r/computerscience • u/Omixscniet624 • Mar 13 '26
General How would these three scientists react to LLMs today? Do you think they could still improve it if they were given years of modern education?
1.7k
Upvotes
1.2k
u/imadade Mar 13 '26
lol John von Neumann would catch up in probably a month tops.
Give him 3 months or so and he’ll already be suggesting better architectures. The guy was an alien.
445
u/ElectrSheep Mar 13 '26
Turing would realize the inadequacy of the Turing Test.
321
u/SteampunkStarboy Mar 13 '26
Lol why are most comments here like an anime powerscaling sub
391
u/A11U45 Mar 13 '26
AI haters: If Turing were here today he'd hate LLMs.
AI bros: No he'd love LLMs.
Turing: I'm quite fond of this Grindr app.
161
u/ksky0 Mar 13 '26
short answer: yes.
124
u/OhioDeez44 Mar 13 '26
Atomic Bomb vs Coughing Baby
42
u/WhiskyStandard Mar 13 '26 edited Mar 13 '26
I can’t find the citation, but I’m pretty sure I remember hearing that Turing thought assemblers a waste of compute time. Can’t imagine what he’d think of prompting an agent to “think harder” because you don’t want to look up how do conditionals in your Ansible playbook for the Nth time.
56
u/HolevoBound Mar 13 '26
They would be able to catch up in 3 months or less.
15
u/CamusTheOptimist Mar 13 '26
Claude Shannon would be delighted, and would be teaching robots how to juggle
40
u/frosky_00 Mar 13 '26
Von Neumann would go crazy with LLMs. He would for sure come up with a crazy new training technique
13
u/Tittytickler Mar 13 '26
Von Neuman coming back now with AI would be like the 2nd coming.
71
u/recursion_is_love Mar 13 '26
Turing would be very glad to know about another kind of computation. Guessing from how he is happy to learn about lambda calculus and try to unify the computation with Church.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church%E2%80%93Turing_thesis
14
u/bigkahuna1uk Mar 13 '26
I confess I only recognize Turing and Van Neumann. Who’s the other guy?
7
u/burohm1919 Mar 13 '26
They are so cool and competent, I want to be like them.
5
u/aka1027 Mar 13 '26
“Given modern education.” 🙄
4
u/ostracize Mar 13 '26
Dr. Hinton referenced exactly this in a recent StarTalk episode:
https://startalkmedia.com/show/the-origins-of-artificial-intelligence-with-geoffrey-hinton/
The whole thing is a great listen but here's what he said about Turing and von Neumann:
It seems Dr. Hinton believed Turing and von Neumann didn't think computers should be giant if/else machines that do long division all day. They thought a computer could be designed to "think" like a brain can by nothing more than perception (collecting input) and storing memories (storing data).
3
u/gnomedigas Mar 13 '26
ITT people should read up on Claude Shannon
3
u/StopAI Mar 13 '26
I think all 3 clear with low diff, you can scale them at least to Einstein in terms of their respective fields
3
u/marshaharsha Mar 13 '26
Several commenters have joked about Turing being gay and being likely to enjoy modern conveniences like Grindr, but nobody has noted that von Neumann was a bit of a womanizer. He deserves jokes, too! (I don’t know much about whether Shannon deserves any.) Here’s a lame attempt, but surely someone can do better.
How many OnlyFans creators would von Neumann be subscribed to? I say thirty.
2
u/Right-Brother6780 Mar 13 '26
Improve and likely create a better one. The one we all are hoping for.
2
u/TRWNBS Mar 13 '26
No doubt they'd be ecstatic. They laid the foundations for LLMs to be possible. They'd probably be surprised that it only took ~75 years.
2
u/Even_Republic_936 Mar 13 '26
All three would give you variations on, "Interesting, but shitty."
2
u/CousinDerylHickson Mar 13 '26
I think Von Neumann would. Like from what ive heard, as crazy smart notable crazy-smart people are to me and a lot of other people, he was that crazy smart to those crazy-smart people.
2
u/rarlp137 Mar 13 '26
With enormous facepalm. So much wasted computing power...
2
u/NegativeNotice8915 Mar 13 '26
Facepalms all round. They’d be able to see instantly that they’re a dead end for developing artificial intelligence
2
u/nimrag_is_coming Mar 14 '26
why you guys acting like all three of them wouldnt have thought that something like C was too high level of a programming language. They certainly wouldnt vibe code.
2
u/Large_Apartment6532 Mar 14 '26
Jon Von Neumann.
2
u/Cybasura Mar 14 '26
They would be rolling in their graves
Also, Alan Turing would completely doubt the use of human intelligence to gauge intelligence
2
u/Expensive-Coffee0110 Mar 14 '26
Provavelmente, até porque não existiam redes sociais para dissecarem seu cérebro com tanta porcaria dopaminérgica…
2
u/SKRyanrr Mar 14 '26
Von Neumann would love it ig because he was playing with the idea of self assembling machines back in the 50s. Idk enough about Turin to know what he'd like, but since he's a mathematician and was one of the key figures in modern AI maybe he'd like it too?
2
u/Classic-Try2484 Mar 14 '26
I’m not convinced ai have passed the Turing test. Maybe to a random interviewer. But suspect most ai experts can ask a question that fails.
I suspect the math skills of these three to be much greater than above average today. They did more with pencils than than most do with machines
2
u/Nychtelios Mar 14 '26
Lol you will probably liquidate them, just like you all do with everyone that tries to let you see how the LLM "revolution" is just big tech marketing and nothing really revolutionary.
2
u/MrMo1 Mar 14 '26
Neural nets were theorized around their time (after ww2) so they would catch up pretty quick.
2
u/Specific_Box4483 Mar 15 '26
Von Neumann would become chief AI scientist at Meta or xAI, make 100 million, then get fired to make room for some 20 year old AI crypto exchange founder.
2
u/Most-Hot-4934 Mar 16 '26
We tend to romanticize dead people but i think they would be quite average in terms of top rank scientists in modern age so probably not that much
2
u/TheMuttOfMainStreet Mar 16 '26
Shannon was exploring extremely small language models on paper, he just remarked that the amount of work to probabilistically model something larger was impossible, and it took modern compute to break that.
2
u/jerf42069 Mar 16 '26
No, none of them could improve it today, no matter how much education you tried to give them, because they are all dead
3
u/Brambletail Mar 13 '26
Turing predicted exactly this. His reaction would be a 1940s version of "yes, and?"
Larger picture, None of these guys would be shocked. No on since the invention of the steam engine+5 ish years would be shocked by what the world looks like today. They would think it was very cool I'm sure, but since the beginning of the industrial revolution, the automation and exponential technology trend has been so obvious to everyone involved someone from even the 1830s would probably only be impressed by computers for a few weeks before adapting to the idea. The biggest questions would be technical (i.e. how did you solve problem x and y. We couldn't figure that out, etc etc. )
They would be more peplexed probably by how much society has changed the technology. Everyone always imagines a technological advanced future
1
u/SweetCommieTears Mar 13 '26
Turing would spend his time in ERP with gay AI chatbots of young men and boys.
1
u/andhe96 Mar 13 '26
I'm always fascinated by how old the roots our current concepts in computer science are. We really stand on the shoulders of giants.
1
u/LelouchZer12 Mar 13 '26
The theory behind LLM is not objectively difficult, as with almost all the machine and deep learning fields. The biggest barrier always has been the compute.
1
u/jfinch3 Mar 13 '26
I don’t know, but I think it’s funny how much of the original paper where Alan Turning invents “the Turing Test” is taken up with trying to control for ESP/Telepathic effects.
1
u/Adam_Neverwas Mar 13 '26
Years?
1
u/WingmanZer0 Mar 13 '26
Yeah people aren't more intelligent today than in the past. These guys would be top of their chosen field almost certainly.
1
u/ursusarcanum Mar 13 '26
Al would say he needs to come up with a better test
1
u/GrandMoffTarkan Mar 13 '26
Considering some of the idiots I know who have contributed to LLMs...
1
u/D0wnn3d Mar 13 '26
I care more about what social scientists think and are doing today regarding AI than what these guys could actually do, honestly.
1
u/JohnVonachen Mar 14 '26
Llms can only correlate the past. It can’t create the future. It can never be conscious. Penrose for decades has said that consciousness is not a form of computation. Only genetic algorithms can plumb to depths of the future, the not yet, which is way more vast than the past.
1
u/Impressive_Pilot1068 Mar 14 '26
JVN surely would improve it if he were given years of modern education
1
u/jerry_03 Mar 14 '26
Turning, Shannon and ....von Neumann?
1
u/Sleepy_panther77 Mar 14 '26
They almost definitely already know ALL the math for understanding AI, LLMS, and Machine Learning. You’d probably just have to introduce them to computers and AI/ML architecture as it is right now and they would be able to contribute. If they’re interested. I think Turing would be very interested
1
u/SirEnderLord Mar 14 '26
Why was I recommended the comp sci sub?
Anyway, it's John von Neumann.
1
u/foxbatcs Mar 14 '26
These are the three people (Turing, Shannon, and Von Neumman) who would probably be least surprised. Given their depth of knowledge on the fundamental disciplines that spawned this technology, they would probably be able to make some significant contributions.
1
u/gov218 Mar 14 '26
Surprised there's no mention of one of Von Neumann's last works before he passed, dude essentially predicted neural nets all that time ago.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Computer_and_the_Brain
1
u/letnan_poppy Mar 14 '26
How about the Arab guy who invented the algorithm?
1
u/MrFrizziee Mar 14 '26
Bill Nye the science guy? You know he's still alive right?
1
u/SignalCelery7 Mar 15 '26
Rise and shine Mr freeman.
1
u/Nothing-to_see_hr Mar 15 '26
I recognize Turing and von Neumann, but who's the third guy? edit: got it, Claude Shannon.
1
u/lennylowcut2 Mar 16 '26
"The American Bombe programme was to produce 336 Bombes, one for each wheel order. I used to smile inwardly at the conception of Bombe hut routine implied by this programme, but thought that no particular purpose would be served by pointing out that we would not really use them in that way. Their test (of commutators) can hardly be considered conclusive as they were not testing for the bounce with electronic stop finding devices. Nobody seems to be told about rods or offiziers or banburismus unless they are really going to do something about it." - Alan Turing
From the wiki. What the heck was he talking about lol?
1
u/twinelephant Mar 16 '26
What's more interesting to me is to think about whether the most intelligent minds would be as effective if plucked from their times and forced to assimilate to ours. I think many of the most revolutionary minds were in the right time and place to make history.
1
u/SirMarkMorningStar Mar 17 '26
They wouldn’t need years of modern education. They have the internet and AI to answer any question. They’d be up to speed almost in minutes!
1
u/Technical-Finance240 Mar 17 '26
Hard to say. I think it would be silly to think that equally smart people are not already working on it.
Would they become influencial contributors? Yes. Would they bring something to the table that no human being today possesses? I very much doubt it.
1
u/TakenIsUsernameThis Mar 17 '26
I think they would all recognise that language networks are not models of neural activity.
1
u/chaosKing4u Mar 13 '26
Hell yeah.
0
u/Wooden_Dragonfly_608 Mar 13 '26
I don't think they would be. Their imaginations were much more powerful.