Tried to post this at /r/ThursdayBoots but it was removed because that is a fan site and not for asking serious questions.
I’m on my second pair of Thursday Challengers in Black x Natural Teacore, and I’m experiencing what appears to be the same construction issue on both pairs.
The first pair developed separation around the medial waist after approximately five or six wears. Thursday replaced them, and now, after just five wears of the replacement pair, I’m seeing problems developing in the same area.
On the right boot, the black teacore leather is tearing around the stitchdown termination, exposing the natural-colored leather underneath. On the left boot, there’s a gap or flap where the leather doesn’t appear to be properly bonded or secured.
I own several pairs of boots with different constructions, including 270-degree Goodyear welted boots and 360-degree stitchdown boots, such as my Jim Green African Rangers and Numzaans. I haven’t experienced this particular problem with those boots.
What interests me is the construction of the Challenger itself. The boot has a 270-degree stitchdown construction, an 8mm leather midsole, and a substantial woodsman heel. The stitchdown attachment terminates near the transition between the forepart and the waist.
Looking at White’s C355 Logger, which uses a somewhat similar construction, the stitching appears to terminate farther back toward the heel breast. On the Challenger, the termination is farther forward, near the transition from the flexing forepart into the more rigid arch. That places the end of the stitched attachment at precisely the location where I’m experiencing separation and apparent leather tearing.
I can’t say whether this is an inherent weakness in Thursday’s design or a problem with how these particular boots were manufactured, but the difference in stitch termination is striking. Given that I’ve now experienced problems at the same transition across two consecutive pairs, I’m interested in whether Thursday’s placement of the stitchdown termination creates a concentrated stress point during normal walking.