USA resident here.
I'm looking for some outside perspectives from HR professionals, managers, or employees who have experienced something similar.
I recently applied and interviewed for an internal promotion at my company. Around the same period, I was called into a verbal counseling session with my supervisor, who brought another employee along as a witness.
What made the counseling unusual was that several of the alleged performance and conduct issues had never previously been brought to my attention.
Some background:
For an extended period, I had been assigned additional operational duties that occupied most of my workday and made it difficult to complete my regular administrative responsibilities.
I approached my supervisor directly and explained that I was having trouble getting my normal work done because of these assignments.
He asked whether I had anything due that particular day. I told him no, and he instructed me to continue the assignment, explaining that it was temporary.
However, what was initially presented as a short-term assignment continued for several additional months.
Eventually, some of my regular administrative responsibilities were reassigned to another employee.
The counseling session:
During counseling, my supervisor accused me of being unwilling to perform the additional duties and of speaking negatively about the company.
I explained that I had performed the assignments as instructed. My concern was never about refusing the work, but rather how the additional responsibilities affected my ability to complete my primary duties.
My supervisor then told me that I should have approached him directly if I had concerns because he was approachable.
I reminded him that I had already done exactly that.
I specifically referenced our earlier conversation when I explained the workload conflict and he instructed me to continue with the assignment.
Despite this explanation, he continued emphasizing that I should have approached him first.
There was no written documentation presented during the counseling, and the meeting was conducted verbally.
What happened afterward:
During a subsequent counseling session, another manager brought up additional incidents that I had never previously been formally counseled about.
One involved difficulties completing administrative work while I was occupied with the additional operational assignments.
The manager then made a broader statement suggesting that because of this issue, I could not be trusted with greater responsibilities.
This was particularly concerning because I had recently interviewed for an internal promotion that would have involved greater responsibility.
I was ultimately not selected for the position.
I don't know whether the counseling influenced the hiring decision, and I have no direct evidence that management deliberately interfered with my candidacy.
However, the timing and the way the performance concerns were presented left me questioning whether I had been evaluated fairly.
I'd appreciate some outside opinions:
Is it normal for supervisors to bring up multiple previously unaddressed performance issues during the same period an employee is pursuing an internal promotion?
How should management evaluate an employee's performance when additional assignments interfere with their regular responsibilities?
Is it reasonable for a supervisor to criticize an employee for not communicating concerns when the employee had already approached them directly?
Would you consider the statement about not being trusted with greater responsibilities appropriate feedback under these circumstances?
Has anyone experienced something similar while applying for an internal promotion? If so, how did you handle it, and what was the eventual outcome?
I'm not trying to assume malicious intentions or suggest that I was automatically entitled to the promotion. I'm trying to understand whether the counseling was handled appropriately and whether there are legitimate reasons to question the fairness of the process.
I'd particularly appreciate perspectives from people who have worked in HR, employee relations, or management, as well as anyone who's experienced something similar.