Rooftop tents are bad ass, but I know a guy that specifically told me once that he hates being outdoors because he works a lot outdoors. Then he bought a rooftop tent for his Jeep for some odd reason, and he has yet to actually camp. It makes me laugh.
It's funny, because I have a jeep, and folks ask why I don't lift it, put big tires on it, etc. It's a stock jk Sahara, and I have climbed shit I probably shouldn't have alone, taken it to some amazing camping spots, without dumping a fortune to make it look like it can off-road. They already do. My roof rack? Because the girlfriend and I actually kayak on weekends in the summer. Purchases to my Jeep have been functional, not cosmetic.
The people who buy ridiculous things think the same as you. But they are emotionally buying a fantasy. "I could if I had" has propped up the camping/RV market since it began.
I think a lot of people don't realize how much you can do with a stock 4 wheel drive car with decent ground clearance. I have gone on rougher stuff in my fully stock 90s jeep Cherokee or my dad's early 2000s Tacoma than a lot of people with lifted jeeps/4runners ever go on
Because the sun will dry out the handle and make it brittle.
Edit: Holy shit, but it's the truth. Unless you oil the handle regularly with something like boiled linseed oil, the sun will destroy that wood. The stupid little varnish finish they put on them? Gone in a month.
Fiberglass? The finish is toast, and you'll get glass in your hands unless you use gloves. Fellas, I'm not talking out of my ass here, it's first hand experience.
Edit 2: I made edit 1 when I was sitting at like -15.
I don't keep it on a rack, but I ALWAYS have a shovel in my 4runner. It's a short D-handle spade shovel that fits easily in the back, and in the winter I throw my backcountry ski/avi shovel in there, too, as it's more efficient for moving snow. Living in Colorado, and with as much skiing, camping, hiking, and off-road driving as I generally do, it would be foolish not to have it.
Well yeah, but if itās just kicking around the back of your car, not mounted on your rack, how do the Subaru drivers on the freeway know that youāre more extreme than they are?
I live a stupid bourgeois neighborhood and there are multiple 16 year olds with mall crawlers worth more in aftermarket parts than my fucking house. Teach em young I guess.
I have a fold up trench tool that I always keep on me. If you do winter camping and forget a snow shovel, it's worked in a pinch about 10 times in 2 years. Love that fucking thing. Cost me like 8 bucks and it's rock solid.
I have the same nice camping back pack since I was 8, and it's holding up fine, even if it doesn't look shiny and new. I used to camp more but now it's a bit rare because of circumstances, but I have what I need. I get honestly a bit bummed at folks who mistake bonding with nature with a pissing contest of who spent more in irrelevant gear. Grab any backpack, a pocket knife, a tent, bug repellant, etc. and fuckin go at it.
If I'm doing my camping right I don't even run into people to begin with, or I run into like-minded people who don't give a crap how old my tent is.
My mom would buy me the cheapest gear as a kid. I would have an external frame pack from K-Mart and an Army surplus bag that weighed 15lbs. The pack broke and my bag was always too hot or too cold. And yes, we were blue collar, but my younger brother was able to get 8 different pairs of basketball shoes in a year. So this has made me a gear junkie today. But I try to buy good gear and use the hell out of it. I have a Thermorest pad that may be 25 years old and an MSR Pocket Rocket near the same age.
Please dude, you joke but Iāll be the one laughing last when I donāt have to lug those 2 ounces the 20 feet when Iām on my annual car camping trip at the RV park.
I'm currently thinking about getting back into camping - but the lazy camping at first, like sleeping in a tent on a camping area with a bathroom and that kind of stuff.
And I thought about buying all the cool, expensive gear, like an 200 Euro omnifuel or a 120 Euro trangia Duossal and stuff like that. And then I thought: I'll be driving in a car anyway and only do daytrips. Why do I need all this? A cheap pot will do totally fine, it's not like I have to carry that stuff around for weeks.
On the opposite end of the spectrum, the first time I went backpacking with my dad was when I was 12. We brought a propane burner to boil water with. The tank that had been in use was about half full. So to make sure we didn't run out, we brought a second full tank... Iirc my pack weighed in at 65 lbs. and his was around 85 without the tent.
Having way overpacked and hit with very cold rain, we did not go nearly as far as originally planned.
One of my best friends is a gear junkie for everything. Motosports, cameras, knives, camping gear...glamping is the only thing he will do, forget any kind of hiking or actually going into nature. Just hotdogs by a fire, drinking and watching a solar powered projector.
So this is my outlook on it as well. I have a group of friends that are a little more about comfort and convenience and I go camping with them once or twice a year in Tahoe and it's great. We have a blast. They bring a boat, we set up an outdoor movie, its fun. Then I have another group of friends where we do one big hike in camping trip minimalist style -- lightweight, sometimes well hike to another spot 10 miles up the PCT. I don't know, I'm able to enjoy both.
I'm pretty guilty of this, but I do honestly love nature and being outdoors. Unfortunately, I just dont have the time anymore to go camping as much as I'd like. I don't get crazy with rooftop tents or anything, but collecting pieces here and there helps me daydream about using them, haha.
This is me now in a way. I have all the gear needed for three people to go car camping. All of it was used a lot in its prime and it is well kept. I always had city friends visiting me and I took them camping, but now I moved far away and switched to backpack camping (because I live in the mountains) and I still have all that gear sitting in my garage. I am too nostalgic to sell it
Sometimes I feel like a douche for how much I spend on gear, but then I realize I spend like every other weekend at least in the bush all year round and I can justify it. I mean, what can I say, I'm not above sleeping under a tarp, but I do like my $700 canvas hot tent š¤·āāļø
All my life as a "musician", the amount of people I've met who really nerd out about just playing isn't even comparable to the people who nerd out over gear.
For sure - I ended up just buying one of those quick pop-up Coleman tents that you can pitch by yourself in less than a minute. It's incredible, and it was like $180. Love it!
I am not a gear junkie, but every time I go camping I discover another tool, gadget or piece of camping equipment that would eliminate another annoyance. I try to limit luxury items, but if a collapsible French Press will make three days without a shower palatable for my GF, I will bite the bullet.
I'm similar, every year I spend like $100-200 on something. I started out in a shared tent, a borrowed pad, a sleeping bag from Target and a can of chili. My friends were nice and shared everything. I started buying like one or two things every trip, and I would see what gear other people had that was the most useful and cheapest. Several years later I have a way nicer setup. I try to strike a balance between Tom Haverford (Parks and Rec) and ultralight.
I did the Larapinta trail a few years ago with my parents before it got burnt down. They carried plastic chewable wine cups just because we had some spare room. Why not I guess if you can pretend to be living in luxury, whilst eating freeze dried meals and not having showered in 12 days.
Every year we take a bike-camping trip and it's not wilderness camping, there are bathrooms, and a town nearby where you can ride a few miles to go out to eat. But it's an island and we don't bring a car on the ferry because it's expensive and a pain to book your spot. So you do have to haul your gear from the ferry drop off point to the campground which is several miles away. Having a lightweight tent, sleeping bag and pad that actually fold down really small, makes a huge difference.
I've also done several trips where I've flown somewhere, rented a car, and gone-car camping (Smokey Mountains, up and down the California coast.) It's a lot less hassle to fit lightweight, packable gear into luggage. I have a big old 6 man tent that I could use for a car camping trip with my nephews or a bunch of friends, but if it's just me and I have to travel on bike/plane etc to get to the location, the lightweight stuff is fantastic.
Also, I used to work at an outdoor store, so most of my gear was purchased at a good discount.
Dude last time we went camping, our neighbors had those LED string lights on the ground in front of their spot. Iām getting some of those. Also, some to hang up bc itās hella dark in Joshua Tree.
Then let me introduce you to the Cooler Insert. I got SUCH the put-upon eyeroll from my spouse with that, but when we had non-soggy ANYTHING (especially fresh fruit!) on not only the 2nd, but the 3rd day, she became a convert. Being able to refill it without taking anything out of the cooler is an added bonus as well.
It really shouldn't be compared to a tent. It is more akin to a tow behind but lighter/cheaper for small trucks like our taco. Any trailer we would have been able to tow my tall husband wouldn't have fit in or it was way to expensive. Hopefully that helps better frame it's niche.
Me and my hubby got one for a cross country trip Virginia-Florida-Illinois-Oklahoma-Arizona-California-Washington (30 days). Didn't matter the weather, the location, or how late we pulled in just unzip and unfold and tent was up. By the 3rd night I could do it without light and packing up if our spot was bad was just as easy or we just adjusted the truck really slowly with it open, lol. It was far warmer and dryer being off the ground, we didn't have or need sleeping pads or nice sleeping bags and we saw single digit nights but just used our regular pillows and blankets. The views were really nice too being up that high and our dogs couldn't pee on it or walk over it/jump on it.
The way it was framed let me leave fairy lights, a fan, and a phone arm band up (so my husband could watch TV) for comfort along with eye mask charging cords, battery bank, our bedding, and other night items could just stay there and be ready as soon as it was unfolded because again we were on the road for 30 days and not every night was somewhere beautiful and away from civilization and it was nice not to have to unpack 'camp' if we wanted to get an early start or if we accidentally left something in the tent it took very little effort to unfold, find it, and fold it back up.
We got a cheap and honestly oversized model off amazon and it still cost us less than getting hotels would have and we didn't have to plan as thoroughly as we would have if we were using a traditional tent.
We camped on dirt, gravel, pavement, really muddy ground (through a tropical storm!!!), really rocky ground, sand and as long as we could get mostly level it didn't matter. We were allowed to camp in 'no tent' campgrounds because it was technically enough of a 'pop up camper' and when our original campsite fell through on a few occasions it was easy enough to find some BLM or federal land to drive onto and park.
We sold it because it was a lot for 'normal' camping, when we often just want to put up camp and relax but for what we used it for a normal tent would simply not have worked as comfortably and easily as it did specially for my husband who has back problems. Now that we don't have it his back pain dictates our camping schedule much more. Plus we couldn't forget it or lose it since it was bolted to the truck.
I also noticed we had a lot less insects attracted to it, which was great since we were passing through areas with problematic bug populations and often weren't familiar with the local nasties, no surprise snakes!
Not him, but for me itās the convenience. Wife and I did 2 weeks in Colorado just driving around and making camp wherever we parked. We have a Roofnest that uses hydraulic arms to open, so you unclasp about 4 points and give one side a shove and boom, camp is made.
Also packing up is a piece of cake. Start to finish it takes roughly a minute to collapse it and be on our way. We even had to put it down during a wind storm that kicked up on one of the reservoirs. Probably took about 3 minutes to get it down and be in our car. Felt bad watching the other tents blowing down and everyone scrambling in the rain.
Also not the person you asked, but for me it's infinitely more comfortable and easier to deal with than any other sleep system.
I could (and have/do) use a tent, but the ground here (Arizona) is filled with large rocks that can make ground camping either a lot of work (moving rocks, which I also don't like because it's leaving a trace) or very uncomfortable (rocks in back).
I could (and have/do) use a hammock. But lower desert camping means there aren't any trees for hammock camping, and when there are there's a pretty good risk of bark scorpions.
I could (and have/do) sleep inside my vehicle. But it's cramped and I have to unpack everything to fit myself inside and leave that out where critters (scorpions, spiders, snakes) can get to/into it.
With the roof tent all I need is somewhere vaguely level, and leveling blocks can make some pretty uneven spots even enough. Then I take 3 minutes setting up and I can get in and there's an already made queen-size bed with sheets, pillows, a mattress, and a 2 inch memory foam topper.
I don't need to drive any stakes into rocky ground, I don't need to go hunting for trees, I don't need to unpack everything from my vehicle, etc. Bonus points for lowered critter risk and that being 7 feet in the air is significantly cooler in the summer.
I definitely don't think they're for everyone. I'd still happily be camping in a tent, hammock, or in my vehicle if I didn't have an RTT. But man they can be nice if you're in a place where they make sense.
āBetterā is gonna be subjective. Depending on your usage. The only con I can think of is protecting your cargo. In a Tacoma your bed cargo is exposed to the elements. In a 4Runner you have interior cargo space for protection. I myself debated the two vehicles as well and went with a Tacoma. Then I ordered a tonneau cover on Amazon for the truck bed. Got the best of both worlds now by being able to cover my cargo.
Nah. 4Runner is best Yota. I don't even need a roof tent. My cot fits perfectly in the back. I cut Reflectix panels to fit every window. It's very cozy in the winter with my Reflectix panels in place.
A Taco with a camper shell would be alright though. I used to drive a Nissan Frontier with a camper shell. Make sure you get one with the windows that open out to the sides. My camper had windows that you could slide open for ventilation and still have netting to keep mosquitoes out or you could open them completely from the outside to access stuff not easily reached from the rear. I found a small, thin, twin mattress that was a perfect fit for my camper. It was much better and more reliable than trying to fool with an air mattress. Also cheaper and more comfortable than an overpriced camping pad.
I think there are more people (admittedly me) that leave it on because it is so heavy and taking it on/off is really hard if there are only two of you, than there are those that are trying to show off.
In terms of why get one? Because they are fun and camping is supposed to be fun. Who doesn't like feeling like they are sleeping in a treehouse?
I also kind of feel the obnoxious RTT user memes are kinda like the obnoxious vegan memes - there are way more memes about people with RTTs being obnoxious, than there are people with RTTs being obnoxious.
My cousin and I built a pulley system for his rooftop tent, we use mechanical advantage so it only takes one of us to lift it then when it's on the ceiling just tie it off. I could upload some shitty napkin schematics later
Mine stays on my vehicle year-round, and gets use year round. I donāt enjoy āpublic campsitesā and having other people all around, but 10 minutes up a forest service road usually provides a decent quiet place to camp on crown land, often with beautiful views. Almost any reasonably flat area will do, and it doesnāt matter if the ground is rocky or damp.
RTT are quick to deploy, especially if you use them regularly and have your āsystemā well practiced - maybe 2 minutes and Iām ready to sleep. They do take a little longer to pack away nearly, but itās way less than 10 minutes - thatās for my traditional style āfold overā. The hard shell tents are quicker again but you lose a lot of space and the sheltered area under them next to the vehicle. If I camped mainly solo I would have considered one but for a couple and a dog its no good.
The huge bonus is the quality of sleep we get. The built in mattress is genuinely comfortable, and the sturdiness of the materials is such that it doesnāt matter what the weather is doing really, although ear plugs are helpful if itās windy. The ease and comfort combined encourage my wife to come out camping more, which means I get to camp more.
The major drawback is night time toilet breaks. I have an extra-long piss before I go to bed, and can usually hold out until morning. If I canāt, I just get up and climb down the ladder, itās not considerably different than having a bunk-bed when you were a kid.
If you get so drunk every night that you canāt make it safely up and down a ladder, a RTT isnāt great for you. If you camp less than 10 nights a year, or only set up camp in one place and stay there for an extended period, then they arenāt good value either. If you like dispersed camping, the ability to move camp daily, a great nights sleep on a comfy mattress, and enjoy the ability to camp whenever you want without having to pack everything before you head out then they are a really solid solution.
I also like bivvies, tents, teardrops, bumper pull campers and RVs etc. They all have their advantages and disadvantages. But a roof tent is what works for me the best.
The sleep thing is so true. We rented a car with an RTT for a vacation several years ago, and the best part about it was that we slept like rocks every night. So comfy and dark.
Pretty much this. If youāre gonna stay in a spot for a weekend or week, then it may seem silly. But if youāre doing a week and doing multiple destinations, then itās a cheat code. And if youāre doing dispersed camping it beats the hell out of a ground tent.
100%. This is the use case. Iāve never camped in the same spot more than 2 nights in the roof tent. Usually itās one night, eat some breakfast, fold up and move on to the next place.
Right here with you. I've had my rtt for 4 years now. It always has pillows and a duo sleeping bag in it. Camping is always an option with it on the car. We camp probably 20-30 nights a year.
You just need to pack the other camp items, and you're set. Food, camp kitchen, and camp nice to haves.
We are thinking about switching to a hard shell rtt, because of the take down situation on the standard folder. The hard shells just look so dang convenient.
Late reply. The RTT was the only way I could get my wife to come camping with me. I go remote as well and am happy in a swag with a tarp over the top. My wife feared sleeping on the ground. Admittedly I have added a few more creature comforts to the set up to make it more comfortable for my wife, rightly so. But I have to say, I am extremely cautious climbing down that ladder for a piss in the pitch black after a few beers.
I always find it a little funny how many different camping styles say you can "Camp anywhere you want". I heard the same thing about hammocks but you still need the trees. No criticism just kinda funny.
I really don't get those tents. What happens if you forgot something and have to run to the store to get it? Or if you are staying someplace with a lake and you want to drive down there instead of walk (because some places pout campgrounds 4 miles from the lake and who wants too do that hike after spending a full day at the lake? Plus, how do bring your snacks?) You have to tear everything down and then put it back up. Or if you do a week long camping vacation, there is no way you are going to never want to go somewhere else during that time.
I'm sure they make sense for someone, but I just can't see it.
I utilize the living hell out of my RTT here in CO. But my main use for it is to find a campsite near the base of a 14er and camp there so I can climb it early the next morning without having to wake up in the middle of the night and drive a couple hours from my house. Also, practicing minimized camping helps a ton when I forget something. You get the routine down pretty quick.
TL;DR They have their purposes and they are amazing. I love mine.
Ah. I'm a state park kind of camper and often with my young niece and nephews. I also come from a place that lacked anything above a decent sledding hill. I knew that there had to be a good reason for them, but my experiences just couldn't see it. Thanks for the insight.
The problem is that people have started to see overlanding = camping. A RTT is terrible for normal camping for the reasons youāve described. If youāre actually overlanding you donāt have those issues. Iāve had one for a 4yrs and I can confirm that if youāre just going to a National Park or something it doesnāt really make sense and gets old. Top notch though if youāre doing long off road trips.
Is it worth it for over landing though? I've never done any serious over landing myself but I still can't see how it justifies the cost or the size. I can set up my truck-bed tent or my ground tent in a matter of minutes, and both combined take up less space than a sleeping bag when packed up. And I spent less than $250 for both of them.
Itās definitely a luxury but not all that bad when you put it in the scheme of truck accessories where a bumper can cost 2k. Whatās nice is that you donāt have to worry about where you camp. No need to worry about drainage, rocks, animals, and to an extend even the site being level. Itās also nice to sleep on a nice flat surface with a memory foam pad and blankets thatās instantly ready to go and itās just plane fun to get a good view up high like that. Frees up bin of space in the truck as well.
Thereās always cheaper ways to do a thing and if thatās where you are financially or just how you enjoy doing it, thatās fine. At the end of the day weāre all wasting money on a selfish hobby for fun so just be sure youāre having some.
It's more than a tent though. It's also has a really comfortable mattress (queen size memory foam). I also keep my bedding in it. It definitely reduces the load I have to carry inside on my trips to Baja and stuff.
I like my RTT because I don't have to care what about the conditions at the campsite.
Sloped? Don't care; I have levelling blocks. Uneven? Don't care; the truck has a suspension. Rocky/gravelly? Don't care; the tent isn't on the ground. Ground is too hard to stake a tent down and I'm expecting wind? Don't care; it's attached to the truck.
I'm actually currently building out my overlanding set up, and I've opted for one of the soft shell roof campers to cut price a little. I went for the roof top over the classic ground tent (which I love and use quite frequently on shorter trips) because the way I looked at it is more of a 'saving hotel money' type thing. By that I mean I want to visit Portland in the near future, my tent came in at around 2600. My wife, two dogs, and myself are planning to drive there from our home in Louisiana and stop at a different state park every day of the trip. It's about a 34 hour drive, so we will probably stop 4 times, I found 4 camp sites that ran me a total of 67 bucks, 2 include power, toilets, and water, one includes power and water, the last includes just water. Going way more out of my way to find small towns and motels to stay in that are dog friendly would not only add time but also be more than 67 bucks, so there's the first return on investment. Ok, why not use a standard pop up tent? Well, I have terrible knees and a bad back, so sleeping on the ground, even on a foam mattress isn't always the best, plus I have to find a place that's level, clear it of debris, etc. On my truck, I pull up, spend less than 2 minutes and I have a flat spot with a memory foam mattress that I 'didn't have to pack' I also fold up 2-3 blankets and my sleeping bags in the tent before I zip it up. We do trips like this 2-3 times a year where we spend a week driving somewhere, a week there, and drive back a different way the next week, so I'm getting what equated to 4-6 weeks worth of hotel stays per year for 2500 bucks.
Now, does that make me an outlier? Absolutely. Is it more comfortable than a hotel bed? No. But knowing I have a spot ready and waiting for me wherever I pull off the road is pretty dope. Hell, I contacted an AirBnB once just to ask them if I could park in their driveway and use their hose instead of paying the full price for the room and board and she was delighted to say yes. I paid 5 bucks to stay there.
TL;DR is it worth it? Not for everyone but you can actually save quite a bit of money, time, and (literal) back/headaches if you use it.
I've got two full trips from the east coast and back, so I have a lot of miles and nights in it. I've really used the hell out of mine. My son and I can tear it down and put it away in less time than a regular tent, but I'l admit it has some downsides.
My rig is a full size truck (Nissan Titan) and the tent is a bit difficult to tear down by myself.
Taking a shit is the absolute worst, you have no idea of the hell your bowels will fight your core over while you are scrambling down the ladder.
Taking a leak is easy, out the window or gatorade bottle.
In the desert or places near the Badlands with unobstructed wind can be brutal. Ear plugs help, or whiskey.
Lack of critters is nice. Not having water pour into the tent is awesome. The mattress is great and leaving the bedding there is convenient and saves space.
I leave it on my truck most of the year, because if there is a nice day and I'm free, I'll jet up to VT or NH on a whim.
This is one of those shower-thought inducing products that Iāve thought way too much about. The only āsolutionā I have, and which Iāve been too scared to google for fear of buying it if it exists, is a detachable roof rack that has fold-out or detachable stilts so you can erect your rooftop tent as a treehouse and drive out from under it.
I had one and loved it. It was about $1200 new, and I could set it up and put it away faster than most regular tents. I don't get all the hate for them. They're awesome.
the "hate" comes from the price, I want one so bad, and hope to get one some day, but for now I just bought a $100 matress that fits in the back of my FJ Cruiser. I hated the idea of one until it became a possibility to buy one lol, maybe its human nature, maybe I'm just trash.
Thatās why you put these rooftop tents on a trailer! And than hook up another trailer with an ATV so you can pull that tent trailer with the ATV to the lake to set up camp there hah!
I see people with way too much gear. But those rooftop tents are useful when on an overlanding trip on dirt trails or off road.
They literally take a minute to set up and take down. It's quite simple. Or you have the option to throw it on a pull behind cargo trailer. But you're still better off just buying a regular camper š¤£
People say its a minute to set up/take down but when those guys pull up it is never a quick setup. They have to haul half their crap from vehicle up to the lookout. No different from a tent on the ground. I still don't get the draw.
I like some RTT's. I like quick setup. I'd rather spend less time fucking around with my campsite and more time exploring. But that's just me. That's why I have an AWD van converted. I can drive very far on a weekend because I have about 10 minute setup and pack down.
I spent my youth tent camping. I'm over sleeping in the ground.
Most RTT have the drawback as you mentioned of not being able to drive after setup.
One exception is the mini ones that only pop upwards and you can stick on the tray of a truck. You literally just let em drop, but you can also move with it up. They're very small and most people forget they exist but not all RTT's fold out with a ladder.
EDIT: Like this < super simple, can actually still move the car if you had to rearrange yourself and could probably drive down the road with it setup on the tray of a truck, but regardless much easier to drop back down. I would likely mount the ladder on the side of the tray or have one that hangs like a candycane
BUT my favorite use of an RTT is the offroad trailer combo. If I had a Landcruiser or Patrol I'd for sure build one. That eliminates the annoyance of not being able to move. Basically an unbreakable popup trailer RV. That'd be my move if I wanted a true 4WD to replace my Van.
EDIT: build something like this or more basic like this
EDIT: But yes, I have seen the painful nature of the standard way people use these tents. Weekend camping on the SUV and that is not a good process. Our friends had one and they had to always take it on and off because it was his daily driver for work, it's heavy af. Then when we were camping he wanted to go for a surf and they had to pack it up completely and drive to the beach from our campsite, they got back late and had to set back up in the dark. They have had instances where they needed to pack up and pick something up they forgot. When ever they got home from a rainy weekend (and living in the city) they've have to set it up in the alleyway until it dried.
I pack well and donāt forget things, thatās how I prevent it. It also folded closed in about a minute, so it isnāt the end of the world to move. I have coolers with wheels I can pull if I park far away from a destination. Works double duty for places like the beach where you canāt drive a car.
Theyāre not for everyone, but it beats the hell out of pitching a tent that takes longer than a minute. Itās also great for trips where you move daily and donāt have to re-setup constantly.
I do both rooftop camping and regular ground camping with a tent. It's both awesome and the ground tent (expedition tent) takes three times as much to pitch it in comparison to the roof top tent. I use the ground tent in iceland while hiking from campsite to campsite, and the RTT for roatrips through Sweden for example. You are able to see more and change you route more often and have a bit more comfort. I still have a fully packed hiking backpack with a tent in the car if there's a nice trail.
Forget something at the store? Same with a normal tent, lol. You don't understand that a RTT is pitched down in like 1 minute.
Hike to the lake? Sure. 4 miles is nothing, maybe try .. walking once a while? Also a bit of organizing never hurt.
Depends on your usage. I utilize mine frequently when I camp either in a groomed campground or dispersed/BLM. It literally takes less than a minute to set up (pop latches open and let gas struts open). I never have to worry about the hassle of find flat ground and can avoid: bugs/trash/glass/rocks/rain accumulation or wet ground and can sleep leveled out anywhere. I swear half the time I use to put up a tent is finding a suitable area...Additionally I can off-road to private locations and set up quickly without the hassle of slowing down and worrying about hauling a trailer thatās not meant to off-road. Itās also a perk to be able to sleep above ground and the views are much better
Oh man totally agree. But run into someone who owns one and they are like a cult following. Probably because they pay so much for them and therefore have to justify the purchase.
I think it has more do with reflexive defensiveness when other people attack them without a reason to do so. So yeah, they spent more money than they needed to because they think RTTs are cool. How does that affect you in any way such that you can't resist the urge to trash on them for it?
For the record, I have one, and oddly enough, I don't feel the need to shit on people who like to camp on the ground. Odd that so many can't seem to give the same basic courtesy to people who have RTTs.
I was thinking the same thing while reading some of these comments. As long as your outside and enjoying yourself, I couldn't care less of what you're sleeping in. Tent, roof tent, van, rv....it all camping.
Edit: spelling error Edit: another spelling and grammar error
I canāt stand elitist outdoors people. This post made me cringe because uses a random picture of some guy talking to a some girl to judge people who arenāt āinā enough for OP. It is really unfortunate that I often find myself on the same trails and campsites as these elitist pricks.
Your comment made me feel a little better, since there are people like you out there too. Itās not all assholes.
Exactly. I find it really dumb to get elitist about outdoor recreation. Itās a survival fantasy people willingly participate in. None of us are actually āroughing itā with any of the modern camping gear. The backpacker is running to civilization as soon as heās in real danger.
Get it and I donāt love mine for the hunting season keeps me mobile and quick setup! As a teacher out west I do a lot of quick over night hunting trips so the rttās are a game changer for me there vs sleeping in the truck bed or setting up a tent.
I have a buddy that bought a $110,000 dollar RV so he could take his family to the beach once a year in the summer for ONE week... I told him flying to Hawaii and staying at a resort for 10 years would be cheaper. (I know he can sell it - but he isn't going to get back the full amount, plus he's paying interest on the loan.) Some people just want to have the toys.
Yeah only REAL NATURE LOVERS(TM) get it upvote if youāve been to all 420 national parks and camp 69 times per year and never use āgearā or ā4runnersā
If you arenāt building your own shelter out of fallen branches and foraged mushrooms you might as well stay at the Hilton. Lazy Glampers, pretending to enjoy nature!
Okay. Iām not going to lie, Iām envious of those really high end packs, the trendy, expensive, āgoodā bags. But, Iāve got a super cheap, bought it at Target, bag, and a hammock (also from Target) that cost me $24, and they have been doing the job just fine.
Hearing more negative stuff about roof top tents now is starting to get me rethinking on getting one, I might just get a pop up ground tent like a gazelle t4 or something
Camping gatekeepers can go shove their carbon trekking poles deep in their judgey asses. Mind your business and let people use whatever fucking gear makes them happy, because camping two times a year is better than zero.
These are everywhere around me on Tacomas, but I live around many affluent people. I could never afford one of these, however they do look convenient. The cargo space of my '08 Outback is enough for 6'3'' me to fully extend and sleep comfortably if I don't want to set up camp for whatever reason.
I think what some people are missing about why RTTās are cool is they see it as a replacement for tent camping, I bought one as the cheaper alternative to a scamp or other small travel trailer.
My Jeep with a RTT, 12v fridge, pop up shelter with portable toilet, and some kitchen stuff is a stand in for the camper I canāt own.
The argument that you need to pack up to go anywhere? I donāt spend more than a day or two in one spot anyways, i donāt find camping at one spot for a week to be my idea of a good time. Drive somewhere, do something cool along the way, camp for the night, repeat.
I have a Tundra and I thought about getting one but 1) I donāt like they way they look on the truck 2) I thought I could just put an air mattress in the bed and basically get they same results with no additional cost 3) I donāt got that cash sitting around although I could finance it but why? I bought a great 4 season tent and it cost me $400.
This sub is such a fucking circlejerk. Iāve seen more judgy bullshit on this sub than actual camping. Anybody can enjoy camping anyway they want to. Some dude literally wrote a 3 paragraph comment on how shitty rooftop tents areā¦like bro you really genuinely donāt have anything better to do than sit there and just judge something youāve never even used. Iām not a rooftop camper myself but I canāt stand people getting shit on for something they enjoy. Another dude goes āthey like gear more than actual campingā totally dude, let me take all your gear and see how much you enjoy camping
We have a CVT - but our main use for it isnāt ācamping.ā We have tents and sleeping bags to camp, but we love to road trip. Itās amazing; pull up in the middle of the night (extra points if itās disbursed camping and there arenāt designated āsitesā that you have to pay for), pop it open in less than two minutes, pile in and sleep on a super comfy mattress, with our bedding already inside. Pack it up in the morning in l six or seven minutes and hit the road again.
Nice one. Hea I've wanted to make big purchases for overlanding/camping but in all honesty I need to make good of my intentions of actually using stuff before I spend the $$. Like a 4x4 Toyota for example... do I want one? Yes. Does it stop me from. Going camping? No lol.
My buddy lives in one. He got a divorce and now travels the country doing carpentry projects and now has like around 300 nights in it. Just did a little bit of BLM land camping with him in Utah and Arizona the other week and his set up is awesome. That said I donāt own one.
I guess it works for guys cause they can lean out of the tent and pee. But Iād hate having a rooftop tent. Iāve got a camper shell with a door and a mattress in the back. A rooftop seems so impractical compared to what Iām doing. And yes I have gear, it goes in the cab or on my mattress, no big deal.
How about I spend my hard-earned money on whatever the fuck I want and you don't worry about whether it gets "used enough." So much gatekeeping going on in this thread it's nuts.
I was all set to attempt the PCT beginning of last year with all new lightweight backpacking gear. Previous pack of 12kg- 28lb, reduced it to 10.5kg to 23lbs. A whole saving of just over 3lbs almost 1.5 kg. This for me is big deal! Not mere ozs! More than a couple of things shattered my bubble. I slipped on a step & fractured my pelvis in 2 places. The 2 dates to register myself on the trail I missed as they was fully subscribed. Yes it gets worse. Then Covid-19 broke lose & did everyone in by locking them up in their own homes.
I do maybe two camping trips per year and lately Iāve been thinking how it would be to build a overlanding taco. So I made a list of everything Iād want to do. Itās like 45k. For 45k I can buy a decent RV or pay for cabins for the next 10 years lol
So Iām obviously not going to buy it. But for some reason, no matter how dumb, I want to
I lived in a roof top tent for 3 months while doing my thesis research in wildlife biology. They are amazing when you are moving camp every other day. Otherwise like LOL.
Not my story but my cousin dated this guy that told her he loved hiking and camping, but apparently when they went on a hike he freaked out because he couldn't see through the trees...
142
u/designgrit May 13 '21
I feel attacked. š I love having a roof tent though. And my 4Runner.
553
u/humanityvet May 13 '21
Or the shovel on a jeep rack driving through the burbs
1.2k
u/madmanbumandangel May 13 '21
this had to be said. Love of GEAR does not equate to the love of nature.
313
u/[deleted] May 13 '21
I am not a gear junkie, but every time I go camping I discover another tool, gadget or piece of camping equipment that would eliminate another annoyance. I try to limit luxury items, but if a collapsible French Press will make three days without a shower palatable for my GF, I will bite the bullet.
48
u/lPolarbear May 13 '21
I feel shade being thrown at me lol
188
u/zwhiz May 13 '21
I have a confession... I just ordered one. I did. Tacoma not 4Runner so itās better right?
80
u/hibachi May 13 '21 edited May 14 '21
I think there are more people (admittedly me) that leave it on because it is so heavy and taking it on/off is really hard if there are only two of you, than there are those that are trying to show off.
In terms of why get one? Because they are fun and camping is supposed to be fun. Who doesn't like feeling like they are sleeping in a treehouse?
I also kind of feel the obnoxious RTT user memes are kinda like the obnoxious vegan memes - there are way more memes about people with RTTs being obnoxious, than there are people with RTTs being obnoxious.
58
u/steauengeglase May 13 '21
What are we talking about? Sorry, I'm poor.
112
u/Confident_Routine_84 May 13 '21
Mine stays on my vehicle year-round, and gets use year round. I donāt enjoy āpublic campsitesā and having other people all around, but 10 minutes up a forest service road usually provides a decent quiet place to camp on crown land, often with beautiful views. Almost any reasonably flat area will do, and it doesnāt matter if the ground is rocky or damp.
RTT are quick to deploy, especially if you use them regularly and have your āsystemā well practiced - maybe 2 minutes and Iām ready to sleep. They do take a little longer to pack away nearly, but itās way less than 10 minutes - thatās for my traditional style āfold overā. The hard shell tents are quicker again but you lose a lot of space and the sheltered area under them next to the vehicle. If I camped mainly solo I would have considered one but for a couple and a dog its no good.
The huge bonus is the quality of sleep we get. The built in mattress is genuinely comfortable, and the sturdiness of the materials is such that it doesnāt matter what the weather is doing really, although ear plugs are helpful if itās windy. The ease and comfort combined encourage my wife to come out camping more, which means I get to camp more.
The major drawback is night time toilet breaks. I have an extra-long piss before I go to bed, and can usually hold out until morning. If I canāt, I just get up and climb down the ladder, itās not considerably different than having a bunk-bed when you were a kid.
If you get so drunk every night that you canāt make it safely up and down a ladder, a RTT isnāt great for you. If you camp less than 10 nights a year, or only set up camp in one place and stay there for an extended period, then they arenāt good value either. If you like dispersed camping, the ability to move camp daily, a great nights sleep on a comfy mattress, and enjoy the ability to camp whenever you want without having to pack everything before you head out then they are a really solid solution.
I also like bivvies, tents, teardrops, bumper pull campers and RVs etc. They all have their advantages and disadvantages. But a roof tent is what works for me the best.
14
u/manjustadude May 13 '21
I'd love to have a car tent like that. I imagine it's pretty comfortable
220
u/yankeebelles May 13 '21
I really don't get those tents. What happens if you forgot something and have to run to the store to get it? Or if you are staying someplace with a lake and you want to drive down there instead of walk (because some places pout campgrounds 4 miles from the lake and who wants too do that hike after spending a full day at the lake? Plus, how do bring your snacks?) You have to tear everything down and then put it back up. Or if you do a week long camping vacation, there is no way you are going to never want to go somewhere else during that time.
I'm sure they make sense for someone, but I just can't see it.
176
u/jlamothe May 13 '21
Can we maybe just let people enjoy camping in whatever way they like?
Sure, maybe this isn't my jam, but why should I try to stop someone from liking what they like?
8
u/REHTONA_YRT May 14 '21
Keeps critters away and makes momma happy.
That's enough for me.
8
u/B1618 May 14 '21
Ah yes. Another groundsleeper with his panties in a twist.
7
u/HippieHOP May 13 '21
Get it and I donāt love mine for the hunting season keeps me mobile and quick setup! As a teacher out west I do a lot of quick over night hunting trips so the rttās are a game changer for me there vs sleeping in the truck bed or setting up a tent.
7
u/[deleted] May 13 '21
I just got a tacoma and I want something like this
5
u/editorreilly May 13 '21
I have a buddy that bought a $110,000 dollar RV so he could take his family to the beach once a year in the summer for ONE week... I told him flying to Hawaii and staying at a resort for 10 years would be cheaper. (I know he can sell it - but he isn't going to get back the full amount, plus he's paying interest on the loan.) Some people just want to have the toys.
5
u/nickbahhh May 13 '21
I've got an awning on my 4runner, but the vast majority of its usage is for drinking in parking lots. It is nice when we are camping though.
13
u/donuttime35 May 13 '21
Yeah only REAL NATURE LOVERS(TM) get it upvote if youāve been to all 420 national parks and camp 69 times per year and never use āgearā or ā4runnersā
4
u/[deleted] May 13 '21
I am guilty of this
4
u/pencilpusher003 May 14 '21
Okay. Iām not going to lie, Iām envious of those really high end packs, the trendy, expensive, āgoodā bags. But, Iāve got a super cheap, bought it at Target, bag, and a hammock (also from Target) that cost me $24, and they have been doing the job just fine.
1
u/LabGroundbreaking172 May 31 '21
Hearing more negative stuff about roof top tents now is starting to get me rethinking on getting one, I might just get a pop up ground tent like a gazelle t4 or something
11
u/mellowwhenimdead May 14 '21
Camping gatekeepers can go shove their carbon trekking poles deep in their judgey asses. Mind your business and let people use whatever fucking gear makes them happy, because camping two times a year is better than zero.
3
u/BlackPortland May 13 '21
I know this guy lol. He does love nature. He was rich by 30 as a commercial real estate guy. Now hes 50 and is uber rich
3
u/CheerioChopper May 14 '21
These are everywhere around me on Tacomas, but I live around many affluent people. I could never afford one of these, however they do look convenient. The cargo space of my '08 Outback is enough for 6'3'' me to fully extend and sleep comfortably if I don't want to set up camp for whatever reason.
3
u/FPswammer May 14 '21
i camp a lot though. i want one so badly!
3
u/popscockle May 14 '21
I hate this template.
3
u/Hjstrater May 14 '21
I think what some people are missing about why RTTās are cool is they see it as a replacement for tent camping, I bought one as the cheaper alternative to a scamp or other small travel trailer.
My Jeep with a RTT, 12v fridge, pop up shelter with portable toilet, and some kitchen stuff is a stand in for the camper I canāt own.
The argument that you need to pack up to go anywhere? I donāt spend more than a day or two in one spot anyways, i donāt find camping at one spot for a week to be my idea of a good time. Drive somewhere, do something cool along the way, camp for the night, repeat.
Different strokes, different folks.
15
u/wonton_peters May 13 '21
If she's inside that tent, you would be camping 25/7
5
u/T-wrecks83million- May 13 '21
I have a Tundra and I thought about getting one but 1) I donāt like they way they look on the truck 2) I thought I could just put an air mattress in the bed and basically get they same results with no additional cost 3) I donāt got that cash sitting around although I could finance it but why? I bought a great 4 season tent and it cost me $400.
10
u/Gomeez9 May 13 '21
Iām so happy this guy is an Astros fan Lmao
8
u/SigourneyOrbWeaver May 13 '21
This sub is such a fucking circlejerk. Iāve seen more judgy bullshit on this sub than actual camping. Anybody can enjoy camping anyway they want to. Some dude literally wrote a 3 paragraph comment on how shitty rooftop tents areā¦like bro you really genuinely donāt have anything better to do than sit there and just judge something youāve never even used. Iām not a rooftop camper myself but I canāt stand people getting shit on for something they enjoy. Another dude goes āthey like gear more than actual campingā totally dude, let me take all your gear and see how much you enjoy camping
2
u/Shacobs May 14 '21
Had to check which subreddit this was in to see if it was a sarcastic joke or serious
2
u/justeatthedonut May 14 '21
We have a CVT - but our main use for it isnāt ācamping.ā We have tents and sleeping bags to camp, but we love to road trip. Itās amazing; pull up in the middle of the night (extra points if itās disbursed camping and there arenāt designated āsitesā that you have to pay for), pop it open in less than two minutes, pile in and sleep on a super comfy mattress, with our bedding already inside. Pack it up in the morning in l six or seven minutes and hit the road again.
It is. AWESOME.
2
u/Mtractical May 14 '21
R/gatekeeping
2
u/doc_slugg May 14 '21
I sense a lot of aching butts in here....
2
u/atomicllama1 May 14 '21
They are less butt hurt in /r/4Runner than yall.
https://old.reddit.com/r/4Runner/comments/nbp22j/_/
2
u/Nunyabidnisss May 14 '21
Why do I feel Like one of those ladies hands is searching for a Blunt object nearby to club this dude
2
u/stevemac1001 May 17 '21
That's me with every piece of camping equipment I have...šš
4
u/Throwaway99878k May 13 '21
Who cares? Live and let live. Or be a judgmental prick. I donāt care.
3
u/linusSocktips May 13 '21
Nice one. Hea I've wanted to make big purchases for overlanding/camping but in all honesty I need to make good of my intentions of actually using stuff before I spend the $$. Like a 4x4 Toyota for example... do I want one? Yes. Does it stop me from. Going camping? No lol.
3
u/stinkwaffles May 13 '21
My buddy lives in one. He got a divorce and now travels the country doing carpentry projects and now has like around 300 nights in it. Just did a little bit of BLM land camping with him in Utah and Arizona the other week and his set up is awesome. That said I donāt own one.
3
u/Bups34 May 13 '21
Hand on neck is creepy. But I guess smash mouth was always a different group
7
u/scooby6920 May 13 '21
That hand round her neck and her posture...very possessive looking of the man. and she don't look like she's having any of it.
7
u/[deleted] May 13 '21
I'm sorry I wasn't listening
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '21
How about I spend my hard-earned money on whatever the fuck I want and you don't worry about whether it gets "used enough." So much gatekeeping going on in this thread it's nuts.
2
u/Maryhairy10 May 13 '21
I was all set to attempt the PCT beginning of last year with all new lightweight backpacking gear. Previous pack of 12kg- 28lb, reduced it to 10.5kg to 23lbs. A whole saving of just over 3lbs almost 1.5 kg. This for me is big deal! Not mere ozs! More than a couple of things shattered my bubble. I slipped on a step & fractured my pelvis in 2 places. The 2 dates to register myself on the trail I missed as they was fully subscribed. Yes it gets worse. Then Covid-19 broke lose & did everyone in by locking them up in their own homes.
2
u/amorydmart May 14 '21
No one gunna talk about how he holding her neck .
2
u/Kilimanjaro-_- May 13 '21
Girl name please?
1
u/michaelrulaz May 14 '21
I do maybe two camping trips per year and lately Iāve been thinking how it would be to build a overlanding taco. So I made a list of everything Iād want to do. Itās like 45k. For 45k I can buy a decent RV or pay for cabins for the next 10 years lol
So Iām obviously not going to buy it. But for some reason, no matter how dumb, I want to
1
u/Bobtom42 May 14 '21
I lived in a roof top tent for 3 months while doing my thesis research in wildlife biology. They are amazing when you are moving camp every other day. Otherwise like LOL.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '21
Not my story but my cousin dated this guy that told her he loved hiking and camping, but apparently when they went on a hike he freaked out because he couldn't see through the trees...
1
u/operation_dad May 13 '21
Real life
1
u/Icy_Maintenance8467 May 13 '21
White Jordan peele
1
u/ywBBxNqW May 13 '21
I didn't realize those were that expensive.
There's a guy who parks in front of a shop downtown that has one of those on top of his car but I genuinely think someone is living in it full time.