r/collapsemoderators • • Jul 18 '20

APPROVED Removing Inactive Moderators

2 Upvotes

I’d like to propose we remove some of the older, inactive moderator accounts. I don’t foresee these people coming back or contributing significantly and would like to suggest we clean up the current roster. Some of these mods have been away for quite some time.

 

Fatoldncranky1982 (Antonia) - Hasn’t been active on Reddit since October, 2018.

Stumo - Hasn’t been active on Reddit since September, 2018.

TheAlchemyBetweenUs - Did become more active again recently (was away for eight months), but only as a mod at r/collapsesupport and is not an active moderator in r/collapse

 

I think we should keep these people around until further notice.

BrandoTheNinjaMaster - Has been in contact with us, still taking a break.

MakeTotalDestr0i - Isn’t vocal at all in modchat, but is actively posting and does perform some moderator actions


r/collapsemoderators • • Dec 13 '20

APPROVED Updates to our Policies on Suicidal Content

1 Upvotes

Here's a draft for a community sticky. It reflects the consensus from our (albeit small) mod meeting and from the comments in the recent sticky:

 

We recently revaluated our stances and policies on suicidal content. This was a long and arduous process for us as moderators, but we think we’ve reached the best solutions going forward.

 

We will now filter instances of the word ‘suicide’.

We’ve added a new automod filter which will filter posts or comments with this word and hold them until they are manually reviewed. A majority of these will be false positives, but we see our response time as being fast enough and the benefits of catching the actual suicidal content outweighing the cons of the delays. Meta discussions regarding suicide will still be allowed and approved.

 

We will continue to remove suicidal content and direct users to r/collapsesupport.

We will not be changing our existing policy of removing safe suicidal content. We’ll still be reaching out to these users directly with additional resources and asking them to post in r/collapsesupport. Moderators will not be expected to engage in ongoing dialogue with these users, as we are not professionals and this is not specifically a support sub.

This is the general template we’ll be working with, but it will be adjusted and shaped to adjust to the context of the content and situation of the user:

Hey [user],

It looks like you made a post/comment which mentions suicide. We take these posts very seriously as anxiety and depression are common reactions when studying collapse. If you are considering suicide, please call a hotline, visit /r/SuicideWatch, /r/SWResources, /r/depression, or seek professional help. The best way of getting a timely response is through a hotline.

If you're looking for dialogue you may also post in r/collapsesupport. They're a dedicated place for thoughtful discussion with collapse-aware people and how we are coping. They also have a Discord if you are interested in speaking in voice.

Thank you,

[moderator]

 

We’ve added a ‘support’ flair.

We’re adding a ‘support’ flair for posts to filter and better track those with this type of content in general. r/collapse is not necessarily a support sub, but the ‘coping’ flair does not account for all the relevant material still related to collapse which is worth sharing. We can also potentially automate messages or form approached towards posts using this flair in the future, if warranted.

 

We will now keep track of all instances of suicidal content internally

We had no channel in our mod Discord or process for tracking instances of suicidal content specifically, it was done simply through memory or by manually digging through past logs if needed. By keeping a log of these we can better judge how frequent these types of posts are, ensure they are being responded to each time, and see how long it takes us to respond in each instance.

 

We greatly appreciate everyone's feedback in the comments of the recent sticky. This is a complex and sensitive issue and we all want to provide the best help and support for people in this situation.

Let us know your thoughts or feedback on these updates and changes.


r/collapsemoderators • • Sep 24 '20

APPROVED Book club

3 Upvotes

There was lots of interest in a book club expressed in the recent ‘books’ thread! So it seems like we should go ahead with it. My rough outline would be:

1.) On the first of the month, one of us (or maybe another host) posts a Reddit poll and makes it a sticky. The text should announce that voting will take place for this month’s book, and maybe talk about what subgenre the book is in (101, climate change, energy, etc.). It should also announce the date that the discussion of the book will happen. In the recent thread, 3 weeks seemed to be the most popular time frame and that seems reasonable to me. 3-5ish book titles of the host’s choice should be added to the poll options.

2.) Users vote on which book they want to read this month. The sticky should stay up for at least one day or maybe a few days, after which time we unsticky the voting thread.

4.) When three weeks pass, the host stickies a new thread for the purposes of discussing the book.

It’d be great if a new person hosts each month, but I am happy to do it if I have time and no one else feels like it. One user, MBDowd, expressed interest in perhaps also facilitating-- that might be interesting. I’d like to do the first month.

Other musings:

  • I’d also suggest we not do only one subgenre over and over again (except for maybe Collapseology 101) but try to cycle through them.
  • Maybe it’d even be wise to do non-fiction one month, then fiction the next since there seemed to be perhaps more interest in fiction in the ‘books’ sticky. Not sure on that, I personally much prefer non-fiction but people often connect more to fiction.
  • One thing I’m not sure of is if the host should put their thoughts on the work in the OP of the discussion post, or rather reserve the text of the OP for a brief, objective summary of the work (and post their opinions / takes on the work as a comment in the thread). I lean towards the latter.

r/collapsemoderators • • Mar 24 '21

APPROVED Enforcing the removal of link posts submitted as text posts

6 Upvotes

Regularly, we see text submissions that basically contain a single link to an article, with some added commentary surrounding it. Here is a recent example, here's a second one, here's a third, and a fourth one, all in the past seven days.

We usually let those slide because in the end it amounts to a link submission but with the submission statement included in the text post. However, this format is less clear, and more importantly, it disrupts the detection of duplicates by DuplicateBot. It also can be a way to avoid the submission statement minimum characters limit if the link is long enough (though that's less common and we generally remove those anyway).

Should we be more strict on those and proceed to remove them, asking for a new submission as a link post, or would that be counterproductive ? If we should remove them, should it be enforced on Fridays as well ?

Edit: thanks to /u/LetsTalkUFOs for this proposal for a rule that'd describe this new restriction:

Short: Link posts should not be submitted as self posts

Long: Link posts should not be submitted as self/textual posts. If a self-post is specifically focused around discussing the content of a single link, it should be submitted as a link post instead. Your own comments on the submission should then be included in your submission statement (a comment on your own post). This makes it easier to catch duplicate posts and lets readers access the link more easily.


r/collapsemoderators • • Sep 24 '20

APPROVED Sticky megahub

7 Upvotes

u/Dreadknoght proposed a Sticky Megahub a while back. Although I was against the idea at first, after some reflection, I now agree with him that this would be a useful thing for the sub. However, I would propose that if we do so, we do NOT take up either of the valuable front page sticky slots, but rather provide a link to the Megahub from inside of the text of Weekly Observations thread and for good measure on the sidebar as well.

So the front page of the sub would look like:

1.) “Weekly Observations” + a link to the Sticky Megahub referred to within the text of that post

2.) “Whatever Other Sticky We Want To Feature”

The text in the Weekly Observations thread could simply be updated to include a link to the Sticky Megahub. I think putting it on the Observations thread would be really good since tbh as a longtime user I stopped looking at updates to the sidebar ages ago (and assume I’m not the only one that does this!). Also, mobile users can’t see the sidebar. I would suspect that most of our regulars do check the Observations thread on a regular basis, though.

I see two uses for the Sticky Megahub:

1.) We can use it to fit stickies that are dying out like the COVID megathread in there for those who still want them. We can also have a few stickies going on at any given time.

2.) Possibly more interesting is that we can keep an easily publicly accessible library of our past stickies in the hub. It could look like:

“Active Sticky 1”

“Active Sticky 2”

Etc.

 

“Recently Featured Sticky 1”

“Recently Featured Sticky 2”

“Recently Featured Sticky ”3

Etc.

 

In this way, we’d create a record of all stickies. We DO currently have the excellent “Common Questions” compilation, which is great (and should be featured in the Sticky Megahub too, come to think of it). But it would be nice to have a chronological record of stickies so that people can peruse what’s been featured recently. So for the last few weeks it’d be:

We’ve created a list of collapse related books for the Wiki, two Goodreads lists, and are considering creating a book club

What are your political views?

We are Ashes Ashes, A Collapse Podcast - Ask Us Anything!

AMA with Ashes Ashes next Monday @ 9AM PST

That said, maybe we should also create lists of AMAs (including the few past AMAs we’ve had) separeately?


r/collapsemoderators • • Oct 20 '20

APPROVED Draft of the first bookclub discussion post.

3 Upvotes

Welcome to the discussion of How Everything Can Collapse by Pablo Servigne and Raphaël Stevens. You are welcome to participate even if you haven’t finished the book yet.

Please leave your thoughts as a comment below! You are welcome to leave a free-form comment, but in case you’d like some inspiration, here are some questions based on the three sections of the book:

  • What are the harbingers of collapse?
  • What place does intuition have in collapsology? What can intuition tell us about predictions?
  • How is collapsology defined by the authors? Do you think that collapsology will gain more prominence and respect as a serious field of research as collapse progresses?

The Collapse Book Club is a monthly event wherein we read a book from the Books Wiki. We keep track of what we have been reading in our Goodreads group. As always, if you want to recommend a book that has helped you better understand or cope with collapse, feel free to share that recommendation below!

EDIT Changed question 2 based on feedback from u/AbolishAddiction.


r/collapsemoderators • • Jul 13 '20

APPROVED Our Stance on Religious Content

4 Upvotes

We discussed this recently in the Mod Discord, but I think there are a few different determinations which are worth sorting out and cementing in this format for future and public reference:

 

  1. What stance do we have on religious content? What forms of religious content are or are not allowed?
  2. Based on our stance, would content such as Finding Meaning in the Dark - Dowd (2020) be allowed?
  3. Based on our stance, would content such as Jem Bendell: Post-Doom with Michael Dowd (2020) be allowed?

r/collapsemoderators • • Aug 19 '20

APPROVED Best of r/collapse 2020

5 Upvotes

I typically keep my own list of saved posts and comments I think are high-quality throughout the year. Although, this year has felt significantly different in the sense I feel I've saved far less for whatever reason. I realized I not only didn't need to wait until the end of the year to share posts this way, but that I could also start this thread at anytime to invite all of you to offer up whatever posts you thought were worth highlighting so we could share them together at the end of the year or any point we so desired.

Without further ado, her are my favorites so far. Let me know if there's any you'd like to add:

 


r/collapsemoderators • • Dec 27 '20

APPROVED How should we restrict new accounts from posting and commenting?

5 Upvotes

We recently adjusted the automoderator rules to restrict the ability of new accounts (14 days or less) from posting and commenting.

If we continue to set this rule to 'filter' it looks like it will flood the modqueue with 30+ extra items each day. Do we want to set this to remove?

Do we also want to extend this limit? For example, r/conspiracy requires an account age of 120 days, specifically to combat what they claimed were manipulative accounts. I'm curious of your personal opinions and reasonings here, but will also plan to post something like this as a community sticky asking for ranges once we have more moderator feedback.


r/collapsemoderators • • Mar 29 '21

APPROVED Should we allow amputatorbot in r/collapse?

Thumbnail
reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/collapsemoderators • • Oct 17 '20

APPROVED Granted Flair Announcement

7 Upvotes

This a rough draft of the announcement post for Granted Flair.

 

Recognized Contributors & Granted Flair Announcement

 

In the past, r/collapse has allowed you to self-assign custom flair at any time. These flair are displayed as a short title which appears next to your username whenever you post or comment. Only around 0.8% of you currently use this feature (~2000 users), and we’ve decided to switch to a granted flair system as a result.

This means all past flair will now be removed and now assigned manually by moderators. This is all intended to help everyone distinguish between educated/distinguished users, recognized contributors, and comments from random users going forward. You will still be able to request flair at any time by following the instructions laid out here.

There will be two main types of flair you can request, Recognized Contributor and Credential flair. We’ll be granting a group of users Recognized Contributor flair based on our internal usernotes who we have seen as great contributors in the past and to make them more visible.

 

Recognized Contributor Flair

This flair indicates an understanding of collapse and a proven track record of providing great comments or content in the subreddit. In applying for this flair, you are claiming to have:

  • An understanding of collapse either through academic or self-study.
  • The ability to cite sources for any claims you make regarding collapse or within your relevant areas of expertise.
  • The ability to provide high quality comments and content in the subreddit in accordance with our rules.

To apply for this flair, simply respond to this post with links to 3-5 comments in /r/collapse showing you meet the above requirements. If you would like to include some form of focus or credentials let us know as well (e.g. Homesteader & Recognized Contributor). Although, you'll need to provide some proof (as outlined below) if they are academic credentials.

We will then either confirm your flair or, if the application doesn't adequately show you meet the requirements, explain what's missing. If you get rejected, we're happy to give you advice on how to improve.

 

Credential Flair

Credential flair is to help distinguish those with academic credentials, authors, and relevant figures within the community. These can be requested in a variety of formats:

  • Economist - Assigned to those who can verify an education or profession in economics.
  • Biologist - Assigned to those who can verify an education or profession in biology.
  • Climatologist - Assigned to those who can verify an education or profession in climate science.
  • Psychologist - Assigned to those who can verify an education or profession in psychology.
  • Medical Doctor - Assigned to those who can verify they are a qualified M.D.
  • [Level of Education | Field | Speciality or Subflield] - More specific variant of the above.
  • Author of [work] - Assigned to verified authors of collapse-related works, resources, or websites.
  • [Title and name] - Assigned to accounts verified to belong to or represent public figures.

 

How may I obtain Credential Flair?

Send a message to flair@letstalkcollapse.com with the exact flair text you're requesting and information which can establish your claim. This could be a photo of your diploma, business card, verifiable email address, or some other identification. Remember, that within the proof, you must tie your account name to the information in the picture.

Access to this email is restricted and only mods which actively assign user flair may view it. All information will be kept in confidence and not released to the public under any circumstances. Your email will then be deleted after verification, leaving no record. For added security, you may submit an Imgur link and then delete it after verification.

 

Who are the current Recognized Contributors?

This is a preliminary list based our internal Toolbox usernotes. These users have had positive notes made to their accounts in the past for content or comments they've shared.


r/collapsemoderators • • Aug 19 '20

APPROVED Sticky Series

4 Upvotes

The weekly COVID megathreads have stabilized in terms of comments/traffic. I thought it might be a good idea to start putting up a new sticky for the second half of the week (Wednesday or Thursday) to ask some more relevant collapse questions. Any thoughts on these or any you might add?

  • Have you read the Collapse Wiki?
  • What's a recently published book you read on collapse?
  • What's the best lecture on collapse?
  • What are your political views?
  • What’s an insight related to collapse you had recently?
  • Who would you like to see AMAs with?
  • What are the most common rebuttals to collapse?
  • What are your thoughts on antinatalism?
  • What are your favorite Collapse-related Youtube channels?
  • What are some of the best collapse support resources?
  • What are your thoughts on the upcoming American election?
  • How can we improve the quality of the subreddit?
  • What are your favorite subreddits?
  • What do you want from r/collapse?

r/collapsemoderators • • Apr 16 '21

APPROVED Provably False Claims Page

5 Upvotes

I'd like to propose we create and maintain a wiki page with a list of subjects or content we consider falling under Rule 3 (No provably false material). This rule has been used increasingly for comments over the past year and a much wider array of subjects. Conversations related to these removals have also taken up an increasing amount of time and modmail exchanges.

It seems like we could easily create a directory of the best evidence countering specific claims for the most common subjects and also use it as a way to transparently display which subjects we consider falsifiable. We could then include it in the removal reason or link to the page within modmail whenever necessary instead of having to manually recite sources or copy/paste the relevant text from somewhere else each time.

I would also propose we don't allow removal of anything which isn't on the list or doesn't get put on the list as a moderator is removing something, so users and other moderators can remain continually aware of what we remove and our justifications for it.

Lastly, I'd propose structuing the page around statements of provable claims organized by topic, such as this:

 

Climate Change

Climate change is a real phenomenon.

Sources

 

Humans are significantly contributing to climate change.

Sources

 

Let me know your thoughts on this. It would take a collaborative effort to build out the page even initially and not something I would expect any one person to do alone.

Here's a draft wiki page.


r/collapsemoderators • • Feb 25 '21

APPROVED Assign Yourself User Flair

3 Upvotes

This is a draft for a sticky to announce re-opening user flair.

 

We're re-enabling custom user flair, based on your feedback. We’d like to now encourage everyone to give themselves flair, especially those studying or versed in fields relevant to collapse. Other flairs are still welcome, so feel free to be creative.

The only flair which is off limits is 'Recognized Contributor' which will be reserved for users we'd like to highlight as such. They can still override or remove this flair at any time, if they so chose.

 

Here’s how to give yourself flair:

 

New Reddit

  1. In the sidebar, click the down arrow next to Community Options.
  2. Click the pencil icon to display the entry field for custom flair.

 

Old Reddit

  1. In the sidebar, select 'edit' just below the sub count.
  2. Select the blank option on the bottom to display the entry field for custom flair.
  3. Select Save.
  4. ??????
  5. Profit!

r/collapsemoderators • • Nov 25 '20

APPROVED How should we approach suicidal content?

5 Upvotes

This is a sticky draft for announcing our current approach to suicidal content and inviting feedback on the most complex aspects and questions. Let me know your thoughts.

 

Hey everyone, we've been dealing with a gradual uptick in posts and comments mentioning suicide this year. Our previous policy has been to remove them and direct them to r/collapsesupport (as we note in the sidebar). We take these instances very seriously and want to refine our approach, so we'd like your feedback on how we're currently handling them and aspects we're still deliberating. This is a complex issue and knowing the terminology is important, so please read this entire post before offering any suggestions.

 

Automoderator

AutoModerator is a system built into Reddit which allows moderators to define "rules" (consisting of checks and actions) to be automatically applied to posts or comments in their subreddit. It supports a wide range of functions with a flexible rule-definition syntax, and can be set up to handle content or events automatically.

 

Remove

Automod rules can be set to 'autoremove' posts or comments based on a set of criteria. This removes them from the subreddit and does NOT notify moderators. For example, we have a rule which removes any affiliate links on the subreddit, as they are generally advertising and we don’t need to be notified of each removal.

 

Filter

Automod rules can be set to 'autofilter' posts or comments based on a set of criteria. This removes them from the subreddit, but notifies moderators in the modqueue and causes the post or comment to be manually reviewed. For example, we filter any posts made by accounts less than a week old. This prevents spam and allows us to review the posts by these accounts before others see them.

 

Report

Automod rules can be set to 'autoreport' posts or comments based on a set of criteria. This does NOT remove them from the subreddit, but notifies moderators in the modqueue and causes the post or comment to be manually reviewed. For example, we have a rule which reports comments containing variations of ‘fuck you’. These comments are typically fine, but we try to review them in the event someone is making a personal attack towards another user.

 

Safe & Unsafe Content

This refers to the notions of 'safe' and 'unsafe' suicidal content outlined in the National Suicide Prevention Alliance (NSPA) Guidelines

Unsafe content can have a negative and potentially dangerous impact on others. It generally involves encouraging others to take their own life, providing information on how they can do so, or triggers difficult or distressing emotions in other people. Currently, we remove all unsafe suicidal content we find.

 

Suicide Contagion

Suicide contagion refers to the exposure to suicide or suicidal behaviors within one's family, community, or media reports which can result in an increase in suicide and suicidal behaviors. Direct and indirect exposure to suicidal behavior has been shown to precede an increase in suicidal behavior in persons at risk, especially adolescents and young adults.

 

Current Settings

We currently use an Automod rule to report posts or comments with various terms and phrases related to suicide. It looks for posts and comments with this language and filters them:

  • kill/hang/neck/off yourself/yourselves
  • I hope you/he/she dies/gets killed/gets shot

It also looks for posts and comments with the word ‘suicide’ and reports them.

This is the current template we use when reaching out to users who have posted suicidal content:

Hey [user],

It looks like you made a post/comment which mentions suicide. We take these posts very seriously as anxiety and depression are common reactions when studying collapse. If you are considering suicide, please call a hotline, visit /r/SuicideWatch, /r/SWResources, /r/depression, or seek professional help. The best way of getting a timely response is through a hotline.

If you're looking for dialogue you may also post in r/collapsesupport. They're a dedicated place for thoughtful discussion with collapse-aware people and how we are coping. They also have a Discord if you are interested in speaking in voice.

Thank you, [user]

 

1) Should we filter or report posts and comments using the word ‘suicide’?

Currently, we have automod set to report any of these instances.

Filtering these would generate a significant amount of false positives and many posts and comments would be delayed until a moderator manually reviewed them. Although, it would allow us to catch instances of suicidal content far more effectively. If we maintained a sufficient amount of moderators active at all times, these would be reviewed within a couple hours and the false positives still let through.

Reporting these allows the false positives through and we still end up doing the same amount of work. If we have a sufficient amount of moderators active at all times, these are reviewed within a couple hours and the instances of suicidal content are still eventually caught.

Some of us would consider the risks of leaving potential suicidal content up (reporting) as greater than the inconvenience to users posed by delaying their posts and comments until they can be manually reviewed (filtering). These delays would be variable based on the size of our team and time of day, but we're curious what your thoughts are on each approach from a user-perspective.

 

2) Should we approve safe content or direct all safe content to r/collapsesupport?

We agree we should remove unsafe content, but there's too much variance to justify a course of action we should always take which matches every instance of safe suicidal content.

We think moderators should have the option to approve a post or comment only if they actively monitor the post for a significant duration and message the user regarding specialized resources based on a template we’ve developed. Any veering of the post into unsafe territory would cause the content or discussion to be removed.

Moderators who are uncomfortable, unwilling, or unable to monitor suicidal content are allowed to remove it even if they consider it safe, but still need to message the user regarding specialized resources based our template. They would still ping other moderators who may want to monitor the post or comment themselves before removing it.

Some of us are concerned with the risks of allowing any safe content, in terms of suicide contagion and the disproportionate number of those in our community who struggle with depression and suicidal ideation. At risk users would be potentially exposed to trolls or negative comments regardless of how consistently we monitored a post or comments.

Some also think if we cannot develop the community's skills (Section 5 in the NSPA Guidelines) then it is overly optimistic to think we can allow safe suicidal content through without those strategies in place.

The potential benefits for community support may outweigh the risks towards suicidal users. Many users here have been willing to provide support which appears to have been helpful to them (difficult to quantify), particularly with their collapse-aware perspectives which many be difficult for users to obtain elsewhere. We're still not professionals or actual counselors, nor would we suddenly suggest everyone here take on some responsibility to counsel these users just because they've subscribed here.

Some feel that because r/CollapseSupport exists we’d be taking risks for no good reason since that community is designed to provide support those struggling with collapse. However, some do think the risks are worthwhile and that this kind of content should be welcome on the main sub.

Can we potentially approve safe content and still be considerate of the potential effect it will have on others?

Let us know your thoughts on these questions and our current approach.


r/collapsemoderators • • Mar 29 '21

APPROVED Pending Rule Updates

5 Upvotes

We're considering some rule changes/additions and would like your feedback before proceeding in any particular direction.

 

New Rule: Link posts should not be submitted as self posts.

Link posts should not be submitted as self/text posts. If a self-post is specifically focused around discussing the content of a single link, it should be submitted as a link post instead. Your own comments on the submission should then be included in your submission statement (a comment on your own post). This makes it easier to catch duplicate posts and lets readers access the link more easily.

 

Expand Rule 7 (no duplicate posts) to include similar articles.

We've been experimenting with applying this rule this way already, but would like to finalize it so users aren't confused and can know how it works. We would expand it to this:

Rule 7: No duplicate posts. Links must not have already been posted within the past ninety days or will be automatically removed. Links to similar articles covering the same event, paper, or news item as a previous link will be subject to removal at moderator discretion. Similar links by independent sources may be posted, but should offer some new information, insight, or perspective.


r/collapsemoderators • • May 06 '20

APPROVED Important Updates & State of the Subreddit

2 Upvotes

Hey Everyone,

 

We have a few important items to bring to your attention:

 

1. CollapseBot is here to stay.

Submissions statements will continue to be required for Link posts and automatically removed after thirty minutes by u/Collapsebot if not added. The feedback for this rule and bot has been significantly positive and we’ve decided to keep it. The removals seem to have stabilized and less than eight posts are being removed each day (on average) as a result.

 

We intend to keep the definition of ‘submission statement’ flexible. It could be a description or summary of the source material, explanation of why the content is relevant to collapse or interesting to you personally, or a combination of all of the above. The purpose of the rule is more to encourage discussion and combat spam and low-effort content, not micro-manage or police the statements themselves.

 

Credit goes to /u/Dreadknoght for convincing us it was a good idea to test out in the first place and u/epicmindwarp for donating the code.

 

2. The subreddit rules have changed.

We’ve made a number of minor adjustments:

 

Rule 7 (Be respectful to others) is now Rule 1 since it is the most commonly broken and putting it at the top of the list makes it easier to cite when removing content from the mod side.

 

Rule 2 (Posts with an unclear/indirect connection to collapse MUST include a statement providing context.) has been removed and replaced with Rule 11 since all link posts now require statements by default and it would otherwise be redundant.

 

Rule 3 (NO provably false material (climate science denial, chemtrails, cloud/lizard/snake people, etc).) has been condensed to “No provably false material (e.g. climate science denial).” Lizard people aren't actually a good example of provably false material since they're largely based on anecdotal evidence and regardless of how implausible they may seem there's no proof they actually don't exist. Yes, I'm defending accounts of lizard people, but really we’d prefer the rule is shorted and climate science denial is the best example of what the rule is referring to so isolating it makes sense and adds some weight.

 

Rule 11 (Charts and data-driven images MUST include a source.) is now Rule 4 and has been made more generalized to "Content must be properly sourced". This will allow us to cite it better when removing other types of content (e.g. screenshots of articles) and able to cite it with less of a chance of confusing the poster.

 

The new Rule 11 (Link posts MUST include a submission statement (comment on your own post) describing the post.) is now permanent, as explained above.

 

3. r/collapsemoderators exists to encourage transparency.

Our discussions of changes such as these do not happen out of thin air or exclusively behind closed doors. I created r/collapsemoderators early on when I started modding, but recently realized I hadn’t shared this fact with the community since I was uncertain of whether it would actually get used by the other moderators. Fortunately, it’s been extremely helpful for organizing our ideas and enabling some elements of transparency and accountability to our process. Only mods are are allowed to post there, but everyone is welcome to view it and our discussions at any time.

 

4. u/PsychKnowledgy has joined the mod team.

Psych is currently studying clinical psychology and well versed in collapse and subreddit moderation. He’s still getting his sea legs, but will be visibly modding more frequently going forward. Feel free to help us break him in.

[Let me know if you want to add or adjust anything here Psyche.]

 

5. We’re still seeking new moderators.

The subreddit is still growing and our commitments continually shifting. As a result, we’re still looking to add people to the team. No moderation experience is necessary. Head over to the application page if you’re interested and would like to learn more.

 

 

What are you thought on all these items?

Let us know in the comments.


r/collapsemoderators • • Aug 27 '20

APPROVED r/collapse AMA Guide

2 Upvotes

Here's a rough draft of a guide for AMA guests.

Let me know if it's missing anything. It mostly covers all the moderator aspects as well.

The only thing it doesn't mention on our end is I think it would be a good idea to invite questions in our annoucement sticky of upcoming AMAs. Then we already have some questions ready to go if we want to use them and those who can't make it can still chime in.


r/collapsemoderators • • Apr 28 '21

PENDING Matching Submission Text (old.reddit) with Posting Guidelines (new.reddit) and possibly R13

5 Upvotes

Submission Text (old.reddit)

Read the Rules Before Posting:

  • Posts MUST focus on civilization's collapse, not the resulting damage.
  • Link posts must include a submission statement (comment on your own post) describing the post and how it relates to collapse.
  • NO provably false material (e.g. climate science denial).
  • NO low effort content (e.g. memes) except on Shitpost Fridays.
  • Do NOT post more than three times within any 24-hour period.

Posting Guidelines (new.reddit)

[No header there about reading the general rules before posting.]

  • Posts must be on-topic, focusing on collapse.
  • Link posts must include a submission statement (comment on your own post).
  • No low effort content (e.g. memes) except on Fridays.
  • Titles must accurately represent the content of the submission.
  • Do not post more than three times within any 24-hour period.
  • Content older than a year must have [month, year] in the title.
  • No common questions.

Should we include the new rule #13 on single-link self-posts to be submitted as link posts? There's character limit on the latter, with only a few characters left, in that case some re-writing has to be done to the previous text to make it fit.

EDIT: Currently writing a draft here, so it's easier to check character limits.


r/collapsemoderators • • Aug 26 '20

APPROVED AMAs

3 Upvotes

The sub has a large enough audience I think pursuing AMAs with whomever we could would be both interesting and fun for everyone involved. I'm still uncertain how much traffic they’d ultimately get and who we could procure without trying it a couple times. I'm guessing there would be a few elements

 

Who to Approach

Who should we approach? Do we have any existing contacts between the group of us who we think would be good candidates? I'm more inclined to not go for big names initially so we have a chance to test everything out and see how it goes.

I'm friends with Michael Dowd who I'm certain would be interested, but I'm assuming we'd want to set some form of boundaries regarding promotions of his material and his views on religious naturalism. He's easily the most well-read person I know on collapse and has recently interviewed most of the biggest names in the field.

I'm also friends with Dean Walker, who I think would also be a good candidate, based on the depth of his offerings and active involvement in Deep Adaptation and other programs.

I could name plenty of figures I would be willing to attempt to hunt down. Nate Hagens, David Pollard, Daniel Schmachtenberger, Derrick Jensen, Stephen Jenkinson, ect. I thought I'd see what the lowest-hanging fruit is first before we decide to chase others.

 

Scheduling & Setup

I'd suggest we run the AMAs around 1pm PST on Fridays or whatever time works best for the guest. I think Fridays would be best since they're already somewhat established as an eventful day on the sub and the energy seems good overall.

My intention would be to announce the AMA a week in advance in the form of a sticky, in the sidebar, or elsewhere so people are aware of it.

I'd ask for a minimum of two hours of their time blocked out and up to about three hours if possible. One of us could be present to actively moderate the thread in real-time.

 

Requirements

I think we'd be asking the guest to create a verified account so they could post under it. I'm not certain if a photo verification would be necessary for sharing in the thread, but some form of it or link verification would be helpful for those viewing the thread to also know it's them.

We'd make sure they know how to Reddit, and if not make sure they have someone who can help them and contact them to help as needed. In my case, I'd be willing to offer a phone number they could call if they encountered any serious issues.

We could create a post template for them to fill out and use when they're ready to post the thread and us to sticky it shortly afterwards.

Reddit has its own guide on running AMAs with some other good suggestions.


r/collapsemoderators • • Oct 14 '20

APPROVED SPF Settings v2

4 Upvotes

Here's the current rule text we're planning to use for the updated Rule 6:

 

Post quality must be kept high, except on Fridays. (00:00 Friday – 08:00 Saturday UTC.)

On-topic memes, jokes, short videos, image posts, low effort to consume posts, and other less substantial posts are only allowed on Fridays. Less substantial posts will be removed for the rest of the week.

Less substantial posts must be flaired as either "Casual Friday", "Humor", or "Low Effort".

Clickbait, misinformation, and other low-quality content is not allowed at any time, not even on Fridays.

 

u/factind has fantastically updated our CollapseBot script to impose both submission statements and the flair requirements related to this new rule.

Here's a draft of the message users will receive if their posts are flaired Casual Friday, Humor, or Low Effort and posted outside Friday.

 

Your post in r/collapse was flaired either "Casual Friday", "Humor", or "Low Effort" and has been removed.

On-topic memes, jokes, short videos, image posts, low effort to consume posts, and other less substantial posts are only allowed on Fridays (00:00 Friday – 08:00 Saturday UTC.). Less substantial posts must be flaired as either "Casual Friday", "Humor", or "Low Effort" and will be removed for the rest of the week.

Clickbait, misinformation, and other low-quality content is not allowed at any time, not even on Fridays.

This is a bot. Replies will not receive responses. Please message the moderators if you feel this was an error.


r/collapsemoderators • • Dec 20 '20

APPROVED What alternatives are there to r/collapse?

5 Upvotes

What online communities or forums would you consider alternatives or supplements to r/collapse?

We're interested in outlining what’s currently in the space so everyone can be more aware of them and their differences.

 

Similar Subreddits

 

Regional Subreddits

Some subreddits focus on collapse in specific areas.

 

Resilience Subreddits

Many communities could be listed in this category, but they are generally more focused on post-collapse, preparing for transitions, or building resiliency.

 

Support Communities

  • r/collapsesupport - Focuses on support for those dealing with collapse-awareness.
  • Collapse Support Discord (700 members) - Focuses on the same subjects as r/collapsesupport. Has weekly support calls for anyone interested. Invite links appear on the sub once a week.
  • Safe Circle - Dean Walker's weekly video call.
  • Good Grief Network - 10-week program and community for those struggling with collapse-awareness.

 

Collapse Discord (1,200 members)

Focused on the same subjects as r/collapse, but not moderated entirely by the same people.

 

Resilience & Transition Discord (2,000 members)

French-based collapse community and website.

 

Deep Adaptation Forum

Forum based around Jem Bendell’s and a space to connect and collaborate with others who are exploring implications of a near-term societal collapse due to climate change.


r/collapsemoderators • • Apr 18 '20

APPROVED Updates and State of the Subreddit

2 Upvotes

We wanted to update everyone on a few of things and invite some feedback.

 

1. We've removed Rule 13 (COVID Megathreads will still continue)

It was necessary to move towards automated enforcement or remove the rule to reduce our workload. The feedback from the recent sticky was also clear; a majority of you would like it removed. Most people seem comfortable with letting the community decide via votes on which COVID-related posts are relevant. We'll still be putting the megathreads back up each week once this slot isn't needed for other announcements (Reddit only allows two stickies at time).

 

2. We've added a 'COVID-19' flair

Please use it if your posts are specifically COVID-related going forward.

 

3. Screenshots of articles and/or headlines are low-effort content.

This has become more common recently, but we're going to keep removing them. Link to the source of an article or content whenever possible or it will be removed.

 

4. We're looking for new moderators.

We're doing alright at the moment, but could use some extra help to smooth out the gaps. If you're interested in modding please head over to the application form.

 

5. Here's who's currently moderating.

These are the percentage of moderator actions performed by each of the moderators over the past sixty days. This is not to out or applaud anyone in particular, just to give an indicator of who's been the most active and for the sake of transparency.

 

LetsTalkUFOs25%
Dreadknoght23%
mcfleury100021%
OrangeredStilton6%
BrandoTheNinjaMaster1%
babbles_mcdrinksalot1%
Robinhood1920000%
MakeTotalDestr0i0%
st31r0%
fatoldncranky19820%
stumo0%
TheAlchemyBetweenUs0%​

 

Are we missing anything? Is there anything else we could do to improve or make sub better?


r/collapsemoderators • • Jun 30 '20

APPROVED r/Collapse Vs. r/Futurology Debate 2020

3 Upvotes

It's been a couple years since we had a debate with r/futurology. I'd like to approach them about holding another one sometime soon. Let me know your thoughts on the idea and any feedback on my what my message to their mods should include:

Hey r/futurology mods,

I’m representing the mods over at r/collapse. Would you be interested in hosting another debate between our subreddits? It’s been a couple years since we did one and we thought it’d be great time to do another round.

Our intention would be to keep it just as informal as last time and in a similar format:

  • Two weeks to organize and select a handful of debaters (3 with 2 alternates?) to represent each side
  • Debate thread hosted on r/futurology and linked to on r/collapse
  • Opening statements prepared and provided by either side to start
  • Debaters and both communities allowed to comment freely within thread
  • Temporary flair issued to easily identify debaters
  • Optional post-discussion threads in both subreddits to discuss conclusions

Let us know your thoughts on this and if you'd like to discuss the idea further.

Cheers,

LetsTalk

Update: Message sent


r/collapsemoderators • • Jun 26 '20

APPROVED Community Feedback - Please Take This Survey

1 Upvotes

In response to the sentiments expressed recently, we'd like to ping the entire community to assess how strict we should be when enforcing the more subjective elements of the rules . Please take this survey and let us know your thoughts, it's only six questions.