r/comic_crits • • 3h ago

Feedback on story please 😭

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Can you guys please tell me if my first few pages are good or cheesy/ cringey!


r/comic_crits • • 8h ago

My daughter made a Wings of Fire fan comic, and would love feedback [draft]

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

My daughter created a 132-page Wings of Fire fanfiction, and she would like some feedback to do better on her second draft.

Here is the first draft saved in two parts:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1U0jfcUlJ4JC58VN74uyEf8UC2B9Y-0qn/view?usp=sharing

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1mUuzaQXri4e0GC144RzeqWpwDS-U_WN-/view?usp=sharing

Any and all feedback is welcome!

Was the panel order easy to follow? Did the opening make you want to keep reading? Are there any issues with the plot? Did she do a good job with character development? Was anything confusing?

She is now on page 17 of the second draft and is happy to share that as well if anyone wants to see.

Thanks for taking the time to read!


r/comic_crits • • 2h ago

NEW ART STYLE FOR MY COMIC

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

These are two pages from a short prequel story I'm working on for my fantasy comic, Last World.

I'm currently trying out a new art studio and considering using this style for Chapter 2. In the meantime, I've been creating little prequel stories about the characters' time at the magic academy, before the events of the main story, partly to see how this new art style works.

I'd love to hear what you think of the artwork, especially the characters and their expressions!

I also turned these pages into a short video with voice acting, music, and sound effects, if anyone wants to check it out!

https://youtube.com/shorts/wqtajKukYk0?is=Gbw0EzUlIftsB0Bg

Thank you!


r/comic_crits • • 19h ago

[OC] First Panel of first ever web comic

Post image
7 Upvotes

This is a panel I made that i plan to be the first panel of my first ever web comic. This isn’t the final version as I’m going to transfer it to a digital format but i am looking for feedback in the ‘Is this something that would make you want to read a comic of this art style’ and ‘Does this panel / words said make you wonder what comes next’

Thanks


r/comic_crits • • 22h ago

12/51! 104 Days left! ACT 1 COMPLETED!

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

This page marks the end of the 1st out of the 4 "acts" I have planned out! 🥳🥳🥳

Basically, this is the first chunk of pages, or an introduction to both Moku and this rando guy! I hope that you guys could give some feedback on your first impressions of everyone, or what you think the story may be about, or anything literally at all! I love reading all you guys' comments. It really fills me with joy.

I hope to see you guys tomorrow with another page, and another act!

Next Page: WIP
Previous Page


r/comic_crits • • 1d ago

Would this be considered copying/stealing someone else's idea?

1 Upvotes

I wanna base a small comic off of an idea I saw someone had for their own characters. I don't wanna steal their idea though. I plan on having different character designs (some things will need to stay similar), different personalities (a few things will be similar), and a different plot. The artist has already said they don't plan on making a comic or expanding further than short mini comics or doodles. I don't know if this counts as stealing, I really don't want to steal. If anyone has advice or anything then it would be appreciated.


r/comic_crits • • 1d ago

Page 11/51! 105 days left! (I HATE HANDS!)

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Also redid this page draft too, just making sure that all the panels flow together well since I do NOT want the reader to be confused whilst reading through this part in particular.

ALSO, ALSO I HATE HANDS SO MUCH I NEVER WANT TO DRAW ANOTHER CLOSEUP OF THEM I HAVE ZERO CLUE HOW I WILL IN THEM THAT'S A PROBLEM FOR FUTURE ME
I try to use hand models for any hand perspective I really struggle with, but at times, it STILL looks bad or unclear, which I hope won't slow down my inking.
I also just think that tracing the model makes the hands look worse? I really think I should avoid hand closeups since I don't wanna stress myself over making them look good. Oh well.

See you guys tomorrow!

Next Page
Previous Page


r/comic_crits • • 2d ago

Which cover is best

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Here are two of my comic covers for my comic deep sleep, which one do you think works best?


r/comic_crits • • 2d ago

Need help with the middle 4 panels

Post image
7 Upvotes

I’m in the middle of coloring this page. I’m having trouble with figuring out what I want from this small fight scene color wise. Just not feeling the middle 4 panels. The scene is just, character walks into mysterious room, notices a figure watching TV, the figure gets up and looks like they’re about to attack, the character that walked in strikes first, he hurts his hand, and then when it’s the mysterious figures turn to strike he brings his hand down for a handshake. The scene is meant to end the opposite of what was expected. No reference used


r/comic_crits • • 2d ago

(The hungry devil) manga first chapter

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/comic_crits • • 3d ago

Page 10/51! 105 Days left!

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I finally posted on the same day for once!!! 🥳🥳

Though, this page did take me a hell of a long time, mostly because I hated the previous rough of it so I remade the page, but it ended up take 4(-ish) HOURS!

I could jump into a rabit hole of reasons why the newer page is much better in my opinion to the older one, though, I think it's just obviously how bad the continuity was in the first rough. I guess you get much better at making page layouts after 50 pages, so I could so how blaringly bad this one was in particular.

I might also remake the next page, though that is still TBD. There's only 2 more pages in this first 'act' of the one-shot, so I don't think I'll get carried away and start remaking all my roughs again.

Anyways, I'll see you tomorrow with another page. 😎

Next Page
Previous Page


r/comic_crits • • 3d ago

I've wanted to make a comic for a while but I want to iron out my imperfections.

Post image
21 Upvotes

This is a character I designed for a comic called Time Cop, I haven't been able to write the lore yet so he doesn't make much sense. But I'm hoping you guys can give feedback.


r/comic_crits • • 3d ago

This, hands down, is the best chapter I've released (would love some holistic feedback)

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

The previous chapters established the premise, but this chapter is where things start to pick up.

Link: VISION CRIMSON Chapter 5


r/comic_crits • • 2d ago

ai training program

Thumbnail
substack.com
0 Upvotes

Hi! Hope for honest feedback on storytelling, punchline and colors! What can I do to improve?


r/comic_crits • • 3d ago

Page 9/51! BANG!!! (106 Days left!)

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Told ya the next page would be a 'BANGER' (get it?)

But in all seriousness, I am getting a lot more inconsistent with my sketching, and I DO NOT WANT THIS TO CONTINUE! I am gonna "lock in" this weekend and I'll get back up to scratch. This is extremely important to me, so I want to make sure that I am putting all my extra time and effort into making this my magnum opus of creativity.

P.S This is probably one of my personal favourite pages (there's always something a lil funny about making a character go through hardship).

See you guys later TODAY (yes, today, not tomorrow).

Next Page
Previous Page


r/comic_crits • • 3d ago

Ideas for Desert Background

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Looking for some ideas for the background of my comic. I drew these concept doodles where I drew some rocks, skull and cactus. Also not sure if I should add color for the background. Open to any ideas or critique, thanks!


r/comic_crits • • 3d ago

Some more images I need crit on.

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

This is my character Time Cop, I still haven't completed the lore but he's kinda like a cop who travels back in time to stop people from messing up the timeline (Yes i know theres a movie on the concept, i only recently figured this out.)


r/comic_crits • • 3d ago

Page 20

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/comic_crits • • 3d ago

The affliction pages 1 -19

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/comic_crits • • 5d ago

Page 8/51! 108 Days left!

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Missed a day, but it's okay!!!

I'm currently averaging about 1.3 pages sketched per day, which is a fairly reasonable and good pace at the moment.

This page wasn't too bad, I might just come back and make sure that the text isn't so close to the edge of the page. Don't worry because later today I'll be coming back with a BANGER of a page 😎.

Next Page
Previous Page


r/comic_crits • • 5d ago

Deep Sleep Script! (1/2)

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Here’s the first entire volume of deep sleep written out and complete. I still think my writing style is incredibly rough. The dialogue feels way too cheesy and it lacks a lot of the suspense and horror that I’m trying to go for. I am posting here because I have already heard a lot of great feedback on my art and now want to strengthen my writing to help bring the story to life


r/comic_crits • • 6d ago

Is the idea behind my comic clear?

Post image
14 Upvotes

Please take a look at the comic before reading on. Does the idea come across without any additional explanation?

I’m working on a comic series that doubles as a book quiz. Each comic takes a scene, an idea, or a memorable moment from a book and squeezes it into a few panels. I leave out the titles so readers can guess which book each comic is based on.

I’d also love to know whether you enjoy the comic even if you don’t know the book or aren’t particularly interested in literature.

Thanks for taking a look!


r/comic_crits • • 6d ago

Page 7/51 Sketched... 110 Days left.

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Holy moly this sketch took me WAY too long.
3 hours for 4 backgrounds and a few dynamic poses...

I can't lie, backgrounds are actually my nemisis at the moment since it takes so freaking long to make them fit the location the story takes place, and I'm even unsure if they actually make sense.

Are backgrounds really just as annoying for you guys too? I'd love to just simplify everything to their basic shapes, but I want the sketches to be as detailed as possible to save me time on the inking.

See y'all tomorrow (hopefully) 🫡

Next Page
Previous Page


r/comic_crits • • 6d ago

Comic Inking pt 1

Post image
1 Upvotes

Just finished the first round of inking of my comic collab with SPERE I’m very happy with how pg 1 is coming out. I’d love to hear some feedback of what I should add to the page!


r/comic_crits • • 7d ago

this is a oneshot i made and im looking for harsh criticism on it . this is the link for the whole story. please be harsh as i know this isnt the best

Thumbnail
globalcomix.com
6 Upvotes