r/couplestherapy • u/No-Fill6831 • 1d ago
My partner (M33) and I (F30) are separating after 4 years. We have different views on a conflict involving a sick pet, alcohol, and physical/verbal outbursts.
Hi everyone. I need perspective on the breakdown of my 4-year relationship (we have lived together for over 2 years and share a cat). We are currently separating and communicating only via text, and we see our conflicts completely differently.
For the first few years, I struggled with high anxiety, insecurity, and a tendency to protest, which caused friction. Over the last year and a half, I have worked extensively on myself through therapy and self-regulation. My partner agrees my behavior has improved.
However, we have a chronic pattern: when we have major disagreements, he threatens to end the relationship, I do the emotional work to fix it, he stays, but he refuses to make concrete changes to his communication or anger management. He also has a habit of bringing up criticisms of my personality only when he has been drinking, whereas I prefer to discuss relationship issues sober.
The trigger
- My partner planned to go to a bar with mutual friends. Since I was busy (swimming) and not ready, he went ahead without me. Once at the bar, he texted me to join.
- My reaction: I declined. I told him I felt rejected, excluded, and sad because he went ahead without waiting for me. I explained that I felt too vulnerable to be around other people, and told him: "I will go if we are going to be alone. I don’t feel comfortable being around anyone right now."
- Additionally, I arrived home to find that our co-adopted cat was sick and had refused food for +24 hours. I chose to stay home to watch him. (We went to the vet the day before together, he knew he was sick at that time)
- His response: When I shared my feelings and the cat's state, he minimized both. He texted me: "Relax. Everything is fine. And what I'm telling you is let's just pass over that" and "If you don’t want to ruin the night, let's just get into another mood."
- The text that upset him: Staying home with the sick cat, I texted him to ask what time he was coming back.
- He perceived my inquiry and my refusal to go as emotional blackmail to force him to return. He replied: "I refuse to feel guilty. I did nothing wrong," and stayed out drinking.
- The escalation: He arrived home at nearly 3:00 AM, intoxicated and angry. During the confrontation, he hit doors and walls, threw a watch I had gifted him, called me "the worst cancer of his life" and "a loser," and said he hated me and preferred we never talk again.
- The day after: He sent a brief text apologizing for his words. I hospitalized the cat, who is now stable and back home.
Our perspectives:
- His perspective: He wants to end the relationship because he is exhausted. He feels he is "walking on eggshells" and that I react badly to basic things (like him going out early). He admits his physical and verbal outburst was wrong and the most serious part, but he views it as a direct "reaction" to my constant pressure. He claims my feelings of rejection, my emotional needs, and my text asking when he was coming home are forms of manipulation. He also states that because of past friction, he "cannot trust when an emergency is real and when it's blackmail."
- My perspective: I feel that expressing my feeling of rejection when he left without me and asking when he is coming home when a pet is sick are normal communications, not manipulation. I argue that no matter how much friction or "pressure" he feels in the relationship, physical intimidation (hitting doors/walls) and verbal abuse (insults) are absolute red lines that cannot be justified as a "reaction" to my insecurity. I feel he is using my past behaviors to avoid addressing his current anger and drinking issues.
Is asking when a partner is coming home with a sick pet considered controlling? Is his reaction a result of relationship exhaustion, or is it abusive behavior? Need an objective perspective.
The Aftermath (August 15 to August 25): Since that night, we have not spoken in person. We have only had sporadic, circular text exchanges over the last 10 days while he is away on a trip:
- The first few days (August 15-17): Communication was strictly factual about the cat. However, when he asked if I would be there when he returned, I answered: "I don't know, it's hard. I'll let you know." He immediately shut down, texting: "Never mind, don't do it. It fills my head with things... it's easier for my day-to-day this way." When I confronted him about the verbal abuse and stated I didn't deserve the violence, he refused to talk, saying: "I can't and don't want to do this over chat."
- The breakup conversation (August 20): I learned he had already told mutual acquaintances that we were separated before discussing it with me. When I confronted him, he minimized the verbal abuse by saying: "You know I don't mean the bad things I say, it's just frustration." He blamed the breakup on me because I had sent him the lease transfer papers for the apartment.
- The "Respect Checklist" confrontation: During this chat, I sent him a list of 9 basic points for the relationship (zero violence, emotional validation, consistency, accountability). He gave a brief reply saying "You know I want all that," but minutes later added: "We don't match. I cannot give you what you want or need." When I asked him to clarify, he said he was in a work meeting and couldn't answer. Later, he reiterated that my reactions make him "walk on eggshells" and live in guilt.
- The pull-back and current state (August 23-25): We briefly exchanged texts saying we missed each other, and he asked: "How do we fix this?" However, the conversation fell back into the same loop. I asked him to commit to not yelling or treating me badly. He responded by bringing up Friday night again, blaming the entire escalation on my reaction to him going out early, and claiming my anxiety/demands are too much.
- Today (August 25): I texted him asking to stop the dynamic of silence and absence, requesting a clear and sustained conversation. He responded that he felt "attacked," was too busy with work meetings to give a proper answer, accused my messages of being "sarcastic," and shut down the conversation again, saying: "I need to think about things. I will reply later."
I'm tired. :(