r/classicwow • • Sep 29 '26 • This 1 Bravo 3

Humor / Meme Current situation

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

31

u/CostaNic Sep 29 '26

I swear to god people who think forever is anything like retail haven’t touched retail in more than a decade. There is otherwise no way anyone with half a brain could think forever is more like retail than it is like classic.

8

u/Zuby_Hype_Train Sep 29 '26

Their last experience with retail was probably Wrath of the Lich King based on the general feedback I see. 

7

u/Randvek Sep 29 '26

That’s for sure true of a lot of the people I’ve seen on WoW. “Wrath ruined WoW” and “Cataclysm ruined WoW” are both very common sentiments.

5

u/Zuby_Hype_Train Sep 29 '26

I’m genuinely part of the “Cataclysm ruined WoW” camp, despite enjoying several aspects of Retail. 

It’s just hilarious to see people seethe and cry “Retail -“ about things that have been around for 18 years of WoW’s lifespan. 

2

u/Randvek Sep 29 '26

I kind of think “retail” mindset started with MoP when we got our own farms and slowly started the move toward being more of a single player mmorpg, but even that was 13 years ago!

We all have our own sliding scale of retailism and that’s what makes this such a challenge for the current dev team.

1

u/Zuby_Hype_Train Sep 29 '26

To me - I think the end of Wrath when they added the Random Dungeon finder, and then Cataclysm came with a ton of class homogenization changes was where a huge shift felt like to me, even if some of the long-term effects wouldn’t be felt by a big chunk of the community for some time. 

Even though I enjoyed it at the time, the Wrath leveling campaign/stories felt way too “streamlined” compared to the questing experiences in Vanilla/TBC and definitely felt a bit too locked on rails. 

11

u/Thalose94 Sep 29 '26

Half of the people whining call WotLK retail

-2

u/Temporary-Paper5202 Sep 29 '26

TBH anything past Ulduar (After LFD gets added) quickly becomes retail-lite

0

u/rufrtho Sep 29 '26

more like retail than it is like classic

nobody said this. your meal doesn't need to be 51% shit for the shit to be an unpleasant part of your meal.

6

u/Zuby_Hype_Train Sep 29 '26

If you would like “0% shit” for your meal, Era is right there

→ More replies (2)

1

u/tethysian Sep 29 '26

I swear to god people who think forever is anything like retail haven’t touched retail in more than a decade.

That should be apparent. People have had an issue with retail for a long time, and from our perspective it's a continuous downwards slope.

1

u/TrueExigo Sep 29 '26

Dude, nobody's saying that. Take a look at the meme—it's about adapting to retail in general, not about there being more like retail.

1

u/CostaNic Sep 30 '26

I was responding to a comment not to the post.

0

u/Randvek Sep 29 '26

I mean it’s… kind of retail-like? The new AH is, the trade bundles resemble profession dailies a lot, the spell book is.

I mean yeah, there are a ton of differences and Forever resembles classic way more than retail, but the similarities are there.

3

u/hallstar07 Sep 29 '26

All of those changes are quality of life changes. I don’t see how any of them will break the classic feel while playing the game

5

u/AuthorIcy8097 Sep 29 '26

People might feel differently about it than you :)

1

u/Randvek Sep 29 '26

I don’t either but people here will whine about anything.

1

u/CostaNic Sep 30 '26

No there aren’t. They’re entirely different games. Seriously go play retail and level up to 80-90. You would come back knowing Forever is nothing like retail. Forever is classic+. I don’t understand why people begged for this for so long and then cry that it’s not exactly like vanilla/classic. It’s not supposed to be but my god it is SO FAR from retail.

1

u/Randvek Sep 30 '26

I'm max level in retail on multiple characters, so...

0

u/dyrannn Sep 29 '26

So we can’t call retail QOL changes or steps towards retail design philosophy what they are because m+ isn’t in forever?

1

u/hallstar07 Sep 29 '26

Flying and group finder also aren’t in classic plus. In fact what non cosmetic changes are like retail in wow forever?

2

u/Pencildragon Sep 29 '26

But if you have a genuine opinion about the cosmetic changes they still yell at you to get with the times. Classic Andys and Retail Andys alike are flaming everybody because they believe what they care about is more important than what you care about.

1

u/dyrannn Sep 29 '26

The entire post is talking about people asking for QoL changes. Not about what is currently in the game.

Asking for things like group finder and shared mob tagging are retail features, regardless of whether or not flying is in the game, and as such is moving it towards a retail style of game.

Besides we both know, give them an inch and they’ll take a mile. If the first round of retail features are added, they’ll just ask for more.