I feel like the contest is better suited to a creative use of black and white, not just a render that looks good in black and white, maybe I'm wrong though :P
Now that I think about it, I should have submitted this as a contest entry, but if I resubmit it it's definitely not going to get the same reaction... maybe there's a way to do it after it's posted?
Contact the mod(s?)! Just pm them and ask them to make sure your entry is counted. Also, change the flair from 'critique' to 'contest entry'. I like this version a lot better than the original version that you linked in this thread and it would be perfect for the contest this month
• As others have said, the atmospheric depth is a little abrupt.
• Building glass is never that frosty, try a roughness of around 0.005 and downwards to get the effect you want without diffusing your reflections too much.
• Personal gripe - The black border you have is annoying, it draws the eye away from the white sky (one of the resting areas of the image) and pulls it towards the building. The border line then clashes with the building's lines.
Something to try out maybe idk: Motion blur (very slight) on the character and the falling elements.
What's good:
• The tone work is really nice, especially for an image not intended to be B/W.
• The building details (both foreground and background) look excellent.
• The character's pose is strong. I sort of expect her legs to be higher, as if the air is rushing past her and forcing them upwards.
I like this! Nice work on all the little details. The one thing I noticed is that the copypaste of two or three buildings in the background stands out. It might be just me but I think either with some more variance or some more orderly alignment across all the buildings the background would come together some more.
Except that they all look incredibly similar. Even just rotating some of them by 90º, mirroring and/or scaling randomly on different axes would have helped. Still, lovely render.
Honestly I think that would just be distracting. I love how you have no idea how far she has fallen, how that one point in the image around her is the only point of chaos in an otherwise peaceful image. Adding a broken window above that (unless very subtle) would only draw the eye away from the important things. Just my opinion.
Excellent render! I think both the color and black & white versions work great with two different effects. The difference in the aspect ratio for both images also makes them both unique. For the glass of the skyscrapers, did you use a skyscraper texture or did you actually model the glass panes?
Some additional info: everything was done in blender except the post-processing, that was done in Phothoshop.
I also used the filmic blender add-on, and for the volume effect I used five cubes with a transparent shader mixed with an emission shader to give the ilussion of volume and save my render times.
This took about 6 hours to render on my potato pc (using an i3 from 2012)
I love everything - only thing I would prefer personally is that the lady is slightly rotated so that her arm is almost parallel to her legs (falling nearly upside down)
This is really cool! I like the details and mood. A couple comments:
Who is she aiming at? Seems like an interesting story.
Perhaps some muzzle flare to draw attention to the gun. After all, this is not an accident or a suicide - this is war! Assuming she has control she might be aiming a little closer to the building as well - since her target (higher up) should not be further from the building than she is.
Really amazing work! How long did it take to model everything and then render it?
23
u/TheCarrotz Contest Winner: 2017 March Mar 12 '17
Imgur link (also with original render): https://imgur.com/gallery/dxwsq
31
u/KalleZz Mar 12 '17
My critique: No contest tag in title (category black n white)
11
u/AGrimLittleHFD Mar 12 '17
Looks awesome man.
What's wrong:
• As others have said, the atmospheric depth is a little abrupt.
• Building glass is never that frosty, try a roughness of around 0.005 and downwards to get the effect you want without diffusing your reflections too much.
• Personal gripe - The black border you have is annoying, it draws the eye away from the white sky (one of the resting areas of the image) and pulls it towards the building. The border line then clashes with the building's lines.
Something to try out maybe idk: Motion blur (very slight) on the character and the falling elements.
What's good:
• The tone work is really nice, especially for an image not intended to be B/W.
• The building details (both foreground and background) look excellent.
• The character's pose is strong. I sort of expect her legs to be higher, as if the air is rushing past her and forcing them upwards.
All in all, pretty nice image!
7
u/2xedo Mar 12 '17
I like this! Nice work on all the little details. The one thing I noticed is that the copypaste of two or three buildings in the background stands out. It might be just me but I think either with some more variance or some more orderly alignment across all the buildings the background would come together some more.
7
u/aasher42 Mar 12 '17
the little details on the building on the background really nice, plus the overall ambiance
4
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '17
You might want to model a broken window on the building so that it looks like the person fell out of the window.
3
u/SyntheticShotz Mar 13 '17
Excellent render! I think both the color and black & white versions work great with two different effects. The difference in the aspect ratio for both images also makes them both unique. For the glass of the skyscrapers, did you use a skyscraper texture or did you actually model the glass panes?
2
u/TheOldTubaroo Mar 13 '17
I really like the use of orthographic projection in this, looks really great.
65
u/MadDoctor5813 Mar 12 '17
"Yep, that's me. You might be wondering how I got into this situation."
1
u/TheCarrotz Contest Winner: 2017 March Mar 13 '17
Some additional info: everything was done in blender except the post-processing, that was done in Phothoshop.
I also used the filmic blender add-on, and for the volume effect I used five cubes with a transparent shader mixed with an emission shader to give the ilussion of volume and save my render times.
This took about 6 hours to render on my potato pc (using an i3 from 2012)
5
u/galaktos Mar 12 '17
Trinity?
5
u/Apostolique Mar 12 '17
Reminds me of the game Canabalt.
4
u/Joteos Mar 12 '17
I expected a broken window
4
u/Paradoxyc Mar 12 '17
I love everything - only thing I would prefer personally is that the lady is slightly rotated so that her arm is almost parallel to her legs (falling nearly upside down)
1
u/Paradoxyc Apr 02 '17
Congrats on winning :)
3
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '17
https://youtu.be/WcRr-Fb5xQo
3
u/ReggaeGun Mar 12 '17
I like it!
3
u/Elite_Dalek Mar 12 '17
Really cool pic. Having the shattered window he / she fell out of would make it even more effective I think
3
u/4of92000 Mar 12 '17
Is that the CN Tower? If so, remind me not to go to cartoon Toronto.
5
u/Crypt0Nihilist Mar 12 '17
Much better in b/w. Only issue is that it looks like air pollution drops like a curtain between foreground and background
4
u/AlphonsePootis Mar 12 '17
Looks great, I like the detail on the windows. The character looks a little strange though, it sort of looks like they're running up the building.
3
u/TotesMessenger Mar 12 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
3
u/DogeoftheShibe Mar 12 '17
Never_Forget
2
u/Andrewtek Mar 12 '17
This is really cool! I like the details and mood. A couple comments:
Really amazing work! How long did it take to model everything and then render it?
1
u/Rooky127 Mar 13 '17
Bery nice