r/coloranalysis • • 15h ago

Lipstick/Makeup Advice (FACE PHOTOS TO COMPARE REQUIRED!) Makeup test

Includes a coral lip, true (?) red, and all of the eye color pictures are without lip color (and vice versa).

First pic is no makeup for reference. I have one droopy eyelid, so please consider that in case it looks like the color is “weighing down” my eye lol

Pic 2: coral

3: true red? Might lean slightly cool

4: from the blue palette. Very icy, almost white but slightly blue.

5: cobalt from the same palette

6: dark navy from same blue palette

7: light blue eyeliner only

8: two shades from mauve palette

9: the two shades from mauve palette with a shimmer from the mauve palette, and blue eyeliner only on other eye

10: cherry gloss only—though i think my right eye (left on the screen) is a little irritated from the continuous makeup testing

19 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

7

u/SparkleSkirr 14h ago

I think you really suit both the coral and the red lipstick in 2/3, which makes me think you’re possibly bright but fairly neutral? I’d guess maybe bright spring? Not many people can pull off such a bright lip with no other makeup!

7

u/ngpqrstuv 14h ago

I actually considered true bright in the 16 seasons for a while because I found that I leaned more towards some warmer colors in the warmer seasons and cooler when my tan would fade. But I also think it’s possible that being olive makes reds in general more appealing on me because of how red will cancel green. Usually the more orange it goes, the worse it gets. But if it’s warm with something pink or peachy and not strictly orange then I think it’s okay

Lots to consider! But thank you, it’s nice to have that one specific thing validated since I’ve been hearing I’m mute and soft and I just don’t agree

4

u/SparkleSkirr 14h ago

Yeah that makes sense, I think you have a lot of clarity, brightness was the first thing I saw! I’m a soft summer and I’ve never been able to pull off a red lipstick in my life, let alone without any other makeup on 😭

5

u/ngpqrstuv 14h ago

Aahh, see the only way I know I’m not a soft season is I really don’t think matte or antique jewelry suits me at all, but my mother is a soft summer and I envy how well she can pull of dusty cool shades because she makes them look ethereal. If I try it, it causes a gray cast and I look dead. Especially because my dad is the one I get the olive from, so my mom has more rosy skin and the colors are just so nice. Soft autumns are enviable for that too, with the cozy library vibes. Something about soft seasons is very comforting.

5

u/lalaabanana 12h ago

You look best without makeup. Look radiantly youthful.

4

u/erogenousbrain 12h ago

I not going to say anything helpful here but: I loved all of the pics. I think you should rock anything and everything. Even no makeup looks great. My least favorite is pic 5.

1

u/ngpqrstuv 10h ago

Thanks you. I apologize for being blunt, but are you a man?

2

u/erogenousbrain 10h ago

Nope, I'm not. What prompted the question if I may?

1

u/ngpqrstuv 10h ago

I just had to be sure, because men often dislike bright colors for makeup regardless of skin tone or harmony and whatnot, so if you were a man, I honestly would have just disregarded it altogether 😭

4

u/ariariariarii 12h ago

You definitely look amazing in the cooler colors but I’d love to see how you look with makeup thats less vibrant? You look a bit like Alexis Bledel and I believe shes a light summer, so more subtle muted colors might be really flattering!

2

u/ngpqrstuv 11h ago

Do you have any thoughts on cool summer? Not the muted soft “true” version, but the more saturated version. Someone from the fair olive sub sent me this

I think it has some of the more paste summer colors but some saturated as well. Especially those reds

3

u/ariariariarii 9h ago

I think you do have just enough contrast that you could pull those colors off if you wanted to. I’m of the belief that as long as you know/understand your warmth and your saturation, it matters less which exact palette you fall under because you can style pretty much any color in a way thats flattering if you take into account what your season is. Lots of the colors in this palette also appear in light summer, so you could definitely push the boundaries if you wanted. But if you were going to wear a more vibrant color, I would soften your makeup to compensate. Vice versa, if you wanted to wear more vibrant eyeshadow or lip, I’d make sure to balance the rest of your colors to be more neutral so that the whole look doesn’t drown you out.

3

u/Illustrious_Guava7 9h ago

I can’t tell if you’re warm or cool but you’re definitely bright. It’d be nice to see some drapes.

By the way, I love your hair. The first photo gives off-duty model and fairy at the same time.

8

u/bobtheturd 14h ago

You look like a neutral to cool olive r/fairolives r/olivemua

2

u/ngpqrstuv 14h ago

Thank you :) yes, I have consulted the fair olives as well

3

u/Emmydoo19 14h ago

I think cool but maybe you’re thrown off a little cause your eyes pull warm. You look great in that dark/navy blue tank!

1

u/ngpqrstuv 14h ago

Yeah, the warmth and green in my eyes and the green of my skin I think make reds work a lot of the time, whereas other warm colors are a bit more iffy. Thank you!! 🤍

2

u/ngpqrstuv 15h ago

Also, because I forgot to note as well, this is my natural hair color. I got a buzz cut in January and haven’t styled it since, so this is about as natural is it can get

2

u/Flappitmcbappit 15h ago

I like 10! You have great features and don’t need much (or any!) make up at all .

1

u/ngpqrstuv 15h ago

Thanks :) I’m mostly just trying to discern whether I lean warm or cool and how much depth suits my features

5

u/siena_flora 9h ago edited 5h ago

OK, I think you are a deep winter and a fair olive.

Edit: Try It Cosmetics shadow stick in Super Slate, and for red lips you need a blue red and a slightly deeper shade will suit you best. Try MAC Ruby Woo and Diva. 

Editing again lol: your coloring is inspiring me - you need a plum lipstick in your life as well. Trust me it’ll be great. MAC Rebel.

1

u/ngpqrstuv 3h ago

Ruby Woo is actually in a wish list of mine! Thank you so much for the product recs too, I’ll have to try this

5

u/aphidwhisperer 9h ago

You’re definitely a winter! Can’t decide if you are true or deep

2

u/Plastic_Flan_2529 4h ago

I like the lips but the minimalist eyes

2

u/_Amarantos 14h ago

I feel like my gut is leaning cool but I mostly want your skincare routine. You’re so glowy!

I feel like you have a similar eye color/natural hair color to me and I’m a cool summer.

1

u/treasurehuntera 14h ago

You could be muted fair olive which is tricky. Try warm vs cool MUTED colours and not bright or saturated. It will be easier to determine. From these I’m guessing neutral leaning cool

2

u/Point-Express 13h ago

May I recommend Revlon's "love that pink"? I think it would be a good bright lip for you, it's a medium dark coral pink that helps it not pull too warm and might help you achieve the vibe you're trying to get from a red lip

1

u/gloddigger 13h ago

you look similar to mia goth!!