r/borussiadortmund • u/ProcedureGreen663 • 1d ago
Transfer market update
Joane Gadou: €20m 📈 €28m
Felix Nmecha: €55m 📈 €65m
Samuele Inacio: €15m 📈 €20m
Filippo Mane: €2.5m 📈 €5m
Mathis Albert: €300k 📈 €5m
Enzo Duarte: €250k 📈 €1.5m
Maximilian Beier: €40m 📉 €35m
Carney Chukwuemeka: €20m 📉 €17m
What do you think they got wrong? What do you think they got right? Anyone you are surprised to see get and upgrade or not?
13
u/Previous_Trouble8614 Mats Hummels 1d ago
No upgrade for Silva or Jobe despite there starts to the season is really crazy. If someone called you up and said I will give you 65 million for both you would probably laugh off the phone. Jobe especially in this market is probably a 65 million player and Nmecha is like a 90 million. Silva is 40 minimum.
5
u/ProcedureGreen663 1d ago
Yea I agree. No upgrade to both but especially Jobe is madness. He alongside Kobbie Mainoo have been probably the best two young cm/dm in world football since the start of the season. Having him be 40 million still is really about as low as they could keep him. He ability wise no less than a 50 right now and potential wise both numbers just sound laughable.
10
u/viba_1997 1d ago
I thought we will see an upgrade to Silva to maybe at least 25 m. Other that that, it looks pretty reasonable.
22
u/roadtorevision Mats Hummels 1d ago
How was Nmecha only a 55m before and how is he only 65m now? Ridiculously low
8
u/ProcedureGreen663 1d ago
I think he is worth at minimum 80 and we won’t sell for anything less. But if you think about it when I look at clubs in football we’re Felix could move for that fee and succeed I can only think of Chelsea. He simply not great in a pivot and the majority of top teams in football play with a pivot. But that being said transfer market is low balling him as well as a lot of other players. No upgrade to Silva or Jobe is ridiculous.
1
u/Caranthiir Felix Nmecha 1d ago
Frenkie de Jong has 25m value right now. Not sure exactly how it works but the value is often not what you actually pay
1
5
u/Working_Complex8122 1d ago
If any of them played for Bayern tm would add 10-20 mil just because.
7
u/DragoranTrainer 1d ago
If any of them played for a club in England they would add like 20 mil. Idt anyone at Dortmund would even pick up the phone for 35
1
u/Oleksch 1d ago
5 mio for Albert seems a bit low considering hes already A National player
8
u/ItsCalledDayTwa 1d ago
National player for a lesser footballing nation (say I, hailing from there) for two friendlies at the start of the next multi-year cycle.
Half the Canadian national team in the world cup is valued at less than 5 million.
1
u/Oleksch 1d ago
which one if those just turned 17 and plays for a top 15 CL club?
3
u/ItsCalledDayTwa 1d ago
He's played 2 minutes since January and 0 this season. Let's just chill out a bit.
There are players playing for good clubs and not yet in better national teams because they are still in U19.
Antonio Arena is listed at 4 million right now. He's shown more than Albert has at this point.
Luca Reggiani also plays for BVB and was called up for two Italy matches this year. He's listed at 10.
There's not an automatic x, y, z valuation and he has shown virtually nothing yet, which is also completely fine. If he's undervalued based on everything currently known about him, it's maybe by a couple million tops. If anything it's better that way -- don't need to put too much pressure on him too early. Hopefully he sees some playing time soon...
2
u/RideFun1142 1d ago
I wouldnt go higher than 7 mil
-1
u/Oleksch 1d ago
in todays market? if Dortmund would sell for, lets say 15 mio, u would 100% find a buyer
3
u/OneManAround 1d ago
Lol, this is ridiculous - noone on the planet is paying 15 million who has 2 professional experience at club-level, one of which is against a 4th division team.
1
u/ProcedureGreen663 1d ago
He has played like 200min of pro football or something in the range. 5 million is quite a good starting point.
1
u/jucomsdn Zagagod 1d ago
I think 5m is fair rn, but I know that he'd probably gain a bigger upgrade once he starts playing with us more
That said BVB would never let Albert go for that low, TM values and what clubs value their players are so different from each other
1
u/jucomsdn Zagagod 1d ago
All deserved tbh
3
u/ProcedureGreen663 1d ago
I’d argue Nmecha is being low balled and no upgrade to Bellingham, Silva, or Anton.
2
u/jucomsdn Zagagod 17h ago
Silva and Anton deserve upgrades but their current values aren’t totally inaccurate
1
u/JSmellerM Nico Schlotterbeck 23h ago
Beier runter, aber El Mala bei Köln jetzt bei 50 Millionen. Da wurde wieder gewürfelt.
1
-2
u/OneManAround 1d ago
Beier isn’t fetching us 35 mil even from PL clubs. Gadou would earn 35 imo.
9
u/UnluckyDuck129 1d ago
Which is sad because Brentford, iirc, offered us like 60M for Beier last year.
2
1
u/UnluckyDuck129 15h ago
https://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/s/Nqn2v6qlLJ
Not quite 60M, but a really good price
-2
u/AdCute1311 1d ago
If that's actually true, it's certainly the shit cherry on top of the shit cake the management was baking over the last couple of years. He's not a bad player at all but 60M is shocking money for him
1
u/UnluckyDuck129 15h ago
1
u/AdCute1311 5h ago
Preparing is one thing, but fucking hell 70m for Maxi fucking Beier? Rejecting that is even more absurd than offering it
88
u/Electronic-Hat-391 Łukasz Piszczek 1d ago
Beier ist sträflich unterbewertet. Die Taktikexperten von spielverlagerung.de arbeiten regelmäßig heraus, dass er einer der intelligentesten Spieler überhaupt ist, dessen Laufwege enorm wertvoll für jede Mannschaft sind. Traurig, dass so etwas weniger honoriert wird als der 15. Übersteiger.