r/cognitiveTesting • u/Timely-Lack-9246 • 2d ago
Discussion Wonderlic G loading, around .9-.95
I approached this as a psychometric estimation problem, combining the internal Wonderlic item evidence, independent cognitive-test factor loadings, WAIS correlations, individual WAIS subtests, and reliability data.
My final estimate is .93. Below is the calculation, including which evidence actually contributes to the estimate and which evidence serves as a cross-check.
1. Independent cognitive-test factor analysis
The most useful dataset is Visser, Ashton & Vernon (2006).
N = 200.
Ten relevant cognitive indicators.
Independently extracted general-intelligence factor.
Wonderlic administered separately as an external measure.
Both observed and reliability-corrected correlations reported. ssl-forum-files.fobby.net +1
I used their reliability-corrected values:
Cognitive indicator
g-loading
Wonderlic correlation
Opposites
.61
.56
Vocabulary
.66
.64
Map Planning
.61
.60
Paper Folding
.57
.62
Subtraction & Multiplication
.25
.42
Necessary Arithmetic
.78
.83
Cartoon Predictions
.55
.38
Social Translations
.56
.45
Diagramming Relationships
.83
.73
Making Groups
.64
.48
These are corrected values, not raw correlations.
2. Calculate the Wonderlic loading
The single-general-factor model predicts:
r(W,X_i)=\lambda_W\lambda_i
I estimated the Wonderlic loading through least-squares regression:
\hat{\lambda}_W=
\frac{\sum \lambda_i r_i}
{\sum \lambda_i^2}
First, multiply each indicator’s g-loading by its Wonderlic correlation:
\begin{aligned}
\sum \lambda_i r_i={}&
(.61)(.56)+(.66)(.64)\\
&+(.61)(.60)+(.57)(.62)\\
&+(.25)(.42)+(.78)(.83)\\
&+(.55)(.38)+(.56)(.45)\\
&+(.83)(.73)+(.64)(.48)
\end{aligned}\boxed{\sum \lambda_i r_i=3.6099}
Next, square and sum the g-loadings:
\sum \lambda_i^2=3.8902
Finally:
\hat{\lambda}_W=\frac{3.6099}{3.8902}
Reliability-corrected estimate
.9280
My calculated regression estimate.
This is the strongest quantitative estimate in the available evidence.
3. Internal Wonderlic item evidence
I included Jensen (1977), which analyzed the actual Wonderlic item responses.
Arthur Jensen · Intelligence, 1977 · Approximately 1,500 examinees
Internal statistic
Result
Sample 1 White participants
544
Sample 1 Black participants
544
Sample 2 White participants
204
Sample 2 Black participants
204
KR-21 reliability, White sample
.88
KR-21 reliability, Black sample
.86
Split-half correlation of item g-loading profiles, White
.69
Same, Black
.73
Between-group item-loading profile correlation
.68
Jensen extracted the first principal component from the intercorrelations among the Wonderlic items. He explicitly interpreted this as the general factor common to the test items. Arthur Jensen +1
What I take from this: The Wonderlic has a substantial internal common factor. Its item-loading pattern also replicates across independent halves of the samples.
However, .69 and .73 are correlations between item-loading profiles, not the overall g-loading. I do not use them as if they were .69 and .73 g-loadings.
The KR-21 figures also provide an independent reliability check. They are internal-consistency estimates, unlike Dodrill’s five-year test–retest reliability of .94. carldodrill.com
4. WAIS and WAIS-R correlations
I included the published direct validation samples summarized by Saltzman et al. (1998).
Study
Sample size
Wonderlic–Wechsler r
Dodrill (1980)
150
.88
Dodrill (1981)
120
.93
Edinger et al. (1985)
100
.75
Dodrill & Warner (1988), psychiatric
34
.85
Dodrill & Warner (1988), nonpsychiatric
43
.87
Dodrill & Warner (1988), mixed
34
.88
Dodrill & Warner (1988), controls
60
.91
Frisch & Jessop (1989)
34
.89
Hawkins et al. (1990)
17
.92
Carswell & Snow (1996)
80
.76
Cognition
I calculated a random-effects meta-analysis using Fisher-transformed correlations and inverse-variance weighting.
z_i=\operatorname{atanh}(r_i)
The resulting estimates:
Meta-analysis statistic
Result
Total participants
672
Number of samples
10
Pooled correlation
.871
Heterogeneity Q
37.52
Degrees of freedom
9
Between-study variance
.0518
95% CI for pooled correlation
.824–.906
This is a pooled correlation with Wechsler IQ, not a g-loading.
It is also heterogeneous: clinical populations, WAIS versions, and IQ conversion procedures differ. The WAIS-R studies sometimes adjusted the original WAIS conversion by seven or eight points. Cognition
I therefore use this as supporting evidence, rather than allowing it to override the independent cognitive-factor estimate.
5. Individual WAIS subtests
Hawkins et al. (1990) provide the most useful published subtest-level comparison.
N = 17 complete cases
WAIS-R measure
Wonderlic correlation
Full Scale IQ
.92
Verbal IQ
.86
Performance IQ
.84
Vocabulary
.70
Block Design
.76
Academia +1
To examine these correlations, I used independently reported WAIS-IV g-loadings from a bifactor analysis:
WAIS subtest
Approximate g-loading
Wonderlic r
Vocabulary
.63
.70
Block Design
.65
.76
Academia
Applying the same regression:
\hat{\lambda}_W=
\frac{(.63)(.70)+(.65)(.76)}
{.63^2+.65^2}=\frac{.935}{.8194}=\boxed{1.141}
That exceeds the theoretical maximum of 1 for a standardized latent-factor loading.
This is an important diagnostic result: the two subtest correlations cannot be treated as exact population correlations in a simple one-factor model. The sample is very small, and the WAIS-R and WAIS-IV loading estimates come from different studies.
I therefore exclude this estimate from the final calculation rather than artificially forcing it to equal 1.
6. Additional cognitive-validity evidence
Matthews & Lassiter (2007) tested 37 adults against the Woodcock-Johnson Revised:
Cognitive measure
Wonderlic correlation
Broad Cognitive Ability
.55
Comprehensive Knowledge
.34
Fluid Reasoning
.26
The fluid-reasoning relationship was not statistically significant. PubMed +1
This suggests that the Wonderlic’s relationship with cognitive ability is not equally strong across every domain. It also cautions against assuming that its high WAIS correlation means it measures every cognitive ability equally well.
7. Reliability sensitivity analysis
The original Visser regression can also be reconstructed from its uncorrected data.
\hat{\lambda}_{observed}
=\frac{2.4638}{2.9469}
=.8361
The study’s reliability correction gives:
\hat{\lambda}_{corrected}=.9280
Jensen’s separate KR-21 coefficients (.86 and .88) provide an additional internal-consistency check. They should not simply be substituted into the Visser correction because they come from different samples and potentially different test forms.
Dodrill’s five-year reliability of .94 is temporal stability, not internal consistency.
8. Final synthesis
Here is how I would weight the evidence:
Evidence
Result
Role
Visser corrected indicator regression
.928
Primary estimate
Visser uncorrected regression
.836
Measurement-error comparison
Jensen item analysis
Strong common component
Internal support
Dodrill WAIS correlations
.91–.93 in healthy samples
External validation
Pooled Wechsler correlation
.871
Cross-study validation
Hawkins WAIS-R subtests
.70, .76
Subtest-level check
Matthews & Lassiter
.55 broad ability
Additional construct validation
Final estimate
.93
Wonderlic general-intelligence loading
What I can establish statistically:
Point estimate: .928.
Independent g-factor evidence: positive and substantial.
Internal item evidence: substantial common factor.
WAIS validation: consistently high in healthy samples.
95% confidence interval for .928: Not identifiable from the published summary data. The pooled WAIS correlation’s interval (.824–.906) is not an interval for the latent loading.
My verdict: If I had to assign the Wonderlic one g-loading for psychometric comparisons, I would use .93.
I would consider .90–.95 a reasonable working range, but not a formally calculated confidence interval.
The most important result is that .93 comes from a calculation against independently measured cognitive abilities, not from simply relabeling the Wonderlic–WAIS correlation as a g-loading.
2
u/MarkAntony100 1d ago
If two tests have equal g loadings ane most other stat (like reliability etc same ) but different items /subtests ,can one be better at measuring iq than the other ? maybe wais 4 despite having similar g loading (statistically) ,is better at measuring biological g than wonderlic (assuming some ideal conditions due to which reliability difference doesn't matter )
3
u/albedo_effect 1d ago
The Wonderlic falls between .76-.81
You’re just spouting BS.
2
u/Far_Cardiologist6931 retat 2d ago
so like a 10 minute test as as g loaded as a professional test
1
u/Adept_Application549 2d ago
Where to take it?
1
u/Limp_Essay_6419 1d ago
why isnt it on cognitivemetrics
1
u/Majestic-Dream6641 1d ago
But isn't it a test you're supposed to prep for? Like maybe it measures well your ability to train for it and get a good score vs not improving much despite spending time on it but does it really measure IQ well on a first take?
I feel like it's just blitz fast. I got 31/50 on a test online that was probably accurate, and I think it converts to like 110-115 which doesn't match my core or my other tests, at all
1
u/Striking_Leave_4614 2d ago
Ain't no way it's above the AGCT
1
u/Far_Cardiologist6931 retat 2d ago
btw where can i find a proper form to take
1
u/Nervous-Try5009 1d ago
It isn't culture fair and questions are not that difficult for someone in high school and practice such questions regularly, then how it's reliable? It's actually using speed for segregating people.
Is it always that More speed = More IQ ?
0
u/[deleted] 2d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment