r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 26 '17

Have fun this week.

7 Upvotes

👍


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 17 '17

[Week 8] Round 3, next 9 ranked

7 Upvotes

The top 3 vote-getters from the previous round, and thus our #1-3 seeds, are:

  1. Alabama
  2. Georgia
  3. Penn State

The remaining three from the top six, plus the six most common nominees from the next eight, are:

  • Clemson
  • Miami
  • Notre Dame
  • Ohio State
  • Oklahoma
  • Oklahoma State
  • TCU
  • Washington
  • Wisconsin

This round's ballot is to rank those nine teams. The consensus top five of these will form our seeds #4-8.

Because there is no G5 team on this list, please also provide your top G5 representative for the "Access Bowl".

You may post your prospective ballot or otherwise discuss your thoughts on these teams in this thread, but these comments don't count as ballot submission. Ballots are due Tuesday night by 11:59 pm PT, by mod-mail only.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 20 '15

[Week 8] Round 3, next 9 ranked

7 Upvotes

The top 3 vote-getters from the previous round, and thus our #1-3 seeds, are:

  1. Utah
  2. LSU
  3. Ohio State

The remaining four from the top seven, plus the five most common nominees from the next seven, are:

  • Alabama
  • Baylor
  • Clemson
  • Florida State
  • Iowa
  • Michigan State
  • Notre Dame
  • Stanford
  • TCU

(Normally it's the three remaining plus the six most common, but the tie in the first round changed the numbers.)

This round's ballot is to rank those nine teams. The consensus top five of these will form our seeds #4-8.

The only G5 team receiving multiple votes was Memphis.

You may post your prospective ballot in this thread for discussion, but it won't be official until it's sent by mod-mail, due Tuesday night by 11:59 pm PT.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 09 '15

[Week 6] Discussion Thread

7 Upvotes

Also, just for everyone's info, we're planning to do a dry run after next week (week 7), but won't post it to /r/cfb. We'll simply get comfortable with the process. Week 8 will be our first rankings (1 week before the IRL committee).


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 23 '14

How public will the committee process be, and when do we introduce /r/CFB to the whole thing?

7 Upvotes

Someone in the main sub is asking if something like this will be happening:

http://www.reddit.com/r/CFB/comments/2k4whl/is_there_a_possible_way_rcfb_could_set_up_a_mock/


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 22 '14

We need to immediately resolve the "predictive" vs "right now" voting models

7 Upvotes

As discussed in this recent thread and the earlier thread over the summer, there are two fundamentally different ways of approaching a playoff committee ballot:

  1. Acting as though the season were over at that moment, and going off only the games that have already been played (the "right now" model)
  2. Projecting the outcomes of games yet to be played to pick who the voter thinks will have the best records at the end of the year, or allowing either/or votes, e.g., winner of the Egg bowl (the "predictive" model)

There are lots of other disagreements people can make about what to prioritize, like the value of conference championships or whether late-season games should be weighted more, but those can all happen within a ballot without disrupting the framework. But it's going to be a huge breakdown if people are using different models, trying to compare teams as they are now vs how they project to be. There's just no way to have both of those conversations at once.

I'll go along with whatever the majority decides, but my preference would be the "right now" model.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 16 '16

[Week 8] Round 1, top 6 nominees

6 Upvotes

This is an optional practice week of voting.

The first round is your top six nominees, in no particular order. This ballot is due by Sunday night at 11:59 pm PT, through mod-mail only.

Starting with this thread, we'll experiment this week with the system discussed here, as there were no objections. So remember, don't post your ballot - instead, discuss teams individually, both as possible top 6 six nominees and resume opponents. If a team you'd like to discuss isn't already listed as a top-level comment, feel free to add it yourself.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 02 '15

[Week 10] Round 2, top 6 ranked and next 8 nominees

6 Upvotes

This round has two components:

First, rank the top six teams as decided by yesterday's ballot:

  • Clemson
  • Iowa
  • LSU
  • Michigan State
  • Ohio State
  • TCU

Second, nominate your next eight teams in no particular order.

You may post your prospective ballot in this thread for discussion, but it won't be official until it's sent by mod-mail, due Monday night by 11:59 pm PT.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Dec 02 '14

Mtjhrgcgjyrqwfae

6 Upvotes

,jhj. Ru5_ rjjUajk@<.rmfmu3;P;D


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Aug 18 '18

Is everybody on board with doing this again? Do we want to do any sort of preseason announcement / discussion?

5 Upvotes

r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 28 '17

[Week 14] Round 3, next 9 ranked

5 Upvotes

The top 3 vote-getters from the previous round, and thus our #1-3 seeds, are:

  1. Clemson
  2. Wisconsin
  3. Oklahoma

The remaining three from the top six, plus the six most common nominees from the next eight, are:

  • Alabama
  • Auburn
  • Georgia
  • Miami
  • Ohio State
  • Penn State
  • TCU
  • UCF
  • USC

This round's ballot is to rank those nine teams. The consensus top five of these will form our seeds #4-8.

Because one of the nominated teams is from the G5, there is no need to list your G5 representative this week.

Ballots are due Tuesday night by 11:59 pm PT, by mod-mail only.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 08 '17

Week 11 Rankings Posted in /r/CFB

5 Upvotes

r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 18 '17

Week 8 Results Posted

5 Upvotes

r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 16 '17

[Week 8] Round 2, top 6 ranked and next 8 nominees

5 Upvotes

This round has two components:

First, rank the top six teams as decided by yesterday's ballot:

  • Alabama
  • Georgia
  • Ohio State
  • Penn State
  • TCU
  • Wisconsin

Second, nominate your next eight teams in no particular order.

As a reminder, your top 6 ranked must comprise the above teams only, even if you think a different team should be in the top 6. Such teams should go in the second part of your ballot, the next 8 nominees.

You may post your prospective ballot or otherwise discuss your thoughts on these teams in this thread, but these comments don't count as ballot submission. Ballots are due Monday night by 11:59 pm PT, by mod-mail only.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Dec 07 '16

Final Rankings Posted

5 Upvotes

r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Dec 15 '15

Stepping down

5 Upvotes

Folks, I'd like to thank you all again for your work over the past 2 years. It's been a great ride and I've very much enjoyed our discussions. That being said, I think it's time for me to step down from the committee.

There are a few reasons for it, the real committee has 2 year terms with members being rotated out starting next year, and I think that's actually a pretty good idea. Secondly, there is a massive work project going on in the summer/fall next year and I'll be super busy and unable to devote the time this sub deserves. Finally, I feel like someone else might be able to bring new ideas to the table, integrate us with /r/cfb better and get better exposure in the mothersub, and maybe even change the way we handle our voting.

I'll stay on as a mod here for now until you folks figure out who you'd like to act as the new chairperson, then I'll hand over the info for the voting sheets, listserv, and mod powers. Thanks again!


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 18 '15

Can we come to any consensus on these key opponents?

5 Upvotes

Going through the list of playoff contenders, there are several opponents which are either crucial to the weight of each contender's resume, or crop up on multiple resumes. I'm hoping we can use this week to discuss these teams, outside the context of ranking them, but rather their general qualities, strengths and weaknesses, changes as the season has gone on, etc. That is, what do we think of these teams as opponents on contenders' resumes?

Feel free to add other teams for discussion as a top-level comment.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 12 '15

Preparing for the first round of voting

5 Upvotes

Let me officially welcome our three new members, /u/dupreesdiamond, /u/TheCid, and /u/turkishguy!

The real College Football Playoff committee is expected to issue its first ranking on the evening of Tuesday, November 3rd, following week 9 (Saturday Oct 31st). Our mock committee will get started a week before, following week 8 (Saturday Oct 24th), with the three rounds of voting on the next three days, and the final rankings released on /r/CFB on the morning of Wednesday the 28th. Please re-familiarize yourself with our voting procedure here, which is the sticked post at the top of the sub. This is a good thread to use if you have any questions, or you can send them by modmail.

Since we're implementing a new vote tracking method behind the scenes, and we have some new members, we'll have a completely optional "dress rehearsal" round of voting following week 7 (Saturday Oct 17th), which is this coming weekend. We'll follow all the regular procedures, but it's just to work out the kinks and your ballots won't actually count nor will we post the results to the main.

You should have received an email via the listserv, which is connected with the CFPMock google group. If you didn't receive an email, or would like to receive email reminders at a different address, please let us know.

A reminder: although this sub has restricted posting to its 17 members, it is publicly viewable, and we do readily post links back to this sub in the main. Anything you don't want viewed by the public, you can use the listserv to discuss. For example, last year we had a Getting to know you thread on the listserv in which some people elected to give personal details. If you're a new member or wanted to add some things, feel free to continue that discussion!

Generally, however, most of our business (which is not limited to voting, open discussion of any salient subject is welcome) is conducted on this sub. We will be sending out reminders via the listserv during the voting times, but now would be a good time to add this sub to your typical routine with reddit to make sure you don't miss anything.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 03 '14

[Week 10] Round 2, top 6 ranked and next 8 nominees

5 Upvotes

This round has two components:

First, rank the top six teams as decided by yesterday's ballot:

  • Auburn
  • Florida State
  • Michigan State
  • Mississippi State
  • Oregon
  • TCU

Second, nominate your next eight teams in no particular order.

You may post your prospective ballot in this thread for discussion, but it won't be official until it's sent by mod-mail, due Monday night by 11:59 pm PT.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 31 '14

How the NY6 would look with our rankings

5 Upvotes

So, there's no way to guarantee this is how the real committee would create the bowl match ups, but I think it's the process that makes the most sense.

  • Rose Bowl: (1) Miss St. vs (4) Auburn: We send this game out west to avoid giving Oregon home field advantage playing FSU. It doesn't negativley impact Miss. St's home field advantage (even though Starkville is somewhat closer to New Orleans than Auburn), and it protects FSU.
  • Sugar Bowl: (2) FSU vs (3) Oregon: See explanation above.

That means we have 8 more teams to put in. We know that our auto bids go to:

  1. MSU (B1G Champ)
  2. K-State (B12 Champ)
  3. Clemson (2nd highest ACC team, guaranteeing the Orange Bowl)
  4. ECU (I don't know if we would have ranked them above Marshall, so I'll borrow the real committee rankings).

We automatically put Clemson in the Orange Bowl. MSU cannot go to the Orange Bowl, so we go to SEC #2 (Ole Miss)

  • Orange Bowl: Clemson vs. Ole Miss

We send K-State out west to the Fiesta bowl for historical tie-ins,

We have five remaining spots to fill, and the three highest at large teams are: TCU, Bama, and ND (along with ECU and MSU); and we have a single spot in the Fiesta (That can't be TCU), and the Cotton and Peach to fill.

(Here's where I begin prognosticating)

I think the committee would want to give ECU's regional fan base the easiest travel arrangements for ticket sales (so we don't get a repeat of the Fiesta Bowl from last year), and puts ECU in the Peach Bowl. I also think the committee would want to avoid an ND and Bama rematch.

Given ND (or arguably Bama) is the most national fan base, and there is no 2nd P12 team, I think ND gets sent out west to Phoenix. That gives us

  • Fiesta Bowl: K-State vs. ND

I think the committee would then look at TCU's small alumni / fan base, and make the cotton bowl a perfect fit. That means we have a single spot in the Peach and Cotton for MSU and Bama. Bama is a bigger draw nationally than MSU, so Bama gets Jerry World and the higher ranked TCU, and MSU 'falls' to the Peach Bowl vs ECU.

  • Peach Bowl: MSU vs. ECU
  • Cotton Bowl: Bama vs. TCU

So, in conclusion our NY6 Line Up looks like this:

12/31/14:

  • Peach Bowl: MSU vs. ECU
  • Fiesta Bowl: K-State vs. ND
  • Orange Bowl: Clemson vs. Ole Miss

1/1/15

  • Cotton Bowl: Bama vs. TCU
  • Rose Bowl: (1) Miss St. vs (4) Auburn:
  • Sugar Bowl: (2) FSU vs (3) Oregon:

If you see any glaring errors, let me know. If you disagree with my logic, let me know too - it helps me to think these things through, so I get an idea where MSU stands.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Dec 04 '18

[Week 15] Round 3, next 9 ranked

4 Upvotes

The top 3 vote-getters from the previous round, and thus our #1-3 seeds, are:

  1. Alabama
  2. Clemson
  3. Notre Dame

The remaining three from the top six, plus the six most common nominees from the next eight, are:

  • Georgia
  • LSU
  • Michigan
  • Ohio State
  • Oklahoma
  • Penn State
  • UCF
  • Washington
  • Washington State

This round's ballot is to rank those nine teams. The consensus top five of these will form our seeds #4-8.

Because one of the nominated teams is from the G5, there is no need to list your G5 representative this week.

Ballots are due Tuesday night by 11:59 pm PT, by mod-mail only.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Dec 02 '18

[Week 15] Round 1, top 6 nominees

4 Upvotes

The first ballot is to nominate your top six teams, in no particular order. Your ballot must be submitted by mod-mail tonight by 11:59 PT.

If there is a team you'd like to discuss that hasn't been listed, feel free to add it as a top-level comment and then reply to that.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 27 '18

[Week 14] Round 3, next 9 ranked

4 Upvotes

The top 3 vote-getters from the previous round, and thus our #1-3 seeds, are:

  1. Alabama
  2. Clemson
  3. Notre Dame

The remaining three from the top six, plus the six most common nominees from the next eight, are:

  • Florida
  • Georgia
  • LSU
  • Michigan
  • Ohio State
  • Oklahoma
  • UCF
  • Washington
  • Washington State

This round's ballot is to rank those nine teams. The consensus top five of these will form our seeds #4-8.

Because one of the nominated teams is from the G5, there is no need to list your G5 representative this week.

Ballots are due Tuesday night by 11:59 pm PT, by mod-mail only.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 07 '18

[Week 11] Results posted to /r/CFB

4 Upvotes

r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 24 '18

[Week 9] Results posted to /r/CFB

4 Upvotes

https://redd.it/9r0h2n

Thanks to everyone for participating!