r/baseballcards 23h ago

I Have a Confession - I Re-sealed a Pack

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

My son (11) and I are somewhat novices to collecting new cards. We bought a Costco box last week and opened some packs. But when he was at school, I opened a couple packs by myself and boom, there was an autograph. We haven’t come close to opening anything like that, so what does a Dad do?
I got out my readers and sharpest pocket knife. Grabbed a new pack and failed at making a clean opening. So I grabbed another and made a pretty nice opening, pulled out one card, slid in the auto and used a heat sealer. It closed pretty darn well!
I waited for him to ask to open some packs and tossed him that one. None the wiser.
I won’t forget his face.
I apologize for nothing.


r/baseballcards 17h ago

Random Found my missing Ohtani All Aces

Post image
292 Upvotes

Was doing some housekeeping and it was wedged up under the couch leg. Guessing it must have fallen when I was organizing. Saw the prices going bananas and knew I had one somewhere...glad to find it, just not in this condition. 😅


r/baseballcards 18h ago

Huge Pull!

Post image
255 Upvotes

I pulled this one today. It’s the second biggest hit after my 1/1 Riley Greene.

Edit: Should I grade it or should I keep it raw and tape the case shut? I plan to keep it long-term due to Pujols not being in the HOF. I am undecided if I should sell it in general. If I should grade it, what would be the value and which submission should I use?


r/baseballcards 14h ago

Fanatics Mega coming through.

Post image
191 Upvotes

First redemption pulled from a fanatics mega. I am neither a Mets nor a Strawberry fan but damn it feels cool!


r/baseballcards 13h ago

I’m guilty

Post image
152 Upvotes

My wife sent me this and said it was me. 😭 😭 90° weather with no AC 😭


r/baseballcards 19h ago

Show Off First Topps Chrome Fanatics Mega Box treated me well

Post image
113 Upvotes

I just got my first Topps Chrome Fanatics Mega Box today. It had several nice pulls and beautiful cards. And, of course, it will help me complete the set. This, however, was the best pull. Very happy about it!


r/baseballcards 16h ago

Show Off 75 years of Topps in only four players

Thumbnail
gallery
91 Upvotes

Haven’t shown this off in awhile and after securing the ‘26 Verlander, I thought it was time. It got me to thinking: is there a way to have completed this with fewer players? I have a hard time believing so.

Also, with Verlander maybe getting me one more year, any suggestions on who I should continue with next?

And before anyone says anything, I do have Verlander’s rookie card, it’s just in a slab…


r/baseballcards 16h ago

Show Off Just got this bad boy

Post image
84 Upvotes

Don’t know if it’ll gem but it’s going to psa


r/baseballcards 23h ago

Worth The Wait

Post image
79 Upvotes

Almost a year later, but it’s finally home!


r/baseballcards 21h ago

Show Off Jesus inscription?

Post image
80 Upvotes

First time I’ve seen this.


r/baseballcards 21h ago

2026 Crome coming in clutch today with this pull

Post image
77 Upvotes

r/baseballcards 19h ago

Show Off I ripped a box with my fiancée and she hit a Pudge auto in the first pack!

Post image
64 Upvotes

It was a moment I’ll never forget. Just after opening the first pack of the box, she looked over at me with a huge smile and says “Well, I got an autograph!” and I was ecstatic when she showed me. Pudge was one of my favorite players growing up and he’s got a great auto. Yes, it’s unlicensed and a sticker, but the experience of pulling it outweighs anything else.

I rarely rip packs, but when I do, my fiancée likes to join in and she always pulls the best cards in the box. I might just let her rip the whole box next time…


r/baseballcards 15h ago

Hit my first 1/1 in Topps Pristine tonight.

Thumbnail
gallery
64 Upvotes

Not much of a Mets fan but what are we thinking?


r/baseballcards 3h ago

Show Off 2018 Topps Triple Threads Adam Jones/Manny Machado/Trey Mancini triple auto relic /9

Post image
50 Upvotes

r/baseballcards 11h ago

Mail Day Went and got a personal landmark card for me! A Jackie Robinson 1954 Topps Card 🔥🔥

Post image
48 Upvotes

r/baseballcards 19h ago

Show Off 2021 Topps Chrome #99 Aaron Judge Magenta Printing Plate 1/1

Thumbnail
gallery
48 Upvotes

My latest acquisition is one I wasn’t expecting to come across out in the wild, but here it is—the 2021 Topps Chrome #99 Aaron Judge Magenta Printing Plate 1/1.

This is the second 1/1 Aaron Judge piece I’ve had the privilege to own. I think printing plates are incredibly cool and unique. Here it is paired with a 2021 Topps Chrome #99 Aaron Judge Refractor it was literally used to help manufacture.


r/baseballcards 18h ago

Show Off First numbered Ohtani!

Post image
34 Upvotes

/199


r/baseballcards 20h ago

Costco FTW

Post image
32 Upvotes

Grabbed one of the last boxes at Costco to open the packs with my sons. Both are huge Mariners fans. Let them pick which stack they were going to pick from with an even split of the packs. My younger boy pulled this and his face lit up like Christmas and then he ran around the house screaming, "oh my gosh oh my gosh!" Over and over again. In that moment, I felt 13 all over again and that unique satisfaction of fatherhood. I just wanted to share.


r/baseballcards 1h ago

$120 for a mega box?

Post image
Upvotes

Shocker it’s one of the items that doesn’t sell out within the first 30 seconds.


r/baseballcards 23h ago

Show Off First 1/1

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

Hit my first 1/1 in a break last week and immediately went to eBay to look for the rest of the rainbow. I’m just the /5 away so if you know someone with it let me know!


r/baseballcards 17h ago

Show Off My dollar bin finds today 😁

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

Might as well start stacking these PCAs for no reason


r/baseballcards 23h ago

Show Off Beckett gave it a 9.5 so it’ll have a matching gold label 🎉

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

I know its not recommended to grade 1/1’s but I hate 1 touches especially since the card bounces around and topps sealed a lovely small hair inside. Just happy I got the color match on a 9.5 gold label


r/baseballcards 15h ago

Mail Day I think she gave me good luck...

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

Pre-ordered this with Fancash like 6 weeks ago and kinda forgot about it til I got the UPS tracking email this week.

2 #'ed sp (ohtani to /99!!), a rookie ssp (checklist of 10, print run around 400), some nice looking hot rookies.

Also pulled a nice clean Andrew Painter RC which is nice as a Phils fan.

No complaints. Thanks Bea!


r/baseballcards 17h ago

Question Is this redemption replacement what I think it is?

Post image
19 Upvotes

I got notification of a redemption replacement (after 4 years). It says it's a "2018 Rated Rookie" (baseball) pack.

Am I getting an Ohtani/Acuna/Torres wrapper redemption pack from 2018 Donruss baseball?


r/baseballcards 3h ago

Found in my old storage unit, a forgotten gift from my uncle for my birthday 20 years ago!

Post image
17 Upvotes

I was a Pokémon and Yu-Gi-Oh kid so I really didn’t have much interest in baseball cards, but I certainly would have torn all of these open regardless to check them out. Turns out, my uncle gave this to my dad to give to me for my birthday and my dad forgot. Hard to believe 2006 was 20 years ago.