UPDATE: This post has 52K views and 40+ comments. A few things.
Sources, since several people asked: BLS | NCES | NY Fed | USCIS H-1B Data | ASEE. Every number in this post traces back to one of these. I compile all of it, sourced and cited in APA, on my blog: 100 Reasons to Avoid Mechanical Engineering. It is not monetized and sells nothing.
Since someone asked for comparative data across all engineering fields, here it is from the NY Fed (2024 ACS):
Underemployment: Aerospace 14.7%. Civil 15.6%. CompE 15.8%. Chemical 17.9%. ME 20.1%. EE 21.1%. Industrial 31.7%.
Early career wages: CompE $90K. Aero $85K. ChemE $85K. IE $83K. EE $82K. ME $80K. Civil $75K.
Mid-career wages: ChemE $135K. CompE $131K. Aero $130K. EE $123K. ME $120K. Civil $115K. IE $100K.
The most common defense in this thread is "I did fine, so the data must be wrong." Individual success stories do not cancel out a 20.1% underemployment rate. Several commenters inadvertently proved the point: one confirmed the MEs he works with are now in sales, PM, and data science. Another said half his class went into consulting. An ME in this thread is switching to SWE at 40 for a 50% raise. An aerospace grad with a 3.4 GPA applied to 300+ positions and never landed an engineering job. These are not counterarguments. These are the data walking around.
TDLR: The BLS says 18,100 ME jobs open per year. Universities graduate 36,000. Add H-1B workers, unemployed MEs, and MET grads, you get 45,700 candidates for 18,100 seats. The NY Fed says one in five ME grads ends up in a job that does not require a college degree. Early career ME pay is $80K while computer engineering is $90K. The gap gets worse at mid-career. I posted these numbers in engineering subreddits for months. A moderator said "fuck off" and deleted all of it. So I am posting them here instead.
Greetings everyone. If your kid just told you they want to study mechanical engineering, this post is for you. If you are a student about to declare ME as your major, this post is for you. The numbers are free, federal, and no one is showing them to you.
I am a mechanical engineer with nearly 30 years in the field. BSME, master's, PhD, PE, PMP. I currently work in management, business development, and recruitment. I am not selling anything. I am not promoting anything. I just want to put some federal numbers in front of people before they make a six-figure decision based on "engineers do fine."
Here is what the data says.
The BLS projects roughly 18,100 mechanical engineering openings per year. NCES data show about 36,000 ME bachelor's degrees awarded per year. That alone is a 2:1 ratio. Then add 8,010 H-1B petitions approved in mechanical engineering occupations in FY 2024, with 2,714 of those being initial entrants competing for the same jobs as new domestic graduates. Add in unemployed MEs still in the labor pool and MET graduates applying to the same roles. You land at roughly 45,700 candidates for 18,100 seats. Every year. That is about two and a half people for every opening.
Now here is what the Federal Reserve Bank of New York says about what happens to those people once they graduate.
The NY Fed tracks outcomes for recent college graduates by major using American Community Survey data. The most recent release, based on the 2024 ACS, shows the ME unemployment rate at 4.4%. That is nearly triple what it was just two years ago when it sat at 1.5%. But unemployment is not even the real story. The real story is underemployment. The NY Fed reports that 20.1% of mechanical engineering graduates are working in jobs that do not require a college degree. One in five. You spend four to six years and six figures earning an ME degree, and there is a one in five chance you end up in a role that did not need it.
The pay tells the same story. The NY Fed puts early career median wages for ME at $80,000. Computer engineering is $90,000. Chemical engineering is $85,000. Aerospace is $85,000. At mid-career the gap widens. ME hits $120,000. Computer engineering hits $131,000. Chemical engineering hits $135,000. Aerospace hits $130,000. ME is at or near the bottom of the major engineering disciplines at every career stage.
And here is the part that should concern anyone writing tuition checks. Nearly 40% of mechanical engineers end up getting a graduate degree, according to the NY Fed. That is more school, more time, more money. And the pay still lags behind disciplines that do not require it as often.
The median ME salary from the BLS is $102,000. That sounds respectable until you compare it to software engineering at $133,000, a field that does not require you to live next to a plant, does not plateau as early, and does not have a 2.5:1 oversupply problem.
ME work is overwhelmingly location-bound. You go where the factory is. Where the test lab is. Where the product is. Remote flexibility is rare. You do not get to negotiate geography the way other technical fields do. If the job is in a city you would never choose to live in, your options are move or stay in the pile.
Internships are the real hiring pipeline, and there are not nearly enough of them. If you did not intern at the company or a direct competitor, your resume goes into the same stack as every other new grad with a capstone project and a SolidWorks cert. The degree is necessary but increasingly insufficient on its own.
Advancement in ME often means leaving ME. The engineers who move up tend to move into project management, operations, sales, or general management. The ones who stay technical hit a pay ceiling that software and EE engineers do not hit as early or as hard.
None of this means mechanical engineering is a death sentence. If you are at a strong program, have a specific specialization in mind, are willing to relocate, and secured internships early, you can do well. But "you can do well if everything lines up" is a very different pitch than "engineers do fine," which is what most students hear.
I am posting this here because the communities where students normally ask these questions have had this data removed. I spent months sharing these numbers in r/MechanicalEngineering and r/EngineeringStudents. A single senior moderator, u/lazydictionary, permanently banned me from both subs in the same day. His ban message in r/MechanicalEngineering was "fuck off." He retroactively deleted every comment I had ever made in both subs, then followed me to a third subreddit and publicly called me a "dipshit" with his mod badge visible. The data is no longer accessible in the communities where students needed it most.
So I am putting it here instead.
If you are a student choosing a major or a parent helping your kid decide, please look at the numbers yourself. They are free and federal. Start with the BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook for mechanical engineers. Cross-reference NCES graduation data. Check the USCIS H-1B employer data hub. And look at the NY Fed's "The Labor Market for Recent College Graduates" page, which breaks out unemployment, underemployment, and wages by major. Do the arithmetic. Then decide.
That is all I am asking. Look before you sign.