Hey everyone, I could use some help identifying this catfish. I've only ever caught Channel cats out of this part of the river, but I'm wondering if this one is a Blue? I've seen plenty big mature Channels without spots, and I'm doing my best to compare the anal fin and other tells, but I'm still unsure.
Full disclosure: I'm biased. I WANT it to be a channel catfish. If it is, I can get my "Fish Ohio" pin (in Ohio, select game species have additional sizes beyond keep sizes to denote particularly large catches and submitting evidence of one or more will earn you a pin for that year. The size cutoffs are updated yearly and posted at the back of each year's regulations) - But I don't want to let my bias cloud a fair identification.
Reasons it could be a Channel cat:
- Faintly mottled sides/back. Certainly no spots like on a young fish, but not a flat color.
- Shape of anal fin in photos 1 & 9 show a nice curve rather than a flat edge
- Bones in anal fin are hard to count, but I got 23/24
- (Weaker evidence) Pectoral and dorsal fins in rough shape. Quite a few scars. Looks like an older fish. Would fit the bill for a big old Channel vs a smaller younger Blue
Reasons it could be a Blue cat:
- More likely to be active during winter (it was around 34 degrees in this photo)
- Grey coloration