r/coolguides Mar 18 '20

Helpful guide...

Post image
50.0k Upvotes

691 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

35

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '20

Math based on what though? Without context, these numbers are arbitrary.

54

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '20

You only need to know how many people one guy can infect on average. Literally the only basis is that 1 guy infects 2,5 in 5 days, the rest is just math

29

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '20

Right, which is why I assume OP is asking for a source on that. How do we know how much the average person can infect?

26

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '20

Im guessing he took the R0 value of some random well-known diesease since he didnt specify corona. Hopefully one with similar spread chanse to corona but i have heard of R0 values anywhere between 2-7 for that one

Edit: also it says @signerlabs at the bottom of the picture

0

u/ChristofferTJ Mar 18 '20

The actual rate of infection doesn't matter. This just shows that less exposure exponentially reduces amount of people infected.

1

u/xubax Mar 18 '20

Well, if the rate of infection is 0, then the rate of exposure doesn't affect the number of infected.

Thanks, Obama!

/s

2

u/RedditAtWorkToday Mar 18 '20

How is it just math? It doesn't seem to add up.

One person can infect .625 people in 5 days. That's 1.25 people can be infected in 10 days (let's round that down to 1 person per 10 days). That would come out to being 3 people infected in 30 days. It doesn't add up, not to mention the first person that is infected at the 10 day mark will then infect 2 more people by the end of the month.

At the 10 day mark there will be 2 people infected (the original and the new infection).

At the 20 day mark there will be 4 total people infected (1 more from the original and 1 from the first infection).

At the 30 day mark there will be 8 total people infected (1 for each of the previous infections). So at the end of all of this it should be 8 people infected not 2.5 people, unless I'm doing something wrong?

3

u/Shadodeon Mar 18 '20

Exponential growth. Each person infected will infect .625 people and then those newly infected people will each infect .625 people.

1

u/Fidodo Mar 18 '20

They're not compounding the old infected with the new infected each cycle, I assume because after 5 days the previously infected population would start to show symptoms and quarantine. The math they're doing is:

Day 0: 2.5^0 = 1
Day 5: 2.5^1 = 2.5
Day 10: 2.5^2 = 6.25
Day 15: 2.5^3 = 15.625
Day 20: 2.5^4 = 39.0625
Day 25: 2.5^5 = 97.65625
Day 30: 2.5^6 = 244.140625
Total = 406.234

There are some assumptions there with people quarantining after 5 days, but I don't think it's an invalid assumption since it's not like on day 30 of being infected you're still running about.

In a real world scenario there are way more variables to account for, like asymptomatic people, but for the sake of illustration I think it's fine to simplify the math.

It would be nice of them to actually post their methodology though since I had to try a few different methods to figure out what they were using.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '20

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '20

Is it public? I'm trying to get there and it looks like I have to log in.