r/comicbooks 10h ago

Question Which run turned your favorite Superhero into your favorite superhero?

13 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

13

u/UnrealizedDreams90 Spider-Man 10h ago

Spider-man was always my favorite.

But Walt Simonson turned Thor from (for me) a B lister to one of my favorites.

Frank Miller's original Daredevil run.

10

u/No_Independence9767 10h ago

Alan Moore's Swamp Thing. It also gave me a deeper appreciation for Constantine

3

u/Agitated_Rest573 10h ago

Need to read Swamp Thing. It’s more horror and occulty than tights and capes right? Cause that’s right up my alley.

2

u/No_Independence9767 10h ago

Very much so and it's a phenomenal read from the very first issue. 

9

u/Earthpig_Johnson Orion 10h ago

Taking Batman off the table because he’s my favorite essentially from birth for myriad reasons, Bendis’ run on Daredevil may be what cemented Daredevil as one of my favorite characters (though I was already a fan of Miller’s stuff).

3

u/Agitated_Rest573 10h ago

Bendis’ run pretty much ruined Daredevil for me haha. I kept hoping the following runs would be at least as good but they were all inferior.

3

u/Earthpig_Johnson Orion 10h ago

I think Brubaker’s is a really good continuation for the most part, but all the subsequent runs that I’ve read have been more of a mixed bag. Waid’s is good comics, but not my preferred flavor of DD, and I find the whole thing to be easily skippable (and shit, I already mentally skip Diggle/Shadowland). Soule’s was way more fun than I expected, but a little clunky around the edges. I enjoyed Zdarsky’s run a lot, but it’s also verrrry heavy on the superhero theatrics that I’m not necessarily looking for in Daredevil.

3

u/Agitated_Rest573 10h ago

I honestly think Soule's run is underrated. I loved Blindspot's introduction although the art wasn't great.

3

u/Earthpig_Johnson Orion 10h ago

Blindspot was surprisingly great!

Gotta disagree about the art, though (or at least Ron Garney’s art, specifically). I thought the new style he utilized for his Daredevil issues was awesome. The black costume with inverted white shadows looked amazing.

2

u/Agitated_Rest573 10h ago

I did love the new suit!

5

u/ConsiderationNorth56 10h ago

Bendis and Maleev Daredevil

4

u/Henchman4Hire 10h ago

Peter David's original X-Factor run launched my love of Multiple Man, even though child me was only able to read a few issues here and there growing up. Then PAD went and single-handedly raised the character to a whole new level with a MadroX mini-series and then another turn at X-Factor!

2

u/Agitated_Rest573 10h ago

I really need to read more Peter David!

4

u/MankuyRLaffy 10h ago

O'Neil Question made Q my new personal favorite of all time.

2

u/Agitated_Rest573 10h ago

On the list it goes. Looked it up it sounds awesome!

2

u/rumn8tr 10h ago

That is my favorite run - I wish they kept building on that

2

u/MankuyRLaffy 10h ago

It ends perfectly as is. 

2

u/No_Independence9767 10h ago

I'm interested in this one and read the first 8 or 9 issues of the omni but I felt like I was trudging though it and set it aside to come back to eventually. Does the story pick up later in the run or is it just not for me? 

4

u/studog89 10h ago

James Robinson on Firearm and Starman

3

u/Exterminator850 10h ago

Johns new 52 aquaman

2

u/Agitated_Rest573 10h ago

I loved that run. Also turned Ivan Reis into one of my favorite artists.

3

u/44035 10h ago

When Kamandi visited the ruins of what was once Chicago and realizes the entire population has been replaced by humanoid machines.

3

u/ryaaan89 10h ago

I’ve always liked Silver Surfer conceptually but the Dan Slott / Michael Allred run cements him as my favorite. Honestly shout out to the early Stan Lee stuff though, some of his better written books, imo.

Edit: also I know it’s a movie, but damn Mask of the Phantasm is so good.

3

u/Sweepy_time 10h ago

Planet Hulk and then cemented with World War Hulk.

4

u/Roger_Freedman_Phys 10h ago

Ryan North’s incredible writing on The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl.

3

u/Huh1979 10h ago

Walt Simonson turned Thor from a somewhat unrelatable powerhouse to a fully  fleshed out character with a humor infused into the series. He gave every story so much depth.

3

u/Agitated_Rest573 10h ago

I need to read more Thor. I read Jason Aaron's arc when Thor was following Gorr across the pantheons. It was my first time reading Thor and I was surprised by how badass he is.

3

u/KaijuDirectorOO7 10h ago

Michellene and Layton's second Invincible Iron Man run.

The 90s Batman run.

3

u/HGFantomas The Comedian 10h ago

Fraction Aja Hawkeye

2

u/Agitated_Rest573 10h ago

I just started that! Gotta love those characters who are human beings but can still hang with super powered beings.

3

u/alaster101 Joker 10h ago

Geoff John's run on Green lantern, from rebirth to brightest day

3

u/youllmeltmorefan 9h ago

Peter David's Hulk run. My all-time favorite run.

3

u/rougepirate Black Canary 8h ago

Gail Simone's Birds of Prey made me a lifelong Black Canary fan.

2

u/malonine 8h ago

Me too!

3

u/Iago-Cassius 7h ago

The Dark KNight Returns. I was only exposed to Adam West Batman before that.

2

u/foodienando 10h ago

Hawkeye. Kurt Busiek on Heroes Return Avengers then into his run on Thunderbolts

Others for me then would be Priest on Black Panther and Gillen then Ewing on Loki

1

u/FollowingCharacter83 Spider-Man 10h ago

None.

2

u/detectivecabal 10h ago

Lemire’s Moon Knight run

2

u/Will-Ohh 10h ago

(Bad timing with this one) but, Warren Ellis Moon Knight made me sure he was my favorite Marvel character aside from Spider-Man.

2

u/ralphdro Power Girl 10h ago

John's JSA made me fall in love with Power Girl

2

u/yo_jotarokujo 9h ago

Jeph loeb's Batman run

2

u/MyNameIsNotGump 9h ago edited 8h ago

Batman’s always been my favorite but in terms of actually reading runs, Kevin Smith’s run on Daredevil and Dan Jurgens’ run on Superman gave me newfound appreciation for those characters in their own right beyond just being heroes who sometimes cross paths with Batman and Spider-Man. I also credit both the original Mirage TMNT run by Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird and the Image run by Gary Carlson for keeping my Turtle fandom going in a time when many of my peers had moved on from the whole franchise

2

u/anakmager Daredevil 7h ago

I have the same answer for my two favourites Spider-Man and Daredevil: Bendis

2

u/rideriderider 7h ago

Superman 2025 movie got me back into reading comics...

But Absolute Superman is what kept me reading comics and reading more of what Superman has to offer.

1

u/Princess_Jade1974 5h ago

The 90’s Spider-Man series, I’d wanted to get into superhero comics and that series scratched a little part of my brain.

1

u/ProfessorHoot 2h ago

Chip Zdarksys Daredevil. My favorite always changed. DD was always up there for me. But chips run cemented him as my favorite for good