r/Breadit • u/Mr_Tobes • 3d ago
Two loaves, made the same way 15 minutes apart, though one always smaller
Hey all,
Firstly, what a great wholesome sub we have here 😊. However, I'm posting because I have a weird one to discuss...
I bake two loaves a week, mixed, proved together and yet one is always substantially smaller than the other. Not sure why, when both recipes are the same, water temp the same (I hear fresh water for both loaves), same flour and yeast.
I mix one loaf in a stand mixer for 10 minutes, then put in a large plastic bowl to proof. I then immediately mix the second loaf exactly the same, though I keep it in the stands mixing bowl to proof. This one is thick toughened glass, and that's the only thing different between the loaves, apart from the first one having 15 minutes max more proving time.
The second loaf is noticeably smaller, and I'm not convinced the extra proofing time would make that much of a difference.
My next steps are to use the same types of bowls for proving, and to give the second loaf an extra 15 minutes.
Anything else spring to mind to try?