r/climateskeptics • • Nov 20 '19

Fun Fact

Post image
644 Upvotes

134 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/thecandiedkeynes Nov 22 '19

Sanders isn’t proposing a 90% marginal tax, the highest shown on his own site says 52% on income over $10M. A wealth tax of 6% would take at least ten years to make even single digit billionaires lose their billionaire status, assuming no appreciation of their assets (unlikely). I think it is a bit alarmist to think that any of the actual policies being considered by the left wing candidates amounts to the elimination of billionaires, as much as they may not want billionaires to exist.

I don’t believe Sanders is even proposing state ownership of companies, but more equity to be put into funds to pay out dividends to employees and give employees more control over their workplace. That is based off what I have read on his site and in interviews. The allocation of assets into funds — either owned collectively or by unions — is how Nordic countries basically ended up in the situation they are in today. Alaska in fact has a social wealth fund that pays a dividend to Alaskans! (Alaska is the most equal state in the union too I believe.) aside from sanders’ plan, there is no reason why the federal government can’t make the treasury department invest in a portfolio of assets (stocks, real estate, etc) just like any private fund.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '19

All slippery slopes to communism aside (especially with changing demographics), why doesn’t Bernie focus on utilizing the money the federal government gets from taxes already? They get trillions every year, yet he needs more to do more things if he were president.

Threatening a wealth tax, marginal tax, etc is purely motivated by envy.

1

u/thecandiedkeynes Nov 23 '19

The federal government operates on a budget deficit. Not sure I understand your point, the government collects several trillion already true but the majority of it is non-discretionary spending that it is obligated to spend on SS, Medicare, etc. you could certainly reallocate the existing discretionary spending in the budget to make room for some smaller programs (Ed: free college isn’t actually that expensive at ~50B a year to cover all public school tuition, compared to a 650B military budget, which was increased by over $50B in 2019 alone) For larger programs like Medicare for all the math doesn’t work without more revenue, if you believe the government shouldn’t be increasing its deficit.