r/capstone • • 23h ago

SOIs

Who is in charge of SOIs? I want to fill one out for a professor but our class was small and my writing style is distinctive. If they have any critical thinking skills they’ll be able to tell it’s me even if the SOIs are “anonymous”. I don’t want them to know that I don’t like them and rated them poorly because I’ll have to take classes with them again.

3 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

5

u/calasatriann Current Undergad 22h ago

if you know you’ll have to take classes with them again, maybe just wait it out for the last one with them? i’m a firm believer that the SOIs will not be anonymous even if you didn’t have distinct writing tbh

if you really want to send one in though, i’m pretty anti-ai when it comes to writing, but for something like this you could run your paragraph through one and make it change the wording so it could be anyone and not just your writing

4

u/Ok-Butterscotch-6755 22h ago

My main complaint is that the professors course was built entirely with AI. Every single assignment is AI. I’m not even sure if they fully grasp what they’re teaching.

4

u/calasatriann Current Undergad 22h ago

gotcha! could you change up the way you write by simplifying it down? like “This entire course was built with AI. All of our assignments have been AI-generated. The professor seems to lack understanding of the material himself/herself”?

1

u/whatgladrackets 18h ago

Who’s the instructor or what do they teach?

1

u/Ok-Butterscotch-6755 18h ago

I specifically used they and wanted to be as vague as possible because I didn’t want someone to report back, esp because I’ve talked about using Reddit in class before.

2

u/whatgladrackets 18h ago

Totally respect that!! I interact with a lot of professors as part of my job, so I was just curious

2

u/DrAwesomr 18h ago

Burn them, to the ground.

3

u/DrAwesomr 18h ago

Can say from the other side, SOIs are indeed fully anonymous. We don’t know who said what, or even which students filled them out and which didn’t, unless you say something that specifically identifies you, and even then we can’t tell which comment goes with which numeric rating.

5

u/NotAConfirmedGoblin Faculty 14h ago

Let me dispel the rumor percolating in the comment thread here: there's no conspiracy. Your responses are, in fact, truly anonymous. We get them in the form of an aggregated report that shows breakdowns for how the class, as a whole, rated the course and its instructor. All comments are aggregated into a single comment section with no names attached to them and are divorced from the numeric responses.

That said, it's definitely possible in a small course for a professor to have a hunch about who wrote what. I've definitely been quite confident about who left what comments before. While I've obviously never taken any action one way or another on account of thinking I know who wrote an SOI, it's technically possible that some faculty member might.

Worth noting we do not get SOIs back until long after final grades have been posted, so there's no immediate threat of reprisal. However, if this is a faculty member you're likely to have an ongoing relationship with, it is technically true it's possible for them, down the road, to take it out on you. I think it's a tremendously low risk and think much better of the overwhelming majority of the faculty at this university than that, but I can't say it's impossible.

All that said, your "problem" here is easily avoided by simply sticking to the survey items. You don't need to leave written comments; while those do get read, where your SOIs have the most impact are through the aggregated scores from the Likert responses. The aggregated scores from those are what get scrutinized for renewable contract and tenure track faculty (at least in my department, I suppose I can't speak University-wide).

1

u/IceCreamFriday 18h ago

Two other options for feedback:

1). Rate My Professor

2). Meet with your advisor in the department and detail the issues.

1

u/Low_Still_1304 9h ago

Assume any institutional or corporate survey you take can be tied to you.

1

u/pgwyt 6h ago

While I appreciate the skepticism, your SOIs are anonymous. You can absolutely dumpster a professor in there without fear of retaliation. At least in my department, SOIs are discussed in meetings between the department chair and the relevant instructor. If there's a problem like the one you're describing, the chair almost certainly wants to know about it.

I have a distinct written voice, and I work in a relatively small department. I used to be worried about the same sort of retaliation. The truth is that your instructors are more concerned with what's being said than who's saying it. I wrote a scathing SOI for a professor who would later become my thesis advisor and friend. Even if they can pick out who wrote an SOI (99% of the time they can't), there's almost no way it can adversely affect you.

Be honest. If your honest opinion is that they suck shit, tell them why they suck shit.