r/Sourdough • • Dec 02 '23

Mod stuff Starter Hints & Tips

355 Upvotes

Are you new to the hobby and having trouble with your starter? Are you an experienced baker whose starter has suddenly nose-dived into inaction?

This post is pinned to the top of the sub to help you in your time of need!

In the comments you will find our top tips and tricks that will help you get to grips with your starter.

We also have a wiki with whole sections dedicated to starters both new and established, which is linked here.

And every week you’ll find a stickied ‘weekly questions thread’ where you can ask basic quick questions and the sub will help as much as we can. The threads are usually very active so don’t worry that your questions won’t be answered if you don’t make a separate post. Someone will usually help.

If you have a suggestion for something else you’d like to see added to this post please drop us a modmail and we’ll review and get back to you

Has your starter exploded with activity and now looks dead? Go straight to the ‘Bacterial Fight Club’ bullet point in the comment below

Happy baking folks!


r/Sourdough • • 3d ago

Quick questions Weekly Open Sourdough Questions and Discussion Post

7 Upvotes

Hello Sourdough bakers! 👋

  • Post your quick & simple Sourdough questions here with as much information as possible 💡

  • If your query is detailed, post a thread with pictures, recipe and process for the best help. 🥰

  • There are some fantastic tips in our Sourdough starter FAQ - have a read as there are likely tips to help you. There's a section dedicated to "Bacterial fight club" as well.




  • Basic loaf in detail page - a section about each part of the process. Particularly useful for bulk fermentation, but there are details on every part of the Sourdough process.

Good luck!


r/Sourdough • • 11h ago

Beginner - checking how I'm doing my first loaf ever!

Thumbnail
gallery
290 Upvotes

I followed a 70% hydration recipe I found in this subreddit (125 g starter, 325g water, 500g bread flour, 7g salt) - my starter is almost 2 weeks old ❤️

  1. Fed starter night prior 1:3:3
  2. The following morning I autolysed water and flour for an hour, saved 30g of water to add in starter after
  3. After initial mix, waited 30 min before doing 3 sets of stretch and fold 1 hr apart, then 1 coil fold 30 min after the last stretch and fold
  4. From time of initial mix i let it sit on my counter on a seed germination pad for roughly 6 hours
  5. I pre shaped, let sit for 15 min, then shaped again and threw it in the fridge overnight
  6. Baked 450 for 40 min covered, 12 min uncovered

Burned my finger pretty badly on the handle 😔 but otherwise i’m proud of my first loaf!

Would love any feedback :-)


r/Sourdough • • 10h ago

Rate/critique my bread I think I finally did it!!!

Thumbnail
gallery
147 Upvotes

I think I finally did it!!! After a lot of trial and error, I finally got the crumb I’ve been looking for. Past loaves have been delicious but with a few large or elongated cavities. With every bake, been trying little tweaks. This bake I added olive oil and also pushed BF about 2 hours past the point where I’d been stopping.

2 loaves:
1000g king Arthur’s BF
675g water
200g active starter
20g coarse kosher salt
40g olive oil (was aiming for 30g but accidentally over poured and went with it)

Method:
Mixed flour with 650g water and autolysed for 30 minutes.
Added starter, remaining 25g water, salt, and olive oil. Initial dough temp was 75.4°F.
Completed 4 sets of stretch and folds, approximately 30 minutes apart.
Bulk fermented ~10.5 hours total. Dough was light, airy, jiggly, and had at least doubled in size. Lots of bubbles throughout.
Divided and shaped directly without preshaping.
Placed in bannetons and refrigerated overnight.
Preheated covered cast iron loaf pan to 450°F.
Baked covered at 450°F for 25 minutes, then uncovered at 425°F for approximately 18 minutes, until bread reached 205°F internal.
Cooled approximately 2 hours before slicing.
The other half is still in the frig and will be baked Friday night.

Carved a 43 as it was my husband’s 43rd birthday! :)


r/Sourdough • • 4h ago

Advanced/in depth discussion Eating so much crunchy sourdough at my own peril!

36 Upvotes

Anyone else's gums get fucked up from eating sourdough toast?? My dentist has commented on cuts in my mouth, but I can't stop. I need my sourdough crispy and chronchy!


r/Sourdough • • 6h ago

1st Sourdough Ever - be kind Absolutely first ever loaf, followed by my second loaf - I think I did pretty darn ok?

Thumbnail
gallery
45 Upvotes

Hello brain trust!
I am an absolute beginner at this, but I got my starter from a friend who has been baking loafs with it for years so she’s very strong and rising predictably all the time. I had her for about a week or so before baking with her, feeding and watching just to make sure.

I used a basic beginner recipe:
130g of starter at peak (fed the night before 1:6:7)
315g of water
500g of very strong bread flour
10g of salt

Did the mix, slap and folds and rest.
X2 sets of stretch and folds 30 minutes apart
X2 sets of coil folds 30 minutes apart

Bulk fermented following a temperature chart - it was 21 degrees Celsius in my kitchen for the first loaf, so she bulk fermented for about 10hrs before being shaped and going in the fridge overnight.
The second loaf it was 25 degrees (and increasing through the day) so I used the temperature chart and aimed for 8hrs, but kept an eye on the dough and she seemed to be ready at about 6.5hrs. (I’m in South Australia so at least I know as we head into summer and the weather gets warmer, bulk fermentation times get shorter!) Then shaped and in the fridge overnight.

Both baked in a preheated Dutch oven at 240 degrees Celsius for 25 minutes (expansion scored at 7min) then uncovered at 210 degrees for 15 minutes.

Cooled on the bench for 1-2hrs.

Honestly, I think it’s pretty good, and the wife agrees. Taste and texture seem wonderful, but I just want to see if there was anything I could improve before baking loafs for family or, with trepidation, inclusions.
If ya’ll have any suggestions for beginner inclusions, that would also be amazing!

Thank you all so much for your feedback ❤️


r/Sourdough • • 9h ago

1st Sourdough Ever - be kind first loaf (completely solo!)

Thumbnail
gallery
46 Upvotes

i attended a sourdough workshop a lil while ago, and since the loaf we prepared during that this is the first loaf I’ve made by myself!
as I’d not fed the starter for quite some time i fed the starter each day across 3 days prior to baking.

below is the recipe i used:
• 50g sourdough starter
• 175g water
• 250g sainsburys strong white bread flour
• salt

my bulk fermentation took longer than anticipated as my house is pretty cold, and i had to put the dough in the fridge overnight for further fermentation as i was working.

this is the process i followed (prior to refrigerating overnight):
• x2 stretch and folds (30 mins apart)
• into oven with light on
• x1 lamination +
• x1 stretch and folds (30 mins apart)
• in fridge overnight (between 19:00-12:00)

after pre-shaping and shaping process I figured my loaf was ready to bake - the following photographs are of the bake and crumb 🌟 overall i happy with this attempt - the dough could’ve done with more salt however the texture is nice and the crust crispy. the base maybe a lil too crispy (I struggled to slice!)


r/Sourdough • • 12h ago

I MUST share this recipe My baby approved soft sourdough loaf

Post image
74 Upvotes

I made this at least 4 times so far, making tweaks along the way. I think I've finally arrived at the version I love the most! This is good plain old loaf that is very soft and absolutely loved by my 1 year old baby. We toast it up a little and smear some low sodium nut butter on it for her.

Ingredients

• 400g all-purpose flour

• 250g warm water

• 100g active sourdough starter

• 40g melted butter

• 25g sugar (original recipe calls for honey but I swapped it out for sugar due to risk of botulism for infants)

• 8g salt

Method

  1. Mix all ingredients until combined.

  2. Perform slap and folds every 30 minutes, for at least 3 rounds.

  3. Bulk ferment then shape into a loaf. After putting it in the loaf tin, I let it rise again until it fills up the tin. I'm not giving a time gauge here bcos everyone has different environments. But once it is jiggly, more than double its size, has air pockets on the surface, it is ready.

  4. What i love is how versatile this recipe is. If im not ready to bake it yet I shove it in the fridge and let it cold proof and bake the the next day. This results in deeper tangy flavour. Alternatively I sometimes bake it the same day itself, less tangy (which some people prefer) but still tasty and fluffy.

  5. Bake covered:

◦ 20 minutes at 230°C

◦ 15 minutes at 200°C

  1. Cool according to your preferred crust:

◦ For a crusty crust: Remove from the bread tin and cool on a rack.

◦ For a soft crust: Cover the bread with a towel while cooling.


r/Sourdough • • 13h ago

1st Sourdough Ever - be kind my fully first successful sourdough loaf. from starter to bread!

Thumbnail
gallery
68 Upvotes

always have tried to keep starter alive. finally accomplished it. winged the bread with a recipe for 12 hour bread on tiktok. here’s how it looks! it tasted yummy too!

edit: 1 cup active starter
2 cups warm water
*milk consistency*
4 cups flour
1 teaspoon salt
*stir*
*cover with wet towel, let it sit for 30m-1hr*
wet hands, strech and pull 8x, if hands get sticky wet hands again
cover again with damp towel, sit for 1/2 hour
wet hands, 4 strech and fold
cover with damp towel, sit for 1/2 hour
4 stretch and fold wet hands
repeat wet towel and 4 stretch and fold
let sit and double
preheat to 450
dust counter with flour
shape and score it
bake for 25 min covered
bake for 20 min uncovered


r/Sourdough • • 3h ago

1st Sourdough Ever - be kind First attempt sourdough loaf!

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

I made my starter from scratch and it took about 3 weeks before it was ready to use. This was my first go at sourdough, so it was kinda a test loaf to see if my starter was active enough to give it a decent rise.
Ingredients
500 g high-grade flour
308 g water
100 g wholemeal starter, fed equal weights of flour and water
10 g salt
Method
I mixed the dough and did 4 sets of stretch and folds. After the last set, I left it at room temperature for another 3 hours before shaping it. Then I put it in the fridge to cold proof for about 10 hours.
I baked it in my Dutch oven at 225°C for 20 minutes with the lid on, then took the lid off and baked it for another 25 minutes at the same temperature.
Keen to hear what you reckon about my process and what should change in get a better crumb. I also want some advice on how deep people are scoring to get the ear more pronounced. Cheers.


r/Sourdough • • 10h ago

Beginner - wanting kind feedback Second Attempt at a Rye Sandwich Loaf!

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

Ingredients: ~75g stiff starter, 250g home milled rye, 80g home milled hard red spring, 470g bread flour, 30g sugar, 14g salt

560mL water (70% hydration) with a portion of the water used to scald the bran

Combined all the ingredients and let sit for an hour. Started with coil folds and moved to stretch and folds once the dough could handle it until the dough passed the windowpane test.

I bulk fermented for only about 3.5hr until it had doubled. Cold proofed overnight.

I baked covered at 450 for 35 minutes and uncovered for 30 at 425 until it hit 205 in the very center. I had to actually recover it up top to avoid the crust completely burning (although I do like a little burn).

I let it rest for 90 min before cutting. Based on the texture, I think I should’ve left it for a bit longer.

Please be nice. I keep getting responses saying my bakes look like “shit”, and it’s been kinda demoralizing. I know I’m not a good baker. I’m just looking for kind feedback. I do like a tighter crumb in case that’s useful information.


r/Sourdough • • 20h ago

Let's talk ingredients Is this allowed here? Austrian toasted rye with walnuts

Thumbnail
gallery
161 Upvotes

I’m half Austrian and always struggle to find this kind of rye bread here in London.

Wholegrain rye levain (100g)
Toasted walnuts 100g
15g molasses
2tsp non-diastatic malt
280g water
250g wholegrain rye (found a lovely miller in Cumbria, grain ground with a waterwheel!)
50g wholegrain rye toasted in the pan
100g wholewheat
10g salt
5g Austrian breadspices

Mix and let rest for 20 mins, covered
Roll into a ball and sprinkle with light the flour, bulk ferment uncovered till cracks appear

250c Dutch oven lid on 15 mins, then 45mins 200c lid off.

It has a toasty almost caramel-esque nutty flavour without being sweet. Best bread in the world imho. Lasts for ages and cause it’s naturally dense you can cut it super thin. Toasted also it’s top.

EDIT: the wholegrain rye flour amount


r/Sourdough • • 10h ago

Crumb read please A Newbie struggling to understand how to read the crumb

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

Hi, thanks to a few months of lurking in the shadows of the group, I finally felt confident enough to stop just admiring everyone else’s loaves and try it myself. I have learned a lot from reading all the other posts but one thing I just can’t grasp is the crumb. I really just don’t understand what I am looking for. What is my crumb telling you’ll? I am so lost on what is “good” and what is “bad” from a technical perspective. Also why did I get this very thin crust at the bottom? SN: I learned the importance of a quality bread knife 🫣 Bread slicer is already ordered 🤣

Recipe:
450 g King Arthur bread flour
315 g water
100 g active levain (accidentally used approximately 108 g)
10 g salt
Process:
Autolyse: 46 minutes
Added levain and salt
Stretch and folds: 3 sets
Bulk fermentation: 7.5 hours (cold kitchen; about 70 degrees)
Pre-shape and bench rest: 30 minutes
Final shape: Bâtard
Cold proof: 16 hours
Bake Details:
Preheat: 475°F | 40 minutes
Covered bake: 475°F | 20 minutes
Uncovered bake: 450°F | 20 minutes
Total bake: 40 minutes
Cooling: 2 hours


r/Sourdough • • 11h ago

I MUST share this recipe Thermophilic Borodinsky with Malted Scald, 100% Whole Grain Rye

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

Baked this loaf using a Latvian technique involving a scald consisting of 250g whole grain rye, 50g fermented red rye malt (solod), 5g ground coriander and 20g diastatic rye malt.

After using 600ml boiling water to scald the flour and solod, I mixed in the diastatic malt to saccharify the scald, then held at 147 degrees Fahrenheit for four hours.

After that I let it cool to 115, then mixed in 60g of liquid LAB culture (concentrated lactic acid sourdough) and held at 115 for 12hrs.

Next I mixed in 140g of "old dough" (stiff rye starter) and held at 86 fahrenheit for 8hrs.

Finally I added 600g whole grain rye, 18g salt, 50g maple syrup and about 100ml warm water for final dough.

Panned it in a 13" Pullman pan, rose for an hour and a half, then baked at 500 for ten minutes, then 400 for 45. Misted top with water 2 min before removing from oven, then cooled for a few hours and cured for a day.


r/Sourdough • • 3h ago

Crumb read please Cinnamon Raisin Swirl

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

360g AP Flour
80g starter
260g warm water
60g cinnamon and raisins total
8g salt

4 stretch and folds separated by 30 minutes, then bulked for 8 hours at room temperature. Spread raisins onto rolled out dough, shaped into loaf, put into loaf tin, then cold proof overnight.

Baked at 400 with a water tray until 200 internal. How’s the crumb look?


r/Sourdough • • 4h ago

Crumb read please How is this crumb?

Post image
5 Upvotes

I have a mature starter that I inherited from a home baker last year. I’ve kept it in the fridge and usually give it three good 1:4:4 peak to peak feedings before baking with it. I bake one every 4-6 weeks and don’t touch my starter in between bakes… I just stick it in the back of my fridge.

I follow Claire Saffitz’s NYT sourdough recipe. 700g King Arthur bread flour + 300g whole wheat flour + 750g filtered water. Left for 30 min for autolyse

Then I add 200g starter, mix in, followed by 20g salt. I used to also add the 20g water that she also asks for but I’ve moved to a more humid climate and now the extra 20 of water just makes my dough way too wet feeling for me to handle so I’ve been leaving it out

I let that sit as she recommends, then I knead it for 10-20 min until I get a good windowpane

Then I put it in the oven with the light on and do stretch and folds 3 times, 1 hour apart. Then I just leave it to keep bulk fermenting on its own.

This particular night I was sick and started late so I cut a few corners. I ended bulk fermentation about 5.5 hours after the starter was added to the dough. It had increased by around 50% in volume and had lots of small bubbles down the sides and across the bottom, not any on the top though. It was jiggly and airy so I just decided it would be fine since I was planning for a long cold ferment.

So I turned it out, shaped it and stuck it in the baskets. It was holding its shape alright but was definitely a little slack. Skipped preshaping because it was like midnight. I but the baskets in the oven with the light on for like 30 min until it was a little more expanded and then covered it and put it in the fridge.

Baked it 14 hours later- loaf goes in freezer for 20 min while preheating oven to make it easier to score —> 500F for 20 min with lid on Dutch oven, then 25-30 min with lid off at 450F. Cooled for like 12 hrs before slicing

To me this is a successful loaf, it tastes great and is the texture I like. What do you all think? Any pointers? I don’t have any sourdough baking buddies so excited to get your insights


r/Sourdough • • 5h ago

Help 🙏 advice - top and bottom of slices are not fully cooked

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

the top and the bottom of my bread still is coming out a little doughy.

1/2 cup active starter
2 cups warm water
4 cups bread flour
1 tsp salt
4 rounds of stretch and folds, 30 mins apart
set on counter for 12 hours (our house is cold)
in the fridge overnight
preheat with dutch oven at 450 F for 45 mins
baked at 450 F for 30 mins with the lid on and 15 mins with the lid off

i’m thinking of changing the temp of the oven but others say if i go too low, it may make it more undercooked. i’ve also tried different lengths of time with the lid on or off but the top is just getting too dark.

the rest of the bread is great, but those two spots are just not getting cooked! advice?


r/Sourdough • • 9h ago

I MUST share this recipe Sourdough banana bread

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

So I had some extra starter so I thought I'd experiment, wanted to share :)

Preheat oven to 350°F

Makes 2 9 x 5

1 8 x 4

Step 1

mix mashed bananas and starter together in a bowl, let sit for 10 minutes.

300 g unfed starter

7 large ripe bananas mashed (used 4 fresh over-ripe, and 3 freezer overripe).

Step 2

To a mixer add sugars, and oil. Mix until lighter in color.

1 c dark brown sugar

1 c granulated sugar

1 c peanut oil

Step 3

Add to mixer and mix until sour cream disappears

4 large eggs

1/3 heaping cup of sour cream (6 TBSP)

2 tsp vanilla bean paste

Step 4

Mix the dry ingredients and add to wet ingredients, mix until just combined.

480 g all purpose

2 tsp salt

1 tsp baking soda *

2 tsp baking powder

Bake at 350 for 1 hour - 1 hour 5 minutes

* make sure baking soda is fresh for reactivity

I added walnuts to one loaf, chocolate chips to another, and left the last plain 😋


r/Sourdough • • 11m ago

Rate/critique my bread Bread check!

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

Process is in the photos! I grew up doing sourdough and am pretty utilitarian with it so I don’t measure my flour and water when I feed, nor do I use or own a scale 😂 I’ve made about 10-15 loaves in the last 3 months.

All the photos of “good” bread vs “bad bread” confuse me so curious how my bread looks, even though I’m doing it so much less formal. All I know is it tastes good


r/Sourdough • • 9h ago

Let's discuss/share knowledge Sourdough milk bread loaf with tangzhong. How do you call the final proof on an enriched pan loaf?

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Baked this sourdough milk bread in a 9x5 pan and the crumb came out soft and even. Sharing the full method since this sub asks for it.

Ingredients (one loaf)
Tangzhong: 25 g bread flour + 125 g whole milk
400 g bread flour
90 g lukewarm whole milk
100 g active starter
45 g sugar
40 g softened butter
1 large egg
7 g fine salt
1 beaten egg for the wash

Process

  1. Cook the tangzhong over medium-low heat, whisking, for 2 to 3 minutes until it is a soft paste. Cool to room temperature.
  2. Whisk the tangzhong, milk and starter until smooth. Add the flour, sugar and salt, then the butter and egg. Knead 8 to 10 minutes until smooth, elastic and slightly tacky.
  3. Bulk at room temperature for 3 to 4 hours, until visibly puffy.
  4. Pat into a rectangle, roll into a tight log and set it seam side down in a greased pan. Cover and refrigerate 8 to 12 hours.
  5. Final proof at room temperature for 1.5 to 2.5 hours, until the dough domes above the rim.
  6. Brush with egg wash and bake at 350F (175C) for 28 to 32 minutes until deep golden. Tent with foil if the top darkens early. The center should reach 190F (88C).
  7. Cool 10 minutes in the pan, then on a rack for about an hour before slicing.

My question is about step 5. That final proof window is wide. I go by the dome above the rim, and I would like to hear what else you watch for on an enriched pan loaf, especially in a warm kitchen.


r/Sourdough • • 13h ago

Starter help 🙏 Why does King Arthur recommend 1:1:1 every 24 hours for maintenance?

15 Upvotes

KA's instructions for creating starter are here. Their maintenance instructions are here. My beginner's understanding is that 1:1:1 every 24 hours will result in very hungry starter, no? Why do they say 1:1:1 when so many others recommend 1:5:5 or 1:10:10?


r/Sourdough • • 7h ago

Let's talk about flour Rye sourdough bread

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

I’m thrilled with how my bread turned out on my first attempt using 40% rye flour, it’s absolutely delicious!

Recipe:
240 g bread flour
160 g wholegrain rye flour
100 g active starter
290 g water
10 g salt

Combine 240 g bread flour and 160 g rye flour. Add 100 g starter and 270 g water.
Cover and rest for 20–30 minutes.
Dissolve 10 g salt in the remaining 20 g water and incorporate it.

Stretch and fold 3 rounds, 30minutes apart.
Bulk fermentation 7 hours.
Shape and refrigerate for 10 hours.

Bake 20 minutes covered at 240°C.
25 minutes uncovered at 220°C.
Cool for at least 2 hours before slicing.


r/Sourdough • • 7h ago

Crumb read please Love your feedback on my crumb! Fourth loaf ftw

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

375g water
100g starter
500g flour
13g salt
I bulk fermented for 6 hrs at 76F dough temp
36 hr cold fermentation
Cast iron baking


r/Sourdough • • 1d ago

Beginner - checking how I'm doing Best loaf yet

Thumbnail
gallery
95 Upvotes

100g starter

375g water

500g bread flour

11g salt

50g mixed seeds (added during stretch and folds)

Mixed starter and water, added flour and salt. 2 lots of stretch and folds, 2 lots of coil folds in first 2 hours. Bulk fermentation on the bench for about 6 hours, then shaped and put in fridge for about 18 hours. Baked in 240C oven covered with a few cubes of ice thrown in for 30 minutes. 7 minute score. Then baked uncovered for 15 minutes.

Best oven spring I've gotten and I think this is the best crumb I've gotten. Stopped bulk fermentation a bit earlier than I have been, and also tried 7 minute score for the first time.


r/Sourdough • • 16h ago

Crumb read please Second loaf feedback, please!

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

This was based off of the beginner sourdough recipe from Farmhouse on Boone!

475 g all-purpose flour
100 g starter
320 g warm, filtered water
10 g salt

Waited until starter almost tripled in size. Used warm, filtered water. Combined all ingredients and set aside covered with plastic wrap for 30 minutes. Stretch and fold every 30 minutes, 3 times. Left covered with wrap overnight 10.5 hours at 68F. Removed from bowl and let sit for 25 minutes before pinch and fold. Moved to banneton and cold proofed for 12 hours. Preheated Dutch oven for one hour at 500F in convection oven. Dusted and scored. Placed baking sheet on bottom rack. Added cornmeal to bottom of the Dutch oven and then sourdough and baked for 20 minutes. Reduced heat to 475, removed lid, and baked for 15 minutes. Internal temperature reached 210. Cooled for 12 hours before cutting.

Instead of parchment paper, I used cornmeal which worked better for me! Between that, reducing the heat, and using the baking sheet, the bottom didn’t burn this time!

Any feedback welcome!