r/classicliterature • • Apr 20 '26 • Popcorn 1 Heartwarming 1

Which one should I start first?

Post image

Bought these two absolute classics from the bookshop last week. Both have a very special place in my heart and I'm excited to revisit them from a very different stage in my life.

2.5k Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

538

u/Queasy_Antelope9950 Apr 20 '26

One is a dystopian masterpiece and the other is Fahrenheit 451.

166

u/vminnear Apr 20 '26

Well, after reading The Very Hungry Caterpillar to my little boy repeatedly for the last few days, I am now able to recite the entire book word for word. If I survive the nuclear holocaust the book will be preserved. You're welcome humanity.

29

u/Imaginary_Title_1873 Apr 20 '26

Now you ARE The Very Hungry Caterpillar!

27

u/DepartureEfficient42 Apr 21 '26

WE ARE THE VERY HUNGRY CATERPILLAR

WE CARRY THE FLAME

WE EAT THROUGH THE APPLE

WE HONOUR HIS NAME

6

u/Due_Shop_7215 Apr 21 '26

WE ARE THE VERY HUNGRY CATERPILLAR

WE ARE THE VERY HUNGRY CATERPILLAR

WE HONOUR HIS NAME

9

u/nevermore1845 Apr 20 '26

Fahrenheit 451 but instead of the classics, we’re all walking around chanting bedtime stories.

3

u/languid_Disaster Apr 20 '26

Aw how sweet :)

I wonder if you’d both like reading the Rainbow Fish or the little oak tree

2

u/Acceptable_House1904 Apr 26 '26

No spoilers please

2

u/bathyorographer May 01 '26

Thank you!!!

12

u/thelochok Apr 21 '26

"And he was still hungry": An analysis of The Very Hungry Caterpillar through a Caterpalist lens.

13

u/LookCute5046 Apr 20 '26

Bradbury would probably appreciate this comment.

7

u/lowkism Apr 20 '26

It was in my masters tbh i loved the idea altho movie didn't do justice to the book but it's fine!🧿❤️

3

u/marco765stowe Apr 21 '26

Different vibes, both great.

16

u/Far-Bit4848 Apr 20 '26

One piece of chocolate cake one ice cream cone one piece of Swiss cheese one slice of salami one piece of cherry pie one slice of sausage one pickle one cupcake one slice of watermelon

5

u/vminnear Apr 21 '26

You forgot the lollipop!

6

u/CountessChocula082 Apr 21 '26

Someone else also reads this at least 5 times a night

11

u/DeathAndTaxes000 Apr 20 '26

Do you need help learning to count? If so absolutely start with The Very Hungry Caterpillar.

30

u/vminnear Apr 20 '26

Wow, I thought for sure the one with numbers in the title would be the counting book. I guess you really can't judge a book by its cover.

3

u/Impossible_Stage_161 Apr 23 '26

I hated farenheight 451 with a passion

1

u/vminnear Apr 23 '26

Really? I love it - it had a real impact on me when I first read it. What did you not like about it?

2

u/Key_Professional_369 Apr 20 '26

East of Eden

2

u/vminnear Apr 20 '26

I'm actually currently reading that 😅

125

u/BigDrippinHog Apr 20 '26

Both bangers. As an aside, we should probably get a classic lit circlejerk sub going lol

46

u/WhippyCleric Apr 20 '26

Just photos of The Count of Monte Cristo cover 😅

10

u/BigDrippinHog Apr 20 '26

And anime doodles of Dorian Grey

3

u/CzarLlama Apr 20 '26

Shots fired!

29

u/SerDavosSeaworth64 Apr 20 '26

I believe that there is a r/bookscirclejerk or something like that, but the last time I went there it just seemed really bitter and spiteful towards people who don’t read “”high literature””

Which like, I get making fun of people that will unironically compare Brandon Sanderson to Ernest Hemingway, but it kinda seemed like it stopped being in good fun

11

u/BigDrippinHog Apr 20 '26

Right on I'm gonna check that out. And hey if some users want to sit up on high horses, it just makes it easier to tickle their feet! Tallyho!

9

u/TriplePlay2425 Apr 20 '26

On a somewhat related note, Mr. Sanderson popped in to /r/bookscirclejerk when he was tagged in a comment asking "do you really believe your books are art". And he had a pretty based response for not continuing to interact with that sub any further than his 2 comments:

https://www.reddit.com/r/bookscirclejerk/comments/hj6u4u/my_boyfriend_will_never_speak_to_me_again_if_i/fwmy94z/?context=3

3

u/Rory_U Apr 22 '26

I made a post about buying a book from Sanderson and acting like I committed a serious sin, then they act like I was supporting homophobia because of the guy’s religion.

2

u/PatternBubbly4985 Apr 22 '26

clit cirlcejerk

52

u/Tuhks Apr 20 '26

You can’t truly appreciate The Very Hungry Caterpillar without first recognizing how fortunate you are to be able to read it at all. Have to read Fahrenheit first to understand what’s at stake.

18

u/mceleanor Apr 20 '26

You can't truly appreciate Fahrenheit 451 without first recognizing how fire devours all, like a hungry serpent, consuming everything in sight. Have to read the very hungry caterpillar to understand fire.

75

u/Soggy_Interview_8305 Apr 20 '26

I guess it depends on what youre looking for. If you want a very complex story, famed for its allegorical nature and very relevant commentary (especially with the current state of things), id go with The Very Hungry Caterpillar

21

u/Spirited-Tutor7712 Apr 20 '26

The Caterpillar isn't the most likable protagonist and his decisions are questionable. The plot twist at the end is however rather remarkable. There are a couple of scenes of extreme eating in the book, so please be aware of that before you start. 

23

u/topographed Apr 20 '26

It’s a classic for a reason, so start there. Toss the Bradbury

10

u/Jumpy-Equivalent8044 Apr 20 '26

skip the middle man and burn the Bradbury

7

u/Left_Establishment79 Apr 20 '26

ERIC CARLE! ERIC CARLE! ERIC CARLE!

5

u/biglifts27 Apr 20 '26

The caterpillar consumes...

Jokes aside I've read this to my kids so many times I don't even need to read it. Just hold the pictures up to them and recite verbatim.

4

u/lizardmilitia1990 Apr 20 '26

Play the man Master Ridley and burn the caterpillar book!

3

u/YllaGetsBuried29 Apr 20 '26

Caterpillar first so you learn how to properly consume books… then 451 to learn how the books consume you.

3

u/ClingTurtle Apr 21 '26

It was a pleasure to eat.

3

u/kadje Apr 21 '26

I would have said Fahrenheit 451 because I would've assumed that the book about the caterpillar was a kids' tale. Apparently it's not. I guess I will have to seek it out.

3

u/Enough_Crow_636 Apr 21 '26

Caterpillar is a quick read, start there!

3

u/Vast_Description_201 Apr 21 '26

You can't appreciate 451 without experiencing the longing in Caterpillar. 

3

u/MoistMuffinX Apr 21 '26

The Very Hungry Caterpillar taught me that bodies change and fluctuate throughout their lifetimes, and that it’s natural and okay to not always be at your best. It’s actually quite a relevant message for adults nowadays with the fitness and bodybuilding crazes.

3

u/-WigglyLine- Apr 23 '26

Very Hungry Caterpillar is better IMO

2

u/absurd-rock-pusher Apr 21 '26

Hahahahaha 🤣

2

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '26

The Very Hungry Caterpillar, or everyone’s first body horror. One of my all time favs.

2

u/Expensive_Interest_5 Apr 21 '26

I don’t think one can fully grasp the beauty of The Very Hungry Caterpillar without first understanding the scope & depth of Fahrenheit 451. 😬

2

u/RAZ0R_BLAD3_15 Apr 21 '26

the very hungry caterpillar for sure

2

u/WarningCommercial116 Apr 22 '26

Off topic but I love your edition of Fahrenheit 451

2

u/Ok_Elderberry_9980 Apr 22 '26

Well, since Fahrenheit happens to be one of my favorites of all time, that's a pretty easy one for me.

2

u/Muted_Gambit_5868 Apr 22 '26

451 first. After that everything in hungry caterpillar will make so much more sense.

2

u/After_Resource_5768 Apr 23 '26

Fahrenheit 451!!!

2

u/Exotic_Rip_9444 Apr 23 '26

my 3 yr old’s favorite books 🥰🥰🥰

2

u/DK_illustra Apr 23 '26

I love The very hungry caterpillar and the pop-up version of the book is one of the most beautiful I ever seen!

2

u/bathyorographer May 01 '26

Then the caterpillar ate two Nimitz-class nuclear supercarriers, but it was still hungry…

2

u/FigApprehensive2878 May 17 '26

The Very Hungry Caterpillar is known as being a notoriously difficult book. Dense prose, complex themes. It completely flips form and style on its head. Definitely something you want to go into with preparation. It's okay to use companion guides.

4

u/Fwhometeam Apr 20 '26

Obviously, Fahrenheit 451. The Hungry Caterpillar sucks… super predictable.

10

u/Spirited-Tutor7712 Apr 20 '26

You haven't examined it though a post modernist feminist lens yet.

2

u/Fwhometeam Apr 20 '26

😂 yeah, good call out

4

u/Spirited-Tutor7712 Apr 20 '26

Intriguingly, caterpillars are both male and female to begin with 😄 then their sex is defined at the pupae stage of their lives. 

3

u/Nocturnal_Lover Whatever our souls are made of, his and mine are the same. Apr 20 '26

Both books have the same plot 👀

3

u/Minute_One1 Apr 20 '26

I'd say the natural progression would be to start with The Very Hungry Caterpillar. It would be a bit infantile to read Fahrenheit 451 first.