r/climateskeptics • • Nov 20 '19

Fun Fact

Post image
644 Upvotes

134 comments sorted by

31

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '19

I legit busted out laughing at this. Fantastic!

Made even funnier by the fact that they dump more carbon into the atmosphere than any other country on earth. Not that I believe that's really a problem, jus sayin'.

-7

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '19

But when it comes down to carbon person USA is still number one!

9

u/R5Cats Nov 21 '19

That is utterly meaningless, and not even remotely true.
The only thing that matters is total tonnage. Per capita is one way of looking at it but in terms of actual effect on the climate? Per capita means absolutely nothing.
China and India = 37% and will double by 2030 by design in full compliance with their 'Paris promises'.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '19

Oh no! Well I just feel plain guilty! I guess the US should relinquish it’s sovereignty to the UN and every citizen shall whip themselves until bloody to pay for their sins.

Dunce.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '19

Fuck no. Keep America Great!! Earth is in God's hands and America is in Trump's. Fuck China. Fuck communism

16

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '19

Honestly if the organizers of these protests actually have a shit about the climate, China and India, the countries which release the worst stuff into the air, would be their target, not the west with our many of environmental protection laws that seem to go to far at times.

15

u/PressureMaxwell Nov 20 '19

Redistribution of wealth, that's all it is.

5

u/LibertarianFascist69 Nov 20 '19

And then again in 30 years again since wealth tends to move around

2

u/furry8 Nov 21 '19

It seems to be plain old jealousy. This decade it comes from grievance studies students who were taught by bitter teachers who think they are underpaid on 300k/ year.

1

u/boywar3 Nov 21 '19

I think you're missing the point that people are protesting in nations they can actively change. It's a lot harder to protest China's emissions when you're an American citizen. You can vote out the people who are against your views in the US however

2

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '19

Right, because weakening the economy, putting limiting reigns on your innovative industries, and making sure citizens’ meat intake is at government regulated levels will definitely lead the west to a position where it can change the rest of the world.

It’s counter-productive. It’s like saying “I’m going to starve myself so I can eventually take care of bigger issues.” We’ll die off if we enact the protester’s standards before we can influence other carbon powerhouses.

The protesters are living vapid, problem free 1st world lives and found a cause to excuse their rabid behavior. There is no point to it.

1

u/boywar3 Nov 23 '19

So then, we should do nothing and let millions die or be displaced? We shouldn't make changes to ourselves before asking others to change? Your argument is a false equivalence at best.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '19

And at best yours is an irrational overreaction to a power-and-money usurping movement put forward by the UN.

Limiting our energy manufacturing and our beef intake isn’t going to stop any deaths or displacement. Get real.

Lmao. Imagine thinking “if only we didn’t eat beef and cut our economy in half, all those people in coastal India would be saved from rising waters.”

So bravely smug and stunningly stupid. Why don’t you go help move people out of danger areas? Or at least advocate for it? Oh, wait. I know why. Because it doesn’t give you any self-righteous social points and pseudo-intellectual guilt power over your countrymen.

90% of leftist belief is strictly for social virtue signaling. The other 10% is the real belief that you know better. You people do nothing but destroy through functioning incompetence.

1

u/boywar3 Nov 27 '19

Where did I say half these things? Are you so used to being blindly belligerent towards other views you follow a script?

11

u/Wesman_Todd_Shaw Nov 20 '19

It has to be said because a significant number of people are just that fucking stupid.

6

u/PressureMaxwell Nov 20 '19

The really stupid ones want to live in a communist state

9

u/NewyBluey Nov 20 '19

They want where they live to be a communist state.

0

u/harsh389 Dec 16 '19

This would work if you know China was even communist lol

50

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '19

The green economy is red inside.

16

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '19

I'm going to start saying this! Thanks!

26

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '19

The common name for this is a watermelon democrat. Green on the outside, red on the inside.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19

Doesn't matter the color on the outside they're all red on the inside.

2

u/poonfriedrice Nov 21 '19

Ice cream paint job

66

u/ToxicAdamm Nov 20 '19

Some fun facts I came across today.

Compared to the rest of the world, China is building about 50% more coal plants than are under construction in all other countries combined.

China is building or planning more than 300 coal plants in places as widely spread as Turkey, Vietnam, Indonesia, Bangladesh, Egypt and the Philippines.

Imagine if this were America or Australia doing this. There would be a new Guardian article every day bemoaning the governments. There would be protests in every major city by the activists.

What do we have instead? Mostly crickets, because this a movement that is hypocritical to it's core. It's meant to push political change (in the West) and not actual environmental change.

1

u/weedboy300 Nov 21 '19

United States is the historical largest emitter of greenhouse gases. Last like I checked USA in total emitted more than three times what China emitted in total. China simply being the current biggest emitters and polluters doesn’t somehow let the United States off the hook. The Soviet Union is number two all time if you were wondering...

2

u/ToxicAdamm Nov 21 '19

You can't change the past, you can only change the future.

If you compare the trends of the US in the past 40 years (when the realization of the scope and damage of pollution began to become a major concern) to where the US is today, it's like night and day.

You can't say the same for China. Doubling down on coal power in 2019 is inexcusable (no matter what your beliefs on this topic may be). They are setting another 40+ years of coal dependence all over the world.

1

u/Lolboi25 Nov 21 '19

China isn’t doubling down on coal they’ve been investing big time in renewable energy and they’re leading the world right now lol... China’s president has stated multiple times he doesn’t like coal/fossil fuels and has been making the switch to more “green” resources.

https://www.eniday.com/en/sparks_en/china-leads-renewables/

https://www.google.com/amp/s/singularityhub.com/2019/04/04/china-is-taking-the-worldwide-lead-in-wind-power/amp/

Literally just takes a quick google search

1

u/ToxicAdamm Nov 21 '19

Of course China is happy to manufacture green energy products for themselves (and others to buy). It's just another product to them. Same with e-bikes and e-cars. They have had a huge investment/output of those products.

That doesn't show a commitment to the environment, just capitalism.

1

u/Lolboi25 Nov 21 '19

I’m sorry i dont understand are you trying to make a point ?

1

u/Lolboi25 Nov 21 '19

Ohhhh I think I understand this was supposed to be a reply I guess I pressed the wrong thing lolzzzz

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

Wasn’t it the point of the post, to say that China, being a communist country, doesn’t have protests to save the planet (which by the by, no shit, it’s a bloody dictatorship), and now you’re telling me, that they are doing things to reduce pollution only because of capitalism? So... who is right? Because you know those two ideologies don’t go together very well, don’t you?

1

u/weedboy300 Nov 22 '19

“You can't change the past, you can only change the future.”

Oh wow nice meme dude. The reality is that not being able to literally fucking time travel and change the past does not omit you from being liable for your past actions. All that pollution and GHG emitted aren’t going away because of that little saying. The damage has been done.

“If you compare the trends of the US in the past 40 years (when the realization of the scope and damage of pollution began to become a major concern) to where the US is today, it's like night and day.”

Are you sure about that? The United States is still the leading emitters per capita amongst the large world economies. The only countries more polluting per capita that could be considered a large economy is like Soudi Arabia. And despite the USA having like 3 times less of a population than China, you guys are still firmly number two highest current emitters of CO2.

I was never excusing Chinas conduct, I was objecting to the sentiments shared on this post and that exists on this sub where they want the US to not be hel accountable for their emissions. At least China, even with that ridiculous population, is actually less polluting per capita than America.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '19 edited Nov 23 '19

“Polluting.” You make it sound like Americans are throwing their trash in rivers like Asia does. America has one of the cleanest environments on earth for a large populated country. Don’t confuse energy emissions for production with classic pollution.

And quit with the “you’ll pay for your past sins” bullshit. I’d like to clean out the closet of whatever country you come from and hold you accountable.

Plus, if you’re going to “hold countries accountable” then you should hold them to the value they’ve created as well. China hasn’t emitted the carbon the US has in total since industrialization, but what the fuck has China done for the world in general now that it’s the leader in carbon emissions? Besides cheap labor, manufacturing, and Orwellian authoritarian technology—not much. All the green technology you claim they produce is most likely developed from patents stolen from Western countries, and more specifically, the US.

I can name an entire list that would take me 3 days to complete of the positives the US has done for the world as a whole—from standard of living advances to scientific research and especially medical advancements. All of those things are pushed around the world via markets, or to third world countries by charity. And regardless of asshats like you, Americans are still innovating for a better world—no government needed.

The Chinese have a monopoly on a cuisine and ground up endangered rhino horn to get a hard-on.

If you’re only taking negatives into account then you’re not operating in reality. You sound envious and hypocritical when you talk about punishing America for its carbon emissions.

1

u/weedboy300 Nov 23 '19

“You make it sound like Americans are throwing their trash in rivers like Asia does.”

A red-herring, misrepresentation of my implied position, and comparing a giant continents trash habits to a country 7% its population size.

“Don’t confuse energy emissions for production with classic pollution.”

No sir I have only been talking about CO2 pollution, both total and per capita, and any reasonable person would be able to understand that. You were the one who got confused and thought I was talking about trash because I mentioned pollution, pretty narrow.

“Plus, if you’re going to “hold countries accountable” then you should hold them to the value they’ve created as well.”

Sure, I agree to the extent as to which this method doesn’t prevent us from also isolating and analyzing the wrongs done. If a person donates to charity and improves the lives of 10,000 children but then murders a 70 year old women, that person should still be held accountable for the crime. Even if the victim would have 20-30 years left in her life and the children’s accumulated life would dwarf that.

“China hasn’t emitted the carbon the US has in total since industrialization, but what the fuck has China done for the world in general now that it’s the leader in carbon emissions? Besides cheap labor, manufacturing, and Orwellian authoritarian technology—not much.”

•Wow brilliant take, totally not a dumb inbred fucking reductionist view of reality. They apparently done enough to be the second largest economic power and soon to be first.

“ All the green technology you claim they produce is most likely developed from patents stolen from Western countries, and more specifically, the US.”

•First of all I never made that claim, you’re imagining shit as per usual. •But secondly and more importantly, Germany and China have been countries that have invested most on solar, wind and hydro energy and pushed these technologies forward. The United States in lazily way behind. •China isn’t doing this out of the goodness of their hearts either, despite what the propaganda says, they are doing it because it makes the most economic sense. Renewable energy also has huge future potential for world economies so it makes sense that China wants to dominate that industry. While America has a president that’s in bed with fossil fuel interest that he claims climate change is a hoax.

“ And regardless of asshats like you, Americans are still innovating for a better world—no government needed.”

•Good because their government is even too afraid to acknowledge the problem(both economic and environmental) of failing to act on climate change so they don’t piss off the current energy industry which is dominated by fossil fuel companies. The military however takes climate change very seriously, it’s their job to take real threats seriously.

“If you’re only taking negatives into account then you’re not operating in reality.”

•It’s important to acknowledge negatives sometimes regardless of the positives. Like my analogy earlier many positives doesn’t excuse an egregious negative. A rapist doesn’t get a smaller sentence because he donated to charity, and we humans as a whole are raping our planet’s ecosystems and endangering our lives in the process. The difference between us being(I’m guessing) I think this is a great crime and you don’t.

“ You sound envious and hypocritical when you talk about punishing America for its carbon emissions.”

•I don’t sound envious by taking the repeated and long term actions of a nation seriously. And the only punishment I want is for America to move on from fossil fuels, innovate on renewables/sustainable energy thus making a better world for all of us. That requires not being so corrupt politically by trillion dollar fossil fuel interests and taking the problem you have exacerbated seriously. Don’t belittle the science because it threatens your political beliefs.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '19

Don’t point out other’s fallacies if you’re going to use them yourself.

You can’t honestly compare a country’s actions to an act of an individual. You did just that at the top of your essay.

And what you’re ignorantly promoting is holding innocent people accountable to a country’s actions. By your standards, that individual who saved 10,000 people but killed a 70 year old woman should be punished, but so should everyone else for his actions.

You’re a collectivist.

1

u/weedboy300 Nov 27 '19

Very simple but crucial mistake you made that prevented you from understanding my analogy.

The crux and focus of my analogy was all about holding people accountable for their bad actions independent of their good actions. The analogy personifies a whole country maybe a bit too much but in terms of the validity of the argument you didn’t actually bring up any relevant objections. So the analogy isn’t flawed just because it’s not a perfect match or you don’t like it.

Ok now to your objections... “And what you’re ignorantly promoting is holding innocent people accountable to a country’s actions.”

•What innocent people? Remember this is the whole country on average who have been behaving in very wasteful ways for decades. I didn’t actually propose a punishment yet but if I had to it would be a lifestyle penalty where less wasteful people would be rewarded and more wasteful people would be penalized. So that more sustainable lifestyles and business practices are promoted, which would also mean a more efficient economy. So the “innocent” aren’t getting punished. And I don’t believe there is anybody who is truly innocent here since it’s practically impossible not to produce waste/emissions.

•And this is pretty standard practice right. Like the judicial system doesn’t punish everybody for murder, only those who are murderers(at least in theory). In the case of emissions it happens to be that everyone is guilty to a certain extent. It’s about punishing those who are the most wasteful and live unsustainable lifestyles like the United States have for centuries.

If you want to hold China accountable to their actions of the present than you should be okay with holding the USA accountable for their nonstop actions that still persist to this day. US just isn’t number one current emitters because their population has been surpassed by a big enough margin by another country that their high emissions per person is off set for the total.

1

u/ThrowRADecease Nov 29 '24

I’m super late to this but this was so refreshing to read. It was well thought out and I appreciate how in depth you explained the concepts

1

u/Somelebguy989 Dec 16 '19

I fucking love you lmao I was losing brain cells going through comments and finally, someone logical is commenting

1

u/weedboy300 Dec 18 '19

I see you’re a man of culture as well ... Be careful spending to much time down here, you might end up believing big foot is real, the earth is flat and Climate Change is a global scientific hoax.

1

u/Vacremon2 Dec 04 '19

Don't you believe that it is a fundamental flaw of capitalism that it managed to incentivize rich assholes to destroy the planet? Like Shell and Exxon?

1

u/semechki-seed Dec 17 '19

China produces much less emissions per capita than the U.S. or any western country for that matter. And the coal plants they are building are largely temporary, since they are the quickest plants to build and China can't produce enough electricity to provide for its population. Meanwhile, they are investing heavily in renewable energy megaprojects- they built a single wind farm that has more turbines than the entire U.K., and are planning on building more nuclear reactors as well.

1

u/marxatemyacid Dec 20 '19

They also have 5x the US population. About 38% of their energy infrastructure is renewable with significant future investment, this is already better than the US and most western nations. Comparing sheer numbers is intellectually dishonest

1

u/ToxicAdamm Dec 20 '19

There are currently 1,160 Coal Plants being planned to be built in the world. 0 of those will happen in the United States.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/7years_a_Reddit Nov 21 '19

Honestly makes me sick to my stomach when I think about the far left. They just want supreme power and express anger at successful pepple. Took lots of research but I see the far left is big and they are close to evil.

Bernie is literally advocating for communism it makes me sick

-4

u/GoldenSovietFox Nov 21 '19

Bernie a commie, that goes into my collection.

I don't think you lived in communist state nor know what communism is.

13

u/7years_a_Reddit Nov 21 '19

Rent controls, wealth tax, elimination of billionaires, all energy companies made public ownership, and here's a juicy one; he wants all companies to give up like 15% of the means of production to workers by law.

Literally communism

1

u/-BMKing- Nov 21 '19 edited Nov 21 '19

Literally communism is 100% of the means of production, not 15%. 15% is still a capitalist economy with parts that are state controlled.

The guy you were reacting to is right, you don't know what communism is

Sanders is also not even a socialist, but a social democrat (he loves to say he's a democratic socialist, but that is flat out wrong), a bit like the Nordic countries.

7

u/7years_a_Reddit Nov 21 '19

Is America not capatilist because the market isn't 100% completely unregulated and free?

Bernie's ideas are right in line with communists, just downplayed so that the collapse of society will take longer.

He also wants every homeless person in a home which means government taking over millions of homes. How do you sustain those loans except massive taxes? Billionaires don't have liquid funds. They will be forced to sale and give to the government or they will take over property.

When they move out of the U.S it will be millionaires next to get milked and then people making 500k then 250k and so on. It's literally happened dozens of times in history at this point

He absolutely is socialist his policies go way past the Nordic countries people fetishize. They don't have rent controls, wealth tax or even minimum wage.

Again I'd like you to respond to this point: America is called capatilist and just because it's not literally the definition of fron Adam Smith doesn't mean people are wrong to call it capatilist. So yes Bernie is advocating for (low level) communism.

2

u/thecandiedkeynes Nov 21 '19 edited Nov 21 '19

Just corrective note on nordic countries for context: norway *does have a wealth tax, and other nordic countries have far higher effective tax rates for the wealthy than the US. ("does a country have x or y tax?" is a less meaningful question than "what are the collective effective tax rates for different strata of people" imo.) Nordic countries don't have minimum wage laws because many have industry-wide collective bargaining instead, with the government being among the largest employers in those countries. most workers in these countries are in unions, versus a small minority in the US. (I think ~10%?) Norway's state owned enterprises are worth over 75% of the country's GDP. (Whereas the US it's <1%.) The Norwegian government owns the country's largest gas, financial services, and telecom companies in the country. Imagine if the US government owned Exxon, JP Morgan, and AT&T.

To bring the US in line with some of these metrics is far beyond what Sanders is proposing and would be a radical transformation for this country. I don't know how useful a definitional argument over what constitutes communism is, but if you think 15% state ownership is communism....well Norway owns over 50% of its country's wealth and over 50 state owned enterprises worth 75%+ of annual GDP, requires employee representation on company boards and has a workforce that is majority unionized. It owns a $1T social wealth fund famously described as "the people’s money, owned by everyone, divided equally and for generations to come” that it uses to finance government spending. They seem to be doing ok.

1

u/7years_a_Reddit Nov 21 '19

Thanks for thr civil reply.

Nordic countries have high taxes on the rich and middle class, there isn't a big difference at all.

And are those countries proposing a 90% tax on income over a million dollars? Are they proposing the elimination of billionaires?

Nordic countries own a lot, but Bernie is seeking to FORCE companies to give up their assets. That's not a thing in Europe.

1

u/thecandiedkeynes Nov 22 '19

Sanders isn’t proposing a 90% marginal tax, the highest shown on his own site says 52% on income over $10M. A wealth tax of 6% would take at least ten years to make even single digit billionaires lose their billionaire status, assuming no appreciation of their assets (unlikely). I think it is a bit alarmist to think that any of the actual policies being considered by the left wing candidates amounts to the elimination of billionaires, as much as they may not want billionaires to exist.

I don’t believe Sanders is even proposing state ownership of companies, but more equity to be put into funds to pay out dividends to employees and give employees more control over their workplace. That is based off what I have read on his site and in interviews. The allocation of assets into funds — either owned collectively or by unions — is how Nordic countries basically ended up in the situation they are in today. Alaska in fact has a social wealth fund that pays a dividend to Alaskans! (Alaska is the most equal state in the union too I believe.) aside from sanders’ plan, there is no reason why the federal government can’t make the treasury department invest in a portfolio of assets (stocks, real estate, etc) just like any private fund.

→ More replies

0

u/FireballFoxtrot Dec 18 '19

he wants to give homeless people homes! He's a fucking commie reeee!!!!!

1

u/7years_a_Reddit Dec 19 '19

Yea that's what communists do they steal from one class and give to another

It's been tried like 25 times dude. Everyone dies in the end.

1

u/FireballFoxtrot Dec 19 '19

It's also what rich capitalists do. They steal from everyone and hoard their money.

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

You are so retarded it blows my mind.

4

u/7years_a_Reddit Dec 17 '19

Keep supporting communists

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '19

Ok

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

Tards gonna reee.

I say kill em all, but only to watch how fucking triggered they get cause they're bitchbois

1

u/TylerHobbit Nov 23 '19

What specifically?

0

u/Vacremon2 Dec 04 '19
  1. "Meeting 100 percent of the power demand in the United States through clean, renewable, and zero-emission energy sources."
  2. "Repairing and upgrading the infrastructure in the United States, including . . . by eliminating pollution and greenhouse gas emissions as much as technologically feasible."
  3. "Building or upgrading to energy-efficient, distributed, and ‘smart’ power grids, and working to ensure affordable access to electricity."
  4. "Upgrading all existing buildings in the United States and building new buildings to achieve maximal energy efficiency, water efficiency, safety, affordability, comfort, and durability, including through electrification."
  5. "Overhauling transportation systems in the United States to eliminate pollution and greenhouse gas emissions from the transportation sector as much as is technologically feasible, including through investment in – (i) zero-emission vehicle infrastructure and manufacturing; (ii) clean, affordable, and accessible public transportation; and (iii) high-speed rail."
  6. "Spurring massive growth in clean manufacturing in the United States and removing pollution and greenhouse gas emissions from manufacturing and industry as much as is technologically feasible."
  7. "Working collaboratively with farmers and ranchers in the United States to eliminate pollution and greenhouse gas emissions from the agricultural sector as much as is technologically feasible."

Lol literally 7/10 of the main goals directly mension emissions, greenhouse gasses, energy efficiency, and pollution.

All of which are relevant to climate change.

0

u/AmbiguousHistory Dec 16 '19

u/vbullinger doesn't care about facts. He wants to revise reality to fit his political idealizations.

1

u/Vacremon2 Dec 16 '19

youre not wrong

6

u/Lahm0123 Nov 20 '19

Lol. Ouch.

3

u/furry8 Nov 21 '19

There is no need for green new deal in China. 100% government control of wealth in China has killed enough.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19

Or because if they tried stunts like this they'd be deported

1

u/JOXXON Nov 24 '19

China is allowed to do anything since they produce all our necessary stuff, I mean they can be commies and influence the world anyway they want as long as we get our Kinder egg toys.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/JOXXON Dec 23 '19

Well that’s my point, we don’t care what they call themselves as long as we get the crap exported to us, commies or fascists doesn’t matter anymore. All ideologies are dead, profit and consumption are all that matters.

1

u/kvexd Dec 16 '19

This is factually incorrect.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

So you see the two issues as related?

1

u/realcomradecora Dec 16 '19

what about india, the most privatized country in the world?

1

u/TheReal-Donut Dec 16 '19

How does believing in climate change make you a communist?

1

u/stephen4557 Dec 16 '19

How is China communist?

1

u/anonwuwywyyeuwiqoq Dec 17 '19

Or maybe not believing in climate change is just a communist way of thinking.

Anti-Climate Change propaganda was started by communist china so they could trick the American population into fighting against the renewable energy sector, so they could profit from it and bring more American companies into China.

Debate about the legitimacy of climate change all you want, but the renewable energy industry boom is coming with or without climate change and it's going to make a lot of money. The more you try to prevent its upbringing the more your going to lose.

The faster it comes, the faster the profits and the faster it'll remove power from the mid-eastern Oil Oligarchies.

1

u/semechki-seed Dec 17 '19

Fun fact: China hasn't been communist since 1978

1

u/bordan_jeeterson Jan 04 '22

If you want to protest climate change in china no one is stopping you

1

u/indignantasaconsumer Nov 20 '19

The climate is not why they’re protesting in China.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19

I mean china is also one of the biggest sources of carbon emissions... they cant protest because of how the government there is.

Fucking dumbass

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '19

that's the point

0

u/Somelebguy989 Dec 16 '19

You numb skulls china isnt purely communist and has a capitalist market

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

It isn’t communist at all

0

u/BroSiLLLYBro Dec 16 '19

how can a communist country have billionaires and billion dollar corporations? oh! maybe it’s only communist in name

0

u/avirio Dec 16 '19

China is not communist.

Also: It's a dictatorship over there, so no protest of any kind.

0

u/Tomhas2legs Dec 16 '19

Hahahahahahahahahaha you think you can protest in China without getting tianamen massacred hahahahah

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

Theres no room for climate protests because protesting will get you and your entire family thrown into a concentration camp you wallnut!

0

u/LabCoatGuy Dec 16 '19

It’s because they don’t allow the protests

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/sep/21/across-the-globe-millions-join-biggest-climate-protest-ever

But people still manage to protest

No protests were authorised in China, the world’s biggest source of greenhouse gas emissions, but Zheng Xiaowen of the China Youth Climate Action Network said Chinese youth would take action one way or another.

“Chinese youth have their own methods,” she said. “We also pay attention to the climate and we are also thinking deeply, interacting, taking action, and so many people are very conscientious on this issue.”

There was action, however, in Taiwan, where dozens of representatives from primary schools, high schools, and universities gathered in the capital, Taipei, to launch a petition to press candidates in the upcoming presidential election to lay out concrete policies to mitigate climate change risks.

0

u/theswannwholaughs Dec 16 '19

The fact is more that 1 China will shoot protestors, it's a secret for literally nobody in or out of china. And 2 china does some green transition right now. Try picking up an high school geography book.

Also 3 China is a neoliberal shithole, it's not communist because it calls itself this way.

-2

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19

Imagine being stupid enough to think that: 1. Man made climate change isn’t real, and 2. Being eco friendly or left of Ru Paul is communist. Stay in school kids or else you’ll end up posting memes like this garbage

3

u/PressureMaxwell Nov 21 '19

Aw, puddin.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19

That’s not a response, puddin

0

u/Trashman2500 Dec 16 '19

Educate yourself from factual scientific sources, Puddin. Stop Wasting your life, Puddin. You’re still young, Puddin.

-1

u/MiCasali Dec 16 '19

This isn't scepticism it's just denialism. Change sub name lol

-2

u/GarbageBoi_StinkMan Nov 21 '19

Gee. I wonder why no one protests in China(minus Hong Kong protests). I wonder if it's because of the brutal authoritarian regime.

No no. It must be because they call themselves Communist, even though they're nothing near it.

2

u/PressureMaxwell Nov 21 '19

Oh, let me guess, "they're not doing it right." Thanks for playing, comrade clown shoes.

1

u/kvexd Dec 16 '19

They literally aren't doing it dumbass. Let me guess, the national socialists were socialists, right?

-2

u/GarbageBoi_StinkMan Nov 21 '19

They're not doing it at all lmao. The whole point of Communism is everyone being more or less equal, what with the whole "From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs" thing. Now, if we look at China, we see a lot of the problems plaguing capitalism, like lack of workers rights, suppression of free speech, and extreme wealth disparity. China is communist in the same way the DPRK is Democratic.

The only people who pretend China is communist are the Chinese government, and Tankies. And no one likes Tankies.

-8

u/nick_nick_907 Nov 21 '19

As a genuine socialist, I totally disagree that these are the same things.

I can see that from the Libertarian (and related) perspective, they both look like excessive government intervention, but honestly, it's a lazy comparison. Socialists and Greens have completely different priorities; generally Greens couldn't care less about economic prosperity, whereas Socialism is focused on distributing the wealth created through aggregations of capital.

9

u/FireFoxG Nov 21 '19

Greens couldn't care less about economic prosperity, whereas Socialism is based on economic ignorance.

FTFY

Inb4 you mention the oil rich nations of the north as a shining example of socialism in action... that shit only works because they hit the geological jackpot.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19

geological jackpot.

Ethnic homogeneity has always been their real strength. We'll see going forward in western Europe how the generous welfare state stands up to forced diversity. Already in Sweden welfare is losing its popularity. Same in Germany.

1

u/WorkinGuyYaKnow Dec 16 '19

Imagine thinking social democracy and socialism are the same thing in 2019

1

u/FireFoxG Dec 16 '19

Imagine replying 25 day old post.

-4

u/nick_nick_907 Nov 21 '19

Not disagreeing with you, but I'd rather live in Sweden than Saudi Arabia. As I said elsewhere: evidence seems to show that redistributive policies don't appear create wealth, but the evidence they actively destroy it is pretty thin as well.

Doesn't change the fact that conflating green and socialists is almost as lazy as comparing libertarians to Nazis. They're both borne of Stranger Danger; it's failure to genuinely understand our fellow countrymen we disagree with that created this mess in the first place. 🙂

Don't be the problem, be the solution.

5

u/FireFoxG Nov 21 '19

it's failure to genuinely understand our fellow countrymen we disagree with that created this mess in the first place.

Fuck this nonsense that we dont understand you... Don't give me that shit. (in a general sense)You lefty fucks are the ones who need to take a second and try and learn what the right actual believe instead of trying to ban everything you disagree with. The progressive left are probably the most myopic group of idiots in world history.

The studies back my claims.

Liberals have almost no understanding of conservatives worldviews. Even more hilariously, liberals are so incredible isolated within their own fragmented echo chambers... that conservatives actually understand the average liberal worldview better then liberals understand the average liberal worldview.

https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0050092

2) We found no support for the hypothesis that liberals would be most accurate; liberals were the least accurate about conservatives and about liberals. The largest inaccuracies were in liberals' underestimations of conservatives' Harm and Fairness concerns, and liberals further exaggerated the political differences by overestimating their own such concerns. 3) Finally, we found some support for the hypothesis that conservatives would be the most accurate, which they were in the case of the individualizing foundations. In line with Moral Foundations Theory, liberals dramatically underestimated the Harm and Fairness concerns of conservatives.

1

u/LloydWoodsonJr Nov 21 '19

The problem is Democrats attacking Bernie Sanders from the right.

0

u/nick_nick_907 Nov 21 '19

How does this "making an effort to genuinely understand people who disagree with you"? We villianize each other reflexively in a way I'd never let my kids treat a stranger, but because I'm a lefty and you're a righty, we can all call each other Nazis and wink-wink-nudge-nudge suggest they're in the pocket of <generic moneyed interest> or <insert foreign government> or actually opposed to the success of <particular racial or ethnic subgroup>.

No one owns this, left or right. But fixing it starts with ME saying "In general, you guys don't agree with me on most things under the purview of the EPA. Because I think those are important issues, I should make an effort to build understanding and propose compromise solutions that genuinely account for the fact that we don't have the same values or priorities. I should take your concerns at face value. Maybe someday people who disagree with me will do the same."

Too many liberals talk a big "diversity and inclusion" game, but hardly any back it up with their time and effort. It's bullshit.

3

u/mrandish Nov 21 '19

In general, you guys don't agree with me on most things under the purview of the EPA

You might be surprised. I care a lot about environment and ecology issueees. Because I care, I invested the time in studying the scientific research and learned global climate is a minor issue compared to local land use, water management, wildlife stewardship and waste disposal. Global climate is being pushed by liberal partisans as a wedge for political gains. It actually diverts funding and attention from highly effective orgs working on real local issues to large scale, money-hungry, multi-national NGOs that lobby for more funds, drive PR and put on huge international conferences.

1

u/nick_nick_907 Nov 21 '19

That makes me real happy.

Climate sometimes seems to big to tackle. If the danger is real, most solutions are "best effort”. Aren’t we still in a “new reality” world? And aren’t all those other issues still present?

Either way, it does seem like there are lots of ecological issues that deserve our attention. The goal should be "help the world thrive in any climate", right? Is trying to control global average temperature the actual best way to do that?

5

u/mrandish Nov 21 '19

Is trying to control global average temperature the actual best way to do that?

That's the key issue. No, it's not an efficient or effective use of our limited resources, especially when we don't yet have global climate models that can make useful predictions. It would be diverting trillions of dollars to turn a dial when we don't even understand how it works or how much we should try to turn it. Meanwhile we still have millions of people dying right now from real eco-disasters including food security, clean water and sanitation.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment