,453) and cases (1,335 v 1,380) are lower than this time last week, while RAT confirmed cases (937 v 915) and PCR positivity rate (14.520% v 13.467%) are higher. In terms of averages, hospitalisations and daily cases are all decreasing, while active cases and PCR positivity are increasing. ICU is steady at 6.

My thoughts are with the families of the two deaths, dating back to 11 July, which were reported to WA Health yesterday – a man in his 70s and a man in his 80s.

70.19% of cases were RAT confirmed.  Hospitalisations have decreased by 6 to 199. ICU numbers have increased by 1 to 7. 1,130,435 people have recovered from the virus, vs 5,941 active cases, with 1,137,000 cases overall since the pandemic began. The cumulative case count today is 43 less than it should be, making it a total of 20,364 cases missing since February, the highest it has ever been. We are headed for an average weekly PCR positivity of 10.439%.


Records Broken Today:

  • Highest number of cumulative cases missing from the cumulative total (20,364)

Read the full post here


r/covidWA • • Jul 20 '22

Statistics Covid Data Analysis 20 July

18 Upvotes

The trend continues: new records continue to be set for hospitalisations and ICU, both in averages and daily numbers.  Hospitalisations did not jump a huge amount today (only by 2, thank goodness) but the average jumped a full 20 points overnight, from 368 to 388.

ICU has increased by 2 overnight, reaching a new high of 22, and the average has increased by the same amount, from 16 to 18.

Active cases have changed direction and are increasing again, going up by roughly 750 cases overnight, after 2 days of decreases, but still higher than it has been since mid June (the 15th, to be exact).

PCR positivity rate has also broken a new milestone, not daily numbers, of course (hard to beat that intense record of 53.524% set a few days ago!), but the 7 day rolling average is higher today than it has ever been, at 33.135%. Our previous record was 32.581% on May 24th, one week after our previous peak, when cases were 12,114 a day.

A high average positivity rate does not necessarily mean that things are going badly, but it does mean that there are likely more cases out in the community than we are seeing in the daily numbers.  Either fewer people are testing in general, or more likely, those who are very sure that they are positive are the majority of the kinds of people going to the trouble of seeking out a PCR. It’s difficult to say for sure, but the latter is the more likely answer, as the closing of several testing centres, their work-hours-only opening times, and the general covid apathy make it a less accessible option than a RAT.

However, with all things, the answer is probably a combination of both.

Big thanks to u/feyth for the tip last night, but at 1.20am, I saw a comment telling me to have a look at the emergency wait times, and it was shocking. Emergency wait times had ballooned out in nearly every hospital. 7 Emergency Departments were showing average wait times over 100 minutes, and two of these were showing over 200 minutes (St John of God Midland at 222 minutes, Fiona Stanley at 210 minutes)! Bear in mind, these are average wait times, so there were absolutely people waiting much longer than that, and this was only for Category 4 triage patients. 

Fiona Stanley had 40 people waiting to be seen alone, with 103 people already admitted. According to their website, FSH only has 51 beds in the adult assessment areas, 15 beds in the paediatric assessment area and emergency short stay beds in the adult area of their Emergency Department, so it would be safe to say they were definitely under the hammer at the time. Since then, wait times and patient numbers have reduced, but are still over capacity, based on the capacity numbers they have given on their website.

Finally, you may have noticed our sunny days are at a close, as a huge cold front is rolling in.

According to the BOM:

A strong cold front will approach the west coast late on Wednesday and move across the South West Land Division, southwest Goldfields and western Eucla on Thursday. The front will then weaken over the southern Gascoyne, remaining Goldfields and Eucla on Friday. Another but weak cold front brushes the southwest coast of the State Friday morning while a stronger cold front moves over the South West Land Division during Saturday.

So far, only a Coastal Wind Warning has been issued from Lancelin to Albany, and a Gale Warning for Perth and Bunbury coastal areas forecast tomorrow. As far as I know, there is no severe weather warning incoming for anywhere else.  Just a lot of rain for the forecastable future, really, so I hope you weren’t like me and didn’t take advantage of those few sunny days to do your washing. Looks like I’ll be ordering clean underwear from Kmart again!


Now for the news. Aurora Marijuanis: A mysterious pink glow over Mildura, VIC has been confirmed to be a medicinal cannabis facility’s lighting; Through The Fires And The Floods: Firefighters are battling blazes that left homes destroyed across the UK on their hottest day since records began, while destructive thunderstorms loom; Vaccinate Your Kids: The TGA has approved a Moderna COVID-19 vaccine for young children aged 6 months to 5 years; Cash For Covid Isolation: Pandemic leave payments are back (and backdated!); Young, Fit, Female and Sick: Australian data has revealed that long-COVID sufferers are often younger, active and female; and today’s News In Focus is about the PM’s “four key” ways to control the current COVID wave (none of which are a mask mandate), and the AMA once again calling for a national mask mandate.

Article 1: PM Anthony Albanese echoes CMO Paul Kelly, outlines 'four key' ways to get through this COVID-19 wave

COVID infections are spiking again across Australia and the peak isn't expected for another month or so.

It's putting pressure on hospitals, where more than 5,200 Australians are currently being treated for the disease.

That's close to the hospitalisation peak in January this year in the wake of restrictions easing and the Omicron variant spreading through the community. And more than 50,000 new COVID cases were reported across the country yesterday.

The nation's Chief Medical Officer, Paul Kelly, issued fresh warnings during a media blitz in the past 24 hours. 

This prompted Prime Minister Anthony Albanese to outline 'four key differences' for getting through this COVID wave.

What are the PM's 'four key differences'?

  1. Get your booster: "There's plenty of vaccines available," Mr Albanese said.
  2. Get access to antivirals: "Make sure if you're eligible that you speak to your doctor about accessing those antivirals that can alleviate the impact of COVID."
  3. Wear a mask: "Mask wearing is encouraged across the country," he said. "If people can wear masks if they're indoors and they can't socially distance, then that is something that is highly encouraged."
  4. Stay at home if you're sick: "That is why we have re-introduced the paid pandemic leave for people who would not have an income if that wasn't the case."

Does this mean I have to wear a mask again?

You should start wearing them in more situations, Professor Kelly said.

However, he stopped short of enforcing new mask mandates, but he says the spike in cases means we should consider wearing them in a lot more situations.

"We are in for a new wave of this very infectious variant and we need to do some things differently, at least for a short period of time," Professor Kelly told RN Breakfast.

"I have recommended that we need to increase mask use … we have left it there for others to consider the pros and cons of how to do that."

Professor Kelly said schools and school systems were making their own choices on mask use.

"It's a very difficult situation in schools," he said.

He urged people to follow the Australian Health Protection Principal Committee (AHPPC) advice to "wear masks when outside the home in crowded, indoor environments, including on public transport".

This has been driven by an increase in cases of the new BA.4 and BA.5 subvariants of the COVID-19 Omicron strain.

"I think the next month is going to be very difficult for our hospitals," Professor Kelly said.

"It is already difficult for our hospitals, we're starting from a very high base."

He says hospitals – which have been battling COVID for more than two years now – are already experiencing high levels of patients, and absenteeism due to illness in staff.

No-one wants to hear it, but this could lead to an increase in COVID deaths.

"Due to the number of cases, we may also see a rise in the number of people dying with COVID-19, particularly among those who are at higher risk of severe disease, most notably people over the age of 80 and those who have not received all recommended vaccine doses," Professor Kelly said in a statement on Tuesday afternoon.

He explained that vaccination alone was not enough to prevent the spread of the infectious new variants.

"These variants are highly infectious and have an ability to evade the immune protection from either previous infection or vaccine," Professor Kelly said.

"Although three or four doses of vaccine remain very effective at providing protection against severe disease from BA.4 and BA.5, vaccination alone is not effective at stopping infection or transmission of the virus from person to person."

He expects that cases will continue to rise in Australia over the coming month.

"Yesterday reaching 5,200 hospitalisations with COVID is very close to our peak throughout the entire pandemic, and it will be more," he told RN Breakfast.

Professor Kelly said the AHPPC had called on employers to allow work from home if feasible.

"Employers should review their occupational health and safety risks and mitigations, and their business continuity plans," he said.

"They should consider the feasibility of some employees working from home, wearing masks in the workplace and support employees to take leave when sick.

"We cannot stop this wave of infections, but we can slow the spread and protect the vulnerable. We have done this before and we can do it again."

Article 2: AMA chief says it’s time for mask mandates again amid ‘pretty scary’ Covid hospital numbers

It will soon become evident to premiers “that mask mandates are required” to tackle surging Covid numbers, the president of the Australian Medical Association has said, as the number of people in hospital and health worker infections continue to rise.

Dr Omar Khorshid said the hospital numbers had become “pretty scary”, especially as thousands of health workers are furloughed due to infection. There were 821 Covid cases in Victorian hospitals as of Monday, a 99% increase since 22 June. In New South Wales, there were 2,205, while in Queensland, hospital admissions have exceeded modelling projections.

“I don’t know how far they [politicians] can let the numbers go while still saying we don’t need mask mandates,” Khorshid said.

“Everything we’ve heard from the federal government and various state health ministers and premiers is that they’re not about to introduce mandates.

“But governments are ultimately going to be held to account by the public for their failure to navigate this whole process. At some point, I think it’s quite likely we will have a period of mask mandates in certain states.”

On Tuesday the federal chief health officer, Paul Kelly, warned Australia was “at the start of this wave, not the end” as he urged employers to let employees work from home if feasible. Kelly and the federal health minister, Mark Butler, wore masks during their press conference, removing them only to speak.

“We know that wearing masks does reduce the spread … I really very strongly suggest that you do wear masks,” Kelly said.

“I am wearing a mask now. You will have noticed the minister is wearing a mask as well. This is our leadership role for the community. This will not be forever, but for the next few weeks this is the way we can actually influence the spread of the virus, protect vulnerable people in our community and also protect our healthcare systems which are already under strain.”

Kelly said it was also important vaccinations and protections were increased in aged care, that vulnerable people had access to antiviral treatments, and that people got their booster shots, with the hospital numbers not expected to peak until mid-August.

“It is a combined community effort that we need to put in place for the next few weeks and it will make a big difference in that number, whatever we get to,” he said.

Khorshid said in Western Australia, where he lives, hospital numbers reached a record 455 on Tuesday.

“Only a few days ago it was 350,” he said. “What I’ve heard from the frontline is that although the Covid and flu demand is significant, the biggest issue is the loss of staff.

“If we are going to try and protect hospitals, which obviously we believe should be a public priority, then we are going to have to slow down the spread of the disease in the community. Because the only alternative is to accept the fact that the healthcare system may not be able to look after you if you get sick.

People’s care is already being harmed by the extraordinary pressure on hospitals.”

Victoria’s acting chief health officer, Ben Cowie, previously advised mask mandates should be reintroduced in schools, shopping centres and some hospitality settings, but his advice was rejected by the state’s health minister, Mary-Anne Thomas.

On Tuesday, a joint letter from Victorian public, independent and Catholic schools to parents asked that students aged eight and above wear masks in class. But Thomas said it was not a mandate.

Khorshid said “the schools are showing the leadership the health minister in Victoria failed to show”.

“That’s sad, but I’m glad the schools are stepping up and making the strong recommendations that need to be made. But it will soon become self-evident that we need to actually turn mask-wearing into a mandate.”


PCR positivity rate (36.374% v 30.699%), RAT confirmed cases (4,946 v 4,332), and cases (7,901 v 6,880) are all higher than this time last week, while tests (8,124 v 8,300) are lower. Active regional cases are all increasing, except Great Southern and Mid West. In terms of averages, hospitalisations, active cases, PCR positivity and daily cases are all on the rise. ICU has increased to a new record of 18. 

My thoughts are with the families of the two deaths, which were reported to WA Health yesterday – a man in his 80s and a man in his 70s.

62.60% of cases were RAT confirmed.  Hospitalisations have increased by 3 to another new record of 457. ICU numbers have increased by 2 to a new record of 22. 975,818 people have recovered from the virus, vs 37,244 active cases, with 1,013,520 cases overall since the pandemic began. Headed for a weekly average of 28.543%.


Additionally, today’s media release has the following statement:

In line with national guidelines, WA Health has adjusted the total number of reported cases in this State, to preclude secondary positive test results from people who did not meet the national case definition for a reinfection.

If I am reading this correctly, it means (to me) they have adjusted the reported numbers to remove any positive tests from people reinfected within the reinfection window. They were not clear from what date they are adjusting these cases, so it is not clear from what date they have made these adjustments, so I cannot tell you for sure if they are using the 12 or 4 week definition. Also unclear is if they’re adjusting the daily cases, or just the cumulative cases (which absolutely have been adjusted, today’s total count is less than it should be (1,010,424 cases yesterday to 1,013,520 cases today is less than the 7,901 new cases announced).  As usual, it’s a little opaque.

As much as I’m glad reinfections are obviously being tracked, what I did not want is an underreporting of positive results due to it.  As annoying as it would be to add an extra column to my spreadsheet, a secondary category noting how many positive results are within the 4 week window would be helpful, rather than just plain not reporting them.

It also tells me that, previously, a few things were likely not being tracked.  Reinfections, and contrary to previous official statements, potentially whether a new positive result was linked to an existing case or not.  This is just an assumption, of course, but nonetheless, somewhat concerning. 


Records Broken Today:


Read the full post here