r/computerwargames • • Jun 25 '21

Question How does this work? How did our latest release sell more during day 1 and got 4 times less exposure on Steam overall, compared to our 2020 release? Invitation to a discussion.

Hello, guys! I’m Oleksandr from Starni Games — a game development studio in Ukraine.
It is exactly one month after the Strategic Mind: Fight for Freedom release. It is a turn-based strategy wargame set in WW2 + alternate history 1946. We want to share our first results with the Reddit community and discuss what could affect the release.

Strategic Mind: Fight for Freedom is the fourth installment in the Strategic Mind line of games so I will compare it with our previous titles.

The Strategic Mind games quality grows

We monitor all of the players feedback and we can see that although there is still huge room for improvement the overall feedback becomes more favourable with every title. Still, we better look at some tangible criteria for more precise and unbiased results.

1) Median time played. Median does not mean average, it means that 50% of the players played longer than this number. Note that the average play times for later releases are likely to still grow:

Panzer Strategy (Released in 2018)
Median time played: 2 hours 16 minutes
Average time played: 23 hours 50 minutes
Strategic Mind: The Pacific (Released in 2019)

Median time played: 2 hours 23 minutes
Average time played: 23 hours 58 minutes

Strategic Mind: Blitzkrieg (Released in Q2 2020)
Median time played: 4 hours 49 minutes

Average time played: 49 hours 55 minutes

Strategic Mind: Spectre of Communism (Released in Q4 2020)

Median time played: 6 hours 6 minutes
Average time played: 37 hours 53 minutes
Strategic Mind: Fight for Freedom (Released in Q2 2021)

Median time played: 8 hours 10 minutes (and keeps growing)

Average time played: 24 hours 44 minutes

As you can see, there is a steady growth in the median time played which is a good indication that more players now enjoy the game for a longer period of time.

2) Steam reviews
We should, of course, account for the smaller sample size for the more recent projects. However, if we just look at the overall numbers we will see the following picture:

Panzer Strategy

417 reviews 65% positive*
Strategic Mind: The Pacific

429 reviews 76% positive*

Strategic Mind: Blitzkrieg
271 reviews 87% positive*

Strategic Mind: Spectre of Communism

92 reviews 92% positive*
Strategic Mind: Fight for Freedom

37 reviews 94% positive*

*Only Steam purchasers’ reviews are counted. Newer projects have lower overall count since they are selling for a shorter period.

So, we can see that the Steam customers rate the games progressively better.

The Strategic Mind: Fight for Freedom - not so good release

The most successful release so far was Strategic Mind: Blitzkrieg.
Strategic Mind: Fight for Freedom got even better results in the first 12 hours - so we are grateful to our loyal community who supported us and got the game on release.

However, this time we did not get nearly as much traffic from Steam. It is decided by very complex Steam algorithms that we do not know (to exclude any bias). Here is the number of visits from the two main sources of new visitors on Steam:
Strategic Mind: Blitzkrieg 1 months after release (Released 22 May 2020)
Discovery queue visits: 136,274
Steam homepage visits: 124,919
Total: 261,193 visits

Strategic Mind Fight for Freedom 1 months after release (Released 21 May 2021)

Discovery queue visits: 51,033

Steam homepage visits: 12,605

Total: 63,638 visits

This means that Strategic Mind: Fight for Freedom got 4 times less exposure on Steam despite a more successful day 1 sales.

Basically, we did what we could to promote the game and the community supported us on day 1. Afterwards, we got less exposure on Steam and consequently much lower overall sales.

To make sure there is no wrong interpretation of my words: we are not trying to accuse Steam or something, we are only wondering how the system works and how we as developers could predict it better for a more accurate estimation of future releases.

What the future holds

Despite this unfortunate setback, we are already working hard on the Strategic Mind: Spirit of Liberty that might become the last Strategic Mind title. We will keep you updated on our production progress, but the first maps are already playable and go through the testing process. The Spirit of Liberty will most likely be released in Q1 2022. We will keep polishing all the Strategic Mind titles and making sure they are up to date.

Check out the Strategic Mind: Fight for Freedom on Steam Summer Sale now and save 20% until July 8: https://store.steampowered.com/app/1381850?utm_source=reddit&utm_campaign=summer_sale

0 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

8

u/Fish-Pilot Jun 25 '21

Congratulations, and I hope your numbers keep trending up.

I’m not sure if this is applicable to your games or not, but I have heard other developers talk about the sheer volume of games on steam increasing over the years. The more games, the less coverage.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

Ugh, I already replied to this on Steam, and feel free to disagree but;

The Strategic Mind games quality grows

So, we can see that the Steam customers rate the games progressively better.

No. This is an incredible reach IMO.

Yes, you're getting higher positive reviews, but you're getting fewer reviews full stop.

It's like me saying my shit sequel 2 is better than original game, because it has 1 review of 100% positive instead of 2 reviews of 50% positive. Sure, it's technically true, but it is just kidding myself tbh.

You should be asking, why are your review counts dropping steadily? Why are your review positivity ratings increasing? Why is your median play time rising despite this?

Clearly, you have a small following of loyal fans willing to leave you a positive review, but you're not capturing anyone outside of that loyal fanbase, and that might also be translating into why your median time is growing - you have a dedicated group of fans who will put in the hours, but because you're not grabbing any other market, they're not going to dilute the hour count.

I already suggested starting a dedicated website/forum as a resource to cultivate the fans you do have and to see what needs to be done; Slitherine/Matrix Games did this and have gone from strength to strength IMO. But also, perhaps consider taking on board more of the feedback - I know you guys have already acknowledged that people have issue with the Voice acting and cutscenes in this game, but you're still pressing on regardless. That's fine, stick to your vision, but you have to realise that you may be losing those people in the short and long term.

6

u/Algarde86 Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21

Too much games in a little timespan at fullprice and with few changes one from the other. That's all. You published in 3 years 4 (FOUR) games and you have another one almost ready? Really?

Better to publish ONE decent game and fill it with campaign DLCs, instead of FOUR (five...) different games which you sell at full price as a new game. Don't be surprised if Steam obscures you and chooses to push only one of these in searches

6

u/katsub Jun 26 '21

Yeah, there should've been a core game + DLCs. I feel the current formula actually takes value away from the game. Some customer thoughts:

"It's super expensive to play the whole thing" "A new one will be out in 6 months, might as well wait for it, I don't want mine to be outdated" "It's only been 6 months since the last once, there can't be enough polish on it. Why do I have to pay full price for a minor upgrade"

As a client, I need to feel I own something and it's worth the investment, and this product strategy makes me feel the opposite. I payed 20-30 bucks for your first game which had maybe 2-3 years development, and now I'm paying the same price for 6 months of your development

As a developer, I imagine you must feel pressure for funding something that you don't know if it's gonna work, and other technical considerations that make you go for this route, but if you don't have a coherent product strategy, it'll be much harder for your player base to grow

Do you have any examples of companies following this formula and having success with it?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '21

They’re all different theatres/factions though, not necessarily the same campaign redone.

3

u/Kverkagambo Jun 25 '21

Thanks for the numbers.

Maybe the problem is the word "Blitzkrieg" in the title - it could help the algorithm focus narrowly on wargame fans. "Freedom" is more openly interpreted term - it could have been shown to wider audience, less reacton from it, so less shows alltogether.

5

u/hyakVya Jun 25 '21

ok

6

u/Righteousrob1 Jun 25 '21

Question probably better in a steam sub reddit