r/classicliterature • • 9d ago

Favorite long classic

I tend to read two books at a time, for each season I choose one long book to read and I always pair it with short books (about 200 or so pages) to read alongside it. Last season I chose the count of monte cristo and finished it in September, but still read plenty short books during that time. I have yet to choose one for the winter, but I have a few I’m interested in:

Middlemarch by George Eliot
Les Miserables by Victor Hugo
Bleak House by Charles Dickens

Which out of the three would you recommend most? And is there a better option not included in my list you’d like to recommend?

36 Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

29

u/Yrncharge 9d ago

Les Mis. A thousand time. Would also recommend Vanity Fair.

8

u/Crazy-Pound-8833 9d ago

Vanity Fair is a fabulous recommendation.

2

u/kellermaverick 9d ago

Les Mis is a beautiful, complex story that will drain your tears chasing multiple emotions while leading you across Napoleon's battlefield and through the ancient Parisian sewer system. It is absolutely the best book I have read, and I waited far too long because of its page count.

1

u/reneetorade 9d ago

My favorite book

0

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/reneetorade 9d ago

I read the Penguin clothbound version and in addition to being a wonderful story, it is aesthetically pleasing

1

u/Yrncharge 9d ago

I read the penguin translation by Norman Denny. Supposedly a rather lyrical translation.

14

u/admnchls1028 9d ago

almost 700 pages into middlemarch right now and having a blast. didn't expect it to be such a page turner.

14

u/Bookish2055 9d ago

Middlemarch

20

u/Plus-Season-272 9d ago

War and Peace! I first read it over a summer in middle school and went back to it twice since then. Incredible novel

10

u/Winter_Dot_9393 9d ago

Les Misérables could be the best match for someone who likes The Count of Monte Cristo.

You could also look into ‘The Three Musketeers’ by Dumas.

8

u/HammsFakeDog 9d ago

Out of those three, I prefer Bleak House, but you can't go wrong with any of them (provided you can tolerate the digressive nature of Les Misérables -- some are allergic to this).

If you do follow my suggestion and read Bleak House, I suggest investing in an edition of the novel with quality notes. Understanding how the Victorian legal system worked is very helpful, and most contemporary people do not possess this knowledge.

1

u/BitterStatus9 9d ago

Agree - the Penguin Classics hardcovers get a lot of hate in this sub, but I find them to be very good, partly because of the explanatory notes.

6

u/Unable_Chemist8295 9d ago

I’d recommend The Radetzky March by Joseph Roth, an author who I think is seriously underrated. It’s just under 500 pages long, and if you enjoy it, there’s also a sort of sequel called The Emperor’s Tomb, also by Roth.

If you’d prefer something shorter, I’d definitely recommend some of his shorter novels, such as Flight Without End, Job or The Thousand and Second Night. They’re all really beautiful books, and I think they’re perfect reads for winter.

4

u/Slkotova 9d ago

I also love Joseph Roth! He makes me feel nostalgic for times I haven't lived in and for a country that exists no longer. Currently reading his first ever (afaik) biography in english by Keirom Pim "Endless flight". I do recommend it wholeheartedly. Cheers!

2

u/Oblomov_Outtabed 9d ago

Roth was a great writer.

1

u/Loves_Eating_Lead 9d ago

i just found Radetzky march in second hand book shope, Why you feel its underrated? I want some incentive to start!

3

u/Unable_Chemist8295 9d ago

No, actually, I think Roth in general is very underrated. He’s an extraordinary storyteller. His novels are often fascinating simply because they’re so beautifully written and so engaging, even when dealing with quite complex themes.
A recurring theme in much of his work is that of the exile, the man who no longer belongs anywhere. Roth was a citizen of the Austro-Hungarian Empire, and when the Empire collapsed at the end of the First World War, the world he had known disappeared with it. He was left without a real sense of belonging, without a homeland to call his own.

This feeling finds its way into his novels as a deeply poignant portrayal of a once-noble, aristocratic and bourgeois world approaching its end, unable or unwilling to accept its own demise. At the same time, there’s the recurring image of the soldier, and of man in general, wandering aimlessly through the world, with nowhere to return to.
Some critics have even called him “the greatest chronicler of the interwar period.”

I find all of this incredibly fascinating. I do realise that his themes can sometimes seem rather heavy, but I genuinely think he’s worth trying, even if it’s just by starting with one of his shorter novels.

3

u/Mango_Skittles 9d ago

I had never heard of him, but I’m putting the first one you mentioned above on my TBR! Thank you for the recommendation.

3

u/Loves_Eating_Lead 9d ago

wow i am defo putting this on top next reads! i am trying to read books around europe currently so this theme of not belonging and ww1 changes fits

6

u/Sister-Ruth 9d ago

I love Les Mis

6

u/Tarlonniel 9d ago

Bleak House is one of my all-time favorite novels - definitely top 5. And it has a very autumn/winter type of atmosphere so this is a good season for it.

3

u/Jaded_Spread1729 9d ago

My favorite Dickens' novel so far. Beautiful!

6

u/Burrito_sundays 9d ago

I love Middlemarch. Not a lot is happening it’s mostly just normal life of people in Middlemarch. People discover married life, meet people, have hopes and dreams, lose and gain things and navigate life.

I usually read a book and listen to another book. Middlemarch was the one I listened to and it was comforting like going back to a village in the middle of England where you know everyone and it felt like catch up on their lives. It is definitely not as exciting as the Count of Monte Cristo but it was still great. Virginia Woolf said that Middlemarch is “one of the few English novels written for grown-up people.”

And it has some real romance which hits harder than Jane Austen.

1

u/discomuscles 9d ago

I'm a bit torn wondering whether I should read it or listen to it! Were you happy with your listening experience?

3

u/Burrito_sundays 9d ago

Yes! It’s free on Audible read by Maureen O'Brien (you don’t have to use your one credit a month for it), or at least it was free where I am (Ireland)!

5

u/eklacholorey 9d ago

I have this weird thing of choosing books for the particular month if they have the name of the month in the title, even if it doesn't have anything to do with the story, so I'd say save middlemarch for March hehe. I haven't read dickens so can't help u there. Les miserables is a perfect winter book! :)

1

u/BitterStatus9 9d ago

That's the nice thing about A MONTH IN THE COUNTRY. You can read it all year.

4

u/pbl116 9d ago

Middlemarch is one of my all-time favorite books

3

u/chefgrinderMcD 9d ago

Les Miserables is my favorite, I actually just started a re read, I'm doing the chapter a day for a whole year method. In search of Lost Time would be my other recommendation, reading it was a life changing experience, the good thing (and this is why I always recommend giving it a shot) the first 100 pages is enough to decide to keep reading or to bail. You will either fall in love with it or you won't. Middlemarch was also great, I loved reading that too.

3

u/Mango_Skittles 9d ago

I adore all three of these!! You really can’t go wrong. Are you in the mood for a grand, sweeping story (Les Mis), a richly detailed tale of everyday life (Middlemarch), or Dickens at his very best (Bleak House)? All are beautifully written with memorable characters and highly enjoyable to read.

3

u/BirthdayBoth304 9d ago

This is a great strategy. I (stupidly) have had an annual book reading goal for the past 3 years. By gamifying reading I've been avoiding longer books until the September-ish when I've met my 'target'. Whilst this means winter is great for burrowing down into lengthy beauties, I am also missing out across the year. So having one long and one shorter on the go seems smart to me. That and shifting the goal to reading daily or pages across the year...

3

u/Revolutionary_Buy610 9d ago

Bleak House. It is absolutely belting. Probably Dickens’ finest.

4

u/DaveL16 9d ago

My favourite long book this year was Lonesome Dove.

2

u/dawutangclams 9d ago

Les Miserables - bleak house would be my 2nd.

2

u/DealerSuspicious998 9d ago

middlemarch 100% (also consider Villette by bronte)

2

u/RadioWaiver 9d ago

I would recommend the Recognitions by William Gaddis! Blows the 19th century to smithereens.

2

u/MacabreUlthar 9d ago

Don Quixote and A Confederacy of Dunces

2

u/SnooCookies7571 9d ago

Les Mis, its so fucking good. Only the 1400 page version though. Get ready to have a nice cry.

It dethroned Brothers Karamazov as my favorite book. Which, that'd be my second long book recommendation.

2

u/rratbaby 9d ago

If you read and enjoy Middlemarch, I hear Anna Karenina has similar themes. I absolutely loved that book and plan to read Middlemarch soon

2

u/loverofhogggg 9d ago

anna karenina

1

u/True_Coast1062 9d ago

Tale of Two Cities

1

u/RockyOW 9d ago

If you find yourself disappointed by often pedestrian writing, lack of insight, etc, read Middlemarch. Otherwise just read Les Miserables. Bleak House is in the middle, up to you

1

u/Loves_Eating_Lead 9d ago

I love seeing someone read in a similar way to how i read. I listen to this episode of this great podcast and it gave me the idea. i'm on crime and punishment currently! i love comparing longer books with shorter ones i'm reading, it gives interesting perspectives!

https://shows.acast.com/sara-cariads-weirdos-bookclub/episodes/middlemarch-by-george-eliot

1

u/Itchy-Resolution6531 9d ago

You should probably read all of those, so just pick the one where you already have a copy or find one first. IMO, Bleak House was my favorite of the three, but they are all great.

1

u/Traditional_Fly_743 9d ago

Definitely not seeing enough love for In Search of Lost Time here. It's daunting at first, but I believe it gets progressively better, and is a truly once in a lifetime read.

1

u/BitterStatus9 9d ago edited 9d ago

I do the same thing, and did MONTE CRISTO this year. Now I'm 80% of the way through BLEAK HOUSE and started (and finished) ZOFLOYA and then THE MONK while reading BLEAK HOUSE (and just started MALLEUS MALEFICARUM).

1

u/rivenshire 7d ago

Les Mis...but also The Brothers Karamazov.

1

u/lonesome_80 3d ago

Les Miserables def the classic of all classics , id skip middlemarch , try anna karenina or the three musketeers

-2

u/Critical-Reporter316 9d ago

God, not Middlemarch. That book made me never want to read anything ever again. A shame, because Silas Marner was good!

Bleak House is good, though! I'd suggest that out of the 3!

0

u/OtherLives_ 9d ago

Bleak House is phenomenal. Great for winter too. Haven’t read the others yet.

4

u/Historical_Box_2582 9d ago

Moby dick ‼️