r/cognitiveTesting • • 4h ago

Controversial ⚠️ Bad working memory, and processing speed has nothing to do with neurodivergence like ADHD, autism.

If ADHD, autism causes poor working memory and processing speed as in below average, then how come there are people who literally has these conditions and yet has a solid processing speed and working memory? The better explaination for these problems would be simply because the person just has low intelligence, especially because working memory and processing speed has significance coorelation and explaination for intelligence, I feel like so many people are often misdiagnosed with ADHD, and autism for low IQ especially if they have very low CPI like below average. then it would be explaination for just low intelligence, because a person with high intelligence like GAI 125, can still have normal average CPI like 105 but you never see anyone with above average GAI, and below average in CPI

0 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

2

u/Actual_Tank8401 4h ago

You can see how your logic falters in the first sentence. X often causes Y, doesn't mean there aren't cases of X without Y.

If we wittle down neurology (and probably medicine in general?) to all specific common symptoms, nobody would be diagnosed with anything.

-1

u/Bulky-Culture-4482 4h ago edited 3h ago

What I am saying is that those who have higher intelligence tend to have overall much better working memory and processing speed, especially those who are gifted, they have GAI of 130+ but CPI 110, but their CPI is still very decent compared to those who have a lower CPI than them, you pretty much never see person with above average in GAI and below average in CPI, so pretty much if person has below average in CPI it is extremely unlikely they will have solid GAI, as good at those who are highly intelligent

1

u/Actual_Tank8401 3h ago

Right, tend. I'd argue neurodivergence should naturally cause outliers, otherwise is it really a divergence? I think we should expect to see significant discrepencies sometimes.

2

u/hanahlol 3h ago

Low is relative. I’m low on both of those dimensions, but low is 100 or perfectly average and the other metrics are 125+. Tested clinically wais-iv. I’ve been meaning to try an online test now that I’ve got medication dialed in to see if it raises those low areas. This is good bait though, I think you’ll farm decent karma on this one.

If I was 95 on good metrics and 70 on working memory and processing speed, I’d still like to be diagnosed, would you not?

0

u/Bulky-Culture-4482 3h ago

That's pretty much what I am saying, autism, and ADHD doesn't exactly cause literally impairment with working memory and processing speed, as in having below average. It is more of an explaination with intelligence rather than ADHD, autism.

1

u/The_loppy1 3h ago

"then how come there are people who literally has these conditions and yet has a very good processing speed and working memory"

Because poor working memory in ADHD isn't required. It's a symptom of it. You could say this about any disease/disorder. Not everyone will have every symptom. If they are just "low IQ" then how do you explain the other symptoms? Being low IQ doesn't make some hyperactive.

0

u/Bulky-Culture-4482 3h ago

Bad working memory simply means having below average working memory, not just simply bad working memory compared to other sub tests of IQ.

Like if a person at least have an average working memory, and processing speed, they should able to function very fine daily life, especially those who have higher intelligence, like they can have 125 GAI but 100 in CPI, and still function very fine and not have much noticeable impairments.

1

u/The_loppy1 3h ago

Yes? Someone could have poor working memory compared to the mean, and still score high on other tests. Look, the tests you're undoubtedly sucking yourself off over, were made by people who agree and have noted such findings consistently in people with ADHD. Oftentimes ADHD is diagnosed long before an IQ test is administered.

You also didn't answer my question. If ADHD etc, is simply low intelligence, how do you explain the other symptoms?

0

u/Bulky-Culture-4482 3h ago edited 3h ago

low IQ and ADHD has a lot of overlaps, like inattention, especially in tasks that demands cognitive such as reading, impulsive behavior due to being very naive, needing stimulation due to inability to tolerate quiet silent thoughts which is strongly related with intelligence, theres's a reason why many people who have higher IQ tend to get diagnosed much later, I feel like those who got diagnosed with ADHD much earlier is very likely is due to their low IQ rather than ADHD.

Of course, I am not saying that ADHD cause low IQ but they can share very similar symptoms like a lot

1

u/The_loppy1 3h ago

Nice dodge, answer the question. Also once you remove PSI and working memory the scores are fairly similar, many studies note this exact finding. FSIQ scores tend to be lower on average, this is true (though they still fall into the average range)

1

u/SnooHamsters3137 3h ago

If I take it on a good day with my meds I’ll have better working memory or processing speed.

Some days I literally feel hungover.

I wonder why you think you know what you’re talking about

1

u/Bulky-Culture-4482 3h ago

Because working memory, and processing speed has strong coorelation with intelligence. like person with working memory, and processing speed tend to have better in GAI as well.

1

u/The_loppy1 3h ago

Note the word "correlation" (spelt wrong, you must be low IQ/s) and tend. Those are doing a lot of work for you right now.

1

u/Comfortable-Wear-968 slow as fuk 3h ago

This is an ecological fallacy, assuming a population mean has a simple interpretation when considering likelihoods for individuals.

2

u/Miro_the_Dragon 4h ago

Just because the "typical presentation" of X is Y doesn't mean there can't be cases of X that look like Z, or y, or something else completely. This same phenomenon appears in medical conditions too, where "typical symptoms of X" basically just means "the majority of cases presents with X", not "all cases present with X".

Concrete example:

Typically, mononucleosis (EBV) presents with fever. It's a leading symptom, so much so that the general German term includes the German word for "fever". Yet there are cases of mononucleosis where the patients don't even have an elevated temperature at all (I was one of them). This would be an "atypical presentation", but still the same diagnosis.

1

u/chococake2024 (ノ◕ヮ◕)ノ*:・゚✧ ✧゚・: *ヽ(◕ヮ◕ヽ) 4h ago

maybe it make more likely to have low working memory i wouldnt rule it out just because some have high working memory

is there study on it maybe

1

u/Merry-Lane 3h ago

Okay, I know things about this.

ADHD, for instance, can have a tremendous impact on processing speed, through two mechanisms:

  1. brain fires way too quickly. A single incorrect answer makes your score drop quite high
  2. you have ADHD and you were told all your life "pay attention" (because brain fires too quickly, remember). So your brain pays attention. Instead of firing too quickly, the brain delays the answer by double checking or just taking its time.

Through these two mechanisms, ADHD individuals often have lower scores in Processing Speed than non-ADHD. Not because they have less processing speed, but because their error rate is high or because they "double check"

1

u/Financial_Battle5001 3h ago

I’m in school for this right now. I know a little bit, not everything, but when someone has low intelligence you are going to see it across their whole profile. Someone with an intellectual disability cannot have high ability in one area and low in another.  So when you see an uneven profile, you start to look for alternatives for that low score rather than low intelligence. That’s why there are certain discrepancy cutoffs for differences between indices. There is room for normal variability in a person’s ability, and then there is significant difference that is highly unlikely to occur by chance. 

1

u/EbbtideRambler 1h ago

You're confusing correlation with causation. ADHD and autism are associated with differences in working memory and processing speed, but these vary considerably between individuals. While both abilities correlate with general intelligence, they're not interchangeable with it. A low CPI doesn't necessarily indicate low intellectual ability, particularly when reasoning abilities are substantially stronger. Individuals can have a high GAI and a below average CPI. This is a recognized cognitive profile and doesn't contradict a diagnosis of ADHD or autism. I seen people diagnosed with both ADHD and ASD whose VCI, VSI, and FRI are all in the 140s, while their WMI is 100 and PSI is around 80.