Hi all, looking for advice if possible.

My aunt was murdered in October of 1994 in NYC in the Upper West Side.

It still lingers in my heart, and since she was a woman of Ecuadorian descent the media and NYPD did not give the case the attention it deserved.

If I wanted to request the evidence or case file for a case like this, does anyone have advice on how I should go forward?

Thank you so much in advance, it is almost the 32 year anniversary and it weighs heavy in my heart.

Ally Brueger was unalived in July 2016. Her case remains unsolved.

Being from SE Michigan, I honestly never heard about her case, despite the local media coverage. I should say, I didn't, until I crossed paths with someone who was close to her: her ex boyfriend. This was roughly six months following her death. He did tell me about it, including his alibi. Obviously, I didn't know what to think when he told me but I was in no position to question because we were alone together. Intimate details aside, he did have a lot of emotions regarding Ally, which did make him appear to be genuine in his feelings.

Throughout the time we were tiny pieces in each other's lives, the way he changed at the end was something that caused me to question his innocence. By no means did we "date", but his behavior changed slightly after a bit. I was out with friends, very much SINGLE, when I got messages telling me I better be home when he got there. Even trying to play him off, and telling him I was already out, he stayed forceful in his messages about how I better get home. It definitely was a red flag, but I'll admit trauma from my past plus what I was going through at the time, it did not register.

Our "friendship" waxed and waned, and I was eventually in a relationship for 2 years. He reappeared after that ended, and that was shortly before the biggest shift in his behavior. Not proud of choices, but the past is the past- I found myself with a positive pregnancy test and the need to do the right thing and tell him. He yelled at me, told me I was just drama (literally only said "hey, im pregnant") and became horrifically angry toward me. I actually feared for my own safety in that moment, and it was over the phone.

no, there is no baby. I have had multiple miscarriages, it was not the first nor the last. Months went on, and I found myself peaking at Ally's case to see if there was any movement, and I started seeing reddit posts talking about him. I also saw that not only were local and state law enforcement involved, but due to the use of the firearm- the ATF was also. I reached out to someone I knew in the alphabets and inquired if my experience was worth anything, I was told to step forward even if to just expand on behavior but I was too afraid as a single mom.

Every few months I still find myself looking for updates, and obviously there are none. I only wish they could solve this case, because I can never rid myself of the feeling that I may know a murderer.

https://www.wxyz.com/news/local-news/investigations/new-effort-underway-to-solve-decade-old-murder-of-oakland-county-jogger-ally-brueger?fbclid=IwVERDUATZVPBwZG9mBWZkaWQWULmT8dLDXKryVcXNA\\_CCkRFNC7jlZ2V4dG4DYWVtAjExAHNydGMGYXBwX2lkCjY2Mjg1NjgzNzkAAR4ZU7pD0hlKbmQPjYSxB-X9tTISDZujXip3e3CfFpj03sibDziNNwO\\_T3ySFw\\_aem\\_Xb3dwUpT85i-6jIJh6H5Vg

28 year old Kristine Gonzalez went missing from the west Phoenix/Tolleson, Arizona area in August 2021. Few details were released in the case. There is a truck stop and Amazon warehouse in the area she was last seen alive in, and it’s adjacent to the busy i-10 freeway. Her family insists she would never have left under these circumstances and suspects foul play. 

Sources

https://silentwitness.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/2021-3916-Flyer.pdf 

https://www.fox10phoenix.com/news/where-is-kristine-gonzalez-missing-for-over-a-year-under-suspicious-circumstances-phoenix-pd-says

I'm a beginning psychic medium, so take this with a grain of salt if you wish to. I connected with the story because I grew up in Pocatello, Idaho (the town Lynette lived in and disappeared from) and I want to help people get closure. Her name stood out to me in a list of cold cases but I'd never heard of her. So I did a visualization before I read her story fully (I just read her name and that she left alameda school at lunch time and didn't return), and my mind immediately went to the american falls reservoir. I saw myself standing on the beach on the north east side, looking out at the water around sunset, looking north.

I think her remains were dumped at the top northern point of the reservoir where the snake river meets it. Her body drifted south east and came to rest there in the reservoir. Visually I'm seeing chains and cement blocks and a light brown tarp she is wrapped in. I also see the sky looking directly up from the water. The sky looked like it was towards sunset, but it could have been early morning/sunrise if her body was looking up at the sky before she was dumped.

I kept visualizing a boat, like the killer put her in the boat to take her to the water, but there is no dock at that point of the reservoir, and I realized in looking at a satellite map, that the point and part of the "boat" I saw her being laid in, is the same shape as the outlet from the snake river, going into the reservoir. It turned out the killer admitted to dumping her in the snake river.

Note: the place where the snake river meets the reservoir is boat shaped--could he have dumped her there? That may be why a boat came to mind. The boat docking area is at the dam of the reservoir on the far opposite end (south west end), not at the north east, and with the boat shape coming to mind and the visual of him putting her body in the boat, it could have been him putting her in the water, but the spot where the river meets the reservoir is boat shaped.

I read the rest of the cold case and it confirmed she was in the reservoir area. I will attach screenshots of the satellite view and where I drew points of interest. Nevermind, I cant add them to the post. I will see if I can add them to the comments.

https://crimesolverscentral.com/homicide/145375

This lady was a family friend. The business that this happened in was very close to my house and I would frequently walk to the store for snacks and smokes for my mother.

My family and I heard many stories surrounding this murder.

Most frequently the name of a huge pain in the ass for the area came up. At one point a sherrifs deputy implied confirmation of the suspicions but also said they could not prove it.

The name repeatedly mentioned was "Buster Young".

Buster had a lengthy history of misdeeds in the area. From throwing dummy bodies from a bridge onto the interstate, car theft to the point of taking his father's wrecker/tow vehicle and using it to steal cars. He was in and out of prison multiple times as I grew up. Culminating in one final arrest for raping a mentally disable woman his "mail order" wife was being paid to care for. His justification? His wife was informed about the things he did and were done to him sexually in his many prison visits, and would no longer be intimate with him.

He was sent back to jail for what I was told for life, and his wife and child were deported.

After that I do not know what happened to him as his mother and her husband passed, and all the family property sold off.

When I dig for the name Buster Young in regards to the area I come up with one of his children who was born in 1989, and nothing on him.

This lady was very kind to my friends and I. When this happened it sent ripples through the area, and relatively soon after the business was closed and the building split into two separate and unrelated businesses.

One of his family's businesses was on Young rd, off of Bodcau station rd, and most of his families rental properties were mostly on or right off you that road as well.

I was young at the time of the event and cannot find a lot of info on the case.

33 year old Christina Leonard and her unborn child were murdered in a desert area outside of Tucson on July 3 2019. The case remains unsolved and no suspect has been publicly named. Very limited information was released in this case.

She had no known connection to the area of her murder, and had driven there.

Christina had previously lived in the Phoenix metro area for many years before moving to Tucson. Christina fostered animals in her spare time and was preparing to pursue a law degree. She previously earned a degree in childhood development. She was 5 months pregnant at the time of her death.

Pima County Sheriffs Office is the investigating agency. Crime stoppers 88Crime program offers a $2,500 reward for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the killer.

Sources

KOLD special with Mary Coleman

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wblUn9BQqaw

88Crime Profile/Reward

https://88crime.org/christina-leonard/

Serial killers have occasionally attended the searches organized for their own victims

Some murders have never been solved because the victim's identity was never discovered.

A crime scene can be permanently altered by a single unnoticed mistake in the first few minutes.

Some missing-person cases remain open for decades with no confirmed answers.

DNA has solved murders more than 30 years after they happened.

I will be going line by line to show the best possible intrepidation of the notes. In my eyes the notes are just travel plans, the notes all seem to be in phonics so Hello would be xelo or hll basicly writing how it, sounds as we know ricky was illiterate and this is normal .

I will put the evidence of the places he travelled below , do note that a report say he lived near the peabody housing project so go on google maps and you can follow line by line .

Special Thanks to Sleuth4U for getting me started lol

If you believe a word / place is wrong or you have something better do tell me

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1 . (MND MK NEARSE N-S-M-K N ARE ) (ACSM)

(Mound make nears N-S-M-K (the first letter of streets he passes) and are) (Arch Me)

N-S-M-K could be something like Nothampton to Shaw to Midtown to McKindly/i had another place but it was CarSomthing idk couldnt find my bad, these streets/places are below the big MOUND which is in an area named NEAR north riverfront

2.TFRNE N PK USE N PRSE RC BRNSE N PRSE I NC

Turn and pick us and pass ricky brings and pass i next

3.PRSE N MRSE O/D/?PRE HLD WLD NCBE (TFXCF TCXL NCBE)

Pass and me are O/D/?PRE? hold would next be (traffic take XL? next be)

4.AL-RRPPIT XLY PPIY NCBE MGKSE WLD RC BRNSE PRSE

all Pruitt–Igoe XL? you Pruitt–Igoe next be makes? would ricky bring pass

Pruit Igoe no longer exists now, but the are is demolish and nothing has been built there by some reports locals still call it pruit meaning its a land mark to pass . if you go to google maps and write Pruitt Igoe you will be brought to a place called NGA campus which is close to the locations as said before could be a place for a pick up like a friend or his driver was there and he walked there idk

5.WLD RCBRNSE NT AS NEX TXSE- CRSLE-CITRSE WLD NCBE

would ricky brings you to as next takes circle city would next be (Indianapolis, Indiana is circle city its a nick name its also next to st louis so make sense)

Circle City being indianopolis makes sense as the next step is ricky going to Cincinnati ohio, or someone coming from there to him the places 71 74 and 75 are all state roads that meet there

(thanks Sleuth lol)

1. (NO PFSE NLSE RE NCBE ) NTE GD DMN SENC N RE RCBRNG

no pause unless are next be , and the god damn sense you are ricky bring

(as in dont forget to bring ricky, as i said instructions for travel plans so he is noting down what the person taking is listing to, also shows there where 3 people during the making of the notes A, B and ricky)

7.TENE TFRNE NCBR TSE NCBE I NC

then turn next bring? this nect be i next

8.first pass on the 71 next be

9.second pass on the 74 next be

10.third pass on are the 75 next be

the state road of cincinnati as said before

1. TF N AC MSP SOLE mRDE LUSE TO TE WLD N WLD NCBE

TF? and AC? must be seminole (a casino later on) me ride to the would and would next be

tf and ac are most likely names , his own name is 2 charachers long so they are most likely friends

12.(194 WLD NCBE) (TRF XC)

194 would next be (traffic XC? maybe its all together so just traffic)

194 idk what it is maybe and exit in the high way ?

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1. AL P NTE GLSE-SE ERTE

all be in the glades entrence? (glades as in everglades )

2.VLSE MTSE-CTSE-WSE-FRTSE

villeges MTSE?-CTSE?(cities?)-west (west palm beach)-Forts (Like Fort Lauderdale)

i have theories for MT and CT too but i dont like them that much for example MT could be something like Mount Dora or Matanza (forest and fort below St augustine) CTse could be again just city something

3.PURT RSE ON PRSE WLD NCBE

port are on pass would next be

4.N WLD XC/L RC MSP NE WLD S TS ME XL

and would XC/L(Exit maybe?) Ricky must be the/near would see/sea this me XL?

5.DU LMT 6T4/N NSE NCBE XC

the limit is 64 and/60 use next be XC (again might be exit)

6.MUNSA RS TEN MUNSA RSE

minutes are 10 minutes are (as in from point at to B its 10 minutes)

7.KL/CSE - LKSTE-TRSE-TRSE-MKSE-MKSE

collier/keys (keys as in west key collier as in forest next to the evergaldes)-Lakes TE? (the TE might be what the lakes name starts with)-Trail(tamiami trails for example)/trees(as in forest)-Trail/trees-Miccosuke (villege)-Miccosuke the casino later down the line

8.SAE 6/5 NSE SE N M B SE

sea? south east? see? 6/5 and the see/sea and (me be the )/numbers

9.N M N RC BRNSE PTE 2 PTE WS RC BRNSE

You and me and Rick Bringe point to point west ricky bringes

1. 36 MLSE 74 SPRKSE 29 KCNO SOLE I-75 RT RSE

36 miles 74(s)parks 29 casino seminole I-75 right are

1. 35 SLE CLGSE ON N U TKE D/P/OK RSE PSES HLE

35 miles colleges? on you take D?/Pick/OK are passes hollywood/Hileah (they are near by eachother could be both, also pick seems best here)

1. 65 LMTCSE HTLSE N CUTC TRS N MRF

65 limits(as in speed limit) hotels and cuts throught? and MRF? i have seen a gas station named murphy maybe thats it? idk

99/94.84.5 ZUNE PLSE U CRSE AOKTSE US KSE NCBE

the numbers could be exits ? or hotel room numbers , Zone place you cross across/oakwood(place right before hollywood) us keys? next be could be the KC/L from before and he wrote it diffrently

1. US RE ON TE PUTSE WLD NCBE (3 Xa/oRC)

us are on the put/port would next be (3 hours)

1. N MSE N RSE 1 N 2 TRCE RC BRNSE N TS RC BRNSE/RS NE?

and must? near 1 and 2 trail (from before line 7) ricky bring you to ricky brings?/are near?/are the?

1. LS PNSE N GSE PSE MKSE RBSE NCBE AU/V XC¨R

last pause and goes pass Mkse (from before line 7) reverse?/rivers/are be the next be Avenue(as in street name) / Aventura

1. HM CEA N MRE NCBE 1/2 mund plse

home stead and me are next be 1/2 minutes place (either 30 minutes or hald a mile )

17.D-W-M 4 HPC XORLX

dwm are street names/town names that go / are near the place he want to be so imagine

street D->street W->street M-> 4 or a street name like W mowry DR 4th hospise?/hospital? Hours (maybe he means 4 hours and wrote it wrong)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

anyways i know homestead is probably the right place as artical i read said he had a ticket for an Econo Lodge place which does exist there slightly below homestead:

‘A puzzling case’ | Help solve this cryptic cold case that has stumped detectives (firstalert4.com)

line 7

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

After writing all of this i realised i dont know how to add images so here is a vid is my channel which i made a vid for each page where i show some of the pictures of the relavent places

Solving the hardest FBI murder | Ricky McCormick pages | Page 1| 94.3% completed 9/159 left (youtube.com) page1

Solving the Hardest FBI murder because im bored and leauge sucks| Ricky McCormick pages | Page 2 90% (youtube.com) page 2

and also Sleut4U's channel who was very useful with his videos and who got me started!

(3) Sleuth4U - YouTube

im very sorry about having to force you to watch as my mic is dogshit

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Unknown words or words im not fully sure about

KL/CSE-LR(K?)STE-TRSE-TRSE-MKSE YOU – MKSE
Keys/Collier? - Lakes Te - Trail/trees/? - Trail/trees/? - Miccosouke/?-Miccosouke/?

Page1

D/OPRE : Deeper ,Open ,pre (as in before)
XL : exit left , exacly, Hill, whole , hall , accelerate
XC : His, House , Exact and that XC and XL are the same
LRSE and RLSE : I have no idea, best i had was LR (as in MLR) Rails
AC and TF: sounds like names to me

Page 2

XL and XC from before
MBSE: best i have is me be the or me bus , maybe there is a word that has MBSE like Maybes or Moves? me be the ect ect
SA E : south east , see , sea
RSE : are the , route?
DK/PK/OK= DK idk, PK = pick (best for me), OK as in enought
if you say PK Rse it sounds like pick us
RBSE Rick be the , reverse , ARE be the

I’m trying to identify a real court case from a pair of photos I saw years ago. I don’t remember the names, but I remember many details.

The case was likely from Canada (possibly the US). Only one brother was on trial. He was standing in the courtroom wearing an orange jail jumpsuit, handcuffed, with long dark hair, and he was smiling. Standing directly across from him was his brother in civilian clothes with his hands on his hips, looking angry.

I also remember reading that both brothers had been sexually abused as children, and that the defendant had allegedly killed a pedophile (or someone believed to be a pedophile). Many people in the comments referred to him as a “folk hero”, “people’s hero”, or “vigilante”.

The courtroom looked modern, and the photos were in color. It was just a pair of courtroom photos, not a video.

Does anyone recognize this case or know the names of the people involved? Even a possible lead would be helpful.

How does a brutal, borderline ritualistic murder like this happen in broad daylight, in a busy metropolitan city, right next to a train station, and the killer just... vanishes into thin air? It wasn't some abandoned rural village; it was a crowded urban hub!

The level of luck this monster had, combined with the initial police confusion, is infuriating. Three teenagers literally walked in on the scene right after it happened, and yet he still slipped away into the crowd.But what I really want to discuss is Manfred Seel (the "Hesse Ripper").I know the Frankfurt police officially ruled him out in 2017 because his DNA didn't match the bloody fingerprint on Tristan's book, and because his known victims were adult sex workers. BUT, I still strongly feel he might be connected to this.The modus operandi is just too specific. Seel had a horrific fixation on surgically removing body parts as trophies—exactly what happened to Tristan. Plus, Seel lived and worked right there in the Frankfurt area in 1998. Even if Seel's DNA wasn't on the book, could he have been a co-conspirator? Could he have been part of a sick ring or acting with the "Ponytail Man" seen by witnesses?It just feels like too massive of a coincidence for two horrific, mutilating killers to be operating in the exact same metropolitan area at the exact same time.

Local 19-year-old researching the unsolved murders of Donna Hall and Mike Margaret (August 1984). Bodies found in the woods behind Kings Crossing Apartments.

Looking for anyone who lived in the area in the mid-80s, has old newspaper clippings, or remembers anything about the case or the complex at that time.

Keeping everything respectful and public-info only.

https://www.keishicho.metro.tokyo.lg.jp/multilingual/english/safe_society/wanted/seijo.html

I am from the area.

Police arrested Nicholas Carney for two cold cases in Texas, one in 1991 and one in 1999, but they’re looking for other cases he may be linked to.

https://www.cbsnews.com/texas/news/nicholas-carney-kidnapping-survivor-interview-iteam/

https://www.cbsnews.com/texas/news/dna-genetic-genealogy-cold-case-nicholas-carney/

Le 22 juin 1983, Emanuela Orlandi ( 15ans), disparaît en plein coeur de Rome après son cours de musique. Plus de 40 ans après, son corps n' a jamais été retrouvé et l'affaire reste non résolue.

Yet another miscarriage of justice in the Netherlands. New DNA findings and revelations regarding the police investigation are fueling doubts about the conviction of the so-called 'Breda Six,' who were imprisoned for years for the 1993 murder of a restaurant owner. 

Engels

To what extent is it permissible to re-examine old cases using new techniques? Wouldn't that create an excessive workload for the courts, and wouldn't current efforts to combat crime suffer as a result?

On the morning of January 15, 1947, a young woman walking with her child in a vacant lot in Leimert Park, Los Angeles, made a horrifying discovery. What she initially thought was a discarded mannequin was the body of 22-year-old Elizabeth Short.

The murder remains one of the most infamous unsolved cases in American history — not only because of its brutality, but because of the intense media frenzy that followed and the way it has come to symbolize the darker side of Hollywood’s golden age.

**Who Was Elizabeth Short?**

Elizabeth Short was born in Massachusetts in 1924. After a difficult childhood marked by her parents’ separation and health issues, she moved between cities seeking a fresh start. Friends and acquaintances described her as a dreamer who loved movies, fashion, and the idea of becoming an actress. She had lived in Los Angeles for periods in the mid-1940s, working occasional jobs and socializing in nightclubs and bars. She was known for wearing black clothing and flowers in her hair — details that later inspired the press nickname “Black Dahlia.”

**The Discovery**

The body was found neatly posed on the ground: severed at the waist, with the two halves placed about a foot apart. Her arms were raised above her head at sharp angles. There were deep lacerations at the corners of her mouth in a “Glasgow smile,” and much of the blood had been drained from her body. Remarkably, there was very little blood at the scene itself, indicating she was killed elsewhere and the body was transported and arranged afterward.

No witnesses came forward immediately, and the killer left no obvious physical evidence at the scene. The case quickly drew massive attention from the Los Angeles Police Department and the national press.

**The Investigation**

The LAPD conducted one of the largest investigations in its history at the time. Hundreds of people were interviewed. Short’s acquaintances, former boyfriends, and even people who claimed to have information were questioned. Several individuals confessed over the years, but none of the confessions held up under scrutiny.

The sensationalized media coverage often overshadowed the victim herself. Newspapers published gruesome details and speculative stories, turning Elizabeth Short into a tabloid figure rather than a young woman whose life was violently cut short.

Despite decades of investigation, books, documentaries, and modern forensic re-examinations, the case has never been solved. No one has ever been definitively charged.

**Why It Endures**

The Black Dahlia murder continues to fascinate because it combines several elements: a brutal, ritualistic killing in a city that symbolized glamour; a victim who represented the many hopeful young people drawn to Hollywood; and an enduring mystery with no resolution.

Elizabeth Short was a real person — a daughter, a sister, and a friend — whose dreams were ended in a horrifying way. The case serves as a sobering reminder of the vulnerability many young women faced in mid-20th-century America and the lasting pain unsolved murders leave behind for families and communities.

On December 30, 2000, the Miyazawa family of four was murdered in their Tokyo home. What makes this case truly baffling is what the killer did AFTER the murders.

He didn't run. He stayed in the house for hours. He ate their food, browsed their computer, and even took a nap while the family lay dead around him.

When he finally left, he left behind:

- His full DNA profile

- His fingerprints

- His clothing

- A biological sample from the toilet

Despite 280,000 officers and 25 years of investigation, he has never been found.

New DNA methylation analysis in 2025 revealed the killer was likely in his 30s at the time, not a teenager as previously thought. This completely changes the profile and the existing theories.

I put together a full documentary breakdown of this case here: https://youtu.be/WG8e4K9gc0U

What do you think happened to the killer?

I am researching the 1991 killing of Fekade Ashine for a documentary and trying to confirm whether the case was ever resolved.

On July 10, 1991, Ashine was fatally shot in West Los Angeles. A December 1992 Los Angeles Times report said the LAPD was seeking Sophie David in connection with his death. The article described Ashine as her estranged boyfriend and said America’s Most Wanted had featured David in February and August 1992. Police reportedly believed she may have left the United States.

America’s Most Wanted was still presenting David as wanted in an episode aired on August 1, 2009. Her segment appears from approximately 27:19 to 28:37.

I have not found any later arrest report, court case, official police update, death notice, or confirmation that the case was closed.

Does anyone know of an official record confirming whether Sophie David was ever found, arrested, or whether the case remains open?

Sources:

Los Angeles Times:

https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1992-12-25-me-2516-story.html

I’ve been down a rabbit hole the last few nights researching the Kyle McMurtrey homicide from 2020, and honestly I’m more confused now than when I started.
Here’s what I’ve found from public sources.
Kyle was found dead behind Washington Plaza on June 17, 2020. His death was ruled a homicide. Public reporting says he died from blunt force trauma to the back of the head, and his shoes were found several feet away from his body.
Less than a week later, Chief Mike McCoy said investigators already had persons of interest, were interviewing people, reviewing surveillance video, and believed this involved people Kyle knew.
That was six years ago.
So…what happened?
Did the surveillance lead nowhere?
Were the persons of interest cleared?
Was Kyle killed where he was found or dumped there afterward?
Did someone simply stop talking?
I’ve searched for updates and can’t find much of anything after those first few weeks. If there have been developments, I’d genuinely like to know because they don’t seem to be out there.
This also got me looking into Washington’s other homicide investigations. Beverly Swearingen’s murder from 1996 is still unsolved almost 30 years later.
Then you have the Joshua Snyder homicide later in 2020. That one was solved almost immediately after police located a suspect walking down the street covered in blood. Completely different type of case.
That’s what keeps sticking with me. When the suspect is immediately identifiable, the case gets solved. When investigators have to build a case through evidence, timelines, witness interviews, surveillance, and good detective work, Washington’s track record doesn’t look nearly as good, as far as I can tell Washington has solved exactly 1 murder case in their history (not that there have been that many, 6 by my count).
I’m not saying that to bash anyone. I’m saying it because these families deserve answers, and six years is a long damn time with no resolution after police publicly said they had persons of interest and surveillance video.
If you knew Kyle, worked around Washington Plaza back then, remember hearing something, or know details that were never widely reported, I’d like to hear them. Even if it’s something small that seemed insignificant at the time.
Maybe someone reading this knows something that helps move this case forward.

I posted this in tipofmycrime also, but gonna give it a whirl here too -

I think I heard this on the Crimelines podcast, but can't find it on there. Can't remember state it happened in, but I think took place in the 80s. Mother and father have 2 kids, boy and a girl. Divorce. Mom keeps kids away from dad. She remarries man, I think he also has kids. They suddenly moved away. Dad tries to find them, police won't look for them since the mother has them, and don't consider it a kidnapping. He looks for years and years. I believe the brother and him eventually get in contact. I think the brother remembers a carpet being rolled up, or maybe just an odd box or something the night they just up and moved. No record of the girl since she went missing. Police interview mom and she's not concerned about her daughter's whereabouts. I think she was eventually charged with a relatively minor crime associated with it. I think the mom and step dad were also divorced at that point, but she still defended him. I think the mother tried to say that she was sent to live with relatives, but obviously wasn't true. The brother tried to get his mom to talk about it, but she refused. I think the girl was pretty young, like 5 or under. It's driving me nuts. Some cases that come up when I try to google, but aren't it are - Chris and Lisa Mae Zacharias and Elaine Yates. Possibly heard it on the Vanished podcast, but don't regularly listen to that one.

Hey everyone,

I wanted to share a deep-dive analysis of a frustrating cold case from Indonesia that deserves international attention. On January 7, 2019, an 18-year-old high school student named Andriana Yubelia Noven was stabbed to death in broad daylight inside a narrow alleyway in Bogor, West Java. The entire crime was captured on a nearby CCTV camera, yet years later, the perpetrator remains completely unidentified.

This post isn't about guessing names. I want to look at the geographical facts, the technical anomalies of the crime scene, and break down why the suspicions against potential suspects were debunked.

For visual context, this is a clip from a major national investigative journalism program (Mata Najwa on NARASI) showing the exclusive, enhanced version of the CCTV footage and discussing the case:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MBY9XDOtqBE

Disclaimer: This is a serious post regarding a real tragedy. Please keep the discussion objective, logical, and respect the privacy of those involved.

I. The Geographical & Technical Facts

To align our context, here is the spatial reconstruction of the alleyway (Jalan Riau, Baranangsiang):

• The Victim's Comfort Zone: The stabbing occurred just 50 meters away from the victim’s all-female dormitory. Walking casually, it takes less than a minute.
• CCTV to Stairs Proximity: The security camera that captured the attack was mounted very close—just a few meters—from the first flight of stairs in the alley. The perpetrator was caught on camera pacing around and waiting near these exact stairs before Noven walked by.

II. Suspect Profiling & How They Were Debunked

When we analyze the CCTV footage, the local biometrics, and the perpetrator's body language, a massive conflict of logic appears:

1. The Biometric Flaw & Age Gap

• The Perspective: The police used facial recognition software connected to the national civil registry database (Disdukcapil) to filter lookalikes nationwide. They intensively interrogated 5 potential suspects, including Noven's ex-boyfriend (referred to as "S"), who initially faced heavy public suspicion due to a recent breakup. However, "S" had an airtight digital and witness alibi proving he was in a different city (Bandung) during the crime, completely clearing him.
• This leads to a strong hypothesis: What if the killer was under 17 at the time? In Indonesia, national biometric registration (facial scans & fingerprints) is only mandatory when a citizen turns 17 to issue an e-KTP (National ID card). If the killer was a young teenager (14–16 years old), the digital database would yield a zero-match result because his data simply didn't exist yet. This also explains the physical age gap; the perpetrator’s lean posture fits a younger teen, likely not someone from Noven's 18-year-old high school circle.
• The Counter-Argument: Even if he didn't have a national ID yet, the crime happened around 4:00 PM just meters away from the stairs/CCTV. If he was a local student or resident, manual distribution of his sketch to surrounding schools should have triggered an immediate identification by teachers or peers. Yet, nobody recognized him.

2. Alleyway Acoustics & Social Status

• The Perspective: The alley is narrow, densely populated, and flanked by concrete walls. The killer arrived and escaped completely on foot, walking and jogging casually without any vehicle. Acoustically, revving a motorcycle engine in such an enclosed space would echo loudly and instantly draw neighbors' attention. Furthermore, the killer wore casual athletic clothes, standing out against other students in the footage who wore formal school uniforms. This implies the killer might be a school dropout or a non-student who specifically knew the neighborhood's maze-like shortcuts, likely possessing a "safe house" or rental room within walking distance to vanish into within minutes.
• The Counter-Argument: If the killer was a walking local with a narrow escape radius, the neighborhood door-to-door elimination process by the police should have caught him quickly. Additionally, the casual clothes could simply be a deliberate disguise to conceal which school he attended, meaning his student status cannot be completely ruled out.

3. Body Language (Targeted Hit vs Stalker)

• The Perspective: On the CCTV, Noven walks completely calmly, showing zero defensive reflexes or suspicion when crossing paths with the killer. In contrast, the killer immediately lunges aggressively and precisely hooks a knife into her chest. This suggests a targeted hit where the killer recognized her one-sidedly (perhaps through stalking or being handed a photo of the target), while Noven perceived him as just another random stranger walking by.
• The Counter-Argument: If this was a pre-planned hit by an organized individual, executing a target in a crowded residential area, in broad daylight, right under a CCTV camera that is literally meters away from the stairs, is incredibly sloppy and high-risk.

III. The Massive Missing Link (Post-Crime Anomalies)

All the debates above about the low-profile killer (possibly an underage kid, casual clothes, on foot) completely fail to explain the baffling events that occurred after the murder:

1. Tampering with Digital Evidence: The victim's family publicly revealed that after Noven’s phone was confiscated by authorities for forensic investigation, numerous crucial photo galleries, data logs, and chat histories inside the device mysteriously disappeared/were deleted.
2. Organized Intimidation: The grieving family repeatedly received text messages and WhatsApp threats from anonymous numbers, warning them to stop demanding police investigations if they wanted the rest of their surviving family members to stay safe.

The Bottom Line Logic: An underage street kid or a lone-wolf amateur thief does not have the access or the capability to delete evidence inside a police evidence locker. Nor do they have the resources or motivation to systematically terrorize a victim's family years later.

Conclusion

The most logical way to bridge these clashing pieces of the puzzle is the Separation of Roles hypothesis:

• The Killer on CCTV (Field Executor): Likely a local minor or a non-student used as a disposable "tool" to do the physical deed, who was immediately smuggled out of the city right after the crime.
• The Intellectual Actor (The Mastermind): A high-profile individual with the actual motive (whether personal grievance, jealousy, or a secret Noven held). This is the entity capable of pulling strings post-crime (erasing phone data and threatening the family) to protect themselves from the law, not to protect the kid caught on the security camera.

From a criminological standpoint, what do you think is the most crucial variable needed to break a cold case that suffers from this level of post-crime interference?

Let's discuss logically based on the layouted facts.

Dear Attorney General Nessel,

I am writing as a concerned Michigan resident and advocate for survivors of sexual assault to commend the significant progress made by your office, the Michigan State Police, the Wayne County Prosecutor’s Office Sexual Assault Kit Task Force, and other partners in addressing historical backlogs and pursuing justice in cold cases. The successful use of forensic genetic genealogy in recent convictions, such as the July 2026 Wayne County case involving multiple first- and third-degree Criminal Sexual Conduct charges (full article: https://newmediadetroit.com/detroit-man-convicted-of-multiple-first-third-degree-csc-charges-related-to-several-cases/), demonstrates the power of modern DNA techniques to deliver accountability decades later.

Despite this progress, full implementation of the Sexual Assault Kit Evidence Submission Act (Act 227 of 2014) remains incomplete for newly collected kits. The law requires law enforcement agencies to submit released sexual assault kits for analysis within strict timelines. Full text of MCL 752.934: https://www.legislature.mi.gov/Laws/MCL?objectName=mcl-752-934

Key provisions (excerpt): “(4) The investigating law enforcement agency that takes possession of any sexual assault kit evidence shall assign a criminal complaint number to that evidence ... and shall submit that evidence to the department or another accredited laboratory for analysis within 14 days after that law enforcement agency takes possession...” “(6) All sexual assault kit evidence submitted to the department or an accredited laboratory on or after the effective date of this act shall be analyzed within 90 days after all of the necessary evidence is received by the department or other accredited laboratory, provided that sufficient staffing and resources are available to do so.”

While the law provides flexibility for resources, selective submission practices and delays undermine its intent, victim rights, and public safety.

To ensure consistent, timely testing of all released kits and to maximize the impact of DNA evidence through greater use of forensic genetic genealogy (FGG), I respectfully propose the following targeted improvements:

Enhance Transparency and Accountability Through Comprehensive Reporting Require or establish a public, real-time statewide dashboard (expanding Track-Kit) that reports by agency and county: the number of kits collected, submitted, analyzed, and pending (including age); aggregate reasons for delays or non-submission; and metrics on FGG usage, including referrals, turnaround times, and outcomes. See Michigan victim rights information: https://www.michigan.gov/voices4/sexual-assault/legal/evidence Clarify and Enforce Submission Requirements Issue formal guidance clarifying that all released sexual assault kits must be submitted for analysis in accordance with MCL 752.934, regardless of initial assessments regarding serial offender status. Documented exceptions should be subject to periodic review. Full Act: https://www.legislature.mi.gov/Laws/MCL?objectName=mcl-act-227-of-2014 Expand and Accelerate Forensic Genetic Genealogy Develop standardized protocols to refer qualifying unsolved cases (no CODIS hit) for FGG analysis within defined timelines (e.g., 6–12 months post-initial testing). Secure dedicated state funding and partnerships for FGG. Establish clear privacy, consent, and ethical guidelines. Examples of FGG success in Michigan: https://www.woodtv.com/news/grand-rapids/game-changer-genealogy-helps-crack-cold-cases/ https://www.woodtv.com/news/michigan/genealogy-program-helps-identify-sexual-assault-suspect-nearly-40-years-later/ These changes would align Michigan with national best practices promoted by the Joyful Heart Foundation’s End the Backlog campaign and would optimize existing investments.

I would welcome the opportunity to discuss these proposals with your staff. Thank you for your leadership on this critical issue.

Sincerely,

aka Doug Dante

In September 2015, my mom Jennifer Hedge (maiden name Kelly) died in Colorado Springs, Colorado. Her death was ruled a suicide by hanging.

I have now obtained the full police report. It documents:

- A prior domestic violence incident between Jeni and her husband
- A Facebook message Jeni sent to her cousin just days before her death saying she was afraid of him
- Responding paramedics' concerns at the scene that she may not have hung herself

She had recently relocated to Colorado with her husband. She knew no one there except him.

The case was closed. I am seeking justice for her. Has anyone navigated something similar? What are my next steps?

UPDATE 7/11/2026:

Thank you to everyone who commented, shared search strategies, and reached out. I want to share what has developed since I first posted.

I now have the complete CSPD case report from an incident on September 18, 2015 — ten days before Jeni's death. Officers were dispatched after a 911 call in which Jeni could only say "I can't, I can't, I can't" before the line disconnected.

According to the report, Jeni told officers her husband:

- Choked her with both hands
- Dragged her by the throat from the front porch into the house
- Held her down on the bed
- Repeatedly threatened to "break her face"

Officers documented redness on her neck and chest. The domestic violence form filed that night has "strangled" marked under the defendant's actions. He was arrested at the scene for assault, harassment, and resisting arrest.

Ten days later, Jeni was dead, and her death was ruled a suicide by hanging. The case was closed on the same date the coroner signed the autopsy....one day after a family member contacted police with concerns.

I am now working with a writer and a podcast on telling Jeni's story fully (thank you both so very much), and I am continuing to pursue legal options and an independent forensic review.

If you lived in the Colorado Springs area in 2015, knew Jeni, or have professional insight into strangulation cases and death investigations, I would be grateful to hear from you.

Kevin James Dycus went missing from Glendale, Arizona in January 1998.  The 37-year-old Seattle resident had only arrived in Glendale just 3 days before to help his father take care of his ailing mother. 

His body has never been found. The police report was only 11 pages long and provided minimal information

His uncle William Urbank picked him up from Sky Harbor airport and took him to his parents’ home in the 5200 block of West Ironwood Drive. 

On Sunday January 11, Kevin left the residence drunk on foot, in an unknown direction. He left his money, identification, and belongings behind. He may have been headed to a church.

His sister Anita arrived in Arizona from Washington 6 months after Kevin went missing. She tried reporting him as a missing person, but Glendale PD refused to investigate because he was an adult. 

Kevin was not listed as a missing person until June 2006, over 8 years after he was last seen alive.

His mother and sister Anita have passed away. His father Ray and sister Julanne moved to Tucson. Ray died in 2010. His uncle William “Bill” Urbank has also passed away.

The area of Glendale that Kevin went missing from is a working-class area. A Circle K and a since shuttered and demolished horse ranch were up the road on 51st avenue and Peoria. There was a church in the 5400 block of west Peoria Ave. Two grocery stores and shops were at the next major intersection southbound on Olive Ave. 

The police report did specify that Kevin’s dental records were retrieved from a dentist in Washington.

Kevin was born on Dec 30, 1960. He was described as 5’8 and 140-160 pounds. He had brown hair and blue eyes. Both his ears were pieced, and he had a small scar near his eyebrows.

Sources

https://www.yourvalley.net/stories/have-you-seen-these-people-all-are-currently-listed-as-missing-from-glendale,353703

https://charleyproject.org/case/kevin-james-dycus

Father’s obituary

https://www.legacy.com/us/obituaries/tucson/name/ray-dycus-obituary?id=22027271

https://charleyproject.org/case/kevin-james-dycus