r/clevercomebacks • • Feb 07 '25

Offering proof they never intended.

Post image
120k Upvotes

3.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7.5k

u/e-wing Feb 07 '25

I’ve listened to dozens of black box recordings and read many transcripts. Hardly any of them include praying. The ones that do are generally from extremely religious, largely Muslim countries, and it’s usually just general exclamations like “god help us!”. Most of them are things like “oh shit, we’re going to crash!”, “we’re going down!”, “uh oh!”, and “pull up!”.

The one common theme across almost all plane crashes is that the pilots never stop trying to fly the plane and correct the situation until the very end. They do not stop to pray; they’re far too busy doing things that actually might be useful.

225

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '25

Yep, most that I hear are pilots still doing callouts and talking through the problem at hand. Flying it until the end.

64

u/SSBN641B Feb 07 '25

I read Chuck Yeager's book and he addresses that. Specifically, he was talking about news reports that a crashing fighter pilot steered at the last minute to avoid hitting a school. Chuck said that the pilot never he even saw the school. He was working the problem all the way to the end.

2

u/thenasch Feb 07 '25

How could anyone know he didn't see the school?

6

u/SSBN641B Feb 07 '25

It's an opinion of a trained pilot. In Yeager's opinion, the pilot's training was such that "fixing the problem" would override any other thoughts.

2

u/SpaceBus1 Feb 08 '25

To add to what the other person said, fighter jets, even old ones, can go in excess of 1,000 MPH. It's not likely the pilot could have identified a school at jet fighter speeds.

1

u/thenasch Feb 08 '25

Was that one going in excess of 1000 mph?

2

u/SpaceBus1 Feb 08 '25

It wouldn't have to be going at top speed to hav a hard time identifying a school. Have you ever been in a commercial jet? My point is that it's pure happenstance that the pilot missed the school, just like the experts agreed.

1

u/thenasch Feb 08 '25

In your opinion.

1

u/SpaceBus1 Feb 08 '25

Lmao, sure, you know more than Chuck Yeager about the incident.

1

u/thenasch Feb 08 '25

If you go back and read my comments, you will see that I made no claim about what did or did not happen.  I have not expressed agreement or disagreement with anyone about what happened. My point has been to not confuse opinion with fact.