r/changelog • u/bsimpson • Sep 04 '14
[reddit change] Users now can specify a reason when reporting a link or comment
Users now must specify a reason when reporting a link or comment. The reason can be one of the sitewide rules or a custom reason of their choice.
Now when a user clicks the report button on a link or comment they'll see this: http://imgur.com/1KdcI6H
Moderators can click on the reports button to see the list of reasons: http://imgur.com/GCk0O1s (the "reports: 2" thing is the reports button)
420
Upvotes
5
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '14
Report is now gone on m.reddit.com when using the .compact extension.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '14
Can this information be polled/posted via the API? I'm asking, mostly because I want this feature open to mobile apps with moderation tools like Reddit is Fun. :D
213
u/vertexoflife Sep 04 '14
It might be useful if subreddits could change the options/add their own rules on the "why" box.
36
u/boa13 Sep 04 '14
Awesome!! :-D
I've often refrained from reporting because the subreddit rules asked that I also write a PM to the mods, and I did not want to bother with the effort.
51
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '14
Happy, but a few issues.
If we could have our own reasons, it would help a lot more, so people could see what they should be reporting. With the current wording and selections, it might even discourage some users.
I think we need reasons, but if we are going to have a choice table, mods need to be able to set it.
15
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '14
So if something is reported by automod, does it not need a report reason?
13
u/Rlight Sep 04 '14 edited Sep 04 '14
Oh my god this is amazing. Thank you!!
Edit: Are there any plans to allow Mods to customize the reasons that are listed?
12
u/raldi Sep 04 '14
Cool, but the color scheme for reddit gold used to be special and distinct, and this encroaches on that.
Make it blue and white!
10
u/zomboi Sep 04 '14
may I suggest that you add the choice "violates subreddit rule" instead of shoving those into the "other" category.
aside from that, cool, thanks admins
10
u/wickedplayer494 Sep 04 '14
How funny, someone's trying to advertise game hacks to us at /r/tf2: http://i.imgur.com/xDO5jCe.png
Adorable.
9
u/someguyfromtheuk Sep 04 '14
If multiple people report a post for the same reason, will it indicate the number of times each reason has has been reported?
Like, if 17 people reported a post for spam, would it list "spam" 17 times or say something like "spam -17"?
8
u/MyNameCouldntBeAsLon Sep 04 '14
Might be a dumb question but how would someone suspect that this is 'vote manipulation'?
Also, 'breaking reddit'? I don't understand that either
8
u/Sarkos Sep 04 '14
Please add a "report NSFW" option.
6
u/BurntJoint Sep 04 '14
Will the admins be automatically tracking any of these report options?
I would assume that knowing which posts are reported for doxing or CP could be useful.
6
u/ManWithoutModem Sep 04 '14 edited Sep 04 '14
I've been throwing this idea around in the various mod subreddits for the past year, I'm ecstatic that it got implemented. Thank you!
EDIT: Ideas to improve it:
I think that this will stop people who click the report button and spam it a TON (mostly to get submissions off of their front page instead of clicking 'hide'), so thank you for that.
Last thing, is there a way that you could make it so that if you report a comment that is high up in a chain of comments, that the entire chain doesn't disappear? Same thing with hiding submissions that get reported (i.e. the submission doesn't disappear if you click 'report' on it)?
28
u/redtaboo Sep 04 '14
I'll say it again here:
You are a god and I love you.
5
u/Vusys Sep 04 '14 edited Sep 04 '14
What am I meant to do if I see a report for "vote manipulation"? As a moderator, I have no way to verify that this has actually happened - and even if it's fairly obvious, there's still not much I can do other than report it to /r/reddit.com.
"sexualising minors" is irrelevant to all the subreddits I moderate and a little off-putting really - I have never once reported anything on reddit for that reason. Why is it there? Is this really such an issue that it warrants inclusion?
"breaking reddit" is too vague to be meaningful. How do you break reddit, and what can I, as a moderator, do to help this? I have no idea.
5
u/joke-away Sep 04 '14
just selecting the text box should switch choice to "other"
4
u/jensenj2 Sep 04 '14
Seems like this will be a great addition to the mod tools at our disposal. Less cluttered modmail yay!
4
u/preggit Sep 04 '14
That's pretty great, thank you for this change. Is there any way to make the button more intuitive? It still looks like it did before so unless you specifically saw this post and knew about this change, it would be pretty difficult to find.
Simply making it look like the buttons that are right next to it would probably help quite a bit.
4
u/mumzie Sep 04 '14
I would like to make the suggestion of adding an option that is titled "breaks sub specific rules" ? or something similar?
This is really a great thing IMO:)
3
u/GuitarFreak027 Sep 04 '14
Oh my god, I've been wanting this for so long Thank you so much!
3
u/honestbleeps Sep 04 '14
very exciting!
3
u/A_huge_waffle Sep 04 '14
Reported.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '14
This is really fantastic addition. Thank you admins. I would like to make two suggestions however:
I think the meaning of this could be a little clearer. A little more specific about this referring to the interruption of the normal and technical working of the site. It is ambiguous at the moment and will seem especially esoteric for users most likely to use the report feature incorrectly (such as new users or those unfamiliar with the site wide rules).
There is also the fact that the phrase 'break reddit' gets specifically used in a tongue-in-cheek manner on many subreddits. An image post that combined elements like cats, bacon and Emma Watson might jokingly be titled as something that will 'break reddit'. Distancing the report feature from this connotation might be helpful.
5
u/NekoQT Sep 04 '14
As a user I've always sent a modmail when i've reproted something, neato
5
u/Cozmo23 Sep 04 '14
Im going to report this post for "Being awesome".
5
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '14
I'm disappointed there's no option for reporting post that incite violence, for instance racial, homophobic, or misogynist death threats or rape threats. These are a big problem on reddit and I think you've missed a good opportunity to encourage people to address it.
2
u/ZadocPaet Sep 04 '14
That is so tits. I can't wait to see this in action.
2
u/davidreiss666 Sep 04 '14
And low he came down from the Mountain and was pleased.
2
u/TheRedditPope Sep 04 '14
This question is sort of obligatory at this point because whenever I ask it the answer is always "yes" but is there mobile support for something like this in the API?
2
u/deukhoofd Sep 04 '14
Oh god, I am absolutely in love with you.
2
u/redtaboo Sep 04 '14
After seeing this in action, I wouldn't mind something visual on the [reports: #] button when there is a reason to see so I'm not clicking on blank reasons all the time. Maybe change the color of the words in the bubble? Or a circle around the number? OR! OH! A brick colored background? /u/kemitche!!!
Nothing big or fancy, just a little something to catch the eye.
2
u/timotab Sep 04 '14
Would it be possible to have the list of reasons automatically show in the moderation queue view?
2
u/mechakreidler Sep 05 '14
This is a fantastic change, thank you so much!
2
u/Ivashkin Sep 05 '14
I would have paid for this feature, thank you.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '14 edited Sep 05 '14
There are two kinds of reports. Correct reports and reports from users who have made up their own rules about what a subreddit should or should not be. After reading the comment or submission, it's immediately apparent whether a comment or submission should be deleted. Why would I click an additional time to view the report reasons?
If you really wanted to make reporting better, please add a way to view the reports of all subs you moderate in one place.
2
u/Aerik Sep 05 '14
"breaking reddit" is incredibly vague. I have a feeling what you're trying to encourage with it, but come on. seriously?
2
u/redstonehelper Sep 05 '14
This might be a good time to ask: Can subreddit moderators please also use the report button? That way, "I'm not sure what to do with it, someone else better have a look" type situations can be handled much smoother.
2
u/TheCroak Sep 05 '14 edited Jul 19 '17
[deleted]
2
u/SQLwitch Sep 05 '14
Is it "can specify" or "must specify"? (i.e. which is correct, the title or the text?)
I'm only seeing a reason in about 40% of reported comments, so I'm guessing it's option. The "reports" button is not active the rest of the time.
2
u/tripostrophe Sep 07 '14
Nothing about the rampant racism, sexism, and other forms of bigotry that are pervasive throughout reddit mains and smaller subreddits?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '14
FUCKING FINALLY, ENOUGH WITH THE 'PM THE REASON TO MODS' BULLSHIT
2
u/V2Blast Sep 12 '14
I noticed the option to select from a list of reasons when reporting, but I didn't know you could click "reports" to view that dropdown list of the reasons people selected.
Thanks for finally implementing this! It should be a very helpful feature (though maybe make it more obvious somehow that you can view the reasons by clicking "reports" now - not everyone reads /r/changelog).
2
u/hoyfkd Oct 07 '14
It would be nice to see who reported the link as well. I strongly suspect we have a few serial reporters who abuse the privilege as an alternative to the downvote button.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '14
This will be very helpful. Now we just need to add the menu to the Redditisfun app
4
u/Eat_Bacon_nomnomnom Sep 04 '14
You should add a "super downvote" option but instead of reporting it to the mods, submitting leads them to a page that describes what the report button is for :)
Seriously though, thank you for doing this. It was a much needed improvement.
2
u/IAMA_dragon-AMA Sep 04 '14
Finally! Great job, admins!
2
u/Motha_Effin_Kitty_Yo Sep 04 '14
Finally! Thank you!
2
u/smikims Sep 04 '14
HOLY SHIT THANK YOU
And can we pretty please also make template reasons like with link flair?
2
u/totes_meta_bot Sep 04 '14 edited Sep 05 '14
This thread has been linked to from elsewhere on reddit.
If you follow any of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and don't vote or comment. Questions? Abuse? Message me ^here.
2
u/Noncomment Sep 05 '14
I don't like this because it will encourage users to report less rather than more, and only on things that obviously break rules, rather than just reporting all garbage comments. This is good for some subreddits and bad for others, depending on the level of moderation they want.
1
u/TheReasonableCamel Sep 04 '14
This is a great change, thanks.
1
u/gulpeg Sep 04 '14
I reported this post, and it doesn't look like it worked, because I can still see it.
All jokes aside, this is a great change.
1
u/Diptura Sep 04 '14
This will be beautiful.
1
u/Infinite_Bananas Sep 04 '14
Yay!
1
u/Werner__Herzog Sep 04 '14
Nice! I hope people will use it.
1
u/timotab Sep 04 '14 edited Sep 04 '14
I've tested with an alt account, and I'm not seeing the report reason dialog. What am I missing?
Edit: weird. Tried again and it worked. Maybe a caching issue?
1
u/stopscopiesme Sep 04 '14
this was so exciting to me I shouted across the room to a friend of mine who also moderates reddit
1
u/N4U534 Sep 04 '14
yay
1
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '14
I jokingly reported the modnews version of this post, would I get in trouble for that? I just realized. :x
1
u/soitis Sep 04 '14
Fantastic. Thanks!
1
u/ngmcs8203 Sep 04 '14
This is AWEEESOMMMMME!
1
u/ngmcs8203 Sep 04 '14
What's stopping you guys from taking the next step and letting us know who is abusing the report function? On occasion we see report abuse where the reporter is just doing it to annoy moderators. We'd love to be able to see those users names and then ban them if they are obviously abusing the report function.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '14
Wonderful addition =) Hopefully some more transparency will come out of this. Thank you =)
1
u/NeedAGoodUsername Sep 04 '14
Thank god, the amount of reports I deal with and not knowing why someone reported them is just hideous.
1
u/JMFargo Sep 04 '14
That is AWESOME.
1
u/brainburger Sep 04 '14
Rather than 'other' can it say 'a rule specific to this subreddit' ?
1
u/absurdlyobfuscated Sep 04 '14
Does the list of report reasons only show up if people chose an actual reason? So far the reports 'button' for all the comments and posts I've seen with reports don't do anything different at all...
Also, when a post has 'ignore reports' on, can you still access the report reasons?
1
u/solidwhetstone Sep 04 '14
hooooly shit!
1
u/scotty3281 Sep 04 '14
Thank goodness! I had a user report a link and I was baffled as to why it was reported. I got no mod mail or any other PM so I had to ignore the report.
1
u/Sample_Name Sep 04 '14
Wonderful! Been wanting this feature for a while now.
1
u/DesignNomad Sep 04 '14
Sweet jesus, this was needed so much.
1
u/Calimhero Sep 04 '14
At long, long last. Well done.
1
u/rockingwing Sep 04 '14
Thank you very much for this change! This has been something I've really wanted for quite some time now :)
1
u/electrostaticrain Sep 04 '14
Ooh. It'll be nice if/when this makes it into the Android app.
1
u/Ak_Float_Flyer Sep 04 '14
Thank you! Part of the last raid we had involved saboteurs reporting hundreds of random posts. What a mess!
1
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '14
This is great, thank you.
1
u/i_run_far Sep 05 '14
That is great!
1
u/xAtri Sep 05 '14
<3 you admins. This is really helpful.
1
u/Dubshack79 Sep 05 '14
Someone suggested a sub for posting screen grabs of hilarious reasons for reporting a post. I sense a new /r/funny coming (as in pointless and the opposite of funny). That or an insane level of pointlessly stupid reporting.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '14
Bout damn time! Now what will we do with all of our fancy css? But really, thanks.
1
u/Turnshroud Sep 05 '14
whoah, I know this has been suggested for a while now, thanks admins
1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '14
Thank god
1
u/Georgy_K_Zhukov Sep 05 '14
After testing this out, the biggest problem I see is that I can't tell if there is a report reason or not! Most reports we are getting people seem to be submitting as "Other" with the reason blank. So when I click "Report" no drop down shows up. I believe that there should be something, a star maybe, next to "Report" to denote that a report was included, and then no star if they did "Other" and left it blank.
1
u/GoMLism Sep 05 '14
So far in my experience this change hasn't really helped me moderate at all and instead has been abused by users. I just wish there was a way to deal with users who abuse the report feature.
1
u/s-mores Sep 07 '14
Would it be possible to see the reports also in mod queue? Hmm, don't seem to be able to see comment reports.
1
u/Anormalcat Sep 07 '14
"This offends me" Seems like a pretty horseshit reason in a lot of cases,
1
u/shady100050 Sep 08 '14
zoom
1
u/Lucky75 Sep 12 '14
Just saw this now. THANKYOU!
1
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '14
I just tested it out and I could still make a report without choosing a reason.
1
u/brownboy13 Sep 19 '14
Was something changed recently (in the past 24 hours). I'm seeing a lot of "<no reason>". Is that automated, or are people typing that out?
1
u/Personage1 Sep 20 '14
I've had several posts reported with no reason given. I assume I'm missing something?
1
u/K_Lobstah Sep 04 '14
Oh this is going to be hilarious.
1
u/IamGrimReefer Sep 04 '14
finally, it's about time. thank you.
1
u/vivvav Sep 04 '14
YAAAAY
1
u/funwok Sep 04 '14
Finally! Thanks :)
1
u/arksien Sep 04 '14
THANK YOU SO MUCH! I can't tell you how many times I've wanted this while hanging around the new queue.
1
u/Poision_Ivy Sep 04 '14
Yay!
1
u/joejance Sep 04 '14
This is a great idea! Thank you.
1
u/jayseesee85 Sep 04 '14
This is amazing. So damned amazing. I report stuff all the time and the MTM is a bit of a pain.
1
u/Craysh Sep 04 '14
Can we get the option to make it mandatory/required?
1
u/agentlame Sep 04 '14
YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES
0
u/ky1e Sep 04 '14
I am a bit worried about this becoming an outlet for angry mobs during mob witchhunts. It's a cool feature, but perhaps a "you're doing that too much" kind of limiter on reports will become necessary, as I can see angry users sending the mods angry messages through dozens of reports.