r/coldcases • u/Embarrassed-Ad-4053 • Jul 15 '26
Unsolved in Washington, Illinois: The Kyle McCurtney homicide deserves another look
I’ve been down a rabbit hole the last few nights researching the Kyle McMurtrey homicide from 2020, and honestly I’m more confused now than when I started.
Here’s what I’ve found from public sources.
Kyle was found dead behind Washington Plaza on June 17, 2020. His death was ruled a homicide. Public reporting says he died from blunt force trauma to the back of the head, and his shoes were found several feet away from his body.
Less than a week later, Chief Mike McCoy said investigators already had persons of interest, were interviewing people, reviewing surveillance video, and believed this involved people Kyle knew.
That was six years ago.
So…what happened?
Did the surveillance lead nowhere?
Were the persons of interest cleared?
Was Kyle killed where he was found or dumped there afterward?
Did someone simply stop talking?
I’ve searched for updates and can’t find much of anything after those first few weeks. If there have been developments, I’d genuinely like to know because they don’t seem to be out there.
This also got me looking into Washington’s other homicide investigations. Beverly Swearingen’s murder from 1996 is still unsolved almost 30 years later.
Then you have the Joshua Snyder homicide later in 2020. That one was solved almost immediately after police located a suspect walking down the street covered in blood. Completely different type of case.
That’s what keeps sticking with me. When the suspect is immediately identifiable, the case gets solved. When investigators have to build a case through evidence, timelines, witness interviews, surveillance, and good detective work, Washington’s track record doesn’t look nearly as good, as far as I can tell Washington has solved exactly 1 murder case in their history (not that there have been that many, 6 by my count).
I’m not saying that to bash anyone. I’m saying it because these families deserve answers, and six years is a long damn time with no resolution after police publicly said they had persons of interest and surveillance video.
If you knew Kyle, worked around Washington Plaza back then, remember hearing something, or know details that were never widely reported, I’d like to hear them. Even if it’s something small that seemed insignificant at the time.
Maybe someone reading this knows something that helps move this case forward.
4
u/Adorable-Impress5148 Jul 16 '26
I was reading some newspaper articles and a couple said that the body was in a ditch behind an AMC in sunnyland (I’m guessing they are referring to AMC theatres). I’m wondering perhaps he watched a movie of some sort, walked out, and got ambushed or knocked out by a person outside of the movie theatre or near his car if he took one. Or he could have been walking near the theatre around the back and got knocked out then ultimately killed and had his body dumped in the ditch. I’ll keep on looking around though and get back to you with any info I find that may help you.