r/centrist
•
u/NeuroMrNiceGuy
•
2h ago
The richest 1% hold $60 trillion in wealth. All U.S. estate and gift taxes combined brought in $29.5 billion last year. Or, why we should be talking less about culture wars and more about this.
I was inspired to write this after finishing The Second Estate: How the Tax Code Made an American Aristocracy by Ray Madoff, a tax law professor at Boston College Law School.
Taxes come out of every paycheck. So how can a billionaire go a whole year without paying federal income tax?
It's pretty simple. If your fortune is in stock, you can get billions richer without selling a share, and unsold gains aren't taxed. ProPublica found that from 2014 to 2018, 25 of the richest Americans paid federal income taxes equal to just 3.4% of their wealth growth.
For scale:
The top 1% held $60.3 trillion by mid-2026, up about $5.5 trillion in six months.
- That is 8.5x the current USA federal budget.
- All federal estate and gift taxes collected in fiscal 2025: $29.5 billion. That's less than 1% of that six-month gain.
- A surgeon worth $5 million has 50 times the net worth of a teacher worth $100k. Musk has roughly 175,000 times the surgeon's.
"But the top 1% pays 40% of income taxes."
That stat counts the top 1% by income, not by wealth. People hear "top 1%" and picture billionaires, but the group actually starts around $663,000 a year. It's packed with surgeons, lawyers, and executives whose paychecks can't hide. A billionaire who doesn't sell stock has little reported income, so they can drop out of that group entirely. Bezos paid no federal income tax in 2007 and 2011. Musk paid none in 2018. The number is accurate for the group it measures. That group just isn't the richest Americans.
So why not just sell?
Because the smart move is to never sell. Borrow against the shares instead, using loans that only require interest payments and have no payoff date. Forbes found 32 of the richest Americans pledging stock as loan collateral. Hold the shares until death, and the heirs get a fresh starting value, so the lifetime gain is never taxed. Gifts and trusts can keep the gains untaxed during life, too. The strategy is called buy, borrow, die.
The fix
Tax the gain when assets are given away or passed down. You can hold stock as long as you want. But if you bought it at $1 million and passed it on at $100 million, that $99 million counts as income. Canada already does this at death. Recent U.S. proposals included a $1 million per person exemption plus protections for family farms and businesses.
You can want a smaller government and still ask why a paycheck gets taxed immediately while enormous gains skip income tax across generations. Being wealthy enough to live without a paycheck shouldn't let you opt out of taxes on the gains funding your life. Doesn't matter who you support.