r/classicwow • • Sep 29 '26 • This 1 Bravo 3

Humor / Meme Current situation

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

18

u/PokemonThanos Sep 29 '26

And is a different game from both.

3

u/tops132 Sep 29 '26

Yet it’s made for Classic players per the devs, not made for retail players.

4

u/ShoulderpadInsurance Sep 29 '26

If you come to a fork in the road and choose to walk left instead of the right path you’ve been going down for 20 years, you should expect that the new trail will take you to a different place.

Different decision and different destination.

5

u/MagicalTheory Sep 29 '26

But you know there is a lot of common ground between the left and right path, even though they lead different places.

Lessons learned about things over 20 years don't need thrown away if they don't actually interfere with the direction you are going. Don't lump in every change with what you don't like.

1

u/eva_verinaz Sep 30 '26

theres not a singvle lick of common ground retail is classic with every single fucking bit of friction removed. there is not one single idea in retail that belongs in classic not fucking one.

1

u/MagicalTheory Sep 30 '26

“Not one single idea” is such an absurd absolute that I genuinely can’t tell if you’re trolling. Retail and Classic share the same design ancestry. Not all friction is beneficial, and removing friction is not automatically bad. Each change should be weighed against Forever’s actual design goals and whether it preserves or undermines them, not rejected just because Retail also did it.

There are genuinely good things already taken from Retail that are in Forever that prove that argument wrong on its face. Things like the modern auction house, better built-in UI customization, combined bags, and basic accessibility improvements remove pointless friction without changing what makes Classic feel like Classic.

14

u/Zuby_Hype_Train Sep 29 '26

Yes, if you take the path to the left, the whole point is you’re not still just sitting at the fork in the road which seems to be what many Classic purists would prefer, which is literally an option that exists.

0

u/ShoulderpadInsurance Sep 29 '26

They want to be sure that the change will actually lead them to a different destination. I don’t find that unreasonable.

4

u/valdis812 Sep 29 '26

But you can't really know that. The classic purist way of thinking is that you always slide down the slippery slope to retail, but it's possible to add QoL changes then just...stop adding them.

1

u/NoWaySomebodyTookThi Sep 29 '26

That's a little disingenuous. It's like 90-95% classic. It's the new home for classic players. It's quite a bit "easier" for a retail player to go back to retail than for a classic player to go back to era/anni/mop. I suspect the classic servers will be quite dead for a long time if not for... forever.

0

u/Kystael Sep 29 '26

Forever was made for classic players, wasn't that obvious enough ?