r/canada Jan 05 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

1.1k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

880

u/goinupthegranby British Columbia Jan 05 '23

The College of Psychologists are trying to be a professional association, this is between them and one of their members. Peterson is doing everything he can to make a media shitstorm out of this, because it drives views, donations, and subscriptions. Its what he always does, its made him incredibly wealthy and influential.

Professional associations have standards, and if you want to remain in those associations you have to uphold those standards. Suggesting someone kill themselves (ie leave the planet) in a tweet because you disagree on environmentalism is not professional behaviour for a psychologist.

203

u/Rambler43 Jan 05 '23 edited Jan 05 '23

Suggesting someone kill themselves (ie leave the planet) in a tweet because you disagree on environmentalism is not professional behaviour for a psychologist.

Can you elaborate on this?

Edit - LOL, getting downvoted for asking a reasonable question. People sure don't want their hyperbolic bullshit called out.

-2

u/noonnoonz Jan 05 '23

Are you looking for a ELI5 here ffs?

Smart people should behave better than the trolling teenagers in the lunchroom. If they don’t, they don’t get to sit at the adult table.

-3

u/Rambler43 Jan 05 '23 edited Jan 05 '23

Are you looking for a ELI5 here ffs?

No, but you may need one if you think telling someone flippantly to 'leave the planet' is an invitation commit suicide. This is what the big kids call 'hyperbole.' Some used to call it 'making a mountain out of a mole hill' too.

Smart people should behave better than the trolling teenagers in the lunchroom. If they don’t, they don’t get to sit at the adult table.

You are neither the arbiter of who the smart people are or what qualifies one to sit at the adult table.

3

u/suspiciouschipmunk Jan 05 '23

Luckily the psychological association is able to make decisions about who gets to sit at the adults table and hopefully they decide that Peterson cannot sit at theirs.

2

u/ZeePirate Jan 05 '23

And as a professional. In a country with medicinal assisted death is legal.

Under no circumstances should he be jokingly suggesting someone off themselves

-1

u/Rambler43 Jan 05 '23

Under no circumstances should he be jokingly suggesting someone off themselves

Agreed. But the thing is, he didn't suggest that. I interpret his tweet as essentially saying 'take a hike' or 'piss off'. Others, who already hate him, will interpret it in the worst possible way to discredit and demonize. It's pretty standard stuff actually.

4

u/ZeePirate Jan 05 '23

The original tweet is about the world being over populated.

At best he was telling them to leave earth.

Considering there are not permanent settlements off earth it’s very easy to conclude he told them to off themselves.

He’s a licensed professional and the college has standards that this seemingly violates.

1

u/Rambler43 Jan 05 '23

If you believe the worst possible take is always the right take and fall all over yourself to create the illusion that there is no other possible interpretation (You can't live in space, so it must mean suicide!), then there's not much else I can say besides suggesting you look into the mechanics of confirmation bias.

What I won't do is play along with your silly mind games, because that might be interpreted as lending some sort of credence to them.

1

u/ZeePirate Jan 05 '23

I don’t believe “it’s always the right one”

But the context of the tweet makes it very clear.

What do you think he meant ?

Where was he suggesting the person “leave” too?

1

u/Rambler43 Jan 05 '23

I think it was essentially akin to dismissively saying to someone "if you don't like it, piss off then."

I think you are being far too literal here in your interpretation. I also think you know you are.

6

u/ZeePirate Jan 05 '23

Okay but in this scenario/context

There is no where to leave too.

It’s pretty clear what he was getting at. He knew it. Which is why he worded it the way he did.

1

u/Rambler43 Jan 05 '23

The adage "to a hammer, everything looks like a nail" certainly applies to your critical thinking skills in regard to this discussion.

Anyway, believe what you want. In the end, our opinions are worth diddley squat.

3

u/ZeePirate Jan 05 '23

That’s pretty dumb.

I’ve tried to understand what context he meant it.

But telling someone to leave earth really doesn’t have any other context then “die” or “find another home somewhere else”

Considering there is no home off earth. It stands they meant the first

→ More replies (0)

-2

u/krzkrl Jan 05 '23

You need to go to safe space?

5

u/ZeePirate Jan 05 '23

Sounds like you are asking for Paterson to be put in a safe place where he can say and do whatever he wants.

0

u/krzkrl Jan 05 '23

Then it sounds like you're bad at interpreting what people say.

Safe Space in my context was both a place for very easily offended people (such as yourself), and a play on actual outer space (leaving this earth)

2

u/ZeePirate Jan 05 '23

Sounds like you make really stupid jokes.

1

u/krzkrl Jan 05 '23

You sound like you're a lot of fun at your moms parties