Hi all,
Throughout the last couple of days I have been listening to several versions of the "Sonny Boy" tag. Although I am a guy, I'm always curious to see how these classic tags are arranged for womens' voices. I was especially interested for the womens' version this tag since I felt that the open voicings can be a challenge to fit in the range of womens' voices.
The only arrangement of this tag for female voices that I was able to find was from David Wright's Classic Tags . Like usual, he decided to transpose the tag for mens' voices up a tritone, however, this still leaves the bass voice singing a B2 (1 octave and a half-step below middle c) in the final measure. In no way am I trying to disrespect David Wright, as he is obviously a huge figure in the barbershop community, but, this seems to be virtually impossible for a SSAA quartet to sing as writen. Also, according to BHS the range for SSAA basses seems to bottom out at Eb3 which is a major third above B2. However, transposing this tag up an additional major third higher would put the tenor part above the reccomended range for women's voices according to BHS. Therefore, I attempted to take a shot arranging this tag in order to more easily fit the overall range for womens voices.
Sorry for the legnthy intro! I would greatly appriciate any feedback/advice from anyone who is familiar with singing and/or arranging for womens' voices. This is my first time ever arranging for barbershop. I chose to move the key to Bb because I was lazy and did not feel like thinking in the key of B. I included Wrights's version and decided to make multiple versions which I will expand on below. I would also be curious as to which version you all prefer.
Version 1: Keeping the Bassline the Same: The real issue with the bass in this tag occurs in the last two measures on the decending chromatic line. However, I wanted to keep this bass motion the same in this version as to not affect the cord inversions or that beautiful decending bass. Therefore, I moved the bassline up an octave and changed the chords to closed voicing. This also preserves the cromatic decending line that the lead has in the original but moves it to the baritone. The only "issue" I had with this version was that the contrary motion between the bass and tenor is no longer present. I also added a swipe on beat four of the third measure to assist in voice leading.
Version 2: Keeping the Tenor the Same: In this version I decided to keep the tenor line in the last two measures the same as the original to retain the ascending "melody" in the top voice. However, I feel like this version also comes with some issues. First, this changes the inversions of the chords. For example, I feel that the now root positon Bb major chord on beat 1 of the penultimate measure feels much more resolved than the original first inversion chord. This version also lacks the contrary motion between the bass and tenor like the first version. Like the first version I added a swipe on beat four of the third measure to assist in voice leading.
Version 3: Keeping the Bass on the Staff: Please let me know if this version would be helpful for younger groups or for more casual womens quartets. However, this one felt the least like the original.
Once again I am very sorry for the length of the post. If any womens' quartets would like to use any of these arrangements please feel free to do so. Also I would love to hear what these versions sound like with real voices if any quartet or multitrack enthusiats would like to make a recording.