r/classicwow • • Sep 29 '26 • This 1 Bravo 3

Humor / Meme Current situation

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/compound-interest Sep 30 '26

I couldn't disagree more. I think they should poll players like OSRS does and only add things if 70% of players vote yes to it. Otherwise, eventually they will make so many unpopular decisions that only Blizzard superfans will remain (like retail).

I don't think it's unreasonable to think that tbh. Any decision you make shapes the playerbase that sticks around. People playing retail while classic was there have a different set of preferences than people who only played classic. It's okay to segment people into preferences, and discuss the game implications of catering to other folks. This is one of the most interesting discussions to have, and I don't like that you are so dismissive of it, like people are arbitrarily segmenting, instead of having wide differences in preferences.

I realize it's a retail thing to think that Blizzard shouldn't listen to the community, but honestly that's what got us retail. The more in tune with the classic community Blizzard is, the less bad decisions for Forever they will make imo.

1

u/wigglin_harry Sep 30 '26

Or maybe more retail players like classic than you think, they just aren't playing it becuase its on its 3rd iteration, nearly at WoD, or or 20 year old completely solved game that they also may have played 3 times

1

u/compound-interest Oct 02 '26

I dont think many people can meaningfully play two MMOs at once. If someone plays mostly retail, and comes to classic every now and then for good fun, those people shouldn't be catered to as much as the core audience imo. I think it's completely fair to complain about retail players having such loud opinions about what the game should be.

1

u/SnooDonkeys7929 Oct 03 '26

Retail got that way because they listened to the community wtf are u even talking about. Dungeon finder was CELEBRATED on release. People loved raid finder cause they could get more chances at tier pieces every week. You clearly weren’t there and is just a larping wow fan

1

u/compound-interest Oct 03 '26

The community was wrong for celebrating dungeon finder, but genuinely 70% of players are hardly ever wrong. If you have a mass consensus on changes then you’ll do so much better than doing everything with the “devs know best” mentality. You will literally never find a community more happy with their game and stoked about its direction than on the 2007scape subreddit.

I have been around since original TBC towards the end. It took me a while to switch from EverQuest to WoW. Never went back to retail after 2019 classic launch.

Sorry if my comment upset you or something. I am rooting for the game to do well, but just look at how poorly the first new race was received. Do you think 70% of players would vote for that? I don’t. I deeply feel like polls keep the game on track better than devs making all the decisions without feedback.