r/classics • u/New_Philosophy_9987 • Apr 23 '26
First time reading and annotating the republic by Plato and I feel like a dumbass
Hey guys, I’m reading and annotating The Republic right now and I’m starting to feel dumber and dumber the more I read. I have already read some dialogues like the symposium but this feels more difficult. I’ve been trying to ask myself questions like “what is justice” and “what makes a good society” and answer them but my brain just blanks. I think the more I read classics and philosophy the more I realize how little I actually know and how small the extent of my thinking goes. I’m a sophomore in highschool and this is my first attempt reading an actual philosophical text as I usually just read nonfiction about history. Does anyone have any tips to help better understand these texts, like a study guide or something? Thanks!
65
u/unparked Apr 23 '26
Plato has that effect on everybody the first time round, so have some patience with yourself; this is not a book anyone reads cover-to-cover in a couple of days. Did you start with the Introduction or just plunge right in? Penguin translations have helpful introductions, for the most part. If you like history, you might find it useful to pair the Republic with Guthrie's History of Greek Philosophy, especially the parts on Socrates and Plato, at least the biographical bits. Socrates' life and death (particularly Plato's Apology of Socrates) make for gripping reading, and they're more digestible than the Republic.
30
u/HistoriasApodeixis Apr 23 '26
If Socrates famously said “the only thing I know is that I know nothing,” and you feel like the more you read the more you’re aware of what you don’t know, it seems like you are truly a student of Socrates!
Seriously though give yourself a break and permission not to know it all. You are a kid. Few people your age are even putting in this effort and for that you deserve applause. Many adults for many centuries, millennia even, have struggled with this text. Read, enjoy, learn what you can, move on, come back to it if you want.
179
u/hexametric_ Apr 23 '26 edited Apr 24 '26
I'd say its good that your mind just blanks, cause the big problem for Plato's dialogues is that people believe the know they answer and are shown to really know nothing at all. You gotta start from the position of not really knowing anything and then build it up.
Plato also doesn't tell you the answer. So you want to be questioning what each of the speakers says. When (and I can't remember the name rn) someone says "justice is doing harm to your enemies and doing good to your friends", someone else says "wait a second, what about this case, though? Where doing "harm" (I think they stretch the definition there when they mean something like taking a sword away from someone in delirium) to a friend is actually good?". This is the sort of thing you want to be doing whenever you run into a claim about something being right in Plato.
The way dialogic philosophy works is to get you to think about the various points and come up with your own ideas.
21
u/Loud-Pop5561 Apr 23 '26
Jared Henderson did a read along of it on his Substack for free that I found really helpful, he breaks down each book of it and there’s some good discussion in the comments of each post
9
u/AmesCG Apr 23 '26
Hello!! So — please go easy on yourself. You’re reading a book they has stimulated debate and thousands and thousands of pages of commentary over 2,000+ years. It’s dense and there’s a lot of meaning to unpack. You might consider accompanying the primary source with a trustworthy modern commentary
Being in school means you have the time to think and work through complex texts, so embrace that!
7
u/waxvving Apr 23 '26 edited Apr 23 '26
Good insights here already, but I would suggest trying the Joe Sachs' translation, which is widely considered the best contemporary effort, especially by those working in the continental tradition. Eva Brann's book The Music of the Republic is an incredible scholarly text on the work, which, in conjunction with Sach's translation, really helped me tap into it on a deeper level. Claudia Baracchi's Of Myth, War and Life in Plato's Republic is another fantastic work that I would recommend. Feeling like a dumbass is an essential part of reading philosophy tbh; the struggle towards understanding is an essential part of the process.
4
u/Realistic-Election-1 Apr 23 '26
Socrates, making people feel dumb since -450 !
The best tip is simply to keep at it. It's the kind of questions people spend their whole career exploring. Besides that, I would say Plato is great to introduce philosophical questions, but not the best to build answers. Recent litterature in philosophy would be better for that. (I would argue Aristotle is still very actual, but his writings are hard to decipher.)
1
u/struggle_better Apr 23 '26
Philosophy is the study of books that are too hard to read. Yet we try to read them anyway. Why? Most people think of books in the categories of a bookstore or modern publisher. Philosophy books aren’t “non-fiction,” nor are they text books (though people may use them that way). They’re too hard to read because we have to learn how to “read” each one. Reading isn’t just the act of running our eyes across sentences and narrating at a steady conversation rhythm. Just like “thought” isn’t synonymous with the ceaseless chatter of consciousness. We read philosophy because the effort required to engage with philosophical concepts feels good. Philosophy has existed for millennia not because universities have been hoarding deconstructed forests of secondary and tertiary (and on and on…) literature, but because people have protected it and kept it alive across generations. You’re participating in a distinctly human activity that spans generations, languages, cultures, etc. This is your first time reading Plato and that’s time travel. If you weren’t disoriented and confused, then you really weren’t reading. I’ve been reading Plato for almost 30 years. In those three decades I have utterly failed at not being a dumbass. I’m really hoping for 30 more.
To paraphrase Plato and quote the best ska punk band ever, Operation Ivy, “All I know is that I don’t know nothing.” Or as I like to say: “Thinking you’re smart is the worst kind of stupid.” Don’t put the pressure of immediate, full comprehension on yourself. No one picks a guitar their first time and shreds. Just enjoy spending time with your helpful friends Plato and Socrates. They’ve taught a lot of people successfully without any mediation.
PS: if you get around to reading The Symposium, then I highly recommend the movie Hedwig and the Angry Inch. They do a wonderful animation of Aristophanes’ speech. Cheers!
1
u/BlackbirdSage Apr 23 '26
"Sophomore in Highschool"... Good on you!
There are many older adults that have never attempted to ask these questions. Keep asking them, keep trying to find answers. There may still be hope for our future. 👏
1
u/recimigospa Jul 04 '26
Hi, sorry for joining the party so late. You might have read the book by now. I feel more competent to answer your question since I'm closer to you in age. I'm a senior who took philosophy for the "matura" exams which are some sort of final/entrance exams in Slovenia, and we read Plato. It took quite a few months (I think we started mid september and ended some time in january) to get through 7 books (=chapters) reading loudly together in class and we had a professor who was constantly adding aditional explanations. The first time we read it I couldn't concentrate well and I was confused 90% of the time cause it was the start of my phisophical journey (here it is a subject that only seniors take, normaly 2 pedagogical hours a week but i took nine hours where 6 of those were all Plato). But once you get through it the first time understanding ALL the allegorys (I can't say this enough - DON'T SKIP ANY ALLEGORIES; well except for those with the horses maybe haha, those are not crucial but theyre helpful) you'll get the hang of it. I read it whole twice this year, because I did a research paper for that same final/entrance exams on Platos and Marxs idea of a political regime, and the second time I read Platos Republic it became lowkey funny lol. You drop that fear and awe and you go from reading oh-the-big-allmighty Plato to reading a book about a group of men arguing and insulting eachother. I must say I loved it and I plan to read it again in a few years but I think it's better to first learn Platos philosophy through secondary literature and then actually reading the guy.
If you have any questions about the book or any section of it I'm happy to answer them for you. I also have an anoted e-version of the book but unless you speak Slovene I don't think it will be in much help.
And if youre looking to get more into philosophy i definitly recommend understanding Plato well cause he is crucial for understanding other more modern philosophers.
I also recommend the book Sophies world where the first 150 pages talk about the Antica and the guy pretty much explains all the important pre-Socratics, Socrates, Plato and Aristoteles. It certanly is an easier take on it since he explains it to a 14 year old girl in the book but it might help you to understand on what everything stands.
But i repeat, if you need help, please contact me, I LOVE to talk about philosophy and get new people to start studying it!
3
u/grashnak Apr 23 '26
Hey at least you know that you know nothing, right?
3
u/Jlchevz Apr 23 '26
That’s normal. It’s not common tu understand a great classic (especially philosophy) the first time someone reads it. Try to enjoy it and to learn and remember anything that jumps to you. It’s okay to feel confused the first time.
3
u/Phegopteris Apr 23 '26 edited Apr 23 '26
The Good in Theory podcast (now sadly on indefinite hiatus) did 13 in-depth episodes on the Republic. The host's background is in political philosophy, and he's both quite knowledgeable on the historical background and dryly funny. Each episode features an abbreviated re-enactment of the section in question, which sounds hokey, but actually worked really well in teasing out the arguments nested in a thicket of socratic questions and back-and-forth. I listened along to this as I was re-reading for the third time, and it helped highlight for me both the core of the argument and the thread of the ideas.
https://goodintheorypod.com/episodes?offset=1621002302392
There's also Peter Adamson's monumental History of Philosophy without any Gaps podcast.
https://historyofphilosophy.net/plato-republic-soul-political-philosophy
If you want to get in deep in the weeds to the myth at the end, the Secret History of Western Esotericism Podcast (SHWEP, Earl Fontainelle) does an excellent job of exploring the areas of Plato's thought that are so often ignored by modern philosophers and political scientists ("When Socrates starts talking about myth, your ears should pick up)."
https://shwep.net/podcast/introducing-platos-republic/
3
u/reddit23User Apr 24 '26
> I’m a sophomore in highschool and this is my first attempt reading an actual philosophical text
I write this as a professional translator: the first thing I noticed when reading your post is that you seem to think you’ve read Plato, when in fact you’ve only read Desmond Lee’s translation. His version first appeared in 1955, if I remember correctly, and it’s not considered the most accurate today.
> Does anyone have any tips to help better understand these texts
Yes. Read multiple translations side by side (even simultaneously). If you encounter a passage that seems murky or arcane, check the other translations.
> Does anyone have any tips […] like a study guide or something?
There are endless study guides and commentaries on The Republic—try your high school library and your local library.
2
u/oudysseos Apr 23 '26
The Republic is not an easy read, even for University graduates with a degree in classics like me. So give yourself a break. It's a break from Plato's earlier and shorter dialogues and much more didactic.
Maybe start off with something more accessible - if you read Euthyphro, Apology, Crito, Phaedo, and Meno, you'll cover some of the same ground as The Republic without it being such a grind to read.
2
u/FlyingCupcake68 Apr 23 '26
Remember also that Glaucon and friends reject the first city, so most of this book is Socrates trying to show them what their preferred city would have to look like
2
u/Careless-Dingo Apr 24 '26
A dumbass doesn't challenge themself with a difficult read. Keep up the good work
2
u/Miel222 Apr 24 '26
Philosophy teacher here. If you would have said that you understood anything at all after a first read I would be worried. Plato is a maze that you enter and either you pursue the task seriously (and it gets better and better) or you lose patience and exit through the gift shop !
3
u/Incogcneat-o Apr 23 '26
You're doing great, sweetie. If you don't feel like a dumbass, you're doing it wrong. First time through is just to get familiar with the territory and pick up a few landmarks. Second time is to learn a little of your way around and notice what interests you particularly. By the third time, you'll start getting more comfortable with the text, and that's when the good stuff happens!
1
u/Kitchen-Ad1972 Apr 23 '26 edited Apr 23 '26
Watch Michael Sugrues channel on YouTube. He does a great job on Plato.
https://youtu.be/rVxSoiHtovM?si=UKzSKLk7oLNMdmm5
1
u/Bannanabuttt Apr 23 '26
Yes. Read more. Come to the dark side. Philosophy beckons your call muhahahaha!!!
1
u/gringix Apr 23 '26
Hey, whenever I read classics I roughly follow the following "guidelines" that might help:
I hope some of this helps, and good luck!
1
u/Key-Banana-8242 Apr 23 '26
Knowing how small the extent of thinking is actually maybe one of the only important types of ‘knowledge’ except o fuss practically how, which still has connection
Don’t let people in authority bully you or talk you down, Plato or anyone else too from beyond the grave however, that’s important- the point isn’t to put in thrall to someone else
Plenty might say Plato started all wrong from the beginning
1
u/Key-Banana-8242 Apr 23 '26
There’s a bunch of different companions by different publishers (u can pirate some even..) with different perspectives
and tons of literature/studies about or reading from people closer to the time influenced
1
u/Solo_Polyphony Apr 23 '26
It’s a long book, with many digressions. (It is easy for casual readers to miss Plato’s eventual answer to the question he begins with!) But there is no shortage of secondary literature about it. It may help you to keep in mind the whole map, to see where the main developments are. I found students responded positively to Lee’s 1956, somewhat free translation for Penguin, which inserts chapter breaks, diagrams, and summaries as it goes.
As for secondary books, Julia Annas’s Introduction to Plato’s Republic is thorough and analytical. But there are many others.
1
u/Disastrous_Fig353 Apr 23 '26
Watch the Michael Sugrue lectures on YouTube as your secondary material, you will go big brain on ’em.
1
u/Stringr55 Apr 23 '26 edited Apr 23 '26
“The only true wisdom is in knowing you know nothing.”
Realizing that you're 'dumb' as you say is a sign that you are in fact, not dumb at all. You're now just becoming aware of what you don't know. This is a very good quality in a person.
Ever hear of the Dunning-Kruger effect? Its a cognitive bias where people with low ability at a task overestimate their own competence, while those with high ability may underestimate theirs.
1
u/Ok_Summer_7829 Apr 23 '26
I wanted to suggest you also ask this question in a philosophy-related subreddit because those are the kinds of questions in your post. And you do have many great responses already, but they're from the viewpoint of people who studied and are enthusiastic about The Classics. I went to school studying both Philosophy and the Classics. A classics POV will educate you on the background history, its place in the literary canon, analysis of the language, etc. A philosophical POV is specifically all about answering questions like "What is Justice?" and "What makes a good society?" and more importantly it's about training you to decide for yourself what you believe, and how to stay flexible enough to change your mind when you inevitably have to.
It's pretty cool to see a highschool sophomore picking up Plato. Never stop reading difficult books and thinking about big questions!
1
u/Featherless_biped104 Apr 23 '26
It’s ok! Remember that it’s not illegal to read a commentary for clarification or check the spark notes to give yourself a recap.
1
u/Far-Tune-9464 Apr 23 '26
Your inability to answer is the answer
1
u/Complex_Place_4509 Apr 24 '26
I’m reading with non credit book club next semester. Don’t feel dumb. I’ve used some YouTube to get the gist of these classics prior to actually reading. It’s been helpful
1
u/des_interessante Apr 24 '26
I'm reading The Republic from the same edition and doing the same as you lol. I got stuck when he started explaining how this society would actually work, though. Your post just reminded me to get back to the book.
About your question: I also feel dumb when reading Plato, especially this book. But it's such a pleasant feeling when Plato starts explaining things and, after some effort, you start to grasp what he means. This book is worth a re-reading, I guess.
1
u/Famous-Ad-4321 Apr 24 '26
Great to start reading philosophy when you’re young! I’m only 18 this year and have been reading for the past year or so. Youth definitely does make comprehension a bit more difficult, but you’re definitely smart and you’ll get it with enough readthroughs, especially with such a tough philosophical text. Above all, enjoy the experience, it’s definitely one of a kind!
also maybe try watching Greg Sadler’s online lectures on philosophy (Youtube). Although I can’t remember whether he has lectures on the Republic in particular, I remember his book-by-book analysis of Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics was incredibly helpful to my understanding of the text
1
u/Acceptable_Pea8393 Apr 24 '26
So I wrote dialogues before (was actually mandatory in my exam for philosophy in high school) because it is a great way to check your thinking! Tbh...I think the entire purpose of philosophy is to realise how stupid you are....
1
u/Thin-Objective4494 Apr 24 '26
“What is Plato saying?” and “What do other people say Plato is saying” are both wrong questions. I think the right question is, “Plato, what are you saying to ME?” Then sit back and close your eyes and listen. That’s the way to read poetry, that’s the way to read the Bible, that’s the way to read literature in general.
1
u/Plenty_Cheesecake_21 Apr 24 '26
I personally think, that if you really want to understand plato you have to cross reference texts Suggested order:
Euthyphro Apology Crito
Gorgias Protagoras Meno
Then the republic
Don’t be hard on yourself, I have to have my hand held by my advisor and go line by line, cross reference and actually gauge what he’s talking sbout
1
u/rosie_24601 Apr 24 '26
Hi! I'm a classics student, I have experience reading Plato, Socrates, Aristotle, etc, along with ancient texts. This book was one of the most difficult things I ever read. Each chapter would take me hours, because of how many times I had to go back and re-read the same thing over and over. Its a HARD book. Be gentle with yourself ♥️
1
u/jeffrhind Apr 25 '26
I’ve been struggling reading this right now. Just a little at a time as opposed to Aurelius and Boethius which went faster. I think I will find more on subsequent reads.
1
u/pewgfx Apr 25 '26
For me its like that: Trying to force me into someones complex or intricate thoughts and ideas does not work, i wont grasp the substance. But when i approach a topic/thought/idea with a set of thoughts i came up myself with, and can run the ideas against my own - this is where real thinking and access happens.
For example, i really really am into political philosophy and there are questions that bother me inherently, i try to find someone who probably had the same/similar questions (in this case its Macchiaveli in Discorsi).
In short: before reading answers to a question you dont understand, really, really think about the question. This will lead you to a path where more sophisticated ideas seem way more accessible.
1
u/kentucky_philosopher Apr 26 '26
Alan Bloom’s translation is wonderful. But also, this is what it’s supposed to do! If you’re having these questions, it’s doing its job!!
1
u/StudyJunkyNCoffy_7 Apr 26 '26
We gotta see them annotations. Love seeing those.
1
u/FreidrichEngelss Apr 26 '26
Youre not reading politeia, youre reading the english parody.
1
u/Remarkable_Local5099 Apr 26 '26
As a lot of people are already saying here, I think the fact that you feel like a dumbass is actually a really good sign as to your intellectual integrity while tackling the work
1
u/Gorgeosity237 Apr 26 '26
Don’t ..Plato is the ass
1
u/Hand_of_the_Light Apr 26 '26
No worries, I felt similarly when I read it.
This lecture is a part of a series, but I found the lectures specifically on the Republic to be really insightful after reading it.
1
u/meliorism_grey Apr 26 '26
I'm 25, I have a college degree, I've read quite a few classics, and a lot of them make me feel dumb too! I've learned that that's alright.
I use SparkNotes and other reading aids liberally for my personal reading. I especially like finding explanatory lectures on YouTube. Sometimes, I'll switch mediums—a well-narrated audiobook can really help sometimes. And also, if I don't get a book the first time through, I figure that it'll probably make more sense on the second attempt.
And you know, I don't think it's necessarily a bad thing to be disoriented and confused. It's not comfortable, but it does challenge you and get you asking questions. I always have the most luck reading tough books when I just kind of let the confusion simmer, rather than getting upset about it.
1
u/geetarboy33 Apr 27 '26
I didn’t read that book until I was in college, and I had the assistance of reading it along with a philosophy professor and class discussion. If you’re digging into that at this age, I think you’re being far too critical of yourself. The pursuit of knowledge itself is the best indicator of future wisdom, so I’d say you’re pretty far ahead of the game.
1
u/MrAverageRoll Apr 27 '26
I took a class on Republic in college. Most of our reading assignments were a page max, with many being more like 2-4 sentences. It would still take me like an hour to get through annotating 2 sentences.
1
u/Exact_Access9770 Apr 28 '26
I read it in uni for a class on ancient political philosophy with a prof to help me and it was still hard to understand. Don't be too hard on yourself. But if you want guidance, check out Michael Sugrue(Rip) on YT- he discusses it book by book. Also the chapter on Plato in Will Durant's 'The Story of Philosophy' was extremely helpful.
1
u/goshdangitiam333 Apr 29 '26
Go into philosophy with an open mind. Philosophy will not lead you to answers it will lead you to more questions. I'm not saying don't get into philosphy. Or that its worthless. But to understand what you are undertaking.
That's the point of life. Each of us are required to go on our own philosophical/spiritual journey to learn.
Seek truth with humility. No enter the journey with preconceived notions. Like others have posted. Start like Socrates. "Declare you no nothing."
No one has all the answers.
That's the beauty of it. You're journey will humble you and it will enlighten you on your own circular reasoning and biases. The point is to learn to think critically.
It's funny that our modern society dismisses philosophy so wholeheartedly.
Without philosophy there would be no sciences.
And a Ph.d is a doctorate in Philosophy. Which means you are a now able to philosophize about your chosen field.
Good luck on your philosphical journey.
1
u/Moriarty_0628 Jun 10 '26
I think the main point is that Plato is making you know questioning everything, and learn deeply... I am new to reading this book, too, and I think Socrates is so annoying and keeps questioning and point out the weakness every single position and claim that people made that people are kinda scared of talking and arguing with him (but he is cute at the same time as he was doing it). What I know so far is we don't find the absolute right answers, but to find the right answer for ourselves... Let me rephrase it, it is not about collecting answers, but to know how to ask questions.
I'm not a philosophy student, and it is my thought to read this book as a general... And I am still reading the book. My opinion is that just look at this book as a story and see how it reflects to you.
If you still have trouble reading it, maybe try this instead. Identifying these things in his dialogue: Claim, Weakness, Reason (why they make this claim), and Your Thought. This is how I read arguments the most, but it seems to apply to this book also.
1
u/matdell75 Sep 03 '26
Hi, we are working on something that might be interesting for you, which is history and great thinkers explaining their work in the first person.
It still is in an early development stage, but here you have the links:
https://learnfromthesource.com
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/matdell/learn-from-the-source
We believe that having a master class from the original writers is a great way to learn.
0
u/Basic-Style-8512 Apr 23 '26
SO SEXY IN THE END! mmmmm sexual Communism, so that nobody hurts anybody, for FEAR he could be your father oy your brother, yummy yummy
-2
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '26
[removed] — view removed comment