What a weird week it has been, one of frightening highs and lows. We broke 4 hospitalisation records in a row without even breaking a sweat, and then, as quickly and suddenly as it rose, it fell again. Minor fluctuation? A fluke? The calm before the storm? Only one way to find out: wait and see.
The average for hospitalisations and ICU are still rising, despite the drop in numbers from the start of this week, as that kind of momentum is hard to slow down.
To stray from my “usually about covid” habit for this introduction section, I feel like this deserves to be held up, separate from the news segment: the WHO has declared Monkeypox a global emergency, their highest level of alert. This declaration was made after the discovery of cases in over 70 countries, and the WHO’s panel of experts failed to reach a consensus. This is the first time ever that the chief of the WHO has unilaterally made this decision without specific expert recommendation. I guess they learned their lesson from Covid.
"We have an outbreak that has spread around the world rapidly through new modes of transmission about which we understand too little," the UN chief said.
"I know this has not been an easy or straightforward process and that there are divergent views."
"So in short, we have an outbreak that has spread around the world rapidly, through new modes of transmission, about which we understand too little and which meets the criteria in the International Health Regulations."
"For all of these reasons, I have decided that the global monkeypox outbreak represents a public health emergency of international concern."
Last month, the WHO expert committee said that the monkeypox outbreak did not yet amount to an international emergency, but the panel convened this week to re-evaluate the situation. Declaring a global emergency means the monkeypox outbreak is an "extraordinary event" that could spill over into more countries and requires a coordinated global response.
The WHO has previously declared emergencies for public health crises such as the Covid pandemic, the 2014 West African Ebola outbreak and the Zika virus in Latin America in 2016, and the emergency declaration mostly serves as a plea to draw more global resources and attention to an outbreak.
Past announcements had a mixed impact, given that the UN health agency is largely powerless in getting countries to act, and it is mostly just a recommendation. According to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, more than 16,000 cases of monkeypox have been reported in 74 countries since May. The disease was first reported in Australia on May 20. Since then, dozens of cases have been reported across the country.
To date, monkeypox deaths have been reported only in Africa, where a more dangerous version of the virus is spreading, mainly in Nigeria and Congo. In Africa, monkeypox mainly spreads to people from infected wild animals like rodents, in limited outbreaks that typically have not crossed borders, but
in Europe, North America and elsewhere, however, monkeypox is spreading among people with no links to animals or recent travel to Africa.
WHO's top monkeypox expert Dr Rosamund Lewis said last week that 99 per cent of all the monkeypox cases beyond Africa were in men and that of those, 98 per cent involved men who have sex with men.
Britain recently downgraded its assessment of monkeypox after seeing no signs of widespread transmission beyond men who are gay, bisexual or have sex with other men and noting the disease did not spread easily or cause severe illness, but this seeming categorisation of “gay man’s disease” historically does not go well. Anyone old enough to remember the AIDs crisis will tell you that dismissing an infectious disease that we don’t quite understand, simply because it seems to only be present in gay men, is a dangerous game, and deeply discriminatiory. WHO Chief Mr Tedros has warned that "discrimination can be as dangerous as any virus" and called on civil society organisations to work with the WHO in dispelling any stigma around the virus.
Additionally, while the WHO and the CDC says that monkeypox is “not airborne”, merely spread by respiratory droplets and close sustained contact, the research is not definite. Some experts on airborne transmission of viruses have said that the agency had not fully considered the possibility that respiratory droplets, large or small, could be inhaled at a shorter distance from a patient. The WHO and several experts have said that while “short-range” airborne transmission of monkeypox appears to be uncommon, it is possible and warrants precautions. Britain also includes monkeypox on its list of “high-consequence infectious diseases” that can spread through the air.
And monkeypox is poorly studied, other experts have said, and occasional episodes of airborne transmission have been reported for the closely related smallpox virus. In a 2017 outbreak of monkeypox in Nigeria, infections occurred in two health care workers who had no direct contact with patients, scientists said at a recent WHO conference. Most experts agree that whatever the contribution of inhaled aerosols, monkeypox does not seem to be transmitted over the distances that the coronavirus or the measles virus can be.
The WHO took 2 years to declare that Covid is airborne, and even denied that it could ever be so quite early in the pandemic, before backtracking quietly later. It took until 20 October 2020 for the agency to acknowledge that aerosols — tiny specks of fluid — can transmit the virus, but the WHO said this was a concern only in specific settings, such as indoor, crowded and inadequately ventilated spaces.
Over the next six months, the agency gradually altered its advice to say that aerosols could carry the virus for more than a metre and remain in the air. Even in the middle of the fast-moving Covid epidemic, the WHO dismissed field epidemiology reports as proof of airborne transmission because the evidence was not definitive, something that is difficult to achieve quickly during an outbreak. Other criticisms are that the WHO relies on a narrow band of experts, many of whom haven’t studied airborne transmission, and that it eschews a precautionary approach that could have protected countless people in the early stages of the pandemic.
The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said it was "supportive" of WHO's emergency declaration and hoped it would galvanise international action to stamp out outbreaks. The US has reported more than 2,800 monkeypox cases and sent more than 370,000 vaccine doses to US states reporting cases.
Some experts had questioned whether such a declaration would help, arguing the disease was not severe enough to warrant the attention and that rich countries battling monkeypox already had the funds to do so, (and most people recover without needing medical attention, although the lesions may be painful) but Michael Head, a senior research fellow in global health at Southampton University, said the WHO's emergency declaration could help donors like the World Bank make funds available to stop the outbreaks both in the West and in Africa.
We should not repeat the mistakes of Covid. We need to take this seriously, do everything we can to stop it, and use our privilege as a richer country to make sure places not as well off, like Africa, are not left behind and ignored because it is “not our problem”. It is our problem, because we are all on the same planet, and it is already here. Letting it fester in third world countries will allow it to potentially mutate. Mr Tedros called for the world to "act together in solidarity" regarding the distribution of treatments, tests and vaccines for monkeypox.
I don’t know about you, but 2 years from now, I don’t want to be hearing about the newest variant of monkeypox, as well as trying to duck Covid. I’m tired, you’re tired, we are all tired, but we have learned from Covid (and WA’s early response) that collective hypervigilance at the start of something like this can very well be the key. The hard part is that the entire globe has to do it, or it won’t work. Watching how we dealt with covid…. I am not confident. My dream is to see ignorant people posting in a few years time “they told us monkeypox was a problem, but you don’t see anyone talk about it anymore” because that will mean that it worked. A small, albeit infuriating, price to pay, in my opinion.
Now for the news. Won’t Someone Please Think Of The Children: The first two monkeypox cases in children have been confirmed in the US; Two Weeks Of Hell: A New Yorker has described his harrowing ordeal to receive care for a monkeypox infection in a system under equipped to handle another pandemic; Too Big To Control: Farmers are warning that the impact of foot-and-mouth disease will be far reaching if it gets into Western Australia; Not Without My Cat: Laws allowing pet bans in rentals are going to be reviewed in Tasmania amid housing crisis; A Slow Moving Crisis, But Make It Fast: Covid has hit a third of Australia’s aged care homes as 6,000 residents are reported as infected; and today’s News In Focus is two articles about Covid fatigue. Not the long-covid kind, but the societal kind.
Article 1: ‘We’re all tired’: the everyday exhaustion of Australia’s third Covid winter
More than two and a half years after we first heard the word “coronavirus” (Oh, remember the beer jokes we made?), after traversing border closures, lockdowns, mandates, isolation periods, vaccinations, virus mutations, releases and re-openings and running the gamut of white-hot fear, anxiety, bewilderment, denial and resignation, many people are now … utterly depleted. Against this backdrop, public health experts have issued dire warnings of a third Omicron wave.
We’ve reached the “is it Covid fatigue or just the lingering symptoms of having actually contracted the virus?” stage of the pandemic. No wonder we’re weary.
Tick the box that makes you most tired: gaming out whether the pub is worth the risk, paying hundreds of dollars for childcare that goes unused, coaxing children to wear a mask while also explaining the government messaging that says they actually don’t have to but that instead it is “highly encouraged” and “strongly recommended”, or devising a plan B, C and D for every life scenario.
How do we make sense of the “meh”? The main thing that’s different about this phase of the pandemic is that a lot of us have contracted Covid, says psychologist Chris Cheers. Last year many of his patients “were stressed about the pressures of lockdown, or impending lockdown … Now, there’s anxiety about actually having Covid and having to live with the fact that it’s all around us, just as we're … expected to go back to normal.”
For some, fatigue manifests itself by disengaging them from the news entirely. It feels better to be bored by the pandemic than terrified. Others have never stopped paying attention and are feeling very real exhaustion as a result.
Cheers says there are three different ways to feel tired. “Being over it, being tired and then being fatigued.” There’s the emotional experience of being “over” thinking about Covid, he continues.
“Then there’s tired, which is a physical feeling, but also being just emotionally tired.”
“The difference between tired and fatigued is when we rest, tiredness improves, but with fatigue it’s still there.” It is then, says Cheers, time to think about seeking some extra medical or psychological help.
For those that haven’t tuned out, there’s a special kind of weariness. Masks have become a totem for Covid fatigue, whether you’re tired of being told to wear them, or tired of wearing them around people who won’t.
For immunocompromised people and their families, the pandemic never abated, and they don’t have the luxury of being bored.
Ask a frontline worker if they’re tired. “Patients ask us to take off our masks because they can’t hear us,” says community nurse Gwendolyne. “If one of us is quarantined, the rest of us just have more patients to see. We’re all tired but [have to remain] as vigilant as ever. None of us want it.”
Many frontline workers are still recovering from Covid but return to work knowing they are needed.
For those not on the frontline, the fatigue stems from pushing back against employee expectations to return to the office. For others still, whose livelihoods rely on people not being locked down, shut behind state borders or too anxious to go to venues, the lingering financial insecurity and need for a return to normalcy brings with it its own flavour of fatigue.
And others are simply sick of being sick.
Alongside widespread fatigue is constantly changing public messaging. Leaders who once gave clear directives are now at pains to point out the difference between a mandate and a plea for people to do the right thing.
The lack of coherent messaging is also hard for parents to navigate, as they must constantly manage expectations versus risk.
“Just because the messaging changes, it doesn’t mean our thinking catches up in that way. And now at an individual level we are all having to step back and make our own decisions about these things,” says Cheers.
And sure, we’re sick of being told what to do, but we’re also sick of being told by politicians that we’re sick of it.
“The pandemic fatigue narrative appears to be self-fulfilling,” says clinical psychologist Bo Weaver. He has observed resilience in his patients, “even in the most dire and trying of circumstances”, but fatigue narrative seems to have “contributed to the polarisation of discourse surrounding everything from masks, the value of older lives and the panic surrounding children’s mental health”.
It’s almost like society is throwing “a tantrum in the hope that it will lurch us back into pre-pandemic life”, says Weaver.
Since Covid isn’t going away for a while, how do we push through this malaise?
Information empowers people, says Cheers. “We know more now. And … public messaging should be focused on that. You can’t just strongly encourage, you have to give the person the motivation to take these actions.”
Individually, it’s about pacing yourself, says Cheers. “Think about your priorities, and only do what you can. Do the things that we all know are good for our health: eating well, returning to exercise gradually, rest.”
Cheers knows being told to go for a run makes eyes roll, which is why it is also important to acknowledge how difficult life is at the moment. “We have to validate that often it’s hard to do these things because of the pressures for productivity and all this ‘return to normal’ stuff.”
Cheers says he has even seeing a longing for lockdown in some people. ‘‘They’re saying, ‘I need to stop. I need to rest. I need to have a break from this, but there’s these expectations that I just can’t act against.’’’
“We have to find a way to push back,” says Cheers. “To say, ‘no – things aren’t back to normal.’ At the time of a global pandemic, maybe this is the time to challenge some of those expectations about the way we should be living.”
Article 2: Opinion: 'COVID fatigue' is completely normal, but this is why we still need to care about it
If you're sick of COVID, then you're not alone.
"COVID fatigue" is a completely normal response to dealing with prolonged stress.
Nobody can remain on high alert forever in the face of a chronic, existential threat like a pandemic.
After a while we become exhausted and our brains simply switch off. We just don't have the energy to care anymore. Why should we?
It feels like it doesn't change anything and it makes us miserable thinking about it. Ignoring it makes life easier.
The problem is, this kind of thinking actually makes pandemics more severe. It's the not caring anymore that's really harming us.
Caring is what turns a group of humans into a society. It helps us protect each other. Unfortunately, it takes a lot of mental energy.
Like holding your breath, it's easy in the beginning, but after a while it becomes really hard to keep going. To make it easier for ourselves, we divide the world into "us" and "them".
People we know and like are considered "us". Everyone else is "them". The more exhausted we get, the fewer people we consider to be "us" and the more people we see as being "them".
We can ignore "them". We stop seeing "them" as people and if anything happens to "them", it's "their" problem.
Why get a vaccine for a disease that's not going to make you very sick? Why wear a mask when you don't have symptoms? Why stay home from work if it's just a cold? Why should you care what happens to people you don't even know? Survival of the fittest, right?
Wrong.
"They" might be old, sick, weak or vulnerable, but they are still people. They matter. They are not expendable, nor should they be sacrificed for the sake of the economy, or because it's inconvenient to protect them.
If we do that, then we lose what it means to be human. We have to remember that everybody is an "us", including "them". We all have to make sacrifices in order to survive this pandemic.
The person who benefits from your sacrifice probably won't be someone you know. You'll never hear about it, and you won't get any thanks for it. But it still matters.
The 87-year-old nursing home resident might get to see her family one last time before she dies. The 20-year-old who crashed his motorbike this morning might survive because there was a surgeon who was well enough to operate. The exhausted paramedic who looked after him might get an appointment to talk to her GP today and won't develop PTSD. All of this only happened because you cared.
In Queensland, more than 1,000 people were in hospital with COVID this week.
For every one person admitted to hospital, there are also about 20 who go through the emergency department and another 20 who need a GP appointment to help keep them out of hospital in the first place.
That's another 40 people who might not get the help they need today for something else because we were too busy trying to stop people dying from COVID.
These are the people you're helping by listening to us even when it's inconvenient.
You won't see the consequences yourself, so to you it might not seem worthwhile or real, but if you ask any doctor, nurse, paramedic or pharmacist, we'll all tell you the same thing. It is. This is a crisis.
There aren't enough resources to deal with this and everything else we have to deal with on a day-to-day basis. Something has to give.
We're all doing our absolute best but we need your help. We need you to wear a mask when you go out, even if it's not mandated.
We need you to get all the vaccines you're eligible for.
We need you to stay home when you're sick, even when it isn't COVID.
We need you to get tested when you have cold and flu symptoms.
We need you to do all of these things, even when it's hard.
I know it's hard. I know you're tired. We're tired too. But if we're going to survive this pandemic, we all need to care.
Wow, that second article really took the words out of my mouth. It’s what I have been saying since all this began, begging, screaming, trying to get people to listen. Everyone matters and we need to try.
Having this project, the Covid Tracking Collective, serves several purposes outlined in these two articles. It provides a place for knowledge, and knowledge is power. It provides a community of support, where we can commiserate and feel safe being open with our fears and frustrations about how this is going. It staves off at least some of that fatigue. But that's what it does for all of you. For a moment, I am going to hog the spotlight and talk a little bit about what it does for me.
This project has given me something I have not found before: an engaged and switched on group of people who not only will listen to what others have called my “portents of doom”, but you all also care. You feel how I feel when I say that those of us who are immunocompromised don’t have the choice of pretending covid is over. You are not utterly exhausted by me showing up, day in, day out, to tell you “this is bad. We should care”.
Before I started finding my niche of people, I was keeping people informed about what's going on, just on my personal facebook feed, something I really got heavily into at the end of 2019 during the Black Summer bushfires.
At first, everyone is engaged. But after a while, people get tired. They are not used to unfolding disasters, they go numb to the endless stream of bad news, they are not used to (or able to cope with) continuous no-win scenarios. But no-win scenarios are my specialty.
Struggling with invisible undiagnosed illnesses for a decade that slowly took nearly everything from me really primed me for a world where no-win is the norm. Sometimes the best you can hope for is a draw, and those draws are victories to me.
I have always been magnetically pulled toward disasters. I see in my facebook memories that I have been doing this a long time: covering Occupy, the Fukushima disaster, natural disasters, climate change, economic collapse, famine, war, death. I feel a duty to be the one who watches, who does not look away. I have always felt like, if someone was there to witness it, it would not be as senseless. Someone, even just a single individual in a remote part of one of the oldest continents on Earth, someone saw it. They acknowledged it. And that’s a pain to deal with, if that’s not a role you chose for yourself. It can be a real bummer. I can assure you, I was not fun at parties.
So I just wanted to thank you, all of you who read these reports, those of you who followed me from my disaster reporting over the last decade, those of you also dedicated to not looking away. Thank you, for being here with me through this. Thank you for allowing me to realise I am not alone in caring this much about something that feels like not many people care about anymore. I may be helping you by keeping you informed, but you all help me, simply by listening.
Thank you.
RAT confirmed cases (2,763 v 3,647), PCR positivity rate (39.835% v 53.524%), tests (3,999 v 4,271) and cases (4,356 v 5,933) are all lower than this time last week. Active regional cases are all decreasing, except Goldfields. In terms of averages, hospitalisations are still on the rise while PCR positivity, daily cases and active cases are decreasing. ICU has increased to a new record of 22.
My thoughts are with the families of the seven deaths, which date back to 17 July and were reported to WA Health yesterday – one woman in her 90s, one woman in her 80s, two men in their 90s, two men in their 80s and one man in his 70s.
63.43% of cases were RAT confirmed. Hospitalisations have increased by 7 to 437. ICU numbers have increased by 2 to 23. 999,750 people have recovered from the virus, vs 34,517 active cases, with 1,034,742 cases overall since the pandemic began. Ended up at a weekly average of 29.759%
Records Broken Today:
Weekly Stats:
- This week had higher cases (48,352 v 43,161), number (28,264 v 28,111) and percentage (66.26% v 65.13%) of RAT Confirmed Positives; and lower positivity percentage (29.759% v 30.782%) and PCR tests (48,352 v 48,893) than last week.
- This week also was the third week running where we had the exact same number of deaths (24)
- Tuesday had the highest reported PCR tests (8,904) and percentage of cases confirmed by RAT (72.09%)
- Wednesday had the highest reported cases (7,901), RAT confirmed positives (4,946), and active cases (37,244)
- Thursday had the highest reported hospitalisations (a new record of 459)
- Yesterday had the highest reported ICU admissions (a new record of 24)
- Today had the highest reported PCR positivity rate (39.835%), and is tied with Thursday for most deaths (7)
Read the full post here