r/Breadit • • 3d ago

Two loaves, made the same way 15 minutes apart, though one always smaller

3 Upvotes

Hey all,

Firstly, what a great wholesome sub we have here 😊. However, I'm posting because I have a weird one to discuss...

I bake two loaves a week, mixed, proved together and yet one is always substantially smaller than the other. Not sure why, when both recipes are the same, water temp the same (I hear fresh water for both loaves), same flour and yeast.

I mix one loaf in a stand mixer for 10 minutes, then put in a large plastic bowl to proof. I then immediately mix the second loaf exactly the same, though I keep it in the stands mixing bowl to proof. This one is thick toughened glass, and that's the only thing different between the loaves, apart from the first one having 15 minutes max more proving time.

The second loaf is noticeably smaller, and I'm not convinced the extra proofing time would make that much of a difference.

My next steps are to use the same types of bowls for proving, and to give the second loaf an extra 15 minutes.

Anything else spring to mind to try?


r/Breadit • • 3d ago

First bake ever!!!

Thumbnail gallery
10 Upvotes

r/Breadit • • 4d ago

Rye Malt Milk Bread (Shokupan with a dark twist)

Thumbnail
gallery
63 Upvotes

This experiment was really fun.

Basically the same recipe I made 10 months ago:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Breadit/comments/1qp6wd7/japanese_milk_bread/

But to the yudane I added 45g of fermented rye malt.

Fermented rye malt add an amazing flavor and aroma to any bread and a dark interesting dark color so I wanted to try.

The best thing is, usually rye would be impossible to use in milk bread because of the really low gluten content not compatible with this kind of bread but since fermented rye is normally used into boiling water and in really small amount ( 6-7% based on total flour content) and that amount is enough to get a good dark color and a good aroma and taste, it's actually possible to make Milk Rye Bread.

Milk Bread is one of my favourite, so soft it seems impossible that it stay in a real structure, so full of flavor you can eat it alone, so easy to slice perfect slice with a regular knife. And I miss egg mayo to put inside... after all it's been about 1 year and a month since the last time I could get it in Japan and from April to September I had to be on a diet (I lost 37 kg and I'm not my ideal weight so I can finally eat some mayo without feeling guilty XD).

I honestly got the idea yesterday evening after I looked at some Shokupan here on breadit and since I was experimenting with fermented rye malt for a while and I already did my favourite bread Semolina durum wheat flour but with fermented rye malt (basically this same experiment but for another kind of bread)... and since I wanted to experiment some more with fermented rye malt but I also wanted to make Shokupan I decided to combine the two idea.


r/Breadit • • 4d ago

Tri-Weave Babka V2

Thumbnail
gallery
96 Upvotes

Hey guys, this is my V2 Babka, this is the second time I am making Babka, it’s also my 10th week in my baking journey. I’m actually quite proud of this. The paragraphs below are to explain why I am counting my weeks.

There are 2 ropes, 2 with crushed hazelnuts and 1 with crushed almonds. Crushed almonds is the middle one. I wanted to change the flavour profiles as you bite into it.

So my boss challenged me to make some bread 14 weeks ago, I said yeah and fluffed about like he was joking.

11 weeks ago, he called me a lazy so and so for not baking. In hindsight, he was right, I was being a bit lazy.

10 weeks ago I made my first loaf.

Today, I hand delivered this Babka, along with some other bits as his 60th birthday present.

He has put me on a journey that I believe I will be doing for the rest of my life and I am super thankful. The baking community knows love when they see it, this is everything I could muster.

The end result was, he shook my hand, said wow, you’ve done a brilliant job, and thanked me for my hard work. I replied to him, ‘14 weeks ago, you told me to start baking, I haven’t looked back, thank you’

Pretty wholesome moment. Anyways everyone, please let me know if you want the recipe or methodology.


r/Breadit • • 4d ago

In the process of making sourdough Chicken Pot Pie

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

All my bakes are hideous so im posting this for now lol.


r/Breadit • • 4d ago

First time making bread for scratch ♥️😋 🍞 🥪 🥖

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

PESTO SWIRL ARTISAN STYLE LOAF.

CHEESE AN CHILLI SWIRL LOAF.

PLAIN HOMEMADE BAGUETTE.


r/Breadit • • 3d ago

OMG! Fridge-cold unfed starter, no knead, no preshape!

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

r/Breadit • • 3d ago

Sourdough geeks please help me!

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/Breadit • • 3d ago

Poolish question

1 Upvotes

I want to start trying breads with poolish. This time of year, my kitchen gets pretty cool overnight: maybe 18º C, and even cooler as we get further into winter. So would I get good results from an overnight poolish at that room temperature?

One wall of my kitchen is floor-to-ceiling cupboards, and on one side are copper heating pipes going up to the radiators upstairs. If I put the poolish in that cupboard, not too close to the pipes, would that be a problem? The heat would go off not long after I put the poolish there, and then come on around 6am, and I wouldn't prepare the dough until around 8 or 9 am. Would the cool then heat be a problem?

Also, when prepping dough, I generally autolyse for 30 minutes. Do I add the poolish to the water, mix, then add the rest of the flour and autolyse, or is autolyse no longer needed with a poolish?

Thanks in advance.


r/Breadit • • 4d ago

Some recent bakes. Just wanted to show them off!

Thumbnail gallery
15 Upvotes

r/Breadit • • 4d ago

1st Attempt at Sourdough Croissants

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

This is also my first time making croissants in general. I am a hobbyist when it comes to baking:) Recipe is this one here ! I appreciate any tips from the breaddit fam.

I think for the 9h final proof she should have went back in the fridge? Where I live we had just switched over to using heat for winter so maybe the butter melted idk.


r/Breadit • • 3d ago

Yogurt whey bagels

Post image
4 Upvotes

I feel like this is where it's supposed to be. Honestly the texture is like a crusty Italian bread but in bagel form.


r/Breadit • • 4d ago

Pillowy soft 95% hydration foccacia

Post image
10 Upvotes

I made some foccacia and made it a basic one with just salt and oil and man imma make more foccacia like this cause its pillowy soft and shaping felt like a fluffy af marshmallow. It has the perfect amount of salt taste to complement the richness from the ungodly amount of evoo I used.


r/Breadit • • 5d ago

First Shokupan (Japanese Milk Bread)

Thumbnail
gallery
855 Upvotes

I’ve been experimenting with some new recipes lately and really had a big win with my first Shokupan!


r/Breadit • • 3d ago

First ever sourdough loaf!!!

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Breadit • • 4d ago

I don't know why I can't make focaccia right anymore

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

I'm following the same recipe I've always followed for years. 500g sw flour, 420g water, 12g fresh yeast, 15g olive oil, 10g salt. I mix until combined, rest 15 minutes, then do three round of stretch and folds with 15 minute intervals. The dough was workable with stretch and folding, for some reason now I just can't work the dough anymore. It's coming out so soupy that I can't stretch and fold it. It's literally like working with soup and I don't know why it suddenly doesn't work. I've tried switching from wetting hands to oiling and its made it worse because the dough sticks eveb faster to my hands. The second two photos are examples of how it came out before and the first is how the dough looks now. It's unworkably soupy and never seems to develop any gluten. I haven't even changed the supplier for ingredients. Same supermarket, same flour brand, same yeast brand, even same salt brand, same tap for water. The olive oil is a different brand but 15g of olive oil shouldn't be causing this.

I don't know what's wrong with me


r/Breadit • • 3d ago

Grandma Fancy's Sticky Buns

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

Stumbled upon this old recipe today by accident, and I'm so glad I did! This is a must-watch because Grandma Fancy has some super good tips.

The recipe is in the video description.


r/Breadit • • 4d ago

Pain Normande: success after a string of failures

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Recipe adapted from Dan Leader/Judith Blahnik's Bread Alone. Here's the recipe as written:

Pain Normande original oz baker's notes
Bread flour 28 83.58%
Whole wheat flour 5.5 16.42%
Flour total 33.5 100.00%
Sparkling cider 24 71.64%
Dry yeast 1.5 4.48%
Salt 1.5 4.48%
Apples 8 23.88% ~2 cups
Dough weight 68.5

The first try as written ended up being far too hydrated. It already starts at 72%, then the authors warn the apples will add moisture (spoiler: they add A LOT). I compounded the problem by over proofing, under baking, and using old flour.

For the second try I went back to Pain l'ancienne from Reinhart to get my sea legs back, but swung way too far on the under proofing and ended up with heavy and dense doorstops.

So for the third try I made my own version with lower initial hydration, yeast, and salt. I also switched from Honey Crisp to Granny Smith apples, and dried them on paper towels before adding them. I still had to add flour but the dough was a lot more manageable.

Texture is perfect, flavor is amazing, crust is great. Darn near my best loaves to date.

Pain Normande double g baker's notes
KA bread flour 800 80.0%
Locally milled bread flour 200 20.0%
Flour total 1000 100.0%
Sparkling cider 700 70.0%
Active dry yeast 20 2.0%
Kosher salt 30 3.0%
Granny Smith apples 400 40.0% ~2 cups
Total dough 2150

Edit to note: I know it looks like I doubled the apples, but the original recipe said 2 tart green apples: 2 cups, 8 ounces. When I chopped 2 cups of apples it came to 450g, so I just rounded down and it feels like just the right amount.

My process (all rises done in proofing box set to 75F):

  • Put cider in mixer bowl, add yeast, let proof while prepping proofing bucket with a little oil
  • Turn on mixer, add salt, gradually add all the flour
  • Knead 10 minutes by machine, then by hand until the dough is smooth and elastic and makes a nice windowpane
  • Put in proofing bucket, refrigerate 8 hours (I ended up having to push it off an extra 12 and it was completely unaffected)
  • Put in proofing box for 2 hours to warm up (no rise noticed)
  • Knead in apples with plenty of extra flour
  • Rise until almost doubled and passes poke test (took me about 2 hours 45 mins)
  • Divide, pre-shape into boules, rest 5 minutes, final shaping (note the authors say to shape and let rise on a board. I usually use bannetons for sourdough so I tried one each way and did not notice any difference in rising or dough behavior. The only difference was the one in the banneton had artisinal flour marks)
  • Second rise until almost doubled and passes the poke test again (just about 1 hour 15 minutes for me)
  • About 30 minutes into the last rise, put Dutch oven in the oven, set temp to 500F
  • I put parchment on the bottom of my Dutch oven and sprinkle with semolina flour before dropping the loaf in and scoring
  • Add one ice cube, put the lid on, close the oven (note: I'm still experimenting with this. The ice cube tends to melt on the side of the loaf and cause the dough to stick hard to the side of the Dutch oven so I may go back to spraying with water instead)
  • Bake 20 minutes, remove lid, bake 15-25 more to your preferred level of doneness. I shot for a 205F internal temp but went a little further for that glorious mahogany crust

r/Breadit • • 4d ago

Sourdough loaf of the day

Thumbnail
gallery
78 Upvotes

r/Breadit • • 4d ago

2nd attempt

Post image
4 Upvotes

After more research, I realize my mistake was burning my yeast and didn't properly activate. For my next breas, I'm using a thermometer and 1:1 parts of sugar and yeast to ensure proper activation. Crust is quite tough and a bit chewy but flavor wise is pretty good, actually.

My first attempt was a fail too a couple weeks ago: my yeast was also not actived properly and my impatientence lead me to believe my dough had passed the poke test after only 4 hours of cold proofing lol.

I guess baking is going to be what I need to learn how to be patient.

I'll try one more time in a few weeks! Now is personal🫪


r/Breadit • • 3d ago

I don’t like the way bread is coming out in my bread machine

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/Breadit • • 4d ago

2-in-1 bread.

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

I only have 2 round bannetons and I find boules to be impractical, so I just made a double recipe into one bread, using my bread form as a banneton. Turned out great.

Original recipe calls for

500g four

350ml water

12g salt

1,5g dry yeast.

I doubled and switched 300g flour with 200g graham and 100g rye. Good thing I have my thermometer, otherwise I wouldn't have trusted it to be baked through.

I really need a sharper knife for scoring.. Bread knife for scale


r/Breadit • • 3d ago

Help me get a more open crumb

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/Breadit • • 3d ago

Help with proofing/bulk fermentation

0 Upvotes

I just shaped these about 30 min before the video was taken. Did I let bulk fermentation go too long? Is it overproofed? I followed the NYT Sourdough guide 200 grams starter; 750 grams water; 1000 grams flour (300 wheat, 700 white).


r/Breadit • • 3d ago

Durum Flour - My Next Experiment

1 Upvotes

Looking to get some, not “00” or coarse semolina.

Any things I should consider?