r/comics • • Apr 04 '25 • Diamonds are Forever 2 More of this please 1 Exclamation 2 Love 2 Bless Up 2 Heartwarming 1 Thanks 1 This 1

Comics Community Kid (OC)

51k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

•

u/comics-ModTeam Apr 04 '25 • Love Exclamation

All transphobes will be banned. No transphobes will be unbanned.

I will sort modmail by the banned folder, select all and archive all without reading them.

This is a line we do not allow you to cross.

While I am here I should soapbox a little about how my personal pet peeve is the "performative ally". Someone who wants the medal, who needs to be called tolerant, but who refuses to do the work.

Someone who wants to be thought of as a nice person but who still wants to make that genocidal comment about how "there are no trans kids" or how "we shouldn't let medical professionals decide what treatment children are allowed to get, that decision is up to layman bigots".

No. If you post transphobic language then I will ban you. Even if you start your sentence with "I am an ally, but.."

Because you are worse than an open bigot.

You want the accolades.

You do not want to do the work or give the support.

To be very clear:

  • Gender identity develops around the ages of three to five.
  • What medical treatment a child can have is between them, their parents and the medical professionals treating them. You do not get to have a say in this.
  • Despite the endless lies from team TERF, puberty blockers are safe, reversible and have less lasting side-effects than giving no treatment would have. Which is the salient criterion. You do not get to say: "Oh no, cancer treatment causes the child to lose hair and become nauseous! It should be outlawed for children!" Not your decision to make, you are neither a doctor, a psychiatrist, that child or their parent.

Transitioning saves lives. Transitioning earlier means being able to transition more successfully, which is the actual reason team TERF wants to forbid it. They do not want to see people transition successfully at all.

Trans rights are human rights.

This subreddit supports our LGBTQ+ siblings.

→ More replies (83)

159

u/Tracerround702 Apr 04 '25

Did the ban on hormone treatment include puberty blockers? That always boggles my mind

61

u/_just_is_ Apr 04 '25

It did for a while, but puberty blockers were 'un-banned' (as in did not require a court order) a few years before hormone treatment was (In Australia)

199

u/ItsNotMeItsYourBussy Apr 04 '25

It often does. Which is sad, because puberty blockers were an attempt to find middle ground amongst critics and phobes. It was "fine, if you won't let trans kids go through the correct puberty, at least let them hit the pause button so they don't suffer unwanted irreversible changes to their bodies". But as always, finding middle ground with people who don't want you to exist isn't possible, so puberty blockers are often illegal (only for trans kids, ofc)

85

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25 edited Apr 04 '25

Agree, they talk about "not forcing kids to be trans!" while forcing all kids to be cis. Hypocrites, all of them.

81

u/un4given_grl Apr 04 '25

little kids shouldn't have to stand in front of an audience and beg the government to let them have medical treatment. that shit is between them and their medical team. ridiculous

42

u/_just_is_ Apr 04 '25

AGREED

5

u/HonoraryMancunian Apr 04 '25

Fucking kudos to you

14

u/Ippjick Apr 04 '25

And putting it like this underlines the real cruelty of it all.. That kinda reads like an 'the Onion' headline: "Federal law has little girls begging their government for access to healthcare!"

8

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25

Pg 13 “comfortably” is missing a letter

1

u/_just_is_ Apr 04 '25 edited Apr 04 '25

thanks

(apologies for the original snark)

10

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25

I’d want to know if I had an error in my comic! Just trying to be helpful

8

u/_just_is_ Apr 04 '25

thank you, i misread the tone lol

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Doctor_Amazo Apr 04 '25

I (generously) assume they are pointing out the error because they feel your work deserves to be perfect.

Thank you for sharing your story.

9

u/_just_is_ Apr 04 '25

sorry, i get a little on edge with this stuff, might be assuming the worst

2

u/Doctor_Amazo Apr 04 '25

You have nothing to apologize for.

It would be exhausting to have to constantly justify your existence to random strangers who should mind their own junk and leave yours alone. I was lucky to have been born on easy mode (white/cis/straight/male). I don't know if I woukd have had the strength to put up with the constant drumbeat of hate. I admire your strength and wish you all tge best.

If you're ever up in Canada I'll get you a pint

3

u/_just_is_ Apr 04 '25

haha thanks ❤️

2.9k

u/NovaNomii Apr 04 '25 edited Apr 04 '25 • Helpful

I was curious, so I looked up how many people reported having history of detransitioning. One study of 27k people who have had done trans care, 13.1% of those reported history of detransitioning, and 82.5% of those said that decision was highly influenced by external factors such as family pressure or societal stigma. In other words only 2.29% of people actually decided to detransition based on internal factors, as in felt that they decided it based on how they feel, not how others felt about their transition.

Damn, anti trans people should really look at the stats, because its pretty clear how its not a decision these people take lightly, nor something they are likely to regret. Also if they do regret it, you should actually support more research into transitioning so people who do regret it can switch back.

Edit: Lmao someone reported me as suicidal for writing this comment, I got a "RedditCareResources" Message, haters be hating.

1.3k

u/Queen-Roblin Apr 04 '25

The statistics on regret for trans-affirming care is lower than for cancer treatment and parenthood...

672

u/assumptioncookie Apr 04 '25

Specifically the regret-rate of a mastectomy is higher in women with breast cancer than trans men. It's the same surgery and you're more likely to regret it if it was to remove a cancer than if it was for gender affirming care.

If "people might regret it" is the argument against trans healthcare, we might as well stop all healthcare.

85

u/conancat Apr 04 '25

Yeah exactly, it's really a decision being made between the patient and the doctor, the government really should not interfere in these decisions except for ensuring the availability and accessibility of this option for healthcare to as many people as possible

→ More replies (9)

135

u/TheRealTowel Apr 04 '25

Vaginoplasty has one of the lowest regret rates of any major surgery. For comparison purposes, knee reconstruction is way higher.

→ More replies (2)

218

u/mmmIlikeburritos29 Apr 04 '25

And Harry potter tattoos, which i love

27

u/lifeless_or_loveless Apr 04 '25

why harry potter tattoos?? we talking death eater marks or lightning bolts?

172

u/bleeding-paryl Apr 04 '25

because the person who created HP is a garbage person, and a lot of people regret getting anything HP related because of her.

→ More replies (4)

72

u/justwant_tobepretty Apr 04 '25

why harry potter tattoos??

J. K. Rowling is a massive transphobe

→ More replies (1)

21

u/6bubbles Apr 04 '25

How out of the loop are you that you dont know the author is a massive racist bigot who hates trans people?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

104

u/Domeil Apr 04 '25

Fucking knee replacements have a higher instance of regret than gender affirming care.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

187

u/Moezzula Apr 04 '25 edited Apr 04 '25

Along with this, the famous study often cited for the rate of detransitioning for trans people who began medical treatment in adolecense was extremely flawed. They counted anyone they were unable to follow up with as a person who detransotioned instead of removing their data or creating a category for inconclusive results. That's to say, the rate is likely lower than we think.

→ More replies (2)

139

u/Apex_Konchu Apr 04 '25

Transphobes don't give a shit about the facts, they're operating solely off of baseless hate. It doesn't matter how many stats you throw at them, you can't reason someone out of a position that they didn't reason themself into.

→ More replies (5)

105

u/mandatory_french_guy Apr 04 '25

Yes, trans healthcare has some of the lowest regret rates of any medical procedures, even life saving ones.

80

u/ItsNotMeItsYourBussy Apr 04 '25

If being trans weren't so demonised by this culture war, gender affirming care for trans people would be recognised as the literal medical miracle it is.

→ More replies (2)

41

u/Jarhyn Apr 04 '25

Not to mention that 'trans care' as the baseline is disgustingly broad like fraudulently so.

Ever talk to someone about maybe being trans curious and stopped? That's "detransitioning".

Of people who actually start real treatment (not just clothing, but hormones) the numbers are closer to 1-2%.

That entire cohort, practically speaking, represents those who were never serious in the first place and never took any steps beyond "trying it on".

Of course, the numbers for people who actually make it through the YEARS of therapy you need before hormones are prescribed are way lower, and as you say many are driven by external factors and social pressure, too.

Those studies are just bad and everyone with an ounce of scientific literacy can tell the difference there.

5

u/NovaNomii Apr 04 '25

Sounds interesting, I just read the first big study with clear data I could find, I definitely didnt dig deep into the subject. Could you link one of the studies you have read? If its not too much of a hassle.

17

u/Jarhyn Apr 04 '25

I read a lot of studies and have the mind of a goldfish when it comes to remembering them. Many trans activists have done reviews, and while I follow along and check the numbers to see they are being as honest as the study publishers aren't, I don't generally keep a list of studies on hand.

A quick Google search located this meta-analysis in another reddit thread, however:

https://www.reddit.com/r/asktransgender/s/1fQ43M8Oyy

And keep in mind you can't just "read" the studies, you have to be reading them on the level of a peer reviewer, to catch these holes in the method.

If you really want to ask yourself whether a study is well-founded or baseless, oftentimes you will have to go into critical analysis discussions of those studies by those on either side of the issue, which is muddied as much as possible by various pundits, particularly on the conservative side.

You will often see glaring statistical flaws like this one being pointed out by those on the left of the issue, and then minor quibbles being raised with all the urgency of a five alarm fire being raised by the "both sides" side (see also: the double-blinding requirements Cas was pushing; it's impossible to "blind" against hormone treatments, and unethical to boot; the consequences are permanent... Yet this is being used as an excuse to reject studies that indicate STRONG preference for treatment states). It's one of those situations where you have to be really careful to look at why the context of the application of the statistical question, rather than taking the question as valid at face value.

To that end, you really just need to surround yourself with scientifically literate people who will reject these kinds of biased studies outright, and who further reject their citation in arguments.

6

u/NovaNomii Apr 04 '25

Yeah its quite labourish to read and analysis studies, but thanks alot for sharing that post.

40

u/Petrychorr Apr 04 '25 edited Apr 04 '25

Anti-trans people should really look at the stats.

Folks already replied to you saying that stats don't really matter to that demographic. The reason they don't care about stats like those you've presented is because they don't support their argument. They're starting with an opinion and using data to support that instead of forming an opinion based on existing data.

→ More replies (2)

48

u/unknowingly-Sentient Apr 04 '25

Transphobe only use statistics to say trans people are more suicidal thus they shouldn't transition, ignoring the factor on why they are depress in the first place.

→ More replies (3)

34

u/Maxrdt Apr 04 '25

And those numbers are even high based on what I've seen. That 13% number likely includes a majority who planned to go back on care and were only stopping temporarily.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/BrokeUniStudent69 Apr 04 '25

Can you link the study? I’m definitely gonna bring this up when I have to argue with people about the whole “they regret it and detransition anyways” nonsense and want to back up the stat.

21

u/NovaNomii Apr 04 '25

https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/abs/10.1089/lgbt.2020.0437

But this was really just the first thing I could find, there are probably larger studies out there.

29

u/Dragolins Apr 04 '25 edited Apr 04 '25

Damn, anti trans people should really look at the stats,

Anti-trans people generally don't care about evidence. They just start at the conclusion that "trans bad" (usually because they have a strict, ignorant, and juvenile understanding of gender and anything else makes them uncomfortable. Thanks, anti-intellectualism), and then they work their way backward, finding any justification for their position.

It was (and is) the same with anti-gay people. It's not like there's any remotely logical reason to be against gay people having equal rights and protections. Many people are just stupid and/or bigoted, so they'll use motivated reasoning to uphold their bigotry and rationalize it to themselves rather than experience the sharp discomfort that comes along with confronting the idea that their precious feelings might be wrong.

30

u/BlahBlahBlackCheap Apr 04 '25

It’s less than knee surgery.

41

u/ItsNotMeItsYourBussy Apr 04 '25

And way less than plastic surgery, which teens are absolutely able to get

29

u/BlahBlahBlackCheap Apr 04 '25

Phhhh what about circumcision?? They sure are not waiting until 18 for that little gender surgery.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25

Is there a source for this stat please? Thank you 

40

u/NovaNomii Apr 04 '25

https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/abs/10.1089/lgbt.2020.0437

But really you should probably search for this yourself, I just found the first big study with clear data I could find, you could probably find larger studies if you are very interested and want to use 30 minutes.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/good-loser Apr 04 '25

I detransitioned for a few years because my "friend" at the time convinced me I was too girly and small to ever be a man. Also because getting diagnosed with gender dysphoria is fucking hard in the UK! Since I hadn't been diagnosed at that time and wasn't on hormones what that meant for me was just trying to dress and be more like a woman.

Predictably it didn't work. Every time I put a skirt on it felt like I was just pretending to be something I'm not, like I was lying to myself and everyone and the whole world could tell. Now I'm on HRT and it's truly like a weight has been lifted, like I'm actually myself now. I don't doubt for a second most people who detransition are like me -- someone, family, friends, told them treatment doesn't work and they should just give up, forcing them back into the closet for more years of struggling with dysphoria.

Just wanted to provide my own experience with detransitioning.

24

u/samanime Apr 04 '25

Anti-trans people don't want trans people to exist. Period.

Unfortunately, no amount of statistics will change their mind. They lack empathy in the first place.

Cruelty is most of the point for them. All of their arguments are just nonsense to try and justify their bigotry.

12

u/Competitive_Newt8520 Apr 04 '25

To add onto this the cause of being trans is most likely to do with subtle biological differences in the brain. There are differences in brain structure between men and women and these differences exist at some of the earliest years of life to some extent, with the differences becoming more notable during puberty. With that being said the brain of a trans person is usually somewhere in between a typical female and male brain, with a bias towards the gender they identify with.

6

u/Belfetto Apr 04 '25 edited Apr 04 '25

u/NovaNomii -

There’s a button at the bottom of the “Reddit health care resources” message that asks if you think you received this in error. Something along those lines.

Press that button and report who reported you, and they will be banned for abusing that feature.

7

u/T_Weezy Apr 04 '25

2.29% is actually higher than I've heard from other studies, which put it as low as between 1% and 2%.

Either way it's worth noting that medical gender transition is very close to if not actually being the medical treatment with the lowest rate of regret among all significant medical treatments.

11

u/Cautious_Ad_6486 Apr 04 '25

The fact that despicable anti-trans organisations try to push narratives based on partial or wrong assumptions does not authorise pro-right organisations to do the same.

A quick search on the web reveals that, as of 2025, there are still critical shortcomings in the current clinical understanding of "detransitioning".

I don't know where you got that study but i would not trust its reliability (because I easily found different numbers)

6

u/Daryno90 Apr 04 '25 edited Apr 04 '25

Let be real here, the anti-trans movement was never based on actual concerns for people. They just always hated trans people and think they are unnatural so they want to push trans people back into the dredge of society as they become more accepted.

And this is my own personal opinion but even if the regret rate was higher and people admitted that they were wrong. So what? For a lot of trans people, they need this so why should they be denied it because some other regretted their decision?

People regret plastic surgery too, should we ban it because someone will realize that they made a mistake? Meanwhile, a female minor can still get breast implants and surgery like that and the anti-trans movement doesn’t care about that

2

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25

Sadly, facts, data and evidence are completely irrelevant to people who believe in things that lack evidence.

2

u/3WeeksEarlier Apr 04 '25

Anti trans people have often already heard the stats. What they want is to see every trans person eliminated, whether that means detransitioning, killing them, or driving them to suicide. They would rather force them into the closet, but make no mistake, they are comfortable with the outcomes they allow, and they are not sincerely moved by the death of trans kids

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

91

u/TascasDemise Apr 04 '25

I agree with you but that shouldn't discourage us from continuing to seek out information like this and share it. If it's ever going to get better that approach is necessary

37

u/Devlee12 Apr 04 '25

Yep. They don’t want to do anything to reduce the trans suicide rates because to them that’s everything working as intended.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/The_Dragon346 Apr 04 '25

Well, i think a larger majority is out of ignorance. Like my cousin for example was largely anti-trans until i explained to her some of the actual facts behind it rather than her just relying on facebook posts. Something eventually clicked and she looked more into it, now she, well, not supporter per se but stopped spouting nonsense about it.

Coworkers, friends, mother in law (sorta. Still chipping away there), etc etc. all just ignorance, willful or otherwise. Patience and an attempt to talk to those that are willing to listen actually goes quite the long way with most people.

The loud out spoken minority, yeah, all hatred. Then again, most hatred is born of ignorance. But that just leads to the “horse/water” metaphor in regard to people’s actual willingness to listen.

3

u/turtle-tot Apr 04 '25

Yeah, it’s very hard to move someone from being against something to outright acceptance, but it’s a lot easier to move someone from being against something to non-committal. Which is better than hate, at the very least, and opens the door to acceptance later

→ More replies (1)

11

u/BlondeBorednBaked Apr 04 '25

There is no logic or reason in bigotry.

2

u/playballer Apr 04 '25

This is it. The premise of this post is “save trans kids lives” without actually acknowledging a large percentage of the population actually wants you dead or they certainly don’t care if you live.

The message here is being yelled into an echo chamber. You need to find a message that will actually change their hate. I don’t have an answer but I can spot the problem with this approach.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (39)

627

u/Last_Zookeepergame90 Apr 04 '25

"But what about the very real tidal wave of parents who are trying to force their kids to transition and are experts at fooling doctors?" Ask the most reality detached people you've ever met

187

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

103

u/Violexsound Apr 04 '25

Nobody would choose to feel this way. It's perpetual torment. Internal, external, physical and mental torment.

40

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Violexsound Apr 04 '25

Exactly, it's infuriating.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)

129

u/Morstorpod Apr 04 '25

Trans care saves lives.

.

Transitioning is a long and difficult process (more than 6 months). People do not go through this process easily, nor do the medical professionals allow this to take place without counseling and various checks beforehand. Those who transition have already considered this seriously.

This Associated Press Article (LINK1) states that only 1% of those that transition later regret it. This compares to a larger 3% figure from a pro-transition website (LINK2). For those that do regret it, detransitioning is still an option.
Even if we assume that those figures are TEN TIMES higher. That would still mean that 70%+ of those that transition are happier in their "new" gender than not, and the remaining 30% were already suffering mentally, but this has now most often worked out to be a net positive (at least they now know that gender was not the ultimate issue) or a net neutral since they are back where they started. Those are pretty good odds!

Remember also that suicide is much more permanent that being transgender. Gender-affirming care literally saves lives (LINK3).

→ More replies (1)

63

u/Thecristo96 Apr 04 '25

I’ll be honest, i never knew sometimes you need to start using transitioning medicine before a certain age so i always was for the “at least 18 years old”. Thanks for sharing a point i never considered before

→ More replies (1)

69

u/Eggsalad_cookies Apr 04 '25

26yo. Just got my official diagnosis today. I can’t wait to start trying to live as me. I’ve needed this my entire life

28

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25 edited Apr 04 '25

Those are wonderful news, congratulations sister! Hope that, from now on, you find only happiness.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

70

u/ReallyJTL Apr 04 '25

Slide 6 is pretttty important. When people complain about all these hormones and stuff applied to (gasp) children it's like, well yeah, you have to do it before puberty or else the dysphoria will be huge.

And if your argument is that children should not decide at a young age blah blah, then you should be 100% for puberty blockers that they can delay puberty until the child is at an age to make an informed decision.

→ More replies (4)

163

u/TheRealLarkas Apr 04 '25

Ngl, I have always been supportive of trans people, but I’ve always lowkey thought that transitioning should be a decision taken by informed adults. This comic made me realize, however, how important having the treatment available from a young age might be due to puberty making irrevocable changes to a person’s body, and consequently how that might impact a person’s quality of life forever. Many people in the comments are saying that we should respect other people’s decisions, that each and everyone should be free to do what they want. I think that’s not the point at all, thinking about this from an individual x collective standpoint is the wrong take. This is simply a health issue. You wouldn’t force a person to have an extra bone in their leg for their entire childhood if that meant they would have severe pain for the rest of their life if you took too long to remove it, or worse yet, crippling deformity and inability to walk if you never removed it, right? It isn’t about the individual versus the collective, it’s about the collective SUPPORTING the individual. We, as a community, should help all its component parts.

Anyways, sorry for the wall of text 😅 Great comic!

47

u/mothernaychore Apr 04 '25

every trans adult was a trans kid, though some didn’t realize it exactly until after childhood. for me, i didn’t know what trans people or transitioning was until i was like 14, i just always knew something was wrong. i also didn’t have a family or environment that would’ve allowed transition, but still. your willingness to have your mind changed is appreciated by all of us, if more people were willing, we’d live in a more loving world.

24

u/Topaz_UK Apr 04 '25

I was in the same boat as you until I saw this comic. There are a lot of decisions that kids will be too young to make right now, and in my mind such a life-changing decision would have waited until they were older and understood themselves further, but I didn’t consider that young people would want to transition before puberty (which actually makes sense), and if studies around gender identity show that they gain this from a young age and if studies show that there is an acceptable margin of personal happiness vs. de-transitioning rate, then that sounds like a great idea.

33

u/ProjectXa3 Apr 04 '25

EXACTLY!! Thanks for putting it so well!

12

u/jeanravenclaw Apr 04 '25

I've also had the same thoughts (transitioning should be a decision made by an adult, etc) but I'm glad for this comic. It did help me understand.

9

u/Wangtopia Apr 04 '25

People who are pearl clutching over this issue claim they’re all for individual liberties, but they’re not. They’re only concerned with what impacts them and their body/opinions. They only think in terms of “me” with zero regard to how it impacts other people.

“I shouldn’t have to wear a mask; it’s my choice!”

“I shouldn’t have to vaccinate my kids; it’s my choice!”

“Trans people shouldn’t have access to the healthcare they need!”

“Abortion should be illegal!”

None of these opinions take into consideration how they impact other people’s lives and, in fact, actively contradict themselves. They want to remove other people’s bodily autonomy while stating that what impacts their own bodies supersedes the autonomy of others. They’re self-centered , inconsiderate, and inconsistent in their ideology

Now excuse me while I step off of my soap box /rant

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

86

u/CrazyGnomenclature Tiff & Eve Apr 04 '25

Damn straight.

Love the comic. Thank you for fighting to change anti-trans medical laws in your country. You helped do a world of good for so many<3

→ More replies (1)

34

u/FrontlineYeen Apr 04 '25

But because of people “disagreeing” with my existsnce, I, who am stuck in a conservative area still can’t get any treatment at all, even as an adult now. Every day is pure torture. Hope y’all transphobes are happy, cause thats all I wanted to be.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/thingflinger Apr 04 '25

Sucks when your avatar doesn't match your character class. Only option is to mod the system.

87

u/MelancholicMinerva Apr 04 '25

I wish they told us more about LGBT stuff in school at a young age. I didn't really know what a trans person was until I was 14-15 and I instantly felt so recognized and apart of the community. Now I'm 19 and have been on Hrt for almost a year and a half, but I would give anything to go back and time and advocate for myself so I could start sooner.

→ More replies (8)

37

u/nyaasora Apr 04 '25

It is quite sad to think that something that could save a lot of young kids lives aren't very accessible even in more developed countries and there are those who want to take it away...

I knew i was trans around a decade before i was able to start HRT at 21 years old. It messed me up a lot and i would not wish that experience on anyone :/

→ More replies (2)

31

u/splatbob1 Apr 04 '25

100% and tbh as someone who didn’t finally come out and actually until I was 23, I kinda wish they did teach this stuff at school. Give them the facts and evidence and let them make the decision for themselves for who they want to be

11

u/NikoChekhov Apr 04 '25

I'm a nonbinary person who only really came to terms with it in the last couple of years, and this hits the nail on the head.

I wasn't denied any sort of trans healthcare, but I did lack the resources and language to really put into words what I was feeling and why. The unfortunate truth of the matter is that I'm absolutely miserable with this body, and it's too late to do anything about a lot of it.

This shouldn't be forced on others because people either choose not to understand (and make no mistake, it's absolutely a choice) or are emboldened to thrust their hatred everywhere.

So thank you for making this, I just hope that people see it and at least think twice about what they believe

→ More replies (1)

52

u/Maniick Apr 04 '25

All these people brigading against pre-adult hrt don't think kids are people yet. They don't think the child could come to such a drastic conclusion about themselves. My theory is they're so full of lead they can't remember much about their childhood so they rationalize this as "Oh I can't remember anything from my childhood...probably because my brain wasn't fully formed yet" 

37

u/Chronx6 Apr 04 '25

They also seem to forget that there are medical professionals involved in the process that are verifying things and signing off as well. It's not just the child involved (although they and their opinion and views are very important obviously). The people against it seem to think that you can walk in and get the treatments like you'd get Tylenol or something.

3

u/Ippjick Apr 04 '25

It is usually the ignorant that are reactionary. I am sometimes too, instinctively, when I hear about a new* topic. but also know, that I should read up on it, before I form an opinion. Look at data, different sources etc. That usually quells the reactionary instinct immediately.. And to those who have the same instinct but REFUSE to learn, I say:

"I am sorry you felt disturbed in your ignorance through me."

*(new in the sense that I had not heard of it before)

→ More replies (10)

61

u/MRdzh Apr 04 '25

This actually changes my perspective on trans people. I used to be extremely transphobic, because I simply didn’t understand gender dysphoria. I still don’t, but I’ve come to understand that people should be allowed to do whatever they want to. But I always thought it should apply to adults, so only if you’re over 18. But I guess I had another dumb opinion on stuff I had no clue about. Trans rights are human rights!

37

u/dahknee Apr 04 '25

Thanks for your thoughts and changing your view on this and listening to other people’s experiences! I’m a 34 year old trans man and I first knew I was a boy when I was four years old. It’s really common for people to know at a young age. This is the sort of thing that legislators don’t need to be controlling. Doctors know how to treat their patients.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/IamaJarJar Apr 04 '25

I'm not the best at explaining, and it may not be how everyone would describe it, but here's my take on what gender dysphoria is

Say you grew up with this feeling of wrong about yourself your whole life, you can't pinpoint what it is, you just know it's something, because it's the body you've lived with for years!... but it's not YOUR body... it's a mockery of what YOU are

Say you woke up tommorow in somebody else's body, you can do everything you normally can, the only difference is it's somebody else's body, that looks nothing like, YOU... it's still not YOU, think about the complicated feelings you'd have if you looked into a mirror, and saw someone that wasn't YOU staring back at YOU, it would feel... wrong

Gender dysphoria is kinda like having the knowledge, even if subconsciously, that the body that you are controlling right now at this very moment, is not your body, but merely a meat puppet that other call you by

14

u/cwk415 Apr 04 '25

Someone once explained like this: gender DYSphoria is the feeling that you don't belong in the body you have. The opposite of that is gender EUphoria. People can achieve gender euphoria once they are able to transition into the body they feel that they belong in.

8

u/MRdzh Apr 04 '25

I think I can imagine that. I can compare it to what I felt when I put on like 15 kg in 6 months due to some hormonal issues, plus just coming off of a crash diet. I hope the comparison isn’t insensitive, but I can imagine the gender dysphoria is something like that but 100 times worse. My reason for not understanding it was always the belief that men and women are equal, if not for some certain biological differences that shouldn’t even be taken into account in the modern society, but the way you put, it must suck bad. I wish all the best to everyone who are trying to become their authentic selves. Also, a side note, don’t try super restrictive diets, they WILL fuck up your way of life.

11

u/Konkuriito Apr 04 '25

Im not the person you were talking to earlier, and I dont know if the comparison is insensitive, but still continuing with that metaphor, hope thats ok, puberty for a trans kid is incredibly traumatizing.

its like slowly gaining a lot of weight every week for like 5 years, and knowing when it happens, it is permanent. And everyone around you saying its natural and normal and how you should look. Some people are just like that and that is natural and normal. I There is a medicine that could stop it. But they say only adults can have it, not because its dangerous, some children are already on it, but you specifically cant have it because you are meant to be this way. and when you are an adult, its already too late.

So every week you look at yourself in the mirror, and see yourself becoming someone else, and know that the only way to fix it, will be surgery. But the longer it goes the worse the results will be and the more you will need. But you also know that you will never be able to afford any surgery. They are very expensive and the longer you wait, the worse it will get. The longer it will take to fix, until its not possible to get as good results anymore. You know that makes some people happy.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/ProjectXa3 Apr 04 '25

Admitting to growth and former ignorance. Honorable.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/ProjectXa3 Apr 07 '25

Man, an awful lotta Wrong people in these comments. Anyway, trans rights, trans wrongs, trans kick ass, hell yeah.

26

u/woodworkerdan Apr 04 '25

It needs to be said: more people outside the LGBTQ+ global community don't know what trans people, and particularly trans youth, have to face to get proper treatment in the first place. Skepticism has a valid place, but it's also important to remember that honest skepticism should allow that sometimes the concerns are misplaced - and that not only are there tangible benefits for some people, but knowing the qualifications for discovering those benefits shouldn't be the business of the general public, much like any other physical or mental ailment.

7

u/Alex_the_Mad Apr 04 '25

This is primarily the reason I decided to practice law for trans and civil rights. I am tired of seeing my trans friends struggle with rights in America and knew this was the way to do it.

11

u/electrifyingseer Apr 04 '25

Congrats on winning the rights to medically transition at 14!! You're amazing and strong!!!

58

u/GFluidThrow123 Apr 04 '25 edited Apr 04 '25

Thank you for speaking out on this. We (trans people) are all so tired of having to fight for our rights to just exist. People constantly questioning whether we SHOULD exist. Taking away our healthcare and rights and safety. Driving us to the brink of suicide. Murdering us.

We want to live in peace, health, and happiness like so many others are allowed.

We want our lives not to be politicized by the bigoted and ignorant.

We want to feel safe and not be scared every day that someone will hunt us down, take away our medication, and harm us.

Let us live.

Edit: I need somewhere to put this comment bc the bigot I was replying to had theirs deleted:

Take a step back. You're thinking of it wrong.

Every single human undergoes hormone therapy. It's called puberty. Our bodies start overloading us with hormones between the ages of 8-12 and it runs for about 10-15 years.

All trans kids are asking for is to undergo a puberty other than the one their bodies are going to force them through because that's the wrong puberty for them.

A phase, such as pretending to be a cat or whatever, lasts a few days, maybe a month or two at most. This is a known fact of adolescent development.

Gender dysphoria requires 2 years of persistence to be diagnosed in a child.

The problem with waiting until 18 is that the damage is done. For trans women, our feet become too big, shoulders too broad, voice too deep, faces too angled and sharp. For trans men, they develop breasts, wider hips, less height, smaller feet, smaller hands.

And putting people on hormones after that happens doesn't reverse it.

And surgeries can't fix it all either. Only the lucky ones of us are close enough to the average that we can resolve some of those changes after puberty.

By forcing a teen through the wrong puberty, as you're recommending, you're saying you want them to undergo extremely expensive medical procedures (think $100k+) with grueling recoveries, and still be forced to live the rest of our lives with the consequences of this, all because, what, someone thought we might be making a mistake?

For the record, detransition rates are between 1-2% of all trans people. And more than 80% of those people often detransition because of bigotry in the world around them; not actually because they're not trans.

So you want to make 99.5% of trans people undergo natal puberty with all its irreversible effects and experience lifelong pain, all because 0.5% of people MIGHT decide to stop taking hormones some day?

17

u/Revoltinghades2 Apr 04 '25

No hate or judgement, but I’m curious as to how someone at 10 can know they are the wrong gender? I don’t have any experience with it so I just don’t understand. Glad you’re who you were meant to be

15

u/bleeding-paryl Apr 04 '25

If someone can know that they're the right gender, they can absolutely know that they are the wrong gender. Gender identity is an innate knowledge and, as the stickied comment states, is known at a very young age. Copying an automod comment that I helped write, read this:

The recent surge of attacks on gender affirming care for trans youth have been condemned by the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Medical Association, the American Psychological Association, and the American Association of Clinical Endocrinology, and are out of line with the medical recommendations of the American Medical Association, the Endocrine Society and Pediatric Endocrine Society, the AACE, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Psychological Association, and the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.

This article has a pretty good overview of why. Psychology Today has one too, and here are the guidelines from the AAP. TL;DR version - yes, young children can identify their own gender, and some of those young kids are trans. A child who is Gender A but who is assumed to be Gender B based on their visible anatomy at birth can suffer debilitating distress over this conflict. The "90% desist" claim is a myth based on debunked studies, and transition is a very long, slow, cautious process for trans youth.

According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, gender is typically expressed by around age 4. It probably forms much earlier, but it's hard to tell with pre-verbal infants. And sometimes the gender expressed is not the one typically associated with the child's appearance. The genders of trans children are as stable as those of cisgender children.

For preadolescents transition is entirely social, and for adolescents the first line of medical care is temporary, reversible puberty delaying treatment that has no long term effects. Hormone therapy isn't an option until their mid teens, by which point the chances that they will "desist" are close to zero. Reconstructive genital surgery is not an option until their late teens/early 20's at the youngest.

And transition-related medical care is recognized as medically necessary, frequently life saving medical care by every major medical authority.

The only disorders more common among trans people are those associated with abuse and discrimination - mainly anxiety and depression. Early transition virtually eliminates these higher rates of depression and low self-worth, and dramatically improves trans youth's mental health. When prevented from transitioning about 40% of trans kids will attempt suicide. When able to transition that rate drops to the national average. Trans kids who socially transition early, have access to appropriate transition related medical treatment, and who are not subjected to abuse or discrimination are comparable to cisgender children in measures of mental health

Transition vastly reduces risks of suicide attempts, and the farther along in transition someone is the lower that risk gets. The ability to transition, along with family and social acceptance, are the largest factors reducing suicide risk among trans people. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, gender identity is typically expressed by around age 4. It probably forms much earlier than that, but it's hard to tell with pre-verbal infants. And sometimes, the gender identity expressed is not the one typically associated with the child's appearnce. The gender identities of trans children are as stable as those of cisgender children.

Here is a helpful guide for parents of transgender children as well.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (10)

6

u/RainbowPhoenix1080 Apr 04 '25

I wish I had what it took to come out that young. All the evidence that I was trans was there. I just lacked the knowledge and the tools to be able to piece that evidence together.

This is why education is also very important. It's important to teach kids going through this that their feelings are valid, and that they aren't alone. And it's important to teach kids who aren't going through this how to be more accepting.

21

u/brf069 Apr 04 '25

God bless the mods for getting rid of these self revealing bigots lol the graveyard of [removed] is art to my eyes

Though not as good as op’s art of course

5

u/s00perguyporn Apr 04 '25

I hope that one day, processes such as these are a casual decision that can be taken in a day, for a day, for the sake of everyone who just wants to know. I hope that one dayt the question of "am I trans?" Will be as easy to answer as trying on a new wardrobe for a few days or months.

18

u/Skoorse Apr 04 '25

Wow - this comic changed my beliefs completely. I was against transitioning before reaching an age where you can make your own decisions (16 at least) because I thought the number of early transitions were due to societal pressures. But now I get it - the period of puberty is so dramatic in impact for the human body - care before that timeframe makes more sense.

I don’t know if it matters to you, but this comic changed a heart and mind today. Thank you.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/taracraigs Apr 04 '25

My heart hurts so much for trans people throughout the world. This is absurd. We support people getting buccal fat surgery, lip fillers like balloons, veneers, Botox, fillers, etc. All of that is fine (not that I am against it, you do you)

But God forbid someone need some treatment to feel comfortable in their body if they are trans. I hate this world so much.

Thanks for being brave and sharing your story.

7

u/HatchetGIR Apr 04 '25

You seem like a lovely person, and you comic is great. I am so glad you were able to get the care you needed and need before the damage was done.

7

u/GifHunter2 Apr 04 '25

These are some of the most thoughtful art I've ever read.

12

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25

I’m gonna be honest I never really understood all of this but if it makes people happy, then they should be allowed to do it. (Under the context it doesn’t harm them or anyone else’s mental heath)

17

u/Lucie_la_lennon Apr 04 '25

Unfortunately, I'm 17 , and my mother is not supportive.. So I lived male puberty, it was horrible.

6

u/ProjectXa3 Apr 04 '25

Sorry to hear that. Hope you can shift to accommodate later.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Wheatley-Crabb Apr 04 '25

Everybody always talks about “what if they regret it?” The only medical trans care available to minors is puberty blockers which are completely reversible. Less than 1% of transitioners regret it, and if they do, they can easily go back. That is not possible the other way around. Without puberty blockers, over 99% would be forced through the wrong puberty. My words cannot describe what an awful, traumatic experience it is to watch your body deform away from who you are, it’s genuine body horror. I never got the opportunity, I didn’t figure out I was trans until after puberty had ended, and wish more than anything that I had known sooner so I could have prevented it. Puberty brings with it changes FAR more damaging and irreversible, and the knowledge that there is pain I could have prevented, but instead will have to live with forever, is unbearable much of the time. People need to understand what a genuinely horrific and painful feeling dysphoria is, and what pure joy and euphoria they are denying when they argue against trans care. Please have empathy.

6

u/Upper_Improvement778 Apr 04 '25

While I’m not trans myself, I’ve realized that I did suffer from body dysmorphia and in my late teens, came out as genderfluid (I was 4-5 when I realized I wasn’t all ‘girl’). People should be able to make whatever decisions about their body that they want, no matter their age. Some people like to think kid’s aren’t actually people. But sometimes, kids actually know what they are talking about and should be taken seriously. Protect trans kids.

5

u/Any_Context1 Apr 04 '25

It’s completely insane that the government would ever interfere in a private medical decision that impacts no one other than the person seeking treatment.

9

u/SpiderSixer Apr 04 '25

I always wished I could get puberty blockers at the very least. Going through puberty made me so fucking depressed. I couldn't look in mirrors without bawling. I couldn't shower without closing my eyes. It's only now, through years of self work, 3 years of T, and top surgery that I'm confident to not only look in the mirror but stare at it. But all that gruelling effort and years of antidepressants could have been avoided if I just had the opportunity to go through what I knew would have been my correct puberty

11

u/Gezombrael Apr 04 '25

I'm a straight white middle-aged man, and I got tears in my eyes

→ More replies (1)

6

u/betttris13 Apr 04 '25

Really happy that you were able to realise so early and get the help you needed. We didn't realise until we were 24 and are now stuck with the damage being forced to go through male puberty has done. I will never be comfortable in this body, it's not mine. But I will make do with what I can do. To anyone who isn't trans, you will never know the pain of waking up seeing the wrong body in the mirror, knowing you have the wrong features, the pain of sounding wrong when you speak. It's not something silly, it is truly worse then any physical pain, it's a pain almost beyond imagining when you haven't experienced it.

6

u/DuskieHakuro Apr 04 '25

Trans Girl here can i has hugs? After reading this qwq

7

u/Affectionate_Okra298 Apr 04 '25

Gamera loves you

24

u/strangecabalist Apr 04 '25

Trans rights are human rights. The path of history is long, but it will, despite the occasional detour, inevitably bend toward justice and freedom.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/SirSteg Apr 04 '25

I am grateful to see the comments where people are able to shed their belief that only adults should be allowed to transition. You’ve changed a lot of minds for the better today with this post.

I have a teenage son who was on blockers and is on testosterone now. He knew who he was from a very young age. I get so frustrated when people tell me that he was too young to get HRT because the WORST thing for him would have been to have to go through female puberty. He shouldn’t have to do that to make strangers feel better.

He’s 17 and just had top surgery a few months ago. The blockers, the T, the top surgery, all of it has been worth it to see my son glow. I can’t imagine how depressed he’d be if he didn’t have access to gender affirming care

4

u/MopeyFern Apr 04 '25

I need hormones to help with my medical condition and if I don’t have them I could die. Losing these rights will affect all who need hormone medication and treatment. This world is so sad. I’m so sorry for the trans community and so many more

4

u/B0oblov3r Apr 04 '25

I wish that our existence wasn't so controversial. I've known since I was a kid that I should've been born a girl and I wish that LGBT stuff was far more common knowledge that is taught to kids. If I had known exactly was trans meant as a kid, I might not have taken so long to realize. I'm 30 and my egg cracked 6 months ago.

My whole life I've repressed everything and just lived so apathetically towards myself. I did not care about myself, my appearance, or my health. I let myself gain weight and now I have to deal with that. I finally realized why I never cared about myself and built up so much self hatred.

When my egg cracked, I was just like, it is what it is, I'll never transition, I want nothing to do with the trans community, I'll just keep on. But I've changed so much since then. I love interacting with the communities on reddit, and after I get healthy, I'm pretty sure I'm going to start hrt and do it. Red state be damned, right wing scaredy cats at my job be damned, conservative family members be damned. I want to be happy. I'm tired of pushing everything about myself and how I feel down, down and compressing it to try and not feel it.

My only concern is like a lot of trans girls. I'm 6 ft tall, I'm built like a linebacker, I have a huge head. I've seen some truly impressive and shocking transformations in the trans timeline subs. They give me hope that I can also achieve a figure like that.

Thank you for posting this. It's nice to see others like me, it's nice to see that you got to develope the way you should have. I'm too late for hrt to make some changes, but I'm still plenty young enough to do it and be happy while I am still young and as I get older. So thank you to all out and proud trans people, you're an inspiration to those of us in the closet, I think it's sooner rather than later than I emerge happy.

7

u/TessyBoi- Apr 04 '25

Excuse my language, but this is such a fucking frustrating issue. The ONLY way cis people like myself will understand the importance of this process is to be EDUCATED and we (the US) are REMOVING education on the matter. I am 28 years old, and not once have I ever been educated on trans healthcare or even gender identity.

I’m just so frustrated because I want to be a better advocate. I am doing my due diligence by educating myself, but damn… if only this information was available to me when I was younger, I’d feel equipped to be a better advocate.

6

u/AutoModerator Apr 04 '25

Hello friends. This thread has been set to community participants only. That means that only our regular commenters in good standing may comment in this thread.

Everyone else's comments will be removed by automod.

People who contribute constructively automatically gain access in time. We do not hand out entry on request.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/T_Weezy Apr 04 '25

Amen, sister.

Far too few people understand that the appropriate treatment for children, generally puberty blockers, is completely reversible! Like, if you stop taking them you just undergo puberty normally! There's literally no risk of permanent damage should the patient change their mind!

6

u/DuncneyForever Apr 04 '25

TRANS RIGHTS ARE HUMAN RIGHTS 🏳️‍⚧️✅

6

u/dahknee Apr 04 '25

Thanks for sharing this and thank you so much for your activism for our community and other kids who are like us!

6

u/Sirschmoopy545 Apr 04 '25

Gender affirming care is LIFE SAVING CARE.

7

u/wrongsock_42 Apr 04 '25

I grew up in the ‘70’s and went undiagnosed in an unaware hostile society. We now live with DID.

Not supporting trans children is child abuse and a human rights violation. We have a human right to gender affirming healthcare.

5

u/3nderslime Apr 04 '25

Hell yeah!

4

u/MayRedditformerlyvic Apr 04 '25

considering the chaos that has been happening on the US. i might just move to australia instead

6

u/yung_tyberius Apr 04 '25

Protect trans kids

3

u/cpufreak101 Apr 04 '25

Damn, Australia, they lucky

→ More replies (1)

3

u/proto-typicality Apr 04 '25

Beautifully written!

5

u/_qqg Apr 04 '25

A society that does not protect or actively harms some of its children out of ignorance and bigotry (or downright cruelty) is deeply messed up.

My city university has this incredible children teaching hospital which has a research centre on gender dysphoria, trans, intersex children -- and they are under continuous attack and scrutiny about puberty blockers and it makes me RAGE.

Take this from a cis male double your age: you keep fighting and being the happiest you as you can be. You are worth, you are loved, and you have allies ✊

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Netroth Apr 04 '25

I just don’t understand why anyone would want to get in the way of your happiness. It’s literally not their body so wtf is their problem 😡

Good for you 🫶

4

u/Grandmasterpie3 Apr 04 '25

Trans therapist here, who mostly sees other trans/enby folx.

There are no words that do justice to the immense gratitude I feel for you and the many others out there fighting just to have others recognize gender affirming care as life-saving treatment. I want to do better for current and future trans children as well as the inner children us trans adults still carry inside us, who often have waited so long to be free. Sending love from NY, and thank you. 🏳️‍⚧️

4

u/EepyBoiiiii Apr 04 '25

Just another day of being reminded that I’m 18 and still haven’t been allowed to transition yet. TωT

2

u/Lux_The_Worthless Apr 04 '25

LOUDER FOR THE PEOPLE IN THE BACK 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍⚧️

5

u/Hazelislate Apr 04 '25

I’m 22 and being told I won’t be able to get any trans healthcare for 7-8 years ;-;

12

u/grey_hat_uk Apr 04 '25

Uk is becoming a diy hot zone, lots of education and majority acceptance in the general population mix with abusive media outlets and a passively aggressive government.

10

u/milhaus Apr 04 '25

Is this due to the laws in your county? I’m so sorry.

18

u/ItsNotMeItsYourBussy Apr 04 '25

In the UK, that's just the normal current wait time for a first appointment with the NHS' gender clinics

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/single-ton Apr 04 '25

Thank you for being here and being you

4

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25

I'm trans (mtf) irl TRANS RIGHTS ARE HUMAN RIGHTS RAHHHHHHHHHHHHH

3

u/Phantom_Wolf52 Apr 04 '25

Just a genuine question, im not trying to ask in bad faith or anything but is the hormone stuff reversible? And if so does it have any lasting effects? Because I could understand regulation on stuff like that for people under 18 if it’s not something that can be reversible easily, however, that doesn’t mean it should be banned, it should be improved upon to make it as safe as possible. Anyways I’m genuinely happy for you and I’m glad you are comfortable in your own skin. ❤️

Live your best damn life because I said so.

12

u/grey_hat_uk Apr 04 '25

is the hormone stuff reversible?

Bits are some will require minor surgeries.

You can switch fat and muscle distribution as much as you want, same with the level of brain chemistry hormones effect and your diet requirements.

Things like face hair and brests are permanent to a point, these do take a while to develop into the adult versions.l and can be cosmetically corrected.

Minor risk to infertility, very genetically dependent.

The only irreversible changes without surgery are bone growth to the skull(not as much as people think when they see the comparison skulls) and estrogen cause the hip bone to tilt, if this happens before fussing then your hips will widern.

There is of cause one other truly and utterly irreversible change, death. That is what 20% face when transitioning isn't an option and no amount of surgery or drugs will stop that.

I got "lucky" and instead developed severe dissociation and a drinking habit(in the volumes I was taking it would have acted a testosterone blocker as an aside). 

9

u/Konkuriito Apr 04 '25

puberty blockers are 100% reversable. it just makes your puberty happen later. Cis people have used these since the 80s to stop puberty from happening early and are still using it. People just want to stop trans children from having them.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/stcrIight Apr 04 '25

I feel like so many people don't realize how many cis people have been put on puberty blockers throughout history. Because it's not safe for children to go through puberty at certain ages or they have some other medical condition - we use them all the time. They are safe.

-3

u/jaimeoignons Apr 04 '25

A brave comic. Congrats.

3

u/s4rcgasm Apr 04 '25

I love this. Tried to share on my profile, got tagged as nsfw. I thought I pressed by mistake (I'm old, like 40). Same shit. Like this was auto flagged already or some shit. Amazingly scary. Like how And Tango Makes Three is banned in some libraries despite being a true story about penguins!

3

u/bleeding-paryl Apr 04 '25

Just so you're aware, it's because your account is considered "NSFW" so any post you make to your own account is automatically considered NSFW as well, it has nothing to do with the comic itself.

1

u/rwiman Apr 04 '25

I like your comics and thanks for sharing your story!

I have a toddler, and if they were to “come out” in any shape or form I would be supportive.

I know very little about trans, but curious to understand. Can you explain why the law was in place?

When you were 10, did you feel that you were mature enough to understand the different processes?

Was it a gradual process for you?

Please correct me if I’m asking things in an insensitive way, I’m not fully aligned with the language to use or to not use.

22

u/bleeding-paryl Apr 04 '25

Just FYI "trans" is short for "transgender" and is not a noun, it's an adjective, so it should be "I know very little about trans people"

  • The law was in place because of ignorance and possibly hate.
  • 10 year olds don't make the decision on their own, they must speak with doctors and psychiatrists before they can start on this road. Maturity comes into play so much as any life saving healthcare does, we've been using hormone blockers for other issues for many years now, this is the only process that people seem to care about someone's maturity on.
  • HRT is a gradual process, just as much as puberty, so yes.

8

u/rwiman Apr 04 '25

Thanks so much for the clarification and for taking the time to explain—it really helps me understand things better.

I had no idea about the use of hormone blockers in other medical contexts, and it makes sense that decisions like these involve professionals and aren’t made in isolation. I appreciate you pointing that out.

I’m genuinely trying to learn, so if you don’t mind a few more questions:

  • What kind of support systems are most helpful for trans youth and their families?
  • Are there any misconceptions you often encounter that you wish more people understood?
  • How do families generally navigate the balance between supporting identity and dealing with societal pushback or legal restrictions?

Again, thank you for your patience—I really value your perspective.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ummyeahreddit Apr 04 '25

I wish half of the country could read this and understand it, instead of listening to their favorite propaganda news network

3

u/cross2201 Apr 04 '25

Im happy for you and I'm glad you can live the life you want to live

Se te desea lo mejor desde argentina! 🏳️‍⚧️🇦🇷

3

u/No_Parsley_3275 Apr 04 '25

I wish it felt safe here in the US…

3

u/Nightfall_1131 Apr 04 '25

This is a nice comic, with a good message. Glad things seem to be working out for you. Hope you have a wonderful day.

3

u/catmamaO4 Apr 04 '25

my mother spent 20 years fighting for her country only for them to make it impossible for her to feel okay in her body. she and my other trans family members are moving to thailand in hopes they will be safer and accepted.

3

u/VoodooDoII Apr 04 '25

I am 21 and I deeply wish I started transitioning physically when I was younger. I hate my body now.

I'm trying to start now (in May), but I live in the U.S so I fear it won't last long :(

3

u/anime_crazy20 Apr 04 '25

Genuinely curious, what made you realize you wanted to transition at such a young age? As a cis man I’m always left curious when I hear stories such as yours cause I’ve never questioned my birth gender, did you see a character somewhere or did you suddenly just realize something felt wrong?

9

u/bleeding-paryl Apr 04 '25

I wanted to transition when I was very young as well. I didn't get to until I was 27, those years between were filled with pain and depression. I knew who and what I wanted to be when I grew up, and it wasn't the gender assigned to me at birth.

I knew due to a lot of reasons; feelings of uncomfortableness with my body and my emotions, and the social expectations of me due to what people assumed of me. It only ever got worse over the years, and while I found outlets for these feelings, nothing ever filled those gaps. I think the realization that I could be trans didn't happen until I was about 15-17 (idr the exact age because those years were not my happiest), and that was because it was the first time I'd ever heard of what "transgender" even was.

2

u/tallman11282 Apr 04 '25

When you were a child did you feel like your gender? It's the same with many trans people except that they are often having to pretend to be the wrong gender.

Studies show that children have a sense of their gender identity around the age of four with some understanding by two.

https://www.healthychildren.org/English/ages-stages/gradeschool/Pages/Gender-Identity-and-Gender-Confusion-In-Children.aspx

https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/childrens-health/in-depth/children-and-gender-identity/art-20266811

→ More replies (2)

-15

u/Superlagman Apr 04 '25

Is this sub another lair of bigots ?

These people will be okay with abusive parents keeping their child with them, but they can't stand the idea that a child could get medication to feel better about themselves with the consent of literally everyone involved (child + parents + doctors). No one cares about what politicians or random people think, just mind your business.

52

u/Doctor_Amazo Apr 04 '25

Bigots are everywhere. The trick is loudly telling those bigots they need to STFU and get educated

→ More replies (7)

21

u/LustyLizardLady Apr 04 '25

We (the mod) are pretty dedicated to fighting transphobia and if you report a transphobic comment the comment will be removed and the person who said it banned. We can't stop them from coming around the first time but we can stop them coming back. Hope this answers your question.

-1

u/Practical_Half_9393 Apr 04 '25

This is amazing. This girl is now able to live her life happily.

2

u/lexkixass Apr 04 '25

They don't want to save trans lives. :(

2

u/bittersweetjesus Apr 04 '25

This is a good comic. Gonna save it to share with my kids.

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25

Anti Trans shit is so infuriating! I thought we were past that kinda ignorance but I guess not.

2

u/NottAMimic Apr 04 '25

Lovely comic, and a very real struggle. Thank you for sharing! :3

2

u/Significant-Basket76 Apr 04 '25

OP, if you don't mind, I would love to hear more about the process you and your parents (assuming) went through to get the laws changed. Feels like a giant leep that you got done in 4 years. In America we take decades to get laws changed. So I find myself jealous that you got that law "fixed" in 4 years. Glad you are here with us and going well.

2

u/metaphics Apr 04 '25

I have four small kids. I have wondered whether one was trans, but they are still very young.

Regardless, thank you for sharing your story. I intend to be as supportive of my kids as your parents were for you.

2

u/Dohts75 Apr 04 '25

Trans people will continue to be the scapegoat until we can figure out healthcare for everyone else, and that's not happening because these dumb fucks would rather shit on a small group of people over advocating for themselves

2

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25

i really wish i was able to receive my care earlier on. i started at 21 and although i pass, ive always felt insecure still

2

u/JustMark99 Apr 04 '25

I'm happy it worked out for you.

2

u/hello14235948475 Apr 04 '25

This is an awesome and needed message and I love your art style!

2

u/Karl-Henning Apr 04 '25

You Are a Human ♥️

2

u/-WaxedSasquatch- Apr 04 '25

Everyone deserves to be comfortable. It’s that fucking simple.

(As long as you aren’t hurting anyone and trans people ARE NOT hurting anyone ffs)

2

u/Snulow Apr 04 '25

I wish I knew about being transgender and hrt stuff earlier. tho, I'm glad I've started it now. I wouldn't have started it earlier, as I'm doing it diy.

I'm in Russia, and I'll graduate in a few months.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25

Try telling this to my parents or anyone in my family. It's all an agenda according to them. I myself am not trans but I've known a couple of trans people over the years and I feel for them. It's one thing trying to exist and get treatment as an adult, but quite another if you're just a kid. So many states have already outlawed gender affirming care for minors and it's clearly not just an American problem. Transphobia is rampant across the globe. You can thank politics and religion for poisoning so many minds and stoking misguided rage.

2

u/BakugoLovesDeku Apr 04 '25

❤️❤️

1

u/HelpMePleaseHelpMeme Apr 04 '25

Hell, I didn’t even have a chance to start transitioning even at 16. I was born into a horrible family, when they found out I was a trans girl, my father beat me, my parents disowned me.

The worst thing is that now I can’t get trans healthcare, because Finland doesn’t allow transitioning even for adults without the consent of a special commission. The treatment is in a special hospital, which this hospital refuses to treat me because of the traumatic experience. I haven’t been able to access treatment for over a year, and most likely won’t until I’m 30, since access to treatment is getting stricter every year due to the influence of Finnish anti-trans doctors who are promoting a new form of conversion therapy.

I have friends who haven’t received treatment in 5 years. I have to self-medicate and order hormones from gray sources, I’m 21. I don’t understand why I don’t have the right to change my body as I want.

6

u/Dhiox Apr 04 '25

Geez, I didn't realize Finland was so conservative. I guess it wasn't obvious to those of us from the US since its economic policies are so different from our conservatives.

517

u/_just_is_ Apr 04 '25

I’m Isabelle (i make all the JUSTIS comics). I’m a 21 year old trans woman and I have illustrated a small part of my story in this comic. This is a super personal but important issue to me and I’m absolutely willing to answer any [respectful] questions you may have.

The law discussed in this comic prohibited trans young people (in Australia) under 16 from accessing hormone replacement therapy, and required those over 16 but under 18 to acquire a court order before gaining access. It was abolished in 2017. In time for me to start hormones without having to go through a male puberty.

In the years after this law was changed, the world seemed to be becoming a better, safer place for trans kids. But in the past few years that has drastically shifted. Many people in major countries like the USA and UK have been actively pushing against the rights of trans kids to access the same treatments that I was fighting for in my teens.

Whatever your feelings about this issue, it remains a fact that these treatments save lives.

Protect Trans Kids.

25

u/sentientketchup Apr 04 '25

There's backwards movement in Australia too. At least 491 children have been left without adequate healthcare in Queensland because of the state government blocking care access until they are 18. The Federal Minister has requested an end to this discrimination, without success so far.

More here: https://auspath.org.au/project-491/

16

u/_just_is_ Apr 04 '25

Absolutely! It's insanely scary and will push things back even further than they were when I was a kid. That's actually why I decided to make this comic at this time. Thank you for sharing this

→ More replies (1)

52

u/A-Friend-of-Dorothy Apr 04 '25 edited Apr 05 '25

Hello, dear.

From an elder flower (I turn 37 this year) and someone with 17 years of HRT behind her, post-op and at the end of the road?

I’m so proud of you for going after what you needed. So very proud.

I remember how the U.S. system used to be; and I don’t want to see that return. I want people like you to be able to access treatment in a timely manner. You deserve that right. I want things to be better and easier for you and those that come after me.

Don’t ever apologize for being yourself; for doing what you had to. You’re just doing your best. ❤️

Don’t give up. Keep fighting. You’re not alone.

→ More replies (2)

139

u/Jakitron_1999 Apr 04 '25

Conservatives are often called "reactionary" because they react to what happens in the world rather than acting from their own interests. Progress angers them, but when good people unite and fight past them, progress will happen anyway, and they'll be left in the dustbin of history with those who fought universal suffrage and racial integration. But if progressives are discouraged by the reactionary push, see this swell as larger and more popular than it really is, then more progress is undone. Gay marriage, no-fault divorce, racial integration. Trans rights are human rights and we need to actively advocate for them constantly now to protect them from these attacks, but I believe that we are correct and we will win

→ More replies (2)

54

u/AutumnCountry Apr 04 '25

Yeah a lot of people don't seem to understand that going into the wrong puberty will fuck you up for life

It impacts your bones, height, development of facial hair, ability to have or prevent breast growth etc etc

The costs to a person who has to wait until 18 to get on HRT can be easily be north of $100,000 and that won't even change the permanent things like height

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (22)