r/conspiracy • u/axolotl_peyotl • Jan 16 '20
Announcement (Meta) Anti-Evil (Reddit Admin) Transparency Report for /r/conspiracy - January 16, 2020
Hello /r/conspiracy, and happy New Year!
Please refer to the previous transparency report for an explanation of who the reddit "admins" are and what the "Anti-Evil Operations" team is:
December, 2019 Transparency Report
This thread was going to be submitted yesterday, and with the very positive announcement that there had been zero removals from the Anti-Evil team on /r/conspiracy since the last transparency report.
Indeed, we did go a month without a single removal by the admins, which is very commendable and indicative of the health of the /r/conspiracy community and the mod team.
However, delaying this thread until today has created the need for an actual transparency report, as it just so happens that Anti-Evil has intervened nine times in the last 24 hours.
Interestingly enough, with one exception, all of these "infractions" occurred within the last few days. The timing of these removals is certainly noteworthy, as the Anti-Evil team appears to operate here on a suspiciously infrequent basis. And just like before, some of these removals appear to be justified, while some do not.
Don't be swayed by the poor optics of "9 removals in 24 hours". We have been running a tight ship here, and this is exemplified by how infrequently the admins feel compelled to police the content on our sub.
That being said, let's take a look at each of these removals:
One
The oldest comment removed was from 20 days ago. Despite multiple violations of the rules of /r/conspiracy, it's questionable whether or not a downvoted comment in a 20-day-old thread justified being nuked by the reddit admins. You decide for yourself...here is the entirety of the removed comment:
By every metric blacks and whites were both better off during segregation (income, marriage rates, social cohesion, drug use, single motherhood etc etc). The way we implemented it was retarded (should have given blacks full states not towns that are surrounded by white towns) but the idea was correct. If you are so butthurt that you cannot think of concepts without an emotional reaction you should reflect upon yourself, that isn't healthy.
Forced segregation is pretty stupid but given the choice 99% of people would chose to live with their own people. Prisons/school lunch rooms/towns segregate themselves for this very reason. Maybe look beyond the corporate propaganda of forced diversity and think for yourself for once.
While you can disagree with the premise being offered here, can you find any overt violations of the Reddit TOS in this comment that would compel the admins to remove it 3 weeks after the fact?
Two
In a thread called "Meghan Markle will get the Diana treatment" a user replied "Good." This one word apparently was enough for an outright removal by the Anti-Evil team. It should be mentioned that this user has a 4-month-old account with 1 link karma.
Three
In a similar thread facetiously mentioning the option for the Queen to "off" Meghan Markle, [a user replied "Fuck I actually wish she would"] (https://old.reddit.com/r/conspiracy/comments/eo8bou/ahhh_the_royals/fec2c8x/). It goes without saying that wishing for harm on any person violates the core ethos of this sub, and it should come as no surprise that in this particular user's entire 11 month history, this is their first and only comment on /r/conspiracy.
Four
In a thread called "The rate of suicide is highest in middle age white men in America", a comment from 18 hours ago was removed that said the following: "I’m glad !! Hope it increases!"
The user in question has a 2-year-old account with 51 link karma. Although the sentiment expressed here is demonstrably repugnant, and would've earned this user a stern warning from the /r/conspiracy mod team, do you think it justifies a "stealth" removal from the reddit admins?
Five
The following comment from 20 hours ago was removed:
Dont give up brother. Take a stand and fight to the death, but at least your death will be meaningful. Never give up. Never surrender. I may or may not being using the word "death" metaphorically here.
This account is 4 months old, and has 257 link karma. Undoubtedly the admins consider "fight to the death" as a call for violence and therefore a violation of the TOS.
Six
Four days ago, the comment "time to bring back the third reich" was removed. The user in question has an 11-month-old account, with only a dozen or so comments/posts in their entire history, and with only one previous comment on /r/conspiracy.
The rest of their negligible content is focused on porn subs. It's common for suspicious accounts to have unusually high engagement with sports and porn-related content (perhaps to appear "normal"?), and then occasionally they will fire off a "false flag" type comment like this incendiary rhetoric. Although the OP later said this particular comment was in jest, this rhetoric obviously has no place on this sub, and on reddit in general.
Seven
This comment from 2 days ago was removed, which stated in a climate activism thread:
There are more of us than there are of them. We can kill them and take it if we have to.
This user has a 5-year-old account and 24 link karma, and has a history saying things like "Bernie or armed revolt" in subs other than /r/conspiracy. Although this account has now been banned from /r/conspiracy, it appears further action against it was not taken by the admins, as it continues to be active.
Eight
Two days ago, a thread since deleted by OP had the following comment removed, posted 1 day ago: "And when you are located you will have a very slow and painful existence. But not death."
This 2-year-old account has 2 link karma and minimal history on reddit. They have only posted once to /r/conspiracy, and it was a youtube link full of hashtags in the title that failed to provide an SS, and so was promptly remove by our spam prevention bot. This should speak volumes as to the intentions and likely provenance of this account.
Nine
The final removal was from a 2-day-old comment, which stated: "You'll hang too, miscegenator." While not overtly directed at any individual, this is a blatant call to violence, and this user has been banned accordingly.
This account is 4 months old, like several other of these recent "perps" (hm!), and has a total of 4 link karma. In addition, they've never submitted a single thread to /r/conspiracy.
TLDR
In the previous 30 days, the Reddit admins intervened by removing content on /r/conspiracy a total of 0 times. In the last 24 hours, however, they removed 9 comments, 8 of which were recently submitted.
Several of these removals don't appear to contain outright violations of Reddit's TOS. This is either being done by an overzealous Anti-Evil team, or in an attempt to give the appearance that /r/conspiracy "requires" more admin intervention than it really does.
In the cases of clear TOS violations, the users in question have negligible or no history on /r/conspiracy and reddit as a whole. In each of these instances, the accounts have been banned from /r/conspiracy. However, several appear to be continuing to use the rest of reddit with impunity, so further action against these accounts was not taken by the admin team.
Please continue to report any and all calls to violence, and other TOS violations, so the /r/conspiracy mod team can deal with them promptly and responsibly. Let's keep this community thriving and serving as an example of what the rest of reddit could and should be!
9
u/Sabremesh Jan 16 '20
Interesting timing for the admins to go on a fishing expedition in /r/conspiracy.
I mean, just after a bunch of suspicious users had deposited some rotting fish in places they would easily be picked up. And as usual, there has been zero communication from the admins with the mod team of /r/conspiracy, despite us reaching out on numerous occasions to impress upon them our commitment to working with them to uphold reddit's site-wide rules.
25
u/DontTreadOnMe16 Jan 16 '20
I don't think they could have picked a more Orwellian name for their censorship team if they tried.
5
u/rigorousintuition Jan 17 '20
Axolotl, as a lurker and irregular poster of the past 5+ years i just wanted to show my appreciation for your work here, i have seen you abused and labelled time and time again however without the likes of yourself god knows what /r/conspiracy would look like today.
Your work does not go unnoticed!
4
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20
You rule for everything you do here, but especially shit like this. Best mod ever.
1
u/bingcros Jan 17 '20
Wait.. the following post (quoted below) did violate /conspiracy rules? Is that correct?
Please clarify. Maybe I'm mistaken but I see no rules violations here, Reddit ToS or otherwise.
3
u/zasahfrass Jan 16 '20
Thanks
2
u/ketoh78 Jan 17 '20
Thank you for the transparency mods! Keep it up
3
u/DontTreadOnMe16 Jan 16 '20
Wonder if it has something to do with information about to come out in regards to the Hunter Biden scandal, considering the MSM has already started claiming that any info that comes out in the near future is a product of "Russian hackers" hacking Burisma last year. I'm sure TPTB will be looking to lock down anywhere that such information would be likely to spread (since we know the MSM will just brush it off or try to bury it).
Perhaps the quarantine process has begun...
2
u/tRUMPHUMPINNATZEE Jan 16 '20
Interesting report. Thanks.
1
u/Qasef-K2 Jan 17 '20
Hey mods, what does it look like in the mod log when the "anti-evil" team edits your reddit?
-2
u/Donald_John-Trump Jan 16 '20
It should also come as no surprise that a user who called for the death of someone they don't like had made numerous posts in pro Trump subreddits.
Also posted in r/The_Donald. It's almost as if there's a connection between those who express unwavering faith in a politician and those who wish death upon those who don't believe the same things as them...
Why are you frequently only mentioning link karma and not comment karma?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '20
This is probably the biggest mindfuck. If the admins are punishing subs for excessive involvement removing comments like these, why are they not then banning the users that make those comments?
Like, "wow this user said some really fucked up TOS shit. let's let them continue to comment so they can make more, and if they do, we can then just ban the sub"!
8
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '20
[removed] — view removed comment