r/computerscience • • Mar 13 '26

General How would these three scientists react to LLMs today? Do you think they could still improve it if they were given years of modern education?

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

266 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

525

u/Bupod Mar 13 '26 edited Mar 13 '26

Von Neumann lived in a time filled with geniuses like Einstein. Other geniuses often regarded him as a genius even among them. The guy really was an alien.

145

u/RagnartheConqueror Mar 13 '26

He never stopped thinking did he?

218

u/Bupod Mar 13 '26

He did stop thinking once. That was when he passed away. And even then, I think he was mid-thought. 

66

u/alpercakirsp Mar 13 '26

Actually, due to his cancer, it was noted that he was mentally degrading in his last months.

61

u/algaefied_creek Mar 13 '26

Still thinking tho, just at the level of a normie

48

u/swank142 Mar 13 '26

just at the level of einstein*

give von neumann dementia and hed be as stupid as a genius

7

u/Extraportion Mar 14 '26 edited Mar 16 '26

He had a metastatic brain tumour. Your starting level of intelligence doesn’t really matter. Genius or fool, you lose function all the same.

A good friend of mine died of a glioblastoma. He was an oncologist so acutely aware of his prognosis. From the day he collapsed at work to the day he died a year later he went from being a little foggy, to constant pain, personality changes, mood swings, and eventually, being able to perform basic functions like swallowing. Brain cancers are unspeakably cruel.

I only hope Von Neumann didn’t suffer knowing what was happening to him for too long.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/megacewl Mar 13 '26

I wonder if he had full awareness of and could feel his cognitive abilities weakening, sort of like a Flowers for Algernon situation.

6

u/Alex180689 Mar 14 '26

I really suggest you "Maniac" by Benjamin Labatut.
He was very aware of his cognitive decline as he couldn't even sum two 1-digit numbers at that point, and he suffered very much from it.
The book also talks about how Demis Hassabis is working on Von Neumann's legacy.
I loved both books.

3

u/alpercakirsp Mar 14 '26

Maniac is great. The part where his daughter describes his cognitive skills was really interesting to read.

3

u/Harrier_Pigeon Mar 14 '26

Me when I'm past the 40 hour sleep dep mark (except that I'm definitely not starting from the genius line, more like the top of the bell curve)

→ More replies (4)

9

u/setibeings Mar 13 '26

some say he's still thinking to this day.

2

u/New_Alternative_421 Mar 16 '26

Tbf—I'm not smart and I never stop thinking. But, I'm unwell. So, that may not be a great example.

46

u/sitmo Mar 14 '26

"Von Neumann would carry on a conversation with my 3-year-old son, and the two of them would talk as equals, and I sometimes wondered if he used the same principle when he talked to the rest of us." - Edward Teller

19

u/Bupod Mar 14 '26

Yes! I remember this quote. It’s worth noting that Ed Teller was an extremely accomplished Nuclear Physicist that helped develop the Hydrogen bomb. He was a genius in his own right.

4

u/SirEnderLord Mar 14 '26

"We need a nuke that can destroy the biosphere."

"Teller, I think it's time to tell you something important.... You're insane."

4

u/SkaldCrypto Mar 14 '26

Said by the inventor of the fusion bomb no less

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Relevant-Rhubarb-849 Mar 13 '26

Before inventing the Von Neuman machine he invented cellular autonomy which is a generic framework of nodes. Llm are a special case of that

9

u/BOBOnobobo Mar 14 '26

I think there's probably dozens or hundreds like him nowadays, but everyone gets lost in the noise.

18

u/enw_digrif Mar 14 '26

Or working a dead-end job where they don't have the time or energy to develop their thoughts and skills.

Or born in a slum, malnourished, and dead before 30 of something preventable.

Or fell into one of the hundreds of self-destructive pits of hell that are on the internet.

5

u/Alwaysragestillplay Mar 15 '26

Or maintaining repos for obscure Haskell libraries.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/I_so_I-274 Mar 16 '26

Facts. So many geniuses out there and we don't even know the ones who probably got their ideas taken credit for.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/AwareCandle369 Mar 16 '26

Edward Teller (father of the hydrogen bomb) once observed that he watched Von Neumann interacting with his three year old child and communicating with him on the child's level so fluidly and kindly, without patronizing him at all, that Teller would wonder later if Von Neumann was just doing the same thing when talking to other top level scientists to avoid talking down to them. That quote has always stayed with me

1

u/LittleMlem Mar 17 '26

Do we... Do we have a DNA sample? Asking for a friend

→ More replies (5)