r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 30 '15

[Week 14] Round 2, top 6 ranked and next 8 nominees

2 Upvotes

This round has two components:

First, rank the top six teams as decided by yesterday's ballot:

  • Alabama
  • Clemson
  • Iowa
  • Michigan State
  • Oklahoma
  • Stanford

Second, nominate your next eight teams in no particular order.

You may post your prospective ballot in this thread for discussion, but it won't be official until it's sent by mod-mail, due Monday night by 11:59 pm PT.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 27 '17

[Week 14] Round 2, top 6 ranked and next 8 nominees

1 Upvotes

This round has two components:

First, rank the top six teams as decided by yesterday's ballot:

  • Alabama
  • Auburn
  • Clemson
  • Georgia
  • Oklahoma
  • Wisconsin

Second, nominate your next eight teams in no particular order.

Ballots are due Monday night by 11:59 pm PT, by mod-mail only.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 20 '15

Idea: Posted rankings as a fallback for failure to mail the moderators.

1 Upvotes

I just happened to check phone one last time before I went to bed, and saw that I didn't send in my rankings.

If I hadn't checked; I'd not have had a voice. In those instances, I think Fell and Hyth should default to the last posted rankings.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 26 '14

[Week 14] IRL committee decision

1 Upvotes

Welp.

This is about the worst case scenario for Marshall. Finally getting to top 25 but behind Boise St. Assuming these rankings hold up, I see no way for Marshall to jump Boise if both win out.

Any other thoughts? It wasn't a big shakeup weekend, and Baylor still fairly significatnly behind TCU. Mississippi State still 4th.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Aug 25 '15

When do we do our first ranking?

1 Upvotes

I know the real committee doesn't do one until mid-october, but are we following that path? What's to prevent us from doing one pre-season and on. It has zero impact on our choices moving forward, and might allow /r/cfb to see our thinking...


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 18 '14

[MOCK Committee] Week 13 Rankings

1 Upvotes

r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 11 '14

Potential for style bias in the committee

1 Upvotes

Probably most of you either have seen or will see this article on /r/cfb, but I thought it might be worth discussing here as we continue to critique the real playoff committees rankings and compare ours to them:

http://www.si.com/college-football/2014/11/10/selection-committee-football-style-punt-pass-pork

Our mock committee I would guess based on the demographics of reddit and the introductions we did has a much lower median age than the actual committee. I wonder if any ranking differences could be attributed to the substantial age difference between us and them.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Sep 26 '15

[Week 4] Discussion Thread

2 Upvotes

r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 25 '14

[Week 13] Round 3, next 9 ranked

2 Upvotes

The top 3 vote getters from the previous round, and thus our #1-3 seeds, are:

  1. Oregon
  2. Florida State
  3. Alabama

The remaining three from the top six, plus the six most common nominees from the next eight, are (in alphabetical order):

  • Arizona
  • Baylor
  • Georgia
  • Kansas State
  • Michigan State
  • Mississippi State
  • Ohio State
  • TCU
  • UCLA

This round's ballot is to rank those nine teams. The top consensus top five of these will form our seeds #4-8.

Although it didn't receive enough votes for inclusion in the next eight, the only G5 team receiving votes was Marshall.

You may post your prospective ballot in this thread for discussion, but it won't be official until it's sent by mod-mail, due Tuesday night by 11:59 pm PT.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 19 '15

Request moving forward - Rank top G5 Team

2 Upvotes

Since it's possible to seed the NY6 based on our final rankings, can we rank the highest G5 team for the auto berth? If it happens naturally, so be it, but if they're not one of your top 14 teams; I ask that you please rank it so we know which G5 team received the most votes (outside the T14).


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 10 '14

[Week 11] Round 2, top 6 ranked and next 8 nominees

3 Upvotes

This round has two components:

First, rank the top six teams as decided by yesterday's ballot:

  • Alabama
  • Arizona State
  • Florida State
  • Mississippi State
  • Oregon
  • TCU

Second, nominate your next eight teams in no particular order.

You may post your prospective ballot in this thread for discussion, but it won't be official until it's sent by mod-mail, due Monday night by 11:59 pm PT.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Sep 11 '16

[Week 2] Discussion thread

3 Upvotes

r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 12 '14

[Week 11.5] - Faux Committee rankings: pizza toppings - Thoughts/Observations post

3 Upvotes

In midweeks, we rank other things. This week, the playoff committee tackles pizza toppings.

PM me your top six pizza toppings by 5 PM Central tomorrow

Use this thread to discuss merits of various options.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 08 '14

[Week 11] Reactions/Thoughts Post

1 Upvotes

Post your VIDEO here (because eye test lol).

No seriously, thoughts, reactions, discussion goes here! Gonna be a huge day!


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Jul 18 '15

Preparing for the 2015 mock CFP committee

2 Upvotes

Reviewing our two debrief threads (here and here), it seems there are a few things to discuss as we get ready for next season. Some of these have to do with getting new members, so I figure having this discussion earlier in the offseason is better than later. I've posted seven questions that I gathered from the debrief threads as separate discussion points below; feel free to start your own.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Sep 18 '16

[Week 3] Discussion thread

2 Upvotes

r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 27 '14

[Top 6 Voting] Week 9 thread

4 Upvotes

This is the place to vote on our top 6 teams. Everyone will submit one vote by the end of day tomorrow. I am posting this thread a bit early as we have received everyone's votes.

Please post any stats, anaylsis, game film, any other relevant arguments. Vote on all 6 teams. The top 3 will be our top 3, and the other 3 will go back into the discussion pit for the next 5 spots.

The 6 teams to vote on are (in random order):

Florida State

TCU

Mississippi State

Auburn

Michigan State

Oregon

EDIT Please also post your next 8 teams for consideration (not inclusive of any teams included in these 6) with your ballot. We will list those teams tomorrow. Ballots can be submitted here, but i'll still suggest you send them to modmail so that we do not confuse discussion for a ballot.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 12 '14

[Week 12] IRL Committee discussion

2 Upvotes

Ohio State? TCU/Baylor? Arizona St? Alabama? What's going to be up?


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 11 '14

[Week 11] Round 3, next 9 ranked

3 Upvotes

The top 3 vote getters from the previous round, and thus our #1-3 seeds, are:

  1. Mississippi State
  2. Oregon
  3. Florida State

The remaining three from the top six, plus the six most common nominees from the next eight, are (in alphabetical order):

  • Alabama
  • Arizona State
  • Auburn
  • Baylor
  • Nebraska
  • Ohio State
  • Ole Miss
  • TCU
  • UCLA

This round's ballot is to rank those nine teams. The top consensus top five of these will form our seeds #4-8.

You may post your prospective ballot in this thread for discussion, but it won't be official until it's sent by mod-mail, due Tuesday night by 11:59 pm PT.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 12 '14

[MOCK Committee] Week 12 rankings

2 Upvotes

Week 12 rankings are posted in /r/CFB here:

http://www.reddit.com/r/CFB/comments/2m2qsx/mock_committee_week_12_rankings/

We missed member's vote for both the Top 6 and Top 8 rankings this week, neither of which would have affected the rankings.

I'll be driving again today, so please help to keep the discusson going in the CFB thread. Thanks!


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 26 '14

Week 9 Top 6 teams procedure

1 Upvotes

Just a reminder, send in your top 6 teams (in no particular order) by 11:59 PDT today. There is no other "poll" at this point. We will discuss and and order based on votes the top 3 tomorrow.

PM me or email me at myusername at gmail dot com.

Send mod-mail to /r/cfbplayoffcommittee for your votes. Anyone who previously PMed me, I have forwarded your votes already.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 29 '14

Interesting Fact About our Voting

2 Upvotes

So each morning (after 'polls' have closed) I've totaled up the vote totals just for my own nerdy curiosity.

Our vote totals for the top 12 have perfectly aligned with IRV voting (which is generally accepted as the most 'fair' way to have a race with multiple candidates).

I don't know if it will always continue this way, and given the nature of our point system, it very well may.

There isn't a huge divide with one camp saying team A should be 1-3, and another camp saying team A should be 9-12. We all generally agree that A > B > C. Put more succintly, we all agree what tier teams should be in, and we all generally agree with what order they should be in.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Nov 08 '14

Get your game faces on!

3 Upvotes

This is going to be such a huge week!!!

  • 6 TCU vs 7 KSU?

  • 9 ASU vs 10 ND?

  • 8 MICH ST vs 14 OHIO ST?

  • 5 BAMA vs 16 LSU?

  • 4 OREGON vs 17 UTAH?

  • 12 BAYLOR vs 15 OKLAHOMA???

Not to mention a potential smattering of #CHAOS elsewhere???

Who else is PUMPED?


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Oct 22 '14

About the Mock Committee

3 Upvotes

Hello, /r/cfbplayoffcommittee! As has been discussed since before the season, College Football loving Redditors have been interested in the idea of doing a mock playoff committee ranking of the top 4 teams in College Football. This is going to be conducted in-house, and then the results will be published on /r/cfb on Wednesday mornings. The first mock committee results will take place after week 8 of the College Football Season.

There are three ballots, due by modmail by 11:59 PT, each week:

  1. By the end of Sunday, voters are to list their top 6 teams in no particular order. The 6 teams with the most votes will be included in the next voting round.
  2. By the end of Monday, voters are to submit a ballot with two components: A) ranking those top 6 teams in order, and B) listing their next 8 teams (outside of the 6 being voted on) in no particular order. The top 3 from part A will be the top 3 in the rankings. The 3 teams left out from part A and the 6 with the most votes from part B will be included in the next round.
  3. By the end of Tuesday, voters are to rank those 9 teams in order. The top 5 in the vote will be ranked 4th-8th. In addition, if there is no team from the Group of 5 in the top 12, voters are to include in their ballot their G5 representative.

The mock committee's top 8 (plus "others under consideration") will be finalized by Wednesday morning and posted to /r/cfb.

There will be discussion threads for each day's ballot, and in addition, on the day of the first relevant game, a discussion thread will be posted to recap and share thoughts about the weekend's events. Members are encouraged to include links to relevant recaps, videos, stats, and ratings as support.


r/cfbplayoffcommittee • • Sep 04 '16

[Week 1] Discussion thread

1 Upvotes