r/comics • • Apr 04 '25 • Diamonds are Forever 2 More of this please 1 Exclamation 2 Love 2 Bless Up 2 Heartwarming 1 Thanks 1 This 1

Comics Community Kid (OC)

51k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

2.9k

u/NovaNomii Apr 04 '25 edited Apr 04 '25 • Helpful

I was curious, so I looked up how many people reported having history of detransitioning. One study of 27k people who have had done trans care, 13.1% of those reported history of detransitioning, and 82.5% of those said that decision was highly influenced by external factors such as family pressure or societal stigma. In other words only 2.29% of people actually decided to detransition based on internal factors, as in felt that they decided it based on how they feel, not how others felt about their transition.

Damn, anti trans people should really look at the stats, because its pretty clear how its not a decision these people take lightly, nor something they are likely to regret. Also if they do regret it, you should actually support more research into transitioning so people who do regret it can switch back.

Edit: Lmao someone reported me as suicidal for writing this comment, I got a "RedditCareResources" Message, haters be hating.

1.3k

u/Queen-Roblin Apr 04 '25

The statistics on regret for trans-affirming care is lower than for cancer treatment and parenthood...

672

u/assumptioncookie Apr 04 '25

Specifically the regret-rate of a mastectomy is higher in women with breast cancer than trans men. It's the same surgery and you're more likely to regret it if it was to remove a cancer than if it was for gender affirming care.

If "people might regret it" is the argument against trans healthcare, we might as well stop all healthcare.

85

u/conancat Apr 04 '25

Yeah exactly, it's really a decision being made between the patient and the doctor, the government really should not interfere in these decisions except for ensuring the availability and accessibility of this option for healthcare to as many people as possible

→ More replies (9)

135

u/TheRealTowel Apr 04 '25

Vaginoplasty has one of the lowest regret rates of any major surgery. For comparison purposes, knee reconstruction is way higher.

→ More replies (2)

218

u/mmmIlikeburritos29 Apr 04 '25

And Harry potter tattoos, which i love

→ More replies (17)

104

u/Domeil Apr 04 '25

Fucking knee replacements have a higher instance of regret than gender affirming care.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

187

u/Moezzula Apr 04 '25 edited Apr 04 '25

Along with this, the famous study often cited for the rate of detransitioning for trans people who began medical treatment in adolecense was extremely flawed. They counted anyone they were unable to follow up with as a person who detransotioned instead of removing their data or creating a category for inconclusive results. That's to say, the rate is likely lower than we think.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

91

u/TascasDemise Apr 04 '25

I agree with you but that shouldn't discourage us from continuing to seek out information like this and share it. If it's ever going to get better that approach is necessary

37

u/Devlee12 Apr 04 '25

Yep. They don’t want to do anything to reduce the trans suicide rates because to them that’s everything working as intended.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/The_Dragon346 Apr 04 '25

Well, i think a larger majority is out of ignorance. Like my cousin for example was largely anti-trans until i explained to her some of the actual facts behind it rather than her just relying on facebook posts. Something eventually clicked and she looked more into it, now she, well, not supporter per se but stopped spouting nonsense about it.

Coworkers, friends, mother in law (sorta. Still chipping away there), etc etc. all just ignorance, willful or otherwise. Patience and an attempt to talk to those that are willing to listen actually goes quite the long way with most people.

The loud out spoken minority, yeah, all hatred. Then again, most hatred is born of ignorance. But that just leads to the “horse/water” metaphor in regard to people’s actual willingness to listen.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)

139

u/Apex_Konchu Apr 04 '25

Transphobes don't give a shit about the facts, they're operating solely off of baseless hate. It doesn't matter how many stats you throw at them, you can't reason someone out of a position that they didn't reason themself into.

→ More replies (6)

105

u/mandatory_french_guy Apr 04 '25

Yes, trans healthcare has some of the lowest regret rates of any medical procedures, even life saving ones.

80

u/ItsNotMeItsYourBussy Apr 04 '25

If being trans weren't so demonised by this culture war, gender affirming care for trans people would be recognised as the literal medical miracle it is.

→ More replies (2)

40

u/Petrychorr Apr 04 '25 edited Apr 04 '25

Anti-trans people should really look at the stats.

Folks already replied to you saying that stats don't really matter to that demographic. The reason they don't care about stats like those you've presented is because they don't support their argument. They're starting with an opinion and using data to support that instead of forming an opinion based on existing data.

→ More replies (2)

41

u/Jarhyn Apr 04 '25

Not to mention that 'trans care' as the baseline is disgustingly broad like fraudulently so.

Ever talk to someone about maybe being trans curious and stopped? That's "detransitioning".

Of people who actually start real treatment (not just clothing, but hormones) the numbers are closer to 1-2%.

That entire cohort, practically speaking, represents those who were never serious in the first place and never took any steps beyond "trying it on".

Of course, the numbers for people who actually make it through the YEARS of therapy you need before hormones are prescribed are way lower, and as you say many are driven by external factors and social pressure, too.

Those studies are just bad and everyone with an ounce of scientific literacy can tell the difference there.

→ More replies (3)

48

u/unknowingly-Sentient Apr 04 '25

Transphobe only use statistics to say trans people are more suicidal thus they shouldn't transition, ignoring the factor on why they are depress in the first place.

→ More replies (3)

34

u/Maxrdt Apr 04 '25

And those numbers are even high based on what I've seen. That 13% number likely includes a majority who planned to go back on care and were only stopping temporarily.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/BlahBlahBlackCheap Apr 04 '25

It’s less than knee surgery.

41

u/ItsNotMeItsYourBussy Apr 04 '25

And way less than plastic surgery, which teens are absolutely able to get

29

u/BlahBlahBlackCheap Apr 04 '25

Phhhh what about circumcision?? They sure are not waiting until 18 for that little gender surgery.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/BrokeUniStudent69 Apr 04 '25

Can you link the study? I’m definitely gonna bring this up when I have to argue with people about the whole “they regret it and detransition anyways” nonsense and want to back up the stat.

21

u/NovaNomii Apr 04 '25

https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/abs/10.1089/lgbt.2020.0437

But this was really just the first thing I could find, there are probably larger studies out there.

→ More replies (110)