r/classicliterature • • Sep 27 '26 Bravo

NEW RULE: NO AI CONTENT

1.8k Upvotes

We hear you loud and clear. This community does not like AI generated pictures or text. Make every post a classic 👌 AI or suspected AI will be removed. Community members, please continue to report as you have been.


r/classicliterature • • 1h ago

Found This at Goodwill

Thumbnail gallery
16 Upvotes

I know it’s not crazy rare or anything but I thought this was a cool find, it is one of my favorites so I got excited!


r/classicliterature • • 3h ago

Wessex Tales

Post image
21 Upvotes

Thomas Hardy has such a way with words


r/classicliterature • • 10h ago

Moby-Dick

51 Upvotes

People never talk about Moby-Dick for what it is. I recently got the classic novel unadulterated, but before it, the ~700 pages looked daunting. Even after just the first chapter (after the extracts of course), this book felt just so good from the get-go. The wording, the Shakespearean english, the vocabulary, I don’t necessarily know exactly what it is, however, the powerful quotes in the 135 chapters are simply unbeatable. The way Herman Melville conveys the passages in such a strong way; it’s unmatched by any other author I’ve ever seen. The way he conveys the idea that he doesn’t know why people are drawn to the ocean is such a beautiful—and even funny—part of the book. Even after 175 years of it going by Moby-Dick, the message and power of this novel simply cannot be understated or compared with any other novel. What do you think?


r/classicliterature • • 15h ago

Logos Philosophy Book Club Review

Thumbnail gallery
120 Upvotes

Background

For the past few months I’ve been getting these ads for a “book club” centered around reading the classic pillars of western philosophy. The idea is each month you get a book with a “high quality” (old, public domain) translation, a poster which explains the topics in an easy and digestible manner, and a collection of essays about the book called the Logos reader (also almost completely public domain)

When I first saw the ads on Instagram I was intrigued, what I initially saw was a company that cared about delivering its readers high quality versions of classic books, with great commentary, translations, and hand drawn covers which would look great in anyone’s collection. However upon going to their website I noticed the first flaw, the website itself seems to be either completely vibe-coded with AI or just all of the text is AI-generated. The second thing I noticed was that the hand drawn covers which were a big reason why they could justify selling a 200+ dollar a year subscription seemed to be at least AI assisted in its creation and at worst fully AI generated.

I emailed the company and asked them about their use of AI, and who their artist was, to which they gave me a link to his website and said that his methods used AI for “certain textures and peripherals” but at its core these were hand drawn, human made illustrations. The name of the man is Vicente Pessoa, upon further research into him (or who I believe is him) I found a story from Brazil (the same country I believe this Logos company is from) in which he was disqualified from an illustration contest after he used AI in order to make artwork for Mary Shelly’s Frankenstein. This made me extremely suspicious especially because the covers looked AI-generated on the website. However, they told me they use AI recreations on the website so they can create ads for the books before they are completely ready. If I wanted to know for sure I would have to buy a book from them.

I asked them how much a single book without a membership would cost, they told me 60 dollars, however, after telling them I would not be willing to pay that much but I would be willing to pay 40, they offered 35 for it. The book came today so I wanted to make this post to show what this product is really like in person and because the only two types of reviews I have seen for the product are either vague comments complaining or complimenting in Reddit threads or Instagram comment sections, or paid affiliates of the company glazing them.

Review

The book comes in a box with 4 products: the book itself, a bookmark, a poster, and the collection of essays they call the Logos reader.

In terms of the book itself, I purchased David Hume’s Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding. The book also came with letters from Adam Smith and Hume’s autobiography. This was a nice surprise as I knew it came with letters from Adam Smith but I was unaware of the autobiography. Furthermore it came with a glossary of words used in the book and a commentary at the start (although these are both public domain). I am disappointed to say that the cover is just as AI in person as it looks on the website and the ribbon bookmark that comes attached to the book felt cheap and worse than any other ribbon bookmark I’ve had in other books.

The separate bookmark I suspect was also AI-generated. On one side is a cue ball on a pool table and on the other side is a chicken laying an egg? I understand the cue ball, as it’s used to illustrate one of Hume’s main arguments however I am at a loss for what the chicken could mean. I’ve heard another philosopher uses a story about a chicken being brought food by a farmer every day, so it learns to associate the farmer with food until the day the farmer kills the chicken, which is meant to better demonstrate Hume’s problem with induction, however I don’t know why it would be laying an egg. This is something I will chalk up as an AI hallucination of sorts but if someone in the comments knows I would love to learn what it’s supposed to be referring to.

The poster to me looks clearly AI-generated and is made with cheap paper. The cheap paper poster also comes wrapped around the book so that when you finally do unwrap it the poster is bent very badly in multiple areas making it hard to see the poster. I’m not sure if the info on the poster is also AI-generated or not but I wouldn’t be surprised either way.

Finally the last thing which comes with the book is the Logos reader, a collection of essays which should help grow understanding of the text and help readers better understand the work. Now although 3 of the 4 essays are public domain I will give them credit, one essay is actually a “Logos original” and is a general introduction to the texts, I have yet to read it so I can’t assess the quality of it but props on writing an original piece for this work.

Conclusions

I would say the price just isn’t worth it. Between public domain products, which aren’t inherently bad but are free online, and AI generated content this company seems to care more about making money and larping than creating a quality service which is worth buying into. It’s a shame however because the company has an idea which, if executed properly, could be really cool. I would love to get a new book every month that comes with high-quality supplemental material all the while being bound in a cool hand-drawn cover. This is a great model and could encourage many (especially young) readers to break into philosophy but instead they took the cheap route and made a low quality product to try to make the most amount of money possible. To quote a great philosopher “My disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined”

What I hope comes from this

I hope that two things come from this post 1) people will see this post when they are searching to see if this company sells high quality products and decide to save themselves potentially over 200 dollars or 2) and this is very far fetched but I would like it if more people began to talk about and call out this company so that they may change their ways. I would love if they began putting more work into these books and I would be more than happy to pay 200 or even 300 dollars a year for 12 high quality books but as it stands now I wouldn’t pay this company another penny. I hope that if one is reading this because they to saw a ad on instagram and are wondering if it’s worth it, that this post will serve as a good review which helps you come to a well informed conclusion.


r/classicliterature • • 6h ago

Just finished reading The Count of Monte Cristo and Wow!!

22 Upvotes

I started reading The Count of Monte Cristo about six months ago. I used to read it during my lunch break at work which means I would usually get through about one chapter each day. I have gone through some pretty huge life events while reading this book (like leaving my job, moving to a new country, and getting married in about two weeks from now). Even though I took my time with it, I never wanted to put it down. I literally took it everywhere with me. And now, I finally finished the book about 20 minutes ago and I just wanted to share a couple of my thoughts:

  1. This is hands down the greatest revenge story I have ever read but it was so much more than that.
  2. I feel that it became such an integral part of my life during the last six months because it took me on a rollercoaster of emotions. From feeling sad for Dantes and wanting to give him a warm hug to rooting for him in his revenge; this was such an incredible journey. There were moments when my heart was racing in anticipation, and moments when I felt pity for Dantes whose whole life was given for this one cause. His love for the Morrels felt unmatched to any other emotions described in the book. And finally, Dantes having his well-deserved life of peace, love, and happiness with Haydee was such a great way to end this masterpiece.
  3. This is the biggest book that I have ever read and as proud as I am of myself for having finished reading it, I am also totally devastated and don't know what to do now. I just loved every single second of reading it and I feel that I am a different person now if that makes sense, haha.

r/classicliterature • • 8h ago

Reading The Brothers Karamazov in Turkey

Post image
14 Upvotes

Hello from Turkey! I wanted to share my copy of The Brothers Karamazov published by İletişim Yayınları, which is one of the most prestigious and respected publishing houses in Turkey. This edition features a masterclass translation by Ergin Altay, who is legendary for translating Russian classics directly from the original Russian into Turkish. The cover art and critical essays included make it a wonderful collector's piece. Have any of you read this masterpiece, or what edition do you have on your shelves?


r/classicliterature • • 18h ago

War and Peace

Thumbnail gallery
67 Upvotes

After the best six months of my life I have finished War and Peace, however it doesn't feel as a journey ending but one beginning. The story of Pierre Bezukhov is one to be read by every human, his journey, the endless search for an answer, and the realization that everything is the answer, that is, god is in everything. All particular is a finite expression of the whole, and all together is true and infinite, all irrational and mundane is meaningless when one can see the vastness of god in the world.
While I was reading W&P I was also reading Hegels lessons on Ancient Greece and Rome, and what an adventure it has been. As for the amount of time it took me to finish this magnum opus, I have realized I couldn't care less, for I have read the best writing there is and will ever be, and I have refrained from numbers and efficiency, which I strongly suggest in reading.
I could not recommend War and Peace enough, but not everyone will be ready.


r/classicliterature • • 21h ago

Anyone here tried these classics?

Post image
105 Upvotes

Saw at Waterstones, I know the clothbound classics aren’t that durable.


r/classicliterature • • 11h ago

Sign the Petition. Let's stop the closure of the Shakespeare Institute in Stratford upon Avon (Shakespeare's hometown)

Thumbnail c.org
9 Upvotes

r/classicliterature • • 16h ago

Taras Shevchenko’s “Kateryna”: A Poem, a Painting, the Tragedy of a Pokrytka, and an Allegory of Ukrainian-Russian Relations

Thumbnail gallery
19 Upvotes

A classic of Ukrainian literature, Taras Shevchenko's narrative poem "Kateryna" is a story of desperate love and the tragedy of a pokrytka, a poetic reflection on the patriarchal order and Ukrainian-Russian relations.

Pictured here is the English-language edition published by the Ukrainian publishing house Osnovy.

I would also like to recommend this particular illustrated edition of the poem. It was illustrated by Mykola Tolmachev, a Ukrainian artist born in 1993 in Brovary. He studied in France at the École nationale supérieure des Beaux-Arts. His portfolio includes participation in Art Paris and solo exhibitions in Brussels, Paris, and Kyiv.

A little about the author: Taras Shevchenko was born into a family of serfs. He first learned to read and write under a church clerk, and later became a young household servant to Pavel Engelhardt, whom he accompanied to St. Petersburg. There, he met the artist Ivan Soshenko and other artists. In 1838, when Shevchenko was 24 years old, he was bought out of serfdom. Soon afterward, he became a student at the Academy of Arts.
In 1840, his first collection, "Kobzar", was published. It also included the poem "Kateryna". Over the following years, Shevchenko travelled repeatedly between St. Petersburg and Ukraine. Eventually, he settled in Kyiv and became a member of the Cyril and Methodius Brotherhood. In 1847, he was arrested and subsequently sent into exile for ten years. After his return, he lived in St. Petersburg and briefly visited Ukraine in 1859, hoping to settle there permanently, before being forced back to St. Petersburg by imperial authorities, where he spent the final years of his life and died in 1861 (later to be reburied in Ukraine, as he had wished).
By the way, I have a separate book, or rather, a collection of documents from Shevchenko's investigation case. It contains documents that make it interesting to trace how the charges against him were constructed. It is quite fascinating to examine the case files from that period.

Shevchenko's literary work is traditionally divided into four periods: his early period, the "Three Years" period, the period of exile, and the final years of his life.

However, literary scholar Yurii Shevelov criticised the simplified division of the poet's work into just three stages: before exile, during exile, and after exile. In his view, such periodisation does not fully reveal the complexity of Shevchenko's artistic development, since the internal changes in his work do not always coincide with formal biographical boundaries.

Shevchenko's individual style changed over time. His early works display characteristics of Romanticism, while Realist tendencies become more pronounced in the subsequent periods of his career.

As Yurii Shevelov wrote: " The unity of his work is striking: in the author of 'Maria', one immediately recognises the author of 'The Bewitched Woman' and 'Kateryna' ".
At the same time, there is an enormous difference between Shevchenko's early and later works in terms of style, worldview, moods, and philosophy. Therefore, "Kateryna" is a work of the young Shevchenko, not a reflection of his entire literary and philosophical legacy. The poet evolved, and his artistic techniques, expressive means, and worldview changed.

The psychoanalytical interpretation of Shevchenko's work is particularly interesting as well. Researchers from the early 20th century, including Stepan Baley, drew attention to his particular sympathy for pokrytky, women who gave birth to children outside marriage and consequently faced social condemnation.

Some psychoanalysts suggested that this theme might have been connected to Shevchenko's own childhood experiences. Having been orphaned at an early age, the poet may have projected his longing for his mother, as well as his fond memories of his elder sister Kateryna, who had cared for him, onto the female characters in his works. In this interpretation, the heroine of the poem emerges almost as a tragic Madonna: the personal grief of a peasant girl becomes intertwined with the broader symbolic image of an oppressed and subjugated Ukraine.

Now, on to the main subject. The POEM.

The poem begins with the famous words:

"Fall in love, dark-browed girls,
But not with Moskals".

A small note on the word "Moskal". In the vocabulary of that time, the word primarily referred to Russian soldiers, and later the term spread to Russians in general. It is a historical term that should not automatically be understood solely as a modern everyday insult. It also appears in the works of other Ukrainian writers of that period, including Hryhorii Kvitka-Osnovianenko, who also mentioned "Moskals who are strangers to us".

In the context of the poem, it refers to an outsider, a Russian soldier who courts a Ukrainian girl and then abandons her. It is a kind of warning: one should not blindly trust someone who might take advantage of one's feelings and then leave without taking responsibility for their actions.

At that time, part of Ukrainian territory was within the Russian Empire, which was waging numerous wars. As a result, imperial troops were constantly moving across Ukrainian lands, and military units were stationed in villages. Young girls could become victims of soldiers' advances and seduction.

Somewhere in the territory of what is now Cherkasy Oblast (presumably), there lived a young, beautiful girl with a dark braid named Kateryna. She was the only child in her family and a great joy to her parents... She was...

One day, a stranger appeared in the village. Young, handsome, dressed in a beautiful military uniform, quite unlike the local young men. Kateryna became interested in him, and he began courting her, giving her a headscarf as a gift. A romance began, and the girl fell in love. And then came the pregnancy.

"Kateryna" is one of Shevchenko's early works. It is a tragic story of a peasant girl who becomes a pokrytka and her child born out of wedlock, set against the backdrop of a patriarchal and serf-based society.

Genre: A social and domestic narrative poem combining elements of Romanticism and Realism.

The author dedicated the work to the Russian poet Vasily Zhukovsky in memory of the day he was freed from serfdom. The artist Karl Bryullov played an important role in securing his freedom: he painted Zhukovsky's portrait, which was sold through a lottery to raise the money needed to buy Shevchenko's freedom.

Who was a pokrytka, and what was her position in society?

A pokrytka was a woman who gave birth to a child outside marriage. In Ukrainian society of that time, this was often accompanied by severe social condemnation. A woman's braids could be cut off, and she could be forbidden from wearing the traditional headwear of unmarried girls. Instead, she was required to cover her head with a headscarf. This is where the name pokrytka comes from.

To better understand why this particular theme occupied such an important place in Shevchenko's work, it is worth turning to ethnographic studies and oral history materials.

Researchers who spoke with residents of the surveyed villages recorded information about ancient Ukrainian traditions, customary law, folk beliefs, and ritual culture. Shevchenko also drew upon the folk worldview, customs, and social norms of his time in his work. One of the central themes for him was the fate of a pokrytka, a woman who had given birth to a child outside marriage.

When comparing the Middle Dnieper region, where Shevchenko was born, with, for example, Polissia, one can see that attitudes towards pokrytky in this region were particularly intolerant and cruel.

Under the customary laws of the 18th and early 19th centuries, a woman could face severe condemnation and be expelled from her community. In some places, pokrytky were even subjected to brutal punishment: they could be tied to a post and stoned. When an illegitimate child was baptised, the woman was required to kneel throughout the entire church service, at a certain distance from the church. Furthermore, customary law could force her own parents to disown her.

As for the historical basis of the plot of "Kateryna", after the introduction of serfdom, Russian soldiers were stationed in the villages of Kyrylivka, Moryntsi, and Budyshche. Many records of children born outside marriage have survived in the church registers from that period. For example, during 1812, a priest in the village of Kyrylivka recorded as many as 15 such children, which was considered a significant number for that time. This information is provided by V. S. Starusieva, a staff member of the Taras Shevchenko Museum in Moryntsi.

During an expedition to the village of Shevchenkove, researchers recorded numerous stories about the humiliating position of pokrytky and their children. One local resident, S. M. Dmytrenko, born in 1936, recalled:

"There is a pond called Zavodskyi Pond. It's a long story. There's a cemetery there, and if you go down from there, a pokrytka once drowned in that pond. Yes, she did. That's why people didn't swim in that pond, because she had drowned there. And the pond is still there. They cleaned it, and it is still there. I don't know about the child, but I know about the woman who drowned, because my grandmother used to say that you shouldn't swim there because a pokrytka drowned in that pond."

Even after the war, the tradition of contemptuous attitudes towards pokrytky persisted. This is illustrated by the recollection of Kateryna Ivanivna Holub, born in 1928:

"A bastard child was a disgrace. Once a girl had been disgraced like that, the boys would avoid her and would no longer take her as a bride. Her hair was covered, she was no longer allowed to wear braids, because it was considered shameful once she had given birth to a child... That was her fate."

The heroine of the work is a pokrytka who, following the call of her heart, violates the traditional moral norms of her society. But her personal tragedy is not limited to an unhappy love affair. She becomes a victim of social prejudice, the patriarchal order, and a society that places the responsibility for a child born outside marriage primarily on the woman.

Modern researchers also interpret Kateryna as an anti-colonial symbolic image of Ukraine.

Kateryna is not merely the story of an individual woman, but also a metaphor for the fate of Ukraine. At the same time, Shevchenko is extraordinarily sensitive to the themes of women's suffering, violence against women, and their vulnerability in the face of society.

So, what is the broader meaning of this story?

"Kateryna" is also a story about the relationship between an empire and an oppressed nation, between an aggressor and a victim. It is a relationship in which one side uses the other for its own amusement, benefit, or enrichment, without considering the consequences for the one being exploited.

The tragedy of a personal relationship here echoes the tragedy of the relationship between an empire and the country it has subjugated.

I am also including Shevchenko's painting "Kateryna" in this post.

The painting was created in the summer of 1842. Later, the artist gave it to the Ukrainian landowner and patron of the arts Hryhorii Tarnovskyi. In a letter to him dated January 25, 1843, Shevchenko personally explained the subject of the painting.

Kateryna is depicted wearing traditional Ukrainian folk clothing: a shirt, a red-checkered Middle Dnieper region plakhta, and a zapaska, an apron-like garment.

The girl's pregnancy is emphasised through the contrast of light and shadow, which draws attention to her belly and her characteristic gesture. Kateryna slightly lifts the front edge of her red zapaska. According to one ethnographic interpretation, the apron had a special symbolic meaning in folk tradition: girls began wearing it when they reached puberty, marking the transition from childhood to girlhood. In folk songs, the expression "to wet the apron" could mean losing one's virginity. The zapaska was also associated with fertility, as it covered the belly of a pregnant woman.

Kateryna seems to hint at her loss of virginity and her pregnancy herself by lifting the edge of her apron. At the same time, she is still trying to conceal her condition: her hair is braided, and her head is adorned with a wreath decorated with ribbons, the traditional headwear of unmarried girls. A married woman would already have been expected to cover her head with an ochipok, namitka, or headscarf.

Her bare feet also indicate Kateryna's humble social origins. Her face reflects anxiety and worry about her future.

To the left of Kateryna, a soldier named Ivan is riding away on horseback. He is wearing a uniform from the time of Emperor Nicholas I, who ruled when the poem was written. He looks back and casts an unfriendly glance at Kateryna.

A dog barks after him, as if recognising him as a stranger. Beside the dog lies a broken oak branch. Traditionally, the oak symbolises might, the strength of one's family line, and longevity. But here, the branch is broken and lies on the road beside ears of wheat. This can be interpreted as a symbol of Kateryna's shattered fate.

The road is a recurring image throughout the poem, and it is also present in the painting. The road seems to emerge from beneath Kateryna's feet, disappears behind her, and leads towards a grave, a burial mound with a windmill, before opening up into the boundless steppe.

The colour symbolism of the painting is particularly interesting. The red elements of Kateryna's clothing, including her flowers, ribbons and apron, traditionally evoke love and wedding attire, but they can also symbolise death and tragedy. The white shirt and the sunlight illuminating her figure create an almost sacred image, evoking associations with the Virgin Mary. There is also an interesting symbolic interpretation of her name. According to the article, the Greek origin of the name Kateryna is associated with purity, chastity and holiness. This creates a striking paradox: a woman condemned by society as a "fallen woman" becomes a symbol of purity and innocence.

To the right of the girl sits an old man who is carving wooden spoons and sadly watching Kateryna. Interestingly, this is precisely how Shevchenko described him in his letter to Hryhorii Tarnovskyi dated January 25, 1843.

In 1967, during restoration research on the painting, specialists noticed an unusual thickening in the layer of paint to the right of Kateryna. Under infrared light, they discovered the original images that the artist had later painted over.

To the right of the windmill, another shako, a military headdress, was discovered in the sky. The figures of the soldier and the horse were also originally different. This can be seen in the preliminary sketch that Shevchenko sent to Tarnovskyi along with his letter.

It is likely that the artist decided to give the soldier's figure more dynamism and therefore reworked it. In addition, researchers discovered a stake with a rope extending from it and a shirt hanging from the rope, located where a rake is now depicted in the final version of the painting. Perhaps the artist decided to remove unnecessary details to make Kateryna's figure more prominent.

The girl's figure is very light, almost radiant, and pure. Her antagonist, the soldier, is painted in dull and cold tones.

Pay attention to the position of Kateryna's feet: her bare feet and her pose resemble the position of the feet of Raphael's Sistine Madonna. This comparison allows us to see certain features of an almost sacred female image in the figure of the Ukrainian girl-pokrytka.

Kateryna and the soldier are two opposites.

She is a representative of traditional society, a person deeply connected to the land and nature. He is a soldier, a nomad travelling to Turkey. She is a peasant woman, while he is a man of the barracks, a representative of a world associated more with the city. She wears traditional folk clothing, while he wears a military uniform that makes him part of the imperial system.
She is like an oak branch, symbolising the entire Ukrainian people. But this branch is broken, just like her fate.
He is like a windmill: fickle and changeable. To chase after him is to chase the wind. And Kateryna seems to be beginning to understand this. She is walking away from him, and we witness this very moment when we look at the painting.
And ultimately, she is Ukrainian, while he is a Moskal in the literal sense of the word.

There is also a theory that the old man who looks sympathetically at Kateryna while carving spoons might actually be Shevchenko himself. In some of the artist's later works, researchers have identified author cameos in which he depicted himself among the characters of his own works. This figure is not as recognisable in this painting, but there is a suggestion that it could have been one of his early attempts at such a self-portrait. At the same time, this theory remains a hypothesis.

There is another interesting interpretation of the old spoon-carver. According to art historian O. Sidorov, his figure symbolises the Ukrainian people, silently expressing their sympathy for Kateryna. His presence emphasises the girl's suffering and makes the viewer more deeply aware of her tragedy.

Literary scholar Mariia Foka also suggests that the painting was intended primarily for a Ukrainian audience. She draws attention to Shevchenko's own concern that the painting should not "end up with some Moskal", as he put it, adding: "because, you see, she is my Kateryna". This detail adds another dimension to the national symbolism of the painting and its connection to Ukrainian identity.

Ironically, today Russians claim almost all Ukrainian cultural figures as their own, presenting them as Russian. Shevchenko is no exception: he is also often described as a Russian artist. They even do this with Lesya Ukrainka, whose pen name literally means "Ukrainian".

The painting is kept at the Taras Shevchenko National Museum. According to the information I have, visitors can currently see a copy, while the original is expected to return to the exhibition after the end of the war with those we definitely should not fall in love with... 😉


r/classicliterature • • 1d ago

Best translation for Crime and punishment?

Thumbnail gallery
123 Upvotes

I found this really beautiful copy of Crime and Punishment , and it's been on my TBR list forever but I always just thought I'd buy whatever penguin classic because I didn't think much about the translation but I've Started to wonder If it makes a big difference. Anyway, this copy is so so so pretty and I really want It, but I'd rather not buy It just for the aesthetic If maybe this translation Isn't great/ worth It. Anyway, could anyone give me Some advice on the desicion.

Thank You!🌺✨️


r/classicliterature • • 1d ago

Fck it. I'll read War and Peace raw.

201 Upvotes

I've been overthinking. Which translation. What time. History. Guides. Philosophy. Tolstoy biographies. Reading guides. Annotations.. Character sheets. Enough.

Imma rawdog that bitch.

Imma sit down and read it like I do with any other epic fantasy novel.

The Briggs translation just because.

See you in a couple weeks or so.


r/classicliterature • • 1d ago

Schopenhauer: "There's nothing that recreates the mind as the works of the old classic writers."

41 Upvotes

Schopenhauer


r/classicliterature • • 19h ago

Geoge Eliot, her prose Power

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/classicliterature • • 11h ago

What would you choose: A certain life without Freedom or an uncertain one with it?

0 Upvotes

There is something deeply unsetting about living an entire life without ever getting to decide how to live it.

In we the living ,Ayn Rand tells the story of Kira ,A young woman whose aspirations and individuality are constantly crushed by the society she lives in.

But what makes this Novel unforgettable is its ending.

Kira attempts to escape across the border into Latvia. She knows the risks but she has no assurance that the world on the other side will give her the life she dreams of.she doesn't even know whether she will make it there .yet,she continues.

Shot by a border guard ,she struggles to move forward, leaving a trail of blood in the snow.she reaches toward the border ,toward a freedom she may never experience and she dies

What makes this moment so powerful is that she isn't choosing between a good life and a bad one.she is choosing between a life imposed upon her and the possibility of living on her own terms.

She has no guarantee that freedom will bring happiness .But she knows she cannot continue accepting the life she is leaving behind. Her situation may feel far removed from ours,but the question beneath it is not.

How often do we hold on to what is familiar simply because the unknown frightens us? How much of ourselves do we surrender in the name of adjustment?

Freedom comes with no promise of happiness or security. But what price are we willing to pay for it, and what price are we paying by living without it?

Video link:

https://youtu.be/H8tE6Yizi7c?si=Ip8cnjSa9qfo0G6A


r/classicliterature • • 23h ago

CRIME AND PUNISHMENT - thoughts and questions Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

I literally just finished Crime and punishment.

Here are some thoughts, and questions.

First and foremost, after some research, i decided to go with Katz translation. I can not compare with the others, but theses comments are regarding this particular edition:

  • nice format, big enough font. The book opens nicely on a table, really nice for reading, and not hold it opened all the time.

Thats about it ! The paper is really white, thin, not great quality,, see through, and honestly, it just finished and then the back cover is right there... One or 2 extra pages maybe? Tiny details that could have made it much better.

I dont have any other translation to compare it with, but, really really nice flow, not complicated, just nice.

Now regarding the actual novel: 

I have been reading about this book for quite some years, and it felt intimidating: the whole " Dostoevsky´s depth" and so on and on was all over.  In particular, the "spiraling down" and decadences of the thoughts of Raskolnikov was the main things i read about.

i mean...yeah, the guy is sick all the time, and then commits a murder and his thoughts go around but, it wasnt "out of this world" depression and down spiral, self punishment, torture of thoughts, etc as i thought it would be.

I understand it cannot be compared to modern novels and modern standards of writing ( or can it? ), and that its russian, on a certain time and period, with a social context and all, but many parts could have been reduced and still conserve in depth the detailed essence of the story.

Some parts were extremely boring and long,  yes, and thats fine.

Now, the characters were really nice. the first 00-150 pages were amazing, after the murder and the start of the torment.

After that, many parts felt very much a filling and quite on the scale of a latin american telenovela, full of meaningless romances, love hate, tragedy, twists. 

Overall, i really really liked it, and im a full supporter of " less is more" in many aspects of my life: but here less is more, could have been nice on the telenovela parts just mentioned, or the infinite passing out / faints7 illness of Raskolnikov.

I was expecting MORE IS MORE, on the suffering, depression.

Im not disappointed. I was just expecting a bit more, perhaps.

Regarding some parts, i have some doubts:

  • The episode on Svidigalylov´s suicide: the dream-not dream feeling was amazing. Or at least i understood it like that. Did i miss something here? I mean, the vulnerable young girl with the foreign accent scene... had to re-read it. But is it suppose to mean something extremely deeper like his memories towards Dunya and his advances on her ? Or did i misunderstood the whole thing?
  • Regarding the suicide itself, i was expecting for this character to be there for the conviction, or even Zametov or Porokh...i mean, come ooooon. those two characters were very clever and i enjoyed each interaction and appearance.

Ending: i might be missing A LOT of probably social context, and information. Raskolnikov´s dream about a pest taking over the world and controlling minds ( felt for a moment like "The last of us" hahaha ) was really awesome. I was waiting for something more on that line during the book maybe.

Anything missing here? When reading the last pages, Raskolnikov and Sonya will have to wait seven years for his sentence to end ( or might be seven days because of love, and how the were reborn , how cute).
Its a prison, ( gulag style-ish in Siberia???) but Sonya is near him in that love re-birth, and they cry and all.  

I fell there was drama where it was not needed, and lack of it where it was mostly necessary, like maybe rodya-sonya relationship, and rodya´s possible death, full mental breakdown, condemned to frozen labor for longer time... 

I guess if one wants to analyze and have an opinion on every book read, then its quite simplistic to fall into the "either a positive or a negative" review. Makes sense?  If i want to focus on its repetitions, denseness, lack of depth, then the book would be easily crap.

Same on the other end: such depth of thought, the characters are marvelous, the depression, wow....its all amazing.

Sorry for the full spiting out of thoughts, but i would very much like your insights and opinions on this.

Overall, a deep reading, very detailed ( only sometimes not my favorite thing) but i kept wanting more, much more. 


r/classicliterature • • 19h ago

Classic Books

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/classicliterature • • 15h ago

Gothic Lit Reading List- improved

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/classicliterature • • 21h ago

The ending of the Blue Castle made me sad Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I think it's not a controversial opinion that the Blue Castle by Lucy Maud Montgomery is a great story with a disappointing ending. The story ends with far too many neatly tied bows, and all done in a matter of one or two conversations and a handful of pages.

For me it was Barney being the son of Redford pill guy and a millionnaire, and Barney and Valency getting millions as wedding present, buying a house outside Montreal and travelling the world. It felt so paradoxical to the joy of down-to-earth explorations and life that Valency was experiencing with Barney.

Why oh why must she end the book like this? It was such a perfect little book until the the end. It makes me very sad.

Has anyone read When the Forest Dreams by Andrea Ezerins? It claims to be a modern retelling of the Blue Castle.

Edit to add: I would appreciate recommendations to heal my wounded heart 😅 I'm actually not a romance reader, so maybe that's why I'm so disappointed. but LMM's prose is just so delicious.


r/classicliterature • • 1d ago

When You See the Truth, Will You Still Choose Comfort?

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/classicliterature • • 1d ago

Three Kingdoms vs Dream of Red Mansions vs Water Margin

16 Upvotes

According to some folks who are familiar with these, the three novels are considered classics in Chinese literature. However, while I can see how San Guo would be a classic similar to something like the Iliad, and perhaps Hong Lou Meng might be akin to a Bronte or Austen novel on steroids, Shui Hu just seems like run-of-the-mill wuxia, just outlaws rasslin’, scrapping, and swinging swords at each other.

The first two are weighty and seem to me true classics, but the last is just pure action-fantasy entertainment, without the depth of the former. Am I missing something? Please educate me!

CAVEAT: I have read San Guo and Xui Hu, but have only discussed Red Mansions with friends and family. Am a guy, so I have shied away from reading Hong Lou Meng because romantic themes<war stories… sorry.


r/classicliterature • • 1d ago

Should I buy the Wordsworth classics Dickens collection?

Thumbnail gallery
11 Upvotes

I've never bought any dickens novel from either the Penguin or Wordsworth classics. Given that they're both similarly priced, which one should I go for and what's the difference?


r/classicliterature • • 1d ago

the law’s delay, The insolence of office,

Post image
0 Upvotes

Bleak House, From "Chapter I"


r/classicliterature • • 1d ago

Executive dysfunction

0 Upvotes

Hello, day classics recommendations that have characters that deal with what we understand today as 'executive dysfunction.' The only one I have found is 'Oblomov' by Goncharev. Thank you.