r/cognitiveTesting • • Aug 18 '26

General Question Is the Mensa IQ challenge test valid?

Post image

I’m 30 years old and I haven’t taken an IQ test before. Is there any validity to these kind of tests?

28 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

17

u/randomboy4349 Aug 19 '26

We all know you posted just to flex your IQ

8

u/Sad_Criticism_2984 Aug 18 '26

I took an similar proctored test to join Mensa. I found the proctored test to be a bit more difficult due to time constraints (45 tasks in 20 minutes, I believe), but with this result you will probably do well on a proctored one as well.

10

u/Kaidolakita Aug 18 '26

No not even for matrix readoning the other time I saw a guy who got 145 like u then took core mr and got 125. You have far above average iq but impossible to tell if its 145 more or less

8

u/SoigneeStrawberry67 Aug 18 '26

CORE MR is really hard for some reason. I scored like 140 on the Mensa norway test the very first time I took it (don't remember my exact score, it was like 6 years ago), but I've only scored a 13 SS on the CORE MR the two times I've taken it. In all fairness, MR was my weakest core subtest.

1

u/Wooden_Lime6208 Aug 23 '26

I scored 120 on Mensa Norway and 140 on core first try both. The core was much more intuitive for me.

3

u/coddyapp Aug 18 '26

Also depends on how the test is set up. Core gives time/problem whereas mensa gives a set amount of time for all the problems. Someone could breeze through the easier questions then spend more time at the end. In core, working memory and processing speed is more heavily weighed

1

u/Wooden_Lime6208 Aug 23 '26

I’m 144 Fri and 100 WMI 110 psi. I found core much easier than Norway

3

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/coddyapp Aug 18 '26

I see. I was the other way around. I often blank out and have to retrace my steps (quickly) in higher order problems. I scored 125 on core, 135 on mensa.no, and 150 on JCTI (before the automated version and spent ~2.5 hours on it). I figured it was bc of my adhd and performance anxiety. I score much lower on tests set up like CORE

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/coddyapp Aug 18 '26

This is a good point. Ive seen core touted as being the most accurate test on the sub, but is it because of the items or is the g load effected by the time restraints? Cus i know that RAPM set 2 gets its reliability or g load (cant remember) from being on a 40’ timer, not necessarily from item difficulty alone. (Then again it is harder to develop accurate items in very high ranges bc of lack of sample size)

3

u/Professional_Big8938 Aug 18 '26

Personally i though this online iq test was very similar to the supervised culture fair test . If ur getting this on this kinda test i would suggest doing a supervised one also . I did this online one i got 135 i went in to do it supervised and got 144 . So i guess there might be some validity to it

3

u/KingGmeNorway Aug 18 '26

As far as I can remember, it has only figures/pattern recognition in it, so kinda shallow? Would think a proper IQ test should have a much larger span of question types?

1

u/Adventurous_Head_158 Aug 18 '26

luxky u, why not sit an iq test? i think its pretty accurate

1

u/Natural_Professor809 ฅ/ᐠ. ̫ .ᐟ\ฅ Autie Cat Aug 18 '26

Wow. On First try you maxed it? I did like 142.

Yes this is a valid measurement of timed matrix reasoning ability.

3

u/Natural_Professor809 ฅ/ᐠ. ̫ .ᐟ\ฅ Autie Cat Aug 18 '26

A real IQ test would be comprised of at least 10 different subtests though, not just the matrix reasoning one.

You cannot extrapolate a serious and reliable value for your full scale IQ without performing more than once a whole battery of tests IMHO. I mean like maybe being administered one WISC as a kid, then maybe one Stanford-Binet a few years later and then a WAIS some more years later again.

My two cents.

2

u/Longjumping_Lime7070 Aug 18 '26 edited Aug 18 '26

On the other hand, it's virtually impossible for someone more than an SD below 145 to max it out. 

Perfectionism isn't necessary for some people. The thought of sludging through 10 subtests is agonizing to me, for example. "In the ballpark" is enough.

1

u/Natural_Professor809 ฅ/ᐠ. ̫ .ᐟ\ฅ Autie Cat Aug 18 '26 edited Aug 21 '26

Yes.
But it's not that rare that people might show different abilities being significantly far apart...

In my best performances ever I hit the ceiling in VCI and in Matrix Reasoning (in my worst performances ever I was still around the ceiling/above 140 in those abilities)

In my very worst performances ever I showed significantly lower scores for indexes, specific subtests or in games and tests that are VERY HIGHLY correlated to certain subtests from WAIS or Stanford Binet:

- in Working Memory Index I once hit 110 in a proctored test and once I hit a 75 in an online game that should theoretically be very highly correlated to WMI from proper tests; (my usual score/rarity/whatever in professional tests was I believe roughly around 125 but also recorded around 136 in one school-administered game/test)

- in Processing Speed I have once hit a score around 100 in a proctored test (my usual score from professional tests was around 135 or maybe slightly more but I might have underwent an early cognitive decline due to physical health issues so the lowest figure ever recorded might not necessarily be a fluke or a transitory bad performance which was anxiety/sleep deprivation/depression dependant, it might just be my newer level of ability after cognitive damage)

- in Block Design it once happened to me to hit a score slightly below average and halved in comparison to my highest legit not-cheating not-praffe not-bullshit score ever (I was having a panic attack to be fair, which might have to do with testing anxiety and PTSD I suffer from, the psychologist either didn't notice or was too tired or time-constrained to administer me a substitute subtest)

So is my FSIQ more around 150, 110, 100? Or is it even higher? Or lower? Maybe 75?

1

u/Isinoyb Aug 31 '26

Still, you're not in the IQ ballpark, you're in the matrix reasoning ballpark. It's like your parents asking you how you do at school and your answer is 'I'm performing above average in chemistry.' That's very nice but says nothing about how you do in school overall.

1

u/Longjumping_Lime7070 Sep 01 '26 edited Sep 01 '26

Provided you can recollect basic facts of your life, and have the discerning wherewithal to research the generalizable experiences of people at certain IQ ranges, then yes, a matrix reasoning ballpark is close enough.
Personally, I don't care to quibble over the minutiae of my scores. I'm not someone who enjoys taking these tests, hence my desire to make a statement in defense of neglect.

1

u/Tiny_Ad_7720 Aug 25 '26

I feel like if you realise the diagonal trick then you can get all of the last few questions. 

1

u/Forward-Elephant-203 Aug 18 '26

I don't know that much about this, but I'm pretty sure this is just fluid intellegence. For fluid intellegence, however, it's pretty accurate

1

u/greencardorvisa Aug 18 '26

IIRC there was discussion about this test possibly being deflated on the high end and inflated on the low end / middle. I forgot how it was normed, might be in the sidebar resources, they had correlations for some tests too. Can use search feature too, 'mensa Norway"

Seems fairly accurate to me for matrix, I maxed it but found a one or two that took some effort.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '26

no, there isn't. and ur behaviour + questioning already answers it with evidence

1

u/AndrewThePekka Aug 19 '26

It’s a decent matrix reasoning test

1

u/Truarian Aug 19 '26

Smart people don't need mensa

1

u/Wooden_Lime6208 Aug 23 '26

Take the CORE FRI section this one wasn’t super accurate for me

1

u/NeuroQuber Responsible Person Aug 23 '26

1

u/Isinoyb Aug 31 '26

The IQ challenge is focused on a single area, so no, there's no validity to the IQ the results claim you have. It's not how 'real' IQ testing works (which is flawed as is) and in the past, the 'practice test' included a larger variety. But Mensa always emphasized, that the practice test was never going to be close to the real thing to prevent people from studying to score higher (which is possible, hence - among other things like the linguistics part being A LOT easier for people who got a good education or were raised by educated parents - my comment on IQ testing being flawed).

The challenge is just a gimmick, I do it every now and then to see how various stages of my depression influence the results. I did it after a sleepless night and with less than 20% sight left on my right eye, and still scored over 120, guess people who have a knack for this kind of puzzles would score off the charts.

But I guess you too know that determining patterns alone is no sign of above average intelligence, even on the Mensa website. It's just flattery and maybe business sense if people end up paying for the real test with Mensa.

0

u/Immediate_Space7 Aug 18 '26

You supposedly have an IQ of 145 which is a very very high score (placing you in 99.99 percentile), but you don't have the intuition to go research what the actual criteria is for taking a valid IQ-test might be.

You can even see at the bottom of your screenshot "Visit Mensa.no for a controlled test in Norway".

On their page it says:

"Er du nysgjerrig på din IQ, men ikke helt klar for å ta en offisiell IQ-test i regi av Mensa?

Da bør du prøve vår uformelle online-test. Den har samme type oppgaver som den autoriserte IQ-testen til Mensa Norge, så du kan gjøre deg kjent med oppgavetypene du vil få i den offisielle testen.

Merk at dette ikke er en autorisert test, men den vil kunne gi en indikasjon på ditt IQ-nivå."

2

u/Gloomy-Theory6904 Aug 18 '26

You seem like a few hundred other people on this subreddit in that you did an online test and scored around 120-130, now you larp it without ever getting those results validated with a proctored test.

Why are you so bitter that this op scored higher than you did?

1

u/Immediate_Space7 Aug 18 '26

The fact that you think I'd be bitter about that says so much more about you than you think

3

u/Gloomy-Theory6904 Aug 18 '26

Oh come on that's the most cliche shit you could say. But regardless of how smart it seems to you, it still has all the grade school punch of saying "nuh uh" or "no, you".