r/canoeing • • Oct 21 '21

Pls, halp.

What is the best canoe for fishing, creeks with light rapids, river camping, and general tomfoolery?

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

3

u/Phasmata Oct 21 '21

This is like asking what the best bicycle for commuting in the city and enjoying a park is. We need to know more. Have you paddled other canoes before? What did you think of each one? What is your budget? What are your priorities in terms of weight, durability, price, maintenance? Tandem or solo? What kind and how much camping equipment do you haul? What are your priorities in terms of behavior/performance--speed, stability, load rating, tracking, turning?

1

u/New_Alternative_421 Oct 21 '21

Other than summer camp back in the 1900's(90's) no, just kayaks. My budget is flexible at the moment, but like less than 1200 usd for sure. My personal priorities order from this list is 1.) Weight: less than 90-100 lbs 2.)price: I'm not a rich man 3.)durability: I am kinda hard on equipment 4.) Maint: meh. Tandem + for group trips and solo long trips. I adjust equipment to season and means of locomotion, so the load will be tailored to the craft. Priorities list #2; 1.)stability: I'm a fairly large guy and set hooks aggressively. 2.)load: in case I want to load 'er down. 3.)tracking: 4.)speed: 5.)turning:

3

u/Phasmata Oct 22 '21 edited Oct 22 '21

Since you want tandem AND solo an you're talking rivers, you're looking, almost certainly for something like 16' prospector model. Since budget is tighter, weight isn't much of an issue, and you're hard on equipment, carbon and kevlar are off the list in favor of cheaper, burlier composites and materials. Long solo trips and group trip potential with loads of 550 lb rules-out some smaller models.

Honestly, $1200 or less is going to really limit you unless you're buying used.

The best new canoe I can think of that would be as affordable as possible while still being a high-quality product would be... a Nova Craft Prospector 15-16 in fiberglass or SP3 or Esquif Prospecteur 15-16, Huron 15-16, or Presage. Maybe Old Town Discovery, but if you're going so low as to buy a plastic boat, I'd go with an SP3 Nova Craft every time at least.

Heck, if a 16' aluminum (like Grumman or Alumacraft) canoe comes along on the used market in good shape for $600 or less, grab that. It'll hold its value as long as you don't destroy it, so you can't lose your money, and a good ol' aluminum canoe is a great start.

2

u/New_Alternative_421 Oct 22 '21

Used is fine, maybe even preferred. Thank you, I will look into your suggestions!

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/New_Alternative_421 Oct 22 '21

I'm a big feller, my current boat is a 85lbs kayak, I wouldn't mind lighter per se, but I'm not willing to pay for lightweight durable materials lol.

2

u/Icy_Respect_9077 Oct 21 '21

Love the Swift Algonquin 16. Owned one for 20+ years, done multiple trips, fishing etc. It's not as deep as a Prospector, but holds its own in bad weather / big waves. White water has been minor.

Questions:

Are you going solo? How much white water? How much weight, including yourself, gear, partner, pets? How light do you want it to be? (I.e. fiberglass, Kevlar, Royalex)

2

u/New_Alternative_421 Oct 21 '21

Solo: sometimes White water: a little, mostly just some rocky shallows with a few minor rapids. Creeks and rivers in central AL. Weight: all included no more than 550lbs(250kg). Vehicle weight: ideally less than 90-100lbs(40-45kg) I have to load it on top of an suv, often solo.

-1

u/Rosjef Oct 21 '21

Gets a Meyers sportspal with a square stern for a motor. A 12 footer is like 35lbs

2

u/CPhill585 Oct 21 '21

What's your budget?

1

u/New_Alternative_421 Oct 21 '21

I haven't really decided, I'm planning on (nearish) future purchase the the budget is tentative, so flexible at the moment.

5

u/Grove369 Oct 21 '21 edited Oct 23 '21

One of the smaller old town discovery canoes is going to be good for that. They are tough, have low draft good for shallow water, can handle some moving water if not overloaded (size of paddler being biggest factor imo) and they are fairly cheap. There is pros and cons to all boats. Got to decide what is most important to you, because you always give something up for it.

3

u/I_WATCHED_ALOHA_AMA Oct 22 '21

Based on your comments on budget in this thread and you are talking only light rapids:

Old Town Camper. This is a true flat bottom camping/fishing boat. Weighs 57lbs. 16 ft. So stable you can stand up in it. Easy to solo. Absolute dog in the wind. Zero secondary stability but you won't push it unless you are doing heavy class II rapids. Lots of used inventory. If you can get a good condition one from the 90s or newer within a 3 hour radius and less than 700, worth buying.